Tuesday 17 November 2026

Tuesday 17 November34

  • TTMITTM TechnologiesUnchanged

    TTM put its two divisions under a single boss

    TTM Technologies combined its commercial circuit-board business and its defense business into one group run by Doug Soder, who has led each of them. The defense head, Cathie Gridley, becomes an adviser to the chief executive until mid-2027. The company gave no figures and did not say whether it will still report the two businesses separately.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case rests on demand for AI circuit boards and the defense base, not on how the managers are arranged. If the company stops reporting the two businesses apart, the next annual report will show it. The view stays Attractive.

  • TSLATeslaRefreshed

    Tesla plans a big Cybercab factory in Germany and starts selling Cybercabs

    Tesla said it will spend about €3 billion (about $3.3 billion) on its German factory, for a building that could make up to a million driverless Cybercabs a year from 2029. It also began selling Cybercabs to invited buyers for $29,990, plus $299 a month to make it drive, only in its robotaxi areas. Musk had already said the Cybertruck ends in mid-2027.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our view moved. The German spending makes nothing until 2029, and Tesla gave no order numbers or revenue for the Cybercab. The price still sits far above even our best case, so we stay Unattractive with high conviction.

    3 claims changed
    • C61NewTesla said on 16 November 2026 it will spend about €3 billion (reported by Reuters as $3.3 billion) to expand its Grünheide factory near Berlin, first with a building able to make up to a million Cybercabs a year, construction to start in the first half of 2027 and production in 2029, with a permit application to be filed this year.Tesla's 16 November Grünheide announcement, read in the 17 November news review
    • C62NewFrom 13 November 2026 Tesla invited select customers to buy a Cybercab for personal use at $29,990 before taxes, with a $1,000 non-refundable deposit, an estimated December 2026 delivery in Austin, a required $299-a-month autonomy subscription, non-commercial use only, and driving limited to Tesla's Robotaxi service areas in Texas and Florida.the Cybercab's personal-use order terms, read in the 17 November news review
    • C02EditedIt sells five consumer vehicles - Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X and Cybertruck - plus the Semi, and two energy products, Powerwall for homes and Megapack for utilities and data centres. Musk said on X on 6 November 2026 that Cybertruck production at Giga Texas will end in about eight months, around mid-2027, to make room for Cybercab, and that many deposits will be returned (TechCrunch).Date corrected: Musk's post ending Cybertruck production was on 6 November, as the post quoted by Electrek shows, not 9 November; the WSJ's 14 November report of the discontinuation adds nothing beyond it.
      Was

      It sells five consumer vehicles - Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X and Cybertruck - plus the Semi, and two energy products, Powerwall for homes and…

  • TEMTempus AIRefreshed

    Tempus shares drop 14.8% in a week with no company news behind it

    Tempus shares closed at $64.76 on 16 November, down from $76.05 ten days earlier. The company announced nothing that explains it: the week's news was a research partnership with a military cancer charity and six study summaries for a conference. At the new price, investors are still paying for profits Tempus has never come close to making.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Even after the fall, the price is far above our estimate of what the business is worth and above our most hopeful case, so the view stays Unattractive with high confidence.

    1 claim changed
    • C38EditedAt $7.30 of enterprise value for each dollar of trailing sales, the price needs roughly an 18% operating margin on about $3.1B of revenue in 2029, a margin Tempus has never earned.re-struck at the 16 November close after a 14.8% fall; the margin the price needs drops but stays one Tempus has never earned
      Was

      At $10.99 of enterprise value for each dollar of sales, the price needs roughly a 25% operating margin on about $3.1B of revenue in 2029 - a margin T…

  • TELTE ConnectivityUnchanged

    TE Connectivity will build a $60 million fibre-optic plant in New York

    TE Connectivity said it will spend more than $60 million on a factory and research site near Rochester, New York, to make parts that attach optical fibre to AI chips, a product line it bought. The site opens in spring 2027, ramps up through 2031 and should employ more than 800 people. Separately, the shares fell to $213.45.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The plant fits what management already told us: optical parts add real sales only from 2028, and copper stays the main business in AI racks. At about 88% of our value the price is not cheap enough, so our view stays Neutral with medium conviction.

  • TBCHTurtle BeachThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Turtle Beach shares slipped about 6% in a week with no company news

    Turtle Beach shares closed at $15.99 on 16 November, down from $17.04 on 9 November, with no news from the company. We think the business is worth about $13.61 a share, so the price is now about 117% of that value, just under the line where we call it too dear.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Turtle Beach Neutral, with medium conviction. The business has not changed and the cushion is thin, but the price is back inside our margin. Grand Theft Auto VI comes out on 19 November; the holiday report in March is the test.

    1 claim changed
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $15.99 at the 16 November close, about 117% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $320M grow 8%, 10% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 6.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $55M of debt net of $17M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.4% margin) about $19.81.price re-read at the 16 November close of $15.99, about 117% of the unchanged base case, back under the 120% line route P1 drew
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $17.04 at the 9 November close, about 125% of…

  • STXSeagate Technology HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Seagate shares fell about 10% in three sessions to $499

    Seagate shares closed at $499.00 on 16 November, down from $551.72 on 11 November. We found no company news, report or filing in that time. We value the business at about $434 a share on the cash it should earn over many years.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 115% of our value, inside the margin we allow above it, so it no longer looks too dear. We moved Seagate from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C15EditedAt $499.00, the 16 November close, the shares cost about 12.4 times analysts' FY27 EPS and 7.6 times FY28's. FY28's consensus keeps about 53% of revenue as profit, against 26.1% in FY26 and 14.1% at the last peak in FY22: the price does not pay a peak multiple on those forecasts, but the forecast still needs margins this industry has never held through a cycle.re-struck at the 16 November close of $499.00; route P1 fired
      Was

      At $551.72, the 11 November close, the shares cost about 13.7 times analysts' FY27 EPS and 8.4 times FY28's. FY28's consensus keeps about 53% of reve…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Seagate Technology is worth about $434 a share against $499.00 at the 16 November close, about 115% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $13.80B grow 60%, 37% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C34, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 39.6% to its five-year average of 14.7% over five years, because 39.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 21 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.35B of debt net of $1.26B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $173, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.1% margin) about $659.re-priced at the 16 November close of $499.00, about 115% of the unchanged base case; route P1 fired and the view moved to Neutral
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Seagate Technology is worth about $434 a share against $551.72 at the 11 November close, about 1…

  • STRLSterling InfrastructureThesis changed

    Sterling shares slipped 5% in a week to $275.13

    Sterling Infrastructure shares closed at $275.13 on 16 November, down from $290.67 on 9 November. We found no company news or filings in that week. We value the business at about $359 a share on the cash it should earn over many years.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now 77% of our value, just past our cushion. We keep Sterling at Neutral because its signed work fell last quarter and the cushion is thin; a wider cushion or recovered signings would change that.

    1 claim changed
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.re-struck at the 16 November close of $275.13; the base case is unchanged and the price is now 77% of it, just past the 80% line
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $290.67 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    SpaceX caught a returning Starship upper stage for the first time

    SpaceX's giant Starship rocket reached orbit on 13 November, released 26 of its new, larger Starlink internet satellites, and the next day its upper stage flew back and was caught by the arms of its launch tower, a first. The lower stage failed to return and exploded over the Gulf of Mexico.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Catching the rocket brings cheaper, reusable launches closer and adds satellites, which helps the business. But the shares already cost far more than even our hopeful estimate of what SpaceX is worth, so the view stays Unattractive.

  • SOFISoFi TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    SoFi shares fell about 9% in three sessions, with no news from the company

    SoFi closed at $14.85 on 16 November, down from $16.27 on 11 November, with no new results, filings or company news. We value the shares at about $20.36, so the price is about 73% of that value.

    What it did to the thesisThe view moves to Attractive. Last week we asked for a price a quarter below our value, because our value assumes SoFi earns a higher return than forecasts show. The price is now past that line. Confidence stays medium: the gloomy case is far lower.

    1 claim changed
    • C64EditedOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $14.85 at the 16 November close, about 73% of it. Base case: shareholders' equity of $11.30B grows 27%, 23% and 20% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C63, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 7.3%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 7.1%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 5.7% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $6.69, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.8% return) about $36.72.Re-priced at the 16 November close of $14.85, about 73% of the unchanged $20.36 base case (was $16.27 and about 80% at the 11 November close); the value's inputs did not move.
      Was

      On an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $16.27 at the 11 November close, about 80% of it. Base…

  • SNDKSandiskRefreshed

    Sandisk shares slip toward our fair line; an eight-for-one split arrives Friday

    Sandisk's shares closed at $809.11 on 16 November, down from $835 when we last valued them. That is about 121% of what we think a share is worth, just above the line where we would call the price fair. Separately, each shareholder gets seven new shares for every one held, and the shares trade on that basis from 20 November.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business changed, and the price is still a little above our fair line, so the view stays Unattractive with low confidence. The split changes only the number of shares, not the value of the company.

    1 claim changed
    • C45NewSandisk's board approved an eight-for-one forward stock split on 29 October 2026; the shares trade on a post-split basis from 20 November 2026, and every per-share figure in this thesis is before it.the split, filed in the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q and missed by the 9 November review, recorded before the shares trade post-split
  • PLUGPlug PowerUnchanged

    Plug launches a ready-made hydrogen plant design, with an Arcadia project in Texas first

    Plug began selling GenEco Scale, a hydrogen-making plant built from standard 20 MW blocks so customers need less custom engineering. It named Arcadia eFuels, a maker of jet fuel from hydrogen, as the first customer, for a 280 MW plant in Texas. It gave no price, no firm order terms and no start date, and filed nothing with regulators.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Plug had already listed this Texas project among its possible deals, and without a firm order or a value it adds no sales we can count. Our case turns on cash and new shares, and this changes neither.

    49 claims changed
    • C01-C49New · 49First thesis on Plug Power, written from the FY2025 10-K, the Q3 2026 10-Q, release and call.
  • ONTOOnto InnovationUnchanged

    Onto's board approved up to $400 million of share buybacks

    Onto Innovation's board approved buying back up to $400 million of its own shares, replacing an older plan from February 2024. It is permission to buy, not money already spent. Onto held $1.25 billion of cash and investments at September, against $1.5 billion of convertible bonds due 2031.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A buyback only matters once shares are bought, and at about 132% of what we think a share is worth, buying would spend cash dearly. The view stays Unattractive with medium conviction.

  • NVDANVIDIAThesis changed

    US tightens chip rules, the SEC reportedly probes Nvidia, and Congress sets hearings

    The US now needs licences for advanced chips sent to five more countries, and Nvidia's board set up an export oversight committee. Later the SEC was reported to be investigating whether Nvidia misled investors. Former chief Jensen Huang said he would return if the board asked, and Congress will question him on 1 December and Nvidia's top lawyer on 2 December.

    What it did to the thesisNo sales or profit figure moved, and the shares sit well below our value, so we keep Attractive with medium confidence. The investigations raise the legal risk around the founder's exit; a finding against Nvidia or a forced change to its figures would be what moves us.

    20 claims changed
    • C61NewOn November 16, 2026 the Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security issued an interim final rule covering remote access to advanced chips through data centres in third countries, and requiring a licence to export, re-export or transfer advanced chips to Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Brazil. NVIDIA reportedly warned buyers that Chinese access to their capacity could expose them and NVIDIA to legal action.a new export rule reaches buyers outside China, where customers headquartered outside the US were 38% of Q2 revenue (C33)
    • C62NewNVIDIA furnished its Q3 FY2027 results on November 17, 2026 with a supplemental financial statement in place of its quarterly report and said it plans to file the 10-Q in the coming weeks; the Q2 FY2027 10-Q was filed the day of that quarter's results. The release lists expectations for the 10-Q among its forward-looking statements beside the board's independent investigation.the Q3 FY2027 report came without its 10-Q, which NVIDIA filed with the results the quarter before
    • C60EditedNVIDIA's independent directors opened an investigation on November 8, 2026 into the former chief executive's relationship with a Megaspeed executive the US government is reported to regard as a Chinese intelligence asset, and retained Joon H. Kim and Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to run it. On November 16 the Justice and Commerce departments said they are running a criminal investigation into Megaspeed; on November 17 the SEC was reported to have opened a civil inquiry into whether NVIDIA's disclosures misled investors, and three House committees set hearings with Huang on December 1 and general counsel Tim Teter on December 2. The board created a standing National Security and Export Control Oversight Committee on November 17. No finding or charge against NVIDIA has been published.the SEC is reported to have opened a civil inquiry into NVIDIA's disclosures, Justice and Commerce confirmed a criminal investigation of Megaspeed, and House committees set hearings for 1 and 2 December
      Was

      NVIDIA's independent directors opened an investigation on November 8, 2026 into the former chief executive's relationship with a Megaspeed executive…

    • C02EditedQ3 FY2027 revenue was $115,844M, up 103% from $57,006M. Data Center was $107.6B (+110%): Hyperscale $60.1B (+71%) and AI Clouds, Industrial and Enterprise $47.5B (+195%). Edge Computing was $8.2B (+42%). Data Center grew 21% on Q2 FY2027.rolled to Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Q2 FY2027 revenue was $96,221M, up 106% from $46,743M. Data Center was $89,023M (+117%): Hyperscale $48,710M (+102%) and AI Clouds, Industrial and En…

    • C03EditedGross margin was 74.8% in Q3 FY2027 and operating income $77,520M, a 66.9% margin. For FY2026 gross margin was 71.1%, down from 75.0%, after a $4.5B charge on H20 chips it could not sell to China.rolled to Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Gross margin was 75.0% in Q2 FY2027 and operating income $63,734M, a 66.2% margin. For FY2026 gross margin was 71.1%, down from 75.0%, after a $4.5B…

    • C05EditedQ3 FY2027 net income of $65,287M included $1,767M of net gains on equity investments, $2.8B on listed holdings less $1.0B on private ones after a $1.8B impairment; $25,474M in the nine months. GAAP diluted EPS was $2.70 and non-GAAP $2.68, which excludes those gains and includes stock pay.rolled to Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Q2 FY2027 net income of $59,688M included $7,771M of gains on equity investments, $23,707M in the half-year. GAAP diluted EPS was $2.46 and non-GAAP…

    • C04EditedOperating income over the four quarters to October 25, 2026 was $239,089M: $44,299M in Q4 FY2026, $53,536M in Q1 FY2027, $63,734M in Q2 FY2027 and $77,520M in Q3 FY2027, on revenue of $361,808M.trailing year rolled to Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Operating income over the four quarters to July 26, 2026 was $197,579M: $36,010M in Q3 FY2026, $44,299M in Q4 FY2026, $53,536M in Q1 FY2027 and $63,7…

    • C06EditedOperating cash flow rose to $48,253M in Q3 FY2027 from $24,077M in Q2, 74% of net income, while receivables rose to $81,033M from $63,059M. Days sales outstanding rose to 64 from 60, which NVIDIA puts down to shipments late in the quarter on the Rubin launch and extended payment terms on large multi-quarter agreements with investment-grade customers.cash and receivables at October 25, 2026 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Operating cash flow fell to $24,077M in Q2 FY2027 from $50,344M in Q1, 40% of net income, as receivables rose to $63,059M from $38,466M in January. D…

    • C07EditedThree direct customers were 14%, 11% and 11% of Q3 FY2027 revenue; in the nine months four were 13%, 12%, 12% and 11%. Two direct customers held 18% and 17% of receivables.concentration at October 25, 2026 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      One direct customer was 16% of Q2 FY2027 revenue; in the half-year three were 16%, 15% and 13%. Five direct customers held 22%, 14%, 13%, 11% and 10%…

    • C08EditedAt October 25, 2026 NVIDIA had $518B of commitments, $390B of them for supply and capacity, up from $279B, mainly memory, $102B of cloud agreements and data-centre leases not yet commenced, plus $32B of neocloud agreements, and $118.0B of guarantees, $105.0B for SB Energy. It held $44,219M of listed shares and $65,528M of private holdings.commitments, guarantees and holdings at October 25, 2026 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      At July 26, 2026 NVIDIA had $366B of commitments, $279B of them for supply and capacity, up from $119B, plus $56B of AI cloud agreements and leases,…

    • C11EditedThe Q4 FY2027 outlook, for a quarter with an extra week, is revenue of $130.0B plus or minus 3%, with no China data-centre computing, and gross margin of 71.0% to 72.0%. Q3 FY2027 revenue of $115,844M beat its $108.0B guide.the Q3 outlook was tested by the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026 ($115,844M against $108.0B); the claim now holds the Q4 FY2027 outlook
      Was

      The Q3 FY2027 outlook is revenue of $108.0B plus or minus 2%, with no China data-centre computing, and gross margin of 74.0% plus or minus 0.5 points.

    • C23EditedNVIDIA returned $28.1B in Q3 FY2027, $22,122M of buybacks and $6,026M of dividends, and has $227.3B of authorisation left, which it plans to use through fiscal 2028. Diluted shares averaged 24,186M in the quarter against 24,483M a year earlier. The quarterly dividend is $0.25.capital returned in Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Shares outstanding fell to 24,147M at July 26, 2026 from 24,304M in January; NVIDIA bought 203M shares for $39.8B in the half-year, and on September…

    • C24EditedNVIDIA repaid $1.0B of notes in Q3 FY2027; long-term debt was $32,371M with none due within a year, against $53.5B of cash and marketable debt securities.debt and cash at October 25, 2026 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      NVIDIA issued $25.0B of notes in Q2 FY2027; debt was $33.4B against $56.6B of cash and marketable debt securities, with $1.0B due within a year and $…

    • C29EditedEnterprise value is about 15.7 times trailing operating profit of $239,089M, and about 12.1 times Q3 FY2027's operating profit of $77,520M run for a year.re-struck at the 16 November close on the trailing year to Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Enterprise value is about 22.7 times trailing operating profit of $197,579M, and about 17.6 times Q2 FY2027's operating profit of $63,734M run for a…

    • C31EditedAt $156.14 the shares are about 17 times FY2027's expected earnings per share, 10 times FY2028's and 7 times FY2029's, and enterprise value is about 9.2 times FY2028's expected operating profit; the forecasts themselves have profit flat to falling after FY2030.re-struck at the 16 November close against the same consensus (C30)
      Was

      At $186.64 the shares are about 20 times FY2027's expected earnings per share, 12 times FY2028's and 9 times FY2029's, and enterprise value is about…

    • C33EditedThe Q4 FY2027 outlook assumes no China data-centre computing, though NVIDIA shipped $2.4B of Hopper data-centre products to China in Q3; customers headquartered outside the US were 37% of Q3 revenue, and those in China, including Hong Kong, $11,050M.China and foreign customers in Q3 FY2027 from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      The Q3 FY2027 outlook assumes no China data-centre computing; H20 shipments to China were under 1% of Data Center revenue in Q2, and customers headqu…

    • C39EditedPart of today's profit is being lent back or held as paper: customers now take 64 days to pay, $1.8B of Q3 FY2027 profit was gains on shares in customers and partners, and $118.0B of guarantees back buyers' buildings, though Q3 turned 74% of net income into cash after Q2's 40%.the Q3 FY2027 cash, gains and guarantees from the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026
      Was

      Part of today's profit is being lent back or held as paper: Q2 FY2027 turned only 40% of net income into cash, $7.8B of profit was gains on shares in…

    • C52EditedJen-Hsun Huang co-founded NVIDIA in 1993 and ran it as president and chief executive until November 11, 2026, when the board accepted his resignation from those roles and from the board; Colette Kress, chief financial officer since 2013 and from Cisco before that, is interim chief executive while staying chief financial officer, the board is searching for a permanent chief executive among internal and external candidates, and Harvey C. Jones, a director since 1993, is its first chair. Huang's daughter and son are employed by the company. On November 17 Huang said publicly he would return as chief executive if the board asked and would cooperate with its investigation; the board is reported not to be considering his return.Huang said on 17 November he would return as chief executive if the board asked; the board is reported not to be considering it
      Was

      Jen-Hsun Huang co-founded NVIDIA in 1993 and ran it as president and chief executive until November 11, 2026, when the board accepted his resignation…

    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $306 a share against $156.14 at the 16 November close. Base case: FY2026 sales of $215.9B grow 96%, 60% and 15% over three years, the first year being nine filed months and the Q4 guide, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 66.1% to 58% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 26 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 16% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (94% then 20% then a 15% fall, a 45% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (70% and 30%, a 62% margin) about $521. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $205.fair value re-struck on the Q3 FY2027 report of 17 November 2026: FY2027 growth of 96% on nine months filed and the Q4 guide, the trailing margin, cash, debt and diluted shares at October 25, and the 16 November close
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $295 a share against $186.64 at the 6 November close. Base case: FY2026 sa…

    • C60EditedNVIDIA's independent directors opened an investigation on November 8, 2026 into the former chief executive's relationship with a Megaspeed executive the US government is reported to regard as a Chinese intelligence asset, and retained Joon H. Kim and Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to run it. On November 16 the Justice and Commerce departments said they are running a criminal investigation into Megaspeed; on November 17 the SEC was reported to have opened a civil inquiry into whether NVIDIA's disclosures misled investors, and three House committees set hearings with Huang on December 1 and general counsel Tim Teter on December 2. The board created a standing National Security and Export Control Oversight Committee on November 17. No finding or charge against NVIDIA has been published.the SEC is reported to have opened a civil inquiry into NVIDIA's disclosures, Justice and Commerce confirmed a criminal investigation of Megaspeed, and House committees set hearings for 1 and 2 December
      Was

      NVIDIA's independent directors opened an investigation on November 8, 2026 into the former chief executive's relationship with a Megaspeed executive…

  • NSITInsight EnterprisesThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Insight borrowed $650 million through convertible notes and its shares fell 8%

    On 16 November Insight sold $650 million of five-year notes paying 0.875% a year that lenders can later swap for shares. The shares fell 8% that day to $155.29. We think the business is worth about $140 a share, so the price is now about 111% of that value.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Insight Neutral, with medium conviction. The business did not change, but the price is back inside our cushion above its value. What the borrowed money is for is not yet clear; the next test is the February report.

    2 claims changed
    • C50NewOn 16 November 2026 Insight priced $650.0M of 0.875% convertible senior notes due 2031 in a private offering to institutional buyers, and gave the buyers an option to purchase more; the shares closed at $155.29 that day, 8.0% below the 13 November close of $168.76.the convertible notes priced on 16 November, the day the shares fell 8% back under 120% of our value
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Insight is worth about $140 a share against $155.29 at the 16 November close, about 111% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $9.02B grow 1%, 6% and -5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.1% to 6.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales and a further 0.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.50B of debt net of $398M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $96.94, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.0% margin) about $202.price re-struck at the 16 November close of $155.29, about 111% of the unchanged base case, back inside the 120% line; the value is struck on September's debt and cash, before the $650M convertible (C50), whose cash and debt offset until the use of the money is filed
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Insight is worth about $140 a share against $168.75 at the 10 November close, about 121% of it.…

  • NFLXNetflixThesis changed

    Netflix shares slip to $60.75, just under 80% of our value

    Netflix shares closed at $60.75 on 16 November, down about 4% in a week with no company news beyond a concert tour licensing its K-pop film. That is about 78% of the roughly $78 a share we think the business is worth, just past the line where our 20% cushion begins.

    What it did to the thesisNetflix stays Neutral, with medium conviction. Whether its spending on shows slows as promised is answered by the January report, and a large studio purchase is still possible, so a two-point cushion is too thin. We now want the price near $58.55, 75% of our value.

    1 claim changed
    • C66EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Netflix is worth about $78.06 a share against $60.75 at the 16 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $49.73B grow 11%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C65), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 31.3% to 33.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 16.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.13B of debt net of $8.22B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $42.64, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.9% margin) about $101.price re-read at the 16 November close of $60.75, about 78% of the unchanged base case, after route P1 fired; no input to the value moved
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Netflix is worth about $78.06 a share against $63.41 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • MRKMerck & Co.Thesis changed

    Merck stopped testing a blood-cancer pill after a safety and benefit review

    Merck ended all testing of nemtabrutinib, a pill for blood cancers, after an independent panel watching a large trial said its benefits may not outweigh its risks. Two other large trials of the pill stop too. Merck did not say what the programme cost or whether it will write anything off.

    What it did to the thesisWe still rate Merck Unattractive, with medium conviction. Merck needs new drugs to replace Keytruda, and this is the second late-stage one to fall away since September. The pill had no sales, so our value of the company does not change.

    2 claims changed
    • C65NewOn 17 November 2026 Merck stopped all development of nemtabrutinib, an oral blood-cancer pill, after an outside data committee found its benefits may not outweigh its risks in the Phase 3 BELLWAVE-011 trial; two more Phase 3 studies, BELLWAVE-008 and BELLWAVE-010, stop with it.news review of 17 November: the nemtabrutinib programme stopped
    • C28EditedManagement says over 20 new products are a $70B-plus commercial opportunity, and calls the expiry period 'more of a hill than a cliff' it aspires to grow through.counter-evidence added: the nemtabrutinib programme stopped on 17 November (C65)
  • KLACKLAThesis changed

    KLA shares fell 5.5% in a day as chip-equipment stocks dropped

    KLA shares closed at $143.96 on 16 November, down from $152.32 on 13 November, as chip-equipment stocks fell after a rival's report. There was no news from KLA. We think the business is worth about $120 a share, so the price is about 120% of that value.

    What it did to the thesisWe still rate KLA Unattractive, with medium conviction. Our value already counts the analysts' boom year, and at the line the price still asks for more in a cyclical business. A fall to about $132, a tenth above our value, would make it Neutral.

    1 claim changed
    • C62EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $120 a share against $143.96 at the 16 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $14.51B grow 36%, 19% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 42.6% to its five-year average of 39.5% over five years, because 42.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 57 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.72B of debt net of $1.53B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 31.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 43.5% margin) about $170.price re-read at the 16 November close of $143.96, about 120% of the unchanged base case, a hair under the 120% line
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $120 a share against $151 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

  • ICHRIchor HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Ichor shares fall back to about 12% above our value

    Ichor shares closed at $33.65 on 16 November, down about 10% from 11 November with no company news, filing or report. That gives back about half of the jump that took them to about 25% above the roughly $30 a share we think the business is worth.

    What it did to the thesisIchor moves from Unattractive back to Neutral, with medium conviction. At about 12% above our value the price pays for the chip-equipment recovery but not for more. It would turn Unattractive again near $36 and Attractive near $24.

    1 claim changed
    • C30EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $33.65 at the 16 November close, about 112% of it, where enterprise value is about 1.08 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $947.7M grow 31%, 25% and 12% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 1.7% to 7% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 31 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever, the return on new capital gliding to 8%. Bear (flat in 2027 and 2028, a 4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.66, bull (32% and 15%, a 9% margin) about $55.07. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $18.95.price re-read at the 16 November close of $33.65, about 112% of the unchanged base case, after route P1 fired; no input to the value moved
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $37.45 at the 11 November close, about 125% of it, w…

  • IBMInternational Business MachinesThesis changed

    IBM shares dipped 1.9% a day after we wrote our view

    IBM shares closed at $242.51 on 16 November, down from $247.13 on 13 November. IBM also announced plans to work with NVIDIA and the Fermilab physics laboratory on quantum computers, with no money attached. We think the business is worth about $204 a share, so the price is about 119% of that value.

    What it did to the thesisWe still rate IBM Unattractive, with medium conviction. Our value already assumes IBM keeps paying a low tax rate, and growth is slow with high debt. A fall to about $225, a tenth above our value, would make it Neutral.

    50 claims changed
    • C01NewIBM sells software (Red Hat's hybrid cloud platform, automation, data and AI, and transaction processing software for its mainframes), consulting, infrastructure (IBM Z mainframes, Power servers and storage) and financing for clients buying them.what the company sells, for the product block
    • C02NewRevenue was $67,535M in 2025, up 8% (6% at constant currency), against $57,350M in 2021.the record of growth for the growth axis
    • C03NewIn 2025 Software revenue was $29,962M, up 10.6%, at a 33.1% segment profit margin; Consulting $21,055M, up 1.8%, at 11.7%; Infrastructure $15,718M, up 12.1%, at 22.0%; Financing $737M.the segment mix and where profit is made
    • C04NewIn Q3 2026 revenue was $17,103M, up 5% (6% at constant currency): Software $7,804M up 8% (Red Hat up 11%, Automation down 3%, Data up 19%, Transaction Processing up 9%), Consulting $5,335M flat, Infrastructure $3,707M up 4% with IBM Z down 20% and Distributed Infrastructure up 31%.the newest quarter by segment
    • C05NewIn Q3 2026 GAAP pre-tax income was $2.5B, a 14.6% margin, and GAAP diluted EPS $2.31; IBM's operating (non-GAAP) pre-tax margin was 19.3% and operating EPS $2.95.the two profit lines named apart
    • C06NewManagement says Software's annual recurring revenue was $24.9B in Q3 2026, about 80% of Software revenue, and that OpenShift's recurring revenue reached $2.4B, growing over 30%.recurring revenue is the moat's outcome in Software
    • C07NewAt 30 September 2026 IBM had about $69B of remaining performance obligations, about 70% expected as revenue within two years.signed but undelivered work, for demand
    • C08NewConsulting signings fell 13.3% to $21,757M in 2025 and 3.7% to $5,030M in Q3 2026; the Consulting backlog was $30.2B at September 2026, with book-to-bill of 1.04.the forward signal for Consulting
    • C09NewManagement says mainframe clients holding about 85% of installed capacity are maintaining or growing it, installed capacity has tripled over the last few programs, each $1 of mainframe brings $3 to $5 of software, and the z17 program runs over $1B ahead of the last.the installed base the Infrastructure and Transaction Processing case rests on
    • C10NewIBM guided 2026 revenue growth above 5% at constant currency in January, cut it to 4% to 5% in July, and in October raised its free cash flow guide to growth of more than $1B on 2025's $14.7B.the guide the next test reads against
    • C11NewThe shares fell 25.2% in one session in July 2026, from $290.23 to $217.07, after a second-quarter software miss, and reached a 52-week low of $205.77 on 22 July against a high of $329.23 on 2 June.the repricing the variant perception reads
    • C12NewFree cash flow was $14.7B in 2025 on $13.2B of GAAP operating cash flow; in the first nine months of 2026 operating cash flow was $11.8B and free cash flow $7.8B.cash for financial position
    • C13NewAt 30 September 2026 IBM held $11.1B of cash and marketable securities against $63.8B of debt, of which $12.7B funds the Financing business.the balance sheet for financial position
    • C14NewIBM closed the purchase of Confluent on 17 March 2026 for about $11.3B, part of $11.4B spent on acquisitions in 2026.growth bought rather than grown
    • C15NewDiluted shares were 953.5M over the four quarters to September 2026 against 904.6M in 2021; IBM has not bought back shares since the Red Hat purchase in 2019, with $2,008M of authorisation unused.dilution for per-share capture
    • C16NewIBM pays a dividend of $1.69 a share each quarter and has paid one every year since 1916.cash returned to owners
    • C17NewIBM's 10-K names Alphabet, Amazon, BMC, Broadcom, Microsoft, Oracle, Salesforce, SAP and Splunk as principal Software competitors; Accenture, Capgemini and India-based providers in Consulting; and Dell, HPE, Intel, NetApp and Pure Storage in Infrastructure.who the company says it fights
    • C18NewAccenture's 10-K says its competitors include large multinational IT service providers, including the services arms of large global technology providers.an outside witness to the Consulting rivalry
    • C19NewOracle's 10-K names IBM among its competitors in enterprise software and infrastructure.an outside witness to the Software rivalry
    • C20NewAmazon Web Services sells AWS Transform for mainframe, an AI service it says turns mainframe programs into cloud systems, compressing multi-year modernisation into months.a rival attacking the mainframe base
    • C21NewThe US Government Accountability Office named ten critical federal legacy systems most in need of modernisation in 2019; by February 2025 agencies had completed three of the ten, and eight of eleven systems reviewed used outdated languages.how slowly old core systems are retired, from outside
    • C22NewGartner forecast in April 2026 that worldwide IT spending reaches $6.31 trillion in 2026, up 13.5%, with software at $1,443.6B, up 15.1%, and IT services at $1,870.2B, up 9.0%.the market IBM sells into, from outside
    • C23NewManagement says AI work was about 30% of Consulting revenue in Q3 2026 and 35% of its backlog.what AI does for Consulting
    • C24NewIBM said in June 2026 it will invest more than $10B in quantum computing over five years, has signed more than $1.1B of quantum contracts with clients since 2017 across more than 340 network members, and plans a fault-tolerant machine, Starling, in 2029.the quantum line the bet rests on
    • C25NewManagement says IBM Quantum signed 16 enterprise engagements in 2026, three outside groups showed quantum advantage on IBM hardware in July, and DARPA chose IBM for Stage C of its Quantum Benchmarking Initiative.signals for the quantum bet
    • C26NewIn September 2026 IBM's subsidiary Anderon agreed a CHIPS Act award of up to $1.0B to develop quantum wafer manufacturing, with IBM contributing $1.0B of cash; the Department of Commerce holds a minority stake.outside money behind the quantum line
    • C27NewThe shares closed at $242.51 on 16 November 2026, down 1.9% from $247.13 on 13 November.the price the valuation reads
    • C28NewOver the year to 13 November 2026 the price fell 21.5% while revenue per share rose 6.3%, so the multiple of sales fell 26.2%.the market re-rated rather than the business shrinking
    • C29NewIn November 2026, 24 analysts rated IBM a buy, 23 a hold and 5 a sell; FMP's rating series shows 48% positive of 25 against 55.6% of 27 in July, and the average price target fell 7.5%.the consensus view the variant perception faces
    • C30NewAnalysts' average revenue is $70.57B for 2026, $73.32B for 2027 and $77.57B for 2028, and their 2028 operating margin is about 25% on their basis, before stock pay.the analysts' path the fair value uses
    • C31NewAt $242.51 IBM's company value is about $285B: 953.5M diluted shares, plus $63.8B of debt and $0.7B of minority interest, less $11.1B of cash and securities. That is about 22.9 times the $12.4B of pre-tax profit before interest over four quarters.what the price implies, for the valuation
    • C32NewValued in three stages at an 8% required return, IBM is worth about $204 a share in the base case, $104 in the bear and $264 in the bull, so $242.51 at the 16 November close is about 119% of the base: the analysts' revenue path for three years, then fading to 4%, a 22.1% normal margin after stock pay, and a 17% tax.the fair value the view reads
    • C33NewStock pay was $1,715M in 2025, 2.5% of revenue, and $1,969M over the four quarters to September 2026, 2.8%.the cost the operating figures leave in
    • C34NewArvind Krishna, at IBM since 1990, has been chief executive since April 2020 and chairman since December 2020 and owns 418,689 shares; the 20 directors and officers together own 809,792.who runs IBM and what they own
    • C35NewIBM's annual bonus pays on revenue, operating cash flow and a strategic scorecard; performance shares pay on revenue (40%), operating EPS (30%) and free cash flow (30%), adjusted by relative shareholder return.what executive pay rewards
    • C36NewIBM's pension plans were underfunded by a net $2,283M at the end of 2025.a claim ahead of shareholders
    • C37NewFrom 2021 to 2025 gross margin rose from 54.9% to 58.2%, selling and admin fell from 32.7% to 29.8% of revenue, research rose from 11.3% to 12.3%, and the GAAP pre-tax margin rose from 8.4% to 15.3%.what growth costs and how margins moved
    • C38NewIn 2025 the Americas brought $33,342M of revenue, Europe, Middle East and Africa $22,189M and Asia Pacific $12,004M; about 60% came from outside the United States.where the money comes from, and the currency exposure
    • C39NewIBM had about 264,300 employees at the end of 2025.the scale of the services workforce
    • C40NewShares sold short were 17.84M at 30 October 2026, 1.9% of the float and 2.98 days of trading.the short side's view
    • C41NewThree directors bought shares on the open market in February 2026, including 1,000 shares by one director at about $304.insiders buying with their own money
    • C42NewPre-tax income was $10,506M over the four quarters to September 2026 and interest expense $1,929M, so pre-tax profit before interest was about $12,435M.the profit line the routes are drawn on
    • C43NewIBM sold ¥108.8B of notes in November 2026, rated A3 by Moody's and A- by S&P and Fitch.access to credit for financial position
    • C44NewIBM's quantum contracts of more than $1.1B across more than 340 network members since 2017 work out to roughly $360,000 a member a year.what one quantum client is worth a year, for the bet
    • C45NewManagement says about $400M of software deals slipped out of the second quarter of 2026 and about two thirds have since closed.why the guide was cut
    • C46NewIBM's operating tax rate was 14.7% in Q3 2026 and management expects mid-teens for the year; the GAAP rate was 11.9% in the quarter.the tax rate the fair value uses
    • C47NewDARPA moved IBM, Atom Computing, Diraq and IonQ to Stage C of its Quantum Benchmarking Initiative on 7 October 2026, joining Microsoft and PsiQuantum; the program tests whether any approach can reach useful scale by 2033.an outside witness to the quantum race and its timetable
    • C27EditedThe shares closed at $242.51 on 16 November 2026, down 1.9% from $247.13 on 13 November.price re-read at the 16 November close, which took route P1 past its line
      Was

      The shares closed at $247.13 on 13 November 2026.

    • C31EditedAt $242.51 IBM's company value is about $285B: 953.5M diluted shares, plus $63.8B of debt and $0.7B of minority interest, less $11.1B of cash and securities. That is about 22.9 times the $12.4B of pre-tax profit before interest over four quarters.company value re-read at the 16 November close of $242.51
      Was

      At $247.13 IBM's company value is about $289B: 953.5M diluted shares, plus $63.8B of debt and $0.7B of minority interest, less $11.1B of cash and sec…

    • C32EditedValued in three stages at an 8% required return, IBM is worth about $204 a share in the base case, $104 in the bear and $264 in the bull, so $242.51 at the 16 November close is about 119% of the base: the analysts' revenue path for three years, then fading to 4%, a 22.1% normal margin after stock pay, and a 17% tax.price re-read at the 16 November close of $242.51, about 119% of the unchanged base case, a hair inside the 120% line
      Was

      Valued in three stages at an 8% required return, IBM is worth about $204 a share in the base case, $104 in the bear and $264 in the bull, so $247.13…

  • HLIOHelios TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    Helios shares fell to $45.70 with no company news

    Helios shares fell to $45.70 on 16 November, down from $48.00 on 10 November, as other industrial and AI-hardware shares fell. The company published nothing new. We think the business is worth about $61.80 a share, so the price is now about 74% of that.

    What it did to the thesisLast week we said Helios needed a bigger discount than usual, because its customers are cyclical and its first AI order has no size: a price below $46.35. It is now there, so we moved our view from Neutral to Attractive, with medium conviction.

    What this review changed (3 edits)
    • opportunity_view Neutral to Attractive; view reasoning rewritten with `moved`
    • routes rewritten from Attractive: Neutral near $49.44 (16.3 times operating profit) or on a guidance or order slip, Unattractive near $74.16
    • brief verdict, summary, why now, price and routes, the contradiction's handling, the valuation score's wording and the story's verdict, worth and watch slides
  • FSLRFirst SolarThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation1→3

    First Solar shares fell about 19% in a week with no company news

    First Solar closed at $162.45 on 16 November, down from $201.14 on 6 November, with no new results or filings; a news headline linked the fall to fading election hopes for clean-energy policy. We value the business, counting the tax credit still to come, at about $139 a share, so the price is now about 117% of that value, back under the 120% line we had marked as too dear.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Unattractive to Neutral, with medium conviction. Nothing about the business changed; the price now pays only a little more than our value. What new orders fetch once the import floor starts on 4 December decides the next move.

    3 claims changed
    • C27EditedEnterprise value is about 6.0 times the midpoint of guided 2026 adjusted earnings before interest, tax and depreciation at the 16 November close of $162.45, down from 7.4 to 8.0 times in late August, and the shares cost $12.69 for each $1 of trailing yearly profit at the August pack against a six-year usual level of $19.05.Re-struck at the 16 November close: enterprise value of about $16.0B (107.7M shares at $162.45, $108M of debt, $1.62B of cash and securities) over the $2.65B guided midpoint.
      Was

      Enterprise value is 7.4 to 8.0 times guided 2026 adjusted earnings before interest, tax and depreciation, and the shares cost $12.69 for each $1 of t…

    • C34EditedThe price pays roughly $8B for the credit still to come and about $8B for a manufacturer guided to lose money before it.Re-struck at the 16 November close: enterprise value fell from $20.68B to about $16.0B, so the residual after the credit is about $8B rather than $12B.
      Was

      The price pays roughly $8B for the credit still to come and about $12B for a manufacturer guided to lose money before it.

    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return First Solar is worth about $139 a share against $162.45 at the 16 November close, where enterprise value is about 6.0 times guided 2026 adjusted EBITDA. The module business is valued before the Section 45X credit, and the roughly $8B of credit still to come is added beside it. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.22B fall 9% in 2026, then grow 5% a year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin before the credit moves from about minus 3% to 10% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about $1.30 of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (a 5% fall then flat, a 3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $95, bull (12% and 10% growth, an 18% margin) about $215. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $118.Re-priced at the 16 November close of $162.45 after a 19% fall with no company news; the value itself is unchanged at about $139, and the price is now about 117% of it.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return First Solar is worth about $139 a share against $201.14 at the 6 November close, where enterpris…

  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Forgent shares fell 7% in a day with no news from the company

    Forgent shares closed at $20.57 on 16 November, down from $22.12 on 13 November, with no news from the company since a quarterly report that beat its forecast and raised the year. We think the business is worth about $27.66 a share, so the price is about 74% of that value.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Forgent Attractive, with medium conviction. The power-gear shortage will ease and orders are now reported only once a year, but the price sits about a quarter under our value, a big enough cushion. A rise back to about $22.13 would make it Neutral.

    2 claims changed
    • C20EditedAt $20.57 the company value is about $6.66B, about 10.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 15.0 times the $1.37 adjusted EPS midpoint. Counting the $483.0M tax receivable liability as debt adds about three-quarters of a turn. Taking off stock pay at the September quarter's $13.9M a quarter, about $55.5M a year, it is about 12.0 times.re-struck at the 16 November close of $20.57
      Was

      At $22.15 the company value is about $7.14B, about 11.7 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 16.…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.price re-read at the 16 November close of $20.57, about 74% of the unchanged base case, past the 80% line
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $22.15 at the 12 November close (about 80% of it).…

  • FIXComfort Systems USAThesis changed
    Per-share capture3→4

    Comfort Systems bought back about 4% of its shares in seven weeks

    Comfort Systems said it spent $1.89B buying back its own shares this year, about $1.54B of it since the end of September, roughly 4% of all its shares at around $1,150 each. That used about seven-tenths of the $2.16B of cash it held in September. Its board approved buying up to 1 million more shares.

    What it did to the thesisWe still rate Comfort Systems Attractive, with medium conviction. Buying shares well below what we think they are worth helps owners, and it shows management treats customers' prepaid cash as its own. The cost is a thinner cash cushion if those prepayments shrink.

    1 claim changed
    • C28EditedComfort Systems stopped buying its own shares for the first half of 2026, then restarted in the third quarter. Share repurchases were $8,232 thousand in the six months to June 30, 2026 against $111,290 thousand in the same period of 2025, but in the September quarter it bought 206,672 shares at an average of $1,649.54, about $340.9 million, which takes nine-month repurchases to $349.1 million including excise tax, at an average of $1,643.85. The count turned down: common shares outstanding were 34,994 thousand at September 30, 2026 against 35,200 thousand at June 30 and 35,272 thousand a year earlier. The programme is not exhausted: 666,914 shares remained authorised at September 30. Cash and cash equivalents rose to $2,158,027 thousand from $1,854,794 thousand of cash and short-term investments at June 30 and $981,898 thousand at December 31, 2025, so the purchase equalled about 18% of the June cash and about a third of the quarter's operating cash flow. Asked about capital deployment on the July 2026 call, the chief financial officer said the company continues 'to keep a sharp eye out for opportunities to buy stock' and that 'we like our stock better than we've ever liked it. We bought some year-to-date, but after the big purchases of last year, we've been a little slower at the first part of the year.' On the October 23 call the chief financial officer said the company has 'always bought our shares more aggressively when they dip', has used 15 to 20% of free cash flow on repurchases over time, and has returned $349 million year to date with about 212 thousand shares retired. On November 5 the company filed an 8-K saying the board had added 994,606 shares to the programme and that through November 4 it had repurchased 11,752,570 shares for $1,711.8 million before excise tax, against a cumulative 11.1 million at September 30 per the 10-Q: the remaining 666,914 shares were bought within five weeks of quarter end, about 0.66 million shares and roughly $0.8 billion by subtraction from the 10-Q's rounded figures, at an average near $1,235 while the shares fell. On November 17 the company filed an 8-K saying that from January 1 through November 16, 2026 it repurchased 1,552,236 shares for $1,891.7 million before excise tax, from ongoing cash flow and part of its cash, and that the board added 679,520 shares to bring the remaining authorisation back to 1,000,000. Against the roughly 212 thousand shares and $349 million of the first nine months, that is about 1.34 million shares and about $1.54 billion in the seven weeks after September 30, by subtraction: about 3.8% of the 34,994 thousand shares outstanding at September 30, at an average near $1,150, and about seven-tenths of the $2.16 billion of cash held at that date.November 17 8-K (S30): about $1.54 billion and 1.34 million shares bought in the seven weeks after September 30, about seven-tenths of the quarter-end cash; authorisation topped up
      Was

      Comfort Systems stopped buying its own shares for the first half of 2026, then restarted in the third quarter. Share repurchases were $8,232 thousand…

  • ESIElement SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    ConvictionMedium→Low
    Valuation2→3

    Element Solutions shares slip to the edge of what we think they are worth

    Element Solutions shares closed at $31.75 on 16 November, down from $32.96 a week earlier. That is about 120% of our estimate of what a share is worth, about $26.54, which is the line between a price we call too high and one we call fair. The company published nothing new.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business changed, but the price is no longer clearly above our value, so we moved the view from Unattractive to Neutral. Confidence is low, because the price sits right on the line and a small rise would take it back.

    1 claim changed
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Element Solutions is worth about $26.54 a share against $31.75 at the 16 November close ($32.96 on 9 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.49B grow 15% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.7% to 15.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 33 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.08B of debt net of $225M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.0% margin) about $35.46.the price re-read at the 16 November close, about 120% of the unchanged base case
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Element Solutions is worth about $26.54 a share against $32.96 at the 9 November close ($31.35 o…

  • ENSEnerSysThesis changed

    EnerSys shares fell 6% to $138.68 with no company news

    EnerSys shares fell to $138.68 on 16 November from $147.80 on 12 November, as other power and industrial shares fell. The company published nothing new. We think the business is worth about $116 a share without its tax credit, so the price is about a fifth above that.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now just inside the level where we said we would turn neutral, but only by a hair. Its forklift batteries, nearly half of sales, keep shrinking, so we hold our view at Unattractive and would turn neutral near $127.30.

    What this review changed (3 edits)
    • view reasoning: against_value and price lines (Neutral 110%, Attractive 80%)
    • route P1 redrawn near $127.30 (14.6 times normal-year operating profit), basis checked today; P2 re-read at the new close
    • brief price and routes, the valuation score's wording, the worth and watch slides
  • ECGEverus Construction GroupThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Everus approves a $100 million share buyback

    Everus's board approved buying back up to $100 million of its own shares by December 2029, about 2% of the company's value. Management said buying contractors and investing in its own business still come first. The shares closed at $82.92 on 16 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe buyback is a small plus. But the shares now sit only about a fifth below what we think Everus is worth, the cushion we ask for when customers are unnamed and profit runs above normal. We move from Attractive to Neutral.

    2 claims changed
    • C20EditedDiluted shares were about 51.2M in the June 2026 quarter, roughly where they were at the spin-off; stock pay was $8.7M over twelve months; Everus pays no dividend, and on 16 November 2026 its board authorised a $100M share repurchase through 15 December 2029, saying organic investment and acquisitions remain the priority.the board authorised a $100M share repurchase on 16 November 2026 (8-K Exhibit 99.1); until then Everus bought back no stock
      Was

      Diluted shares were about 51.2M in the June 2026 quarter, roughly where they were at the spin-off; stock pay was $8.7M over twelve months; Everus pay…

    • C33EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.price re-struck at the 16 November close of $82.92, about 81% of the unchanged base case; the value and its inputs did not move
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $76.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • DAVEDaveUnchanged

    Dave applies to become a national bank

    Dave asked federal banking regulators for permission to open its own national bank, Dave Bank. If approved, it could hold customer deposits and make its small cash advances itself, instead of through a partner bank. Dave says it will not raise new money for this and nothing changes for customers yet. It hired a former bank president to run it.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Approval is not assured and could take a long time, especially while the government's lawsuit against Dave is open. Until then Dave still depends on its partner bank. Dave stays Unattractive, with medium conviction: the price is above our value.

  • CSCOCisco SystemsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Cisco shares fall after its results, back inside what we think they are worth

    Cisco shares closed at $94.52 on 16 November, down from $100.76 before its results last week. That is about 115% of our estimate of what a share is worth, about $81.85. No new facts about the company came out; the news was commentary on the same results.

    What it did to the thesisThe business case did not change, but the price is no longer more than a fifth above our value, so we moved the view from Unattractive back to Neutral, with medium confidence. Orders after the price rises pass are still the test.

    1 claim changed
    • C38EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $81.85 a share against $94.52 at the 16 November close ($100.76 on 11 November). Base case: trailing sales of $63.33B grow 19% in FY27, the midpoint of the raised guide (C06), then 7% and 7%, the analysts' rates (C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 24.3% to 27.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales and a further 2.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 17.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $29.53B of debt net of $14.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.21, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.3% margin) about $106.27.the price re-read at the 16 November close, about 115% of the unchanged base case
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $81.85 a share against $100.76 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • BKRBaker Hughes CompanyUnchanged

    Baker Hughes' Chart unit sells its gas-cooling process designs for $220 million

    Chart, which Baker Hughes bought in July, agreed to sell its designs for liquefying natural gas in small and mid-sized plants, with over 90 patents and the engineers, to Italy's MAIRE for $220 million in cash. Chart will keep supplying a key piece of equipment for ten years. The buyer expects the business to earn about $25 million a year.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The sale trims Baker Hughes' debt slightly, but next to roughly $14 billion of net debt it barely changes the path we track, and Chart keeps making the equipment. The view stays Neutral until the February report shows Chart's margin and the debt coming down.

  • ANETArista NetworksThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Arista shares fell about 5% in three days with no company news

    Arista shares closed at $187.02 on 16 November, down from $196.68 on 11 November, as other AI hardware shares fell, with no news from the company. We think the business is worth about $157 a share, so the price is now about 119% of that value, just inside the line where we stop calling it too dear.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Arista Neutral again, with medium conviction. Nothing about the business changed, so the rating follows the price back. The premium over our value is still thin: a rise above about $188 would make it Unattractive again; the February report is the next test.

    1 claim changed
    • C75EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Arista is worth about $157 a share against $187.02 at the 16 November close, about 119% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $11.89B grow 41%, 28% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C74), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 43.8% to 41.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 18.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $14.36B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 33.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $70.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 45.9% margin) about $230.price re-struck at the 16 November close of $187.02, about 119% of the unchanged base case, back inside the 120% line
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Arista is worth about $157 a share against $196.68 at the 11 November close, about 125% of it. B…

  • AMZNAmazon.comUnchanged

    Amazon sells most of a $5 billion data-centre portfolio and rents it back

    Blackstone's listed data-centre trust agreed to buy 75% of 13 newly built Amazon data-centre buildings in a deal valued at about $5 billion. Amazon keeps 25% and rents all of them back for at least 12 years. Separately, a rocket failure destroyed 40 Amazon internet satellites, and Amazon plans $7 billion of renewable power in India.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Selling buildings and renting them back is one more way to pay for the huge data-centre build, but it is small next to about $220 billion of spending this year. The shares sit near what we think Amazon is worth, so the view stays Neutral.

  • AMDAdvanced Micro DevicesThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    AMD shares fell about 9% in three sessions, with no news from the company

    AMD closed at $504.28 on 16 November, down from $552.90 on 11 November, with no new results or filings. We value the business at about $460 a share, so the price is now about 110% of that value, back under the 120% line it had just crossed. Company releases that week, a supercomputer launch and a completed purchase of World Labs, carried no figures the case rests on.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Unattractive back to Neutral, with medium conviction: the price now pays only a little more than our value. Sales of the new AI racks in the fourth-quarter results decide the next move either way.

    2 claims changed
    • C36EditedAt $504.28, the 16 November close, AMD trades at about 76 times the last four quarters' adjusted EPS of $6.65, 31 times the analysts' 2027 EPS of $16.07 and 21.6 times their 2028 EPS of $23.40 (forecasts of 16 October, before the results); on GAAP earnings the trailing figure is about 108.Re-struck at the 16 November close of $504.28.
      Was

      At $552.90, the 11 November close, AMD trades at about 83 times the last four quarters' adjusted EPS of $6.65, 34 times the analysts' 2027 EPS of $16…

    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $504.28 at the 16 November close, about 110% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $45.44B grow 60%, 50% and 35% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.7% to 25.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (21.2% after amortisation of past deals, 4.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 29.5%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.08B of debt net of $15.78B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $140, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.7% margin) about $788.Re-priced at the 16 November close of $504.28 after an 8.8% fall with no company report; the value itself is unchanged at about $460, and the price is now about 110% of it.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $552.90 at the 11 November close, about 120% of it. Base…

  • ADEAAdeiaRefreshed

    Canada's Rogers signs a patent licence with Adeia and ends their lawsuits

    Adeia said Rogers Communications, Canada's largest cable and wireless company, signed a multi-year licence to use Adeia's TV and streaming patents, covering its Shaw businesses too. The deal ends all the lawsuits between the two. Adeia did not say how much Rogers will pay or for how long.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our view moved. It adds a paying customer and is another fight that ended in a licence, but with no amount we cannot size it, and our case turns on two US TV companies, DIRECTV and DISH, that still have not signed.

    2 claims changed
    • C69NewOn 17 November 2026 Adeia signed a multi-year licence to its media patent portfolio with Rogers Communications, Canada's largest cable, wireless and media company, including its Shaw subsidiaries, which also resolves all outstanding litigation between them; no financial terms were disclosed.the Rogers licence announced 17 November, read in the news review
    • C22EditedFour refusals have ended in licences: Disney litigated from November 2024 and signed a long-term licence in December 2025 with all cases and patent-board petitions withdrawn; AMD was sued in November 2025 and signed a multi-year licence in March 2026, within four months; Altice USA (Optimum) renewed after a dispute; and Rogers, with its Shaw subsidiaries, signed a multi-year media licence on 17 November 2026 that resolves all litigation between them.Rogers' 17 November licence (C69) is a fourth dispute that ended in a licence.
      Was

      Three refusals have ended in licences: Disney litigated from November 2024 and signed a long-term licence in December 2025 with all cases and patent-…

  • ACMRACM ResearchThesis changed

    ACM Research shares fell 12% to $44.00 with no company news

    ACM Research shares fell to $44.00 on 16 November, 12% below where we last valued them, alongside other chipmaking-equipment makers. Checking our value, we found it had counted all of the profit of ACM Shanghai, its Chinese operating arm, although outside investors own 27.2% of that arm. Counting their share, we put the business at about $50.85 a share, not $58.62.

    What it did to the thesisAt $44.00 the shares are about 87% of our corrected value, not far enough below it to call them cheap given the China and cash risks. So our view stays Neutral with medium conviction; it would turn Attractive near $40.68.

    1 claim changed
    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $50.85 a share against $44.00 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.14B grow 25%, 26% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.5% to 16.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 147 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $343M of debt net of $952M of cash, and less $572.3M of book equity belonging to ACM Shanghai's outside shareholders. Bear (half that growth, a 12.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.06, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.7% margin) about $75.19.the value had subtracted nothing for ACM Shanghai's outside shareholders, who own 27.2% of the subsidiary whose whole sales and profit it valued; less their $572.3M of filed book equity the base case is about $50.85, not $58.62, and the price is re-struck at the 16 November close of $44.00
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $58.62 a share against $49.75 at the 9 November close. Base case: tr…

Friday 13 November14

  • XYLXylemUnchanged

    Xylem's board approves buying back up to $1.5 billion more of its shares

    Xylem said its board approved a new plan to buy back up to $1.5 billion of its own shares, starting now, on the market or in private deals, and that it may stop at any time. An earlier $1.5 billion plan from February was nearly used up. The same day it kept its quarterly dividend at 43 cents.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Xylem already buys back a lot of stock, and this lets it continue. Our Neutral view turns on whether sales grow again without acquisitions and margins hold, which a buyback does not change, and the shares trade about at what we think they are worth.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C08UnchangedIn the first half of 2026 Xylem bought back $1,243M of its shares, about 10.5M, under a $1.5B programme authorised in February 2026 with $453M left at 30 June. It raised the quarterly dividend 8% to $0.43.
    • C09UnchangedAt 30 June 2026 Xylem held $1,276M of cash against $2,926M of debt, of which $531M is due within a year, including $500M of notes maturing in November 2026; management put net debt at 0.8 times adjusted EBITDA. In September it sold $1.5B of notes due 2029 to 2037 to pay for Cornell and Roper, lifting total debt to $4,426M as adjusted, and signed a new $1.5B revolving credit line.
  • WAYWaystar HoldingThesis changed

    Waystar shares slip to $28.14, with no news from the company

    Waystar's shares fell about 4% from $29.18 on 9 November to $28.14 on 12 November, with no filing or company news. That is about 78% of the roughly $35.98 we think the business is worth, a little past the line where our 20% cushion begins.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business changed. With floating-rate debt, owners who may sell their stake and Epic building similar billing tools, a cushion this thin is not enough: Waystar stays Neutral with medium conviction, and turns Attractive near $26.99, 75% of our value.

    1 claim changed
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $28.14 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $1.26B grow 9%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.9% to 37.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.46B of debt net of $277M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 30.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 41.6% margin) about $48.55.Price re-read at the 12 November close of $28.14, about 78% of the unchanged base case: past the band's 80% line, which the view treats as too thin a cushion for this business.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $29.18 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • VSTVistraRefreshed

    Vistra shares rise to $134.51, with no news from the company

    Vistra's shares rose about 8%, from $124.80 on 6 November to $134.51 on 12 November. The only filing was a routine one letting the seller of the Cogentrix plants resell the 5 million Vistra shares it was paid with. The price is about 78% of the roughly $173 we think Vistra is worth.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business changed, so the view stays Attractive with medium conviction. The price is still just under the line where our 20% cushion runs out; it turns Neutral near $138.

    1 claim changed
    • C53EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vistra is worth about $173 a share against $134.51 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $17.74B grow 23%, 8% and 5% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 20.6% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about $1.10 of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less debt, preferred and minority interest at 30 June. Bear (no growth after 2026, an 18% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $50, bull (12% and 8%, a 31% margin) about $259. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $95.Price re-read at the 12 November close of $134.51, about 78% of the unchanged base case: still inside the 20% margin of safety.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vistra is worth about $173 a share against $124.80 at the 6 November close. Base case: 2025 sale…

  • TET1 EnergyThesis changed

    US securities regulator is investigating T1's statements about its tax credit

    T1's quarterly filing, published on 12 November, says that in September the SEC began investigating what T1 has told investors about qualifying for the 45X manufacturing tax credit, and some other accounting matters. T1 says it will cooperate and cannot predict the outcome. Nobody has been charged. The shares closed at $1.97 on 12 November and $1.91 on 13 November, from $2.13.

    What it did to the thesisThe tax credit is T1's whole profit, so an inquiry into what it said about qualifying adds weight to our worry without settling it. The view stays Unattractive with medium confidence; a credit sale to an outside buyer and a closed plant loan are still what would move it.

    3 claims changed
    • C62NewIn September 2026 the SEC's Fort Worth Regional Office told T1 it is investigating T1's public disclosures about its eligibility for 45X tax credits and certain other accounting matters; T1 says it will cooperate fully and cannot predict the duration or outcome. The 10-Q filed 12 November 2026 is the first place it was disclosed; no 8-K reported it.the Q3 10-Q discloses an SEC investigation into T1's 45X-eligibility disclosures, which bears on C12 and C39; the 12 November review read the 10-Q and missed it
    • C12EditedT1 says the February guidance validates its compliance plan and that it expects to be eligible for 45X; it bought cells for part of 2026 output from suppliers certifying non-PFE status, and in November 2026 said third-party diligence put about 65% of its cell supply-chain material through Q2 outside foreign entities of concern, above the 50% safe-harbour ratio.the SEC's investigation into T1's 45X-eligibility disclosures (C62) is new counter-evidence to management's eligibility claim
    • C32EditedIn November 2025 the DOJ subpoenaed T1 and a current executive and director over his 2023 share sales, and the SEC asked for similar documents; the Q3 2026 10-Q repeats both and says T1 is cooperating with the DOJ and the SEC.the Q3 10-Q repeats the DOJ subpoenas and the SEC document request; refresh_by rolled to the FY2026 10-K
      Was

      In November 2025 the DOJ subpoenaed T1 and a current executive and director over his 2023 share sales, and the SEC asked for documents; T1 is coopera…

  • SSentinelOneRefreshed

    SentinelOne signs a $400M credit line it has not used

    SentinelOne agreed a $400M borrowing line with a group of banks led by Bank of America on 12 November. It has not borrowed any of it. Its other news since October was new products and partner awards, with no sales figures. The shares closed at $22.29 on 12 November, down 12% since early October as rival security stocks fell too.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The credit line adds a safety cushion to a company that already holds $813M of cash. Even after the fall, the price still needs profit margins SentinelOne has never reached, so Neutral holds until the 3 December report shows whether new subscriptions grow again.

    4 claims changed
    • C12EditedCash and investments were $813.2M at 31 July 2026 with no borrowing; on 12 November 2026 it signed a $400M secured revolving credit facility, undrawn, maturing in 2031. The Israeli tax settlement is paid in shekels through fiscal 2031 at 7% interest, and $259.7M falls due at once on a change of control.the $400M undrawn revolver of 12 November added
      Was

      Cash and investments were $813.2M at 31 July 2026 with no borrowing; the Israeli tax settlement is paid in shekels through fiscal 2031 at 7% interest…

    • C14EditedAt $22.29 on 12 November 2026 the market value was $7.63B, 6.9 times trailing revenue, against $8.70B and 7.9 times at $25.43 on 5 October; the shares closed at $11.94 on 10 April 2026, about 4 times the revenue then reported.re-struck at the 12 November close
      Was

      At $25.43 on 5 October 2026 the market value was $8.70B, 7.9 times trailing revenue; the shares closed at $11.94 on 10 April 2026, about 4 times the…

    • C16EditedIts filed rivals CrowdStrike and Palo Alto Networks trade at 42.8 and 22.5 times enterprise value to sales, growing 24.3% and 24.5%, against SentinelOne's 6.2 times on 21.1%.re-struck at the 12 November close; the whole cohort fell
      Was

      Its filed rivals CrowdStrike and Palo Alto Networks trade at 52.4 and 30.0 times enterprise value to sales, growing 24.3% and 24.5%, against Sentinel…

    • C38EditedAt $7.63B the price needs stock pay to fall toward 15% of revenue and cash margins before it to reach about 25%, on revenue near analysts' $1.66B for FY2029, for cash after stock pay of roughly $166M a year.re-struck at the 12 November close: about 46 times rather than 52
      Was

      At $8.70B the price needs stock pay to fall toward 15% of revenue and cash margins before it to reach about 25%, on revenue near analysts' $1.66B for…

  • PWRQuanta ServicesThesis changed

    Quanta shares rose 12% in a week to $606

    Quanta's shares closed at $606 on 12 November, up 12% from 6 November, with no news from the company. That is about 40 times its yearly operating profit, against about 21 for three rivals. The government's November energy outlook still expects business and factory power use to keep rising into 2027.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Unattractive and conviction rises from Low to Medium: the price now sits where even our best case values the company. Whether growth without acquisitions passed 20% waits for the annual report in February.

    3 claims changed
    • C10EditedAt a close of $606.16 on November 12, 2026 Quanta's enterprise value was about $100.9B, 39.7 times trailing operating profit against a median of 21.5 for the three filed-cohort competitors (MYR Group 20.2, MasTec 21.5, Primoris 22.2, as of the September 25 pack). Trailing operating profit, from the filings, was about $2.55B to September 30: 2025's $1.61B plus the first nine months of 2026's $2.06B less the first nine months of 2025's $1.13B.Re-struck at the November 12 close of $606.16 (S34) after the price drifted 12% from the November 6 close: 39.7 times trailing operating profit from 38.1, the non-market part of the enterprise value and the trailing profit held as on November 5.
      Was

      At a close of $580.44 on November 4, 2026 Quanta's enterprise value was about $97.0B, 38.1 times trailing operating profit against a median of 21.5 f…

    • C11EditedWhat the price implies: at the cohort's median of 21.5 times operating profit, today's enterprise value of about $100.9B would need operating profit of about $4.7B, 1.8 times the trailing $2.55B. At the trailing operating margin of 6.8% that is revenue of about $69B - against guided 2026 revenue of $41.3B to $41.6B and an average analyst estimate of $62.9B for 2030. At guided 2026 revenue it is an operating margin of about 11.3%, against 5.7% in 2025, 8.5% in the September quarter, the best yet, and a filed-cohort operating margin median of 5.5%.Re-struck on C10's enterprise value at the November 12 close: profit needed at the cohort median $4.7B from $4.5B, revenue at today's margin $69B from $66B, margin on guided revenue 11.3% from 10.9%.
      Was

      What the price implies: at the cohort's median of 21.5 times operating profit, today's enterprise value of about $97.0B would need operating profit o…

    • C34EditedThe Energy Information Administration's November 2026 outlook, released November 10, estimates US electric power sector generation up 2.7% in 2026 to a record, driven by growing commercial-sector demand, and forecasts generation growing a slower 1.2% in 2027 as commercial and industrial demand keeps rising, partly offset by lower residential demand after a milder summer.November outlook (S35) replaces the October one, whose validity ran to 10 November: generation up 2.7% in 2026 and 1.2% in 2027, with commercial and industrial demand still rising. The section no longer gives the third-quarter consumption change or a 2027 commercial-sector rate, so both leave the claim; the next outlook is due 9 December.
      Was

      The Energy Information Administration's October 2026 outlook has US electricity consumption up 4% in the third quarter of 2026 on a year earlier, com…

  • NVTSNavitas SemiconductorUnchanged

    Navitas sues Renesas again, this time over Renesas's newest gallium-nitride chips

    Navitas filed a second lawsuit against Japanese chipmaker Renesas in a Texas federal court on 12 November, saying Renesas's newly announced gallium-nitride power chips break six of its patents. It already sued Renesas in August over four patents, after Renesas accused Navitas's chief executive of taking trade secrets. Only the first paragraph of the announcement could be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our worry is the two lawsuits against Navitas, from Wolfspeed and Renesas, which could cost money or block sales; suing back does not change them, and no court has ruled. Owning patents was already part of the case. We still rate it Unattractive.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C16UnchangedWolfspeed has sued Navitas for infringing GaN and SiC patents and seeks damages and an injunction; in July 2026 Renesas sued Navitas and two employees, including the CEO, for trade-secret theft. Neither is provisioned.
    • C33UnchangedNavitas' moat is its process know-how and patents: a GaN power IC that puts drive, control and protection on one chip, and a 'trench-assisted planar' SiC transistor. It shows up as being licensed and listed, not yet as price.
  • MSFTMicrosoftUnchanged

    Microsoft's Outlook and Teams went down worldwide for more than a day

    From midday on 12 November, many businesses could not use Microsoft's Outlook email, Teams and its Copilot assistant. Microsoft said a number of its servers had stopped working, not a hacking attack. It was still recovering the next morning after more than 19 hours, which may make it the longest such outage it has had.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case leans on businesses paying more each year for Microsoft 365 and staying; an outage could test that, but no customer has left and no cost has been reported. We will watch seat and revenue growth in January's report. We still rate it Neutral.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C18UnchangedMicrosoft raised commercial Microsoft 365 prices worldwide from July 2026: Microsoft 365 E3 from $36 to $42 a user a month, E5 from $57 to $65, Office 365 E3 from $23 to $26 and Business Standard from $12.50 to $14.50. The last broad increase was in March 2022.
    • C19UnchangedWith Microsoft 365 Commercial cloud revenue up 17% on paid seats up 6% in fiscal 2026, revenue per seat rose about 10% a year before the July 2026 price rise, so customers pay more while the seat base barely grows.
  • IONQIonQThesis changed

    IonQ's finance chief leaves suddenly and a software-company CFO will replace him

    IonQ said its chief financial officer, Inder Singh, left his roles on 13 November, effective at once, after fourteen months, and gave no reason. Gary Merrill, finance chief at the data-protection software company Commvault, takes over in early December. A new chief accounting officer, Thomas Austin, formerly of Juniper Networks, starts now.

    What it did to the thesisOur view did not move. We doubt the price because it pays for a technology lead IonQ has not shown and for growth bought with new shares; a new finance chief changes neither. A sudden exit with no reason given is a small new worry. We still rate it Unattractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C45EditedNiccolo de Masi, a director since September 2021 and chief executive of dMY III, the listed shell that took IonQ public, became chief executive on February 26, 2025 and chairman in August 2025. Inder Singh, finance and operating chief since September 4, 2025, stepped down effective immediately on November 13, 2026, with no reason given; Gary Merrill, Commvault's finance chief, becomes chief financial officer in early December and Thomas Austin, formerly Juniper's chief accounting officer, fills a new chief accounting officer post. Peter Chapman and Thomas Kramer, the previous chief executive and finance chief, were released in the third quarter of 2025.the finance chief stepped down on 13 November 2026, effective immediately, and two successors were named (S27)
      Was

      Niccolo de Masi, a director since September 2021 and chief executive of dMY III, the listed shell that took IonQ public, became chief executive on Fe…

  • GRABGrab Holdings LimitedThesis changed

    Grab pledges $750M to AI data centres in Malaysia; shares slip to $3.24

    On 9 November Grab, SoftBank and Sarawak's state oil company agreed to build AI data centres in Malaysia. Grab pledged $750M, paid in stages as projects reach milestones. Its shares then slipped to $3.24, about 78% of the roughly $4.15 we think the business is worth, just past the line where our 20% cushion begins.

    What it did to the thesisGrab stays Neutral, with medium conviction. The pledge puts part of its cash into a costly business far from rides and delivery, with no visible return yet, while Uber and Indonesia remain open. We now want the price near $3.11, 75% of our value, before calling it Attractive.

    2 claims changed
    • C18EditedCommitted and pending deals claim about $2.7B to $4.1B of cash: $1.49B for Atome's 60%, $78M paid for Stash, $0.4B to $1.8B for Atome's last 40%, and up to $750M of seed capital pledged on 9 November 2026 to AI data centres in Malaysia with SoftBank and PETROS, paid in stages as projects reach development and customer milestones; against $5.0B of net cash. The $600M for foodpanda Taiwan is no longer owed (C56).Grab pledged up to $750M of seed capital to AI data centres in Malaysia on 9 November (S25), more cash spoken for
      Was

      Committed and pending deals claim about $2.0B to $3.4B of cash: $1.49B for Atome's 60%, $78M paid for Stash, and $0.4B to $1.8B for Atome's last 40%,…

    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Grab is worth about $4.15 a share against $3.24 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $3.97B grow 24%, 19% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.5% to 18.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.07B of debt net of $5.66B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $2.48, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.7% margin) about $5.36.Price re-read at the 12 November close of $3.24, about 78% of the unchanged base case: past the band's 80% line, which the view now treats as too thin a cushion while $750M is newly pledged to AI data centres.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Grab is worth about $4.15 a share against $3.41 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

  • GDSGDS Holdings LimitedRefreshed

    GDS sets results for 25 November as its DayOne stake's listing looks smaller

    GDS will report its third quarter on 25 November, a week later than we expected. A Bloomberg report on 21 October said DayOne, the overseas data-centre business GDS part-owns, was weighing delaying its US share sale or raising about half the $5 billion it first aimed for. The shares are $20.05, 27% below the price our figures use.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved: we stay Neutral, medium conviction. The cheaper price is weighed against two answers still to come: whether orders and profit hold their pace on 25 November, and what DayOne is worth when it sets a price.

    5 claims changed
    • C24EditedReuters reported that DayOne plans to make its SEC filing public in mid-October and list in November, raising up to $5B at about $20B, after a $4.5B Series C closed in June.counter-evidence added: Bloomberg's 21 October report that the listing may be delayed or halved in size (S21); the claim text stays the September report as made
    • C32EditedAt $27.57 on 2 October 2026 GDS's market value was about $5.37B, 2.2% above its 52-week low; in a year the price fell 31.5%, with revenue per share up 4.6% and the multiple down 34.5%.refresh date moved from 18 to 25 November, the Q3 results date GDS set in its 6-K of 12 November (S22); the figures are re-struck at that print
    • C33EditedSeventeen of eighteen analysts rate GDS a buy, and short interest was 9.3% of the float at 11.5 days to cover on 15 September 2026.refresh date moved from 18 to 25 November, the Q3 results date GDS set in its 6-K of 12 November (S22); the figures are re-struck at that print
    • C36EditedAt $27.57, after crediting DayOne at $2.2B, buyers pay about RMB52.6B for the China business, about 9.6 times 2026 recurring adjusted EBITDA, close to the 9.1 times implied by building new capacity at RMB20M per MW earning RMB2.2M.refresh date moved from 18 to 25 November, the Q3 results date GDS set in its 6-K of 12 November (S22); the figures are re-struck at that print
    • C37EditedAt replacement cost the China business's equity is worth about RMB18.8B, about $2.77B or 52% of market value; adding DayOne at its Series C mark makes about $5.0B, 92%.refresh date moved from 18 to 25 November, the Q3 results date GDS set in its 6-K of 12 November (S22); the figures are re-struck at that print
  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsRefreshed

    Forgent shares fell 10% on the day of a strong report

    Forgent's shares closed at $22.15 on 12 November, down 9.8% on the day it reported sales above its forecast and raised its plan for the year. We already read that report. Our value is still about $27.66 a share, so the price is now about 80% of it.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the business changed, only the price. We turn Attractive at 80% of our value or less, and the price sits a few cents above that line. We hold Neutral with medium conviction: our worst case is far below, so a cushion this thin is not enough.

    2 claims changed
    • C20EditedAt $20.57 the company value is about $6.66B, about 10.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 15.0 times the $1.37 adjusted EPS midpoint. Counting the $483.0M tax receivable liability as debt adds about three-quarters of a turn. Taking off stock pay at the September quarter's $13.9M a quarter, about $55.5M a year, it is about 12.0 times.re-struck at the 12 November close of $22.15, after the shares fell 9.8% on the day of the first-quarter report; guidance, cash and term loan unchanged
      Was

      At $24.57 the company value is about $7.88B, about 12.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 17.…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.price re-read at the 12 November close of $22.15, about 80% of the unchanged base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $24.57 at the 11 November close (about 89% of it).…

  • EMEEMCOR GroupUnchanged

    EMCOR agrees to buy P1 Construction, a Kansas contractor, for cash

    EMCOR agreed to buy P1 Construction, a Kansas firm that installs mechanical and electrical systems, including in data centers. P1 expects $600 million to $650 million of sales this year and about $60 million of cash profit. EMCOR pays from its own cash but did not say the price. The deal should close in early 2027.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. P1 adds about 3% to EMCOR's sales, too little to change our value. Overpaying for a purchase this size would hurt the case, but without a price we cannot judge it. The view stays Attractive and conviction Medium; the yearly report should show the price.

  • CCSIConsensus Cloud SolutionsThesis changed
    Financial position2→3

    Consensus' bank loan rules are now public, and it is well inside them

    Consensus' quarterly report, filed on 6 November, includes its new bank agreement. Its debt may not grow past 4 times a year's cash profit; it stands at about 2.35 times. Debt was $551.6 million at the end of September, with $106.7 million of cash. A director sold 8,000 shares on 9 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe loan set aside to repay the 2028 bonds now has visible room, so we score the balance sheet stronger. The view stays Neutral: what holds it back is corporate customers leaving faster, and the February report is the next test of that.

    12 claims changed
    • C10EditedCorporate revenue growth is coming from account count rather than from spend per account: in Q3 2026 accounts rose 9.5% (69,000 against 63,000, restated) and revenue per account about 0.4%.Counter-evidence updated to the Q3 2026 call's net revenue retention of 104.5% (C13).
    • C11EditedManagement launched eFax Protect in mid-2023 as a corporate e-commerce offering to capture small-business demand; on the Q3 2026 call it said e-commerce for eFax had been extended from SoHo into Corporate over two years and that a new eFax platform is driving customer acquisition, without repeating the record sign-up claim.Its valid_through of 2026-11-06 passed: the Q3 2026 call (5 November) re-states the e-commerce push into Corporate but no longer names eFax Protect or claims record sign-ups.
      Was

      Management launched eFax Protect in mid-2023 as a corporate e-commerce offering to capture small-business demand, and reports record sign-ups for it…

    • C12EditedThe boundary between the Corporate and SoHo lines is set by Consensus and was moved in mid-2023, when an e-commerce offering aimed at small businesses began booking into Corporate.Its refresh_by (next earnings) fired: the Q3 2026 call confirms e-commerce booking into Corporate and says churn and the account base excluding it are stable, which is the boundary effect this inference names; spend per account slipped to $301.42.
    • C13EditedManagement reports trailing twelve-month corporate net revenue retention of 104.5% in Q3 2026, up from 103.1% in Q2 and 101.9% a year earlier.Its valid_through of 2026-11-06 passed: the Q3 2026 call gives 104.5% for the trailing twelve months to September.
      Was

      Management reports trailing twelve-month corporate net revenue retention of 103.1% in Q2 2026, up about 110 basis points sequentially and year on yea…

    • C19EditedManagement says VA revenue is on track to exceed $9M in 2026 and the rollout is in its final stages (it put it at 65% to 80% complete in August).Its valid_through of 2026-11-06 passed: the Q3 2026 call says VA revenue is on track to exceed $9M for 2026 and the rollout is in its final stages, giving no percentage.
      Was

      Management says VA revenue should be north of $9M in 2026 and estimates the rollout is 65% to 80% complete.

    • C24EditedAt 30 September 2026 Consensus owed $551.6M: $348.2M of 6.5% notes maturing 15 October 2028 and $203.4M on a revolver maturing 30 September 2031, with the $300.0M delayed-draw loan reserved for the notes still undrawn (C54).Its refresh_by (next earnings) fired: the Q3 2026 10-Q gives the 30 September balances under the new facility.
      Was

      At 30 June 2026 Consensus owed $558.5M: $348M of 6.5% notes maturing 15 October 2028, a $146M term loan and $64M drawn on a revolver under a facility…

    • C25EditedManagement reports net debt of 2.35 times cash operating profit and total debt of 2.92 times at Q3 2026, against a credit-agreement ceiling of 4.00 times net leverage.Its valid_through of 2026-11-06 passed: the Q3 2026 call gives 2.35 and 2.92 times, and the credit agreement filed with the Q3 10-Q states the covenant levels the counter-evidence said were missing.
      Was

      Management reports net debt of 2.45 times cash operating profit and total debt of 2.97 times at Q2 2026.

    • C35EditedTangible net worth is negative $343.9M: equity of $48.234M against goodwill of $352.576M and other intangibles of $39.588M at 30 September 2026.Its refresh_by (next earnings) fired: re-struck on the Q3 2026 10-Q balance sheet.
      Was

      Tangible net worth is negative $351.6M: equity of $41.566M against goodwill of $352.924M and other intangibles of $40.213M at 30 June 2026.

    • C39EditedNo insider bought a share in the open market in the twelve months to 12 November 2026; five open-market sales of 18,400 shares were all discretionary, none under a plan adopted earlier, the largest a director's 8,000 shares on 9 November 2026 at about $42.46 to $42.90.A director sold 8,000 shares in the open market on 9 November 2026 (Form 4, filed 12 November), with no plan flag; the window is rolled to 12 November.
      Was

      No insider bought a share in the open market in the twelve months to 16 September 2026; three open-market sales of 10,400 shares were all discretiona…

    • C46EditedThe VA issued a policy in late Q1 2026 mandating ECFax as the secure fax solution within the VA, on management's account.Its valid_through of 2026-11-06 passed: on the Q3 2026 call management again said the rollout accelerated after the VA's mandate to use ECFax; the policy itself is still not published where a search reaches it.
    • C52EditedThe 6.5% 2028 notes may be redeemed in whole or part at any time on or after 15 October 2026, at specified redemption prices plus accrued interest, and at par (100%) from 15 October 2027.Its refresh_by (the Q3 10-Q) fired: the 10-Q's debt note carries the notes unchanged at $348.247M and the new facility reserved to retire them.
    • C54EditedOn 30 September 2026 Consensus replaced its credit agreement with a $225.0M revolver and a $300.0M delayed-draw term loan, both maturing 30 September 2031; the delayed-draw loan can be drawn until 15 October 2028 only to retire the $348.2M of 6.5% notes, which it expects to do on about 15 October 2027, when they are redeemable at par.Its refresh_by (the Q3 10-Q) fired: the 10-Q attaches the credit agreement, so the covenant levels are now known (4.00 times net leverage, 1.20 times fixed charges), and the old loans now sit on the revolver at $203.4M.

Thursday 12 November14

  • ZMZoom CommunicationsThesis changed

    Zoom shares rose about 9% in three days with no company news

    Zoom shares closed at $98.08 on 11 November, up from $89.88 on 6 November, with no news from the company. Our value had left out Zoom's $3.79B of stakes in private companies, mostly Anthropic, which its last quarterly report carries on the balance sheet. Counting them, we think Zoom is worth about $93.65 a share.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business moved. At about 105% of the corrected value the price is inside our safety margin, so the view stays Neutral with medium conviction. The 23 November report on big- and small-customer growth is the next test.

    1 claim changed
    • C53EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Zoom is worth about $93.65 a share against $98.08 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.99B grow 4%, 4% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C52), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.7% to 28.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.6% of sales and a further 6.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; plus $7.25B of cash and securities and $3.79B of strategic investments at their carrying value (C17), with no debt. Bear (half that growth, a 22.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79.53, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.9% margin) about $114.the bridge now adds the $3.79B of strategic investments (C17) at their carrying value, which the 10 November value had left out, and the value is re-priced at the 11 November close
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Zoom is worth about $81.02 a share against $89.88 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • STXSeagate Technology HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Seagate shares rose about 20% in a week, with no news from the company

    Seagate closed at $551.72 on 11 November, up from $460.99 on 6 November, with no new results or filings. We value the business at about $434 a share, so the price is now about 127% of that value, above the 120% line we had marked as too dear.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Neutral to Unattractive, with medium conviction. The price now pays for the drive shortage lasting longer than our base case assumes. The business case itself is unchanged; prices fixed into 2029 or a fall back near $520 would change the view.

    2 claims changed
    • C15EditedAt $499.00, the 16 November close, the shares cost about 12.4 times analysts' FY27 EPS and 7.6 times FY28's. FY28's consensus keeps about 53% of revenue as profit, against 26.1% in FY26 and 14.1% at the last peak in FY22: the price does not pay a peak multiple on those forecasts, but the forecast still needs margins this industry has never held through a cycle.re-struck at the 11 November close of $551.72; route P2 fired
      Was

      At $593.76 the shares cost about 14.8 times analysts' FY27 EPS and 9.0 times FY28's. FY28's consensus keeps about 53% of revenue as profit, against 2…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Seagate Technology is worth about $434 a share against $499.00 at the 16 November close, about 115% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $13.80B grow 60%, 37% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C34, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 39.6% to its five-year average of 14.7% over five years, because 39.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 21 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.35B of debt net of $1.26B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $173, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.1% margin) about $659.re-priced at the 11 November close of $551.72, about 127% of the unchanged base case; route P2 fired and the view moved to Unattractive
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Seagate Technology is worth about $434 a share against $461 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    SpaceX says it will spend over $74B on two AI computer sites

    SpaceX said it plans to spend more than $24B on a computing site at its Starbase base in Texas, which will make its own electricity, and about $50B on a campus in Cochise County, Arizona. The Arizona site still needs the county's approval at a hearing in December, and local residents oppose it. No filing or customer contract came with the news.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case already counts SpaceX spending tens of billions a quarter on computers and power; this names two of the places. The view stays Unattractive with high conviction, because the price still sits far above our value and these sites earn nothing yet.

    Checked against 3 claims - none changed
    • C16UnchangedThe CFO now expects fourth-quarter 2026 capital spending of $35B-$40B, about double Q3's $19.6B, as nameplate compute rises from 1.7 to 2.5-3 gigawatts by December; Musk says he is highly confident of 10 gigawatts more in 2027 (13 in all) and has a plan, not a forecast, for 20 more.
    • C40UnchangedBeyond the AI build, SpaceX has announced a $100B Louisiana spaceport with construction from 2027, and a Terafab chip plant with Tesla and Intel whose projects and spending are not yet set.
    • C15UnchangedIn H1 2026 operations brought in $3.47B of cash while equipment spending took $28.48B, so the business used about $25.0B before financing.
  • SOFISoFi TechnologiesThesis changed

    SoFi shares slipped about 3%, with no news from the company

    SoFi closed at $16.27 on 11 November, down from $16.75 on 9 November, with no new results or filings. We value the shares at about $20.36, so the price is about 80% of that value, exactly the line where we would normally call a stock cheap enough.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays Neutral. Our value assumes SoFi earns a much higher return on its net worth than forecasts show, so we now want a price near $15.27, 75% of our value, before calling it attractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C64EditedOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $14.85 at the 16 November close, about 73% of it. Base case: shareholders' equity of $11.30B grows 27%, 23% and 20% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C63, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 7.3%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 7.1%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 5.7% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $6.69, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.8% return) about $36.72.re-priced at the 11 November close of $16.27, about 80% of the unchanged $20.36 base case; route P1 touched and the view was held at Neutral on a wider line
      Was

      On an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $16.75 at the 9 November close. Base case: shareholders…

  • OUSTOusterRefreshed

    Ouster shares rose 35% in a week after its third-quarter report

    Ouster shares closed at $38.22 on 11 November, up from $28.22 on 2 November, most of it in the days after the third-quarter report. A Spanish toll-road company, Indra, said it picked Ouster's sensors, but gave no order size. Counting Ouster's cash, buyers now pay about $2.34B for the business.

    What it did to the thesisThe business facts did not move, so the view stays Neutral with medium conviction. The higher price now needs about 40% sales growth a year for five years, the middle of management's own target, as it did in September. The next test is the December-quarter report.

    3 claims changed
    • C55EditedNet of about $421M of cash and with no debt, buyers are paying about $2.34B for Ouster at the 11 November 2026 close - roughly 9.8 times annualised Q3 revenue and about 23.1 times annualised gross profit, with no refund in the quarter. Earning 12% a year for five years, on 20 times operating profit, needs about $1.16B of revenue in 2031 at a 17.7% operating margin: about 40% compound growth every year, at management's own 37.5% mid-point gross margin, with operating costs rising 6.5% a year throughout.re-struck at the 11 November close: the shares rose 35.4% from 2 November after the Q3 report, so the required growth rose from about 35% to about 40%
      Was

      Net of about $421M of cash and with no debt, buyers are paying about $1.61B for Ouster at the 2 November 2026 close - roughly 6.8 times annualised Q3…

    • C56EditedAt 30% compound growth - the floor of management's own framework - Ouster reaches about $814M of revenue and about $76M of operating profit in 2031, which at 20 times is about $1.51B: about two-thirds of what buyers are paying for the business today, before any discounting.re-struck against the 11 November 2026 close. The 2031 figures do not depend on the price and stand; at 42% gross margin the floor case no longer quite clears the price
      Was

      At 30% compound growth - the floor of management's own framework - Ouster reaches about $814M of revenue and about $76M of operating profit in 2031,…

    • C57EditedOuster closed at $38.22 on 11 November 2026, 35.4% above the $28.22 of 2 November and 40.1% below its 252-day high of $63.79.re-struck at the 11 November 2026 close from the same end-of-day feed; the 252-day high is unchanged
      Was

      Ouster closed at $28.22 on 2 November 2026, 32% below the $41.37 of 24 September and 55.8% below its 252-day high of $63.79.

  • NVDANVIDIAThesis changed

    Jensen Huang resigns as Nvidia's chief executive; finance chief Colette Kress steps in

    Nvidia's board accepted Jensen Huang's resignation on 11 November, after reports of two affairs, one with a woman US officials suspect of spying for China. Colette Kress, the finance chief, runs the company for now while the board looks for a permanent leader inside and outside. Harvey Jones became the first board chair. The board's investigation and Congress's questions continue. Results still come on 17 November.

    What it did to the thesisNo sales, margin or cash figure moved, and the price fell further below our value, so we keep Attractive with medium confidence. Losing the founder is a real risk, now named: the results on 17 November, and who leads next, could change that.

    2 claims changed
    • C60NewNVIDIA's independent directors opened an investigation on November 8, 2026 into the former chief executive's relationship with a Megaspeed executive the US government is reported to regard as a Chinese intelligence asset, and retained Joon H. Kim and Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to run it. On November 16 the Justice and Commerce departments said they are running a criminal investigation into Megaspeed; on November 17 the SEC was reported to have opened a civil inquiry into whether NVIDIA's disclosures misled investors, and three House committees set hearings with Huang on December 1 and general counsel Tim Teter on December 2. The board created a standing National Security and Export Control Oversight Committee on November 17. No finding or charge against NVIDIA has been published.the investigations around the former chief executive outlast his resignation and bear on export and legal risk
    • C52EditedJen-Hsun Huang co-founded NVIDIA in 1993 and ran it as president and chief executive until November 11, 2026, when the board accepted his resignation from those roles and from the board; Colette Kress, chief financial officer since 2013 and from Cisco before that, is interim chief executive while staying chief financial officer, the board is searching for a permanent chief executive among internal and external candidates, and Harvey C. Jones, a director since 1993, is its first chair. Huang's daughter and son are employed by the company. On November 17 Huang said publicly he would return as chief executive if the board asked and would cooperate with its investigation; the board is reported not to be considering his return.the 8-K of November 12, 2026 reports Huang's resignation, Kress as interim chief executive and Jones as chair; the claim said Huang still ran NVIDIA
      Was

      Jen-Hsun Huang co-founded NVIDIA in 1993 and has been its president and chief executive since; Colette Kress joined as chief financial officer in 201…

  • NTNXNutanixThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Nutanix shares rose about 3% in three days with no company news

    Nutanix shares closed at $60.14 on 11 November, up from $58.37 on 6 November, with no news from the company. We think the business is worth about $49.30 a share, so the price is now about 122% of that value, past the line where we call it too dear, and it has sat there for three days.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Nutanix Unattractive, with medium conviction. Our value already counts analysts' faster growth, and the price asks for about twice that. A fall back below about $59 would bring it back to Neutral; the report on 24 November is the next test.

    1 claim changed
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Nutanix is worth about $49.30 a share against $60.14 at the 11 November close, about 122% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.85B grow 13%, 14% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.6% to 22.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 12.5% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 9.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.35B of debt net of $2.36B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25.92, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.7% margin) about $66.82.price re-struck at the 11 November close of $60.14, about 122% of the unchanged base case, past the 120% line
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Nutanix is worth about $49.30 a share against $58.37 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    China approves Lilly's weight-loss pill orforglipron

    Reuters reported that China's drug regulator approved orforglipron, Lilly's daily weight-loss pill, sold in the US as Foundayo. Only the headline could be read, so we do not know whether it covers obesity, diabetes or both, when it launches or at what price. Lilly has not yet put out a release or filing.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The pill gains a large market, which Lilly had expected around now, but our view is about the share price against what the business can earn, and this approval changes no figure in that. We keep Unattractive and Medium confidence and test the business at the February results.

  • LEUCentrus EnergyThesis changed

    Oklo signs binding fuel contracts with Centrus, paying part in advance

    Oklo, which designs small nuclear reactors, turned its June letter of intent into binding multi-year contracts to buy high-grade fuel from Centrus's planned Ohio plant, enough for up to five reactors, with deliveries from 2029. Oklo pays part in advance, helped by Meta's advance payment for Oklo's power. Neither company gave the amount, the price or the size of the advance.

    What it did to the thesisA promise became a contract, which strengthens the case that buyers want the plant's fuel. But with no amount given, it adds nothing we can value, and the share price already sits above even our best case. We keep Unattractive and High confidence.

    1 claim changed
    • C30EditedCentrus signed definitive multi-year HALEU contracts with X-energy (6 August 2026, LEU and HALEU, with prepayments), Radiant (9 September), Antares (17 September, with prepayments) and Oklo (12 November, with prepayments, formalising the June letter of intent: enough HALEU for up to five Aurora powerhouses for multiple years, deliveries from 2029); none discloses a volume or price.Oklo's June letter of intent became definitive contracts with prepayments on 12 November
      Was

      Centrus signed definitive multi-year HALEU contracts with X-energy (6 August 2026, LEU and HALEU, with prepayments), Radiant (9 September) and Antare…

  • ICHRIchor HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Ichor shares rose about 21% in three days with no company news

    Ichor shares closed at $37.45 on 11 November, up from $30.97 on 6 November and $28.03 on 5 November, with no news from the company. We think the business is worth about $30 a share, so the price is now about 125% of that value, past the line where we call it too dear.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Ichor Unattractive, with medium conviction. Our value already assumes margins back to its best years, and two customers set those margins, so nothing earns paying a quarter more. A fall back below about $36 would bring it back to Neutral; the next test is the February report.

    1 claim changed
    • C30EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $33.65 at the 16 November close, about 112% of it, where enterprise value is about 1.08 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $947.7M grow 31%, 25% and 12% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 1.7% to 7% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 31 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever, the return on new capital gliding to 8%. Bear (flat in 2027 and 2028, a 4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.66, bull (32% and 15%, a 9% margin) about $55.07. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $18.95.brought into line with the fair-value block re-struck on 10 November (base $30.07, bear $12.66, bull $55.07), which the claim had not followed, and the price re-struck at the 11 November close of $37.45, about 125% of the base case
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $34 a share against $30.97 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value…

  • HOODRobinhood MarketsUnchanged

    Robinhood says customers added $15.1 billion in October

    Robinhood's October figures: customers added $15.1 billion, a 46% yearly pace, though money paid into the new government-backed Trump Accounts for children is counted in it, much of it one family's gift. Customers reached 28.9 million and loans to traders $22.9 billion. Prediction-market trading was 136% above a year earlier; crypto trading fell 48%.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The deposit pace we watch for the December quarter looks safely met, and one month does not change what the business earns. The shares still cost about twice what we think they are worth, so the view stays Unattractive.

  • COHUCohuThesis changed

    Cohu held its investor day and named one more AI chip customer

    On 10 November Cohu told investors where it hopes to be in three to five years: reports put it at about $1.3B of sales, more than double this year. The same day it said one more unnamed chip designer chose its Eclipse handler. It did not say how many customers have now approved the handler, nor what profit margin it expects under ordinary accounting.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A target years away is a hope, not a result, and the questions we set were left open. The shares at $45.98 cost more than even our hopeful case, so the view stays Unattractive until the February results answer them.

    3 claims changed
    • C10EditedCohu puts its annual computing opportunity pipeline at about $1.0 billion, up 18% from about $850M a quarter earlier: $230M of annual revenue potential is qualified and another $440M is in qualification, across 13 ranked customer programs, and seven more programs worth about $340M a year reach qualification milestones between late November and the first quarter of 2027; several hundred Eclipse systems are forecast for 2027. On 10 November Cohu announced one more, unnamed fabless customer selecting Eclipse for production test of its next-generation computing chips, again without a count of qualified customers.the 10 November release adds one new fabless customer choosing Eclipse for production test; the release gives no count of qualified customers, so the eight-customer line in route P4 is still unanswered
      Was

      Cohu puts its annual computing opportunity pipeline at about $1.0 billion, up 18% from about $850M a quarter earlier: $230M of annual revenue potenti…

    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cohu is worth about $19.79 a share against $38.49 at the 6 November close, and $45.98 at the 11 November close, about 232% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $569M grow 37% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -2.4% to 10.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.0% of sales and a further 2.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 54 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $302M of debt net of $508M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.8% margin) about $32.19.the price rose 19.5% from the 6 November close it was struck at; at the 11 November close of $45.98 it is about 232% of the base case and above the bull case, so the view does not move
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cohu is worth about $19.79 a share against $38.49 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C30RetiredThe chief financial officer guides Q3 2026 diluted shares to about 55M, including 5.8M attributable to the notes, of which 2.4M are offset by the capped call but still counted under GAAP.a Q3 share-count guide that expired on 29 October; the Q3 10-Q read in the 29 October review reports the quarter's diluted shares, so the guide no longer carries anything
  • ANETArista NetworksThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Arista shares rose about 15% in three days with no company news

    Arista shares closed at $196.68 on 11 November, up from $170.80 on 6 November, with no news from the company. We think the business is worth about $157 a share, so the price is now about 125% of that value, past the line where we call it too dear. Analysts have nudged their forecasts up, but not enough to change that.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Arista Unattractive, with medium conviction. The business is solid, but our value already uses analysts' steep growth forecasts, and the price pays for more. A fall back below about $188 would bring it back to Neutral; the next test is the February report.

    1 claim changed
    • C75EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Arista is worth about $157 a share against $187.02 at the 16 November close, about 119% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $11.89B grow 41%, 28% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C74), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 43.8% to 41.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 18.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $14.36B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 33.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $70.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 45.9% margin) about $230.price re-struck at the 11 November close of $196.68, about 125% of the unchanged base case, past the 120% line; the analysts' newer path noted against it
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Arista is worth about $157 a share against $171 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

  • AMDAdvanced Micro DevicesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    AMD shares rose about 23% in a week, with no news from the company

    AMD closed at $552.90 on 11 November, up from $449.04 on 6 November, with no new results or filings. We value the business at about $460 a share, so the price is now about 120% of that value, just above the 120% line we had marked as too dear. Product launches and a quantum-computing investment that week carried no figures that bear on the case.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Neutral to Unattractive, with medium conviction. The price now pays a fifth more than our value while the new AI racks are still unproven. Sales of those racks in the fourth-quarter results, or a fall back below about $552, would change it.

    2 claims changed
    • C36EditedAt $504.28, the 16 November close, AMD trades at about 76 times the last four quarters' adjusted EPS of $6.65, 31 times the analysts' 2027 EPS of $16.07 and 21.6 times their 2028 EPS of $23.40 (forecasts of 16 October, before the results); on GAAP earnings the trailing figure is about 108.re-struck at the 11 November close ($552.90); route P2 fired
      Was

      At $483.90 AMD trades at about 73 times the last four quarters' adjusted EPS of $6.65, 30 times the analysts' 2027 EPS of $16.07 and 20.7 times their…

    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $504.28 at the 16 November close, about 110% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $45.44B grow 60%, 50% and 35% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.7% to 25.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (21.2% after amortisation of past deals, 4.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 29.5%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.08B of debt net of $15.78B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $140, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.7% margin) about $788.re-priced at the 11 November close of $552.90, about 120% of the unchanged base case; route P2 fired and the view moved to Unattractive
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $449 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

Wednesday 11 November13

  • WOLFWolfspeedRefreshed

    Wolfspeed's quarterly filing shows more lender notes turning into shares

    Wolfspeed's shares rose 15% since 4 November, to $26.23, without new company news. Its quarterly filing shows lenders turned $10.0M of notes into 0.8M shares, leaving $1,772.0M of debt, and the company used about $95M of cash in the quarter, counting spending on equipment. That leaves about seven quarters before it hits the lenders' minimum cash.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the business changed. Counting the lenders' notes as shares, the price is now about 4.4 times a year's sales, inside what profitable rivals cost, so we still rate it Unattractive. We would turn Neutral if sales pass $200M a quarter with a gross profit.

    8 claims changed
    • C27EditedDebt principal was $1,772.0M at September 27, 2026: $635.9M of first-lien notes due 2030, now near 16% in cash, $296.4M of second-lien notes paying 7% cash or 12% in kind, and three convertible notes due 2031: $257.1M at $12.23 after $10.0M converted in the quarter, $203.6M at $18.35 held by Renesas and $379.0M at $20.14.re-sourced to the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q debt table: $10.0M of the $12.23 notes converted
      Was

      Debt principal was $1,782.0M: $635.9M of first-lien notes due 2030, now near 16% in cash, $296.4M of second-lien notes paying 7% cash or 12% in kind,…

    • C28EditedThere were 53,581,878 shares outstanding at October 30, 2026 (52,995,396 at August 13), plus 2.0M pre-funded warrants at August 13; Renesas holds a warrant for 4,943,555 shares at $23.95.share count re-sourced to the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q cover
      Was

      There were 52,995,396 shares outstanding at August 13, 2026, plus 2.0M pre-funded warrants; Renesas holds a warrant for 4,943,555 shares at $23.95.

    • C29EditedThe three convertible notes turn into about 50.9M shares and the Renesas warrant into 4.9M more: 55.9M new shares against 55.6M today, so today's holders would own about 50% of the company.re-struck on the 10-Q's share count and the notes left after the quarter's conversion
      Was

      The three convertible notes turn into about 51.8M shares and the Renesas warrant into 4.9M more: 56.7M new shares against 55.0M today, so today's hol…

    • C35EditedMuch of that short position is likely hedging by convertible-note holders rather than outright bets: the notes convert into 50.9M shares, and five of the nine holders above 5% are hedge funds or market makers.the notes now convert into 50.9M shares (C29)
      Was

      Much of that short position is likely hedging by convertible-note holders rather than outright bets: the notes convert into 51.8M shares, and five of…

    • C37EditedAt the $26.23 close of 2026-11-10, counting the notes and warrant as shares, the company is worth about $2.74B: 4.4 times trailing sales of $623.3M. That sits inside onsemi's and STMicroelectronics' 3.8 to 5.5 times as last compared on 2026-10-01, though they keep 34 to 37 cents of each sales dollar as gross profit and Wolfspeed loses about 22.re-struck at the 2026-11-10 close, up 15% since 4 November, on the 10-Q's share count and debt
      Was

      At the $22.79 close of 2026-11-04, counting the notes and warrant as shares, the company is worth about $2.36B: 3.8 times trailing sales of $623.3M.…

    • C39EditedAt STMicroelectronics' 3.8 times, today's company value of about $2.74B needs about $722M of yearly sales, 16% more than the last four quarters' $623.3M but short of the roughly $800M gross breakeven; at onsemi's 5.5 times it needs $499M, but only with onsemi's margins.re-struck on the 10 November company value (C37)
      Was

      At STMicroelectronics' 3.8 times, today's company value needs about $844M of yearly sales, 27% more than fiscal 2026 and above the $800M gross breake…

    • C40EditedCash above the $350M floor is $645.1M. At Q1 fiscal 2027's operating outflow of $84.2M and capital spending of $10.6M, about $95M a quarter, that is about seven quarters, to around mid-2028, unless revenue rises.capital spending from the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q added to the quarterly burn
      Was

      Cash above the $350M floor is $645.1M. At Q1 fiscal 2027's operating outflow of $84M a quarter, before capital spending, that is about seven to eight…

    • C56EditedThe 2026 annual meeting was held on October 27, 2026, and stockholders approved the 2026 employee stock purchase plan of up to 1,700,000 shares at a 15% discount; the proxy also put seven directors, an advisory vote on executive pay and the auditor to the vote.the meeting was held; the 10-Q records the purchase plan's approval
      Was

      The 2026 annual meeting is on October 27, 2026: seven directors, a 2026 employee stock purchase plan of up to 1,700,000 shares at a 15% discount, an…

  • TSMTaiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company LimitedUnchanged

    TSMC plans to invest up to $1 billion in Anthropic and OpenAI

    TSMC's board approved buying up to $500 million of Anthropic shares when Anthropic lists, and up to $500 million of OpenAI preferred shares. It also set aside up to $500 million for a new fund for chip-industry stakes, raised its quarterly dividend to NT$9.0 a share from NT$7.00, and approved about $40.9 billion of new factory spending.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The stakes come to less than 1% of TSMC's cash, too small to change its finances, and the dividend and factory spending fit what our case already assumed. The view stays Attractive.

  • TLNTalen EnergyThesis changed

    Talen sells seven years of a gas plant's capacity to an unnamed buyer

    Talen agreed to sell 750 MW of capacity, a promise to have power ready when the grid needs it, from its Guernsey gas plant for seven years from 2029, for about $100M a year. The buyer is unnamed but creditworthy. Shorter deals cover another 1.3 GW. Talen says 40% of its gross profit is now locked in through 2036.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays Neutral. Locked-in revenue lowers the risk from swinging power prices, but it is not the data-centre contract our case is waiting for. We would move to Attractive on a signed data-centre deal and debt falling toward the company's target.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewOn 11 November 2026 Talen announced a seven-year sale of 750 MW of accredited capacity from its Guernsey gas plant to an unnamed investment-grade counterparty in PJM, covering delivery years 2029/2030 to 2035/2036, expected to bring about $100M a year (about $365 per MW-day, above the $325 cap the 2028/2029 auction cleared at). Separate agreements contract Guernsey's other 588 MW for 2029/2030 and 702 MW of Waterford for 2029/2030 to 2031/2032. With the AWS contract, Talen says 40% of its gross margin is now contracted through 2036 and more than a third of its accredited capacity is under long-term contract. The buyer is not named, no contract or 8-K was filed, and the per-MW-day figure is our division of the company's rounded revenue.Talen's release of 11 November 2026: a seven-year 750 MW capacity sale from Guernsey to an unnamed investment-grade buyer
    • C20EditedManagement describes a development pipeline of approximately 4 GW of land development and data-center contracting options, plus over 2 GW of gas and storage projects submitted into PJM's Cycle 1 interconnection study cluster; management explicitly framed 2025 as 'a year of options' and 2026 as 'a year of market rationalization.' The 3 November 2026 release and 10-Q name no additional signed large-load contract beyond the AWS PPA; on the same-day call management named no signed deal either: it said other kinds of power deals beyond nuclear 'are coming', that it is 'not beholden to a specific timeline for our deals', and that 2029 is becoming the target year for new data-centre sites. It confirmed the American Web Services contract's minimum commitment ramps to 840 MW in 2029, and that no faster ramp is built into the 2029 outlook. On 11 November 2026 Talen signed a seven-year capacity sale from its operating Guernsey gas plant to an unnamed investment-grade buyer (C46); that is contracted revenue from an existing plant, not a data-centre contract from the pipeline, which still has no signed deal.11 November capacity sale read: a long-term contract from an operating plant, not from the data-centre pipeline, which still has none signed
      Was

      Management describes a development pipeline of approximately 4 GW of land development and data-center contracting options, plus over 2 GW of gas and…

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    Report says Nvidia's CEO also had a relationship with an executive reporting to him

    After the market closed, The New York Times reported that chief executive Jensen Huang had a relationship with an Nvidia executive who reports to him. This comes on top of the affair the board has been investigating since Sunday. Only the headline and a one-line summary could be read. Nvidia has not commented and filed nothing. The executive is not named in what we could read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the business moved. A relationship with someone he manages makes it more likely the board's investigation ends with a change in who runs Nvidia. We keep Attractive and Medium confidence until its findings, or Huang's role, change, and test the business on 17 November.

  • NSITInsight EnterprisesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Insight shares rose about 7% in two days with no company news

    Insight shares closed at $168.75 on 10 November, up from $158.25 on 6 November, with no news from the company. We think the business is worth about $140 a share, so the price is now about 121% of that value, just past the line where we call it too dear.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate Insight Unattractive, with medium conviction. Its business is middling and its vendors set its fees, so nothing earns paying a fifth above its value. A fall back below about $168 would bring it back to Neutral; the next test is the February report.

    1 claim changed
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Insight is worth about $140 a share against $155.29 at the 16 November close, about 111% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $9.02B grow 1%, 6% and -5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.1% to 6.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales and a further 0.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.50B of debt net of $398M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $96.94, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.0% margin) about $202.price re-struck at the 10 November close of $168.75, about 121% of the unchanged base case, past the 120% line
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Insight is worth about $140 a share against $158 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sa…

  • HLIOHelios TechnologiesThesis changed

    Helios shares slipped 3% to $48.00, with no news

    Helios's shares fell 3% to $48.00 with no news from the company. That puts them at about 78% of the roughly $61.80 we think the business is worth, a little past the line where our 20% cushion begins.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business changed. Its sales rise and fall with the economy and its first data-centre order still has no size, so a cushion this thin is not enough: Helios stays Neutral with medium conviction, and turns Attractive near $46.35.

    1 claim changed
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Helios is worth about $61.80 a share against $48.00 at the 10 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 3%, 5% and 3% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.9% to 18.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 47 cents of capital; a 23.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $328M of debt net of $73M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.66, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.5% margin) about $76.63.Price re-read at the 10 November close of $48.00, about 78% of the unchanged base case: past the band's 80% line, which the view now treats as too thin a cushion for this business.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Helios is worth about $61.80 a share against $49.48 at the 9 November close, about 80% of it. Ba…

  • GEOThe GEO GroupRefreshed

    GEO's quarterly filing shows four more detention centres readied for sale

    GEO's shares rose 16% since 4 November, to $31.94. Its quarterly filing, out on 6 November, says four more centres it owns, 5,919 beds, were readied for sale in October, a step companies take when they expect a sale within a year. It still says no deal, price or date is agreed. Analysts also raised their forecasts after the results.

    What it did to the thesisOur estimate of what GEO is worth rose to about $35.62 a share, so the price is about 90% of it: still Neutral. We would turn more positive if a second sale is signed near $300,000 a bed with GEO still running the centre, or the price falls near $28.50.

    11 claims changed
    • C62NewGEO's 10-Q says its 1,408-bed Aurora, 1,876-bed Moshannon Valley, 1,635-bed Northwest (Tacoma) and 1,000-bed Delaney Hall centres, 5,919 beds carried at about $219M, met the criteria to be classified as assets held for sale in October 2026; the same filing says no definitive agreement or timeline exists for any further sale to ICE.the Q3 10-Q, read for the first time, shows four more owned ICE centres readied for sale
    • C05EditedManagement says GEO holds about 24,000 ICE detainees of a national ICE population of about 73,000, and that its ICE beds under contract reach about 33,000 at 29 facilities once four reactivations finish; the 10-Q counts about 76,000 beds managed or owned at 97 facilities, idle ones included.re-sourced to the Q3 call and 10-Q: the national count the chairman cites rose to about 73,000 and ICE beds under contract to about 33,000
      Was

      Management says GEO owns about 50,000 beds at 70 facilities, holds about 24,000 ICE detainees of a national 68,000, and will have about 29,500 ICE be…

    • C20EditedGEO says it remains in an active process to sell several more company-owned facilities to ICE and keep operating them, subject to agreement on price; its 2026-10-05 8-K, its 2026-11-05 results release and its 10-Q filed 2026-11-06 all say there is no definitive agreement and no precise timeline for any further sale.the Q3 10-Q repeats that no further sale has an agreement or timeline; the call's new timing added as counter-evidence
      Was

      GEO says it remains in an active process to sell several more company-owned facilities to ICE and keep operating them, subject to agreement on price;…

    • C29EditedThe shares closed at $13.26 on 2026-02-20, $32.34 on 2026-10-05, $27.53 on 2026-11-04 and $31.94 on 2026-11-10, up 16.0% from 4 November; the 52-week range at 2026-10-05 was $12.51 to $33.20.re-struck at the 10 November close
      Was

      The shares closed at $13.26 on 2026-02-20, $32.34 on 2026-10-05 and $27.53 on 2026-11-04, down 14.9% since the Adelanto news; the 52-week range at 20…

    • C30EditedAt $31.94 enterprise value is about $5.53B on the 30 September balance sheet (about 132M shares, $1.53B of debt, $216.0M of cash); that is 10.2 times trailing Adjusted EBITDA of $544.6M and 9.7 times the $570.5M 2026 guidance midpoint; the vendor's prior-year median EV/EBITDA is 7.0.re-struck at the 10 November close
      Was

      At $27.53 enterprise value is about $4.95B on the 30 September balance sheet (about 132M shares, $1.53B of debt, $216.0M of cash); that is 9.1 times…

    • C31EditedAt the old 7 times, $570.5M supports about $4.0B of enterprise value, about $20 a share on the 30 September balance sheet; the $1.54B gap to the price is what about 5,800 beds would net at Adelanto's price after tax, of which Adelanto's 2,644 beds net about $705M, about 46%.re-struck at the 10 November close: the price rose 16%, so Adelanto covers less of the gap
      Was

      At the old 7 times, $570.5M supports about $4.0B of enterprise value, about $20 a share on the 30 September balance sheet; the $0.95B gap to the pric…

    • C44EditedManagement counts about 190,000 on ISAP, up from 184,000 three months earlier, 58,000 of them on ankle monitors against 17,000 in early 2025, and says the shift to pricier devices continues.re-sourced to the Q3 call and 10-Q: about 190,000 on ISAP and 58,000 on ankle monitors
      Was

      Management counts about 184,000 on ISAP, 54,000 of them on ankle monitors against 17,000 in early 2025, and says the pricier devices offset flat coun…

    • C54EditedGEO reported its third-quarter 2026 results on 5 November 2026, the date the vendor calendar of 4 October gave; it held its call that day and filed the 10-Q on 6 November.the call and the 10-Q, unavailable when this was last written, are now read
      Was

      GEO reported its third-quarter 2026 results on 5 November 2026, the date the vendor calendar of 4 October gave; the 10-Q and the earnings call transc…

    • C57EditedPro forma for Adelanto's about $705M of net proceeds, enterprise value is about $4.83B at $31.94, 8.5 times the $570.5M 2026 guidance midpoint against about 7 times before; the remaining $0.83B gap to 7 times is about 3,100 beds at Adelanto's net price a bed, fewer than the 5,919 beds GEO classified as held for sale in October (C62).re-struck at the 10 November close and set against the four centres the 10-Q classifies as held for sale
      Was

      Pro forma for Adelanto's about $705M of net proceeds, enterprise value is about $4.24B at $27.53, 7.4 times the $570.5M 2026 guidance midpoint agains…

    • C60EditedAnalysts expect revenue of $2.99B in fiscal 2026, $3.35B in fiscal 2027, $3.60B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $671M in the last of those years, an 18.7% margin before stock pay.re-read after the Q3 print: the analysts raised 2027 revenue from $3.27B to $3.35B and 2028 operating profit from $603M to $671M
      Was

      Analysts expect revenue of $2.99B in fiscal 2026, $3.27B in fiscal 2027, $3.47B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $603M in the last of those y…

    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GEO is worth about $35.62 a share against $31.94 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.91B grow 12% and 9% over the next two years (the analysts' path, C60), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.0% to 14.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales and a further 3.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 83 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.53B of debt net of $216M of cash. Bear (half that growth, an 11.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.5% margin) about $48.06.re-struck on the analysts' raised path after the Q3 print and the 10 November close
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GEO is worth about $29.65 a share against $27.80 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sa…

  • GDDYGoDaddyThesis changed

    GoDaddy shares edged up about 1% to $113.13, with no news

    GoDaddy's shares rose about 1% to $113.13 with no news from the company. That puts them at about 80% of the roughly $141 we think the business is worth, just over the line where our 20% cushion runs out.

    What it did to the thesisNothing about the business changed, and a fraction of a point is less than our estimate of value can tell apart, so GoDaddy stays Attractive with medium conviction. It moves to Neutral if the shares reach about $117.

    1 claim changed
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.Price re-read at the 10 November close of $113.13, about 80% of the unchanged base case: a hair over the 80% line, which the view now treats as inside the value's precision.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $111.71 at the 9 November close, about 79% of it. Ba…

  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsThesis changed

    Forgent's shares fell 5% to $21.48, a day before its results

    Forgent's shares closed at $21.48 on 10 November, down from $22.60. That is about 79% of the roughly $27.21 a share we think the business is worth, just past the 20% discount we usually ask for. Nothing new was filed or announced. Results are due on 12 November.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The price is only just past our line, and our estimate is very uncertain: the low case is near $7 and most of the value comes from years far ahead. We would call it Attractive below about $20.41, or if the results support next year's plan.

    2 claims changed
    • C20EditedAt $20.57 the company value is about $6.66B, about 10.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 15.0 times the $1.37 adjusted EPS midpoint. Counting the $483.0M tax receivable liability as debt adds about three-quarters of a turn. Taking off stock pay at the September quarter's $13.9M a quarter, about $55.5M a year, it is about 12.0 times.re-struck at the 10 November close of $21.48, 5% below the 9 November close
      Was

      At $22.60 the company value is about $7.38B, about 12.3 times the $600M midpoint of FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 17.0 times the…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.price re-read at the 10 November close of $21.48; the inputs and the $27.21 base case are unchanged and the price is now about 79% of it
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.21 a share against $22.60 at the 9 November close. Base case: FY26 sa…

  • FLOCFlowco HoldingsRefreshed

    Flowco's shares slipped to $20.67, right at the edge of our cheap range

    Flowco's shares closed at $20.67 on 10 November, down from $20.85 the day before. Our alarm for a cheap price went off, but only because it rounded the numbers: worked out exactly, the price is about 80.4% of the roughly $25.72 a share we think the business is worth. Nothing new was filed or announced.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We ask for a 20% discount before calling Flowco attractive, and with falling margins, growth mostly bought and financial controls that do not yet work, we want the full discount. We will move to Attractive if the price falls below about $20.58.

    1 claim changed
    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.72 a share against $20.67 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 16%, 7% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.6% to 19.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 128 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $363M of debt net of $138M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.00, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.3% margin) about $32.61.price re-read at the 10 November close, $20.67, about 80.4% of the unchanged $25.72 base case; the inputs did not move
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.72 a share against $20.85 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • FIGRFigure Technology SolutionsThesis changed

    Figure shares slipped back below our price line a day before results

    Figure Technology closed at $23.34 on 10 November, down from $24.52 the day before, with no news about the business. That is about 117% of the $19.96 a share we think the company is worth, just under the 120% mark we use as a guide. Its September-quarter results are due 12 November.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays Unattractive. One quiet day's dip does not change why the price looks dear: Figure keeps less of each loan and cash ran negative. We would move to Neutral if the price fell to about $21.96, or if the results show the slice it keeps holding.

    1 claim changed
    • C55EditedOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Figure Technology Solutions is worth about $18.40 a share against $24.19 at the 11 November close (about 131% of it). Base case: shareholders' equity of $1.52B at 30 September 2026 earns 14.7%, the first nine months' pretax profit of $223.3M annualised and taxed at 25%, and grows only by what it earns, 14.7% a year, since Figure pays no dividend, then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. The 225.1M shares are all three classes, which share earnings equally. Bear (half that growth, a 10% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $8.48, bull (18% growth and return, new equity earning 15%) about $27.67.re-struck at the 10 November close of $23.34, about 117% of the base case; the value itself did not move
      Was

      On an excess-return value at an 8% required return Figure Technology Solutions is worth about $19.96 a share against $24.52 at the 9 November close.…

  • FICOFair IsaacThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    FICO shares rose about 4% in two days, to the edge of our line

    FICO shares closed at $730.66 on 10 November, up from $704.55 on 6 November, with no company news. We think the business is worth about $610 a share, so the price is about 120% of that. Its annual report, filed on 6 November, does not say how much revenue mortgage scores brought in.

    What it did to the thesisWe now rate FICO Unattractive, with low conviction. Nothing earns a price a fifth above its value while FICO hides its mortgage prices and a cheap rival is allowed. A fall to about $702 would bring it back to Neutral; the next test is the February report.

    3 claims changed
    • C12EditedRevenue from agreements with Experian, TransUnion and Equifax was 60% of FICO's fiscal 2026 revenue against 51% in fiscal 2025 and 45% in fiscal 2024, and 63% of Q3 FY2026 revenue; each was more than 10%.re-sourced to the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November: the bureaus were 60% of the year's revenue, up from 51%
      Was

      Revenue from agreements with Experian, TransUnion and Equifax was 63% of FICO's Q3 FY2026 revenue against 54% a year earlier, and 51% of fiscal 2025;…

    • C13EditedFICO's 10-K names the three bureaus and their joint venture VantageScore as its primary scoring competitors, and TransUnion's own 10-K says it competes with FICO and lists FICO's direct licence program as a risk.re-read in the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November, which names the same competitors and adds VantageScore's increased regulatory acceptance in mortgages
    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FICO is worth about $610 a share against $730.66 at the 10 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.53B grow 4%, 5% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 49.9% to 45.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.26B of debt net of $218M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 36.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $270, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.5% margin) about $826.price re-struck at the 10 November close of $730.66, about 120% of the unchanged base case
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FICO is worth about $610 a share against $705 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

  • AVAVAeroVironmentThesis changed

    AeroVironment won a $405 million order for its anti-drone lasers in the Middle East

    AeroVironment said a customer in the Middle East ordered $405 million of its LOCUST X3 lasers, which shoot down small drones far more cheaply than missiles do. It also plans a local repair base there. The company did not name the buyer, say how many lasers, or say when they will be delivered.

    What it did to the thesisThis is the biggest sign yet that the laser can become a large business, which helps the bullish side of our case. But the shares already cost about twice what we think the whole company is worth, so one order does not change our Unattractive view.

    1 claim changed
    • C45NewOn 11 November 2026 AeroVironment announced a $405 million international direct commercial sales order for LOCUST X3 high-energy laser weapons for counter-drone defence in the Middle East, and said it intends to set up an in-country maintenance and sustainment depot; the release does not name the customer or say how many systems, the delivery years, or whether the order is funded.the $405M international LOCUST X3 order, announced 11 November 2026, bears on C24, C25, C26, C41 and the LOCUST criterion

Tuesday 10 November55

  • WAYWaystar HoldingThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Waystar shares rose to $29.18, past our line for Attractive

    Waystar shares closed at $29.18 on 9 November, up from $28.35 on 6 November, with no company news. We now value the business at about $36 a share, a little lower than last week after we tightened our valuation rules, so the price is about 81% of our value.

    What it did to the thesisThat is just short of the 20% cushion we ask for, and debt, a possible sale and Epic's own billing tools are the risks the cushion is for. We moved Waystar from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $28.14 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $1.26B grow 9%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.9% to 37.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.46B of debt net of $277M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 30.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 41.6% margin) about $48.55.price re-struck at the 9 November close, when route P1 fired: the shares are about 81% of the base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $37.80 a share against $28.35 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $28.14 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $1.26B grow 9%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.9% to 37.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.46B of debt net of $277M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 30.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 41.6% margin) about $48.55.price re-struck at the 9 November close, when route P1 fired: the shares are about 81% of the base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $28.35 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • VRTVertiv HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Vertiv shares rose past our price line, with no news from the company

    Vertiv closed at $200.47 on 9 November, up from $182.86 on 6 November, with no new results or filings. That is 29.6 times its last year of operating profit, above the 28.0 times we had marked as the cheap-enough line.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Attractive to Neutral. We value the shares at about $237 and ask for a 20% cushion; at $200.47 the cushion is about 15%. The business case and the fourth-quarter test are unchanged.

    3 claims changed
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $226 a share against $200 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.12B grow 38%, 24% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 22.8% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 27.0%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.93B of debt net of $3.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $101, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $324.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $279 a share against $183 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $226 a share against $200 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.12B grow 38%, 24% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 22.8% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 27.0%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.93B of debt net of $3.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $101, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $324.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $237 a share against $183 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $226 a share against $200 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.12B grow 38%, 24% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 22.8% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 27.0%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.93B of debt net of $3.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $101, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $324.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $237 a share against $200 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

  • VALEValeThesis changed

    Vale re-valued on a normal year's margin, not today's commodity price

    Vale sells at a commodity price it does not set. We now value it on a normal year's margin, not the analysts' margin at today's price, and count the capital its own filings show it needs. On that basis the shares are worth about $21.99, down from $27.10.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 53% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vale is worth about $21.61 a share against $11.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $48.75B grow -2%, -2% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.9% to 25.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 196 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $30.27B of debt net of $6.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.87, bull (a quarter more growth, a 28.0% margin) about $30.46.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vale is worth about $27.10 a share against $11.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vale is worth about $21.61 a share against $11.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $48.75B grow -2%, -2% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.9% to 25.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 196 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $30.27B of debt net of $6.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.87, bull (a quarter more growth, a 28.0% margin) about $30.46.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vale is worth about $21.99 a share against $11.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • TTMITTM TechnologiesThesis changed

    TTM Technologies re-valued on the margin it has already earned

    TTM Technologies's business goes through cycles, so we no longer assume a margin higher than it has already earned. On that basis the shares are worth about $146, down from $163.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 46% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C65EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TTM Technologies is worth about $141 a share against $66.51 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 56% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.1% to 14.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 15.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 48 cents of capital; a 21.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.64B of debt net of $876M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.71, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.6% margin) about $214.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TTM Technologies is worth about $163 a share against $66.51 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

    • C65EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TTM Technologies is worth about $141 a share against $66.51 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 56% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.1% to 14.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 15.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 48 cents of capital; a 21.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.64B of debt net of $876M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.71, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.6% margin) about $214.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TTM Technologies is worth about $146 a share against $66.51 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

  • TSMTaiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company LimitedUnchanged

    TSMC's October sales were 59.7% above a year earlier

    TSMC reported sales of NT$586.89 billion for October, 14.7% more than September and 59.7% more than October last year. For the first ten months of 2026 sales are NT$4,485.62 billion, up 43.3%. At recent exchange rates October is roughly $17.9 billion, a pace in line with the company's own guide for the quarter.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. One month at that pace fits the guide of $52.3 to $54.3 billion for the quarter and the growth our case needs, but the quarter's results in January are the real test. The view stays Attractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TSMC is worth about $728 a share against $375 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $150.89B grow 42%, 29% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 58.0% to 58.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 0.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 17.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $29.95B of debt net of $122.32B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 46.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $278, bull (a quarter more growth, a 64.2% margin) about $1,013.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TSMC is worth about $757 a share against $375 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

  • TOSTToastThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Toast re-valued with tax at the full rate

    Toast pays little tax today only because of past losses, so we now assume the full rate once they are used up. On that basis the shares are worth about $26.84, down from $28.90.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 129% of that value, so we moved Toast from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Toast is worth about $24.54 a share against $34.67 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.15B grow 19%, 17% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.2% to 8.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.0% of sales and a further 4.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.20B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.88, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.3% margin) about $33.18.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Toast is worth about $28.90 a share against $34.67 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Toast is worth about $24.54 a share against $34.67 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.15B grow 19%, 17% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.2% to 8.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.0% of sales and a further 4.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.20B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.88, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.3% margin) about $33.18.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Toast is worth about $26.84 a share against $34.67 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • TBCHTurtle BeachThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Turtle Beach shares rose 12% in one session to $17.04

    Turtle Beach shares closed at $17.04 on 9 November, up from $15.19 on 6 November. Nothing new was filed or reported in between. We value the business at about $13.61 a share on the cash it should produce.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about a quarter above that value and already pays for a strong holiday that has not happened yet. We moved Turtle Beach from Neutral to Unattractive; conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $15.99 at the 16 November close, about 117% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $320M grow 8%, 10% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 6.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $55M of debt net of $17M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.4% margin) about $19.81.Price re-read at the 9 November close of $17.04, about 125% of the unchanged base case: past the 120% line route P2 drew.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $14.45 a share against $15.19 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $15.99 at the 16 November close, about 117% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $320M grow 8%, 10% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 6.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $55M of debt net of $17M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.4% margin) about $19.81.Price re-read at the 9 November close of $17.04, about 125% of the unchanged base case: past the 120% line route P2 drew.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $15.19 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

  • STRLSterling InfrastructureThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Sterling shares rose 15% in one session to $290.67

    Sterling Infrastructure shares closed at $290.67 on 9 November, up from $252.82 on 6 November. We found no company news in that window. We value the business at about $354 a share on its own future cash.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now 82% of that value, no longer far enough below it for us to call it cheap. We moved Sterling from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; growth the customers fund needs only the plant
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $354 a share against $252.82 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; growth the customers fund needs only the plant
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $354 a share against $290.67 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • SOFISoFi TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    SoFi shares rose past our price line, with no news from the company

    SoFi closed at $16.75 on 9 November, up from $16.21 on 6 November, with no new results or filings. That is 2.35 times what the bank owns after goodwill, above the 2.29 times we had marked as the cheap-enough line.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Attractive to Neutral. We value the shares at about $20.36 and ask for a 20% cushion; at $16.75 the cushion is about 18%. The business case itself is unchanged.

    1 claim changed
    • C64EditedOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $14.85 at the 16 November close, about 73% of it. Base case: shareholders' equity of $11.30B grows 27%, 23% and 20% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C63, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 7.3%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 7.1%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 5.7% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $6.69, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.8% return) about $36.72.Re-struck at the 9 November close of $16.75 (was $16.21 at 6 November); the inputs and the $20.36 value are unchanged.
      Was

      On an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $16.21 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders…

  • SMCISuper Micro ComputerThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Supermicro re-valued with its debt counted

    Our value had left out the $8.65B of bank debt and convertible notes and $4.23B of preferred stock Supermicro owes. Counting them, the shares are worth about $50.83, down from $68.01, and we now hold a business we score Weak at Neutral however cheap it is.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 57% of that value, cheap, but the business is weak, so we moved Supermicro from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C65EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Supermicro is worth about $50.83 a share against $28.76 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $53.99B grow 45% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 5.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 20.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $8.65B of debt and $4.23B of preferred stock net of $6.91B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.7% margin) about $85.11.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Supermicro is worth about $70.27 a share against $28.76 at the 6 November close. Base case: trai…

    • C65EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Supermicro is worth about $50.83 a share against $28.76 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $53.99B grow 45% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 5.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 20.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $8.65B of debt and $4.23B of preferred stock net of $6.91B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.7% margin) about $85.11.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Supermicro is worth about $68.01 a share against $28.76 at the 6 November close. Base case: trai…

  • SKHYSK hynixThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    SK hynix re-valued on memory prices partly falling back

    Memory chips sell at a market price, and today's shortage prices sit inside the analysts' sales forecasts. We now assume half of SK hynix's fall to a normal margin comes from lower prices, which cuts its future sales. On that basis the shares are worth about $127, down from $314.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 100% of that value, so we moved SK hynix from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SK hynix is worth about $125 a share against $127 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $197.35B follow the analysts' path of 60%, 28% and 29% (C46) less the price fall half its margin drop implies, since memory sells at a market price: sales end year three at 49% of that path, so they grow 26%, 0% and 2%, then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.5% to its five-year average of 20.9% over five years, because 74.5% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.49B of debt net of $63.88B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.33, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.0% margin) about $180.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SK hynix is worth about $314 a share against $127 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SK hynix is worth about $125 a share against $127 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $197.35B follow the analysts' path of 60%, 28% and 29% (C46) less the price fall half its margin drop implies, since memory sells at a market price: sales end year three at 49% of that path, so they grow 26%, 0% and 2%, then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.5% to its five-year average of 20.9% over five years, because 74.5% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.49B of debt net of $63.88B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.33, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.0% margin) about $180.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SK hynix is worth about $127 a share against $127 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • RRCRange ResourcesThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Range Resources re-valued on a normal year's margin, not today's commodity price

    Range Resources sells at a commodity price it does not set. We now value it on a normal year's margin, not the analysts' margin at today's price, and count the capital its own filings show it needs. On that basis the shares are worth about $55.54, down from $73.25.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 88% of that value, so we moved Range Resources from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C42EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Range Resources is worth about $48.92 a share against $48.72 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.53B grow 2%, 6% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 34.8% to 26.8% over five years, the median of its last five filed years, below the analysts' 30.0%, because a producer's margin rides a commodity price it does not set; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $781M of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.79, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.5% margin) about $67.30.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Range Resources is worth about $73.25 a share against $48.72 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

    • C42EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Range Resources is worth about $48.92 a share against $48.72 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.53B grow 2%, 6% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 34.8% to 26.8% over five years, the median of its last five filed years, below the analysts' 30.0%, because a producer's margin rides a commodity price it does not set; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $781M of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.79, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.5% margin) about $67.30.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Range Resources is worth about $55.54 a share against $48.72 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

  • PYPLPayPal HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    PayPal re-valued, then judged Attractive on the whole picture

    We re-valued PayPal with a fuller tax rate, which put the shares at about $73.79 and the price at about 80% of it, right on our cushion's line. We then weighed the whole thesis: the price assumes profits shrink a little, and even our gloomy case is only a little lower.

    What it did to the thesisA cushion that close, with the downside already visible, is enough, so PayPal ends the day Attractive. Conviction stays Medium. It goes back to Neutral if the price reaches our value or margin dollars start to shrink.

    1 claim changed
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return PayPal is worth about $73.79 a share against $59.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $34.30B grow 4%, 4% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.0% to 16.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $13.47B of debt net of $10.28B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.92, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.3% margin) about $99.49.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return PayPal is worth about $82.92 a share against $59.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • PTRNPattern GroupThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Pattern shares rose past our price line

    Pattern closed at $19.43 on 9 November, up from $18.27 on 6 November, with no news about the business. Against the $23.07 a share we think the company is worth, the price is now about 84%, no longer far enough below it to call cheap.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Attractive to Neutral because the price no longer clears the margin we require. The business case and the open question, whether Thorne stays under P&G, did not change. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Pattern is worth about $21.21 a share against $19.43 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.26B grow 28%, 24% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.3% to 4.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $352M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.57, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.1% margin) about $29.22.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Pattern is worth about $23.07 a share against $18.27 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Pattern is worth about $21.21 a share against $19.43 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.26B grow 28%, 24% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.3% to 4.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $352M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.57, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.1% margin) about $29.22.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Pattern is worth about $23.07 a share against $19.43 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • PLTRPalantir TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Palantir re-valued with tax at the full rate

    Palantir pays little tax today only because of past losses, so we now assume the full rate once they are used up. On that basis the shares are worth about $127, down from $137.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 126% of that value, so we moved Palantir from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palantir is worth about $109 a share against $160 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.29B grow 60%, 48% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 45.6% to 36.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.5% of sales and a further 7.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $10.56B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 29.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.12, bull (a quarter more growth, a 40.2% margin) about $205.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palantir is worth about $137 a share against $160 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palantir is worth about $109 a share against $160 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.29B grow 60%, 48% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 45.6% to 36.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.5% of sales and a further 7.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $10.56B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 29.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.12, bull (a quarter more growth, a 40.2% margin) about $205.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palantir is worth about $127 a share against $160 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • PENGPenguin SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Penguin back to Neutral: its value rests on shortage memory prices

    We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis, not only the price against our value. Penguin's price is about 62% of our value of about $67.91 a share, but most of the profit behind that value is memory sold at shortage prices, treated as the normal year.

    What it did to the thesisOn a normal memory price the value falls toward the price, so we moved Penguin from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium. The cluster business earning on its new buyers would move it back.

    1 claim changed
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Penguin Solutions is worth about $67.91 a share against $41.83 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.73B grow 42%, 12% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.6% to 11.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $789M of debt net of $647M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.85, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.6% margin) about $118.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Penguin Solutions is worth about $80.27 a share against $41.83 at the 6 November close. Base cas…

  • OSCROscar HealthThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Oscar re-valued with full tax, then its shares rose past our line

    Oscar Health pays little tax today only because of past losses, so we now assume the full rate. On that basis the shares are worth about $39.40, down from $44.85. They closed at $32.14 on 9 November, up from $30.65 on 6 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 82% of that value, no longer cheap enough, so our view moves from Attractive to Neutral. The business case did not change. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $39.06 a share against $32.14 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $17.47B grow 16%, 16% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 3.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $432M of debt net of $7.49B of cash. Bear (the same growth, since at this margin slower growth would be worth more, a 2.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.35, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.8% margin) about $57.93.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%; the bear case keeps the analysts' growth, since at its margin slower growth would be worth more
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $44.85 a share against $30.65 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $39.06 a share against $32.14 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $17.47B grow 16%, 16% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 3.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $432M of debt net of $7.49B of cash. Bear (the same growth, since at this margin slower growth would be worth more, a 2.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.35, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.8% margin) about $57.93.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%; the bear case keeps the analysts' growth, since at its margin slower growth would be worth more
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $39.40 a share against $30.65 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $39.06 a share against $32.14 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $17.47B grow 16%, 16% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 3.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $432M of debt net of $7.49B of cash. Bear (the same growth, since at this margin slower growth would be worth more, a 2.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.35, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.8% margin) about $57.93.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%; the bear case keeps the analysts' growth, since at its margin slower growth would be worth more
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $39.40 a share against $32.14 at the 9 November close. Base case: tr…

  • ORCLOracleThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Oracle back to Neutral: the discount pays for one buyer's risk

    We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis, not only the price against our value. Oracle's price is about 66% of our value of about $177 a share, but that value arrives only if OpenAI pays for what it signed, while Oracle borrows and issues shares to build for it.

    What it did to the thesisA discount is owed for a risk that large and that hard to see, so we moved Oracle from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Low. Cash turning positive, or OpenAI showing its funding, would move it back.

    2 claims changed
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oracle is worth about $177 a share against $116 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $71.78B grow 38%, 43% and 34% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.1% to 23.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.7% of sales and a further 2.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 119 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $125.34B of debt and $4.95B of preferred stock net of $37.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.8% margin) about $321.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oracle is worth about $243 a share against $116 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oracle is worth about $177 a share against $116 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $71.78B grow 38%, 43% and 34% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.1% to 23.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.7% of sales and a further 2.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 119 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $125.34B of debt and $4.95B of preferred stock net of $37.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.8% margin) about $321.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oracle is worth about $220 a share against $116 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

  • NVONovo Nordisk A/SUnchanged

    FDA tells all GLP-1 weight-loss drugmakers to warn of a rare eye risk

    The US drug regulator ordered every medicine of the GLP-1 type, including Novo's Ozempic and Wegovy and Lilly's Zepbound, to add a warning about NAION, a rare condition that damages the optic nerve and can cause sudden vision loss. Across 126 trials it found 6.4 cases per 100,000 patient-years on these drugs against 3.8 otherwise.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The warning covers the whole class and the risk is rare, so it hits Novo and Lilly alike and no prescribing limit was set. Our case rests on US volume offsetting price cuts and on the CagriSema decision; neither changed. The view stays Attractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C63EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Novo Nordisk is worth about $61.61 a share against $40.31 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $49.65B grow -6%, 5% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 46.2% to 38.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 2.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $20.04B of debt net of $7.33B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 31.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.80, bull (a quarter more growth, a 42.7% margin) about $78.91.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Novo Nordisk is worth about $63.81 a share against $40.31 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    Nvidia's independent directors hire a top law firm to investigate the CEO matter

    Nvidia's independent directors hired former federal prosecutor Joon Kim and his firm Wachtell Lipton to run the investigation they announced on Sunday. Earlier, President Trump said the FBI is looking into the matter, and House committee chairs asked the CEO for a briefing. A news report, not confirmed, says the woman's companies moved at least $7.5B of Nvidia chips into China.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the numbers moved. An outside investigation is the right step and its findings are what could change our view of who runs the company. No finding, charge or business figure has changed, so we keep Attractive and Medium confidence and test the business on 17 November.

    1 claim changed
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $306 a share against $156.14 at the 16 November close. Base case: FY2026 sales of $215.9B grow 96%, 60% and 15% over three years, the first year being nine filed months and the Q4 guide, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 66.1% to 58% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 26 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 16% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (94% then 20% then a 15% fall, a 45% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (70% and 30%, a 62% margin) about $521. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $205.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $310 a share against $186.64 at the 6 November close. Base case: FY2026 sa…

  • NFLXNetflixThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Netflix re-valued with a steadier return on new money

    We now assume that money reinvested late in the ten years earns what the business can earn for ever, not more. On that basis the shares are worth about $78.06, down from $81.42.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 81% of that value, so we moved Netflix from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    1 claim changed
    • C66EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Netflix is worth about $78.06 a share against $60.75 at the 16 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $49.73B grow 11%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C65), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 31.3% to 33.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 16.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.13B of debt net of $8.22B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $42.64, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.9% margin) about $101.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Netflix is worth about $81.42 a share against $63.41 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • MRVLMarvell TechnologyThesis changed

    Marvell Technology re-valued on the margin it has already earned

    Marvell Technology's business goes through cycles, so we no longer assume a margin higher than it has already earned. On that basis the shares are worth about $325, down from $401.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 43% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C40EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Marvell Technology is worth about $277 a share against $141 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.45B grow 60%, 60% and 58% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.5% to 27.6% over five years, what its fiscal year to January 2026 earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 33.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $4.96B of debt net of $3.93B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.4% margin) about $542.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Marvell Technology is worth about $401 a share against $141 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

    • C40EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Marvell Technology is worth about $277 a share against $141 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.45B grow 60%, 60% and 58% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.5% to 27.6% over five years, what its fiscal year to January 2026 earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 33.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $4.96B of debt net of $3.93B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.4% margin) about $542.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Marvell Technology is worth about $325 a share against $141 at the 6 November close. Base case:…

  • MITKMitek SystemsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Mitek re-valued on the margin it earns today

    Checking our value against Mitek's filings, we found one cost line excused twice, which lifted the margin we assumed. On the margin it earns today, the shares are worth about $18.05, down from $21.86.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 96% of that value, so we moved Mitek from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C42EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Mitek is worth about $17.39 a share against $17.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $198M grow 6% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.8% to 24.4% over five years, what the last four quarters earned after stock pay and before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 30.1%, whose gap to the filed figure had been set aside twice; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $49M of debt net of $100M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.43, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.8% margin) about $21.78.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Mitek is worth about $21.86 a share against $17.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C42EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Mitek is worth about $17.39 a share against $17.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $198M grow 6% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.8% to 24.4% over five years, what the last four quarters earned after stock pay and before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 30.1%, whose gap to the filed figure had been set aside twice; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $49M of debt net of $100M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.43, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.8% margin) about $21.78.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Mitek is worth about $18.05 a share against $17.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • MELIMercadoLibreThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    MercadoLibre back to Neutral: the margin recovery is unproven

    We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis, not only the price against our value. MercadoLibre's price is about 77% of our value of about $1,966 a share, but that value assumes the profit margin recovers, and the last two reports showed it falling while lending grows fast.

    What it did to the thesisA thin discount to a value that depends on an unproven recovery is not enough, so we moved MercadoLibre from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium. A margin that turns up with credit steady would move it back.

    1 claim changed
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MercadoLibre is worth about $1,966 a share against $1,510 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $38.52B grow 32%, 25% and 26% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $13.19B of debt net of $7.38B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $705, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.6% margin) about $3,104.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MercadoLibre is worth about $2,075 a share against $1,510 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

  • MCHPMicrochip Technology IncorporatedThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Microchip's shares rebounded past what we think the business is worth

    Microchip's shares closed at $61.50 on 9 November, up from $58.35 three days earlier. No new results or filings came out. We kept our estimate of what the business is worth, about $49 a share, and checked the debt claim that had expired: on the 5 November call the company put its debt at 2.36 times yearly cash profit.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 126% of what we think the business is worth, which is more than 20% above it, so we moved Microchip from Neutral to Unattractive. The debt is falling as management promised. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C20EditedManagement put net debt to adjusted EBITDA at 2.85 in June and expected it below 2.5 in September; the Q2 call stated 2.36 at September 30, on net debt of about $5.09B, and expects it to keep falling through fiscal 2027. The chief financial officer said the board wants leverage down first: the dividend stays where it is 'for now', and returns of cash will be evaluated as the company moves into next fiscal year.expired 5 November; the September ratio of 2.36 is on the Q2 call (S36), which the 6 November review recorded as not stated; the no-buyback promise now reads 'evaluate next fiscal year'; shelf life rolled to the next print
      Was

      Management put net debt at about $5.2B and net debt to adjusted EBITDA at 2.85 in June and expected it below 2.5 in September; net debt at September…

    • C28EditedAt $64.85 on November 5, 2026 company value was about $40.3B (543M shares and $5.09B of net debt), 7.2 times trailing sales of $5.60B against a six-year median of 7.2 times. At $75.34 on November 4 it was 8.2 times, and at $81.32 on October 2 it was 9.6 times. At $58.35 on November 6 it was about $36.8B, 6.6 times, and at $61.50 on November 9 about $38.5B, 6.9 times. Across its six fiscal years to March 2026 Microchip's GAAP operating margin averaged 22.2%, so the usual 7.2 times sales is about 32 times a normal year's operating profit after stock pay.9 November close added after a 5.4% rebound
      Was

      At $64.85 on November 5, 2026 company value was about $40.3B (543M shares and $5.09B of net debt), 7.2 times trailing sales of $5.60B against a six-y…

    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $47 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value is about 7.0 times trailing sales. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $4.71B grow 36%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 20.9% to 28% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 45 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (30%, then flat and a 5% fall, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13, bull (36%, 17% and 10%, a 33% margin) about $68. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $30.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $51 a share against $58.35 at the 6 November close, where company value…

    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $47 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value is about 7.0 times trailing sales. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $4.71B grow 36%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 20.9% to 28% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 45 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (30%, then flat and a 5% fall, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13, bull (36%, 17% and 10%, a 33% margin) about $68. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $30.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $49 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value…

  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    Lilly's Foundayo pill cut sleep apnea breathing interruptions in a large trial

    Lilly said its weight-loss pill Foundayo met the main goal of a 52-week trial in adults with obesity and moderate-to-severe sleep apnea. Breathing interruptions fell by up to an average of 44%, and up to 32% of people reached remission or mild disease. Lilly plans to ask the FDA to approve it for sleep apnea by the end of 2026.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It widens what the pill could be used for, but our view rests on the share price against a value near $983 and on volume beating price cuts, and a filing not yet made changes neither. The view stays Unattractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C72EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Eli Lilly is worth about $943 a share against $1,354 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $65.18B grow 40%, 17% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C71), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 61.1% to 50.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 61 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $42.50B of debt net of $7.27B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 40.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $433, bull (a quarter more growth, a 55.5% margin) about $1,326.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Eli Lilly is worth about $983 a share against $1,354 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • LITELumentum HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Risk / rewardSpeculative→Fragile
    The betFair→Expensive
    Valuation4→3

    Lumentum's shares rose 11% in a day, to about five-sixths of our value

    Lumentum's shares closed at $596 on 9 November, up from $539 on 6 November. Our estimate of what the business is worth, about $710 a share, did not change, and no new report came with the move.

    What it did to the thesisAt $596 the price is about 84% of that value, no longer clearly cheap, so our view moves from Attractive to Neutral. Nothing about the business changed. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lumentum is worth about $626 a share against $596 at the 9 November close ($539 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.74B grow 60%, 54% and 41% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.5% to 30.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 110 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.76B of debt net of $1.98B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $159, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.4% margin) about $1,155.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lumentum is worth about $710 a share against $539 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lumentum is worth about $626 a share against $596 at the 9 November close ($539 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.74B grow 60%, 54% and 41% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.5% to 30.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 110 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.76B of debt net of $1.98B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $159, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.4% margin) about $1,155.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lumentum is worth about $710 a share against $596 at the 9 November close ($539 on 6 November).…

  • KLACKLAThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    KLA's shares jumped past what we think the business is worth

    KLA's shares closed at $151.38 on 9 November, up from $138.49 three days earlier. Nothing new was filed and no results came out. We kept our estimate of what the business is worth, about $126 a share, and compared the new price with it.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 121% of what we think the business is worth, which is more than 20% above it, so we moved KLA from Neutral to Unattractive. The business is as strong as before; only the price moved. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C62EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $120 a share against $143.96 at the 16 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $14.51B grow 36%, 19% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 42.6% to its five-year average of 39.5% over five years, because 42.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 57 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.72B of debt net of $1.53B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 31.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 43.5% margin) about $170.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $126 a share against $138 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

    • C62EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $120 a share against $143.96 at the 16 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $14.51B grow 36%, 19% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 42.6% to its five-year average of 39.5% over five years, because 42.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 57 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.72B of debt net of $1.53B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 31.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 43.5% margin) about $170.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $126 a share against $151 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

  • HLIOHelios TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Helios shares rose 4% to $49.48, back to our buying line

    Helios shares closed at $49.48 on 9 November, up from $47.44 on 6 November. Nothing new was filed or reported in between. We value the business at about $61.80 a share on the cash it should produce.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 80% of that value, no longer far enough below it for a cyclical business whose first data-centre order has no size. We moved Helios from Attractive to Neutral; conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Helios is worth about $61.80 a share against $48.00 at the 10 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 3%, 5% and 3% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.9% to 18.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 47 cents of capital; a 23.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $328M of debt net of $73M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.66, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.5% margin) about $76.63.Price re-read at the 9 November close of $49.48, about 80% of the unchanged base case: at the line route P1 drew.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Helios is worth about $63.46 a share against $47.44 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Helios is worth about $61.80 a share against $48.00 at the 10 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 3%, 5% and 3% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.9% to 18.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 47 cents of capital; a 23.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $328M of debt net of $73M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.66, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.5% margin) about $76.63.Price re-read at the 9 November close of $49.48, about 80% of the unchanged base case: at the line route P1 drew.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Helios is worth about $61.80 a share against $47.44 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • HASHasbroThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Hasbro re-valued with a fuller tax rate and a steadier return on new money

    We now assume that money reinvested late in the ten years earns what the business can earn for ever, not more, and that it pays the 25% tax a US company pays once state tax is counted. On that basis the shares are worth about $93.53, down from $104.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 127% of that value, so we moved Hasbro from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    1 claim changed
    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hasbro is worth about $93.53 a share against $119 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.18B grow 6%, 4% and 0% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.8% to 24.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.51B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.7% margin) about $116.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hasbro is worth about $104 a share against $119 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sal…

  • GDDYGoDaddyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    GoDaddy re-valued, then its shares slipped below our buying line

    We now assume money reinvested late in the ten years earns what the business can earn for ever, which puts the shares at about $141, down from $146. At $114 that read as only fair. The shares then closed at $111.71, about 79% of that value.

    What it did to the thesisThe price now clears the 20% cushion we ask for, and nothing about the business got worse, so GoDaddy is back to Attractive with medium conviction. It returns to Neutral near $113.

    2 claims changed
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.Price re-read at the 9 November close of $111.71, about 79% of the unchanged base case: past the 80% line route P1 drew.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $146 a share against $114.38 at the 6 November close. Base case: 2025 sal…

    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.Price re-read at the 9 November close of $111.71, about 79% of the unchanged base case: past the 80% line route P1 drew.
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $114.38 at the 6 November close. Base case: 2025 sal…

  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsRefreshed

    Forgent shares rose 16% in one session to $22.60

    Forgent Power Solutions shares closed at $22.60 on 9 November, up from $19.48 on 6 November. We found no company news in that window. We value the business at about $28.58 a share on its own future cash.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is 79% of that value, still just under our 80% line at $22.86, so the view stays Attractive and conviction stays Medium. A close above $22.86 would move it to Neutral.

    3 claims changed
    • C20EditedAt $20.57 the company value is about $6.66B, about 10.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 15.0 times the $1.37 adjusted EPS midpoint. Counting the $483.0M tax receivable liability as debt adds about three-quarters of a turn. Taking off stock pay at the September quarter's $13.9M a quarter, about $55.5M a year, it is about 12.0 times.re-struck at the 9 November close of $22.60, 16% above the 6 November close
      Was

      At $19.48 the company value is about $6.43B, about 10.7 times the $600M midpoint of FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 14.6 times the…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $28.58 a share against $19.48 at the 6 November close. Base case: FY26 sa…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $28.58 a share against $22.60 at the 9 November close. Base case: FY26 sa…

  • FNFabrinetThesis changed
    Valuation4→3

    Fabrinet shares jumped 12% in a day with other optical stocks

    Fabrinet shares closed at $365.94 on 9 November, up 12% in a day as optical stocks rose together, with no company news. That was about 81% of the $454 a share we think it is worth. On 10 November they fell back to $348.52, about 77%.

    What it did to the thesisThe price briefly lost a sliver of our usual safety cushion. The business is strong, with sticky customers, fast growth and no net debt, so we keep it Attractive and will move it to Neutral near $386. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fabrinet is worth about $454 a share against $366 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.14B grow 34%, 20% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.0% to 10.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 1.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 17.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $75M of debt net of $756M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $202, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.2% margin) about $674.price re-struck at the 9 November close, when route P1 fired: the shares are about 81% of the base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fabrinet is worth about $471 a share against $327 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fabrinet is worth about $454 a share against $366 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.14B grow 34%, 20% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.0% to 10.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 1.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 17.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $75M of debt net of $756M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $202, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.2% margin) about $674.price re-struck at the 9 November close, when route P1 fired: the shares are about 81% of the base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fabrinet is worth about $454 a share against $327 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • FLOCFlowco HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Flowco's shares rose enough to leave our Attractive range

    Flowco's shares closed at $20.85 on 9 November, up from $20.06 three days earlier. Nothing new was filed and no results came out. We left our estimate of what the business is worth, about $25.82 a share, unchanged and re-read the new price against it.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 81% of what we think the business is worth, just short of the 20% margin of safety we ask for, so we moved Flowco from Attractive to Neutral. The business case did not move. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.72 a share against $20.67 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 16%, 7% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.6% to 19.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 128 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $363M of debt net of $138M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.00, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.3% margin) about $32.61.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.82 a share against $20.06 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.72 a share against $20.67 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 16%, 7% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.6% to 19.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 128 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $363M of debt net of $138M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.00, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.3% margin) about $32.61.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.82 a share against $20.85 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • FIVNFive9Thesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Five9 re-valued with full tax and its debt counted

    Five9 pays little tax today only because of past losses, so we now assume the full rate once they are used up. We also found our value had left out the $738 million of convertible bonds it owes. Counting both, the shares are worth about $22.22, down from $35.92.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 127% of that value, so we moved Five9 from Attractive to Unattractive over the day. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $22.22 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.24B grow 9%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.8% of sales and a further 8.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $738M of debt net of $698M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $11.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $28.90.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $35.92 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $22.22 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.24B grow 9%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.8% of sales and a further 8.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $738M of debt net of $698M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $11.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $28.90.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $33.89 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $22.22 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.24B grow 9%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.8% of sales and a further 8.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $738M of debt net of $698M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $11.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $28.90.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $31.77 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • FIGRFigure Technology SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Figure shares rose past our price line ahead of its results

    Figure Technology closed at $24.52 on 9 November, up from $22.73 on 6 November, with no news about the business. Against the $19.96 a share we think the company is worth, the price is now about 123%, more than 20% above it. Its results are due 12 November.

    What it did to the thesisOur view moves from Neutral to Unattractive because the price now runs more than 20% above our value. The business case did not change, and the September results will test it. Conviction stays Medium.

    1 claim changed
    • C55EditedOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Figure Technology Solutions is worth about $18.40 a share against $24.19 at the 11 November close (about 131% of it). Base case: shareholders' equity of $1.52B at 30 September 2026 earns 14.7%, the first nine months' pretax profit of $223.3M annualised and taxed at 25%, and grows only by what it earns, 14.7% a year, since Figure pays no dividend, then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. The 225.1M shares are all three classes, which share earnings equally. Bear (half that growth, a 10% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $8.48, bull (18% growth and return, new equity earning 15%) about $27.67.re-struck at the 9 November close of $24.52, which put the price at 123% of the base case; the value itself did not move
      Was

      On an excess-return value at an 8% required return Figure Technology Solutions is worth about $19.96 a share against $22.73 at the 6 November close.…

  • EXEExpand EnergyThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Expand Energy re-valued on a normal year's margin, not today's commodity price

    Expand Energy sells at a commodity price it does not set. We now value it on a normal year's margin, not the analysts' margin at today's price, and count the capital its own filings show it needs. On that basis the shares are worth about $103, down from $129.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 82% of that value, so we moved Expand Energy from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Expand Energy is worth about $103 a share against $84.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.91B grow -7%, 3% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.7% to 20.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 196 cents of capital; a 20.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $4.63B of debt net of $118M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $74.48, bull (a quarter more growth, a 22.2% margin) about $149.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Expand Energy is worth about $129 a share against $84.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: tra…

    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Expand Energy is worth about $103 a share against $84.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.91B grow -7%, 3% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.7% to 20.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 196 cents of capital; a 20.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $4.63B of debt net of $118M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $74.48, bull (a quarter more growth, a 22.2% margin) about $149.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Expand Energy is worth about $103 a share against $84.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: tra…

  • EQTEQTThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Unattractive
    Valuation4→2

    EQT re-valued on a normal gas year, and judged Neutral overall

    Earlier today we re-valued EQT on a normal year for gas, which put the price about 20% above our value of about $41.01 a share, right on the line we called Unattractive. We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis: EQT owns its pipelines, is cutting debt fast and keeps beating its guidance.

    What it did to the thesisA well-run business a little above a cautious value is Neutral, not Unattractive, so EQT ends the day at Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C37EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EQT is worth about $41.01 a share against $49.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.35B grow 10%, 20% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C36), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 41.8% to 33.5% over five years, the median of its last five filed years, below the analysts' 47.0%, because a producer's margin rides a commodity price it does not set; each added dollar of sales needs 385 cents of capital; a 21.7% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $5.55B of debt net of $79M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.45, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.8% margin) about $72.00.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EQT is worth about $138 a share against $49.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sale…

    • C37EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EQT is worth about $41.01 a share against $49.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.35B grow 10%, 20% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C36), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 41.8% to 33.5% over five years, the median of its last five filed years, below the analysts' 47.0%, because a producer's margin rides a commodity price it does not set; each added dollar of sales needs 385 cents of capital; a 21.7% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $5.55B of debt net of $79M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.45, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.8% margin) about $72.00.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EQT is worth about $40.05 a share against $49.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sa…

  • ENTGEntegrisThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Entegris set a 15% growth target and its shares jumped 9%

    On 9 November Entegris told investors it aims for about 15% yearly sales growth, a 35% adjusted operating margin and about 30% yearly profit-per-share growth, and authorised a $500 million share buyback. The shares closed at $140.06, up 9.4% in a day.

    What it did to the thesisWe still think the business is worth about $109 a share, so the price is now 29% above that. We moved Entegris from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    5 claims changed
    • C61NewAt its 9 November 2026 Capital Markets Day Entegris set a long-term model of revenue growth of about 15% a year, adjusted gross margin of about 55%, adjusted operating margin of about 35% and adjusted earnings per share growth of about 30% a year, with about 50% of excess cash returned to shareholders; the board authorised a $500 million share repurchase and the company expects to raise the quarterly dividend by 10% from the first quarter of 2027.read from the 8-K furnished for the 9 November Capital Markets Day
    • C46EditedEntegris held its investor day on 9 November 2026 and updated its target model (C61).now a held event, sourced to the 8-K furnished for it (S27); the targets themselves are C61
      Was

      Entegris will hold an investor day on 9 November 2026, at which management says it will update its target model.

    • C46EditedEntegris held its investor day on 9 November 2026 and updated its target model (C61).now a held event, sourced to the 8-K furnished for it (S27); the targets themselves are C61
      Was

      Entegris will hold an investor day on 9 November 2026, at which management says it will update its target model.

    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Entegris is worth about $105 a share against $140.06 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.52B grow 19%, 12% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to 27.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 76 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.26B of debt net of $356M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $46.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.9% margin) about $145.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Entegris is worth about $109 a share against $128 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Entegris is worth about $105 a share against $140.06 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.52B grow 19%, 12% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to 27.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 76 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.26B of debt net of $356M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $46.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.9% margin) about $145.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Entegris is worth about $109 a share against $140.06 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailin…

  • EMEEMCOR GroupThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    EMCOR moved to Attractive on the whole picture

    We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis, not only the price against our value. EMCOR's price is about 82% of our value of about $739 a share, a little short of our usual 20% cushion. Behind it are a record backlog of signed work, no debt and cash matching profit.

    What it did to the thesisThat is enough at a slightly thinner cushion, so we moved EMCOR from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium. It goes back to Neutral if the price reaches our value or the backlog shrinks.

    1 claim changed
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $739 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $19.84bn grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 10.4% to a normal 9.0% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 1 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (6% growth, the 2021-2025 average margin of 7.35%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $446, bull (18%, 10.0%) about $1,013. At the base case's 9.0% margin a normal year's operating profit is about $1.79bn, and company value of about $26.1bn is about 14.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $548.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; growth the customers fund needs only the plant
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $728 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $…

  • ECGEverus Construction GroupRefreshed

    Everus shares rose to just under our line for Neutral

    Everus closed at $84.43 on 9 November, up from $76.60 on 6 November, with no news about the business. The price line we set for a move to Neutral is $84.78, 80% of the $106 a share we think it is worth. The printed multiple had rounded that line down.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 80% of our value, a hair under the line, so the view stays Attractive. We corrected the line to its exact figure. A move up of a few cents more would change the view. Conviction stays Medium.

    1 claim changed
    • C33EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $106 a share against $76.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • DLODlocal LimitedThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    dLocal back to Neutral: growth is not yet reaching profit

    We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis, not only the price against our value. dLocal's price is about 69% of our value of about $20.34 a share, but that value assumes volume growth reaches profit, and the latest report showed the price per dollar still falling.

    What it did to the thesisUntil that fall slows, the discount is fair rather than cheap, so we moved dLocal from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium. The price per dollar holding while profit reaches the guide would move it back.

    1 claim changed
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return DLO is worth about $19.29 a share against $13.96 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.47B grow 32%, 24% and 18% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.4% to 16.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay and the 2.8-point gap between their operating profit and the filed one; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; an 18.3% tax rate, the company's estimate for 2026; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; plus $536.9M of the company's own cash less $163.5M of borrowings, on 294.6M diluted shares. Bear (half that growth, a 13.2% margin) gives about $11.55, bull (a quarter more growth, an 18.1% margin, new capital earning 11%) about $31.04.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return DLO is worth about $22.01 a share against $13.95 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sa…

  • CSCOCisco SystemsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Cisco shares rose 5% in a day to $98.65

    Cisco shares closed at $98.65 on 9 November, up from $93.85 on 6 November. The only company news was a new set of AI security products, which does not change the business case. We value Cisco at about $79 a share, so the price is now about a quarter above that.

    What it did to the thesisAt that price buyers are paying close to our best case, for growth that is partly a refresh cycle and price rises. We moved Cisco from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium. The 12 November results could lift our value.

    2 claims changed
    • C38EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $81.85 a share against $94.52 at the 16 November close ($100.76 on 11 November). Base case: trailing sales of $63.33B grow 19% in FY27, the midpoint of the raised guide (C06), then 7% and 7%, the analysts' rates (C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 24.3% to 27.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales and a further 2.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 17.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $29.53B of debt net of $14.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.21, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.3% margin) about $106.27.price re-struck at the 9 November close, when route P2 fired: the shares are about 125% of the base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $82.26 a share against $93.85 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

    • C38EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $81.85 a share against $94.52 at the 16 November close ($100.76 on 11 November). Base case: trailing sales of $63.33B grow 19% in FY27, the midpoint of the raised guide (C06), then 7% and 7%, the analysts' rates (C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 24.3% to 27.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales and a further 2.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 17.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $29.53B of debt net of $14.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.21, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.3% margin) about $106.27.price re-struck at the 9 November close, when route P2 fired: the shares are about 125% of the base-case value
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $79.08 a share against $93.85 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing…

  • CRWVCoreWeaveUnchanged

    CoreWeave signed a multi-year deal to train Wayve's self-driving AI

    CoreWeave said Wayve, which builds AI drivers for cars, will train its models on CoreWeave's cloud using NVIDIA's newest chips. The announcement gives no dollar value, length, or amount of computing power. Wayve was already a CoreWeave software customer.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A new named customer fits the case for a wider customer base, but without a value it adds nothing to the backlog we track. Our test is the earnings report due 10 November.

    11 claims changed
    • C08EditedRevenue backlog, which the company counts as remaining performance obligations plus other committed amounts, was about $132.5B at September 30, 2026, against about $104B at June 30.Q3 2026 earnings review: the Q3 release gives the backlog at September 30
      Was

      Management says more than $25B of net new commitments were signed early in Q3 2026, on top of a backlog of about $104B at Q2.

    • C18EditedQ3 2026 revenue was $3,661M against a guide of $3.45B to $3.6B, adjusted operating income $379M against $200M to $260M, and net interest $846M against $860M to $940M; the GAAP net loss was $709M.Q3 2026 earnings review: the Q3 guide is now a reported quarter, read from the results release
      Was

      For Q3 2026 management guided revenue of $3.45B to $3.6B, adjusted operating income of $200M to $260M, interest expense of $860M to $940M and capex o…

    • C19EditedManagement raised 2026 guidance in November to revenue of $13.0B to $13.3B, adjusted operating income of $1.275B to $1.375B, capex of $37B to $39B and a year-end run-rate of $20B to $21B, from $12.4B to $13.2B, $960M to $1.15B, $35B to $39B and $18.5B to $19.5B in August.Q3 2026 earnings review: management raised the 2026 guide again in the Q3 release
      Was

      Management raised 2026 guidance in August to revenue of $12.4B to $13.2B, adjusted operating income of $960M to $1.15B, capex of $35B to $39B and a y…

    • C22EditedIn the first nine months of 2026 operations brought in $5,638M of cash while capital spending took $23,558M; at September 30 cash was $4,122M with $2,282M more restricted, and management expects about $9B of customer prepayments and deposits in the three months after.Q3 2026 earnings review: rolled to the nine months to September 30 from the Q3 release; the liquidity figure waits for the 10-Q
      Was

      In the first half of 2026 operations brought in $3,663M of cash while capital spending took $14,117M; liquidity at June 30 was $15,553M, of which $10…

    • C26EditedThe shares closed at $48.98 on November 9, 2026, 8.6% up a $40.58 to $138.25 52-week range; over 126 sessions the price fell 57.3% while sales per share rose 16.6%, so the multiple fell 63.4%.Q3 2026 earnings review: re-struck at the 9 November close from the refreshed pack
      Was

      The shares closed at $61.39 on October 16, 2026, near the bottom of a $59.51 to $150.40 52-week range; over 126 sessions the price fell 47.5% while s…

    • C27EditedAt the November 9, 2026 close market value was about $26.9B and company value about $72.0B, 7.3 times trailing sales of $9.89B over the four reported quarters to September.Q3 2026 earnings review: re-struck at the 9 November close on the four reported quarters and the September 30 balance sheet
      Was

      Market value was about $33.9B and the vendor's company value about $79.1B, 10.4 times trailing sales of $7.59B.

    • C28EditedAnalysts' average forecasts put sales at $12.82B for 2026, below the November guide they predate, $26.47B for 2027 and $42.94B for 2028; their profit per share turns positive in 2028 at $0.69 and reaches $6.36 in 2029 on nine forecasts.Q3 2026 earnings review: refreshed from the pack of 10 November; the 2026 average was set before the raised guide
      Was

      Analysts' average forecasts put sales at $12.88B for 2026, $26.56B for 2027 and $42.65B for 2028; their profit per share turns positive in 2028 at $0…

    • C41EditedAt about $72.0B, company value is about 3.5 times the midpoint of the year-end 2026 run-rate guide and about 2.7 times analysts' 2027 revenue; the share price is about 7.7 times the 2029 earnings nine analysts expect.Q3 2026 earnings review: re-struck at the 9 November close against the raised run-rate guide and refreshed estimates
      Was

      At about $79.1B, company value is about 4.2 times the midpoint of the year-end 2026 run-rate guide and about 3.0 times analysts' 2027 revenue; the sh…

    • C43EditedQ4 2026 interest is guided at $1.05B to $1.15B, above the $747M to $847M of adjusted operating income the full-year guide leaves for Q4 after the first nine months' $528M, so the business keeps losing money after interest through 2026 even if the guide is met.Q3 2026 earnings review: rolled from the Q3 guide to the Q4 interest guide against the adjusted operating income the raised full-year guide implies
      Was

      Interest guided at $860M to $940M for Q3 exceeds the $200M to $260M adjusted operating income guided, so the business keeps losing money after intere…

    • C50EditedManagement reported over 1.7 GW of active power and over 4.6 GW contracted at Q3, up from about 1.5 GW and 3.7 GW at Q2, with more than 1.3 GW of the contracted power outside the US, and still targets more than 1.85 GW active at year-end and at least 8 GW by 2030.Q3 2026 earnings review: the Q3 release restates active and contracted power
      Was

      Management reported about 1.5 GW of active power and about 3.7 GW contracted at Q2, 4.2 GW contracted by the call, and targets more than 1.85 GW acti…

    • C57EditedAt September 30, 2026 the balance sheet carried $46,873M of debt, $41,600M recourse and $5,273M non-recourse, with $10,572M due within a year, against $4,122M of cash.Q3 2026 earnings review: replaced the estimate with the debt the September 30 balance sheet carries
      Was

      Counting the September convertible and the post-June draws, borrowings are about $41.7B of principal before leases, against $5.5B of cash at June 30.

  • COHRCoherentThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Coherent's shares rose 17% in a day, to about four-fifths of our value

    Coherent's business goes through cycles, so we no longer assume a margin higher than it has already earned, and we assume the full tax rate once past losses are used up. On that basis the shares are worth about $281, down from $378. They then jumped 17% to $225 on 9 November.

    What it did to the thesisAt $225 the price is about 80% of that value, no longer clearly cheap, so our view moves from Attractive to Neutral. Nothing about the business changed. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C70EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $224 a share against $225 at the 9 November close ($193 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $7.91B grow 49%, 38% and 39% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C69), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.4% to 18.9% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (15.9% after amortisation of past deals, 3.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 21.8%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 71 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $4.00B of debt net of $1.75B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $86.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.8% margin) about $483.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $378 a share against $193 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C70EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $224 a share against $225 at the 9 November close ($193 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $7.91B grow 49%, 38% and 39% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C69), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.4% to 18.9% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (15.9% after amortisation of past deals, 3.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 21.8%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 71 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $4.00B of debt net of $1.75B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $86.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.8% margin) about $483.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $281 a share against $193 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C70EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $224 a share against $225 at the 9 November close ($193 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $7.91B grow 49%, 38% and 39% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C69), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.4% to 18.9% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (15.9% after amortisation of past deals, 3.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 21.8%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 71 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $4.00B of debt net of $1.75B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $86.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.8% margin) about $483.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $281 a share against $225 at the 9 November close ($193 on 6 November).…

  • CIENCienaThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Ciena re-valued on the margin it earned, then its shares rose past our line

    Ciena's business goes through cycles, so we no longer assume a margin higher than it has already earned. On that basis the shares are worth about $313, down from $432. The shares closed at $269.33 on 9 November, up from $243 on 6 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 86% of that value, no longer cheap enough, so our view moves from Attractive to Neutral. The business itself did not change. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $295 a share against $269.33 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $6.02B grow 31%, 30% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.3% to 18.2% over five years, what its August 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 24.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.23B of debt net of $2.63B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.0% margin) about $464.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $432 a share against $243 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sale…

    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $295 a share against $269.33 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $6.02B grow 31%, 30% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.3% to 18.2% over five years, what its August 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 24.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.23B of debt net of $2.63B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.0% margin) about $464.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $313 a share against $243 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sale…

    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $295 a share against $269.33 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $6.02B grow 31%, 30% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.3% to 18.2% over five years, what its August 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 24.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.23B of debt net of $2.63B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.0% margin) about $464.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $313 a share against $269.33 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • CCSIConsensus Cloud SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Consensus back to Neutral: its value needs growth fax may not have

    We now decide each view by weighing the whole thesis, not only the price against our value. Consensus's price is about 54% of our value of about $79.57 a share, but that value assumes growth returns, while corporate customers leave faster than ever.

    What it did to the thesisValued with sales flat, the business is worth only a little more than the price, so we moved Consensus from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium. Corporate customers staying and paying more would move it back.

    1 claim changed
    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Consensus is worth about $79.57 a share against $43.15 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $358M grow 4% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 40.8% to 44.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 5.9% of sales and a further 3.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 29 cents of capital; a 23.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $550M of debt net of $107M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 35.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $54.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 48.5% margin) about $115.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Consensus is worth about $86.53 a share against $43.15 at the 6 November close. Base case: trail…

  • CBRSCerebras SystemsUnchanged

    Bilt will use Cerebras chips for its new AI assistant, terms undisclosed

    Cerebras said Bilt, a rewards app with more than 8 million members and 50,000 merchants, chose it to run Bilt's new AI assistant, which books tables, redeems rewards and plans trips. The announcement gave no price, size, length of contract or start date, and said more details will come as the work progresses.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is a named new customer, which our case wants, but with no money attached it is far from the committed second buyer the thesis is waiting for. OpenAI remains nearly all of the contracted business, and the view stays Unattractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cerebras is worth about $32.83 a share against $101.08 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $756M grow 60% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -99.3% to 10.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.45B of debt and leases net of $7.80B of cash. Bear (half that growth, an 8.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.14; bull (the backlog on its filed schedule, revenue tripling then growing 150%, an 11.0% margin) about $143.65.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cerebras is worth about $40.51 a share against $89.68 at the 6 November close. Base case: traili…

  • BEBloom EnergyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Bloom Energy re-valued on the margin it has already earned

    Bloom Energy's business goes through cycles, so we no longer assume a margin higher than it has already earned. Bloom Energy pays little tax today only because of past losses, so we now assume the full rate once they are used up. On that basis the shares are worth about $90.79, down from $148.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 191% of that value, so we moved Bloom Energy from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Bloom Energy is worth about $74.86 a share against $173 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 60%, 50% and 30% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.8% to 18.3% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 25.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 52 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $2.48B of debt net of $2.49B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.1% margin) about $148.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Bloom Energy is worth about $148 a share against $173 at the 6 November close. Base case: traili…

    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Bloom Energy is worth about $74.86 a share against $173 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 60%, 50% and 30% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.8% to 18.3% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 25.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 52 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $2.48B of debt net of $2.49B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.1% margin) about $148.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten; a US company's normal tax is the federal 21% plus state, 25%
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Bloom Energy is worth about $90.79 a share against $173 at the 6 November close. Base case: trai…

  • APPAppLovinThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    AppLovin's shares rose enough to leave our Attractive range

    AppLovin's shares closed at $410.00 on 9 November, up from $391.22 three days earlier. No results or filings came out. Seven law-firm notices only repeated the 16 November deadline in a lawsuit we already track. We left our estimate of what the business is worth, about $508 a share, unchanged.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 81% of what we think the business is worth, just short of the 20% margin of safety we ask for, so we moved AppLovin from Attractive to Neutral. The business case did not move. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C70EditedAt the 2026-11-09 close of $410.00, 331M shares are worth about $135.7B, which is 27.8 times trailing free cash flow of about $4.88B (the $3.95B of 2025 plus $3,568.5M for the nine months to September 2026 less $2,642.8M a year earlier).re-struck at the 9 November close, $410.00; trailing free cash flow and the share count did not move
      Was

      At the 2026-11-06 close of $391.22, 331M shares are worth about $129.5B, which is 26.5 times trailing free cash flow of about $4.88B (the $3.95B of 2…

    • C71EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $480 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.48B grow 49%, 25% and 20% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin holds near 75%; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% and 5% after 2026, a 65% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $219, bull (32% and 28%, an 80% margin) about $696.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $508 a share against $391.22 at the 6 November close. Base case: 2025 sa…

    • C71EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $480 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.48B grow 49%, 25% and 20% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin holds near 75%; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% and 5% after 2026, a 65% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $219, bull (32% and 28%, an 80% margin) about $696.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $508 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sa…

  • APLDApplied DigitalUnchanged

    Shareholders backed executive pay by a wider margin at the annual meeting

    At the 4 November annual meeting shareholders re-elected all six directors and approved executive pay in a non-binding vote, with about two votes in three in favour, up from barely half last year. The shares are about 14% lower than when we last checked the price.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A firmer pay vote eases one governance worry but says nothing about rent, funding or margins, which carry the case. The view stays Neutral, with medium confidence, until the January report shows whether rent is taking over from construction.

  • AMDAdvanced Micro DevicesThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    AMD re-valued on the margin it has already earned

    AMD's business goes through cycles, so we no longer assume a margin higher than it has already earned. On that basis the shares are worth about $494, down from $581.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 91% of that value, so we moved AMD from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $504.28 at the 16 November close, about 110% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $45.44B grow 60%, 50% and 35% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.7% to 25.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (21.2% after amortisation of past deals, 4.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 29.5%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.08B of debt net of $15.78B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $140, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.7% margin) about $788.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $581 a share against $449 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $504.28 at the 16 November close, about 110% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $45.44B grow 60%, 50% and 35% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.7% to 25.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (21.2% after amortisation of past deals, 4.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 29.5%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.08B of debt net of $15.78B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $140, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.7% margin) about $788.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $494 a share against $449 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales…

  • AMATApplied MaterialsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Applied Materials' shares rose enough to leave our Attractive range

    Applied Materials' shares closed at $370.55 on 9 November, up from $332.72 three days earlier, ahead of its 12 November results. We left our estimate of what the business is worth, about $423 a share, unchanged. We also refreshed four out-of-date facts, including Micron's new chip-factory spending estimate and the latest short-selling count.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is now about 88% of what we think the business is worth, short of the 20% margin of safety we ask for, so we moved Applied from Attractive to Neutral. The business case did not move. Conviction stays Medium.

    7 claims changed
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $422 a share against $395 at the 11 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $34.45B grow 36%, 22% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.2% to 35.3% over five years, what its October 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.53B of debt net of $9.34B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 28.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $204, bull (a quarter more growth, a 38.8% margin) about $583.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $451 a share against $333 at the 6 November close. Base case: t…

    • C24EditedMicron Technology's own quarterly report (May 2026) estimated capital expenditure for property, plant and equipment, net of proceeds from government incentives, at approximately $27 billion in 2026; its annual report of 9 October 2026 estimates approximately $11.5 billion in the first quarter of fiscal 2027 and approximately $25 billion in the first six months, and higher in the second half.expired in October; re-sourced to Micron's fiscal 2026 annual report, which adds the fiscal 2027 estimate; the 2026 estimate the prize build uses is kept
      Was

      Micron Technology's own quarterly report estimates capital expenditure for property, plant and equipment, net of proceeds from government incentives,…

    • C28EditedManagement said on 13 August 2026 that its semiconductor equipment business would grow by more than the 'greater than 30%' guided in May for calendar 2026, having guided 'greater than 20%' in February, and that it expects another strong growth year in 2027, without putting a number on either. On 12 November the chief executive said Applied is on track to grow Semiconductor Systems more than 40% in calendar 2026, which ends with its Q1 fiscal 2027. On the same call he said chip-equipment spending should rise more than 30% in calendar 2027 and that Applied expects to outgrow it, and the CFO said Applied is investing to double its systems output from the Q4 fiscal 2026 level by 2028.expired in October; the 13 August call is still the latest management statement on 2026 and 2027 growth, and the 12 November results re-test it, so its shelf life is tied to that print
    • C38EditedManagement said in August that advanced packaging revenue was growing over 70% in calendar 2026, services more than 20% and process diagnostics and control more than 50%. On 12 November it put advanced packaging at around 90% for calendar 2026 and inspection and metrology above 50%; services revenue was a record $1.9B in Q4, up 26%, and the CFO guided services to grow about 15% a year from here, as the installed base and revenue per tool each add 5% to 10%. None of the packaging or process-control figures appears in a filing.expired in October; the 13 August call is still the latest statement of these growth rates and the 12 November results re-test them, so its shelf life is tied to that print
    • C42EditedShort interest was 14,179,138 shares at the 15 October 2026 settlement, up 4.8% from 13,530,729 at 30 September, which had fallen 4.1% from 14,108,387 at 15 September; about 1.8% of the float, with 2.23 days to cover. The 31 August settlement had risen 31.5% to 15,615,253 after three consecutive falls.expired in October; new FINRA settlements of 30 September and 15 October read: the count is little changed, about 1.8% of the float
      Was

      Short interest fell 9.7% to 14,108,387 shares at the 15 September 2026 settlement, 1.78% of the float, after rising 31.5% to 15,615,253 at the 31 Aug…

    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $422 a share against $395 at the 11 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $34.45B grow 36%, 22% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.2% to 35.3% over five years, what its October 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.53B of debt net of $9.34B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 28.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $204, bull (a quarter more growth, a 38.8% margin) about $583.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $423 a share against $333 at the 6 November close. Base case: t…

    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $422 a share against $395 at the 11 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $34.45B grow 36%, 22% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.2% to 35.3% over five years, what its October 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.53B of debt net of $9.34B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 28.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $204, bull (a quarter more growth, a 38.8% margin) about $583.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $423 a share against $371 at the 9 November close. Base case: t…

  • AKAMAkamai TechnologiesThesis changed

    Akamai sells convertible bonds, and our value now counts its debt

    Akamai sold $2.2 billion of bonds that can turn into shares, to repay older bonds and build cloud capacity. Checking its value, we found it had left out the $7.6 billion of such bonds Akamai already owed in September. Counting them, the shares are worth about $54.15, not $104.

    What it did to the thesisThe bonds confirm the build-out is paid for with debt, not new shares. With that debt counted, the price is about 153% of our value, so we moved Akamai from Attractive to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C43EditedOn the company's own figures cash and securities were $4.2B at September 2026 and fall toward $2.4B by December on about $1.7B of Q4 capital spending, and below zero during 2027 once the 2027 notes are repaid, before any new financing. On the Q3 call management said it expects to fund the build-out through 2028 and the 2027 convertible repayment 'primarily' from existing cash and operating cash flow, possibly supplemented by 'measured incremental financing', and wants to keep its investment-grade rating; it did not say whether that financing is debt or shares. On 9 November it priced $2.2B of 1.00% convertible notes ($1.1B due 2028, converting at $112.41, and $1.1B due 2031, at $102.37, premiums of 40% and 27.5% to the $80.29 close), with up to $300M more on the purchasers' option: about $2.16B of net proceeds, of which about $250M pays for hedges that offset dilution, the rest to repay the $1.15B 2027 notes at maturity and fund cloud infrastructure spending. That names the financing as debt, with no shares sold now.9 November convertible pricing named the incremental financing: $2.2B of 1.00% notes, debt with hedges, no shares sold
      Was

      On the company's own figures cash and securities were $4.2B at September 2026 and fall toward $2.4B by December on about $1.7B of Q4 capital spending…

    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Akamai is worth about $54.15 a share against $83.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.39B grow 14%, 22% and 24% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.1% to 12.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 12.0% of sales and a further 2.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 58 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.57B of debt net of $3.52B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $7.84, bull (a quarter more growth, a 13.7% margin) about $94.46.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Akamai is worth about $112 a share against $83.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Akamai is worth about $54.15 a share against $83.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.39B grow 14%, 22% and 24% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.1% to 12.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 12.0% of sales and a further 2.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 58 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.57B of debt net of $3.52B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $7.84, bull (a quarter more growth, a 13.7% margin) about $94.46.the fair value now subtracts the debt and preferred stock the filings carry, which the reader of the balance sheet had missed (the owner's question of 10 November)
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Akamai is worth about $104 a share against $83.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing s…

  • ACMRACM ResearchThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    ACM Research shares rose to near our value; its filing showed cash spent again

    ACM Research shares rose 11.5% to $49.75 on 9 November, about 86% of the $57.65 a share we think the business is worth. Its full quarterly filing then showed operations used $70.4 million of cash in the September quarter, and named no order yet for its two newer tool lines.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is no longer far enough below our value to call it cheap, so we moved it from Attractive to Neutral. The filing gives no reason to move back: cash and a new-tool order were what the case was waiting for. Conviction stays Medium.

    7 claims changed
    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $50.85 a share against $44.00 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.14B grow 25%, 26% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.5% to 16.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 147 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $343M of debt net of $952M of cash, and less $572.3M of book equity belonging to ACM Shanghai's outside shareholders. Bear (half that growth, a 12.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.06, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.7% margin) about $75.19.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $57.65 a share against $44.61 at the 6 November close. Base case: tr…

    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $50.85 a share against $44.00 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.14B grow 25%, 26% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.5% to 16.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 147 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $343M of debt net of $952M of cash, and less $572.3M of book equity belonging to ACM Shanghai's outside shareholders. Bear (half that growth, a 12.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.06, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.7% margin) about $75.19.re-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
      Was

      On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $57.65 a share against $49.75 at the 9 November close. Base case: tr…

    • C07EditedOperating cash flow was negative in six of the last seven quarters (FY2025 -$10.3M; Q1 2026 -$29.5M; Q2 2026 -$6.4M; Q3 2026 -$70.4M, the nine months' filed -$106.3M less the first half), driven in FY2025 by a $108.2M inventory build and $116.1M receivables growth and in 2026 by a $135.2M nine-month inventory build; free cash flow was -$51.7M in Q1 2026, -$71.5M in Q2 2026 and -$100.3M in Q3 2026 (nine months -$223.5M filed).the Q3 2026 10-Q, filed 6 November, was read: operating cash flow was negative again in Q3, by $70.4M, and free cash flow was -$100.3M
      Was

      Operating cash flow was negative in five of the last six quarters (FY2025 -$10.3M; Q1 2026 -$29.5M; Q2 2026 -$6.4M), driven in FY2025 by a $108.2M in…

    • C08EditedACM Research holds a direct 72.8% ownership interest in ACM Shanghai, its principal operating subsidiary listed on Shanghai's STAR Market (688082), down from 74.6% at 31 December 2025 and 73.2% at 30 June 2026: ACM sold ACM Shanghai shares for $110.2M gross in the nine months, and ACM Shanghai employees' option exercises diluted it further; the September 2025 private offering had raised about $623 million.the Q3 2026 10-Q, filed 6 November, was read: the stake is 72.8% at 30 September, down from 74.6% at the year end
      Was

      ACM Research holds a direct 74.6% ownership interest in ACM Shanghai, its principal operating subsidiary listed on Shanghai's STAR Market (688082), d…

    • C12EditedManagement's Q3 2026 10-Q estimates its products address about $22.1 billion of the 2026 wafer-fab-equipment market, on Frost & Sullivan data of June 2026 (about $22 billion on the Q2 2026 call, raised $1 billion there); on that call it reiterated an unchanged $4 billion long-term revenue target ($2.5B mainland China, $1.5B global).the Q3 2026 10-Q, filed 6 November, was read: it restates the addressed market at $22.1 billion on the June 2026 Frost & Sullivan data
      Was

      Management estimates its addressable wafer-fab-equipment market at about $22 billion (raised $1 billion in Q2 2026) based on Frost & Sullivan data, a…

    • C23EditedAs of the Q3 2026 release on 5 November, ACM's PECVD and Track platforms are not reported as separate product lines and neither the release nor the Q3 10-Q, filed 6 November, names a production order for either; as of the Q2 2026 call both were in customer evaluation with production qualification anticipated by year-end 2026. On the Q3 call the chief executive said the Track system has started customer pre-production alongside a scanner and PECVD is making progress, but no production order was named.the Q3 2026 10-Q, filed 6 November, was read and names no PECVD or Track production order
      Was

      As of the Q3 2026 release on 5 November, ACM's PECVD and Track platforms are not reported as separate product lines and the release names no producti…

    • C37EditedOn May 29, 2026, ACM Shanghai's board approved a plan to issue new H Shares and list on the Main Board of the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, for up to 7% of total post-offering share capital plus a 15% over-allotment option, with proceeds earmarked for R&D, global market expansion, working capital and bank-loan repayment; by the Q3 2026 10-Q its shareholders had approved it too, and it remains subject to market conditions and to filings and approvals including the China Securities Regulatory Commission's and the Hong Kong exchange's.the Q3 2026 10-Q, filed 6 November, was read: ACM Shanghai's shareholders have approved the H-share plan, which still waits on regulators and the market
      Was

      On May 29, 2026, ACM Shanghai's board approved a plan, subject to shareholder approval, to issue new H Shares and list on the Main Board of the Hong…

Monday 9 November194

  • ZMZoom CommunicationsThesis changed

    Zoom re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Zoom closed at $89.88 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $84.53.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 106% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C52NewAnalysts expect revenue of $5.09B in fiscal 2027, $5.32B in fiscal 2028, $5.56B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $2.71B in the last of those years, a 48.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Zoom is worth about $93.65 a share against $98.08 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.99B grow 4%, 4% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C52), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.7% to 28.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.6% of sales and a further 6.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; plus $7.25B of cash and securities and $3.79B of strategic investments at their carrying value (C17), with no debt. Bear (half that growth, a 22.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79.53, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.9% margin) about $114.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Zoom is worth about $93.65 a share against $98.08 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.99B grow 4%, 4% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C52), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.7% to 28.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.6% of sales and a further 6.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; plus $7.25B of cash and securities and $3.79B of strategic investments at their carrying value (C17), with no debt. Bear (half that growth, a 22.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79.53, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.9% margin) about $114.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • XYLXylemRefreshed

    Xylem finished buying Cornell Pump and Roper Pump

    Xylem said it has completed its purchase of two pump makers, Cornell Pump and Roper Pump, announced in August for about $1.46 billion in cash. It closed inside the quarter Xylem had given. Only the first paragraph of its announcement could be read, and it gave no new numbers.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The closing was expected and was already paid for with notes sold in September. Our case turns on growth without acquisitions and margins, which this does not touch; the first test of how the pump makers perform is the fourth-quarter report. Neutral holds.

    3 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $8.96B in fiscal 2026, $9.28B in fiscal 2027, $9.76B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.82B in the last of those years, a 18.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Xylem is worth about $94.67 a share against $97.83 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.06B grow 2%, 5% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 15.1% to 18.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.6% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 22 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.90B of debt net of $708M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.9% margin) about $120.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C10EditedXylem agreed on 11 August 2026 to buy the Cornell Pump and Roper Pump businesses from Indicor for about $1.46B in cash and completed the purchase on 9 November 2026, within the Q4 2026 window it had given. They are expected to earn more than $260M of revenue in 2026 at EBITDA margins above 30%; Xylem puts the price at 11.6 times 2026 EBITDA after $23M of cost savings and $170M of tax benefits. The part of the completion release read gives no final price or new figures.Xylem announced on 9 November 2026 that the purchase was completed; the closing was expected in Q4 2026.
      Was

      Xylem agreed on 11 August 2026 to buy the Cornell Pump and Roper Pump businesses from Indicor for about $1.46B in cash, closing in Q4 2026. They are…

  • WAYWaystar HoldingThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Waystar re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Waystar closed at $28.35 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $37.80.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 75% of that value, so we moved Waystar from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.28B in fiscal 2026, $1.42B in fiscal 2027, $1.57B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $703M in the last of those years, a 44.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $28.14 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $1.26B grow 9%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.9% to 37.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.46B of debt net of $277M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 30.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 41.6% margin) about $48.55.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Waystar is worth about $35.98 a share against $28.14 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $1.26B grow 9%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.9% to 37.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.46B of debt net of $277M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 30.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 41.6% margin) about $48.55.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • VSHVishay IntertechnologyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Vishay re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Vishay closed at $23.28 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $43.32.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 54% of that value, so we moved Vishay from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.72B in fiscal 2026, $4.30B in fiscal 2027, $4.79B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $749M in the last of those years, a 15.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vishay is worth about $41.20 a share against $23.28 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.51B grow 18% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.2% to 14.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 76 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $735M of debt net of $1.14B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.1% margin) about $61.40.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vishay is worth about $41.20 a share against $23.28 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.51B grow 18% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.2% to 14.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 76 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $735M of debt net of $1.14B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.1% margin) about $61.40.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • VRTVertiv HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Vertiv re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Vertiv closed at $183 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $279.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 65% of that value, so we moved Vertiv from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C49NewAnalysts expect revenue of $14.65B in fiscal 2026, $19.46B in fiscal 2027, $23.61B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $7.26B in the last of those years, a 30.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $226 a share against $200 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.12B grow 38%, 24% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 22.8% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 27.0%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.93B of debt net of $3.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $101, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $324.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vertiv is worth about $226 a share against $200 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.12B grow 38%, 24% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 22.8% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 27.0%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.93B of debt net of $3.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $101, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $324.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • VPGVishay Precision GroupThesis changed

    VPG's price reached our target line briefly, but its profit margin has not followed

    Vishay Precision's shares closed at $41.22 on 5 November, under the price line our route to a better view names, then rose 7.3% to $44.21. The same route needs the profit margin to reach 8% for two quarters; the latest is 4.9%. VPG gave no robot-sensor sales figure in its September-quarter results.

    What it did to the thesisThe price half of the route was met but the margin half was not, and robot-sensor sales slipped to February. Valued in three stages the price is now under what the business is worth, so the view moves to Neutral.

    2 claims changed
    • C58NewAnalysts expect revenue of $344M in fiscal 2026, $371M in fiscal 2027, $396M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $65M in the last of those years, a 16.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vishay Precision is worth about $50.97 a share against $44.21 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $334M grow 9% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 1.1% to 15.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 59 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $16M of debt net of $81M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.85, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.2% margin) about $70.32.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • VOYGVoyager TechnologiesRefreshed

    Voyager joined NASA's pool of lunar delivery companies, but has no order yet

    Voyager said NASA picked it as one of the companies allowed to bid for future moon-delivery missions through 2036. The contract can reach $10 billion in total, shared by every company in the pool. The part of the announcement we could read names no mission and no money for Voyager.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is a later route to moon revenue through the Astrobotic landers, not an order. The things our Unattractive view rests on, the thin profit margin, the Starlab funding and a price that needs about 25% growth a year for a decade, are untouched.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewOn 7 November 2026 Voyager said it was selected under NASA's new Commercial Lunar Payload Services multiple-award contract, known as CLPS 2, which puts it in the vendor pool eligible to compete for lunar mission task orders through 2036 under a base ceiling of $10B, extendable to 2041 at $15B. A place in the pool is not an order: no task order or dollar award to Voyager is stated in the part of the release read.the CLPS 2 selection announced 7 November 2026 bears on the lunar delivery line, C37
    • C37EditedThrough Astrobotic Voyager won a $298M NASA lunar delivery award, finished acceptance tests on the Griffin-1 lander and expects it to launch late in 2026.The CLPS 2 selection (C46) adds a route to future lunar orders; no order or date for Griffin-1 changed.
  • VMIValmont IndustriesThesis changed

    Valmont re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Valmont closed at $404 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $383.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 105% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C60NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.36B in fiscal 2026, $4.70B in fiscal 2027, $5.06B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $863M in the last of those years, a 17.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C61NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Valmont is worth about $374 a share against $404 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.29B grow 8%, 8% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.2% to its five-year average of 10.0% over five years, because 14.2% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 36 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $756M of debt net of $122M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $210, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.0% margin) about $481.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Valmont is worth about $374 a share against $404 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.29B grow 8%, 8% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.2% to its five-year average of 10.0% over five years, because 14.2% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 36 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $756M of debt net of $122M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $210, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.0% margin) about $481.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • VIKViking HoldingsThesis changed

    Viking re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Viking closed at $87.48 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $107.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 81% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C56NewAnalysts expect revenue of $7.36B in fiscal 2026, $8.92B in fiscal 2027, $10.13B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.41B in the last of those years, a 33.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Viking is worth about $104 a share against $90.28 at the 16 November close, about 87% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $7.15B grow 16%, 16% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56, as read on 9 November, with the second year cut from 17.3% to 15.8% for the 2027 Net Yield goal the Q3 call lowered, C13), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 22.2% to 29.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales and a further 3.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.36B of debt and leases net of $4.05B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 23.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $49.44, bull (a quarter more growth, a 32.3% margin) about $144.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • VALEValeThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Vale re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Vale closed at $11.59 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $27.10.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 43% of that value, so we moved Vale from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $38.10B in fiscal 2025, $40.99B in fiscal 2026, $40.69B in fiscal 2027, with operating profit of $10.37B in the last of those years, a 25.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Vale is worth about $21.61 a share against $11.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $48.75B grow -2%, -2% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.9% to 25.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 196 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $30.27B of debt net of $6.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.87, bull (a quarter more growth, a 28.0% margin) about $30.46.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • UTIUniversal Technical InstituteThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Universal Technical Institute re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Universal Technical Institute closed at $19.93 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $16.05.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 124% of that value, so we moved Universal Technical Institute from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $896M in fiscal 2026, $969M in fiscal 2027, $1.07B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $88M in the last of those years, a 8.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Universal Technical Institute is worth about $14.96 a share against $22.44 at the 16 November close, about 150% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $884M grow 8%, 10% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.0% to 6.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $160M of debt net of $170M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.28, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.6% margin) about $21.75.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Universal Technical Institute is worth about $14.96 a share against $22.44 at the 16 November close, about 150% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $884M grow 8%, 10% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.0% to 6.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $160M of debt net of $170M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.28, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.6% margin) about $21.75.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • UIUbiquitiThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Ubiquiti re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Ubiquiti closed at $593 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $390.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 152% of that value, so we moved Ubiquiti from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.00B in fiscal 2027, $4.58B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.44B in the last of those years, a 31.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ubiquiti is worth about $376 a share against $593 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.57B grow 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 36.9% to 31.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 21 cents of capital; a 18.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $845M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 25.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $224, bull (a quarter more growth, a 34.4% margin) about $473.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • UBERUber TechnologiesThesis changed

    McDonald's and Uber widened their delivery and loyalty deal to 14 markets

    Uber announced with McDonald's a wider partnership covering delivery and customer loyalty in 14 markets. We could read only the headline: Uber's wire host and the other pages we tried would not open, so the terms, restaurant counts and any figures are unknown to us.

    What it did to the thesisThe news moved nothing. Valued the same day on its own future cash at an 8% return, Uber is worth about $77 a share, so the price is fair, not cheap: the view moves from Attractive to Neutral, conviction unchanged.

    9 claims changed
    • C56NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Uber is worth about $81 a share against $68.59 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value net of $22.7B of investments and with $1.3B of minority interest is about 15.1 times trailing non-GAAP operating income. Base case: 2025 revenue of $52.0B grows 12%, 14% and 13% over three years, then fades toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 12.4% to 15% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 59 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (7% and 5% after 2026, a 10% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37, bull (17% and 16%, a 19% margin) about $111.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C35EditedAt $66.60 Uber's enterprise value of about $145.5B by the vendor's count, about $124.1B net of $22.7B of investments and with $1.3B of minority interest added, is 15.0 times trailing Non-GAAP Operating Income and 14.0 times trailing free cash flow, a free cash flow yield on the $135.6B market value of 7.7%. The frozen pack's valuation ratios are as of 11 September at $71.26 and have not been re-pulled.restated on enterprise value net of securities and investments, with preferred and minority interest added; the vendor's figure subtracts cash alone
      Was

      At $66.60 Uber's enterprise value of about $145.5B is 17.6 times trailing Non-GAAP Operating Income and 14.0 times trailing free cash flow, a free ca…

    • C07EditedUber's chief executive said on the Q2 2026 call that autonomous vehicles are doing 'hundreds of thousands of trips per week' against Uber's roughly 300 million trips a week, 'even less than 0.5% of our overall trip volume'. The Q3 2026 call did not restate the share of trips; it said about 700 fully driverless vehicles would be on Uber by the end of 2026 and more than 2,000 by the end of 2027.re-sourced on the Q3 call: the trip share was not restated, the vehicle counts were
      Was

      Uber's chief executive said on the Q2 2026 call that autonomous vehicles are doing 'hundreds of thousands of trips per week' against Uber's roughly 3…

    • C09EditedUber's answer to the substitute is to become its distribution layer rather than build it: management said on the Q2 2026 call that Uber is live with autonomous vehicles in 7 cities and on track for 15 by the end of 2026, named Nuro with Lucid, Zoox, Wayve, Baidu, Pony, Verne and Rivian as launching partners, described about $10B of multi-year AV investment split between equity stakes in software partners and balance-sheet support for fleets, cited 120,000 vehicle commitments, and said AV Labs is running hundreds of sensor-equipped cars to collect rideshare-specific training data for all partners. On the Q3 call he said Zoox launches on Uber in Las Vegas in November 2026, Nuro follows in California and Houston in 2027, about 700 driverless vehicles are expected by year-end, more than 2,000 by the end of 2027 and tens of thousands from 2028, and the $10B commitment stands.re-sourced on the Q3 call: launch schedule and vehicle targets
      Was

      Uber's answer to the substitute is to become its distribution layer rather than build it: management said on the Q2 2026 call that Uber is live with…

    • C19EditedUber's chief financial officer said on the Q2 2026 call that of the roughly 500 basis point year-on-year fall in Mobility revenue margin, about 400 basis points 'is entirely related to this U.K. business model change, and it's an optical impact', with the remainder deliberate investment in lower-cost offerings. The Q3 2026 call did not repeat the split; the chief financial officer said Q4 supply investment would affect Mobility's take rate but not its margin in a meaningful way.a historical statement of Q2 2026; the Q3 call did not restate the UK split, so it is kept as a closed-period fact with the Q3 comment added and the expiry removed
      Was

      Uber's chief financial officer said on the Q2 2026 call that of the roughly 500 basis point year-on-year fall in Mobility revenue margin, about 400 b…

    • C39EditedGrowth is broadening rather than narrowing, on management's own account: less than 10% of eligible consumers in US sparse markets used Uber in the past 12 months against over 50% in dense markets; only 30% of US Gross Bookings and 25% of US profits come from the top 20 cities; and only about 20% of consumers use both Rides and Eats, with cross-platform users growing 1.5 times faster than single-product users. On the Q3 2026 call the chief executive repeated that less than 10% of eligible consumers in US sparse markets used Uber in the past 12 months against 50% in dense markets, said US delivery growth accelerated for the second quarter running and that members are 70% of delivery gross bookings.re-sourced on the Q3 call: the sparse-market gap repeated, delivery accelerated
      Was

      Growth is broadening rather than narrowing, on management's own account: less than 10% of eligible consumers in US sparse markets used Uber in the pa…

    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Uber is worth about $81 a share against $68.59 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value net of $22.7B of investments and with $1.3B of minority interest is about 15.1 times trailing non-GAAP operating income. Base case: 2025 revenue of $52.0B grows 12%, 14% and 13% over three years, then fades toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 12.4% to 15% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 59 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (7% and 5% after 2026, a 10% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37, bull (17% and 16%, a 19% margin) about $111.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Uber is worth about $81 a share against $68.59 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value net of $22.7B of investments and with $1.3B of minority interest is about 15.1 times trailing non-GAAP operating income. Base case: 2025 revenue of $52.0B grows 12%, 14% and 13% over three years, then fades toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 12.4% to 15% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 59 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (7% and 5% after 2026, a 10% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37, bull (17% and 16%, a 19% margin) about $111.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Uber is worth about $81 a share against $68.59 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value net of $22.7B of investments and with $1.3B of minority interest is about 15.1 times trailing non-GAAP operating income. Base case: 2025 revenue of $52.0B grows 12%, 14% and 13% over three years, then fades toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 12.4% to 15% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 59 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (7% and 5% after 2026, a 10% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37, bull (17% and 16%, a 19% margin) about $111.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • UUnity SoftwareThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Unity re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Unity closed at $51.49 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $10.17.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 506% of that value, so we moved Unity from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.23B in fiscal 2026, $2.71B in fiscal 2027, $3.24B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $956M in the last of those years, a 29.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Unity is worth about $6.77 a share against $51.49 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.18B grow 18%, 20% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -17.9% to 7.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.4% of sales and a further 7.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.24B of debt net of $2.65B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $2.81, bull (a quarter more growth, a 8.3% margin) about $10.03.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • TYLTyler TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Tyler Technologies re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Tyler Technologies closed at $421 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $276.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 152% of that value, so we moved Tyler Technologies from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C50NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.55B in fiscal 2026, $2.80B in fiscal 2027, $3.08B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $899M in the last of those years, a 29.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C51NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Tyler Technologies is worth about $233 a share against $421 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.48B grow 10%, 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C50), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 15.6% to 22.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.41B of debt net of $879M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $120, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $310.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C51EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Tyler Technologies is worth about $233 a share against $421 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.48B grow 10%, 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C50), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 15.6% to 22.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.41B of debt net of $879M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $120, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.1% margin) about $310.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TTMITTM TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    TTM Technologies re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    TTM Technologies closed at $66.51 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $163.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 41% of that value, so we moved TTM Technologies from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.48B in fiscal 2026, $6.59B in fiscal 2027, $7.59B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.41B in the last of those years, a 18.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TTM Technologies is worth about $141 a share against $66.51 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 56% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.1% to 14.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 15.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 48 cents of capital; a 21.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.64B of debt net of $876M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.71, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.6% margin) about $214.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TTM Technologies is worth about $141 a share against $66.51 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 56% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.1% to 14.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 15.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 48 cents of capital; a 21.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.64B of debt net of $876M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.71, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.6% margin) about $214.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TSMTaiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company LimitedThesis changed
    Valuation3→4

    TSMC re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    TSMC closed at $375 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $757.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 50% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C40NewAnalysts expect revenue of $167.22B in fiscal 2026, $231.74B in fiscal 2027, $292.03B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $173.01B in the last of those years, a 59.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C41NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TSMC is worth about $728 a share against $375 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $150.89B grow 42%, 29% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 58.0% to 58.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 0.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 17.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $29.95B of debt net of $122.32B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 46.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $278, bull (a quarter more growth, a 64.2% margin) about $1,013.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • TSLATeslaRefreshed

    Musk says Tesla will stop making the Cybertruck around mid-2027

    Elon Musk said on X that Tesla will end Cybertruck production in Texas in about eight months so the space can build more Cybercab robotaxis, and that many deposits will be returned. Tesla does not report Cybertruck sales; outside estimates put the total near 71,000, far below the 250,000 a year once predicted.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It shows Tesla putting factory space behind robotaxis, the part of the story we say is unproven, while a vehicle line fades. Our case waits on the margin and any robotaxi revenue figure at the next results.

    4 claims changed
    • C59NewAnalysts expect revenue of $107.55B in fiscal 2026, $121.88B in fiscal 2027, $144.34B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $14.41B in the last of those years, a 10.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Tesla is worth about $49.31 a share against $358 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $103.57B grow 14%, 17% and 31% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 3.3% to 5.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 37 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $9.27B of debt net of $45.45B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25.86, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.4% margin) about $71.55.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C02EditedIt sells five consumer vehicles - Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X and Cybertruck - plus the Semi, and two energy products, Powerwall for homes and Megapack for utilities and data centres. Musk said on X on 6 November 2026 that Cybertruck production at Giga Texas will end in about eight months, around mid-2027, to make room for Cybercab, and that many deposits will be returned (TechCrunch).Musk announced the Cybertruck will end production around mid-2027; one of the five consumer vehicles leaves the line-up
      Was

      It sells five consumer vehicles - Model 3, Model Y, Model S, Model X and Cybertruck - plus the Semi, and two energy products, Powerwall for homes and…

    • C46EditedOn the Q2 2026 call (22 July) management named the constraint on Robotaxi as reliability rather than demand or regulation: 'It is really about going through what we call the march of 9s of reliability... I think that is the only thing really constraining our growth in robotaxi.' The Q3 call did not repeat the statement.valid_through passed on 28 October; the Q3 call did not restate it, so it is kept as a closed statement from the Q2 call rather than a current one
      Was

      Management names the constraint on Robotaxi as reliability rather than demand or regulation: 'It is really about going through what we call the march…

  • TPLTexas Pacific LandThesis changed

    Texas Pacific Land re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Texas Pacific Land closed at $272 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $227.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 120% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C44NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.02B in fiscal 2026, $1.17B in fiscal 2027, $1.28B in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C45NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Texas Pacific Land is worth about $220 a share against $272 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $968M grow 16% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C44), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 75.5% to 70.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 33 cents of capital; a 20.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $370M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 56.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $116, bull (a quarter more growth, a 77.0% margin) about $266.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • TOSTToastThesis changed

    Toast re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Toast closed at $34.67 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $28.90.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is just under 120% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C40NewAnalysts expect revenue of $7.49B in fiscal 2026, $8.89B in fiscal 2027, $10.38B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.60B in the last of those years, a 15.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C41NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Toast is worth about $24.54 a share against $34.67 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.15B grow 19%, 17% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.2% to 8.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.0% of sales and a further 4.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.20B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.88, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.3% margin) about $33.18.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Toast is worth about $24.54 a share against $34.67 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.15B grow 19%, 17% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.2% to 8.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.0% of sales and a further 4.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.20B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.88, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.3% margin) about $33.18.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TERTeradyneThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Teradyne re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Teradyne closed at $218 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $236.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 92% of that value, so we moved Teradyne from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C63NewAnalysts expect revenue of $5.23B in fiscal 2026, $6.51B in fiscal 2027, $7.97B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.90B in the last of those years, a 36.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Teradyne is worth about $226 a share against $218 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.00B grow 23% and 23% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.1% to its five-year average of 23.8% over five years, because 32.1% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 41 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $461M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.2% margin) about $318.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Teradyne is worth about $226 a share against $218 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.00B grow 23% and 23% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.1% to its five-year average of 23.8% over five years, because 32.1% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 41 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $461M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.2% margin) about $318.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TENBTenable HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Tenable re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Tenable closed at $42.13 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $17.36.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 243% of that value, so we moved Tenable from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C56NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.09B in fiscal 2026, $1.17B in fiscal 2027, $1.25B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $427M in the last of those years, a 34.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Tenable is worth about $9.28 a share against $42.13 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.07B grow 7%, 7% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 11.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 17.4% of sales and a further 4.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $779M of debt net of $495M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.10, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.9% margin) about $14.22.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Tenable is worth about $9.28 a share against $42.13 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.07B grow 7%, 7% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 11.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 17.4% of sales and a further 4.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $779M of debt net of $495M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.10, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.9% margin) about $14.22.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TEMTempus AIThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Tempus re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Tempus closed at $76.05 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $3.45.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 2204% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C73NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.60B in fiscal 2026, $1.99B in fiscal 2027, $2.41B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $203M in the last of those years, a 8.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C74NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Tempus is worth about $3.22 a share against $76.05 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.51B grow 25%, 22% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C73), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -18.5% to 2.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.3% of sales and a further 7.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 22 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $176M of debt net of $590M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 1.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $1.53, bull (a quarter more growth, a 2.3% margin) about $4.74.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • TELTE ConnectivityThesis changed

    TE Connectivity re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    TE Connectivity closed at $207 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $249.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 83% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $19.86B in fiscal 2026, $22.33B in fiscal 2027, $24.17B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $5.53B in the last of those years, a 22.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TE Connectivity is worth about $244 a share against $219 at the 9 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $19.89B grow 12%, 8% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 21.2% over five years, the best it has filed before amortisation; each added dollar of sales needs 37 cents of capital; a 17.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.64B of debt net of $1.70B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $136, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.3% margin) about $312.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TE Connectivity is worth about $244 a share against $219 at the 9 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $19.89B grow 12%, 8% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.1% to 21.2% over five years, the best it has filed before amortisation; each added dollar of sales needs 37 cents of capital; a 17.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.64B of debt net of $1.70B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $136, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.3% margin) about $312.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TBCHTurtle BeachThesis changed

    Turtle Beach re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Turtle Beach closed at $15.19 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $14.45.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 105% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $344M in fiscal 2026, $378M in fiscal 2027, $406M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $35M in the last of those years, a 8.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $15.99 at the 16 November close, about 117% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $320M grow 8%, 10% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 6.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $55M of debt net of $17M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.4% margin) about $19.81.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Turtle Beach is worth about $13.61 a share against $15.99 at the 16 November close, about 117% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $320M grow 8%, 10% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 6.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $55M of debt net of $17M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.4% margin) about $19.81.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • TATTTAT TechnologiesThesis changed

    TAT Technologies re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    TAT Technologies closed at $37.00 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $34.20.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 108% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $204M in fiscal 2026, $231M in fiscal 2027, $258M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $31M in the last of those years, a 12.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TAT Technologies is worth about $33.95 a share against $37.00 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $178M grow 15%, 13% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.6% to 11.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 73 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $12M of debt net of $51M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $19.58, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.5% margin) about $44.77.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TAT Technologies is worth about $33.95 a share against $37.00 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $178M grow 15%, 13% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.6% to 11.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 73 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $12M of debt net of $51M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $19.58, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.5% margin) about $44.77.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • SWKSSkyworks SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Skyworks re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Skyworks closed at $82.19 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $41.04.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 200% of that value, so we moved Skyworks from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.95B in fiscal 2026, $7.42B in fiscal 2027, $7.90B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.31B in the last of those years, a 16.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Skyworks is worth about $39.27 a share against $82.19 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.01B grow 58%, 23% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.6% to 8.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 5.8% of sales and a further 2.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 51 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $497M of debt net of $799M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $24.93, bull (a quarter more growth, a 8.8% margin) about $62.43.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • STXSeagate Technology HoldingsThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Seagate Technology re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Seagate Technology closed at $461 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $455.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 101% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C34NewAnalysts expect revenue of $20.32B in fiscal 2027, $28.79B in fiscal 2028, $36.05B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $21.38B in the last of those years, a 59.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C35NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Seagate Technology is worth about $434 a share against $499.00 at the 16 November close, about 115% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $13.80B grow 60%, 37% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C34, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 39.6% to its five-year average of 14.7% over five years, because 39.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 21 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.35B of debt net of $1.26B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $173, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.1% margin) about $659.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Seagate Technology is worth about $434 a share against $499.00 at the 16 November close, about 115% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $13.80B grow 60%, 37% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C34, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 39.6% to its five-year average of 14.7% over five years, because 39.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 21 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.35B of debt net of $1.26B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $173, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.1% margin) about $659.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • STRLSterling InfrastructureThesis changed

    Sterling's profit margin is more than double its own past

    Sterling earned about 18 cents of operating profit on each dollar of sales over the last year, more than twice the 7.6 cents of 2020 and 2021. The shares closed at $252.82 on 6 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Attractive, with medium conviction. Even with its margin falling back and growth slowing over ten years, it is worth about $354 a share against $253. On its old average margin it would be worth about the price.

    5 claims changed
    • C41NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.the normal-year reading added when the contractor theme was re-reviewed on one rule
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sterling is worth about $359 a share against $275.13 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.31B grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to a normal 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 11 cents of capital; a 24% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net cash of $122M. Bear (3% growth, the 2020-2025 average margin of 10.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $190, bull (20%, 17%) about $561. At the base case's 14% margin a normal year earns about $459M, about $14.76 a share, and the price is about 18.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $264.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • STSensata Technologies HoldingThesis changed

    Sensata re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Sensata closed at $39.31 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $39.52.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 99% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C62NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.88B in fiscal 2026, $4.01B in fiscal 2027, $4.14B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $950M in the last of those years, a 22.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sensata is worth about $38.14 a share against $39.31 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.70B grow 5%, 3% and 3% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.4% to 16.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 5.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 38 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.83B of debt net of $573M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $17.43, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.1% margin) about $50.49.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sensata is worth about $38.14 a share against $39.31 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.70B grow 5%, 3% and 3% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.4% to 16.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 5.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 38 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.83B of debt net of $573M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $17.43, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.1% margin) about $50.49.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • SPOTSpotify TechnologyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Spotify re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Spotify closed at $603 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $431.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 140% of that value, so we moved Spotify from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $21.83B in fiscal 2026, $25.06B in fiscal 2027, $28.47B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $5.20B in the last of those years, a 18.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Spotify is worth about $420 a share against $603 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $20.96B grow 16%, 14% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.6% to 16.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.5% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $572M of debt net of $12.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $247, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.4% margin) about $545.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesThesis changed

    SpaceX re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    SpaceX closed at $134 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $37.54.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 358% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect revenue of $47.70B in fiscal 2026, $160.26B in fiscal 2027, $333.41B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $109.89B in the last of those years, a 33.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SpaceX is worth about $35.22 a share against $134 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $32.04B grow 60% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -2.0% to 18.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $38.84B of debt net of $89.86B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $11.60, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.0% margin) about $61.97.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • SOFISoFi TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    SoFi re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    SoFi closed at $16.21 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $20.36.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 80% of that value, so we moved SoFi from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C63NewAnalysts expect $5.03B of revenue and $0.60 a share in fiscal 2026, $6.38B of revenue and $0.87 a share in fiscal 2027, $7.76B of revenue and $1.11 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return SoFi is worth about $20.36 a share against $14.85 at the 16 November close, about 73% of it. Base case: shareholders' equity of $11.30B grows 27%, 23% and 20% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C63, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 7.3%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 7.1%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 5.7% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $6.69, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.8% return) about $36.72.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • SNXTD SynnexThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    TD SYNNEX re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    TD SYNNEX closed at $219 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $431.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 51% of that value, so we moved TD SYNNEX from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $80.53B in fiscal 2026, $89.16B in fiscal 2027, $97.36B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.18B in the last of those years, a 3.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TD SYNNEX is worth about $426 a share against $219 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $75.67B grow 15% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 2.7% to 3.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 22.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.52B of debt net of $749M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 2.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $206, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.5% margin) about $564.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return TD SYNNEX is worth about $426 a share against $219 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $75.67B grow 15% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 2.7% to 3.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 22.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.52B of debt net of $749M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 2.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $206, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.5% margin) about $564.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • SNPSSynopsysThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Synopsys re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Synopsys closed at $450 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $254.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 178% of that value, so we moved Synopsys from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C49NewAnalysts expect revenue of $9.72B in fiscal 2026, $11.05B in fiscal 2027, $12.60B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $4.78B in the last of those years, a 38.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Synopsys is worth about $243 a share against $450 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.42B grow 14%, 14% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.5% to 22.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.1% of sales and a further 5.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 17.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $10.04B of debt net of $3.61B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $89.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.8% margin) about $319.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Synopsys is worth about $243 a share against $450 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.42B grow 14%, 14% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.5% to 22.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.1% of sales and a further 5.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 17.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $10.04B of debt net of $3.61B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $89.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.8% margin) about $319.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • SNDKSandiskThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Unattractive
    Valuation4→2

    Sandisk re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Sandisk closed at $835 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $676.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 124% of that value, so we moved Sandisk from Attractive to Unattractive. Conviction stays Low.

    4 claims changed
    • C44NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sandisk is worth about $668 a share against $835.06 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 3.5 times Q1 fiscal 2027 operating profit annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $20.2B grow 120% in fiscal 2027, are flat in 2028 and fall 25% in 2029, then move toward 4% growth by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 72.5% to a 25% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (100%, then falls of 35% and 30%, a 15% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $337, bull (146%, 22% and flat, a 45% margin) about $2,611. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $527.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sandisk is worth about $668 a share against $835.06 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 3.5 times Q1 fiscal 2027 operating profit annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $20.2B grow 120% in fiscal 2027, are flat in 2028 and fall 25% in 2029, then move toward 4% growth by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 72.5% to a 25% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (100%, then falls of 35% and 30%, a 15% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $337, bull (146%, 22% and flat, a 45% margin) about $2,611. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $527.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sandisk is worth about $668 a share against $835.06 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 3.5 times Q1 fiscal 2027 operating profit annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $20.2B grow 120% in fiscal 2027, are flat in 2028 and fall 25% in 2029, then move toward 4% growth by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 72.5% to a 25% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (100%, then falls of 35% and 30%, a 15% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $337, bull (146%, 22% and flat, a 45% margin) about $2,611. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $527.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sandisk is worth about $668 a share against $835.06 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 3.5 times Q1 fiscal 2027 operating profit annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $20.2B grow 120% in fiscal 2027, are flat in 2028 and fall 25% in 2029, then move toward 4% growth by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 72.5% to a 25% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (100%, then falls of 35% and 30%, a 15% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $337, bull (146%, 22% and flat, a 45% margin) about $2,611. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $527.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • SMCISuper Micro ComputerThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Supermicro re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Supermicro closed at $28.76 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $70.27.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 41% of that value, so we moved Supermicro from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect revenue of $76.16B in fiscal 2027, $85.68B in fiscal 2028, $96.15B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $5.69B in the last of those years, a 5.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Supermicro is worth about $50.83 a share against $28.76 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $53.99B grow 45% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 5.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 20.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $8.65B of debt and $4.23B of preferred stock net of $6.91B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.7% margin) about $85.11.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Supermicro is worth about $50.83 a share against $28.76 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $53.99B grow 45% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.6% to 5.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 20.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $8.65B of debt and $4.23B of preferred stock net of $6.91B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.7% margin) about $85.11.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • SKHYSK hynixThesis changed

    SK hynix re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    SK hynix closed at $127 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $314.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 41% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $262.94B in fiscal 2026, $427.70B in fiscal 2027, $503.47B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $450.74B in the last of those years, a 89.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SK hynix is worth about $125 a share against $127 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $197.35B follow the analysts' path of 60%, 28% and 29% (C46) less the price fall half its margin drop implies, since memory sells at a market price: sales end year three at 49% of that path, so they grow 26%, 0% and 2%, then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.5% to its five-year average of 20.9% over five years, because 74.5% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.49B of debt net of $63.88B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.33, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.0% margin) about $180.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • SITMSiTimeThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    SiTime re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    SiTime closed at $417 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $242.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 172% of that value, so we moved SiTime from Attractive to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C51NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SiTime is worth about $225 a share against $416.92 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 12.3 times September-quarter sales annualised. Base case: 2025 sales of $326.7M reach analysts' $875M in 2026 with the Renesas line, then grow 45% and 30%, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and the deal's amortisation, moves from 0.9% to 30% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 67 cents of capital; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% then flat, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $18, bull (55% and 35%, a 38% margin) about $410. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $169.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C51EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SiTime is worth about $225 a share against $416.92 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 12.3 times September-quarter sales annualised. Base case: 2025 sales of $326.7M reach analysts' $875M in 2026 with the Renesas line, then grow 45% and 30%, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and the deal's amortisation, moves from 0.9% to 30% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 67 cents of capital; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% then flat, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $18, bull (55% and 35%, a 38% margin) about $410. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $169.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C51EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SiTime is worth about $225 a share against $416.92 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 12.3 times September-quarter sales annualised. Base case: 2025 sales of $326.7M reach analysts' $875M in 2026 with the Renesas line, then grow 45% and 30%, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and the deal's amortisation, moves from 0.9% to 30% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 67 cents of capital; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% then flat, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $18, bull (55% and 35%, a 38% margin) about $410. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $169.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C51EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SiTime is worth about $225 a share against $416.92 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 12.3 times September-quarter sales annualised. Base case: 2025 sales of $326.7M reach analysts' $875M in 2026 with the Renesas line, then grow 45% and 30%, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and the deal's amortisation, moves from 0.9% to 30% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 67 cents of capital; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% then flat, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $18, bull (55% and 35%, a 38% margin) about $410. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $169.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • SIMOSilicon Motion TechnologyThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Silicon Motion re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Silicon Motion closed at $163 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $169.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 97% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C56NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.95B in fiscal 2026, $2.75B in fiscal 2027, $3.35B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.01B in the last of those years, a 30.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Silicon Motion is worth about $163 a share against $163 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $886M grow 60%, 41% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.5% to its five-year average of 15.5% over five years, because 10.5% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 70 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $202M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $60.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.0% margin) about $260.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • SANMSanminaThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Sanmina re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Sanmina closed at $135 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $196.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 69% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    17 claims changed
    • C56NewQ4 FY2026 revenue was $3.858B, up 84% on $2.096B, and fiscal 2026 revenue $14.525B, up 79%. GAAP operating margin was 6.0% in the quarter and 4.7% for the year; non-GAAP operating margin 9.0% and 7.4%. Fiscal 2026 operating cash flow was $944M and free cash flow $541M; year-end cash $1,676M against $2,088M of debt.the print the pre-registered test was set against
    • C57NewOn 9 November management guided fiscal 2027 revenue of $17.5B to $19.5B, non-GAAP operating margin of 7.0% to 7.5% and non-GAAP diluted earnings of $15.50 to $17.50, and first-quarter fiscal 2027 revenue of $3.8B to $4.1B at a 7.0% to 7.5% margin; the release does not split the accelerated-compute programme out.the first formal fiscal 2027 guide, the single disclosure the view turned on
    • C58NewAnalysts expect revenue of $18.49B in fiscal 2027 and $22.14B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.49B in the last of those years, a 6.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Sanmina is worth about $255 a share against $153 at the 17 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $14.53B grow 27% and 20% over the next two years (the middle of the $17.5B to $19.5B guide, C57, where the analysts now sit, then the analysts' fiscal 2028 revenue, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.7% to 6.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin after stock pay; each added dollar of sales needs 20 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $2.09B of debt and the $261M earn-out owed to AMD, net of $1.68B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $150, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.6% margin, 11% on new capital) about $416.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C09EditedManagement names non-recurring engineering services - the pre-production work on a programme not yet in volume - as a driver of both the Q3 FY2026 margin beat and the Q4 margin guidance, and does not disclose how much of the margin it is.the release does not split engineering fees from volume margin; shelf life moves to the first-quarter report
    • C10EditedThe next-generation accelerated compute programme contributes no revenue to the Q4 FY2026 outlook, on revenue-recognition timing, and management expects it to begin contributing in Q1 FY2027 and ramp over that year.the release is silent on when the accelerated-compute programme first contributes; the call was not yet on the vendor, so the claim stays a management claim and its shelf life moves to the first-quarter report
    • C12EditedQ4 FY2026 revenue was $3.858B, or $275.6M a week over the fourteen weeks, 3.4% above Q3's $266.5M a week and 11.9% above the $246.4M a week its own guidance midpoint implied, where the guide had read as a 7.5% weekly decline.the Q4 print replaced the guidance-based estimate with the reported figure
      Was

      Adjusted for that extra week, the Q4 FY2026 revenue guidance midpoint implies $246.4M a week against $266.5M in Q3 - a 7.5% decline. The ZT Systems h…

    • C13EditedThe $18.5B middle of the fiscal 2027 guide needs weekly revenue of $355.8M over 52 weeks, 29% above the fourth quarter's $275.6M; the first-quarter guide's middle of $3.95B over 13 weeks is $303.8M, 10% above, so the step is weighted to the last three quarters.re-struck on the 9 November guide and the reported fourth quarter
      Was

      Reaching the $16B management states for fiscal 2027 requires weekly revenue to rise 24.9% from the Q4 FY2026 guidance midpoint, from $246.4M to $307.…

    • C14EditedOn 9 November management guided fiscal 2027 revenue of $17.5B to $19.5B, above the '$16 billion-plus' it had stated since bringing the target forward from fiscal 2028; the middle is 27% above fiscal 2026.the guide arrived above the stated target
      Was

      Management states fiscal 2027 revenue of '$16 billion-plus' and says it is more confident than ever of it, having brought that target forward from fi…

    • C18EditedTotal debt was $2,087.5M at 2026-10-03 against $300.5M a year earlier, and cash $1,675.6M, leaving net debt of $411.9M.year-end balance sheet from the Q4 release
      Was

      Total debt rose from $300.5M at 2025-09-27 to $2,172.3M at 2026-06-27 while cash rose to $1,844.9M, leaving net debt of $327.4M.

    • C21EditedFiscal 2026 free cash flow was $541M on revenue of $14.53B, above fiscal 2025's $478M on $8.13B: operating cash flow $944M against $621M, less about $403M of net capital spending.the full-year result replaced the nine-month estimate that had it level with fiscal 2025
      Was

      Fiscal 2025 free cash flow was $478M on revenue of $8.13B, so fiscal 2026 is on course to generate no more cash than fiscal 2025 on close to twice th…

    • C28EditedAt the 9 November close of $149.64 buyers pay about 21.8 times fiscal 2026 GAAP diluted earnings of $6.85 a share, against a six-year median near 12.5 on the 6 September pack; the cash-profit comparison is not re-struck.re-struck on the fiscal 2026 filed earnings and the 6 November close
      Was

      Buyers now pay about $34.80 for each dollar of trailing yearly profit against a six-year median near $12.45, and about $16.80 for each dollar of year…

    • C45EditedAt $8.7B of enterprise value (the 9 November close of $149.64 on 55.08M diluted shares, plus $2.09B of debt, less $1.68B of cash), paying 8 times operating profit, an ordinary price for contract manufacturing, needs $1.08B of operating profit, which on the $18.5B middle of the fiscal 2027 guide is a 5.8% margin. The best full year Sanmina has filed is 5.1%, and the guide is 7.0% to 7.5% before stock pay.re-struck on the fiscal 2027 guide and the 6 November close; the price had been $11.2B of enterprise value on the $16B target
      Was

      At $11.2B of enterprise value, paying 8 times operating profit - an ordinary price for contract manufacturing - needs $1.4B of operating profit, whic…

    • C46EditedManagement says it secured orders for the next-generation accelerated compute business with both hyperscale and original equipment customers, and won further orders in Q3, without naming a customer, a volume or a term.no order, customer or volume was added in the release; shelf life moves to the first-quarter report
    • C56EditedQ4 FY2026 revenue was $3.858B, up 84% on $2.096B, and fiscal 2026 revenue $14.525B, up 79%. GAAP operating margin was 6.0% in the quarter and 4.7% for the year; non-GAAP operating margin 9.0% and 7.4%. Fiscal 2026 operating cash flow was $944M and free cash flow $541M; year-end cash $1,676M against $2,088M of debt.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C57EditedOn 9 November management guided fiscal 2027 revenue of $17.5B to $19.5B, non-GAAP operating margin of 7.0% to 7.5% and non-GAAP diluted earnings of $15.50 to $17.50, and first-quarter fiscal 2027 revenue of $3.8B to $4.1B at a 7.0% to 7.5% margin; the release does not split the accelerated-compute programme out.the business re-valued in three stages at an 8% required return, with analysts' margins put on the filed basis, after the day's review
    • C57EditedOn 9 November management guided fiscal 2027 revenue of $17.5B to $19.5B, non-GAAP operating margin of 7.0% to 7.5% and non-GAAP diluted earnings of $15.50 to $17.50, and first-quarter fiscal 2027 revenue of $3.8B to $4.1B at a 7.0% to 7.5% margin; the release does not split the accelerated-compute programme out.the business re-valued in three stages at an 8% required return, with analysts' margins put on the filed basis, after the day's review
  • SAILSailPointThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    SailPoint re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    SailPoint closed at $19.21 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $7.96.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 241% of that value, so we moved SailPoint from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.27B in fiscal 2027, $1.51B in fiscal 2028, $1.80B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $481M in the last of those years, a 26.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return SailPoint is worth about $7.26 a share against $19.21 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.17B grow 19%, 19% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -18.9% to 17.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 20.5% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 16.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $310M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $3.25, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.5% margin) about $10.32.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • RRCRange ResourcesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Range Resources re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Range Resources closed at $48.72 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $73.25.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 67% of that value, so we moved Range Resources from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C41NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.52B in fiscal 2026, $3.64B in fiscal 2027, $3.91B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.33B in the last of those years, a 33.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C42NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Range Resources is worth about $48.92 a share against $48.72 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.53B grow 2%, 6% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 34.8% to 26.8% over five years, the median of its last five filed years, below the analysts' 30.0%, because a producer's margin rides a commodity price it does not set; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $781M of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.79, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.5% margin) about $67.30.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ROKRockwell AutomationThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Rockwell Automation re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Rockwell Automation closed at $376 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $272.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 138% of that value, so we moved Rockwell Automation from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C52NewAnalysts expect revenue of $9.07B in fiscal 2026, $9.59B in fiscal 2027, $10.19B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.25B in the last of those years, a 22.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Rockwell Automation is worth about $262 a share against $376 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $8.97B grow 5%, 6% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C52), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 22.7% to 21.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 17.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.26B of debt net of $479M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $151, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.2% margin) about $330.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Rockwell Automation is worth about $262 a share against $376 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $8.97B grow 5%, 6% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C52), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 22.7% to 21.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 17.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.26B of debt net of $479M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $151, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.2% margin) about $330.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • RKTRocket CompaniesThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    RKT re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    RKT closed at $15.06 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $15.82.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 95% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect $11.11B of revenue and $0.56 a share in fiscal 2026, $10.62B of revenue and $0.65 a share in fiscal 2027, $11.68B of revenue and $0.84 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return RKT is worth about $15.82 a share against $15.06 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $24.31B grows 30%, -4% and 10% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C46, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 6.5%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 7.1%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 5.7% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $7.09, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.8% return) about $24.59.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • RDWRRadwareThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Radware re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Radware closed at $29.84 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $7.87.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 379% of that value, so we moved Radware from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $335M in fiscal 2026, $366M in fiscal 2027, $398M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $92M in the last of those years, a 23.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Radware is worth about $7.56 a share against $29.84 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $302M grow 11%, 9% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 3.8% to 5.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 8.0% of sales and a further 9.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $121M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.02, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.1% margin) about $9.66.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Radware is worth about $7.56 a share against $29.84 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $302M grow 11%, 9% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 3.8% to 5.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 8.0% of sales and a further 9.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $121M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.02, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.1% margin) about $9.66.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • QQnity ElectronicsThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Qnity re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Qnity closed at $117 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $114.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 103% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C69NewAnalysts expect revenue of $5.76B in fiscal 2026, $6.52B in fiscal 2027, $7.17B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.97B in the last of those years, a 27.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C70NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Qnity is worth about $109 a share against $117 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.49B grow 15%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C69), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.0% to 26.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 44 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $4.02B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.09, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.3% margin) about $148.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • PYPLPayPal HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    PayPal re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    PayPal closed at $59.24 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $82.92.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 71% of that value, so we moved PayPal from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $34.54B in fiscal 2026, $35.96B in fiscal 2027, $37.56B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $7.43B in the last of those years, a 19.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return PayPal is worth about $73.79 a share against $59.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $34.30B grow 4%, 4% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.0% to 16.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $13.47B of debt net of $10.28B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.92, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.3% margin) about $99.49.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return PayPal is worth about $73.79 a share against $59.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $34.30B grow 4%, 4% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.0% to 16.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $13.47B of debt net of $10.28B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.92, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.3% margin) about $99.49.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PWRQuanta ServicesThesis changed
    Valuation1→2

    Quanta re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Quanta closed at $541 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $447.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 121% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Low.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $41.29B in fiscal 2026, $48.93B in fiscal 2027, $55.76B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $5.45B in the last of those years, a 9.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Quanta is worth about $429 a share against $541 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $37.29B grow 26%, 15% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.8% to 8.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 0.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 23.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.99B of debt net of $2.32B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $192, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.3% margin) about $604.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Quanta is worth about $429 a share against $541 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $37.29B grow 26%, 15% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.8% to 8.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 0.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 23.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.99B of debt net of $2.32B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $192, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.3% margin) about $604.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PTRNPattern GroupThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Pattern re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Pattern closed at $18.27 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $23.07.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 79% of that value, so we moved Pattern from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C49NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.50B in fiscal 2026, $4.42B in fiscal 2027, $5.42B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $326M in the last of those years, a 6.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Pattern is worth about $21.21 a share against $19.43 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.26B grow 28%, 24% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.3% to 4.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $352M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.57, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.1% margin) about $29.22.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Pattern is worth about $21.21 a share against $19.43 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.26B grow 28%, 24% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.3% to 4.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $352M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.57, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.1% margin) about $29.22.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • POWLPowell IndustriesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Powell re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Powell closed at $133 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $97.37.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 137% of that value, so we moved Powell from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C37NewBefore updating for the fourth-quarter print, analysts expected revenue of $1.48B in fiscal 2027, $1.72B in fiscal 2028 and $1.96B in fiscal 2029; against fiscal 2026's actual $1.26B that is growth of about 18%, 16% and 14%.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C38NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Powell is worth about $104 a share against $151.20 at the 16 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $1.26B grow 18%, 16% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.6% after stock pay to its five-year average of 9.6% over five years, because fiscal 2026 is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 22.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; plus $861M of cash and no debt. Bear (half that growth, a 7.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $66, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.5% margin) about $132.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C38EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Powell is worth about $104 a share against $151.20 at the 16 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $1.26B grow 18%, 16% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 20.6% after stock pay to its five-year average of 9.6% over five years, because fiscal 2026 is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 22.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; plus $861M of cash and no debt. Bear (half that growth, a 7.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $66, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.5% margin) about $132.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PLTRPalantir TechnologiesThesis changed
    Valuation1→3

    Palantir re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Palantir closed at $160 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $137.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 117% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $8.49B in fiscal 2026, $13.08B in fiscal 2027, $19.20B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $11.01B in the last of those years, a 57.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palantir is worth about $109 a share against $160 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.29B grow 60%, 48% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 45.6% to 36.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.5% of sales and a further 7.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $10.56B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 29.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.12, bull (a quarter more growth, a 40.2% margin) about $205.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palantir is worth about $109 a share against $160 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.29B grow 60%, 48% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 45.6% to 36.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.5% of sales and a further 7.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $10.56B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 29.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.12, bull (a quarter more growth, a 40.2% margin) about $205.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PLMRPalomar HoldingsThesis changed

    Palomar re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Palomar closed at $156 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $121.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 128% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect $2.62B of revenue and $10.13 a share in fiscal 2026, $3.13B of revenue and $11.25 a share in fiscal 2027, $3.19B of revenue and $12.25 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Palomar is worth about $121 a share against $156 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $985M grows 30% and 6% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C64, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 25.8%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 21.3%, theirs for the last year they forecast, cut by 7% because the analysts' earnings per share for fiscal 2025 ran that far above the filed $7.17; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 17.0% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $70.32, bull (a quarter more growth, a 23.4% return) about $163.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • PENGPenguin SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Penguin Solutions re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Penguin Solutions closed at $41.83 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $80.27.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 52% of that value, so we moved Penguin Solutions from Unattractive to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.45B in fiscal 2027, $2.75B in fiscal 2028, $3.36B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $446M in the last of those years, a 13.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Penguin Solutions is worth about $67.91 a share against $41.83 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.73B grow 42%, 12% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.6% to 11.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $789M of debt net of $647M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.85, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.6% margin) about $118.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Penguin Solutions is worth about $67.91 a share against $41.83 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.73B grow 42%, 12% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.6% to 11.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $789M of debt net of $647M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.85, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.6% margin) about $118.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PAYCPaycom SoftwareThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Paycom re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Paycom closed at $237 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $346.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 69% of that value, so we moved Paycom from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.21B in fiscal 2026, $2.37B in fiscal 2027, $2.57B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.24B in the last of those years, a 48.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Paycom is worth about $333 a share against $237 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.19B grow 6% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 33.4% to 44.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.6% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $750M of debt net of $194M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 35.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $192, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.0% margin) about $421.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Paycom is worth about $333 a share against $237 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.19B grow 6% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 33.4% to 44.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.6% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $750M of debt net of $194M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 35.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $192, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.0% margin) about $421.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PATHUiPathThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    UiPath re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    UiPath closed at $13.00 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $10.04.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 129% of that value, so we moved UiPath from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.79B in fiscal 2027, $1.94B in fiscal 2028, $2.09B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $735M in the last of those years, a 35.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return UiPath is worth about $9.46 a share against $13.00 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.72B grow 8% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.9% to 14.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.6% of sales and a further 7.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.28B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.51, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.8% margin) about $11.29.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return UiPath is worth about $9.46 a share against $13.00 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.72B grow 8% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.9% to 14.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.6% of sales and a further 7.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.28B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.51, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.8% margin) about $11.29.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • PANWPalo Alto NetworksThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Palo Alto Networks re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Palo Alto Networks closed at $314 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $45.22.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 694% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C73NewAnalysts expect revenue of $14.17B in fiscal 2027, $16.19B in fiscal 2028, $18.39B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $6.16B in the last of those years, a 33.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C74NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Palo Alto Networks is worth about $41.77 a share against $314 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $11.48B grow 23%, 14% and 14% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C73), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.1% to 13.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 15.8% of sales and a further 3.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.77B of debt net of $3.07B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $20.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.3% margin) about $57.75.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • OSCROscar HealthThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Oscar Health re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Oscar Health closed at $30.65 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $44.85.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 68% of that value, so we moved Oscar Health from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C59NewAnalysts expect revenue of $18.64B in fiscal 2026, $20.86B in fiscal 2027, $24.54B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $958M in the last of those years, a 3.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oscar Health is worth about $39.06 a share against $32.14 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $17.47B grow 16%, 16% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 3.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $432M of debt net of $7.49B of cash. Bear (the same growth, since at this margin slower growth would be worth more, a 2.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.35, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.8% margin) about $57.93.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ORCLOracleThesis changed

    Microsoft is reportedly ending its rental of Oracle's AI computing capacity

    Bloomberg reports Microsoft chose not to renew a deal, begun in 2023, to rent AI computing capacity from Oracle, and has been switching it off because the Nvidia chips were too old for it. The deal's size was never disclosed. Oracle says demand stays strong, including for older chips, which it re-rented at a 20% higher price in September. Oracle shares closed up 0.74%.

    What it did to the thesisThe news moved nothing: the lapse of one old rental does not cancel the $664B of signed future revenue. Valued on its own future cash at an 8% return, the price is about half of what the business is worth, so we moved Oracle to Attractive at Low conviction.

    3 claims changed
    • C40NewAnalysts expect revenue of $90.46B in fiscal 2027, $131.43B in fiscal 2028, $181.22B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $58.74B in the last of those years, a 32.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C41NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oracle is worth about $177 a share against $116 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $71.78B grow 38%, 43% and 34% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.1% to 23.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.7% of sales and a further 2.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 119 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $125.34B of debt and $4.95B of preferred stock net of $37.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.8% margin) about $321.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C41EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Oracle is worth about $177 a share against $116 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $71.78B grow 38%, 43% and 34% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.1% to 23.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.7% of sales and a further 2.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 119 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $125.34B of debt and $4.95B of preferred stock net of $37.08B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 25.8% margin) about $321.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • OOMAOomaThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Ooma re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Ooma closed at $18.00 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $12.41.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 145% of that value, so we moved Ooma from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C58NewAnalysts expect revenue of $333M in fiscal 2027, $349M in fiscal 2028, $377M in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $63M in the last of those years, a 16.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ooma is worth about $10.86 a share against $18.00 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $307M grow 11%, 6% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 3.6% to 9.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.7% of sales and a further 2.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $46M of debt net of $18M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $7.35, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.0% margin) about $15.84.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ooma is worth about $10.86 a share against $18.00 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $307M grow 11%, 6% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 3.6% to 9.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.7% of sales and a further 2.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $46M of debt net of $18M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $7.35, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.0% margin) about $15.84.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • ONTOOnto InnovationThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Onto re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Onto closed at $173 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $207.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 84% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    13 claims changed
    • C45NewThird-quarter 2026 revenue was a record $409.7 million, up 87.8% on a year earlier and 19% on the second quarter; gross margin 54.8%, GAAP operating income $95.4 million, GAAP diluted earnings per share $0.95 and non-GAAP $2.44; cash from operations was $79 million and cash and marketable securities $1.25 billion after the 27% Rigaku purchase.the quarter's reported results, from the release
    • C46NewFor the fourth quarter of 2026 management guides revenue of $430-450 million, GAAP operating margin of 24.4%-24.8%, non-GAAP of 33.5%-34.5%, restructuring of $18-22 million and GAAP diluted earnings of $1.95-$2.07 a share.the fourth-quarter outlook in the Q3 release
    • C47NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.44B in fiscal 2027, $1.88B in fiscal 2028, $2.19B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $792M in the last of those years, a 36.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Onto is worth about $149 a share against $194 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.31B grow 34%, 20% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 15.7% to 26.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.5% of sales and a further 7.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 53 cents of capital; a 20.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $1.5B of 2031 convertible notes net of $1.25B of cash and marketable securities. Bear (half that growth, a 21.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.2% margin) about $250.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C06EditedRestructuring charges were $10.6 million in FY2023, $23.1 million in FY2024, $63.4 million in FY2025 and $42.8 million in the first nine months of 2026, $12.1 million of it in the third quarter; the fourth quarter is guided at $18-22 million, which would take FY2026 to $60.8-64.8 million.Q3 2026 release: nine-month figure and the higher fourth-quarter guide
      Was

      Restructuring charges were $10.6 million in FY2023, $23.1 million in FY2024, $63.4 million in FY2025 and $30.7 million in the first half of 2026.

    • C08EditedThird-quarter 2026 GAAP operating margin was 23.3% against the guided 21.4%-22.4%, non-GAAP 32.6% against 31.5%-32.5%, and restructuring $12.1 million against the guided $15-17 million.the print answered the guide: margin above the band and restructuring below it
      Was

      Management guides third-quarter 2026 GAAP operating margin to 21.4%-22.4% and non-GAAP to 31.5%-32.5%, with restructuring of $15-17 million.

    • C12EditedOn the 4 November cohort medians, Onto is still the cheapest of the four on sales and book value, but after the Q3 print its trailing enterprise value (with the $1.5 billion of 2031 convertible notes) to operating profit is about 43 times at the 6 November close, down from 66 and above the cohort's median of about 35; the peers' own third-quarter figures are not yet in.re-struck at the 6 November close on trailing operating income of $206M after the Q3 print; cohort medians not refreshed
      Was

      Onto is the cheapest of the four on sales and book value and the dearest on operating profit, at nearly twice the cohort's median EV/EBIT.

    • C13EditedAt the 4 November pack Onto traded 12% to 36% above its own six-year median on price to sales, price to book, EV to sales and price to earnings; the Q3 print lifted trailing sales 27% and trailing operating profit 53%, so the sales and profit ratios are lower now and are not re-struck here.Q3 print changed the denominators; the median comparisons need a fresh pack
      Was

      Onto trades 12% to 36% above its own six-year median on price to sales, price to book, EV to sales and price to earnings.

    • C17EditedManagement said backlog rose in the third quarter to more than $1.3 billion, from more than $1 billion at the end of June; the figure appears in a chief-executive quote and in no financial statement.Q3 2026 release raised the backlog figure to more than $1.3 billion
      Was

      Management said backlog exceeded $1 billion for the first time; the figure appears in a chief-executive quote and in no financial statement.

    • C35EditedAt the 9 November close of $194.04 on about 49.3M shares, plus $1.5 billion of 2031 convertible notes less $1.25 billion of cash and marketable securities, company value is about $9.8B, 48 times trailing GAAP operating income of $206M, above a cohort median near 35 struck on 4 November; at the 6 November close the same sum was about 43 times. The price does not require the 23% quarter to be a run rate only to hold the multiple: it requires it to be one.re-struck at the 6 November close after the Q3 print lifted trailing operating income to $206M
      Was

      At roughly 66 times trailing operating profit against a cohort median near 35, the price requires the reported margin to converge on the adjusted one.

    • C45EditedThird-quarter 2026 revenue was a record $409.7 million, up 87.8% on a year earlier and 19% on the second quarter; gross margin 54.8%, GAAP operating income $95.4 million, GAAP diluted earnings per share $0.95 and non-GAAP $2.44; cash from operations was $79 million and cash and marketable securities $1.25 billion after the 27% Rigaku purchase.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C46EditedFor the fourth quarter of 2026 management guides revenue of $430-450 million, GAAP operating margin of 24.4%-24.8%, non-GAAP of 33.5%-34.5%, restructuring of $18-22 million and GAAP diluted earnings of $1.95-$2.07 a share.the business re-valued in three stages at an 8% required return, with analysts' margins put on the filed basis, after the day's review
    • C46EditedFor the fourth quarter of 2026 management guides revenue of $430-450 million, GAAP operating margin of 24.4%-24.8%, non-GAAP of 33.5%-34.5%, restructuring of $18-22 million and GAAP diluted earnings of $1.95-$2.07 a share.the business re-valued in three stages at an 8% required return, with analysts' margins put on the filed basis, after the day's review
  • OKTAOktaThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Okta re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Okta closed at $169 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $43.87.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 385% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.22B in fiscal 2027, $3.54B in fiscal 2028, $3.92B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $1.04B in the last of those years, a 26.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Okta is worth about $43.36 a share against $169 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.07B grow 10%, 10% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.5% to 10.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 16.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $2.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.84, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.2% margin) about $52.29.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Okta is worth about $43.36 a share against $169 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.07B grow 10%, 10% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.5% to 10.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 16.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $2.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.84, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.2% margin) about $52.29.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • NVONovo Nordisk A/SThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Novo Nordisk re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Novo Nordisk closed at $40.31 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $63.81.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 63% of that value, so we moved Novo Nordisk from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C62NewAnalysts expect revenue of $46.01B in fiscal 2026, $46.77B in fiscal 2027, $49.58B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $20.58B in the last of those years, a 41.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Novo Nordisk is worth about $61.61 a share against $40.31 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $49.65B grow -6%, 5% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 46.2% to 38.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 2.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $20.04B of debt net of $7.33B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 31.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.80, bull (a quarter more growth, a 42.7% margin) about $78.91.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • NVECNVEThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    NVE re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    NVE closed at $75.98 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $61.31.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 124% of that value, so we moved NVE from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C45NewNo analyst publishes a revenue estimate for NVE, so the base case holds sales flat at the trailing $31M for three years and takes the higher of today's filed operating margin and its five-year average.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVE is worth about $56.83 a share against $75.98 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $31M grow 0% over the next three years (no analyst path exists, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 60.6% to 62.4% over five years, its filed margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 57 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $22M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 49.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $40.18, bull (a quarter more growth, a 68.6% margin) about $65.47.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C45NewNo analyst publishes a revenue estimate for NVE, so the base case holds sales flat at the trailing $31M for three years and takes the higher of today's filed operating margin and its five-year average.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    Nvidia's board opens a probe into its CEO's link to a suspected Chinese spy

    Nvidia's board started an independent investigation into whether chief executive Jensen Huang was the target of a foreign intelligence effort. Huang told staff he had an affair with an alleged Chinese agent and will cooperate. Shares closed about 4% lower. The New York Times also reports a Commerce Department chip inquiry was halted after Nvidia intervened; only its headline could be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the numbers moved. The risk is about one person: Huang has led Nvidia since 1993 and holds 3.58% of the shares. Until the probe reports, we keep Attractive and Medium confidence and test both on the 17 November results.

    6 claims changed
    • C59NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $306 a share against $156.14 at the 16 November close. Base case: FY2026 sales of $215.9B grow 96%, 60% and 15% over three years, the first year being nine filed months and the Q4 guide, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 66.1% to 58% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 26 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 16% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (94% then 20% then a 15% fall, a 45% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (70% and 30%, a 62% margin) about $521. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $205.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C29EditedEnterprise value is about 15.7 times trailing operating profit of $239,089M, and about 12.1 times Q3 FY2027's operating profit of $77,520M run for a year.Re-struck at the 6 November close, 20% below the 2 October price, on an enterprise value built from the balance sheet rather than the vendor's.
      Was

      Enterprise value is about 28.8 times trailing operating profit of $197,579M, and about 22.3 times Q2 FY2027's operating profit of $63,734M run for a…

    • C31EditedAt $156.14 the shares are about 17 times FY2027's expected earnings per share, 10 times FY2028's and 7 times FY2029's, and enterprise value is about 9.2 times FY2028's expected operating profit; the forecasts themselves have profit flat to falling after FY2030.Re-struck at the 6 November close.
      Was

      At $233.95 the shares are about 25 times FY2027's expected earnings per share, 15 times FY2028's and 11 times FY2029's, and enterprise value is about…

    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $306 a share against $156.14 at the 16 November close. Base case: FY2026 sales of $215.9B grow 96%, 60% and 15% over three years, the first year being nine filed months and the Q4 guide, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 66.1% to 58% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 26 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 16% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (94% then 20% then a 15% fall, a 45% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (70% and 30%, a 62% margin) about $521. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $205.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $306 a share against $156.14 at the 16 November close. Base case: FY2026 sales of $215.9B grow 96%, 60% and 15% over three years, the first year being nine filed months and the Q4 guide, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 66.1% to 58% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 26 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 16% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (94% then 20% then a 15% fall, a 45% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (70% and 30%, a 62% margin) about $521. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $205.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NVIDIA is worth about $306 a share against $156.14 at the 16 November close. Base case: FY2026 sales of $215.9B grow 96%, 60% and 15% over three years, the first year being nine filed months and the Q4 guide, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 66.1% to 58% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 26 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 16% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (94% then 20% then a 15% fall, a 45% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $79, bull (70% and 30%, a 62% margin) about $521. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $205.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • NUNu HoldingsThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Nu re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Nu closed at $12.03 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $12.26.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 98% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C71NewAnalysts expect $22.74B of revenue and $0.87 a share in fiscal 2026, $28.36B of revenue and $1.12 a share in fiscal 2027, $35.41B of revenue and $1.45 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C72NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Nu is worth about $13.18 a share against $12.32 at the 11 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $14.34B at September 2026 grows 30% and 24% over the next two years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C71, held to at most 30% a year), then 4% in the third, where the analysts' average for 2029 rests on two forecasts and falls below 2028, then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 30.5%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 30.2%, theirs for the last year they forecast, cut by 5% because the analysts' earnings per share for fiscal 2025 ran that far above the filed $0.58; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%; on 4,881.1M diluted shares. Bear (half that growth, a 24.1% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $7.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.2% return) about $17.88.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • NTNXNutanixThesis changed

    Nutanix re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Nutanix closed at $58.37 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $58.88.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 99% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.22B in fiscal 2027, $3.66B in fiscal 2028, $4.22B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $1.33B in the last of those years, a 31.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Nutanix is worth about $49.30 a share against $60.14 at the 11 November close, about 122% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.85B grow 13%, 14% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.6% to 22.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 12.5% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 9.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.35B of debt net of $2.36B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25.92, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.7% margin) about $66.82.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • NTAPNetAppThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    NetApp re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    NetApp closed at $169 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $135.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 126% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $8.19B in fiscal 2027, $8.72B in fiscal 2028, $9.34B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $2.86B in the last of those years, a 30.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NetApp is worth about $131 a share against $169 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.39B grow 13% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.0% to its five-year average of 19.6% over five years, because 25.0% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 24 cents of capital; a 22.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.49B of debt net of $3.58B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $80.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.6% margin) about $157.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return NetApp is worth about $131 a share against $169 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.39B grow 13% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.0% to its five-year average of 19.6% over five years, because 25.0% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 24 cents of capital; a 22.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.49B of debt net of $3.58B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $80.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.6% margin) about $157.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • NSITInsight EnterprisesThesis changed

    Insight re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Insight closed at $158 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $146.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 108% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $8.83B in fiscal 2026, $9.17B in fiscal 2027, $9.74B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $739M in the last of those years, a 7.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Insight is worth about $140 a share against $155.29 at the 16 November close, about 111% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $9.02B grow 1%, 6% and -5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.1% to 6.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales and a further 0.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.50B of debt net of $398M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $96.94, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.0% margin) about $202.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Insight is worth about $140 a share against $155.29 at the 16 November close, about 111% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $9.02B grow 1%, 6% and -5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.1% to 6.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales and a further 0.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.50B of debt net of $398M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $96.94, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.0% margin) about $202.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • NOWServiceNowThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    ServiceNow re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    ServiceNow closed at $102 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $46.62.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 219% of that value, so we moved ServiceNow from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C42NewAnalysts expect revenue of $16.23B in fiscal 2026, $19.24B in fiscal 2027, $22.71B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $7.18B in the last of those years, a 31.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C43NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ServiceNow is worth about $45.01 a share against $102 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $15.43B grow 20%, 18% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C42), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.7% to 15.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 15.1% of sales and a further 1.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.52B of debt net of $4.61B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $19.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.6% margin) about $65.27.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C43EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ServiceNow is worth about $45.01 a share against $102 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $15.43B grow 20%, 18% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C42), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.7% to 15.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 15.1% of sales and a further 1.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.52B of debt net of $4.61B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $19.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.6% margin) about $65.27.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • NFLXNetflixThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Netflix re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Netflix closed at $63.41 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $81.42.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 78% of that value, so we moved Netflix from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C65NewAnalysts expect revenue of $51.14B in fiscal 2026, $56.58B in fiscal 2027, $62.10B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $21.52B in the last of those years, a 34.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C66NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Netflix is worth about $78.06 a share against $60.75 at the 16 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $49.73B grow 11%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C65), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 31.3% to 33.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 16.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.13B of debt net of $8.22B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $42.64, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.9% margin) about $101.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C66EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Netflix is worth about $78.06 a share against $60.75 at the 16 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $49.73B grow 11%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C65), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 31.3% to 33.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 16.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $15.13B of debt net of $8.22B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $42.64, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.9% margin) about $101.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • NETCloudflareThesis changed

    Cloudflare re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Cloudflare closed at $269 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $52.40.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 513% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C50NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.87B in fiscal 2026, $3.69B in fiscal 2027, $4.71B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.27B in the last of those years, a 27.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C51NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cloudflare is worth about $37.32 a share against $269 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.73B grow 27%, 28% and 23% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C50), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -14.1% to 18.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 20.7% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 7.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $4.44B of debt net of $5.13B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $14.28, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.8% margin) about $57.04.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • NEENextEra EnergyThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    NextEra re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    NextEra closed at $86.95 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $85.45.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 102% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect $30.50B of revenue and $4.03 a share in fiscal 2026, $33.50B of revenue and $4.39 a share in fiscal 2027, $36.46B of revenue and $4.76 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return NextEra is worth about $85.45 a share against $86.95 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $61.50B grows 14%, 9% and 10% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C46, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 12.3%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 10.7%, theirs for the last year they forecast, cut by 11% because the analysts' earnings per share for fiscal 2025 ran that far above the filed $3.30; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 15%. Bear (half that growth, a 8.5% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $32.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.7% return) about $94.87.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • MXLMaxLinearThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    MaxLinear re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    MaxLinear closed at $49.18 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $11.62.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 423% of that value, so we moved MaxLinear from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C41NewAnalysts expect revenue of $777M in fiscal 2026, $1.38B in fiscal 2027, $1.83B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $655M in the last of those years, a 35.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C42NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MaxLinear is worth about $10.74 a share against $49.18 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $661M grow 60%, 43% and 2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -0.9% to 6.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.2% of sales and a further 15.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $164M of debt net of $81M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $4.64, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.5% margin) about $15.12.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • MUMicron TechnologyThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Micron Technology re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Micron Technology closed at $690 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $736.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 94% of that value, so we moved Micron Technology from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C54NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Micron is worth about $725 a share against $690.00 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value, counting $12.7B of customer deposits as owed, is about 4.2 times FQ4 2026 GAAP operating income annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $133.2B grow 100% in fiscal 2027 and 5% in 2028, then fall 20% in 2029 before fading toward 4% growth, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.6% to a 35% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 63 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (80% then two falls of 30%, a 25% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $332, bull (109%, 17% and flat, a 45% margin) about $1,746. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $550.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C54EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Micron is worth about $725 a share against $690.00 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value, counting $12.7B of customer deposits as owed, is about 4.2 times FQ4 2026 GAAP operating income annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $133.2B grow 100% in fiscal 2027 and 5% in 2028, then fall 20% in 2029 before fading toward 4% growth, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.6% to a 35% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 63 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (80% then two falls of 30%, a 25% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $332, bull (109%, 17% and flat, a 45% margin) about $1,746. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $550.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C54EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Micron is worth about $725 a share against $690.00 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value, counting $12.7B of customer deposits as owed, is about 4.2 times FQ4 2026 GAAP operating income annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $133.2B grow 100% in fiscal 2027 and 5% in 2028, then fall 20% in 2029 before fading toward 4% growth, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.6% to a 35% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 63 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (80% then two falls of 30%, a 25% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $332, bull (109%, 17% and flat, a 45% margin) about $1,746. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $550.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C54EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Micron is worth about $725 a share against $690.00 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value, counting $12.7B of customer deposits as owed, is about 4.2 times FQ4 2026 GAAP operating income annualised. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $133.2B grow 100% in fiscal 2027 and 5% in 2028, then fall 20% in 2029 before fading toward 4% growth, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 74.6% to a 35% normal over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 63 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (80% then two falls of 30%, a 25% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $332, bull (109%, 17% and flat, a 45% margin) about $1,746. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $550.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • MTUSMetallusThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Metallus re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Metallus closed at $16.65 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $9.12.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 183% of that value, so we moved Metallus from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C31NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.30B in fiscal 2026, $1.42B in fiscal 2027, $1.60B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $103M in the last of those years, a 6.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C32NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Metallus is worth about $9.73 a share against $16.65 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.25B grow 11% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C31), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 0.7% to 4.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.1% of sales and a further 1.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 56 cents of capital; a 24.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $99M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 4.4% margin) about $14.88.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • MSFTMicrosoftThesis changed

    Microsoft is reportedly ending its rental of Oracle's AI computing capacity

    Bloomberg reports that Microsoft chose not to renew a deal, begun in 2023, to rent AI computing capacity from Oracle, and has spent recent months switching it off. People familiar say the Nvidia chips were too old for Microsoft's needs. The size of the deal was never disclosed, and Microsoft declined to comment. Microsoft also rents from other providers and is reported to be trimming that list.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 84% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium. The news itself moved nothing.

    3 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $395.22B in fiscal 2027, $476.80B in fiscal 2028, $584.09B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $271.32B in the last of those years, a 46.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microsoft is worth about $611 a share against $531 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $346.44B grow 20%, 21% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 47.1% to 42.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.6% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 85 cents of capital; a 19.7% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $35.48B of debt net of $64.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 34.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $255, bull (a quarter more growth, a 47.1% margin) about $814.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microsoft is worth about $611 a share against $531 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $346.44B grow 20%, 21% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 47.1% to 42.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.6% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 85 cents of capital; a 19.7% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $35.48B of debt net of $64.51B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 34.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $255, bull (a quarter more growth, a 47.1% margin) about $814.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • MRVLMarvell TechnologyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Marvell Technology re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Marvell Technology closed at $141 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $401.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 35% of that value, so we moved Marvell Technology from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $12.06B in fiscal 2027, $19.58B in fiscal 2028, $31.54B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $15.84B in the last of those years, a 50.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Marvell Technology is worth about $277 a share against $141 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.45B grow 60%, 60% and 58% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.5% to 27.6% over five years, what its fiscal year to January 2026 earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 33.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $4.96B of debt net of $3.93B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.4% margin) about $542.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Marvell Technology is worth about $277 a share against $141 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.45B grow 60%, 60% and 58% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.5% to 27.6% over five years, what its fiscal year to January 2026 earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 33.6%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 31 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $4.96B of debt net of $3.93B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $61.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.4% margin) about $542.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • MRKMerck & Co.Thesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Merck re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Merck closed at $147 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $119.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 123% of that value, so we moved Merck from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C63NewAnalysts expect revenue of $67.22B in fiscal 2026, $69.42B in fiscal 2027, $73.58B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $33.97B in the last of those years, a 46.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Merck is worth about $115 a share against $147 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $67.38B grow 2%, 5% and 2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.2% to 38.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.6% of sales and a further 6.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 44 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $53.78B of debt net of $9.65B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 30.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $65.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 41.8% margin) about $138.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • MPWRMonolithic Power SystemsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive

    Monolithic Power re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Monolithic Power closed at $1,190 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $979.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 122% of that value, so we moved Monolithic Power from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.33B in fiscal 2026, $6.55B in fiscal 2027, $8.17B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.27B in the last of those years, a 40.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Monolithic Power is worth about $932 a share against $1,190 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.74B grow 58%, 31% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 29.5% to 32.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 43 cents of capital; a 22.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.09B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 25.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $376, bull (a quarter more growth, a 35.6% margin) about $1,411.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Monolithic Power is worth about $932 a share against $1,190 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.74B grow 58%, 31% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 29.5% to 32.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 43 cents of capital; a 22.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.09B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 25.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $376, bull (a quarter more growth, a 35.6% margin) about $1,411.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • MPMP MaterialsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    MP Materials re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    MP Materials closed at $35.41 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $22.74.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 156% of that value, so we moved MP Materials from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $447M in fiscal 2026, $775M in fiscal 2027, $970M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $412M in the last of those years, a 42.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MP Materials is worth about $21.20 a share against $35.41 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $399M grow 60%, 36% and 20% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -20.5% to 33.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 11.3% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 35.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 200 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $936M of debt net of $1.34B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.8% margin) about $31.62.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • MKSIMKSThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    MKS re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    MKS closed at $192 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $349.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 55% of that value, so we moved MKS from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C56NewAnalysts expect revenue of $5.08B in fiscal 2026, $6.13B in fiscal 2027, $6.76B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.85B in the last of those years, a 27.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MKS is worth about $335 a share against $192 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.77B grow 22% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to 26.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 52 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.78B of debt net of $511M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $151, bull (a quarter more growth, a 28.8% margin) about $463.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MKS is worth about $335 a share against $192 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.77B grow 22% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to 26.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 52 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.78B of debt net of $511M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $151, bull (a quarter more growth, a 28.8% margin) about $463.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • MITKMitek SystemsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Mitek re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Mitek closed at $17.24 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $21.86.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 79% of that value, so we moved Mitek from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C41NewAnalysts expect revenue of $198M in fiscal 2026, $214M in fiscal 2027, $237M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $106M in the last of those years, a 44.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C42NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Mitek is worth about $17.39 a share against $17.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $198M grow 6% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.8% to 24.4% over five years, what the last four quarters earned after stock pay and before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 30.1%, whose gap to the filed figure had been set aside twice; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $49M of debt net of $100M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.43, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.8% margin) about $21.78.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C42EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Mitek is worth about $17.39 a share against $17.24 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $198M grow 6% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.8% to 24.4% over five years, what the last four quarters earned after stock pay and before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 30.1%, whose gap to the filed figure had been set aside twice; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $49M of debt net of $100M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.43, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.8% margin) about $21.78.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • METAMeta PlatformsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Meta Platforms re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Meta Platforms closed at $610 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $720.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 85% of that value, inside our 20% cushion, so the view moves from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Low.

    4 claims changed
    • C45NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Meta is worth about $694 a share against $610.15 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value is about 19.8 times trailing operating profit of $79.38B. Base case: 2025 sales of $201.0B grow 28%, 18% and 14% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 32.9% to 34% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 81 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (8% and 5% after 2026, a 28% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $358, bull (22% and 19%, a 38% margin) about $968.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C45EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Meta is worth about $694 a share against $610.15 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value is about 19.8 times trailing operating profit of $79.38B. Base case: 2025 sales of $201.0B grow 28%, 18% and 14% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 32.9% to 34% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 81 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (8% and 5% after 2026, a 28% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $358, bull (22% and 19%, a 38% margin) about $968.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C45EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Meta is worth about $694 a share against $610.15 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value is about 19.8 times trailing operating profit of $79.38B. Base case: 2025 sales of $201.0B grow 28%, 18% and 14% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 32.9% to 34% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 81 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (8% and 5% after 2026, a 28% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $358, bull (22% and 19%, a 38% margin) about $968.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C45EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Meta is worth about $694 a share against $610.15 at the 6 November close, where enterprise value is about 19.8 times trailing operating profit of $79.38B. Base case: 2025 sales of $201.0B grow 28%, 18% and 14% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 32.9% to 34% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 81 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (8% and 5% after 2026, a 28% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $358, bull (22% and 19%, a 38% margin) about $968.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • MELIMercadoLibreThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    MercadoLibre re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    MercadoLibre closed at $1,510 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $2,075.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 73% of that value, so we moved MercadoLibre from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $41.90B in fiscal 2026, $54.08B in fiscal 2027, $67.03B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $6.49B in the last of those years, a 9.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MercadoLibre is worth about $1,966 a share against $1,510 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $38.52B grow 32%, 25% and 26% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $13.19B of debt net of $7.38B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $705, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.6% margin) about $3,104.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return MercadoLibre is worth about $1,966 a share against $1,510 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $38.52B grow 32%, 25% and 26% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $13.19B of debt net of $7.38B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $705, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.6% margin) about $3,104.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • MEDPMedpace HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Medpace re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Medpace closed at $653 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $420.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 155% of that value, so we moved Medpace from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.85B in fiscal 2026, $3.02B in fiscal 2027, $3.28B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $763M in the last of those years, a 23.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Medpace is worth about $408 a share against $653 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.84B grow 5%, 8% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.4% to 22.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 17.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $705M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $252, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.7% margin) about $506.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Medpace is worth about $408 a share against $653 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.84B grow 5%, 8% and 7% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.4% to 22.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 17.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $705M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 18.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $252, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.7% margin) about $506.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • MCHPMicrochip Technology IncorporatedThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Microchip Technology re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Microchip Technology closed at $58.35 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $48.89.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 119% of that value, so we moved Microchip Technology from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $47 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value is about 7.0 times trailing sales. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $4.71B grow 36%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 20.9% to 28% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 45 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (30%, then flat and a 5% fall, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13, bull (36%, 17% and 10%, a 33% margin) about $68. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $30.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $47 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value is about 7.0 times trailing sales. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $4.71B grow 36%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 20.9% to 28% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 45 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (30%, then flat and a 5% fall, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13, bull (36%, 17% and 10%, a 33% margin) about $68. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $30.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $47 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value is about 7.0 times trailing sales. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $4.71B grow 36%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 20.9% to 28% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 45 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (30%, then flat and a 5% fall, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13, bull (36%, 17% and 10%, a 33% margin) about $68. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $30.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Microchip is worth about $47 a share against $61.50 at the 9 November close, where company value is about 7.0 times trailing sales. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $4.71B grow 36%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 20.9% to 28% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 45 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (30%, then flat and a 5% fall, a 20% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13, bull (36%, 17% and 10%, a 33% margin) about $68. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $30.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • LYVLive Nation EntertainmentThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Live Nation re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Live Nation closed at $175 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $29.94.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 585% of that value, so we moved Live Nation from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C40NewAnalysts expect revenue of $28.12B in fiscal 2026, $30.78B in fiscal 2027, $33.67B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.35B in the last of those years, a 4.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C41NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Live Nation is worth about $33.65 a share against $175 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $27.88B grow 8%, 9% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C40), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 3.2% to 3.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.6% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $9.75B of debt net of $8.26B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 2.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.97, bull (a quarter more growth, a 3.7% margin) about $44.82.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • LSCCLattice SemiconductorThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive

    Lattice re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Lattice closed at $105 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $83.68.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 126% of that value, so we moved Lattice from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C62NewAnalysts expect revenue of $998M in fiscal 2027, $1.61B in fiscal 2028, $2.03B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $1.04B in the last of those years, a 51.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lattice is worth about $77.95 a share against $105 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $809M grow 60%, 34% and 29% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.1% to 32.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.6% of sales and a further 7.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 36 cents of capital; a 24.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $869M of debt net of $128M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $21.66, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.1% margin) about $132.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • LPGDorian LPGThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Dorian LPG re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Dorian LPG closed at $46.55 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $55.76.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 83% of that value, so we moved Dorian LPG from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $774M in fiscal 2027, $433M in fiscal 2028, $342M in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $197M in the last of those years, a 57.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Dorian LPG is worth about $51.58 a share against $46.55 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $682M grow -15%, -25% and -0% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 72.3% to its five-year average of 43.8% over five years, because 72.3% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 200 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $477M of debt net of $579M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 35.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $34.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 48.1% margin) about $79.03.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyThesis changed

    Lilly will sell Zepbound and Foundayo through Hims & Hers at self-pay prices

    Lilly and Hims & Hers agreed that people prescribed on the Hims platform can buy Zepbound from $299 a month and the pill Foundayo from $149, the same cash prices Lilly offers anyone. Hims said it has never offered copies of Lilly's drugs made by compounding pharmacies and will not. No sales or payment terms were given.

    What it did to the thesisIt adds a large online channel for cash-paying patients and one copier-friendly seller steps back. But valued in three stages the price is well above what the business is worth, so the view moves to Unattractive.

    2 claims changed
    • C71NewAnalysts expect revenue of $91.10B in fiscal 2026, $106.45B in fiscal 2027, $118.73B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $61.08B in the last of those years, a 51.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C72NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Eli Lilly is worth about $943 a share against $1,354 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $65.18B grow 40%, 17% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C71), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 61.1% to 50.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 61 cents of capital; a 19.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $42.50B of debt net of $7.27B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 40.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $433, bull (a quarter more growth, a 55.5% margin) about $1,326.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • LITELumentum HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Lumentum re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Lumentum closed at $539 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $710.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 76% of that value, so we moved Lumentum from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C58NewAnalysts expect revenue of $6.55B in fiscal 2027, $10.40B in fiscal 2028, $14.65B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $5.44B in the last of those years, a 37.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lumentum is worth about $626 a share against $596 at the 9 November close ($539 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.74B grow 60%, 54% and 41% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.5% to 30.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 110 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.76B of debt net of $1.98B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $159, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.4% margin) about $1,155.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lumentum is worth about $626 a share against $596 at the 9 November close ($539 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.74B grow 60%, 54% and 41% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.5% to 30.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 110 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.76B of debt net of $1.98B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $159, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.4% margin) about $1,155.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • LEUCentrus EnergyThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Centrus re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Centrus closed at $105 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $69.09.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 151% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $479M in fiscal 2026, $500M in fiscal 2027, $472M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $97M in the last of those years, a 20.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Centrus is worth about $67.87 a share against $105 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $454M grow 9%, -3% and 0% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -1.3% to 9.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 10.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.18B of debt net of $2.24B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $62.65, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.9% margin) about $75.50.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • LENLennarThesis changed

    Lennar re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Lennar closed at $88.74 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $77.53.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 114% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $31.43B in fiscal 2026, $31.66B in fiscal 2027, $33.04B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.09B in the last of those years, a 6.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Lennar is worth about $76.76 a share against $88.74 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $31.97B grow -1% and 3% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.3% to 5.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $60.42, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.5% margin) about $103.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • KTOSKratos Defense & Security SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Kratos re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Kratos closed at $35.10 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $9.93.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 353% of that value, so we moved Kratos from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C47NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.79B in fiscal 2026, $2.22B in fiscal 2027, $2.72B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $344M in the last of those years, a 12.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Kratos is worth about $10.09 a share against $35.10 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.65B grow 28%, 23% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 0.4% to 4.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 56 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.40B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.3% margin) about $13.30.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Kratos is worth about $10.09 a share against $35.10 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.65B grow 28%, 23% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 0.4% to 4.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 56 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.40B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 3.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $9.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.3% margin) about $13.30.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • KLICKulicke and Soffa IndustriesThesis changed

    Kulicke and Soffa re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Kulicke and Soffa closed at $64.01 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $51.83.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 123% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C62NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.15B in fiscal 2026, $1.52B in fiscal 2027, $1.59B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $451M in the last of those years, a 28.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Kulicke and Soffa is worth about $50.93 a share against $64.01 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $950M grow 49% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.2% to its five-year average of 10.0% over five years, because 13.2% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 40 cents of capital; a 19.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $517M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $30.41, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.0% margin) about $65.92.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Kulicke and Soffa is worth about $50.93 a share against $64.01 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $950M grow 49% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.2% to its five-year average of 10.0% over five years, because 13.2% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 40 cents of capital; a 19.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $517M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $30.41, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.0% margin) about $65.92.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • KLACKLAThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    KLA re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    KLA closed at $138 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $126.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 110% of that value, so we moved KLA from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C61NewAnalysts expect revenue of $18.88B in fiscal 2027, $22.66B in fiscal 2028, $26.20B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $12.44B in the last of those years, a 47.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return KLA is worth about $120 a share against $143.96 at the 16 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $14.51B grow 36%, 19% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 42.6% to its five-year average of 39.5% over five years, because 42.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 57 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.72B of debt net of $1.53B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 31.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $55.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 43.5% margin) about $170.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • JOEThe St. Joe CompanyThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    JOE re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    JOE closed at $69.97 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $33.98.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 206% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C49NewAnalysts expect revenue of $86M in fiscal 2026, $91M in fiscal 2027, $103M in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return JOE is worth about $32.68 a share against $69.97 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $543M grow -25% and 11% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.0% to 32.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $362M of debt net of $118M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 25.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $13.91, bull (a quarter more growth, a 35.2% margin) about $49.96.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • JBLJabilThesis changed

    Jabil's annual report matches our case; one customer is now 20% of sales

    Jabil's annual report shows sales of $35.95 billion, up 20.6%, a 5.8% profit margin and $1.53 billion of free cash. Its AI-driven data-centre unit was half of sales, and one unnamed customer grew from 16% to 20%. The report gives no AI sales total.

    What it did to the thesisThe news moved nothing. Valued the same day on its own future cash at an 8% return, Jabil is worth about $252 a share, so at $239 the price is fair, not cheap: the view moves from Attractive to Neutral, conviction unchanged.

    6 claims changed
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Jabil is worth about $237 a share against $239.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $35.95B grow 24%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 4.7% to 5.3% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (20% then no growth, a 4.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $144, bull (16% and 11%, a 5.8% margin) about $350. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $189.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C17EditedAt $239.09 the shares trade at 24.5 times filed fiscal 2026 diluted earnings of $9.75 against a six-year median of 15.9, 18.3 times fiscal 2026 core earnings of $13.09, and about 19.7 times core earnings less stock pay of about $0.97 a share after tax.Re-struck at the 6 November close; core earnings after stock pay added because stock pay is a cost.
      Was

      At $277.18 the shares trade at 28.4 times filed fiscal 2026 diluted earnings of $9.75 against a six-year median of 15.9, and 21.2 times fiscal 2026 c…

    • C18EditedAt the company's six-year median of 15.9 times earnings, $239.09 needs about $15.04 of earnings per share, 15% above the $13.09 reported for fiscal 2026 and 14% below the $17.55 Jabil guides for fiscal 2027.Re-struck at the 6 November close.
      Was

      At the company's six-year median of 15.9 times earnings, $277.18 needs about $17.43 of earnings per share, 33% above the $13.09 reported for fiscal 2…

    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Jabil is worth about $237 a share against $239.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $35.95B grow 24%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 4.7% to 5.3% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (20% then no growth, a 4.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $144, bull (16% and 11%, a 5.8% margin) about $350. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $189.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Jabil is worth about $237 a share against $239.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $35.95B grow 24%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 4.7% to 5.3% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (20% then no growth, a 4.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $144, bull (16% and 11%, a 5.8% margin) about $350. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $189.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Jabil is worth about $237 a share against $239.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $35.95B grow 24%, 12% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 4.7% to 5.3% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital. Bear (20% then no growth, a 4.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $144, bull (16% and 11%, a 5.8% margin) about $350. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $189.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • ISRGIntuitive SurgicalThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Intuitive Surgical re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Intuitive Surgical closed at $453 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $220.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 206% of that value, so we moved Intuitive Surgical from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C72NewAnalysts expect revenue of $11.93B in fiscal 2026, $13.35B in fiscal 2027, $14.99B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $5.62B in the last of those years, a 37.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Intuitive Surgical is worth about $213 a share against $453 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $11.58B grow 12%, 12% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 28.4% to 30.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 71 cents of capital; a 17.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $4.04B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $119, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.2% margin) about $279.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Intuitive Surgical is worth about $213 a share against $453 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $11.58B grow 12%, 12% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 28.4% to 30.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 71 cents of capital; a 17.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $4.04B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $119, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.2% margin) about $279.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • IPGPIPG PhotonicsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    IPG Photonics re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    IPG Photonics closed at $65.31 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $44.93.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 145% of that value, so we moved IPG Photonics from Attractive to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C54NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return IPG is worth about $44 a share against $65.31 at the 6 November close, where company value counting Lumibird Medical is about 1.8 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $1,004M plus Lumibird Medical's roughly $130M grow 10%, 10% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 1.9% to 12% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 98 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 23% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; the $349M Lumibird price comes out of the cash. Bear (6% then 4%, a 6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25, bull (12%, 12% and 10%, a 15% margin) about $70. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $35.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C54EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return IPG is worth about $44 a share against $65.31 at the 6 November close, where company value counting Lumibird Medical is about 1.8 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $1,004M plus Lumibird Medical's roughly $130M grow 10%, 10% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 1.9% to 12% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 98 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 23% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; the $349M Lumibird price comes out of the cash. Bear (6% then 4%, a 6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25, bull (12%, 12% and 10%, a 15% margin) about $70. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $35.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C54EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return IPG is worth about $44 a share against $65.31 at the 6 November close, where company value counting Lumibird Medical is about 1.8 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $1,004M plus Lumibird Medical's roughly $130M grow 10%, 10% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 1.9% to 12% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 98 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 23% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; the $349M Lumibird price comes out of the cash. Bear (6% then 4%, a 6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25, bull (12%, 12% and 10%, a 15% margin) about $70. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $35.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C54EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return IPG is worth about $44 a share against $65.31 at the 6 November close, where company value counting Lumibird Medical is about 1.8 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $1,004M plus Lumibird Medical's roughly $130M grow 10%, 10% and 8% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay, moves from 1.9% to 12% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 98 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 23% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; the $349M Lumibird price comes out of the cash. Bear (6% then 4%, a 6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25, bull (12%, 12% and 10%, a 15% margin) about $70. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $35.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • IOTSamsaraThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Samsara re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Samsara closed at $40.98 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $5.10.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 804% of that value, so we moved Samsara from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.04B in fiscal 2027, $2.45B in fiscal 2028, $2.93B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $890M in the last of those years, a 30.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Samsara is worth about $4.94 a share against $40.98 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.85B grow 21%, 20% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 1.0% to 5.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 17.9% of sales and a further 6.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 22 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $291M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $2.37, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.2% margin) about $7.13.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Samsara is worth about $4.94 a share against $40.98 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.85B grow 21%, 20% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 1.0% to 5.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 17.9% of sales and a further 6.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 22 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $291M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $2.37, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.2% margin) about $7.13.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • INTCIntelRefreshed

    Intel's chief executive bought $9.7 million of Intel stock after the price fell

    Intel's chief executive Lip-Bu Tan bought 150,000 shares at $64.73 on 2 November, about $9.7 million, with his own money and no pre-set plan. It is his second purchase this year. Intel's shares are about 50% below their level a month ago.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the news moved the case. An insider buying shows confidence in the price, not that foundry customers exist. Valued on its own future cash at an 8% return, the price is nearly three times what the business is worth, so we stay Unattractive.

    3 claims changed
    • C72NewAnalysts expect revenue of $61.86B in fiscal 2026, $69.47B in fiscal 2027, $84.68B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $21.47B in the last of those years, a 25.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Intel is worth about $17.57 a share against $56.28 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $59.89B grow 13%, 19% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 2.9% to 18.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.1% of sales and a further 2.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 192 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $50.13B of debt net of $54.01B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.58, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.3% margin) about $33.42.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Intel is worth about $17.57 a share against $56.28 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $59.89B grow 13%, 19% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 2.9% to 18.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.1% of sales and a further 2.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 192 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $50.13B of debt net of $54.01B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.58, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.3% margin) about $33.42.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • ILMNIlluminaThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Illumina re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Illumina closed at $213 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $100.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 213% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.63B in fiscal 2026, $4.95B in fiscal 2027, $5.32B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.28B in the last of those years, a 24.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Illumina is worth about $85.90 a share against $213 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.54B grow 7%, 7% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.2% to 18.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.79B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $45.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.8% margin) about $112.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Illumina is worth about $85.90 a share against $213 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.54B grow 7%, 7% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 21.2% to 18.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.79B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $45.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.8% margin) about $112.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • IESCIES HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    IES re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    IES closed at $158 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $162.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 98% of that value, so we moved IES from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.24B in fiscal 2026, $6.28B in fiscal 2027, $7.46B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $892M in the last of those years, a 12.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return IES is worth about $160 a share against $158 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.99B grow 43%, 26% and -18% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C64), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.4% to 11.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $388M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $77.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.8% margin) about $260.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ICHRIchor HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Ichor Holdings re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Ichor Holdings closed at $30.97 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $32.09.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 97% of that value, so we moved Ichor Holdings from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C30NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $33.65 at the 16 November close, about 112% of it, where enterprise value is about 1.08 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $947.7M grow 31%, 25% and 12% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 1.7% to 7% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 31 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever, the return on new capital gliding to 8%. Bear (flat in 2027 and 2028, a 4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.66, bull (32% and 15%, a 9% margin) about $55.07. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $18.95.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C30EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $33.65 at the 16 November close, about 112% of it, where enterprise value is about 1.08 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $947.7M grow 31%, 25% and 12% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 1.7% to 7% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 31 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever, the return on new capital gliding to 8%. Bear (flat in 2027 and 2028, a 4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.66, bull (32% and 15%, a 9% margin) about $55.07. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $18.95.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C30EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $33.65 at the 16 November close, about 112% of it, where enterprise value is about 1.08 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $947.7M grow 31%, 25% and 12% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 1.7% to 7% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 31 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever, the return on new capital gliding to 8%. Bear (flat in 2027 and 2028, a 4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.66, bull (32% and 15%, a 9% margin) about $55.07. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $18.95.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C30EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ichor is worth about $30.07 a share against $33.65 at the 16 November close, about 112% of it, where enterprise value is about 1.08 times trailing sales. Base case: 2025 sales of $947.7M grow 31%, 25% and 12% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and amortisation, moves from 1.7% to 7% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 31 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever, the return on new capital gliding to 8%. Bear (flat in 2027 and 2028, a 4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.66, bull (32% and 15%, a 9% margin) about $55.07. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $18.95.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • IBKRInteractive Brokers GroupThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Interactive Brokers re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Interactive Brokers closed at $75.82 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $55.92.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 136% of that value, so we moved Interactive Brokers from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect $7.45B of revenue and $2.70 a share in fiscal 2026, $8.89B of revenue and $3.30 a share in fiscal 2027, $10.20B of revenue and $3.84 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Interactive Brokers is worth about $55.92 a share against $75.82 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $6.21B (the public's share of an Up-C) grows 19%, 16% and 12% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C39, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 19.7%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 18.1%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 15%. Bear (half that growth, a 14.4% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $22.76, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.9% return) about $64.84.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • HXLHexcelThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Hexcel re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Hexcel closed at $80.40 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $42.64.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 189% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C61NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.08B in fiscal 2026, $2.28B in fiscal 2027, $2.52B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $399M in the last of those years, a 15.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hexcel is worth about $39.50 a share against $80.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.02B grow 10%, 10% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.2% to 14.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 103 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $935M of debt net of $78M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $18.32, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.4% margin) about $53.45.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hexcel is worth about $39.50 a share against $80.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.02B grow 10%, 10% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.2% to 14.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 103 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $935M of debt net of $78M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $18.32, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.4% margin) about $53.45.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • HSAIHesai GroupThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Hesai re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Hesai closed at $14.33 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $9.22.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 155% of that value, so we moved Hesai from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C72NewAnalysts expect revenue of $614M in fiscal 2026, $852M in fiscal 2027, $1.13B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $231M in the last of those years, a 20.4% margin before stock pay. Read again on 10 November before any revision for the Q3 results.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hesai is worth about $8.34 a share against $14.31 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $539M grow 44%, 36% and 25% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72, not yet revised for the September-quarter results, which put 2026 about 9% under it, so the path is generous), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 4.6% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 62 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $145M of debt net of $1,043M of cash, on 156.9M shares. Bear (half that growth, a 3.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $6.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.0% margin) about $10.40.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • HPQHPThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    HP re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    HP closed at $28.46 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $38.84.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 73% of that value, so we moved HP from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C42NewAnalysts expect revenue of $59.89B in fiscal 2026, $60.93B in fiscal 2027, $60.24B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.99B in the last of those years, a 6.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C43NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return HP is worth about $37.87 a share against $28.46 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $59.16B grow 2%, -0% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C42), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 5.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $9.16B of debt net of $4.17B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $27.62, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.4% margin) about $55.39.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C43EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return HP is worth about $37.87 a share against $28.46 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $59.16B grow 2%, -0% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C42), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 5.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $9.16B of debt net of $4.17B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $27.62, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.4% margin) about $55.39.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • HPEHewlett Packard Enterprise CompanyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Hewlett Packard Enterprise re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Hewlett Packard Enterprise closed at $44.77 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $59.50.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 75% of that value, so we moved Hewlett Packard Enterprise from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $46.60B in fiscal 2026, $54.80B in fiscal 2027, $59.41B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $10.41B in the last of those years, a 17.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hewlett Packard Enterprise is worth about $50.82 a share against $44.77 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $41.87B grow 26%, 11% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.2% to 13.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $20.24B of debt net of $6.22B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 10.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 14.8% margin) about $80.95.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hewlett Packard Enterprise is worth about $50.82 a share against $44.77 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $41.87B grow 26%, 11% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.2% to 13.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $20.24B of debt net of $6.22B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 10.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $28.49, bull (a quarter more growth, a 14.8% margin) about $80.95.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • HOODRobinhood MarketsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Robinhood re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Robinhood closed at $80.91 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $42.40.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 191% of that value, so we moved Robinhood from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C52NewAnalysts expect $5.32B of revenue and $2.13 a share in fiscal 2026, $6.85B of revenue and $2.97 a share in fiscal 2027, $8.01B of revenue and $3.55 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Robinhood is worth about $42.40 a share against $80.91 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $10.00B grows 26%, 20% and 20% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C52, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 19.4%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 17.7%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 14.2% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $18.65, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.5% return) about $67.48.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • HIPOHippo HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Hippo re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Hippo closed at $34.89 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $20.90.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 167% of that value, so we moved Hippo from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C34NewAnalysts expect $588M of revenue and $1.35 a share in fiscal 2026, $763M of revenue and $1.94 a share in fiscal 2027, $930M of revenue and $3.40 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C35NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Hippo is worth about $20.90 a share against $34.89 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $469M grows 30% and 24% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C34, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 7.8%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 9.8%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 8%. Bear (half that growth, a 7.9% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $17.10, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.8% return) about $48.24.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • HASHasbroThesis changed

    Hasbro re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Hasbro closed at $119 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $104.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 115% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C47NewAnalysts expect revenue of $5.17B in fiscal 2026, $5.59B in fiscal 2027, $5.72B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.49B in the last of those years, a 26.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hasbro is worth about $93.53 a share against $119 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.18B grow 6%, 4% and 0% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.8% to 24.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.51B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.7% margin) about $116.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Hasbro is worth about $93.53 a share against $119 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.18B grow 6%, 4% and 0% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.8% to 24.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.51B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $53.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.7% margin) about $116.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • GWREGuidewire SoftwareThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Guidewire re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Guidewire closed at $161 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $85.89.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 188% of that value, so we moved Guidewire from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.72B in fiscal 2027, $1.99B in fiscal 2028, $2.29B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $807M in the last of those years, a 35.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Guidewire is worth about $76.18 a share against $161 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.48B grow 16%, 16% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.2% to 17.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 12.3% of sales and a further 5.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $678M of debt net of $753M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $34.16, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.1% margin) about $97.10.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Guidewire is worth about $76.18 a share against $161 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.48B grow 16%, 16% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.2% to 17.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 12.3% of sales and a further 5.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $678M of debt net of $753M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $34.16, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.1% margin) about $97.10.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • GSThe Goldman Sachs GroupThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Goldman Sachs re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Goldman Sachs closed at $866 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $953.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 91% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C53NewAnalysts expect $73.58B of revenue and $71.35 a share in fiscal 2026, $74.39B of revenue and $74.40 a share in fiscal 2027, $76.35B of revenue and $79.98 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C54NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Goldman Sachs is worth about $953 a share against $866 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $110.15B after preferred stock grows 6%, 2% and 5% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C53, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 19.5%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 19.2%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 15.4% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $594, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.1% return) about $1,228.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • GRABGrab Holdings LimitedThesis changed

    Grab re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Grab closed at $3.41 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $4.26.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 80% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.20B in fiscal 2026, $5.19B in fiscal 2027, $6.13B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.30B in the last of those years, a 21.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Grab is worth about $4.15 a share against $3.24 at the 12 November close, about 78% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $3.97B grow 24%, 19% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.5% to 18.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.07B of debt net of $5.66B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $2.48, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.7% margin) about $5.36.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • GNRCGenerac HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    Generac re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Generac closed at $177 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $195.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 91% of that value, so we moved Generac from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C66NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Generac is worth about $189 a share against $176.78 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 13.0 times 2026 guided adjusted EBITDA after stock pay. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.21B grow 16% in 2026 and 30% in 2027 to analysts' figures, then 12% in 2028, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and acquisition amortisation, moves from 10.4% to 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 42 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% in 2027, flat in 2028, an 11% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $76, bull (38% and 20%, a 16% margin) about $307. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $151.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C66EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Generac is worth about $189 a share against $176.78 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 13.0 times 2026 guided adjusted EBITDA after stock pay. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.21B grow 16% in 2026 and 30% in 2027 to analysts' figures, then 12% in 2028, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and acquisition amortisation, moves from 10.4% to 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 42 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% in 2027, flat in 2028, an 11% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $76, bull (38% and 20%, a 16% margin) about $307. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $151.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C66EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Generac is worth about $189 a share against $176.78 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 13.0 times 2026 guided adjusted EBITDA after stock pay. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.21B grow 16% in 2026 and 30% in 2027 to analysts' figures, then 12% in 2028, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and acquisition amortisation, moves from 10.4% to 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 42 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% in 2027, flat in 2028, an 11% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $76, bull (38% and 20%, a 16% margin) about $307. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $151.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C66EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Generac is worth about $189 a share against $176.78 at the 6 November close, where company value is about 13.0 times 2026 guided adjusted EBITDA after stock pay. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.21B grow 16% in 2026 and 30% in 2027 to analysts' figures, then 12% in 2028, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the GAAP operating margin, after stock pay and acquisition amortisation, moves from 10.4% to 14% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 42 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% in 2027, flat in 2028, an 11% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $76, bull (38% and 20%, a 16% margin) about $307. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $151.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • GLWCorningThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Corning re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Corning closed at $106 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $108.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 98% of that value, so we moved Corning from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C61NewAnalysts expect revenue of $19.41B in fiscal 2026, $23.34B in fiscal 2027, $28.31B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $7.77B in the last of those years, a 27.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Corning is worth about $106 a share against $106 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $17.72B grow 26%, 21% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.5% to 22.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.1% of sales and a further 3.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 111 cents of capital; a 16.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $8.20B of debt net of $2.54B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $42.28, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.4% margin) about $158.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Corning is worth about $106 a share against $106 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $17.72B grow 26%, 21% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.5% to 22.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.1% of sales and a further 3.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 111 cents of capital; a 16.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $8.20B of debt net of $2.54B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $42.28, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.4% margin) about $158.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • GHMGrahamThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Graham re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Graham closed at $78.02 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $49.90.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 156% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $291M in fiscal 2027, $323M in fiscal 2028, $352M in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $38M in the last of those years, a 10.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Graham is worth about $48.48 a share against $78.02 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $265M grow 16% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.0% to 9.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 22 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $71M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.20, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.8% margin) about $60.75.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Graham is worth about $48.48 a share against $78.02 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $265M grow 16% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.0% to 9.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 22 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $71M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.20, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.8% margin) about $60.75.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • GEVGE VernovaThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive

    GE Vernova re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    GE Vernova closed at $774 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $602.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 129% of that value, so we moved GE Vernova from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C78NewAnalysts expect revenue of $46.94B in fiscal 2026, $53.57B in fiscal 2027, $61.99B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $11.48B in the last of those years, a 18.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C79NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GE Vernova is worth about $547 a share against $774 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $44.04B grow 18%, 15% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C78), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.4% to 17.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 1.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.83B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $257, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.2% margin) about $770.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C79EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GE Vernova is worth about $547 a share against $774 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $44.04B grow 18%, 15% and 15% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C78), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.4% to 17.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 1.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.83B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $257, bull (a quarter more growth, a 19.2% margin) about $770.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • GEOThe GEO GroupThesis changed

    GEO re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    GEO closed at $27.80 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $29.67.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 94% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C60NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.99B in fiscal 2026, $3.35B in fiscal 2027, $3.60B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $671M in the last of those years, an 18.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C61NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GEO is worth about $35.62 a share against $31.94 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.91B grow 12% and 9% over the next two years (the analysts' path, C60), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.0% to 14.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales and a further 3.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 83 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.53B of debt net of $216M of cash. Bear (half that growth, an 11.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.5% margin) about $48.06.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GEO is worth about $35.62 a share against $31.94 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.91B grow 12% and 9% over the next two years (the analysts' path, C60), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.0% to 14.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales and a further 3.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 83 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.53B of debt net of $216M of cash. Bear (half that growth, an 11.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.5% margin) about $48.06.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • GEGE AerospaceThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    GE Aerospace re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    GE Aerospace closed at $323 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $202.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 160% of that value, so we moved GE Aerospace from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $50.69B in fiscal 2026, $56.64B in fiscal 2027, $61.89B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $14.94B in the last of those years, a 24.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GE Aerospace is worth about $198 a share against $323 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $52.58B grow 5%, 10% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 19.2% to 22.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 2.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $19.33B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 17.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $97.38, bull (a quarter more growth, a 24.2% margin) about $237.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • GDDYGoDaddyThesis changed

    GoDaddy re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    GoDaddy closed at $114 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $146.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 78% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    5 claims changed
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C26EditedAt $114.38 GoDaddy's 126,647,704 shares are worth about $14.49B, 8.3 times owner cash of $1,743.8M over the four quarters to September 2026 and 10.0 times after stock pay; at a 9% yearly return that price is paid back by owner cash after stock pay falling about 1% a year forever.Re-struck at the 6 November close on owner cash to September 2026.
      Was

      At $104.35 GoDaddy's 126,647,704 shares are worth about $13.22B, 7.8 times owner cash of $1,702.9M and 9.4 times after stock pay; at a 9% yearly retu…

    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return GoDaddy is worth about $141 a share against $113.13 at the 10 November close, about 80% of it. Base case: 2025 sales of $4.95B grow 6%, 5% and 4% over three years, then 4% a year; the official operating margin moves from 25.7% to 27% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 25 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate, paid in full; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.84B of debt net of $1.12B of cash. Bear (2% after 2026, a 23% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $92, bull (7% and 6%, a 30% margin) about $183.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • FTNTFortinetThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Fortinet re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Fortinet closed at $119 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $81.82.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 145% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $8.17B in fiscal 2026, $9.10B in fiscal 2027, $10.11B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.69B in the last of those years, a 36.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fortinet is worth about $78.47 a share against $119 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.88B grow 12%, 11% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 33.0% to 32.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 18.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $497M of debt net of $3.75B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.04, bull (a quarter more growth, a 35.8% margin) about $102.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fortinet is worth about $78.47 a share against $119 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $7.88B grow 12%, 11% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 33.0% to 32.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 3.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 18.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $497M of debt net of $3.75B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.04, bull (a quarter more growth, a 35.8% margin) about $102.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • FTAIFTAI AviationThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    FTAI re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    FTAI closed at $180 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $288.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 63% of that value, so we moved FTAI from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C80NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.85B in fiscal 2026, $6.54B in fiscal 2027, $8.01B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.11B in the last of those years, a 26.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C81NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FTAI is worth about $279 a share against $180 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.42B grow 60%, 33% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C80, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 24.7% to 25.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.8% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 123 cents of capital; a 15.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.46B of debt net of $386M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $82.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 28.2% margin) about $465.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • FSLRFirst SolarThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    First Solar re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    First Solar closed at $201 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $137.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 147% of that value, so we moved First Solar from Attractive to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return First Solar is worth about $139 a share against $162.45 at the 16 November close, where enterprise value is about 6.0 times guided 2026 adjusted EBITDA. The module business is valued before the Section 45X credit, and the roughly $8B of credit still to come is added beside it. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.22B fall 9% in 2026, then grow 5% a year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin before the credit moves from about minus 3% to 10% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about $1.30 of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (a 5% fall then flat, a 3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $95, bull (12% and 10% growth, an 18% margin) about $215. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $118.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return First Solar is worth about $139 a share against $162.45 at the 16 November close, where enterprise value is about 6.0 times guided 2026 adjusted EBITDA. The module business is valued before the Section 45X credit, and the roughly $8B of credit still to come is added beside it. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.22B fall 9% in 2026, then grow 5% a year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin before the credit moves from about minus 3% to 10% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about $1.30 of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (a 5% fall then flat, a 3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $95, bull (12% and 10% growth, an 18% margin) about $215. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $118.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return First Solar is worth about $139 a share against $162.45 at the 16 November close, where enterprise value is about 6.0 times guided 2026 adjusted EBITDA. The module business is valued before the Section 45X credit, and the roughly $8B of credit still to come is added beside it. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.22B fall 9% in 2026, then grow 5% a year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin before the credit moves from about minus 3% to 10% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about $1.30 of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (a 5% fall then flat, a 3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $95, bull (12% and 10% growth, an 18% margin) about $215. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $118.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return First Solar is worth about $139 a share against $162.45 at the 16 November close, where enterprise value is about 6.0 times guided 2026 adjusted EBITDA. The module business is valued before the Section 45X credit, and the roughly $8B of credit still to come is added beside it. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.22B fall 9% in 2026, then grow 5% a year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin before the credit moves from about minus 3% to 10% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about $1.30 of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (a 5% fall then flat, a 3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $95, bull (12% and 10% growth, an 18% margin) about $215. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $118.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsThesis changed

    Forgent Power Solutions re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Forgent Power Solutions closed at $19.48 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $28.58.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 68% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    5 claims changed
    • C35NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C20EditedAt $20.57 the company value is about $6.66B, about 10.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 15.0 times the $1.37 adjusted EPS midpoint. Counting the $483.0M tax receivable liability as debt adds about three-quarters of a turn. Taking off stock pay at the September quarter's $13.9M a quarter, about $55.5M a year, it is about 12.0 times.Re-struck at the 6 November close, 22% below the 22 October close.
      Was

      At $24.92 the company value is about $8.09B, about 13.5 times the $600M midpoint of FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 18.7 times the…

    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C35EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Forgent is worth about $27.66 a share against $20.57 at the 16 November close (about 74% of it). Base case: FY26 sales of $1.42B grow 80%, the raised guide's midpoint, then 25% and 15%, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 12.8% to 18% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 21% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less about $597.0M of term loan and the $483.0M tax receivable payable, plus $199.9M of cash, over 304.4M shares. Bear (FY27 a little under the guide at 72% and no growth after, the margin back at 13%) about $7.30; bull (34% and 30% after FY27, a 21% margin) about $55.40.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • FNFabrinetThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Fabrinet re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Fabrinet closed at $327 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $471.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 69% of that value, so we moved Fabrinet from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C63NewAnalysts expect revenue of $6.59B in fiscal 2027, $7.87B in fiscal 2028, $9.72B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $1.15B in the last of those years, a 11.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fabrinet is worth about $454 a share against $366 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.14B grow 34%, 20% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.0% to 10.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 1.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 17.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $75M of debt net of $756M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $202, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.2% margin) about $674.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Fabrinet is worth about $454 a share against $366 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.14B grow 34%, 20% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 10.0% to 10.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales and a further 1.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 17.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $75M of debt net of $756M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $202, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.2% margin) about $674.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • FLYWFlywireThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Flywire re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Flywire closed at $21.57 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $8.97.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 240% of that value, so we moved Flywire from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $773M in fiscal 2026, $890M in fiscal 2027, $1.02B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $146M in the last of those years, a 14.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flywire is worth about $8.76 a share against $21.57 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $764M grow 12%, 15% and 36% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.8% to 5.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 9.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $410M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $5.42, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.5% margin) about $12.26.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flywire is worth about $8.76 a share against $21.57 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $764M grow 12%, 15% and 36% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 7.8% to 5.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 9.2% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $410M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $5.42, bull (a quarter more growth, a 5.5% margin) about $12.26.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • FLOCFlowco HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Flowco re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Flowco closed at $20.06 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $25.82.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 78% of that value, so we moved Flowco from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C55NewAnalysts expect revenue of $951M in fiscal 2026, $1.08B in fiscal 2027, $1.13B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $234M in the last of those years, a 20.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C56NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Flowco is worth about $25.72 a share against $20.67 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $901M grow 16%, 7% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.6% to 19.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 128 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $363M of debt net of $138M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.00, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.3% margin) about $32.61.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • FIXComfort Systems USAThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Comfort Systems re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Comfort Systems closed at $1,018 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $1,670.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 61% of that value, so we moved Comfort Systems from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    5 claims changed
    • C43NewAnalysts expect revenue of $13.72B in fiscal 2026, $17.37B in fiscal 2027, $20.16B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.42B in the last of those years, a 17.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C44NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Comfort Systems is worth about $1,648 a share against $1,018 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $12.54B grow 30% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.7% to 16.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 4 cents of capital; a 22.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $50M of debt net of $2.16B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $811, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.3% margin) about $2,263.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C18EditedAt $1,017.50, the 6 November close, Comfort Systems' enterprise value (market value of about $35.8B less net cash of about $2.1B) is about $33.7B: 16.1 times trailing operating profit of $2,095M to 30 September, against a filed-peer median of 17.6 as of the 25 September pack (EMCOR 17.6, MYR Group 20.2, Limbach 16.8, not refreshed since), so it now trades below the median where it was the dearest of the four. It trades at 21.9 times trailing earnings against its own six-year prior median of 23.9, and 2.7 times sales against 1.29. At 10.7%, the operating margin of 2024, the same enterprise value would be 25 times operating profit on trailing sales of $12.5B.Re-struck at the 6 November close ($1,017.50) on September-quarter trailing profit, after a 39% fall from the 25 September close
      Was

      At a reference price of $1,658.91, the close of September 25, 2026, Comfort Systems trades at 30.8 times trailing enterprise value to operating profi…

    • C20EditedAs of the 6 November 2026 close Comfort Systems traded at $1,017.50, 50.8% below its 252-session closing high of $2,066.51 and 16.1% above its 252-session closing low of $876.19. Returns are +3.0% over 252 sessions, -45.1% over 120, -41.1% over 60, -40.7% over 20 and -17.5% over 5; the shares fell from $1,285.13 on 3 November to $964.94 on 5 November. No company news explains the fall in the sources read.Re-struck at the 6 November close
      Was

      As of the research pack's close of September 25, 2026 Comfort Systems traded at $1,658.91, 20.01% below its 252-day high of $2,073.99 and 119.14% abo…

    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Comfort Systems is worth about $1,648 a share against $1,018 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $12.54B grow 30% and 19% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.7% to 16.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 4 cents of capital; a 22.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $50M of debt net of $2.16B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $811, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.3% margin) about $2,263.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • FIVNFive9Thesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Five9 re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Five9 closed at $28.12 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $35.92.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 78% of that value, so we moved Five9 from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C43NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.26B in fiscal 2026, $1.38B in fiscal 2027, $1.53B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $425M in the last of those years, a 27.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C44NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $22.22 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.24B grow 9%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.8% of sales and a further 8.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $738M of debt net of $698M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $11.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $28.90.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Five9 is worth about $22.22 a share against $28.12 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.24B grow 9%, 10% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.4% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.8% of sales and a further 8.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $738M of debt net of $698M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $11.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $28.90.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • FIGRFigure Technology SolutionsThesis changed

    Figure Technology Solutions re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Figure Technology Solutions closed at $22.73 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $19.96.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 114% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect $886M of revenue and $1.15 a share in fiscal 2026, $1.17B of revenue and $1.51 a share in fiscal 2027, $1.40B of revenue and $1.87 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Figure Technology Solutions is worth about $18.40 a share against $24.19 at the 11 November close (about 131% of it). Base case: shareholders' equity of $1.52B at 30 September 2026 earns 14.7%, the first nine months' pretax profit of $223.3M annualised and taxed at 25%, and grows only by what it earns, 14.7% a year, since Figure pays no dividend, then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. The 225.1M shares are all three classes, which share earnings equally. Bear (half that growth, a 10% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $8.48, bull (18% growth and return, new equity earning 15%) about $27.67.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • FICOFair IsaacThesis changed

    FICO re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    FICO closed at $705 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $645.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 109% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Low.

    3 claims changed
    • C59NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.62B in fiscal 2027, $2.74B in fiscal 2028, $3.01B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $1.57B in the last of those years, a 52.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FICO is worth about $610 a share against $730.66 at the 10 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.53B grow 4%, 5% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 49.9% to 45.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.26B of debt net of $218M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 36.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $270, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.5% margin) about $826.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FICO is worth about $610 a share against $730.66 at the 10 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.53B grow 4%, 5% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 49.9% to 45.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.26B of debt net of $218M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 36.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $270, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.5% margin) about $826.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • EXTRExtreme NetworksThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Extreme Networks re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Extreme Networks closed at $24.03 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $12.68.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 190% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C49NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.41B in fiscal 2027, $1.54B in fiscal 2028, $1.72B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $341M in the last of those years, a 19.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Extreme Networks is worth about $12.10 a share against $24.03 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.31B grow 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.7% to 9.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.7% of sales and a further 4.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $200M of debt net of $245M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.0% margin) about $17.33.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Extreme Networks is worth about $12.10 a share against $24.03 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.31B grow 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.7% to 9.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.7% of sales and a further 4.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $200M of debt net of $245M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.0% margin) about $17.33.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • EXEExpand EnergyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    Expand Energy re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Expand Energy closed at $84.60 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $129.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 66% of that value, so we moved Expand Energy from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $13.42B in fiscal 2026, $12.76B in fiscal 2027, $13.48B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.76B in the last of those years, a 20.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Expand Energy is worth about $103 a share against $84.60 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $13.91B grow -7%, 3% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.7% to 20.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 196 cents of capital; a 20.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $4.63B of debt net of $118M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $74.48, bull (a quarter more growth, a 22.2% margin) about $149.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ETNEatonThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive

    Eaton re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Eaton closed at $342 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $265.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 129% of that value, so we moved Eaton from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $33.61B in fiscal 2026, $37.53B in fiscal 2027, $41.42B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $9.19B in the last of those years, a 22.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Eaton is worth about $253 a share against $342 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $31.98B grow 14%, 11% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.3% to 19.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 2.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 20.6% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $20.11B of debt net of $818M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $116, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.3% margin) about $345.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ESIElement SolutionsThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Element Solutions re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Element Solutions closed at $31.35 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $27.51.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 114% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C63NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.77B in fiscal 2026, $4.10B in fiscal 2027, $4.29B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $764M in the last of those years, a 17.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Element Solutions is worth about $26.54 a share against $31.75 at the 16 November close ($32.96 on 9 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.49B grow 15% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.7% to 15.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 33 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.08B of debt net of $225M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.0% margin) about $35.46.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Element Solutions is worth about $26.54 a share against $31.75 at the 16 November close ($32.96 on 9 November). Base case: trailing sales of $3.49B grow 15% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C63), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 11.7% to 15.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.4% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 33 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.08B of debt net of $225M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.56, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.0% margin) about $35.46.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • EQTEQTThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    EQT re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    EQT closed at $49.40 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $138.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 36% of that value, so we moved EQT from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C36NewAnalysts expect revenue of $8.98B in fiscal 2026, $10.83B in fiscal 2027, $12.92B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $6.19B in the last of those years, a 47.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C37NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EQT is worth about $41.01 a share against $49.40 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $9.35B grow 10%, 20% and 13% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C36), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 41.8% to 33.5% over five years, the median of its last five filed years, below the analysts' 47.0%, because a producer's margin rides a commodity price it does not set; each added dollar of sales needs 385 cents of capital; a 21.7% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; less $5.55B of debt net of $79M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 26.8% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.45, bull (a quarter more growth, a 36.8% margin) about $72.00.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • EOSEEos Energy EnterprisesThesis changed

    Eos Energy re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Eos Energy closed at $1.74 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $0.35.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 497% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C52NewAnalysts expect revenue of $305M in fiscal 2026, $572M in fiscal 2027, $1.06B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $120M in the last of those years, a 11.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Eos Energy is worth about $0.36 a share against $1.74 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $266M grow 60%, 60% and 38% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C52, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -121.5% to 6.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 9.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 98 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $656M of debt net of $271M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $0.17, bull (a quarter more growth, a 7.1% margin) about $0.63.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ENTGEntegrisThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Entegris re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Entegris closed at $128 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $109.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 118% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C59NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.77B in fiscal 2026, $4.34B in fiscal 2027, $4.83B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.41B in the last of those years, a 29.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Entegris is worth about $105 a share against $140.06 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.52B grow 19%, 12% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.2% to 27.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.1% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 76 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.26B of debt net of $356M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $46.90, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.9% margin) about $145.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ENSEnerSysThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    EnerSys re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    EnerSys closed at $147 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $119.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 123% of that value, so we moved EnerSys from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C43NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.90B in fiscal 2027, $4.09B in fiscal 2028, $4.25B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $711M in the last of those years, a 16.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C44NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EnerSys is worth about $116 a share against $151.33 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.79B grow 4% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.6% to its five-year average of 9.5% over five years, because 13.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 40 cents of capital; a 15.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $815M of debt net of $276M of cash, on 36.96M shares. Bear (half that growth, a 7.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $87.44, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.5% margin) about $158.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C44EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EnerSys is worth about $116 a share against $151.33 at the 10 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.79B grow 4% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.6% to its five-year average of 9.5% over five years, because 13.6% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 40 cents of capital; a 15.4% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $815M of debt net of $276M of cash, on 36.96M shares. Bear (half that growth, a 7.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $87.44, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.5% margin) about $158.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • EMEEMCOR GroupThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral

    EMCOR's profit margin is a record, and its rivals fell with it

    EMCOR earned 10.4 cents of operating profit on each dollar of sales over the last year, a record. Since late September its shares fell 20% and its closest rivals fell 10% to 51%, so it no longer looks cheap beside them.

    What it did to the thesisThe view moves from Attractive to Neutral. Valued on growth that slows over ten years and a margin a little below today's, it is worth about $728 a share against $608: fair, not cheap, inside our 20% cushion. Conviction stays Medium.

    6 claims changed
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $739 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $19.84bn grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 10.4% to a normal 9.0% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 1 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (6% growth, the 2021-2025 average margin of 7.35%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $446, bull (18%, 10.0%) about $1,013. At the base case's 9.0% margin a normal year's operating profit is about $1.79bn, and company value of about $26.1bn is about 14.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $548.the normal-year reading added when the contractor theme was re-reviewed on one rule
    • C35EditedAt $608.45 on 6 November 2026, with $774.8m of cash and no borrowings, EMCOR's company value was about $26.1bn, 12.6 times the last four quarters' GAAP operating profit of $2,070.7m. The filed-rival median of 23.2 times was struck at 25 September prices; from then to 6 November Everus fell 34.5%, IES Holdings 51.1%, Comfort Systems 38.7% and MYR Group 10.1% against EMCOR's 20.2%, so carried on price the rivals sit at roughly 12 to 19 times and their median near 15.Re-struck at the 6 November close; the rivals' 23.2 median was a 25 September reading and is carried to the same close, near 15.
      Was

      EMCOR trades at 23.4 times the midpoint of its own 2026 guidance and at 17.6 times trailing enterprise value to operating profit, the cheapest of the…

    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $739 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $19.84bn grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 10.4% to a normal 9.0% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 1 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (6% growth, the 2021-2025 average margin of 7.35%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $446, bull (18%, 10.0%) about $1,013. At the base case's 9.0% margin a normal year's operating profit is about $1.79bn, and company value of about $26.1bn is about 14.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $548.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $739 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $19.84bn grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 10.4% to a normal 9.0% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 1 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (6% growth, the 2021-2025 average margin of 7.35%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $446, bull (18%, 10.0%) about $1,013. At the base case's 9.0% margin a normal year's operating profit is about $1.79bn, and company value of about $26.1bn is about 14.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $548.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $739 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $19.84bn grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 10.4% to a normal 9.0% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 1 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (6% growth, the 2021-2025 average margin of 7.35%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $446, bull (18%, 10.0%) about $1,013. At the base case's 9.0% margin a normal year's operating profit is about $1.79bn, and company value of about $26.1bn is about 14.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $548.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return EMCOR is worth about $739 a share against $608.45 at the 6 November close. Base case: sales of $19.84bn grow 12% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 10.4% to a normal 9.0% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs 1 cents of capital; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (6% growth, the 2021-2025 average margin of 7.35%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $446, bull (18%, 10.0%) about $1,013. At the base case's 9.0% margin a normal year's operating profit is about $1.79bn, and company value of about $26.1bn is about 14.6 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $548.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • EEExcelerate EnergyThesis changed

    Excelerate re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Excelerate closed at $36.81 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $44.25.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 83% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C39NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.52B in fiscal 2026, $1.98B in fiscal 2027, $2.39B in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C40NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Excelerate is worth about $44.17 a share against $36.81 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.38B grow 35%, 23% and -2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C39), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 23.8% to 23.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 167 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $922M of debt net of $357M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $21.97, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.2% margin) about $60.75.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ECGEverus Construction GroupThesis changed

    Everus shares fell 32% in three days after record results

    Everus closed at $76.60 on 6 November, down from $112.73 on 3 November, the day it reported record results and raised its forecast again; 29% of the fall came on the day of its call. Its profit margin is well above the mid-7% management calls normal.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Attractive. Valued on growth that slows over ten years and a margin near what management calls normal, it is worth about $106 a share against $77: cheap. Conviction stays Medium.

    7 claims changed
    • C33NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.the normal-year reading added when the contractor theme was re-reviewed on one rule
    • C25EditedThe shares closed at $76.60 on 6 November 2026, a market value of about $3.91B, 55.4% below the May high of $171.58 and 32.0% below the $112.73 of 3 November, the close before the third-quarter results; they fell 29.3% on 4 November, the day of the call.re-struck at the 6 November close after a 32.0% fall in three sessions that followed the results
      Was

      The shares closed at $112.73 on 3 November 2026, a market value of about $5.75B, 34.3% below the May high of $171.58 and 18.8% above the $94.91 of 23…

    • C26EditedAt $76.60, with $326.7M of net debt at 30 September (which includes the $295M paid for Epsilon), enterprise value is about $4.24B: about 8.6 times the midpoint of guided 2026 EBITDA of $490M, which includes Epsilon, about 14.5 times analysts' 2026 earnings forecast of $5.30 and 12.8 times 2027's $5.98 (forecasts of 26 October). At an 8% margin on 2027's forecast revenue of $5.21B it is about 10.2 times EBITDA.re-struck at the 6 November close ($76.60), 32.0% below the 3 November close the multiples were struck at
      Was

      At $112.73, with $326.7M of net debt at 30 September (which includes the $295M paid for Epsilon), enterprise value is about $6.08B: about 12.4 times…

    • C33EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C33EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C33EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C33EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Everus is worth about $103 a share against $82.92 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.66B grow 10% in the first year, slowing toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin moves from 8.2% to a normal 7.5% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 26% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; net debt of $326.7M. Bear (5% growth, the 2022-2025 average operating margin of 6.6%, new capital earning only 8%) gives about $65, bull (18%, 8.5%) about $154. At the 7.5% normal operating margin, with depreciation of about 0.9% of revenue, a normal year's EBITDA is about $391M, and enterprise value of about $4.58B is about 11.7 times it. As a risk check, at the 10% return asked of a cyclical or indebted business the base case gives about $75.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • DLODlocal LimitedThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    DLO re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    DLO closed at $13.95 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $22.01.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 63% of that value, so we moved DLO from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.58B in fiscal 2026, $2.06B in fiscal 2027, $2.52B in fiscal 2028 and $2.93B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $510M in 2028, a 20.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return DLO is worth about $19.29 a share against $13.96 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.47B grow 32%, 24% and 18% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.4% to 16.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay and the 2.8-point gap between their operating profit and the filed one; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; an 18.3% tax rate, the company's estimate for 2026; then 4% growth for ever at an 8% return on new capital; plus $536.9M of the company's own cash less $163.5M of borrowings, on 294.6M diluted shares. Bear (half that growth, a 13.2% margin) gives about $11.55, bull (a quarter more growth, an 18.1% margin, new capital earning 11%) about $31.04.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • DGIIDigi InternationalThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Digi re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Digi closed at $63.21 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $49.19.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 129% of that value, so we moved Digi from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C47NewBefore absorbing the Q4 print, analysts expected revenue of $532M in fiscal 2026 (reported $535.2M), $579M in fiscal 2027 and $604M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $178M in the last of those years, a 29.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Digi is worth about $39.66 a share against $66.96 at the 11 November close (about 169% of it). Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $535M grow 10% and 4.5% over the next two years (the low end of the fiscal 2027 guide, which includes Disruptive Technologies, C50, then the analysts' fiscal 2028 step, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.9% to 20.8% over five years, the margin Digi earned in fiscal 2026 before amortisation of past deals and after stock pay; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 22.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less $69M of debt and the $130M Disruptive Technologies price drawn on the revolver, plus $29.5M of cash, over 39.1M shares. Bear (half that growth, a 16.6% margin) about $22.35; bull (the guide's midpoint, a 22.9% margin) about $49.98.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Digi is worth about $39.66 a share against $66.96 at the 11 November close (about 169% of it). Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $535M grow 10% and 4.5% over the next two years (the low end of the fiscal 2027 guide, which includes Disruptive Technologies, C50, then the analysts' fiscal 2028 step, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.9% to 20.8% over five years, the margin Digi earned in fiscal 2026 before amortisation of past deals and after stock pay; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 22.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital, less $69M of debt and the $130M Disruptive Technologies price drawn on the revolver, plus $29.5M of cash, over 39.1M shares. Bear (half that growth, a 16.6% margin) about $22.35; bull (the guide's midpoint, a 22.9% margin) about $49.98.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • DEDeere & CompanyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Deere re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Deere closed at $672 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $413.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 162% of that value, so we moved Deere from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C42NewAnalysts expect revenue of $41.41B in fiscal 2026, $45.02B in fiscal 2027, $48.61B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $12.50B in the last of those years, a 25.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C43NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Deere is worth about $408 a share against $672 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $47.98B grow -8%, 8% and 2% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C42), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.9% to its five-year average of 18.7% over five years, because 18.9% is a cycle trough; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 24.8% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $17.11B of debt net of $8.93B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $221, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.5% margin) about $481.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • DAVEDaveThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→2

    Dave re-valued on its equity and the returns above 8%

    Dave closed at $279 on 6 November. We valued it on its shareholders' equity plus the earnings it should make above an 8% yearly return on it, with the equity growing on the analysts' path and then slowing toward 4%. On that basis the shares are worth about $218.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 128% of that value, so we moved Dave from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C64NewAnalysts expect $735M of revenue and $13.66 a share in fiscal 2026, $904M of revenue and $20.10 a share in fiscal 2027, $1.14B of revenue and $27.74 a share in fiscal 2028.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C65NewOn an excess-return value at an 8% required return Dave is worth about $218 a share against $279 at the 6 November close. Base case: shareholders' equity of $274M grows 24% and 25% over the next years with the business (the analysts' revenue path, C64, held to at most 30% a year), then toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap; the return on that equity runs from 69.5%, the analysts' earnings this year, to 72.2%, theirs for the last year they forecast; each year's earnings above 8% of the equity are added, and after year ten new equity earns 12%. Bear (half that growth, a 57.8% return, new equity earning 8%) gives about $120, bull (a quarter more growth, a 79.4% return) about $301.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • CSTMConstellium SEThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Constellium re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Constellium closed at $21.81 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $35.12.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 62% of that value, so we moved Constellium from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C55NewAnalysts expect revenue of $10.21B in fiscal 2026, $10.14B in fiscal 2027, $10.10B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $658M in the last of those years, a 6.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C56NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Constellium is worth about $33.95 a share against $21.81 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $10.05B grow 1%, -0% and 1% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.9% to 6.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 36 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.82B of debt net of $158M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $25.15, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.9% margin) about $46.80.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • CSCOCisco SystemsThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Cisco re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Cisco closed at $93.85 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $82.26.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 114% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C37NewAnalysts expect revenue of $72.94B in fiscal 2027, $77.99B in fiscal 2028, $83.32B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $30.18B in the last of those years, a 36.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C38NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $81.85 a share against $94.52 at the 16 November close ($100.76 on 11 November). Base case: trailing sales of $63.33B grow 19% in FY27, the midpoint of the raised guide (C06), then 7% and 7%, the analysts' rates (C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 24.3% to 27.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales and a further 2.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 17.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $29.53B of debt net of $14.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.21, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.3% margin) about $106.27.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C38EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cisco is worth about $81.85 a share against $94.52 at the 16 November close ($100.76 on 11 November). Base case: trailing sales of $63.33B grow 19% in FY27, the midpoint of the raised guide (C06), then 7% and 7%, the analysts' rates (C37), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 24.3% to 27.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.0% of sales and a further 2.6%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 17.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $29.53B of debt net of $14.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 22.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $44.21, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.3% margin) about $106.27.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CRWDCrowdStrike HoldingsThesis changed

    CrowdStrike re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    CrowdStrike closed at $217 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $37.52.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 578% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C62NewAnalysts expect revenue of $6.01B in fiscal 2027, $7.38B in fiscal 2028, $9.03B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $3.05B in the last of those years, a 33.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return CrowdStrike is worth about $34.05 a share against $217 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.81B grow 25%, 23% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -6.1% to 24.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 22.8% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 27.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $745M of debt net of $5.23B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $16.00, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.3% margin) about $49.45.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • CRMSalesforceThesis changed

    Salesforce re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Salesforce closed at $214 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $227.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 94% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $46.28B in fiscal 2027, $50.88B in fiscal 2028, $55.79B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $24.32B in the last of those years, a 43.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Salesforce is worth about $218 a share against $214 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $43.94B grow 10%, 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 19.9% to 26.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 8.3% of sales and a further 8.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $39.29B of debt net of $11.40B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $104, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.0% margin) about $293.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Salesforce is worth about $218 a share against $214 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $43.94B grow 10%, 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 19.9% to 26.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 8.3% of sales and a further 8.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $39.29B of debt net of $11.40B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $104, bull (a quarter more growth, a 29.0% margin) about $293.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CRDOCredo Technology Group HoldingThesis changed

    Credo re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Credo closed at $121 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $146.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 83% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C72NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.50B in fiscal 2027, $3.86B in fiscal 2028, $5.01B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $2.86B in the last of those years, a 57.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Credo is worth about $137 a share against $121 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.59B grow 60%, 48% and 26% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 31.7% to 30.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.8% of sales and a further 12.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $764M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $49.58, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.0% margin) about $220.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Credo is worth about $137 a share against $121 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.59B grow 60%, 48% and 26% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 31.7% to 30.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 14.8% of sales and a further 12.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $764M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $49.58, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.0% margin) about $220.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CRCTCricutThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Cricut re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Cricut closed at $8.78 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $5.80.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 151% of that value, so we moved Cricut from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $705M in fiscal 2026, $714M in fiscal 2027, $724M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $77M in the last of those years, a 10.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cricut is worth about $5.58 a share against $8.78 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $708M grow 0% and 1% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.7% to its five-year average of 11.4% over five years, because 16.7% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $273M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $4.79, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.6% margin) about $6.78.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cricut is worth about $5.58 a share against $8.78 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $708M grow 0% and 1% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 16.7% to its five-year average of 11.4% over five years, because 16.7% is a cycle peak; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $273M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $4.79, bull (a quarter more growth, a 12.6% margin) about $6.78.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CPAYCorpayThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Corpay re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Corpay closed at $455 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $653.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 70% of that value, so we moved Corpay from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $5.33B in fiscal 2026, $5.79B in fiscal 2027, $6.33B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.91B in the last of those years, a 61.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Corpay is worth about $623 a share against $455 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.23B grow 8% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 43.9% to 56.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.3% of sales and a further 2.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 24 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $11.23B of debt net of $3.07B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 45.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $307, bull (a quarter more growth, a 62.4% margin) about $824.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Corpay is worth about $623 a share against $455 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $5.23B grow 8% and 9% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 43.9% to 56.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.3% of sales and a further 2.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 24 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $11.23B of debt net of $3.07B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 45.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $307, bull (a quarter more growth, a 62.4% margin) about $824.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • COHUCohuThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Cohu re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Cohu closed at $38.49 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $22.47.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 171% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C59NewAnalysts expect revenue of $625M in fiscal 2026, $839M in fiscal 2027, $985M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $170M in the last of those years, a 17.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cohu is worth about $19.79 a share against $38.49 at the 6 November close, and $45.98 at the 11 November close, about 232% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $569M grow 37% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -2.4% to 10.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.0% of sales and a further 2.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 54 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $302M of debt net of $508M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $12.78, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.8% margin) about $32.19.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • COHRCoherentThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Coherent re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Coherent closed at $193 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $378.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 51% of that value, so we moved Coherent from Unattractive to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C69NewAnalysts expect revenue of $10.84B in fiscal 2027, $15.12B in fiscal 2028, $20.58B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $5.51B in the last of those years, a 26.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C70NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Coherent is worth about $224 a share against $225 at the 9 November close ($193 on 6 November). Base case: trailing sales of $7.91B grow 49%, 38% and 39% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C69), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.4% to 18.9% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (15.9% after amortisation of past deals, 3.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 21.8%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 71 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $4.00B of debt net of $1.75B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.1% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $86.22, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.8% margin) about $483.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • CLSCelesticaThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Celestica re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Celestica closed at $207 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $584.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 35% of that value, so we moved Celestica from Unattractive to Attractive. Conviction stays Low.

    3 claims changed
    • C56NewAnalysts expect revenue of $20.98B in fiscal 2026, $39.88B in fiscal 2027, $56.49B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $5.15B in the last of those years, a 9.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Celestica is worth about $527 a share against $207 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $18.23B grow 60%, 52% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.3% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.5% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $819M of debt net of $3.96B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $248, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $930.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Celestica is worth about $527 a share against $207 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $18.23B grow 60%, 52% and 22% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 8.3% to 8.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.5% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $819M of debt net of $3.96B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $248, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.5% margin) about $930.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CIENCienaThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Ciena re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Ciena closed at $243 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $432.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 56% of that value, so we moved Ciena from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C47NewAnalysts expect revenue of $6.43B in fiscal 2026, $8.45B in fiscal 2027, $10.95B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.20B in the last of those years, a 29.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $295 a share against $269.33 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $6.02B grow 31%, 30% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.3% to 18.2% over five years, what its August 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 24.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.23B of debt net of $2.63B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.0% margin) about $464.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C48EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Ciena is worth about $295 a share against $269.33 at the 9 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $6.02B grow 31%, 30% and 28% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C47), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.3% to 18.2% over five years, what its August 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 24.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 28 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.23B of debt net of $2.63B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $108, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.0% margin) about $464.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CHYMChime FinancialThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Chime re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Chime closed at $31.33 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $17.89.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 175% of that value, so we moved Chime from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.79B in fiscal 2026, $3.43B in fiscal 2027, $4.09B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $721M in the last of those years, a 17.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Chime is worth about $16.92 a share against $31.33 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.63B grow 24%, 20% and 24% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 1.8% to 7.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $100M of debt net of $1.18B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.52, bull (a quarter more growth, a 8.1% margin) about $24.29.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Chime is worth about $16.92 a share against $31.33 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $2.63B grow 24%, 20% and 24% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 1.8% to 7.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 10.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 19 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $100M of debt net of $1.18B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 5.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.52, bull (a quarter more growth, a 8.1% margin) about $24.29.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CCSIConsensus Cloud SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Consensus re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Consensus closed at $43.15 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $86.53.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 50% of that value, so we moved Consensus from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C55NewAnalysts expect revenue of $361M in fiscal 2026, $375M in fiscal 2027, $399M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $214M in the last of those years, a 53.6% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C56NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Consensus is worth about $79.57 a share against $43.15 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $358M grow 4% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 40.8% to 44.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 5.9% of sales and a further 3.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 29 cents of capital; a 23.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $550M of debt net of $107M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 35.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $54.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 48.5% margin) about $115.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C56EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Consensus is worth about $79.57 a share against $43.15 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $358M grow 4% and 6% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C55), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 40.8% to 44.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 5.9% of sales and a further 3.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 29 cents of capital; a 23.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $550M of debt net of $107M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 35.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $54.55, bull (a quarter more growth, a 48.5% margin) about $115.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • CBRSCerebras SystemsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    Cerebras re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Cerebras closed at $89.68 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $40.51.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 221% of that value, so we moved Cerebras from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Low.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $885M in fiscal 2026, $2.93B in fiscal 2027, $7.54B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.51B in the last of those years, a 33.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Cerebras is worth about $32.83 a share against $101.08 at the 11 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $756M grow 60% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -99.3% to 10.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 21.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $1.45B of debt and leases net of $7.80B of cash. Bear (half that growth, an 8.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.14; bull (the backlog on its filed schedule, revenue tripling then growing 150%, an 11.0% margin) about $143.65.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • BWXTBWX TechnologiesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    BWX Technologies re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    BWX Technologies closed at $120 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $82.82.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 144% of that value, so we moved BWX Technologies from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C56NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.79B in fiscal 2026, $4.11B in fiscal 2027, $4.52B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $732M in the last of those years, a 16.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return BWX Technologies is worth about $80.93 a share against $120 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.60B grow 12%, 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.4% to 13.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales and a further 1.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 62 cents of capital; a 17.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.02B of debt net of $569M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.86, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.1% margin) about $111.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C57EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return BWX Technologies is worth about $80.93 a share against $120 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.60B grow 12%, 10% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C56), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.4% to 13.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.0% of sales and a further 1.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 62 cents of capital; a 17.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $2.02B of debt net of $569M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $37.86, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.1% margin) about $111.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • BWABorgWarnerThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    BorgWarner re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    BorgWarner closed at $48.81 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $73.53.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 66% of that value, so we moved BorgWarner from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    6 claims changed
    • C62NewAnalysts expect revenue of $14.11B in fiscal 2026, $14.66B in fiscal 2027, $15.62B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.82B in the last of those years, a 11.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C63NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return BorgWarner is worth about $72.47 a share against $48.81 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $14.24B grow 2%, 6% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 9.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 45 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.00B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $38.32, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.6% margin) about $93.59.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C26EditedAt $48.81 (the 6 November close) the whole company, shares plus net debt and minority stakes, costs about $11.5B, or about 8.7 times its guided 2026 operating profit of about $1.33B. On 10 February, the day before the turbine award was announced, the same measure was about 9.5 times on this guide. At 9.2 times the car parts alone would be worth about $12.3B, so today's price holds about $0.7B, or about $3.50 a share, less than the car parts at that multiple: nothing is being paid for the turbine.Re-struck at the 6 November close ($48.81) after a 20% fall on no news; basis moved to the 9.3-9.6% GAAP margin guide of 29 October
      Was

      At $61.32 the whole company, shares plus net debt and minority stakes, costs about $14.1B, or about 10.3 times its guided 2026 operating profit of ab…

    • C27EditedOn management's figures the turbine's first year earns about $45M of operating profit, about 3% of 2026 guided adjusted operating profit of about $1.51B. At the 6 November price the whole company costs less than the car parts alone at 9.2 times, so the turbine needs nothing to be worth what the price holds for it; at the 61.32 close of 25 September the price held $1.4B and needed about $136M a year, three times the stated first year.Premium re-struck: the price now holds none for the turbine
      Was

      On management's figures the turbine's first year earns about $45M of operating profit, about 3% of 2026 guided adjusted operating profit of about $1.…

    • C33EditedThe shares closed at $53.98 on 10 February 2026 and $66.10 on 11 February, a 22.5% rise on the day the turbine award was announced, fell back to $53.25 by 9 March, reached a 252-day high of $78.82 on 3 June and closed at $61.32 on 25 September, and closed at $48.81 on 6 November, 20% under the 25 September close, with no company news in the window.6 November close added
      Was

      The shares closed at $53.98 on 10 February 2026 and $66.10 on 11 February, a 22.5% rise on the day the turbine award was announced, fell back to $53.…

    • C63EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return BorgWarner is worth about $72.47 a share against $48.81 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $14.24B grow 2%, 6% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C62), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 5.4% to 9.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 45 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $3.00B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $38.32, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.6% margin) about $93.59.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • BULLWebullThesis changed

    Webull re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Webull closed at $4.92 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $5.65.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 87% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $805M in fiscal 2026, $975M in fiscal 2027, $1.15B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $239M in the last of those years, a 20.8% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Webull is worth about $5.34 a share against $4.92 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $571M grow 41%, 21% and 18% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.8% to 13.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.7% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 51 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $653M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 10.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $3.74, bull (a quarter more growth, a 14.4% margin) about $7.86.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • BNBrookfieldThesis changed
    ViewAttractive→Neutral
    Valuation4→3

    Brookfield re-valued on the sum of its parts

    Brookfield closed at $41.38 on 6 November. We valued it as a holding company, adding up what it owns at market prices or as reported and taking off what it owes, with an 8% yearly return asked of anything valued on its earnings. On that basis the shares are worth about $47.72.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 87% of that value, so we moved Brookfield from Attractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    1 claim changed
    • C50NewOn the sum of its parts Brookfield is worth about $46.43 a share against $42.06 at the 11 November close. Base case: its listed stakes at that day's closes are worth $81.0B (Brookfield Asset Management $60.7B after the $2B borrowed against it, Infrastructure $8.2B, Renewable $9.4B, Business $2.6B), private holdings add $48.8B at book, and $20.4B of debt, preferred capital and other items come off, on 2,356.2M shares. Bear (private holdings a fifth under book) gives about $42.28, bull (a fifth over) about $50.57.the fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November; a holding company is valued on its parts
  • BKRBaker Hughes CompanyThesis changed

    Baker Hughes re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Baker Hughes closed at $47.87 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $46.98.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 102% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $29.61B in fiscal 2026, $32.70B in fiscal 2027, $34.72B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $4.77B in the last of those years, a 13.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Baker Hughes is worth about $45.67 a share against $47.87 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $28.74B grow 11%, 7% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 12.1% to 13.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.7% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $18.26B of debt net of $0M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 10.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $19.53, bull (a quarter more growth, a 14.3% margin) about $62.15.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • BILLBILL HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation3→1

    BILL Holdings re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    BILL Holdings closed at $52.41 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $17.88.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 293% of that value, so we moved BILL Holdings from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C44NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.83B in fiscal 2027, $2.04B in fiscal 2028, $2.27B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $704M in the last of those years, a 31.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C45NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return BILL Holdings is worth about $15.93 a share against $52.41 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.65B grow 11%, 11% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C44), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -4.4% to 8.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 13.9% of sales and a further 8.7%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 43 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $1.84B of debt net of $1.94B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.7% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $10.51, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.2% margin) about $24.61.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • BEBloom EnergyThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation1→3

    Bloom Energy re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Bloom Energy closed at $173 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $148.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 117% of that value, so we moved Bloom Energy from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C45NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.45B in fiscal 2026, $7.19B in fiscal 2027, $10.51B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $3.51B in the last of those years, a 33.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Bloom Energy is worth about $74.86 a share against $173 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 60%, 50% and 30% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.8% to 18.3% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 25.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 52 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $2.48B of debt net of $2.49B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.1% margin) about $148.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C46EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Bloom Energy is worth about $74.86 a share against $173 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.83B grow 60%, 50% and 30% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C45, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.8% to 18.3% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 25.7%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 52 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $2.48B of debt net of $2.49B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 14.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $31.27, bull (a quarter more growth, a 20.1% margin) about $148.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AXONAxon EnterpriseThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Axon re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Axon closed at $313 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $169.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 185% of that value, so we moved Axon from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C52NewAnalysts expect revenue of $3.71B in fiscal 2026, $4.81B in fiscal 2027, $6.17B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.40B in the last of those years, a 22.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C53NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Axon is worth about $153 a share against $313 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $3.42B grow 32% and 28% over the next two years (the analysts' path, C52), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 2.0% to 13.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay fading from today's 18.8% of sales to 6.0%, what a mature company pays, and a further 3.0%, faded from 9.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 34 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $2.87B of debt net of $1.66B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 10.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $45.09, bull (a quarter more growth, a 15.0% margin) about $216.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • AVAVAeroVironmentThesis changed

    AeroVironment won a $315 million first order under a $940 million drone contract

    AeroVironment said a US customer, not named, signed a multiyear contract that can reach $940 million, with about $315 million ordered now for products and support from its drone business. The company's page could not be read in full, so the products, delivery years and whether the money is already set aside are not known.

    What it did to the thesisThe award helps the drone half of our case, but it came after the quarter our next test measures. Valued in three stages the price is well above what the business is worth, so the view moves to Unattractive.

    5 claims changed
    • C42NewOn 9 November 2026 AeroVironment announced a multiyear indefinite-delivery, indefinite-quantity contract with a ceiling of $940 million with an unnamed US customer, including an initial award of about $315 million for product deliveries and support, to be delivered through its Autonomous Systems segment; the release as read does not say which products, the delivery years, or how much of the award is funded.the $315M award under a $940M IDIQ, announced 9 November 2026, bears on C05, C09 and C10
    • C43NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.21B in fiscal 2027, $2.54B in fiscal 2028, $2.97B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $340M in the last of those years, a 11.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C44NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AeroVironment is worth about $58.50 a share against $113 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.98B grow 12%, 15% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C43), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -15.7% to 9.5% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 1.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $729M of debt net of $632M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 7.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $27.06, bull (a quarter more growth, a 10.5% margin) about $81.57.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C36EditedAt $112.76 the company is worth about $5.73B; adding $747.5M of notes and taking away about $675M of cash and investments gives a company value of about $5.80B. That is about 18 times guided fiscal 2027 adjusted EBITDA of $315M at the midpoint, 21 times the same figure after about $40M of stock pay, and about 8 times the fiscal 2030 target's midpoint EBITDA.Re-struck at the 6 November close of $112.76, from $137.11, and shown beside the multiple after stock pay under the valuation rules.
      Was

      At $137.11 the company is worth about $6.97B; adding $747.5M of notes and taking away about $675M of cash and investments gives a company value of ab…

    • C37EditedDiscounted at 9% a year and valued at 15 times EBITDA in fiscal 2030, today's company value needs about $520M of fiscal 2030 adjusted EBITDA, about 73% of the investor-day target's midpoint and about 1.7 times this year's guide.Re-struck at the 6 November close: company value of about $5.80B needs about $520M, 73% of the target, from 89%.
      Was

      Discounted at 9% a year and valued at 15 times EBITDA in fiscal 2030, today's company value needs about $630M of fiscal 2030 adjusted EBITDA, about 8…

  • ASMLASML HoldingThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    ASML re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    ASML closed at $1,425 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $1,732.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 82% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C41NewAnalysts expect revenue of $49.31B in fiscal 2026, $63.98B in fiscal 2027, $80.33B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $33.30B in the last of those years, a 41.5% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C42NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ASML is worth about $1,669 a share against $1,425 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $43.98B grow 36%, 26% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 38.6% to 40.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.2% of sales and a further 0.9%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 16.7% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $2.19B of debt net of $14.19B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 32.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $694, bull (a quarter more growth, a 44.3% margin) about $2,236.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ARMKAramarkThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Aramark re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Aramark closed at $52.54 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $50.75.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 104% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C68NewAnalysts expect revenue of $22.02B in fiscal 2027, $23.72B in fiscal 2028 and $25.48B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $1.43B in fiscal 2028, a 6.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C69NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Aramark is worth about $49.03 a share against $55.37 at the 16 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $20.09B grow 9.6%, 7.7% and 7.4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C68, in line with the 9% to 10% guide), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.6% to 5.7% over five years, the analysts' fiscal 2028 margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.23B of debt net of $688M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $21.34, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.3% margin) about $67.67.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C69EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Aramark is worth about $49.03 a share against $55.37 at the 16 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $20.09B grow 9.6%, 7.7% and 7.4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C68, in line with the 9% to 10% guide), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 4.6% to 5.7% over five years, the analysts' fiscal 2028 margin less stock pay of 0.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.23B of debt net of $688M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 4.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $21.34, bull (a quarter more growth, a 6.3% margin) about $67.67.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • APPSDigital TurbineThesis changed

    Digital Turbine re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Digital Turbine closed at $10.38 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $8.52.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 122% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C42NewAnalysts expect revenue of $665M in fiscal 2027, $744M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $157M in the last of those years, a 21.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C43NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Digital Turbine is worth about $7.16 a share against $10.38 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $565M grow 18% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C42), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 6.0% to 15.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.9% of sales and a further 3.0%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $361M of debt net of $38M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 12.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $3.85, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.8% margin) about $12.17.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • APPFAppFolioThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive

    AppFolio re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    AppFolio closed at $231 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $181.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 128% of that value, so we moved AppFolio from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C48NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.13B in fiscal 2026, $1.32B in fiscal 2027, $1.53B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $495M in the last of those years, a 32.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppFolio is worth about $173 a share against $231 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.09B grow 16% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.8% to 24.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales and a further 1.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 20.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $259M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $91.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.6% margin) about $232.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C49EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppFolio is worth about $173 a share against $231 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.09B grow 16% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C48), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 18.8% to 24.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 6.8% of sales and a further 1.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 20.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $259M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 19.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $91.50, bull (a quarter more growth, a 26.6% margin) about $232.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • APPAppLovinThesis changed

    AppLovin re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    AppLovin closed at $391 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $508.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 77% of that value, so the view stays Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    6 claims changed
    • C71NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $480 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.48B grow 49%, 25% and 20% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin holds near 75%; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% and 5% after 2026, a 65% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $219, bull (32% and 28%, an 80% margin) about $696.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C38EditedThe price pays 26.5 times free cash flow for a business that grew revenue 47.6% over the trailing year, earns 63.8% on invested capital and carries net debt of 0.08 times EBITDA - after a 44% rise in two sessions it assumes growth starting near 26% and fading.Re-struck at the 6 November close after the results lifted the shares 44%; what the price assumes is now read off the three-stage fair value.
      Was

      The price pays 24.5 times free cash flow for a business that grew revenue 47.6% over the trailing year, earns 63.8% on invested capital and carries n…

    • C70EditedAt the 2026-11-09 close of $410.00, 331M shares are worth about $135.7B, which is 27.8 times trailing free cash flow of about $4.88B (the $3.95B of 2025 plus $3,568.5M for the nine months to September 2026 less $2,642.8M a year earlier).Re-struck at the 6 November close after the shares rose 44% on the results.
      Was

      At the 2026-11-04 close of $271.75, 331M shares are worth about $89.9B, which is 18.4 times trailing free cash flow of about $4.88B (the $3.95B of 20…

    • C71EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $480 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.48B grow 49%, 25% and 20% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin holds near 75%; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% and 5% after 2026, a 65% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $219, bull (32% and 28%, an 80% margin) about $696.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C71EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $480 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.48B grow 49%, 25% and 20% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin holds near 75%; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% and 5% after 2026, a 65% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $219, bull (32% and 28%, an 80% margin) about $696.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C71EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AppLovin is worth about $480 a share against $410.00 at the 9 November close. Base case: 2025 sales of $5.48B grow 49%, 25% and 20% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the operating margin holds near 75%; each added dollar of sales needs about 17 cents of capital, the average the filings show; a 15% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (10% and 5% after 2026, a 65% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $219, bull (32% and 28%, an 80% margin) about $696.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • APHAmphenolThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Amphenol re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Amphenol closed at $74.59 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $83.43.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 89% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $37.08B in fiscal 2026, $45.71B in fiscal 2027, $52.73B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $14.45B in the last of those years, a 27.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Amphenol is worth about $79.67 a share against $74.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $33.05B grow 31%, 17% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 27.7% to 27.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 23 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $17.87B of debt net of $5.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.72, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.1% margin) about $112.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Amphenol is worth about $79.67 a share against $74.59 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $33.05B grow 31%, 17% and 12% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 27.7% to 27.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 23 cents of capital; a 25.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $17.87B of debt net of $5.30B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 21.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $35.72, bull (a quarter more growth, a 30.1% margin) about $112.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • ANETArista NetworksThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Arista re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Arista closed at $171 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $165.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 103% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C74NewAnalysts expect revenue of $13.18B in fiscal 2026, $18.11B in fiscal 2027, $22.69B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $10.45B in the last of those years, a 46.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C75NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Arista is worth about $157 a share against $187.02 at the 16 November close, about 119% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $11.89B grow 41%, 28% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C74), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 43.8% to 41.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 18.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $14.36B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 33.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $70.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 45.9% margin) about $230.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C75EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Arista is worth about $157 a share against $187.02 at the 16 November close, about 119% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $11.89B grow 41%, 28% and 21% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C74), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 43.8% to 41.7% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 4.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 18.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $14.36B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 33.4% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $70.46, bull (a quarter more growth, a 45.9% margin) about $230.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AMZNAmazon.comThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Amazon re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Amazon closed at $259 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $260.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 100% of that value, so the view stays Neutral. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C61NewAnalysts expect revenue of $829.63B in fiscal 2026, $961.23B in fiscal 2027, $1,120.15B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $194.48B in the last of those years, a 17.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Amazon is worth about $253 a share against $259 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $797.46B grow 16%, 16% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.1% to 14.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.5% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 22.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $180.33B of debt net of $114.23B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $111, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.4% margin) about $325.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C62EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Amazon is worth about $253 a share against $259 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $797.46B grow 16%, 16% and 16% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C61), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 13.1% to 14.9% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.5% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 35 cents of capital; a 22.3% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $180.33B of debt net of $114.23B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 11.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $111, bull (a quarter more growth, a 16.4% margin) about $325.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AMDAdvanced Micro DevicesThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    AMD re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    AMD closed at $449 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $581.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 77% of that value, so we moved AMD from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C60NewAnalysts expect revenue of $52.18B in fiscal 2026, $95.41B in fiscal 2027, $133.53B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $45.28B in the last of those years, a 33.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C61NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $504.28 at the 16 November close, about 110% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $45.44B grow 60%, 50% and 35% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.7% to 25.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (21.2% after amortisation of past deals, 4.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 29.5%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.08B of debt net of $15.78B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $140, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.7% margin) about $788.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C61EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AMD is worth about $460 a share against $504.28 at the 16 November close, about 110% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $45.44B grow 60%, 50% and 35% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C60, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 17.7% to 25.2% over five years, what its September 2026 quarter (21.2% after amortisation of past deals, 4.0% of sales) earned before amortisation of past deals, not the analysts' 29.5%: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.08B of debt net of $15.78B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 20.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $140, bull (a quarter more growth, a 27.7% margin) about $788.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AMATApplied MaterialsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Applied Materials re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Applied Materials closed at $333 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $451.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 74% of that value, so we moved Applied Materials from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C54NewAnalysts expect revenue of $46.86B in fiscal 2027, $57.18B in fiscal 2028 and $62.77B in fiscal 2029, after $34.45B reported for fiscal 2026 against their $34.33B; the fiscal 2028 operating profit they expect is $23.66B, a 41.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $422 a share against $395 at the 11 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $34.45B grow 36%, 22% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.2% to 35.3% over five years, what its October 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.53B of debt net of $9.34B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 28.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $204, bull (a quarter more growth, a 38.8% margin) about $583.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C55EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Materials is worth about $422 a share against $395 at the 11 November close. Base case: fiscal 2026 sales of $34.45B grow 36%, 22% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C54), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 32.2% to 35.3% over five years, what its October 2026 quarter earned before amortisation of past deals: a cyclical business's normal margin goes no higher than it has already filed; each added dollar of sales needs 32 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $6.53B of debt net of $9.34B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 28.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $204, bull (a quarter more growth, a 38.8% margin) about $583.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • ALNTAllientThesis changed
    Valuation2→1

    Allient re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Allient closed at $81.32 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $40.90.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 199% of that value, so the view stays Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C72NewAnalysts expect revenue of $602M in fiscal 2026, $657M in fiscal 2027, $717M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $95M in the last of those years, a 13.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Allient is worth about $38.55 a share against $81.32 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $600M grow 7%, 9% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.8% to 10.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.6% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 37 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $173M of debt net of $40M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $26.59, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.6% margin) about $55.79.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C73EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Allient is worth about $38.55 a share against $81.32 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $600M grow 7%, 9% and 5% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C72), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.8% to 10.6% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 0.6% of sales and a further 2.1%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 37 cents of capital; a 22.2% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $173M of debt net of $40M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.5% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $26.59, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.6% margin) about $55.79.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • ALABAstera LabsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive

    Astera Labs re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Astera Labs closed at $191 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $141.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 135% of that value, so we moved Astera Labs from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C57NewAnalysts expect revenue of $2.01B in fiscal 2026, $3.39B in fiscal 2027, $4.38B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $2.12B in the last of those years, a 48.3% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Astera Labs is worth about $124 a share against $191 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.56B grow 60%, 38% and 43% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.5% to 20.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 15.2% of sales and a further 12.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.38B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $41.37, bull (a quarter more growth, a 22.9% margin) about $212.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C58EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Astera Labs is worth about $124 a share against $191 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.56B grow 60%, 38% and 43% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C57, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 25.5% to 20.8% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 15.2% of sales and a further 12.3%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $1.38B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 16.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $41.37, bull (a quarter more growth, a 22.9% margin) about $212.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AKAMAkamai TechnologiesThesis changed

    Akamai proposes to borrow $2.2 billion through convertible notes

    Akamai said it plans to sell $1.1 billion of notes due in 2028 and $1.1 billion due in 2031, which holders can swap into shares. Interest rate and swap price are not set yet. The money repays part of $1.15 billion of notes due in September 2027 and pays for cloud servers.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 74% of that value, so we moved Akamai from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium. The news itself moved nothing.

    3 claims changed
    • C49NewAnalysts expect revenue of $4.49B in fiscal 2026, $5.22B in fiscal 2027, $6.47B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $1.76B in the last of those years, a 27.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Akamai is worth about $54.15 a share against $83.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.39B grow 14%, 22% and 24% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.1% to 12.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 12.0% of sales and a further 2.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 58 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.57B of debt net of $3.52B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $7.84, bull (a quarter more growth, a 13.7% margin) about $94.46.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C50EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Akamai is worth about $54.15 a share against $83.09 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $4.39B grow 14%, 22% and 24% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C49), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 9.1% to 12.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 12.0% of sales and a further 2.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 58 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $7.57B of debt net of $3.52B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 9.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $7.84, bull (a quarter more growth, a 13.7% margin) about $94.46.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AGYSAgilysysThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Agilysys re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Agilysys closed at $121 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $56.56.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 214% of that value, so we moved Agilysys from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C58NewAnalysts expect revenue of $376M in fiscal 2027, $441M in fiscal 2028, $518M in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $135M in the last of those years, a 26.1% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Agilysys is worth about $54.78 a share against $121 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $344M grow 18% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.3% to 19.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 19.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $138M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.69, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.0% margin) about $73.06.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C59EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Agilysys is worth about $54.78 a share against $121 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $344M grow 18% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C58), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.3% to 19.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.0% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 19.9% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $138M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 15.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $29.69, bull (a quarter more growth, a 21.0% margin) about $73.06.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AEYEAudioEyeThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    AudioEye re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    AudioEye closed at $12.37 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $6.07.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 204% of that value, so we moved AudioEye from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Low.

    2 claims changed
    • C46NewAnalysts expect revenue of $44M in fiscal 2026, $48M in fiscal 2027, with operating profit of $20M in the last of those years, a 41.7% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C47NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return AudioEye is worth about $5.39 a share against $12.37 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $43M grow 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C46), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -4.8% to 16.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 11.7% of sales and a further 13.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 50 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $16M of debt net of $9M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 13.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $3.86, bull (a quarter more growth, a 18.1% margin) about $7.70.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • AEHRAehr Test SystemsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Aehr Test Systems re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Aehr Test Systems closed at $53.57 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $9.34.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 574% of that value, so we moved Aehr Test Systems from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C51NewAnalysts expect revenue of $135M in fiscal 2027, $148M in fiscal 2028, $221M in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $54M in the last of those years, a 24.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C52NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Aehr Test Systems is worth about $9.20 a share against $53.57 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $72M grow 60%, 21% and 40% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C51, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -5.6% to 10.4% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 9.7% of sales and a further 4.4%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2026 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 119 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $0M of debt net of $105M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 8.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $3.44, bull (a quarter more growth, a 11.4% margin) about $14.73.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
  • ADEAAdeiaThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Attractive
    Valuation2→4

    Adeia re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Adeia closed at $15.50 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $28.94.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 54% of that value, so we moved Adeia from Unattractive to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C67NewAnalysts expect revenue of $399M in fiscal 2026, $427M in fiscal 2027, $460M in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $308M in the last of those years, a 67.0% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C68NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Adeia is worth about $27.76 a share against $15.50 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $464M grow -10% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C67), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 38.4% to 54.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 8.4% of sales and a further 4.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 26 cents of capital; a 23.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $381M of debt net of $128M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 43.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.07, bull (a quarter more growth, a 59.5% margin) about $36.65.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C68EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Adeia is worth about $27.76 a share against $15.50 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $464M grow -10% and 8% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C67), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 38.4% to 54.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 8.4% of sales and a further 4.5%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 26 cents of capital; a 23.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $381M of debt net of $128M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 43.2% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $15.07, bull (a quarter more growth, a 59.5% margin) about $36.65.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • ADBEAdobeUnchanged

    Disney and Adobe will build custom AI models for Disney together

    Reuters reports that Disney and Adobe will co-develop custom AI models made for Disney. Reuters could not be opened from here, and the company release was not found, so only the headline is known: no price, length of deal or number of users.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A large media customer is the kind of enterprise demand our case wants to see, but without figures it cannot answer the open question on enterprise growth. The view stays attractive, with low confidence.

    5 claims changed
    • C64NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Adobe is worth about $389 a share against $239.30 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2025 sales of $23.77B grow 12%, 8% and 6% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 35.7% to 38% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 48 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (3% and 2% after fiscal 2026, a 32% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $241, bull (10% and 9%, a 42% margin) about $500.the three-stage fair value added when the Attractive theses were re-valued on one method
    • C25EditedAfter about $2.07B of stock pay, trailing cash profit is about $8.52B against a company value of about $93.9B at the 6 November close: a 9.1% yearly return, which on a 9% required return implies growth of about zero for ever.Re-struck at the 6 November close when the fair value was added; the yield moved from 9.0% to 9.1%.
      Was

      After about $2.07B of stock pay, trailing cash profit is about $8.52B against a company value of about $94.4B: a 9.0% yearly return, which on a 9% re…

    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Adobe is worth about $389 a share against $239.30 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2025 sales of $23.77B grow 12%, 8% and 6% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 35.7% to 38% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 48 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (3% and 2% after fiscal 2026, a 32% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $241, bull (10% and 9%, a 42% margin) about $500.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Adobe is worth about $389 a share against $239.30 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2025 sales of $23.77B grow 12%, 8% and 6% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 35.7% to 38% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 48 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (3% and 2% after fiscal 2026, a 32% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $241, bull (10% and 9%, a 42% margin) about $500.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
    • C64EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Adobe is worth about $389 a share against $239.30 at the 6 November close. Base case: fiscal 2025 sales of $23.77B grow 12%, 8% and 6% over three years, then move toward 4% by year ten, each year closing 30% of the gap; the official operating margin moves from 35.7% to 38% over five years; each added dollar of sales needs about 48 cents of capital; a 21.5% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital. Bear (3% and 2% after fiscal 2026, a 32% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $241, bull (10% and 9%, a 42% margin) about $500.Re-struck on the decaying fade the owner chose on 9 November: after the stated path each year closes 30% of the gap to 4%, and an analysts' margin is cut by their gap to the filed operating profit.
  • ACMRACM ResearchThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    ACM Research re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    ACM Research closed at $44.61 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $57.65.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 77% of that value, so we moved ACM Research from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C59NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.17B in fiscal 2026, $1.51B in fiscal 2027, $1.89B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $432M in the last of those years, a 22.9% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $50.85 a share against $44.00 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.14B grow 25%, 26% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.5% to 16.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 147 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $343M of debt net of $952M of cash, and less $572.3M of book equity belonging to ACM Shanghai's outside shareholders. Bear (half that growth, a 12.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.06, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.7% margin) about $75.19.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C60EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return ACM Research is worth about $50.85 a share against $44.00 at the 16 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $1.14B grow 25%, 26% and 17% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 14.5% to 16.1% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.6% of sales and a further 4.2%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 147 cents of capital; a 15.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $343M of debt net of $952M of cash, and less $572.3M of book equity belonging to ACM Shanghai's outside shareholders. Bear (half that growth, a 12.9% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $23.06, bull (a quarter more growth, a 17.7% margin) about $75.19.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AAPLAppleThesis changed

    Apple borrowed $7.5B in bonds, and a China AI registration story went unread

    Reuters reported on 9 November that China's regulator registered Apple Intelligence for tablets and laptops; we could read only the headline. Separately, Apple's filing shows it sold $7.5B of bonds on 6 November, maturing from 2028 to 2036, and says the money may fund share buybacks and dividends.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 181% of that value, so we moved Apple from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium. The news itself moved nothing.

    5 claims changed
    • C41NewAnalysts expect revenue of $526.23B in fiscal 2027, $566.07B in fiscal 2028, $590.99B in fiscal 2029, with operating profit of $196.22B in the last of those years, a 33.2% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C42NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Apple is worth about $184 a share against $342 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $478.83B grow 10%, 8% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 33.0% to 30.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 17.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $78.11B of debt net of $56.72B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $104, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.4% margin) about $215.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C10EditedApple bought back $89.3B of stock and paid $15.4B of dividends in fiscal 2025, and $62.1B and $11.8B in the nine months to June 2026, then $24B and $3.9B in the September quarter; it no longer targets net cash neutral and says it will invest what it needs and return excess cash, against $13.7B of stock pay over four quarters to June. The November 2026 note sale states that its proceeds may fund buybacks and dividends.the prospectus supplement names buybacks and dividends among the uses of the $7.5B raised
      Was

      Apple bought back $89.3B of stock and paid $15.4B of dividends in fiscal 2025, and $62.1B and $11.8B in the nine months to June 2026, then $24B and $…

    • C11EditedAt September 26, 2026 Apple held $136.9B of cash and marketable securities against about $80B of total debt, about $57B net; operating cash flow in the September quarter was $28.1B, and the dividend was raised to $0.27 a share. On 6 November 2026 it sold $7.5B of notes due 2028 to 2036, about $7.47B net, for general corporate purposes including buybacks and dividends, which takes total debt to about $87.5B with net cash unchanged at about $57B until the proceeds are spent.the 6 November prospectus supplement: $7.5B of new notes raise debt to about $87.5B
      Was

      At September 26, 2026 Apple held $136.9B of cash and marketable securities against about $80B of total debt, about $57B net; operating cash flow in t…

    • C42EditedOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Apple is worth about $184 a share against $342 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $478.83B grow 10%, 8% and 4% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C41), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 33.0% to 30.3% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.9% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 17.0% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 15% return on new capital; less $78.11B of debt net of $56.72B of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 24.3% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $104, bull (a quarter more growth, a 33.4% margin) about $215.growth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  • AAOIApplied OptoelectronicsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Unattractive
    Valuation2→1

    Applied Optoelectronics re-valued on its own future cash at an 8% return

    Applied Optoelectronics closed at $50.13 on 6 November. We valued it on the cash it should produce over ten years, with growth slowing toward 4%, stock pay counted as a cost and an 8% yearly return asked. On that basis the shares are worth about $14.05.

    What it did to the thesisThe price is about 357% of that value, so we moved Applied Optoelectronics from Neutral to Unattractive. Conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C53NewAnalysts expect revenue of $1.05B in fiscal 2026, $2.96B in fiscal 2027, $5.12B in fiscal 2028, with operating profit of $837M in the last of those years, a 16.4% margin before stock pay.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November
    • C54NewOn a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return Applied Optoelectronics is worth about $14.40 a share against $50.13 at the 6 November close. Base case: trailing sales of $747M grow 60% and 60% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C53, held to at most 60% a year), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from -6.8% to 8.2% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 2.4% of sales and a further 5.8%, the gap between their operating profit for fiscal 2025 and the filed one once amortisation of past deals, impairments and deal costs are set aside; each added dollar of sales needs 137 cents of capital; a 25% tax rate, the federal 21% plus state tax; then 4% growth for ever at a 8% return on new capital; less $97M of debt net of $605M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 6.6% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $8.16, bull (a quarter more growth, a 9.0% margin) about $23.35.the three-stage fair value at an 8% required return, rolled out to every thesis on the owner's call of 9 November

Friday 6 November9

  • VPGVishay Precision GroupThesis changed
    Valuation1→2

    VPG shares fell 24% after results, to the price our better-view route named

    Vishay Precision closed at $41.22 on 5 November, down from $54.24 on 3 November, after reporting record orders but a 4.9% adjusted operating margin. Counting its cash, the whole business now costs about 16.7 times its average yearly operating profit since 2018, down from 22.7.

    What it did to the thesisOur route to Attractive needs the price below 18 times and the margin at 8% for two quarters. The price is there; the margin is 4.9%. So the view stays Unattractive, but the price now pays for less, about 8 times the plan's profit, so the price score improves.

    1 claim changed
    • C25EditedAt $41.22 on 2026-11-05 VPG's enterprise value is about $484M: 13.32M shares make $549M of equity, less about $65M of net cash. That is 16.7 times the 2018-2025 average operating profit of $29.0M, 11.1 times the best year's $43.8M, and about 8 times the roughly $60M the target model implies for 2028.re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $41.22 after the shares fell 24% from the 2026-11-03 close
      Was

      At $54.24 on 2026-11-03 VPG's enterprise value is about $657M: 13.32M shares make $722M of equity, less about $65M of net cash. That is 22.7 times th…

  • STRLSterling InfrastructureThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Sterling's shares fell 29% in four sessions with no company news

    Sterling's shares closed at $244.34 on 5 November, down from $345.91 on 30 October. The company filed nothing new about its business; the only items were a shareholder's ownership notice and a conference announcement. At this price the shares cost about 11 times the profit per share Sterling expects this year.

    What it did to the thesisThe price we had set for a better view, 12 times this year's expected profit per share, has been reached, so we moved Sterling from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction stays Medium because signed work fell last quarter and that is still unresolved.

    2 claims changed
    • C25EditedThe shares closed at $244.34 on 5 November 2026, 75.7% below the 52-week high of $1,005.68, for a market value of about $7.47B. Over the 126 sessions to 30 October the price fell 35.1% while trailing sales per share rose 73.7%: the multiple fell 62.6%. It then fell a further 29.4% in four sessions from $345.91, with no company news and no new filing beyond a shareholder's 13G.re-struck at the 5 November close after route P1 fired; the 30 October price no longer trades
      Was

      The shares closed at $345.91 on 30 October 2026, 65.6% below the 52-week high of $1,005.68, for a market value of $10.58B. Over the 126 sessions to t…

    • C26EditedAt $244.34 Sterling trades at about 11.2 times the guided 2026 adjusted EPS midpoint of $21.83 and 12.6 times guided GAAP EPS, 11.7 times analysts' 2026 forecast and 9.0 times their 2027 forecast of $27.12, on forecast 2027 sales of $5.46B. With net cash of $122M, company value is about $7.35B, about 7.5 times guided adjusted EBITDA.re-struck at the 5 November close: 16 times guided earnings became 11.2 after a 29% fall
      Was

      At $345.91 Sterling trades at about 15.8 times the guided 2026 adjusted EPS midpoint of $21.83 and 17.9 times guided GAAP EPS, 16.5 times analysts' 2…

  • MUMicron TechnologyThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→3

    Micron shares fell 38% in five weeks, below the price line in our case

    Micron closed at $656.39 on 5 November, down from $1,065.11 on 30 September, with no new results. On the last quarter's profit, the whole company now costs about 4.0 times a year of it, down from 6.7.

    What it did to the thesisWe said 4.5 times a year of the latest quarter's operating profit would make the price low enough to rate it Attractive. It is there, so the view moves from Neutral to Attractive at Medium. The business facts are unchanged; December's results are the test.

    4 claims changed
    • C30EditedCounting every diluted share, Micron is worth about $754.9B at $656.39, and its enterprise value is about $699B after $68.3B of net cash, treating the $12.7B of customer deposits as owed.re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $656.39 after the shares fell 38% from the 2026-09-30 close
      Was

      Counting every diluted share, Micron is worth about $1,224.9B at $1,065.11, and its enterprise value is about $1,169B after $68.3B of net cash, treat…

    • C31EditedAt about $699B of enterprise value, a 6% after-tax yield at a 15.5% tax rate needs about $49.7B of GAAP operating income a year, indefinitely. That is 50% of fiscal 2026, 25% of the FQ1 2027 guided pace of $202.2B a year, and 3.3 times the fiscal 2018 record.re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $656.39 after the shares fell 38% from the 2026-09-30 close
      Was

      At about $1,169B of enterprise value, a 6% after-tax yield at a 15.5% tax rate needs about $83.0B of GAAP operating income a year, indefinitely. That…

    • C32EditedAt about $699B the enterprise value is 4.0 times FQ4 2026 GAAP operating income annualised ($175.0B), 3.5 times the FQ1 2027 guided pace and 7.0 times fiscal 2026 operating income.re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $656.39 after the shares fell 38% from the 2026-09-30 close
      Was

      At about $1,169B the enterprise value is 6.7 times FQ4 2026 GAAP operating income annualised ($175.0B), 5.8 times the FQ1 2027 guided pace and 11.8 t…

    • C33EditedThe vendor's panel has fiscal 2028 EPS at $199.85 from 22 analysts, so $656.39 is 3.3 times it. Its positive share is 91.8% of 49 analysts, up from 86.4% of 44 in February. Fiscal 2026 diluted EPS was $74.33.re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $656.39 after the shares fell 38% from the 2026-09-30 close
      Was

      The vendor's panel has fiscal 2028 EPS at $199.85 from 22 analysts, so $1,065.11 is 5.3 times it. Its positive share is 91.8% of 49 analysts, up from…

  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    Lilly will sell Zepbound and Foundayo through Hims & Hers at Lilly's own prices

    Lilly and Hims & Hers announced that patients prescribed by a provider on the Hims & Hers platform can buy Zepbound from $299 a month and Foundayo from $149 a month, the same self-pay prices open to anyone. Hims & Hers committed not to sell compounded copies of Lilly's drugs.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It adds a sales route at existing prices and removes one seller of unapproved copies, which supports our note on copies, but it gives no volume or revenue figure. The 2027 results remain the test. The view stays Neutral.

  • LITELumentum HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Risk / rewardFragile→Speculative
    The betExpensive→Fair
    Valuation1→2

    Lumentum's shares fell 19% in a day, past the price we had marked

    Lumentum's shares closed at $509.70 on 5 November, down 19% from $626.75 the day before. The company filed only a routine deal notice. Counting every share, it is now worth about $51 billion, or 35 times a full year of last quarter's operating profit. Its price is tied to Marvell's by the deal agreed on 2 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe price we had set for a better view, 40 times that profit, has been passed, so we moved Lumentum from Unattractive to Neutral. Conviction stays Medium: one customer is 37% of sales and the price still needs profit to rise 2.5 times.

    1 claim changed
    • C57EditedAt the $509.70 close of 5 November 2026 and counting every share, Lumentum is worth about $51.5B and its enterprise value is about $50.9B, which is about 35.4 times four times Q1 GAAP operating income of $359.8M ($1,439.2M). A 6% after-tax yield on that value needs about $3.7B of GAAP operating income a year, about 2.5 times the Q1 run-rate; on 30 September the same test needed $7.1B (C31) and at the 4 November close $4.5B.re-struck at the 5 November close after reconsider P1 fired: 43.6 times became 35.4
      Was

      At the $626.75 close of 4 November 2026 and counting every share, Lumentum is worth about $63.3B and its enterprise value is about $62.7B, which is a…

  • GNRCGenerac HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    Generac's shares fell to the level we set for a better view

    Generac's shares closed at $172.33 on 5 November, down 11% in a week with no news from the company. The value of the whole company is now about 12 times the profit it guided for this year, the line we wrote down on 28 October. Its quarterly filing, published 3 November, repeated figures we had already read.

    What it did to the thesisWe said that at 12 times this year's profit the price would ask for little of 2027's data-centre growth. It has got there, so we move from Neutral to Attractive. Confidence stays medium: the orders can still be cancelled and the fall was not caused by the company.

    3 claims changed
    • C45EditedAt $172.33 on about 59.0M shares the equity is worth about $10.17B; adding $1.33B of borrowings and taking away $0.39B of cash gives a company value of about $11.11B. That is about 11.9 times 2026 adjusted EBITDA of about $932M at July's guidance midpoints before refunds, 12.0 times the last four quarters' $925M including refunds, 18 times 2026 and 13 times 2027 consensus adjusted EPS (set before the Q3 results), and a 3.5% free cash flow yield on July's guide. Taking away about $50M a year of stock pay, the 2026 figure is about $884M; at the 6 November close of $176.78 company value is about $11.37B, 12.9 times that, and about 9.6 times analysts' 2027 EBITDA of near $1.24B less the same stock pay.Re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $172.33 (was $193.71): company value $11.11B and 11.9 times guided EBITDA before refunds (was $12.37B and 13.3 times).
      Was

      At $193.71 on about 59.0M shares the equity is worth about $11.43B; adding $1.33B of borrowings and taking away $0.39B of cash gives a company value…

    • C46EditedAnalysts' 2027 figures (set before the Q3 results) need sales up about a third to $6.52B, which only the data-centre backlog and the Amazon deliveries can supply, and adjusted EPS up about 47% from 2026's $9.67 less about $0.93 of refunds. At about 19% margin those sales give near $1.24B of EBITDA, putting today's company value near 9.0 times 2027: the price pays for that year landing.Re-struck with C45: company value $11.11B puts the price near 9.0 times the 2027 EBITDA analysts' sales imply (was 10.0 times).
      Was

      Analysts' 2027 figures (set before the Q3 results) need sales up about a third to $6.52B, which only the data-centre backlog and the Amazon deliverie…

    • C64EditedThe shares closed at $172.33 on 5 November 2026, down 11.0% from $193.71 on 27 October and 23.4% from $224.94 on 9 October, against a year's range of $134.80 to $296.44 (to 27 October).Re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close after a further 11.0% fall with no company news; route P1 fired
      Was

      The shares closed at $193.71 on 27 October 2026, the session before the Q3 results: down 13.9% from $224.94 on 9 October, up 0.9% in 252 sessions, ag…

  • FSLYFastlyThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Fastly shares fell 27% in two sessions, below the price line in our case

    Fastly closed at $15.38 on 5 November, down from $21.07 on 3 November, after its results and a slower sales guide. On the latest filed figures the business is now worth about 3.4 times its last year of sales, down from about 4.7 times.

    What it did to the thesisWe said 4.5 times sales on an unchanged business, with customers spending at least 10% more than a year before, would make us Neutral. Both hold, so the view moves from Unattractive to Neutral at Medium. Growth outside the biggest is still slow: not Attractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C12EditedAt $15.38, 161.2M shares are worth about $2.48B; with $324M of notes and $365.2M of cash and securities the business is valued at about $2.44B, about 3.4 times trailing revenue of $719.2M and 3.3 times the 2026 guide's midpoint.re-struck at the 2026-11-05 close of $15.38 after the shares fell 27% from the 2026-11-03 close
      Was

      At $21.07, 161.2M shares are worth about $3.40B; with $324M of notes and $365.2M of cash and securities the business is valued at about $3.36B, about…

  • BNBrookfieldUnchanged

    Two Brookfield-affiliated companies report growth ahead of Brookfield Corporation's own results

    Brookfield Asset Management, 74% owned by Brookfield Corporation, reported fee earnings of $864 million and distributable earnings of $763 million, each up 15% on the year, and raised $25 billion in the quarter. Brookfield Infrastructure reported cash earnings of $0.91 a unit, up 10%.

    What it did to the thesisBoth support the idea that the asset manager keeps growing, which is most of the value behind the shares. But they are partial, and Brookfield Corporation's own earnings on 12 November are the real test. Nothing moved; the view stays Attractive.

  • BEBloom EnergyUnchanged

    NTT DATA says it will buy 900 MW of Bloom fuel cells from 2027

    NTT DATA, a large technology services group, announced an agreement for 900 megawatts of Bloom's fuel cells across several data centre projects, with first shipments in 2027. Bloom calls it its largest international project. The release gives no price, no contract value and no binding terms. Bloom's shares fell that day, in step with other fuel cell companies.

    What it did to the thesisIt is a new named customer, which our case wanted, but nothing is booked as revenue until 2027 and the release does not say how firm it is. The two big buyers still hold 69% of sales. Unattractive at Medium stays.

Thursday 5 November11

  • UBERUber TechnologiesUnchanged

    Amazon switches its Prime restaurant delivery perk from Grubhub to Uber Eats

    Amazon Prime members in the US can now order from Uber Eats inside Amazon's site and app, with no Uber account and no delivery fee on orders over $25. Amazon's deal with Grubhub ended the same day. Neither company gave order volumes, and Uber did not say what the perk costs it.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It gives Uber's delivery business a large new door to customers and takes one from a rival, which fits our view that its two products feed each other. Without figures on orders or cost it cannot change the view; Attractive holds.

  • TENBTenable HoldingsRefreshed

    Tenable's quarterly filing confirms its cash, debt and contracted revenue

    Tenable filed its quarterly report. Revenue was $276.4M, up 9.5%. Contracted future revenue is $1.063B, up 14.4%. It holds $495.3M of cash and investments against $800.0M of new convertible notes, and had 104.5M shares outstanding on 30 October.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The filing confirms what we already read. Net debt of about $305M is small against profit, and pay in shares, the hinge of our Neutral view, is unchanged. The shares are 41% above our price figures.

    6 claims changed
    • C05EditedFull-year 2026 guidance, raised on 28 October to $1.084B to $1.087B, and a fourth-quarter range of $277.0M to $280.0M imply fourth-quarter revenue growth of about 6.9% at the midpoint, against 9.5% in Q3 2026 and 8.6% in Q2 2026.Q3 2026 10-Q (S25) confirms the Q3 revenue of $276.4M behind the 9.5%; the guidance of 28 October stands until the Q4 print, so the shelf life moves to that print.
    • C20EditedContracted future revenue is growing faster than reported revenue: remaining performance obligations reached $1.063B at 30 September 2026, 14.4% above a year earlier, with the portion due within a year up 11.7%, against revenue up 9.5% in the quarter.Q3 2026 10-Q (S25) table: remaining performance obligations $1.063B at 30 September, up 14.4% on $0.929B; the portion due within a year $747.2M, up 11.7% on $669.0M.
      Was

      Contracted future revenue is growing faster than reported revenue: remaining performance obligations reached $1.03B at 30 June 2026, 15.4% above a ye…

    • C21EditedShares outstanding fell 6.8% in six months, from 118.5 million to 110.4 million - but the company issued 3.3 million new shares over the same half, about 5.6% a year before any buying back. By 30 October 2026 the count was 104.5 million, 11.8% below the 118.5 million.Q3 2026 10-Q (S25) cover: 104,507,623 shares outstanding at 30 October 2026, after 18.2M shares bought for $453.8M in the nine months.
      Was

      Shares outstanding fell 6.8% in six months, from 118.5 million to 110.4 million - but the company issued 3.3 million new shares over the same half, a…

    • C22EditedOn 15 September 2026 Tenable repaid its $358.1M secured term loan and replaced it with $800M of unsecured 0.25% convertible notes due September 2031; at 30 September cash and short-term investments were $495.3M and nothing else was borrowed.Q3 2026 10-Q (S25) balance sheet: cash $317.4M plus short-term investments $177.9M = $495.3M at 30 September; the term loan is gone and the notes carry $800.0M principal ($779.0M net).
      Was

      On 15 September 2026 Tenable repaid its $358.1M secured term loan and replaced it with $800M of unsecured 0.25% convertible notes due September 2031;…

    • C23EditedTenable One was a record 50% of new business in Q2 2026, up from 41% in Q1 2026 and 40% a year earlier; it is about a third of total revenue and management targets 40% by the end of 2026.Q3 call (read 28 October) put Tenable One at 59% of new business, held in C43; this claim stays the Q2 record, so its shelf life moves to the next print.
    • C48EditedOn 30 September balances Tenable carries about $305M of net debt ($800M of notes against $495M of cash and short-term investments), 1.1 times its guided 2026 adjusted operating profit of $270M to $273M, while cash interest on borrowing falls from about $23M a year to $2M.Q3 2026 10-Q (S25) balances replace the June pro forma: $800.0M of notes against $495.3M of cash and short-term investments is $304.7M of net debt, 1.1 times the $271.5M midpoint of the raised 2026 adjusted operating profit guide.
      Was

      On 30 June balances the financing takes Tenable from about $60M of net debt to about $316M, 1.2 times its guided 2026 adjusted operating profit, whil…

  • SITMSiTimeThesis changed
    ConvictionLow→Medium

    SiTime's shares fell 9.4% after results, to a price we had marked as attractive

    SiTime's shares closed at $403.27 on 4 November, down 9.4% after its results. Its quarterly filing shows 30.2 million shares and $324 million of cash against $1.35 billion of convertible notes. Company value is now about $13.2 billion, 11 times a year of last quarter's sales. What the company said about December sales was on a call we could not yet read.

    What it did to the thesisThe price we had set for a better view, 12 times sales, has been reached, so we moved SiTime from Neutral to Attractive. Conviction is low because the December outlook, which shows whether orders are real demand, is unread.

    3 claims changed
    • C29EditedAt the $472.56 close of 11 November 2026 and 30.21M shares, SiTime is worth about $14.3B, and $15.3B with net debt of $1,025.7M: about 12.8 times September-quarter sales annualised ($1,194.8M), 11.4 times the December guide's midpoint annualised ($1,344M) and about 29.5 times September's non-GAAP operating profit annualised ($129.5M times four).re-struck at the 4 November close of $403.27 (from $444.88 on 3 November) on the 10-Q share count and balance sheet; the price fell 9.4% after the Q3 print
      Was

      At $509.20 and about 30.1M shares, SiTime is worth about $15.3B, and $16.3B with net debt: about 14 times September-quarter guided sales annualised (…

    • C39EditedAt $472.56 the price is 25.9 times analysts' 2027 EPS of $18.24 (C30), against $14.30 for the September guide's EPS midpoint annualised; the price still asks for growth well beyond the guided pace.multiple re-struck at the 4 November close; consensus EPS held as of 2 October and flagged unread
      Was

      Analysts' 2027 EPS of $14.92 is barely above the guided September quarter annualised ($14.30), so at 34.1 times 2027 EPS the price still asks for gro…

    • C37EditedThe growth is real but order-led: buyers in an AI build-out, short of supply, are ordering a year ahead on cancellable orders, the pattern that ended in 2023's 49% fall.The December outlook on the Q3 call added counter-evidence; the claim itself stands because orders stay cancellable.
  • PWRQuanta ServicesRefreshed

    Quanta's quarterly filing shows its electric business earning 12.6 cents per dollar

    Quanta's quarterly filing shows its electric business kept 12.6 cents of each sales dollar in September, above the 12 cents the chief executive called its best case in July. Over twelve months it earned $2.55 billion from operations, so its shares now cost about 38 times that, down from 51.

    What it did to the thesisThe business is better than we assumed, but the shares are still priced at 38 times operating profit against 21.5 for rivals. Unattractive holds, with low confidence. We move to Neutral if the price falls to 32 times profit with growth still above 15%.

    5 claims changed
    • C06EditedThe chief executive said on the Q2 2026 call that Quanta self-performs 80% to 85% of its work; that 'the electric segment has the ability to operate 10 to 12 on the utility side, 12 would be the utmost margins that you would see'; that on the utility side 'we have ratepayers... It's very much regulated'; and that technology is '15% of the business... call it, 15% to 20%'.The statement is a record of what the chief executive said on the Q2 2026 call, so it is historical rather than current; the Q3 10-Q (S29) shows Electric's own segment margin at 12.6% in September, above the 12% 'utmost' he named, which C41 now carries.
    • C10EditedAt a close of $606.16 on November 12, 2026 Quanta's enterprise value was about $100.9B, 39.7 times trailing operating profit against a median of 21.5 for the three filed-cohort competitors (MYR Group 20.2, MasTec 21.5, Primoris 22.2, as of the September 25 pack). Trailing operating profit, from the filings, was about $2.55B to September 30: 2025's $1.61B plus the first nine months of 2026's $2.06B less the first nine months of 2025's $1.13B.Re-struck at the November 4 close on trailing operating profit to September 30 (Q3 10-Q, S29): 38.1 times from 51.0. The earnings and EBITDA multiples and the own-history comparison of the September 25 pack are not re-struck here; they stay in the frozen pack.
      Was

      At a close of $649.13 on September 25, 2026 Quanta's enterprise value was about 51.0 times trailing operating profit against a median of 21.5 for the…

    • C11EditedWhat the price implies: at the cohort's median of 21.5 times operating profit, today's enterprise value of about $100.9B would need operating profit of about $4.7B, 1.8 times the trailing $2.55B. At the trailing operating margin of 6.8% that is revenue of about $69B - against guided 2026 revenue of $41.3B to $41.6B and an average analyst estimate of $62.9B for 2030. At guided 2026 revenue it is an operating margin of about 11.3%, against 5.7% in 2025, 8.5% in the September quarter, the best yet, and a filed-cohort operating margin median of 5.5%.Re-struck on C10's enterprise value and trailing operating profit: 1.8 times needed from 2.4, 10.9% margin from 12.2%. The 8% consolidated ceiling drops out because the September quarter's 8.5% already exceeded it.
      Was

      What the price implies: at the cohort's median of 21.5 times operating profit, today's enterprise value of about $103.7B would need operating profit…

    • C34EditedThe Energy Information Administration's November 2026 outlook, released November 10, estimates US electric power sector generation up 2.7% in 2026 to a record, driven by growing commercial-sector demand, and forecasts generation growing a slower 1.2% in 2027 as commercial and industrial demand keeps rising, partly offset by lower residential demand after a milder summer.October outlook (S30) replaces the September one: commercial demand growth for 2027 is 2.8% against 2.7%. The September outlook's 2026 sales level and its Texas connection pause were not in the section re-read, so they are dropped from the claim; the next outlook is due 10 November.
      Was

      The Energy Information Administration forecasts US electricity sales of 4,135 billion kilowatt-hours in 2026, almost 2% above 2025, with commercial-s…

    • C41EditedAllocating the $1.11B of corporate costs in the first nine months of 2026 to the segments by revenue, Electric earned about $1.79B of operating profit after its share, a 7.4% margin, and Underground and Infrastructure about $0.27B, 5.0%. In the September quarter Electric's own segment margin was 12.6%, above the 12% 'utmost' the chief executive named in July; with corporate costs at 3.5% of revenue, Electric's margin after its share would be about 9.1%.Q3 10-Q (S29) segment note: re-struck on the nine months to September 30 and the September quarter; Electric's segment margin of 12.6% is above the 12% ceiling the July call named, so the ceiling is now a floor under the quarter, not a limit.
      Was

      Allocating the $1.32B of trailing corporate costs to the segments by revenue, Electric earned about $1.78B of operating profit after its share over t…

  • MXLMaxLinearThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation1→2

    MaxLinear shares fell 25% in two weeks to the price that changes our view

    MaxLinear closed at $56.85 on 4 November, down from $75.79 on 21 October, with no news from the company since its 22 October results. Counting its debt and cash, the company is worth 7.96 times its last year of sales. Analysts raised their 2027 sales estimate to $1.38 billion after the results.

    What it did to the thesisThe price we said would make us reconsider, 8 times sales, is reached, so our view moves from Unattractive to Neutral. The business has not changed. The price now needs about $1.3 billion of sales at a 30% margin, which analysts expect next year.

    3 claims changed
    • C20EditedAt $56.85 on 4 November 2026 the market value is about $5.17B on 91.0M shares; adding the $125.0M term loan and $40.0M of revolver and taking off $81.1M of cash gives an enterprise value near $5.26B. That is 8.0 times trailing revenue of $660.5M (7.96 before rounding), 6.0 times Q3 revenue annualised, 5.3 times the Q4 guide's midpoint annualised and 3.8 times the vendor panel's 2027 revenue estimate, read after the print.re-struck at the 4 November close of $56.85, when the cheaper-price route fired
      Was

      At $75.79 on 21 October 2026 the market value is about $6.90B on 91.0M shares; adding the $125.0M term loan and $40.0M of revolver and taking off $81…

    • C21EditedFor a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, the $5.26B enterprise value needs about $399M of GAAP operating profit. At a 30% operating margin that is about $1.3B of revenue: about 1.2 times the 2022 record of $1.12B, at nearly twice that year's 16.1% margin, and about the vendor panel's $1.38B for 2027. Q3's GAAP operating margin was 13.9%.re-struck at the 4 November close of $56.85, when the cheaper-price route fired
      Was

      For a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, the $6.98B enterprise value needs about $530M of GAAP operating profit. At a 30% operating margin that is about…

    • C23EditedThe vendor's snapshot counts 11 Buy and 6 Hold ratings. Average revenue estimates, read on 5 November after the print, are $776.6M for 2026, $1.38B for 2027 with adjusted earnings of $4.66 a share, $1.83B for 2028 and $1.70B for 2029. Short interest was 5.2% of the float on 15 October.consensus re-read on 5 November, after the Q3 print
      Was

      The vendor's snapshot counts 11 Buy and 6 Hold ratings; its dated series shows 63.6% positive of 11 analysts, up from 36.4% in February. Average reve…

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    Meta, Google and TikTok sued California over a teen feed law

    Meta, Google and TikTok each sued California's attorney general to block a law, due to start in January, that bans automatic video and personalised feeds for users under 16. Companies that do not comply face fines of up to $50,000 per affected child. Meta says the law breaks free-speech rules. The details come from a news report, since the court filing was not read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It adds a new youth-safety legal front to the ones we already watch, but no ruling or amount is set and the law covers only users under 16. We keep Attractive with Low confidence.

  • LITELumentum HoldingsRefreshed

    Lumentum's quarterly filing shows one customer bought 37% of its sales

    Lumentum's quarterly report shows one customer bought 37% of its sales in the quarter, and a second bought 11%. It also gives the share count and cash. Counting every share, Lumentum is worth about $62.7 billion after its shares fell to $626.75, or 43.6 times a full year of last quarter's operating profit.

    What it did to the thesisOur price test was not met: we wait for 40 times, and the count of shares in the daily check was too low. The price worry has eased, but depending on one customer for 37% of sales worsens the other worry. View stays Unattractive.

    4 claims changed
    • C57NewAt the $509.70 close of 5 November 2026 and counting every share, Lumentum is worth about $51.5B and its enterprise value is about $50.9B, which is about 35.4 times four times Q1 GAAP operating income of $359.8M ($1,439.2M). A 6% after-tax yield on that value needs about $3.7B of GAAP operating income a year, about 2.5 times the Q1 run-rate; on 30 September the same test needed $7.1B (C31) and at the 4 November close $4.5B.the 10-Q share count and balance sheet let the live multiple be struck, which reconsider P1 turns on
    • C06EditedIn Q1 fiscal 2027 one end customer was 37% of revenue (22% a year earlier) and a second was 11% (21%), together 48%. For all of fiscal 2026 one unnamed customer was 26.6% and a second 15.0%. The 10-K says most customers buy on purchase orders with no volume or long-term commitment; the 10-Q reports $2,948.9M of binding purchase obligations by Lumentum, not by customers.the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q: the largest customer rose from 26.6% of the year to 37% of the quarter
      Was

      One unnamed end customer was 26.6% of fiscal 2026 revenue (15.4% a year earlier) and a second was 15.0% (16.0%). The 10-K says most customers buy on…

    • C26EditedAt 26 September 2026 Lumentum held $1,979.6M of cash and short-term investments against $1,317.5M of convertible note principal (2026 notes $4.2M, 2028 $21.1M, 2029 $27.2M, 2032 $1,265.0M) and about $90.8M of term loans, total debt $1,399.6M; net cash was about $580M. Note principal must be settled in cash, and $779.9M of notes had asked to convert by 30 October.the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q: cash fell $758.9M to settle note conversions; note principal fell from $1,554.3M to $1,317.5M
      Was

      At 27 June 2026 Lumentum held $2,738.4M of cash and short-term investments against $1,554.3M of convertible note principal (2026 notes $54.8M, 2028 $…

    • C28EditedLumentum had 90.7M common shares on 30 October 2026 against 88.6M on 27 June 2026 and 69.8M on 28 June 2025, plus 2.9M NVIDIA preferred shares that convert one-for-one. Diluted shares used for Q1 earnings per share were 101.7M, including 6.5M from the convertible notes.the Q1 fiscal 2027 10-Q cover page and earnings-per-share note
      Was

      Lumentum had 89.7M common shares on 14 August 2026 against 69.8M on 28 June 2025, plus 2.9M NVIDIA preferred shares that convert one-for-one. It issu…

  • FIXComfort Systems USARefreshed

    Comfort Systems bought back about 660,000 shares since September and authorised 995,000 more

    Comfort Systems says its board added 994,606 shares to its buyback. By 4 November it had bought 11,752,570 shares in all, against about 11.1 million at 30 September. That is roughly 660,000 shares in five weeks, about $0.8 billion by our subtraction, while the shares fell.

    What it did to the thesisIt supports the buyback leg of our next test: management is using the cash customers paid up front. We stay Neutral at Medium. The price has now crossed our line for Attractive, but the route also needs growth and margin to hold at the February report.

    1 claim changed
    • C28EditedComfort Systems stopped buying its own shares for the first half of 2026, then restarted in the third quarter. Share repurchases were $8,232 thousand in the six months to June 30, 2026 against $111,290 thousand in the same period of 2025, but in the September quarter it bought 206,672 shares at an average of $1,649.54, about $340.9 million, which takes nine-month repurchases to $349.1 million including excise tax, at an average of $1,643.85. The count turned down: common shares outstanding were 34,994 thousand at September 30, 2026 against 35,200 thousand at June 30 and 35,272 thousand a year earlier. The programme is not exhausted: 666,914 shares remained authorised at September 30. Cash and cash equivalents rose to $2,158,027 thousand from $1,854,794 thousand of cash and short-term investments at June 30 and $981,898 thousand at December 31, 2025, so the purchase equalled about 18% of the June cash and about a third of the quarter's operating cash flow. Asked about capital deployment on the July 2026 call, the chief financial officer said the company continues 'to keep a sharp eye out for opportunities to buy stock' and that 'we like our stock better than we've ever liked it. We bought some year-to-date, but after the big purchases of last year, we've been a little slower at the first part of the year.' On the October 23 call the chief financial officer said the company has 'always bought our shares more aggressively when they dip', has used 15 to 20% of free cash flow on repurchases over time, and has returned $349 million year to date with about 212 thousand shares retired. On November 5 the company filed an 8-K saying the board had added 994,606 shares to the programme and that through November 4 it had repurchased 11,752,570 shares for $1,711.8 million before excise tax, against a cumulative 11.1 million at September 30 per the 10-Q: the remaining 666,914 shares were bought within five weeks of quarter end, about 0.66 million shares and roughly $0.8 billion by subtraction from the 10-Q's rounded figures, at an average near $1,235 while the shares fell. On November 17 the company filed an 8-K saying that from January 1 through November 16, 2026 it repurchased 1,552,236 shares for $1,891.7 million before excise tax, from ongoing cash flow and part of its cash, and that the board added 679,520 shares to bring the remaining authorisation back to 1,000,000. Against the roughly 212 thousand shares and $349 million of the first nine months, that is about 1.34 million shares and about $1.54 billion in the seven weeks after September 30, by subtraction: about 3.8% of the 34,994 thousand shares outstanding at September 30, at an average near $1,150, and about seven-tenths of the $2.16 billion of cash held at that date.The 5 November 8-K shows the remaining authorisation was used within five weeks of quarter end and the programme was topped off by 994,606 shares.
      Was

      Comfort Systems stopped buying its own shares for the first half of 2026, then restarted in the third quarter. Share repurchases were $8,232 thousand…

  • CCSIConsensus Cloud SolutionsThesis changed

    Consensus lined up a $300M bank loan to pay off its 2028 bonds

    Consensus signed a new bank agreement on 30 September: a $225M revolving line and a $300M loan, both running to 2031. The $300M can only be used to pay off its $348.2M of 6.5% bonds, which it expects to do around 15 October 2027. The agreement itself has not been filed.

    What it did to the thesisThe thesis feared all the debt falling due in one quarter of 2028. Now the bank debt runs to 2031 and the bonds have a committed way to be paid. The loan's covenant tests are unpublished, so the balance-sheet score and the Neutral view stay.

    15 claims changed
    • C54NewOn 30 September 2026 Consensus replaced its credit agreement with a $225.0M revolver and a $300.0M delayed-draw term loan, both maturing 30 September 2031; the delayed-draw loan can be drawn until 15 October 2028 only to retire the $348.2M of 6.5% notes, which it expects to do on about 15 October 2027, when they are redeemable at par.the 8-K filed 2026-10-05 replaced the 2028 bank facility and pre-funded the 2028 notes; nothing in the ledger described either
    • C11-C46Edited · 6Its valid_through of 2026-11-04 passed with no print: the company dates Q3 results and its investor call to 5 November (release headline of 2026-10-0…
    • C24EditedAt 30 September 2026 Consensus owed $551.6M: $348.2M of 6.5% notes maturing 15 October 2028 and $203.4M on a revolver maturing 30 September 2031, with the $300.0M delayed-draw loan reserved for the notes still undrawn (C54).The 8-K of 2026-10-05 replaced the bank facility and moved its maturity to 2031; the 30 June figures stand as the last quarter-end balance, now flagged as superseded by C54.
      Was

      At 30 June 2026 Consensus owed $558.5M: $348M of 6.5% notes maturing 15 October 2028, a $146M term loan and $64M drawn on a revolver under a facility…

    • C52EditedThe 6.5% 2028 notes may be redeemed in whole or part at any time on or after 15 October 2026, at specified redemption prices plus accrued interest, and at par (100%) from 15 October 2027.Its refresh_by of 2026-11-04 fired; the 8-K of 2026-10-05 states the par date and that the new delayed-draw loan is for retiring the notes then.
      Was

      The 6.5% 2028 notes may be redeemed in whole or part at any time on or after 15 October 2026, at specified redemption prices plus accrued interest.

    • C04EditedIn Q3 2026 revenue rose 3.7% to $91.0M: Corporate up 9.1% to $61.4M, SoHo down 6.0% to $29.6M (Q3 2026 results release, 5 Nov 2026).Q3 2026 results read: replaced the Q2 split with the September-quarter split.
      Was

      In Q2 2026 revenue rose 4.1% to $91.361M: Corporate up 9.3% to $60.456M, SoHo down 4.7% to $30.905M.

    • C06EditedConsolidated growth rises each year with no change in either half's own rate, because the declining half carries less weight: in Q3 2026 Corporate's 9.1% on a 64.1% weight of the year-earlier quarter is 5.8 points and SoHo's minus 6.0% on 35.9% is minus 2.2, for 3.7%.Re-struck on the Q3 2026 split.
      Was

      Consolidated growth rises each year with no change in either half's own rate, because the declining half carries less weight: Corporate's 9.3% on a 6…

    • C07EditedCorporate monthly churn rose from 1.49% in 2023 to 2.36% in 2024 to 3.03% in 2025, was 3.16% in Q2 2026, and was 3.87% in Q3 2026 against 2.73% a year earlier (restated for removed duplicate accounts).Q3 2026 release: churn rose to 3.87%, the highest in the series and over the 3.5% line for the first of two reports the criterion needs.
      Was

      Corporate monthly churn rose from 1.49% in 2023 to 2.36% in 2024 to 3.03% in 2025, and was 3.16% in Q2 2026 against 2.91% a year earlier.

    • C09EditedRevenue per corporate account fell from $315.51 a month in 2023 to $300.03 in 2025, recovered to $304.86 in Q2 2026 and slipped to $301.42 in Q3 2026 against $300.16 a year earlier, while corporate accounts grew from 54,000 to 67,000 in 2025 and 69,000 in Q3 2026.Q3 2026 release: revenue per account slipped back below the $305 the test asked for.
      Was

      Revenue per corporate account fell from $315.51 a month in 2023 to $300.03 in 2025, recovering to $304.86 in Q2 2026, while corporate accounts grew f…

    • C10EditedCorporate revenue growth is coming from account count rather than from spend per account: in Q3 2026 accounts rose 9.5% (69,000 against 63,000, restated) and revenue per account about 0.4%.Q3 2026 release: the same split, with spend per account flatter than in Q2.
      Was

      Corporate revenue growth is coming from account count rather than from spend per account: in Q2 2026 accounts rose 9.4% and revenue per account about…

    • C26EditedManagement guides FY2026 to revenue of $360M to $364M (narrowed from $350M-$364M), adjusted cash operating profit of $188M to $192M (from $182M-$193M) and adjusted earnings of $6.00 to $6.10 a share (raised from $5.55-$5.95); the Q4 revenue guide is $88.9M to $92.9M. The release does not restate the free cash flow guide of about $106M.Q3 2026 release (5 Nov): guidance narrowed and the earnings range raised; replaces the August ranges.
      Was

      Management guides FY2026 to revenue of $350M to $364M, adjusted cash operating profit of $182M to $193M, adjusted earnings of $5.55 to $5.95 a share,…

  • AMZNAmazon.comUnchanged

    The FTC says Amazon secretly raised ad prices; Amazon denies it

    The US Federal Trade Commission and 22 states sued Amazon on 31 August, saying it secretly pushed up the prices advertisers pay in its ad auctions, most on busy days like Prime Day and Black Friday. A 5 November Wall Street Journal headline says prices tripled on those days; we could not open it. Amazon says the claim is false.

    What it did to the thesisAdvertising is Amazon's third growth engine, so this is a risk to watch, but it is an unproven claim with no penalty set. Nothing in our case moved; it turns on cloud growth, backlog and cash flow, next tested at the fourth-quarter report.

  • AAOIApplied OptoelectronicsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral

    Applied Optoelectronics shares fell below our price line ahead of tonight's results

    Applied Optoelectronics closed at $59.27 on 4 November, down from $67.51 on 23 October, with no company news about the business. Counting the shares it sold in August and all its cash, the company is worth at least 7.5 times its last year of sales. It also filed a new $200 million bank credit agreement.

    What it did to the thesisThe price we said would make us reconsider, 8 times sales, is now reached, so our view moves from Unattractive to Neutral. The business is unchanged and the price still needs about $1.7 billion of sales. Tonight's results replace the figures this rests on.

    9 claims changed
    • C51NewAfter 30 September AOI signed a three-year agreement with a hyperscale data center customer, which is obligated under conditions to buy 10% of certain 1.6 Tb transceiver products from June 2026 to May 2029. AOI must supply them, including building any additional capacity, at agreed maximum prices. The 10-Q states no dollar value; on the 5 November call management estimated $1B-$1.5B of revenue over the term 'although it could vary significantly', with some price reductions over the period and no capital committed by the customer. Actual volumes depend on the customer's demand.disclosed in the Q3 2026 10-Q as a subsequent event
    • C26EditedAt $59.27 on 4 November 2026 the market value is about $5.38B on 90.77M shares (the 10-Q cover count of 2 November); adding $111.5M of bank loans and acceptances and $125M of convertibles and taking off $621.5M of cash including restricted cash at 30 September gives an enterprise value of about $4.99B. That is about 6.7 times trailing revenue of $747.3M and about 4.9 times the roughly $1.0B 2026 guide.re-struck on the filed Q3 balance sheet and trailing revenue after the 5 November results
      Was

      At $67.51 on 23 October 2026 the market value is about $6.09B on about 90.26M shares (84.57M on 3 August plus the 5.69M sold in the finished August p…

    • C27EditedFor a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, an enterprise value of about $4.99B needs about $379M of operating profit. At a 20% operating margin that is about $1.9B of revenue, 2.5 times the trailing year and 1.9 times the 2026 guide, but below the vendor panel's $2.96B for 2027.re-struck with C26 on the filed Q3 balance sheet
      Was

      For a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, an enterprise value of at least $5.21B needs about $396M of operating profit. At a 20% operating margin that is…

    • C11EditedManagement guided third-quarter 2026 revenue of $255M-$290M and said in August that 2026 revenue would be around $1.1B. Q3 came in at $269.9M. The fourth-quarter guide is revenue of $385M-$420M, non-GAAP gross margin of 29.5%-31% and non-GAAP net income of $45.9M-$60.4M on about 96M shares, so 2026 revenue is $998M-$1,033M ($343.1M in the first half plus $269.9M plus the guide), not $1.1B and not the $484M fourth quarter the August guide implied.Q3 release: Q4 guided to $385M-$420M, so 2026 lands near $1.0B, not $1.1B
      Was

      Management guides third-quarter 2026 revenue of $255M-$290M, non-GAAP gross margin of 29%-30.5% and non-GAAP net income of $10.1M-$24.0M on about 92.…

    • C12EditedManagement targets about $471M a month of data center transceiver revenue by the end of 2027 (100G and 400G $90M, 800G $217M, 1.6T $164M), raised in May 2026 from $378M a month and, on the 5 November call, moved from mid-2027 to 'towards the end of 2027' because the Phase II Sugar Land build is delayed by several months awaiting electrical power; 800G revenue was $47.5M in Q3 (nearly four times Q2), below the $55M the thesis looked for; capacity of over 650,000 800G and 1.6T units a month by end-2026 and 930,000 by end-2027 (on 5 November the equipment installed for the end of 2026 was put at over 500,000 a month, and the end-2027 figure raised to over 1 million, with the 2027 US build running late for lack of electrical power); and over $325M a year of CATV revenue.Q3 release cut the end-2026 capacity statement to 500,000 a month and raised end-2027 to 1 million
      Was

      Management targets about $471M a month of data center transceiver revenue by mid-2027 (100G and 400G $90M, 800G $217M, 1.6T $164M), raised in May 202…

    • C15EditedIn the first nine months of 2026 operating cash flow was minus $76.7M, capital expenditure $702.1M and investing outflow $1.11B, while financing brought in $1.59B, nearly all from at-the-market share sales. Cash including restricted cash was $621.5M at 30 September. Management expects spending to stay elevated through 2027. On the call management said it signed a $200M US bank loan after quarter end, could raise US bank debt to $400M-$500M within twelve months, is leaning more on debt than on share sales, and described 2027 capital spending as 'could be lower' than 2026 while the prepared remarks said it would increase further.re-stated on the Q3 10-Q: nine-month cash flow
      Was

      In the first half of 2026 operating cash flow was minus $73.8M, capital expenditure $335.1M and investing outflow $633.7M, while financing brought in…

    • C16EditedShares outstanding rose from 75,198,817 on 24 February 2026 to 84,569,237 on 3 August 2026, 12.5% in five months, after selling about 7.78M shares at the market between March and June. Diluted weighted shares were 81.6M in the second quarter against 56.8M a year earlier, the Q3 guide assumes 92.8M, and a third $600M at-the-market programme was signed on 21 August. On 5 October the company said it had completed that programme: 5,694,845 shares at an average $105.36, $588.0M net of commissions. The 10-Q cover shows 90,770,732 shares on 2 November, 9.2M short of the 100M in the third invalidation criterion, and the Q4 guide assumes about 96M diluted shares.10-Q cover count of 2 November replaces the estimate
      Was

      Shares outstanding rose from 75,198,817 on 24 February 2026 to 84,569,237 on 3 August 2026, 12.5% in five months, after selling about 7.78M shares at…

    • C26EditedAt $59.27 on 4 November 2026 the market value is about $5.38B on 90.77M shares (the 10-Q cover count of 2 November); adding $111.5M of bank loans and acceptances and $125M of convertibles and taking off $621.5M of cash including restricted cash at 30 September gives an enterprise value of about $4.99B. That is about 6.7 times trailing revenue of $747.3M and about 4.9 times the roughly $1.0B 2026 guide.re-struck on the filed Q3 balance sheet and trailing revenue after the 5 November results
      Was

      At $59.27 on 4 November 2026 the market value is about $5.35B on about 90.26M shares (84.57M on 3 August plus the 5.69M sold in the finished August p…

    • C27EditedFor a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, an enterprise value of about $4.99B needs about $379M of operating profit. At a 20% operating margin that is about $1.9B of revenue, 2.5 times the trailing year and 1.9 times the 2026 guide, but below the vendor panel's $2.96B for 2027.re-struck with C26 on the filed Q3 balance sheet
      Was

      For a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, an enterprise value of at least $4.47B needs about $340M of operating profit. At a 20% operating margin that is…

Wednesday 4 November3

  • IONQIonQUnchanged

    IonQ completes its Elisity deal, paid for with its own shares

    IonQ said it finished buying Elisity, a company that secures corporate networks, on 4 November. It paid in IonQ shares and the release does not say how many. Elisity has more than 100 business customers and will keep its current leaders.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We already counted this deal as adding roughly 6 to 10 percent more shares. The exact count and Elisity's sales come with IonQ's filing and its results on 5 November. View stays Unattractive.

  • HPQHPRefreshed

    HP picks former GSK chief Emma Walmsley as its next chief executive

    HP named Emma Walmsley, who ran drug maker GSK until December 2025, as chief executive from 4 January 2027. Bruce Broussard, who has filled in since February, becomes chair. Separately, Intel said high memory prices have cut PC demand; HP's shares fell 9.6% that day and are 16% lower than on 22 October.

    What it did to the thesisA named leader removes one open risk, but she has said nothing yet about costs, dividend or buybacks. Intel's warning leans on the unit outlook our view already doubts. The test is the 24 November forecast; Neutral holds.

    7 claims changed
    • C41NewIntel's September-quarter filing, three days after HP's October guide was read, says demand for certain client (PC) products eased from the first half because of high memory prices, expects substrate and memory shortages to last into next year, and its PC chip revenue fell 5% to $8.1B. HP's shares fell 9.6% on 30 October, to $28.78, the day after Intel reported.a supplier's own filing on the PC market, which bears on management's unit outlook
    • C07EditedOn the August call the chief financial officer said PC units across the industry would fall by the high teens in the second half of 2026 as price rises pressure demand, that memory would take a larger share of a PC's cost, that the benefit of cheaper older inventory was largely behind it, that the October quarter would be the low for Personal Systems margins, and that Print's 16% to 19% margin range holds in fiscal 2027.read against Intel's filing (C41): the supplier also reports softer PC demand on memory prices, so the unit outlook is not contradicted but its second half looks harder
    • C26EditedChief executive Enrique Lores left on 2 February 2026. On 4 November the board named Emma Walmsley, GSK's chief executive from April 2017 to December 2025 and a Microsoft director, to succeed him from 4 January 2027; Bruce Broussard, interim chief executive since February on $362,500 a month and a $7M share award vesting in February 2027, becomes chair then.the board named a permanent chief executive
      Was

      Chief executive Enrique Lores left on 2 February 2026 to take a job outside HP. Director Bruce Broussard, a former Humana chief executive, is interim…

    • C32EditedThe shares closed at $28.27 on 3 November 2026, up 14% in a year after a 9.6% fall on 30 October when Intel warned of weaker PC demand; they are 16.3% below the $33.76 close of 22 October and above the 52-week low of $17.56 in February.re-struck at the 3 November close after the Intel-day fall
      Was

      The shares closed at $33.76 on 22 October 2026, up 19.9% in a year and 62.1% in 120 sessions, from a 52-week low of $17.56 in February; over six mont…

    • C33EditedAt $28.27 the shares are 8.7 times the fiscal 2026 non-GAAP guide midpoint, 9.3 times it without refunds and 8.9 times the fiscal 2027 consensus read on 22 October; the vendor's trailing GAAP multiple, struck at $33.76, was 12.7 against a six-year median of about 9.0.re-struck at the 3 November close
      Was

      At $33.76 the shares are 10.4 times the fiscal 2026 non-GAAP guide midpoint, 11.1 times it without refunds and 10.6 times fiscal 2027 consensus; the…

    • C34EditedOf 52 analysts in the vendor's snapshot 16 rate HP a buy, 28 a hold and 8 a sell; consensus expects $3.26 a share for fiscal 2026, $3.19 for fiscal 2027 and $3.39 for fiscal 2028. The dated series shows the positive share falling from 21.1% in February to 10.0% in October.consensus figures are as of 22 October and were not re-read; the price has since fallen
    • C40EditedIf memory keeps rising in fiscal 2027 while units fall again, Personal Systems can hold its revenue only on higher prices, which is what cost HP the most share of any large maker in the September quarter.Intel's filing (C41) says memory shortages persist into next year, which weighs on management's view that memory costs rise more slowly
  • BWXTBWX TechnologiesUnchanged

    BWXT is refinancing its two 4.125% bonds with a new $500M bond and cash

    BWXT launched a $500M bond due 2034. It will use the money and cash on hand to buy back all of its $800M of 4.125% bonds due 2028 and 2029. It also pushed its $1.25B bank credit line out a year, to November 2031, and loosened some conditions if it earns investment-grade ratings.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our argument moved. Debt would fall by about $300M, and the cost of the new bond is not yet known. The business case rests on naval work and nuclear orders, not on this refinancing. Neutral and medium confidence hold.

Tuesday 3 November12

  • VSHVishay IntertechnologyThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Vishay shares fell to $25.52, down 33% in a month, with no company news

    Vishay closed at $25.52 on 2 November, down from $38.18 on 2 October. The company filed nothing and reported nothing. It is now valued at about 1.08 times a year of sales, down from 1.67, and inside the 0.85 to 1.15 range it fetched at past year-ends.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Unattractive to Neutral. We called the shares full only because they paid for peak profit; at this price they count only part of it. The business has not changed, and the 4 November results test the orders and the margin.

    3 claims changed
    • C21EditedThe shares closed at $25.52 on November 2, 2026, down 33.2% from $38.18 on October 2 and 63.3% below the $69.47 peak of June 18, with no results, filing or company news in between; on November 3 they closed at $27.22. On October 2 they were up 147.6% in 252 sessions: sales per share rose 35.6% and the price paid per dollar of them 82.6%. They closed at $29.96 on July 29 and fell 14.6% to $33.18 the day after the June-quarter beat.re-struck at the 2 November close ($25.52), 33.2% below the 2 October close the figures were struck at; no news
      Was

      The shares closed at $38.18 on October 2, 2026, up 147.6% in 252 sessions: sales per share rose 35.6% and the price paid per dollar of them 82.6%. Th…

    • C24EditedAt $27.22 (the 3 November close) the 153.4M shares are worth about $4.18B and, less about $395M of net cash, the company about $3.78B: 1.08 times the $3,507.7M of filed trailing revenue. Its year-end company value to sales ran from 0.85 to 1.15 over 2020 to 2025, a median near 0.93.re-struck at the 2 November close ($25.52), 33.2% below the 2 October close the figures were struck at; no news
      Was

      At $38.18 the 153.4M shares are worth about $5.86B and, less about $315M of net cash, the company about $5.54B: 1.67 times the $3,319.4M of filed tra…

    • C25EditedAt $27.22 the shares are 10.3 times 2028 consensus EPS of $2.64, a forecast that implies about $0.6B of operating profit, close to 2022's $615.5M, on revenue of $4.74B, 36% above 2022. Per share that is still below 2022's $2.98. The consensus is the one of October 2 and has not been re-read since the fall or the print, so the price pays for part of that recovery rather than all of it.re-struck at the 2 November close ($25.52), 33.2% below the 2 October close the figures were struck at; no news
      Was

      The price pays for record sales at near-peak margins: 2028 consensus EPS of $2.64 puts it at 14.5 times, and implies about $0.6B of operating profit,…

  • TYLTyler TechnologiesUnchanged

    West Virginia's schools pick Tyler for a statewide finance and payroll system

    West Virginia's Department of Education chose Tyler's cloud software for finance and payroll across 65 education agencies, including 55 county school districts, serving about 250,000 students. It won a competitive bidding process. No price or length of contract was available, and the company's own release could not be read; this comes from a summary of it.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It fits our view that Tyler's finance software still wins state bids, but it is one contract with no value given. The risk we watch is a large state project going wrong, as two did in 2025.

  • TLSTelosUnchanged

    Telos wins a one-year State Department deal for its security software

    Telos says the State Department gave it a one-year contract for Xacta 360, its software that tracks whether government computer systems meet security rules, plus related services. The announcement we could read gave no dollar value or start date.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It fits the point that agencies keep paying for Xacta, but with no size it adds nothing to the $500M of bids we are waiting on. We keep Neutral and wait for the 9 November results.

  • STXSeagate Technology HoldingsThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation1→2

    Seagate shares fell a third in a month as profit forecasts rose

    Seagate closed at $593.76 on 2 November, down from $887.09 on 5 October, while analysts raised what they expect it to earn next year to $40.14 a share. Buyers now pay about 15 times that profit, below the 15 times we set in October as the price that would move our view. No new results or filings arrived.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Unattractive to Neutral. The price no longer pays a peak price for peak profit, but next year's forecast still needs margins drive makers never kept through a downturn, so conviction stays Medium.

    3 claims changed
    • C13EditedSeagate closed at $593.76 on 2 November 2026, a market value of $139.2B, 48.1% below its 252-day high of $1,145 and 33.1% below the $887.09 of 5 October. Over 252 trading days the price rose 121.3%: sales per share rose 40.6%, the diluted share count 2.65%, and what buyers pay for each dollar of sales rose from 6.34 to 9.98 times.re-struck at the 2 November close of $593.76 on November consensus; route P1 fired
      Was

      Seagate closed at $887.09 on 5 October 2026, a market value of $198.9B, 22.5% below its 252-day high of $1,145. Over 252 trading days the price rose…

    • C14EditedAnalysts' average forecast is $40.14 of adjusted earnings a share for the year to July 2027 on sales of $20.23B (13 analysts), $65.81 for the year to July 2028 on $28.56B (12) and $91.95 for FY29 on $36.05B (6). 29 rate the shares a buy, 19 a hold and 4 a sell; the share of positive ratings was 84.6% of 26 analysts on 1 November, against 82.1% of 28 on 1 October.re-struck at the 2 November close of $593.76 on November consensus; route P1 fired
      Was

      Analysts' average forecast is $36.16 of adjusted earnings a share for the year to July 2027 on sales of $18.73B (12 analysts), $57.02 for the year to…

    • C15EditedAt $499.00, the 16 November close, the shares cost about 12.4 times analysts' FY27 EPS and 7.6 times FY28's. FY28's consensus keeps about 53% of revenue as profit, against 26.1% in FY26 and 14.1% at the last peak in FY22: the price does not pay a peak multiple on those forecasts, but the forecast still needs margins this industry has never held through a cycle.re-struck at the 2 November close of $593.76 on November consensus; route P1 fired
      Was

      At $887.09 the shares cost about 24.5 times analysts' FY27 EPS and 15.6 times FY28's. FY28's consensus keeps about 52% of revenue as profit, against…

  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    SpaceX is reported to be in talks to buy Boost Mobile; no deal confirmed

    The Washington Post reported on 2 November that SpaceX is talking with EchoStar about buying Boost Mobile, a phone service with about 7.5 million customers that rents its network from AT&T and T-Mobile. Neither company has confirmed it, and there is no price. Barron's headline says buying; the other reports we read say talks.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We rate SpaceX Unattractive on price and heavy spending. A phone-service purchase would add cost and could need the carriers' consent, but with nothing agreed or priced there is no figure to add to the argument yet.

  • NTAPNetAppUnchanged

    NetApp finishes buying PEAK:AIO, a small AI storage software company

    NetApp says it has completed its purchase of PEAK:AIO, a UK company whose software helps very large AI computer clusters find their files quickly. The deal was announced in late September with no price. The completion release itself could not be read, so no terms or dates beyond the title are known.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It strengthens NetApp's AI storage product against private rivals VAST and WEKA, but with no price or revenue given it changes none of our figures. Our case turns on the 1 December results.

  • MRVLMarvell TechnologyThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    Marvell shares fell 37% in a month, most of it after the Lumentum deal

    Marvell closed at $171.41 on 2 November, down from $272.29 on 2 October, and 12.7% down from 30 October, the day before it agreed to buy Lumentum for stock. At that price it costs about 25.4 times analysts' profit forecast for the year to January 2028, down from 40.3. No new results or filings arrived.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Unattractive to Neutral. The shares were full because they paid for this plan and much of the next year; now the next year comes at a discount. The business has not changed, but forecasts predate the Lumentum deal, so conviction stays Medium.

    2 claims changed
    • C13EditedMarvell closed at $171.41 on 2 November 2026, 37.0% below its $272.29 close of 2 October and 48% below the $329.88 high of the year to 2 October, the day after it agreed to buy Lumentum for stock. Over the 252 trading days to 2 October the price had risen 224.6%: sales per share rose 23.4% and what buyers pay for each dollar of sales rose 163%.re-struck at the 2 November close, 37.0% below the 2 October close the price claims were struck at, after the Lumentum agreement
      Was

      Marvell closed at $272.29 on 2 October 2026, a market value of $237.55B, against a 52-week range of $70.69 to $329.88. Over 252 trading days the pric…

    • C15EditedAt $171.41 the shares cost about 25.4 times analysts' FY28 EPS of $6.76 and about 16.4 times FY29's $10.47. Counting this year's rate of stock pay as a cost, FY28 EPS falls to about $5.53 and the price to about 31 times. Both forecasts date from 5 October, before the Lumentum agreement, and analysts have not yet restated them.re-struck at the 2 November close ($171.41), 37.0% below the 2 October close; route P1 fired
      Was

      At $272.29 the shares cost about 40.3 times analysts' FY28 EPS of $6.76 and about 26.0 times FY29's $10.47. Counting this year's rate of stock pay as…

  • METAMeta PlatformsRefreshed

    Meta borrowed another $15 billion in bonds, paying 5.85% to 7.5%

    Meta sold $15 billion of bonds in five parts that come due between 2031 and 2056, paying interest of 5.85% to 7.5% a year. It says the money is for general purposes and it may sell more bonds in euros. This follows the $37.5 billion of shares and preferred stock it sold on 26 October.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The borrowing confirms Meta is paying for its AI build with outside money, which our caution already reflects. Cash and debt rose by the same amount, so its net cash stays near $1.5 billion. We keep Attractive with Low confidence.

    1 claim changed
    • C44EditedOn 26 October 2026 Meta launched about $35 billion (priced the same evening at about $37.5 billion, see below) of underwritten offerings: 250,000,000 depositary shares (about $12.5 billion at a $50 liquidation preference each) in a mandatory convertible preferred stock that converts into common stock on 15 August 2029, and $22.5 billion of Class A common stock sold by banks through forward sale agreements, for which Meta receives nothing at the start and gets cash only when the agreements settle (S32, S33). It also plans a further ATM program of about $60 billion once Class C stock trades, with no agreement signed and no timing or size fixed, making about $95 billion in all. Nvidia, AMD and Broadcom together indicated interest in up to $5.0 billion of the common stock, which is not binding. Proceeds are for 'general corporate purposes'. Meta says it will fund the build from 'a balanced mix of operating cash flow, investment-grade debt, strategic partnerships, and equity capital', and cites $97 billion of operating cash flow in nine months and about $82 billion of cash at the end of September (S33). The pack's market value was $1.91 trillion at the 25 September close (S05), so $95 billion is about 5% of it. At pricing the Class A offering was upsized from $22.5 billion to $25.0 billion, 40,000,000 shares at $625.00 against a $630.56 last sale, and the preferred carries a 6.50% dividend and converts into 0.0681 to 0.0800 Class A shares per depositary share around 15 August 2029, so the launched total is about $37.5 billion and about $97.5 billion with the planned ATM (S34, S35). Press reports say Nvidia will put $3 billion into the equity offering; the filings name no buyer, so that part is reported and not filed. On 3 November 2026 Meta priced $15.0 billion of senior notes in five series: $3.25 billion at 5.850% due 2031, $3.25 billion at 6.250% due 2033, $4.0 billion at 6.550% due 2036, $1.75 billion at 7.350% due 2046 and $2.75 billion at 7.500% due 2056, for 'general corporate purposes', rated Aa3 with a stable outlook by Moody's and AA- with a negative outlook by S&P, with settlement on 5 November (S36, S37). The prospectus says Meta may launch a euro-denominated note offering, with no assurance, and that it issued additional depositary shares of the preferred on 2 November for net proceeds of about $1.87 billion. At 30 September long-term debt was $80.92 billion, so the notes take it to about $95.9 billion before the euro notes; cash and securities were $82.45 billion, to which the proceeds add (S37).3 November: $15.0B of senior notes priced at 5.850% to 7.500% (S36, S37); $1.87B of additional preferred depositary shares issued 2 November; euro notes possible
  • HLIOHelios TechnologiesRefreshed

    Helios set its third-quarter results for after 2 November, not before

    Helios announced the date of its third-quarter results and call; our calendar puts it on 5 November, three days later than the date we assumed. We could read only the headline. It filed nothing else, and other news was awards and a partnership.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our guidance and order claims expired on 2 November waiting for this report, so we pushed their dates to 5 November. The test, whether earnings reach $0.70 to $0.77 and a data centre order arrives, is unchanged. View stays Neutral.

    4 claims changed
    • C07EditedHelios's 2026 outlook as of November 5: sales of $895-902M (from $880-900M), adjusted EBITDA margin 20.2-20.4% (from 20.2-21.0%) and adjusted earnings of $3.08-3.15 a share (from $3.05-3.25), now including the Radio Sound purchase; Q4 sales $205-212M, margin 18.5-19.5% and adjusted earnings $0.60-0.67.Shelf life rolled from 2026-11-02 to the 2026-11-05 Q3 print date: no 8-K or release since the 10 August guidance was filed (latest 8-K is 25 September, before the thesis), so the guidance and order-intake claims stand until that print replaces them.
    • C08EditedThe new full-year outlook implies second-half adjusted earnings of $1.40 to $1.47 a share (Q3's $0.80 plus Q4's $0.60-0.67) against $1.53 in the second half of 2025 -- a fall of about 6% at the midpoint, 9% at the bottom and 4% at the top; the bottom is above the $1.37 line. On the call management explained the lower fourth quarter: last year had an extra week worth nearly $10M of sales and $4M to $5M of orders came early this year.Shelf life rolled from 2026-11-02 to the 2026-11-05 Q3 print date: no 8-K or release since the 10 August guidance was filed (latest 8-K is 25 September, before the thesis), so the guidance and order-intake claims stand until that print replaces them.
    • C09EditedQ3 2026 sales were $229.7M against a $215-222M guide, adjusted EBITDA margin 20.3% against 19.8-20.6% and adjusted earnings $0.80 against $0.70-0.77, up 11% on a year. Management says sales and earnings beat the top of the range partly because customers ordered early ahead of announced price increases.Shelf life rolled from 2026-11-02 to the 2026-11-05 Q3 print date: no 8-K or release since the 10 August guidance was filed (latest 8-K is 25 September, before the thesis), so the guidance and order-intake claims stand until that print replaces them.
    • C20EditedOrder intake grew by double digits over the year-ago period for the fourth consecutive quarter in Q2 2026; on the Q3 call management said orders dipped slightly after July and picked up again as the quarter ended and into October, and gave no growth rate.Shelf life rolled from 2026-11-02 to the 2026-11-05 Q3 print date: no 8-K or release since the 10 August guidance was filed (latest 8-K is 25 September, before the thesis), so the guidance and order-intake claims stand until that print replaces them.
  • GOOGAlphabetThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation2→3

    Alphabet shares fell 18% in a month after its third-quarter results

    Alphabet closed at $278.04 on 2 November, down from $340.35 on 2 October. Buyers now pay about 22 times its yearly operating profit, down from about 28, and below the 22.5 times we set in October as the price that would make it attractive. No new results or filings arrived.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Neutral to Attractive. The price now pays for the AI spending working as planned and little beyond it. Cash is still below zero and 2027 spending rises, so conviction stays Medium.

    4 claims changed
    • C29EditedThe shares closed at $278.04 on November 2, 2026, 18.3% below the $315.35 of October 2 and 31.3% below the year's high of $404.47, a market value of $3.41T and enterprise value of $3.49T by the vendor's count, about $3.17T net of $344.0B of securities and stakes and with $18.0B of preferred added; over 252 sessions the price fell 1.4% while sales per share rose 20.6% and the multiple fell 18.2%.re-struck at the 2 November close of $278.04 on Q3 2026 trailing profit; route P1 fired
      Was

      The shares closed at $340.35 on October 2, 2026, a market value of $4.13T and enterprise value of $4.19T by the vendor's count; over 252 sessions the…

    • C30EditedNet of securities and investments and with preferred added, enterprise value is 20.1 times trailing operating profit against 17.4 for Meta, 23.9 for Microsoft and 27.5 for Amazon (the vendor's figures, which net cash alone, read 22.2, 18.6, 24.4 and 28.1), and the trailing P/E at 14.3 against 20.0 to 27.2 for the same three.re-struck at the 2 November close of $278.04 on Q3 2026 trailing profit; route P1 fired
      Was

      The vendor puts enterprise value at 28.3 times trailing operating profit against 22.5 for Meta, 25.5 for Microsoft and 30.4 for Amazon, and the trail…

    • C31EditedOn the vendor's six-year history the trailing P/E has a median of 24.8; free cash flow yield is 0.6% against a median of 3.5%, and return on invested capital 14.8% against 22.0%.re-struck at the 2 November close of $278.04 on Q3 2026 trailing profit; route P1 fired
      Was

      On the vendor's six-year history the trailing P/E has a median of 24.8; free cash flow yield is 1.3% against a median of 3.5%, and return on invested…

    • C32EditedAt $278.04 the market value is about 26 times trailing operating profit after a 17% tax. To fall to the six-year median P/E of 24.8, operating profit would have to rise about 5%.re-struck at the 2 November close of $278.04 on Q3 2026 trailing profit; route P1 fired
      Was

      At $340.35 the market value is about 34 times trailing operating profit after a 17% tax. To fall to the six-year median P/E of 24.8, operating profit…

  • CRWDCrowdStrike HoldingsUnchanged

    CrowdStrike agrees to buy two AI-security start-ups, Dreadnode and Fiddler

    CrowdStrike said on 3 November it has signed agreements to buy Dreadnode, which tests AI systems for security weaknesses, and Fiddler AI, which watches what AI agents do. We could read only the start of each announcement. Neither price, closing date nor revenue was in what we could read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We already count a steady run of purchases paid mostly in cash, and we rate CrowdStrike Unattractive on its high stock pay and thin profit. Two more deals add to that spending, but without prices there is nothing to restate; the next filing will give them.

  • CIENCienaThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Ciena shares fell to $284.34, down 27% in a month, with no company news

    Ciena closed at $284.34 on 2 November, down from $391.34 on 2 October. It filed and reported nothing. Counting its debt, it is now valued at about 55 times a year of operating profit, down from 76, which pays for about 69% of management's 2029 plan rather than almost all of it.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays Neutral. The lower price meets half of the route to Attractive; the other half is order backlog of $10B or more, which is only reported in December. The price now looks fair for the plan, so we scored it Fair rather than Full.

    1 claim changed
    • C30EditedAt $284.34 Ciena's company value is about $40.8B, 55.2 times trailing GAAP operating profit and about 18.5 times the roughly $2.2B of adjusted operating profit the fiscal 2027 guide implies. The fiscal 2029 targets imply about $14.1B of revenue and roughly $4.4B of operating profit after share pay; at 18 times, discounted three years at 10%, that is worth about $59.5B. The price pays for about 69% of that, or 82% at 15 times.re-struck at the 2 November close ($284.34), 27.3% below the 2 October close it was struck at; no results, filing or company news in between
      Was

      At $391.34 Ciena's company value is about $55.96B, 75.7 times trailing GAAP operating profit and about 26 times the roughly $2.2B of adjusted operati…

Monday 2 November8

  • TTMITTM TechnologiesThesis changed

    TTM's filing shows two customers buy 27% of its sales, less than we feared

    TTM's quarterly filing says one customer bought 20% of September-quarter sales and two customers together 27% of the first nine months, under the 30% we had set as a worry line. TTM also spent $100 million buying back 1.16 million shares at about $86 each and approved another $100 million.

    What it did to the thesisThe customer worry we set before the filing is met, but the other half of our condition, the new boards reaching about $300 million, only shows in the report due early February. The view stays Neutral. The lower share price did not change the facts.

    2 claims changed
    • C09EditedOne customer was about 20% of net sales in the September quarter and two customers together about 27% of the three quarters to September 2026, against 26% for two customers in the June quarter and first half and 22% for two customers in the first three quarters of 2025; the five largest customers were 42% of the quarter and 44% of the nine months, and the ten largest were 55% in the June quarter.The Q3 10-Q put the largest customer at 20% of the quarter and two customers at 27% of nine months, under the 30% line the route was written against
      Was

      Two customers were about 26% of net sales in the June quarter and first half of 2026, against one customer at about 12% a year earlier; in 2025 two c…

    • C29EditedThere were 105,348,864 shares at 31 July 2026; the June-quarter diluted count of 107.6M was 2.6% above a year earlier, first-half stock pay was $37.6M, about twice a year earlier, and a $100M buyback authorisation stood unused; on 26 and 27 October TTM spent it, buying about 1.16 million shares at an average $86.31, and authorised a new $100M programme running to 27 October 2027.The 27 October release shows the $100M authorisation spent at $86.31 a share and a new $100M one opened
      Was

      There were 105,348,864 shares at 31 July 2026; the June-quarter diluted count of 107.6M was 2.6% above a year earlier, first-half stock pay was $37.6…

  • TLSTelosRefreshed

    Telos replaces its long-time chief executive with a 42-year company insider

    Telos's board named Mark Griffin chief executive. He joined in 1984 and ran its main security business. Founder John Wood, who ran the company for most of 30 years, becomes executive chairman on the same pay and with no severance. The company says there was no disagreement.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our case moved. It rests on the profit guide, the unwon bids and a subcontract held by another company, none of which this touches. We keep Neutral and watch whether the 9 November results and any new awards fit the new leadership.

    2 claims changed
    • C24EditedJohn Wood, then chairman and chief executive and now executive chairman, owned 6.82M shares, 9.1%, in his July 2026 Schedule 13D. The 2026 proxy lists the JRP Settlement at 12.3% and BlackRock at 5.4%, and officers and directors as a group at 14.9%.Wood stepped down as chief executive on 2 November 2026 (8-K); the holding is unchanged and his title is not
    • C33NewOn 2 November 2026 Telos's board made Mark Griffin, 66, president and chief executive; he joined in 1984, has led Security Solutions since 2021 and the Telos ID unit since 2007, and gets a $440,000 salary with 24 months of pay if dismissed without cause. John Wood becomes executive chairman with salary, bonus and equity terms unchanged and no severance; the 8-K says it was not a disagreement over operations.chief executive succession announced after the close of the previous review
  • ORCLOracleThesis changed

    Oracle files to sell $10 billion of new shares and $10 billion of bonds

    Oracle filed on 2 November to sell $10 billion of new shares and $10 billion of bonds. At the 30 October share price that is about 76.5 million new shares, taking the total to about 3,100 million from 3,024 million. Prices were not set yet. Management had said on 28 October it would raise this much more through 2030.

    What it did to the thesisThe view holds. This is the planned raise, not a surprise, and it adds about 2.5% to the share count. It does break our rule of no new shares this year, so we re-set that rule above this sale. Neutral and low conviction stay until the 9 December results.

    1 claim changed
    • C10EditedIn the year to May 2026 Oracle raised $43B of debt and $5B of mandatory convertible preferred stock. In the August 2026 quarter it sold 141M new shares for $19.9B, completing a $20B program, and diluted shares rose to 3,000M from 2,909M a year earlier. It bought back no stock and pays $0.50 a share each quarter. On 2 November 2026 it filed to sell $10B of new shares, about 76.5M at the $130.67 close of 30 October, which would lift shares outstanding to about 3,100M from 3,024M, together with $10B of senior notes; neither was priced when filed.Oracle filed to sell $10B of new shares and $10B of notes on 2 November, the first raise under the cap announced on 28 October
      Was

      In the year to May 2026 Oracle raised $43B of debt and $5B of mandatory convertible preferred stock. In the August 2026 quarter it sold 141M new shar…

  • MRVLMarvell TechnologyRefreshed

    Marvell agrees to buy Lumentum for $115 billion, paid entirely in Marvell shares

    Marvell signed a deal to buy Lumentum, which makes lasers for AI networking. Lumentum holders get 4.5 Marvell shares each, and would own about a third of the combined company. It should close in the first half of 2028 if shareholders and regulators agree. Marvell also said its September-quarter revenue is on its guide.

    What it did to the thesisMarvell's cash, debt and growth plan are unchanged, because it pays in shares. The cost is dilution and a big integration. Its price is nearer our Neutral line but has not reached it. View stays Unattractive.

    2 claims changed
    • C37NewOn 1 November 2026 Marvell signed a definitive agreement to buy Lumentum for stock only: 4.500 Marvell shares for each Lumentum share, an implied enterprise value of $115B, about $1,132 a share and a 23.9% premium to Lumentum's close of 28 October, the last day before talk of a deal began. Marvell holders would own about 67% of the combined company and Lumentum holders about 33%. Closing is expected in the first half of calendar 2028, needing both companies' stockholder votes and regulatory approvals. Marvell would owe Lumentum $5.8B if its board withdraws support or takes a rival offer, and $3.2B if regulators block the deal after all other conditions are met.a signed deal changes the share count and what Marvell is
    • C38NewMarvell's deal presentation shows annualized revenue of $12.6B for Marvell (its guided Q3 FY27), $5.1B for Lumentum (its Q1 FY27) and $17.7B combined, with non-GAAP operating margins of 37%, 42% and 39%. It targets more than $1B a year of cost savings, mostly in cost of sales, and says the deal should add to non-GAAP earnings per share in the first year after closing. On the same day Marvell said preliminary Q3 FY27 revenue sits at the midpoint of its $3.15B guide, with the range narrowed to plus or minus 2% from plus or minus 5%.the company's own case for the deal, and the narrowed Q3 revenue range
  • GOOGAlphabetUnchanged

    Alphabet opened a new bond sale of about 6 billion euros

    Reuters reported that Alphabet began selling about 6 billion euros of bonds, roughly $7 billion, in Europe to help pay for its building of AI data centres. Alphabet already owed $125.1 billion at the end of September. We could not read the terms, because the filing was not out and the news sites block us.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is more borrowing on top of a plan we already expected, which keeps cash tight while spending runs near $200 billion this year. It does not change the cloud or search case. Neutral and Medium hold; the next test is the February results.

  • GEOThe GEO GroupUnchanged

    GEO announces a contract for its Big Spring, Texas, complex of 2,329 beds

    GEO said it has a contract for its Big Spring complex in Texas with 2,329 beds. We could read only the headline: the customer, the length and the money are not known. GEO's annual report lists two idle Texas prisons it owns, Big Spring and Flightline, with 2,376 beds between them, which may be what is now being filled.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. If idle beds are being put to work it helps the cost of empty beds, but without the customer, term or fee we cannot say how much. The 5 November results should give the terms.

  • FLOCFlowco HoldingsUnchanged

    Flowco raised how much it may spend buying back its shares to $200 million

    Flowco's board raised its share buyback limit from $50 million to $200 million. It has spent about $31.5 million of the old limit so far. The company is not required to buy anything and can stop at any time. It also declared its usual $0.09 quarterly dividend. Quarterly results are due on 4 November.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A buyback would help our worry about a steady flow of new shares, but nothing says how much will be bought or how it is paid for. Flowco borrowed $113 million in October for an acquisition, so the 4 November results are where we check.

  • BKRBaker Hughes CompanyUnchanged

    Baker Hughes finishes selling its Waygate inspection business to Hexagon

    Baker Hughes said on 2 November it has closed the sale of Waygate Technologies to Hexagon. Its quarterly filing of 28 October said the all-cash price was about $1.45 billion before closing adjustments, with the sale due in the fourth quarter. We could read only the headline of the closing release, so the final cash is not confirmed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The sale closing in the quarter the filing gave was already in our case as a way to pay down the Chart debt. We keep Neutral until the final cash and the next results show the debt coming down.

Sunday 1 November4

  • PYPLPayPal HoldingsRefreshed

    PayPal split itself into three businesses in April, with new bosses for each

    In April PayPal reorganized into three businesses: checkout, Venmo and consumer finance, and payment processing with crypto. Each got a new leader, and two senior managers left. Its latest quarterly report still gives one set of figures for the whole company.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the view moved. Our case already noted that no filing splits checkout from Venmo; the new structure does not change that until PayPal reports the three separately.

    1 claim changed
    • C53NewIn April 2026 PayPal reorganized into three businesses, Checkout Solutions & PayPal, Consumer Financial Services & Venmo, and Payment Services & Crypto, each with a new head.added after the source audit sweep found an uncited 8-K
  • NBISNebius GroupThesis changed

    Checking an outside review against the filings adds six facts about Nebius

    We checked a review of Nebius against the company's own filings. They confirm that Microsoft's capacity has all been delivered, in eleven blocks rather than nine. Most of the first quarter's profit was a paper gain on a stake. Nebius has $12 billion of leases signed that have not started. Q3 results come on 12 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe view and conviction did not move. One way to be wrong, Microsoft cancelling late capacity, has mostly gone. The unstarted leases add to what the build has to fund, which the funding test already watches.

    12 claims changed
    • C55-C60New · 6added after checking an outside review against the filings
    • C04EditedOwned sites hold more than 75% of Nebius's contracted power, against co-location for most of its early capacity.the company set the Q3 results date as 12 November, not 10 November
    • C21EditedManagement reaffirmed 2026 targets in August: ARR of $7B to $9B at year-end, revenue of $3.0B to $3.4B, a 40% adjusted EBITDA margin and $20B to $25B of capex. On 12 November it moved them: ARR above $7B for February rather than $7B-$9B by December, revenue of $3.0B to $3.2B, and no ARR guide after February, the margin about 40%, capex about $27B; for 2027 it guides revenue of $12B to $13B, capex of $40B to $45B and pre-tax breakeven in Q4.the company set the Q3 results date as 12 November, not 10 November
    • C42EditedAnalysts' average forecast puts 2027 sales at $12.09B (15 analysts) and 2028 at $22.91B (6 analysts), about seven times the 2026 range.the company set the Q3 results date as 12 November, not 10 November
    • C08EditedThe four Q2 2026 deals averaged more than $1B each at $20M to $25M a year per megawatt, against about $12M in 2026's base; about 70% of Q2 deals carried prepayments, covering 50% to 60% of capex.adds the Q2 letter's share of deals with prepayments, about 70%; the company set the Q3 results date as 12 November, not 10 November
      Was

      The four Q2 2026 deals averaged more than $1B each at $20M to $25M a year per megawatt, against about $12M in 2026's base, with prepayments covering…

    • C10EditedMicrosoft committed to pay up to $17.39B through 2031, about $6.96B upfront, but may cancel any GPU service Nebius delivers late beyond a grace period; a January 2026 addendum added two tranches to the nine. In November Nebius said more than half of the capacity contracted with Microsoft in New Jersey would be delivered by year-end and the rest in Q2 2027, after the site operator retired temporary power.the 20-F's Exhibit 4.5 shows an addendum adding two tranches, and the Q2 letter says all tranches are delivered
      Was

      Microsoft committed to pay up to $17.39B through 2031, about $6.96B upfront, but may cancel any GPU service Nebius delivers late beyond a grace perio…

    • C25EditedIts 2025 annual report disclosed two material weaknesses in internal control, over fixed assets and over TripleTen revenue, after an adverse 2024 opinion from the dismissed auditor; Deloitte audits 2026, approved at the August AGM.adds the auditor change to Deloitte for 2026, approved at the 25 August AGM
      Was

      Its 2025 annual report disclosed two material weaknesses in internal control, over fixed assets and over TripleTen revenue, after an adverse 2024 opi…

  • MPMP MaterialsRefreshed

    MP agreed a Saudi rare-earth refinery with the US military and Saudi miner Maaden

    In November 2025 MP, the US Department of War and Saudi miner Maaden agreed to build a rare-earth refinery in Saudi Arabia. Maaden owns at least half; MP and the department share the rest, and the department pays the US side's cost. MP brings its know-how. Its annual and latest quarterly reports never mention the project.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the view moved. It costs MP little and could add refining abroad, but no size, date or profit share is given, and the company's own filings leave it out, so it adds no number to the case.

    1 claim changed
    • C49NewIn November 2025 MP, the Department of War and Maaden signed a binding agreement for a rare-earth refinery in Saudi Arabia; MP and the DoW target 49%, Maaden at least 51%, and the DoW funds the US share without recourse.added after the source audit sweep found an uncited 8-K
  • CRWVCoreWeaveRefreshed

    CoreWeave's plan to buy data-center owner Core Scientific failed a shareholder vote

    In October 2025 CoreWeave tried to buy Core Scientific, which owns data centers CoreWeave rents, paying in its own shares. Core Scientific's shareholders voted no, so the deal ended. The two said they would keep working together. CoreWeave's later annual and quarterly reports do not name Core Scientific.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the view moved. CoreWeave still rents much of its capacity rather than owning it, which the case already counts as a cost. The failed deal confirms that rather than changing it.

    1 claim changed
    • C61NewCoreWeave's all-stock takeover of Core Scientific ended on October 30, 2025 when Core Scientific's shareholders voted it down; the two said they would stay commercial partners.added after the source audit sweep found an uncited 8-K

Friday 30 October6

  • VSTVistraThesis changed

    Vistra completed its purchase of Cogentrix's ten gas power plants

    Vistra said it finished buying Cogentrix Energy, ten natural gas power plants totalling about 5,500 megawatts, from funds run by Quantum Capital. All regulatory approvals were in. Vistra's fleet is now nearly 50,000 megawatts.

    What it did to the thesisThe deal closed inside the window we expected, so one risk on our list is gone. Our 2027 profit range excludes these plants, so nothing else moved. We keep Neutral until the early-November results.

    1 claim changed
    • C21EditedVistra completed the acquisition of Cogentrix Energy on 30 October 2026 (10 gas facilities, about 5,500 MW across PJM, ISO-NE and one ERCOT cogeneration facility, bought from Quantum Capital funds) after all regulatory approvals; the agreed price was approximately $2.3B cash net of an estimated $1.5B of assumed debt plus 5,000,000 Vistra shares.The acquisition closed on 30 October 2026, inside the mid-to-late 2026 window; the claim moves from forward to historical.
      Was

      Vistra agreed to acquire Cogentrix Energy (10 gas facilities, about 5,500 MW across PJM, ISO-NE and one ERCOT cogeneration facility) for approximatel…

  • TET1 EnergyUnchanged

    T1 Energy signs contracts to sell over 1.58 GW of solar modules

    T1 says it signed new contracts to supply more than 1.58 gigawatts of solar modules in 2027 and 2028, with subsidiaries of Avantus among the buyers. It says over 4 gigawatts of its 2027 capacity is now under contract. We read only a summary of the release; prices were not disclosed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Another buyer besides Trina is a step toward our test of third-party sales, but no price, payment or tax-credit sale is given, and the cell plant still needs financing. We keep Unattractive and Medium confidence.

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    Nvidia faces a spy-link report and talks on backing Nscale's Anthropic deal

    Reports say US agencies watched a Singapore cloud executive, whose firm is accused of selling Nvidia chips to China, over concerns she gathered information from CEO Jensen Huang. Nvidia says its customer contacts are routine. Separately, The Information says Nvidia is talking about credit support for Nscale's deal with Anthropic.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our outlook already assumes no China data-centre sales, and the credit-support talks are unconfirmed; we already track Nvidia's guarantees. We keep Attractive and Medium confidence and test both on the 17 November results.

  • MSFTMicrosoftUnchanged

    Microsoft plans to borrow about $25 billion in bonds for AI spending

    Microsoft filed papers to sell ten series of bonds. The amounts are blank in the filing; news reports say about $25 billion. It says the money is for general purposes, including building data centers and buying back shares. Its debt was $35.5 billion at 30 September.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It shows the AI build is large enough that Microsoft borrows on top of its cash flow, which our free cash flow test watches. The size and use of the money are unconfirmed until the bonds are priced.

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    S&P Global says Meta's credit outlook is now negative

    Headlines from CNBC and Reuters say the credit rating firm S&P Global changed its outlook on Meta to negative, over cash flow and spending on AI. We could not open either article, so we do not know the rating or what S&P would need to see.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Cash flow and spending are already the heart of our caution, and our scores for funding already reflect them. We keep Attractive with Low confidence and will read S&P's actual words when we can.

  • GEOThe GEO GroupUnchanged

    GEO announced a new contract to keep running its Tacoma ICE detention centre

    GEO said it has a new contract to manage its 1,635-bed immigration detention centre in Tacoma, Washington. We could read only the headline: the length, the price and whether ICE guarantees any minimum number of detainees are not confirmed. The shares rose about 3.5% the next session.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Keeping a contract that was due to lapse on 27 October fits our view and removes one renewal risk, but without terms it adds no evidence on the November test.

Thursday 29 October3

  • UBERUber TechnologiesUnchanged

    Rivian says a year-end robotaxi milestone would bring another $250 million from Uber

    Rivian said in its 29 October results presentation that it expects to hit the next milestone in its robotaxi deal with Uber by the end of the year. Hitting it would unlock another $250 million of Uber's investment in Rivian, to fund Rivian's self-driving work.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It shows Uber is still paying into a driverless partner as planned, which our file already counts as part of its answer to driverless rivals. It adds no trips or bookings, so the 3 November results remain the test. The view stays Attractive.

  • LEUCentrus EnergyUnchanged

    Centrus ships its first new centrifuge to Ohio, ahead of its own year-end target

    Centrus said on 29 October that its Tennessee factory finished its first new uranium centrifuge and is shipping it to Ohio for final assembly, and that its supply chain is in place. It beat the year-end target the company set earlier. The first new capacity in Ohio is still expected in 2029. The release gives no cost, size or machine count for the plant.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is real progress on building the machines, which our case already assumed, and the 2029 date is unchanged. Our view turns on the plant's cost and size, which Centrus still has not given, so those stay the test for the 4 November results.

  • EQTEQTUnchanged

    EQT's chief executive repeats the case for buying Range; no new terms

    On 29 October EQT's chief executive told CNBC the Range Resources purchase will save over $625 million a year, about half from cutting overhead and half from better pipes and demand capture. He said Appalachian gas demand is now over 25 billion cubic feet a day, up from 20, across a range of odds.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The saving matches the figures already in our file, and the demand number is the company's own estimate. Our view turns on falling debt and an earlier pipeline date, which this interview does not touch. The view stays Neutral.

Wednesday 28 October3

  • ORCLOracleThesis changed

    Oracle says cash flow turns positive in late fiscal 2028; sets 2030 targets

    At an investor day on 28 October, Oracle set a fiscal 2030 target of $225 billion or more in revenue. It said cash flow after spending turns positive in the second half of fiscal 2028 and reaches $30 billion or more in fiscal 2029. It will raise no more than $20 billion of new money through fiscal 2030, half in shares.

    What it did to the thesisOur Neutral view held. The dated cash plan answers a worry we had listed, but it is a promise: no new named buyer was announced and spending keeps rising until then. The 9 December results are the next test.

    1 claim changed
    • C11EditedAt its 28 October 2026 investor day Oracle dated positive free cash flow to the second half of fiscal 2028, with at least $30B in fiscal 2029, after peak capital spending in fiscal 2027 and 2028. It targets fiscal 2030 revenue of $225B or more, a 40% or better adjusted operating margin and adjusted earnings of $21 or more a share, reaffirmed fiscal 2027 revenue of at least $90B, and said new raises through fiscal 2030 will stay at $20B, $10B of shares and $10B of debt, beyond the $20B already sold. The chief financial officer said in September that each project, once ramped, converts close to 100% of after-tax operating cash profit into free cash flow.the investor day gave the date for positive free cash flow that the claim said management had not given, and capped new raises
      Was

      The chief financial officer gives no date for positive free cash flow, but says each project, once ramped, converts close to 100% of after-tax operat…

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    US Justice Department questions Nvidia's $12.9 billion Hugging Face purchase

    CNBC reports the US Justice Department has asked Nvidia how buying Hugging Face, a popular site for sharing AI models, could affect competitors. The deal costs about $12.9 billion and is due to close in the first half of 2027. It is a request for information, not a lawsuit.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The purchase is a side bet beside our case, which waits on the 17 November results. A longer review could push the closing past mid-2027, which we will watch.

    Checked against 1 claim - none changed
    • C25UnchangedNVIDIA agreed on September 2, 2026 to buy Hugging Face for about $11.9B in cash plus about $1.0B of retention pay, closing in the first half of 2027, and paid $2,944M in Q2 FY2027 for a non-exclusive licence of Groq's technology.
  • ACMRACM ResearchUnchanged

    ACM Research says third-quarter sales will be up about 35% from a year ago

    ACM Research said ahead of its 5 November report that third-quarter sales will be $360 to $365 million, up 34% to 36% on a year ago and about a quarter above the second quarter. Orders shipped to customers will be $335 to $340 million, up 27% to 29%. It gave no split by product.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Sales are strong, but our test is whether the core cleaning business grows again and whether a new product wins a first production order. Neither is in this notice, so we wait for 5 November.

Tuesday 27 October10

  • VRTVertiv HoldingsUnchanged

    Vertiv finishes buying two small service companies

    Vertiv said it completed its purchases of King Environmental Services and UtilityInnovation Group, both expected to close this quarter. We could not cite a price or sales figure for either.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The deals were already in our write-up as expected to close, and no figure we hold changed. The 28 October results are the test, and we will fold the closings into that review. View stays Neutral.

  • ORCLOracleUnchanged

    Oracle adds OpenAI tools and Google chips to its cloud, with no money figures

    At its Oracle AI World event Oracle said it will build OpenAI's ChatGPT and Codex into its business software, offer Google's AI chips on its cloud from next year, and expand its Nvidia Vera Rubin capacity to multi-gigawatt scale. None of the announcements gave a contract value, customer count or date for revenue.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. These are products and supply choices that spread Oracle's chip risk, but our case rests on the $664 billion backlog, mostly OpenAI, and on spending. The 9 December results test both.

  • METAMeta PlatformsThesis changed

    Meta's share sale prices larger than planned, at about $37.5 billion

    Meta priced its new share sales late on 26 October. The ordinary shares were raised from $22.5 billion to $25 billion, sold at $625 each. The preferred shares pay 6.5% a year and turn into ordinary shares in 2029. Press reports say Nvidia will buy $3 billion of the offering; Meta's filings do not name buyers.

    What it did to the thesisThis confirms the funding plan we scored yesterday and makes it about $2.5 billion bigger, roughly 0.1% of Meta's value. Nothing moved: we keep Attractive and Low confidence, and the scores for funding and dilution stay where they were.

    1 claim changed
    • C44EditedOn 26 October 2026 Meta launched about $35 billion (priced the same evening at about $37.5 billion, see below) of underwritten offerings: 250,000,000 depositary shares (about $12.5 billion at a $50 liquidation preference each) in a mandatory convertible preferred stock that converts into common stock on 15 August 2029, and $22.5 billion of Class A common stock sold by banks through forward sale agreements, for which Meta receives nothing at the start and gets cash only when the agreements settle (S32, S33). It also plans a further ATM program of about $60 billion once Class C stock trades, with no agreement signed and no timing or size fixed, making about $95 billion in all. Nvidia, AMD and Broadcom together indicated interest in up to $5.0 billion of the common stock, which is not binding. Proceeds are for 'general corporate purposes'. Meta says it will fund the build from 'a balanced mix of operating cash flow, investment-grade debt, strategic partnerships, and equity capital', and cites $97 billion of operating cash flow in nine months and about $82 billion of cash at the end of September (S33). The pack's market value was $1.91 trillion at the 25 September close (S05), so $95 billion is about 5% of it. At pricing the Class A offering was upsized from $22.5 billion to $25.0 billion, 40,000,000 shares at $625.00 against a $630.56 last sale, and the preferred carries a 6.50% dividend and converts into 0.0681 to 0.0800 Class A shares per depositary share around 15 August 2029, so the launched total is about $37.5 billion and about $97.5 billion with the planned ATM (S34, S35). Press reports say Nvidia will put $3 billion into the equity offering; the filings name no buyer, so that part is reported and not filed. On 3 November 2026 Meta priced $15.0 billion of senior notes in five series: $3.25 billion at 5.850% due 2031, $3.25 billion at 6.250% due 2033, $4.0 billion at 6.550% due 2036, $1.75 billion at 7.350% due 2046 and $2.75 billion at 7.500% due 2056, for 'general corporate purposes', rated Aa3 with a stable outlook by Moody's and AA- with a negative outlook by S&P, with settlement on 5 November (S36, S37). The prospectus says Meta may launch a euro-denominated note offering, with no assurance, and that it issued additional depositary shares of the preferred on 2 November for net proceeds of about $1.87 billion. At 30 September long-term debt was $80.92 billion, so the notes take it to about $95.9 billion before the euro notes; cash and securities were $82.45 billion, to which the proceeds add (S37).Pricing term sheet and release: common offering upsized to $25.0B at $625, preferred terms fixed; total about $37.5B.
      Was

      On 26 October 2026 Meta launched about $35 billion of underwritten offerings: 250,000,000 depositary shares (about $12.5 billion at a $50 liquidation…

  • IONQIonQUnchanged

    IonQ gets $7.5 million more from the Air Force lab

    IonQ said the Air Force Research Laboratory awarded it $7.5 million of follow-on funding for quantum networking work. We saw the headline only, so the term and when the money counts as sales are unknown.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is small against IonQ's spending and share pay, and fits the government demand we already describe. The 4 November results are the test. View stays Unattractive.

  • INTCIntelUnchanged

    Intel will buy quantum software firm Classiq, reportedly for $2.3B

    Intel announced it will buy Classiq, an Israeli quantum software company, to offer both the hardware and software for quantum computers. Intel gave no price; Bloomberg reports about $2.3B, and Israeli press says part is paid in shares. The deal needs regulatory approval and is expected to close in the first half of 2027.

    What it did to the thesisAlmost nothing moved. Our case turns on chip prices, outside customers for Intel's factories and the share count. At $2.3B the deal is small beside Intel's cash, and we cannot yet say if shares are used. The view stays Unattractive.

  • GWREGuidewire SoftwareUnchanged

    Guidewire agrees to buy hyperexponential for $1.7 billion cash

    Guidewire will buy hyperexponential, a London company selling AI software that helps commercial insurers price and underwrite risk, for $1.7 billion in cash plus up to $400 million if sales targets are met. It is already a Guidewire partner.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our argument moved yet. This is the company's first large purchase after years of small ones and no price, closing date or sales figure is out. Our next test is still the December results; we will read the deal terms then. View stays Neutral.

  • GOOGAlphabetUnchanged

    Google's AI chips are coming to Oracle's cloud next year

    Oracle said at its AI World event that Google's own AI chips, called TPUs, will be rented through Oracle's cloud, starting next year and growing over several years. Reuters reported it; no amount of chips, price or customer was named, and Google's own announcement was not found.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It points to Google selling its chips beyond its own data centres, which our case already notes, but gives no revenue. Tomorrow's results carry the real test.

  • ENSEnerSysUnchanged

    EnerSys agrees to buy battery maker Ultralife for about $320 million in cash

    EnerSys will offer $16.00 a share in cash for Ultralife, a maker of batteries for military radios, drones and munitions, valuing it at about $320 million. Ultralife sold $191 million in its 2025 fiscal year. EnerSys expects $15-20 million of yearly savings and to pay from cash it holds. Closing is expected in early 2027.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It adds to the defence side we already follow and spends cash that also funds the lithium plant and buybacks. EnerSys says profit per share only gains after about 18 months. Our test is still the 4 November results.

  • CEGConstellation EnergyUnchanged

    Constellation says the US government conditionally offered up to $5 billion in loans

    Constellation announced a conditional loan commitment of up to $5 billion from the US Department of Energy to expand nuclear output. One summary says the money would raise output at existing plants. We could not read the announcement itself, so the interest cost, the plants and the conditions are unknown. Nothing has been borrowed yet.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Cheaper money could help growth without straining the balance sheet, which our case watches. Until we can read the terms and see what is actually borrowed, the view stays where it was.

  • AMDAdvanced Micro DevicesRefreshed

    AMD says Helios racks are at Meta and it will invest $1B in Meta

    AMD said its first Helios racks, full server racks for AI, are installed at Meta and being tested, and that Meta uses AMD chips in its AI agent and in production. It also said AMD will put $1B into Meta's share offering. It gave no Helios revenue or shipment dates.

    What it did to the thesisSmall change. The $1B adds to the money AMD already puts behind its own customers, which our case counts as a cost to shareholders. Racks in testing are not yet sales. The view stays Neutral until the 3 November results show Helios revenue.

    3 claims changed
    • C58NewOn 27 October 2026 AMD said it will invest $1 billion in Meta's equity offering, and that initial Helios racks are installed and being tested at Meta on the path to a broader deployment in the near future. Meta has deployed millions of EPYC processors and uses Instinct GPUs in production for training, ranking and recommendations.AMD's 27 October release: a $1B stake in a customer and Helios racks installed at Meta
    • C07EditedManagement says Helios, a full rack of MI455X GPUs with Venice CPUs and Pensando networking, is in production, with a much larger ramp in Q4 and through 2027 and a new rack platform every year. AMD's 3 November release says Anthropic, Meta, Microsoft, OpenAI and Oracle Cloud Infrastructure are running models and workloads on the first Helios racks and that HPE's Vultr will deploy the first Helios by HPE systems; it states no Helios revenue.AMD's 27 October release says initial Helios racks are installed and being tested at Meta (C58); still management-sourced
    • C43EditedAMD is now paying toward part of its own demand: up to $5B of equity in Anthropic, $1B of Meta's own share offering, up to $4.1B of lease guarantees, credit support for TensorWave's lease and up to 320M shares of warrants to OpenAI and Meta. Part of each gigawatt sold is paid for by AMD's shareholders.AMD said on 27 October it will invest $1B in Meta's equity offering, a further payment to a customer (C58)
      Was

      AMD is now paying toward part of its own demand: up to $5B of equity in Anthropic, up to $4.1B of lease guarantees, credit support for TensorWave's l…

Monday 26 October14

  • TEMTempus AIUnchanged

    Tempus signs $192.5 million of data deals with Bristol Myers Squibb and Pathos

    Tempus told the SEC it will earn $137.5 million from Bristol Myers Squibb over about five years for cancer data, and up to $55 million from Pathos AI, a company its own chief executive helps run, for brain-disease records. Separately, Tempus said a European regulator certified one of its tumour RNA tests; we could not read that announcement.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The deals add contracted data revenue, but about $38 million a year is small against what the price needs, and the Pathos part adds to the related-party share we watch. The 2 November results will show how much it matters.

  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    Musk says SpaceX has lined up $40 billion of debt to buy AI chips

    Elon Musk said on X on 25 October that SpaceX has secured $40 billion of debt to buy the graphics chips that train AI models. He gave no lender, interest rate or repayment date, and we found no filing. We read a Business Insider copy, as CNBC and Reuters block our reader.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We already rate SpaceX Unattractive partly because it spends far more than it earns. $40 billion of new borrowing against $39.4 billion of existing debt and leases adds to that. Without terms we cannot size it; the filing will tell.

  • SLNHSoluna HoldingsThesis changed

    Soluna has paid off its Generate Capital loan in full

    Soluna said it repaid the last of a $28.7 million loan from Generate Capital: $19.1 million in August and the rest in October. The loan is closed and the lender's claim on the company's sites is released. Total debt falls from $37.9 million, counted at 30 June, to $9.2 million.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Unattractive. The lender test we feared is gone, but the repayment used cash, and the real problems remain: no signed AI lease, constant share sales, and preferred holders ahead of ordinary shareholders.

    3 claims changed
    • C26EditedSoluna repaid its Generate Capital loan in full: $19.1M in August, which waived June's forward test and included a $3.9M premium, and the rest on 22 October. The facility is terminated and its liens released; total debt was $16.7M net of issuance costs at 30 September and the company puts debt principal at about $7.7M after the October payment, against $37.9M at 30 June.the 26 October release says the Generate loan is fully repaid, so the forward test management expected to fail no longer applies
      Was

      Management concluded it will probably fail its lender's forward test, which counts only contracted revenue, within a year; waiving June's test cost a…

    • C27EditedAt 30 September 2026 the company held $109.3M of cash and $13.8M restricted, carried $16.7M of debt net of issuance costs ($14.4M of it current) and a $19.3M liability to Hewlett Packard Enterprise from a GPU cloud contract it ended in March 2025. After the October repayment debt principal is about $7.7M. Operations used $21.1M of cash in the first nine months of 2026.the 26 October release cut loan principal from $37.9M to $9.2M; the June cash figure is unchanged and the October payment's effect on it is not yet reported
      Was

      At 30 June 2026 the company held $113.4M of cash and $17.9M restricted, owed $37.9M of loan principal, and carried a $19.3M liability to Hewlett Pack…

    • C31EditedThe finance chief says AI projects can be financed about 80% with project debt, with the other 20% from equity or joint-venture partners.the lender named in this counter-evidence was repaid in full per the 26 October release
  • RRCRange ResourcesThesis changed

    EQT agrees to buy Range Resources, paying in its own shares

    EQT, another big Appalachian gas producer, agreed to buy Range. Each Range share turns into 0.987 EQT shares, with no cash. Range's owners would hold about 27% of the combined company. Both companies' shareholders must vote yes and regulators must clear it; the deal is due to finish by 25 October 2027.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays neutral. Until the deal closes, Range's price will follow EQT's rather than Range's own gas contracts. We also rate EQT neutral, so the two views agree. The market had not yet priced the news when we wrote this.

    2 claims changed
    • C39NewOn 25 October 2026 Range signed a merger agreement under which EQT will acquire it for stock only: each Range share becomes 0.987 EQT shares, Range holders will own about 27% of the combined company and EQT holders 73%. Completion needs both companies' shareholder votes, antitrust clearance and an effective registration statement; the end date is 25 October 2027, extendable to 25 April 2028; the break fees are $423M payable by Range and $1,148M payable by EQT. Range's chief executive Dennis Degner and one other Range-chosen director join an EQT board of 12.merger agreement announced 2026-10-26; read from Range's 8-K
    • C40NewEQT and Range state that the combination will bring $325M of annual base cost savings within two years (more than $600M over the longer term), lower EQT's break-even gas price for positive free cash flow to under $2 per MMBtu, give credit metrics of BBB quality at closing, and produce about $20B of free cash flow over five years at recent futures prices.merger agreement announced 2026-10-26; synergy and credit statements are the parties' own
  • RDNTRadNetRefreshed

    RadNet agreed to buy a teleradiology company for $350M cash and 5M shares

    RadNet will buy ONRAD, which supplies remote radiologists to over 225 hospital sites. Owners get $350M in cash and 5M RadNet shares, plus up to $210M more if ONRAD hits a 2027 profit target. RadNet says it should add $190M to $200M of sales and $60M to $65M of profit in its first year. The deal should close in early 2027.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. On RadNet's own numbers it is cheap next to its own price, but the profit is unchecked, new shares dilute owners, and it adds a business outside our case. The view stays Unattractive until filed figures and the call show the profit is real.

    2 claims changed
    • C41NewOn 26 October 2026 RadNet agreed to buy ONRAD, a teleradiology and in-hospital radiology staffing business. Holders receive $350M in cash and 5M RadNet shares, with an earn-out of up to $210M in cash or shares at RadNet's election if ONRAD reaches a 2027 adjusted EBITDA target. Closing is expected in early 2027; the agreement ends if it has not closed by 23 February 2027, extended to 1 June 2027 if only regulatory approvals are outstanding.a large acquisition announced in a new line of business, for the cash, share count and guidance claims
    • C42NewRadNet says ONRAD serves more than 225 hospital facilities in 26 states with more than 130 contracted radiologists, and expects it to add $190M to $200M of revenue and $60M to $65M of adjusted EBITDA in its first year after closing. These are management's figures; the financial statements of ONRAD are not filed.the size of what RadNet is paying for, for the guidance and share-count claims
  • MSFTMicrosoftUnchanged

    Microsoft offers voluntary exits to about 60,000 employees as AI spending climbs

    Microsoft told staff on 26 October that about 60,000 employees, over a quarter of the company, can choose to leave with severance-style pay. Sales, data-center and some engineering teams are left out. People have until early December to decide, and no second offer is planned.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is a cost-saving step, not a change in demand for Azure or in the backlog our case turns on. We will see how many accept, and what it costs, in later results. View stays Neutral; results on 28 October are the test.

  • METAMeta PlatformsThesis changed
    Financial position3→2
    Per-share capture3→2

    Meta starts selling $35 billion of new shares and plans $60 billion more

    On 26 October Meta launched about $35 billion of share offerings: $22.5 billion of common stock and about $12.5 billion of preferred stock that turns into common shares in 2029. It also plans a further $60 billion of gradual stock sales from 2027, about $95 billion in all, to help pay for its AI data centres. Meta still holds about $82 billion of cash.

    What it did to the thesisMeta said on 22 October it had no financing plan; now it does. New shares mean each existing holder owns a smaller slice. Funding strength and protection from dilution each fall one level. We keep Attractive and Low confidence, since the shares are cheaper than when we wrote the case.

    2 claims changed
    • C44NewOn 26 October 2026 Meta launched about $35 billion (priced the same evening at about $37.5 billion, see below) of underwritten offerings: 250,000,000 depositary shares (about $12.5 billion at a $50 liquidation preference each) in a mandatory convertible preferred stock that converts into common stock on 15 August 2029, and $22.5 billion of Class A common stock sold by banks through forward sale agreements, for which Meta receives nothing at the start and gets cash only when the agreements settle (S32, S33). It also plans a further ATM program of about $60 billion once Class C stock trades, with no agreement signed and no timing or size fixed, making about $95 billion in all. Nvidia, AMD and Broadcom together indicated interest in up to $5.0 billion of the common stock, which is not binding. Proceeds are for 'general corporate purposes'. Meta says it will fund the build from 'a balanced mix of operating cash flow, investment-grade debt, strategic partnerships, and equity capital', and cites $97 billion of operating cash flow in nine months and about $82 billion of cash at the end of September (S33). The pack's market value was $1.91 trillion at the 25 September close (S05), so $95 billion is about 5% of it. At pricing the Class A offering was upsized from $22.5 billion to $25.0 billion, 40,000,000 shares at $625.00 against a $630.56 last sale, and the preferred carries a 6.50% dividend and converts into 0.0681 to 0.0800 Class A shares per depositary share around 15 August 2029, so the launched total is about $37.5 billion and about $97.5 billion with the planned ATM (S34, S35). Press reports say Nvidia will put $3 billion into the equity offering; the filings name no buyer, so that part is reported and not filed. On 3 November 2026 Meta priced $15.0 billion of senior notes in five series: $3.25 billion at 5.850% due 2031, $3.25 billion at 6.250% due 2033, $4.0 billion at 6.550% due 2036, $1.75 billion at 7.350% due 2046 and $2.75 billion at 7.500% due 2056, for 'general corporate purposes', rated Aa3 with a stable outlook by Moody's and AA- with a negative outlook by S&P, with settlement on 5 November (S36, S37). The prospectus says Meta may launch a euro-denominated note offering, with no assurance, and that it issued additional depositary shares of the preferred on 2 November for net proceeds of about $1.87 billion. At 30 September long-term debt was $80.92 billion, so the notes take it to about $95.9 billion before the euro notes; cash and securities were $82.45 billion, to which the proceeds add (S37).Meta launched the $35B offerings and announced a further $60B ATM plan; read from the prospectus supplements and the launch release.
    • C42EditedMeta's board approved on 19 October 2026 a new class of non-voting Class C common stock, effective 19 January 2027, with a one-for-one stock dividend on Class A and Class B shares after which Meta expects the Class A price to reflect a two-for-one split. A Founder Alignment Agreement with Mark Zuckerberg frees 20% of his Class C shares and staples the other 80% to a matching reduction in his voting power, with 2.5% a quarter released while he stays in a full-time role. The release gives the purposes as capital raising, employee pay, acquisitions and general corporate purposes (S28, S29). Under the Founder Alignment Agreement the board must also pay an additional Class C dividend, one share for each outstanding Class A, B and C share, each time the 30-day average Class C price reaches 2x, 4x and 8x the $580.60 Class A price of September 10, 2026 and the compound annual shareholder return is at least 10%; Zuckerberg's shares from those dividends are unstapled while he stays in a full-time role. Any Class A repurchase must be matched by the best efforts to buy back at least as many Class C shares, and he commits to stay a California resident for eight years. The 10-Q treats the dividend as a stock split and says it does not change total equity (S31). The 26 October prospectus names the $60 billion ATM program as starting once Class C stock trades (S33).The Class C stock is now the vehicle for the planned $60B ATM (C44); no term of the recapitalization changed.
      Was

      Meta's board approved on 19 October 2026 a new class of non-voting Class C common stock, effective 19 January 2027, with a one-for-one stock dividend…

  • FNFabrinetThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Fabrinet shares fell 32% in three weeks with no news from the company

    Fabrinet closed at $314.94 on 23 October, down from $463.69 on 2 October. Other optical makers fell too, and the company filed nothing new. The whole company is now worth 22.5 times last year's operating profit, down from 34 times.

    What it did to the thesisThe price now needs about 14% growth a year to 2029, not 31%, so we call it fairly priced rather than full. The view stays Neutral: becoming attractive also needs its AI module sales to grow again, which the 2 November results will show.

    2 claims changed
    • C29EditedAt $314.94 Fabrinet is worth about $11.3B on 35,834,864 shares and, net of $875.1M of cash, about $10.4B as a company: 22.5 times fiscal 2026 operating income of $462.9M and about 24 times GAAP EPS.re-struck at the 23 October close after a 32% fall; was 34.0 times at $463.69
      Was

      At $463.69 Fabrinet is worth about $16.6B on 35,834,864 shares and, net of $875.1M of cash, about $15.7B as a company: 34.0 times fiscal 2026 operati…

    • C30EditedCarried three years at 10% and divided by 20, today's company value needs about $693M of fiscal 2029 operating income, about $6.9B of revenue at a 10% margin, or 14% growth a year from fiscal 2026.re-struck on C29's lower company value: the growth the price needs fell from 31% to 14% a year
      Was

      Carried three years at 10% and divided by 20, today's company value needs about $1.05B of fiscal 2029 operating income, about $10.5B of revenue at a…

  • EQTEQTThesis changed

    EQT agrees to buy Range Resources, paying in its own shares

    EQT agreed to buy Range Resources, another large Appalachian gas producer. It pays 0.987 EQT shares for each Range share, no cash, so Range's owners would hold about 27% of the combined company. Both sets of shareholders must vote yes and regulators must clear it. The two companies expect $325 million a year in savings.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays neutral. The deal adds scale and a vote to pass, but our case turns on pipelines, export deals and falling debt, which it does not answer. The savings figure is the companies' own estimate. Results on 27 October still carry the test.

    2 claims changed
    • C33NewOn 25 October 2026 Range signed a merger agreement under which EQT will acquire it for stock only: each Range share becomes 0.987 EQT shares, Range holders will own about 27% of the combined company and EQT holders 73%. Completion needs both companies' shareholder votes, antitrust clearance and an effective registration statement; the end date is 25 October 2027, extendable to 25 April 2028; the break fees are $423M payable by Range and $1,148M payable by EQT. Range's chief executive Dennis Degner and one other Range-chosen director join an EQT board of 12.merger agreement announced 2026-10-26; read from Range's 8-K
    • C34NewEQT and Range state that the combination will bring $325M of annual base cost savings within two years (more than $600M over the longer term), lower EQT's break-even gas price for positive free cash flow to under $2 per MMBtu, give credit metrics of BBB quality at closing, and produce about $20B of free cash flow over five years at recent futures prices.merger agreement announced 2026-10-26; synergy and credit statements are the parties' own
  • ECGEverus Construction GroupThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive
    Valuation3→4

    Everus shares fell to $94.91, down 25% in three weeks, with no company news

    Everus closed at $94.91 on 23 October, down from $126.17 on 5 October. The company filed nothing and reported nothing. Counting the debt taken on for its Epsilon purchase, it is now valued at about 11.8 times the profit management expects this year, down from 15.4.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Neutral to Attractive. We called the shares fair only because they paid for a peak profit margin; at this price even management's normal margin is paid for. The business has not changed, and the 3 November results test whether the margin holds.

    2 claims changed
    • C25EditedThe shares closed at $76.60 on 6 November 2026, a market value of about $3.91B, 55.4% below the May high of $171.58 and 32.0% below the $112.73 of 3 November, the close before the third-quarter results; they fell 29.3% on 4 November, the day of the call.re-struck at the 23 October close after a further 10.5% fall from 21 October ($106.00); no news
      Was

      The shares closed at $106.00 on 21 October 2026, a market value of $5.41B, 38.2% below the May high of $171.58 and 16.0% below the $126.17 of 5 Octob…

    • C26EditedAt $76.60, with $326.7M of net debt at 30 September (which includes the $295M paid for Epsilon), enterprise value is about $4.24B: about 8.6 times the midpoint of guided 2026 EBITDA of $490M, which includes Epsilon, about 14.5 times analysts' 2026 earnings forecast of $5.30 and 12.8 times 2027's $5.98 (forecasts of 26 October). At an 8% margin on 2027's forecast revenue of $5.21B it is about 10.2 times EBITDA.re-struck at the 23 October close, 10.5% below the 21 October close the multiples were struck at
      Was

      At $106.00, adding the $295M paid for Epsilon to June's net debt, enterprise value is about $5.83B: about 13.1 times guided 2026 EBITDA of $417.5M pl…

  • AVGOBroadcomThesis changed

    Banks and Blackstone line up $63 billion to buy Broadcom chips for Anthropic

    Four financial firms said they will fund a $63 billion vehicle that buys Broadcom's AI chips and networking and leases them to Anthropic, with deliveries starting in 2027. Broadcom will give residual value support equal to the senior loan, meaning it stands behind the equipment's resale value. The size of that senior loan was not given.

    What it did to the thesisGood for demand, since the chips get paid for. But Broadcom again stands behind its customer, so its exposure to Anthropic's ability to pay grows by an amount not yet disclosed. View and confidence stay; the December report should show the terms.

    3 claims changed
    • C51NewOn October 26, 2026 Bank of America, Blackstone, Citi and Morgan Stanley announced a $63 billion transaction through a new special-purpose vehicle with committed financing to buy Broadcom accelerators and networking to lease to Anthropic, as part of the compute agreement Broadcom announced earlier, with deliveries from calendar 2027. Bank of America, Citi and Morgan Stanley arrange the first lien, Blackstone alone commits the second lien, and Broadcom provides residual value support to the vehicle equal to the first lien amount. The release does not say how large the first lien is.second financing structure announced by the lenders on October 26; bears on C07, C08, C36 and the next test
    • C08EditedIn June 2026 Broadcom launched the AI XPV platform with an initial $35 billion tranche led by Apollo with Blackstone and global banks, to fund more than 1 gigawatt of accelerator-based compute for Anthropic from mid-2026, and says the platform is designed to enable more than 20 gigawatts for Anthropic and OpenAI through 2028. The financial partners fund the racks and lease them to the customer; Broadcom supplies the technology. A second structure of $63 billion for Anthropic was announced by the lenders on October 26 (C51).the lenders announced a second, $63 billion Anthropic structure on October 26, so 'none has closed' no longer holds
      Was

      In June 2026 Broadcom launched the AI XPV platform with an initial $35 billion tranche led by Apollo with Blackstone and global banks, to fund more t…

    • C36EditedBroadcom's largest planned customer for 2027 is a company whose rent Broadcom guarantees and may fund: the backstop covers 85% of Anthropic's outstanding lease amounts less recoveries up to $29 billion, and Anthropic may issue Broadcom up to $42 billion of convertible notes to meet those same lease payments. Anthropic's ability to pay rests on its own revenue growth and fundraising, and Broadcom's own 8-K conditions the capacity on Anthropic's continued commercial success. On October 26 a second, $63 billion structure for Anthropic was announced in which Broadcom gives residual value support equal to the first lien amount (C51); how much that adds to the $29B backstop is not stated.a second financing with Broadcom residual value support was announced; the exposure to the same customer is larger or at least not yet bounded
      Was

      Broadcom's largest planned customer for 2027 is a company whose rent Broadcom guarantees and may fund: the backstop covers 85% of Anthropic's outstan…

  • AMZNAmazon.comUnchanged

    Amazon's CEO says cloud capacity is mostly booked; Verizon signs a $2 billion deal

    On 23 October Amazon chief executive Andy Jassy said capacity for AWS, its cloud business, is largely sold out for 2027, with a good chunk of 2028 also spoken for, and gave no dollar amount. On 26 October Verizon said in its results release that it signed a deal worth over $2 billion with AWS for AI computing, without giving terms or length.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Both match what we already hold: a $496 billion order backlog and management saying it lacks capacity. The Verizon deal is about 0.4% of that backlog. Our test is the 29 October results: cloud growth, backlog and cash flow.

  • AMATApplied MaterialsRefreshed

    Applied Materials will raise its stake in chip-packaging partner Besi to about 20%

    Applied Materials agreed to buy more shares of Besi, a Dutch maker of machines that bond chips together, so it owns about 20%. It first bought in April 2025. It says it will not go higher or seek a board seat. The price was not disclosed, and the deal waits on a US antitrust waiting period.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is a sign Applied wants a strong position in chip packaging, which fits our case, but without a price we cannot weigh it against its cash. The view stays Neutral; the November results remain the next test.

    1 claim changed
    • C53NewOn 26 October 2026 Applied agreed through an accelerated share purchase to raise its stake in Besi, a Dutch maker of hybrid-bonding assembly equipment, to about 20% of Besi's shares, from the holding first bought in April 2025. Delivery waits on the US antitrust waiting period; Applied says it does not intend to go above about 20% or seek a board seat. The price paid is not disclosed in the filing or release.the first sizeable purchase of a partner's shares since the capital-return claims were written
  • AAOIApplied OptoelectronicsThesis changed

    Applied Optoelectronics shares fell 32% in three weeks with no company news

    Applied Optoelectronics closed at $67.51 on 23 October, down from $99.26 on 30 September. Other optical makers fell 22% to 32% over the same weeks, and the company filed nothing new. Counting the shares it sold in August and all the cash raised, the company is worth at least 8.7 times its last year of sales.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays Unattractive. The price we said would make us reconsider, 8 times sales, was flagged as reached only because of a dating slip in our own figures; correctly dated it is not reached. The price now needs about $2 billion of sales instead of $3.1 billion.

    3 claims changed
    • C26EditedAt $59.27 on 4 November 2026 the market value is about $5.38B on 90.77M shares (the 10-Q cover count of 2 November); adding $111.5M of bank loans and acceptances and $125M of convertibles and taking off $621.5M of cash including restricted cash at 30 September gives an enterprise value of about $4.99B. That is about 6.7 times trailing revenue of $747.3M and about 4.9 times the roughly $1.0B 2026 guide.re-struck at the 23 October close after a 32% fall; shares and cash now include the August programme the 30 September version left out
      Was

      At $99.26 on 30 September 2026 the market value is about $8.39B on 84.57M shares; adding $92.8M of bank debt and $125M of convertibles and taking off…

    • C27EditedFor a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, an enterprise value of about $4.99B needs about $379M of operating profit. At a 20% operating margin that is about $1.9B of revenue, 2.5 times the trailing year and 1.9 times the 2026 guide, but below the vendor panel's $2.96B for 2027.re-struck at the 23 October close; the revenue the price needs fell from about $3.1B to about $2.0B
      Was

      For a 6% after-tax yield at 21% tax, the $8.10B enterprise value needs about $615M of operating profit. At a 20% operating margin that is about $3.1B…

    • C29EditedThe shares fell from $29.10 on 6 November 2025, after a third-quarter print 9.8% below the revenue estimate, to $19.49 on 20 November; rose 56.9% the day after the February 2026 results; peaked at a $223.10 close on 13 May; closed at $99.26 on 30 September, and fell to $67.51 on 23 October, 32% lower in three weeks with no company news and the optical group falling alongside. Over 252 sessions to 30 September they rose 282.7%, of which revenue per share explains 12.7% and a higher multiple the rest.added the 23 October close; the 252-session decomposition stays as of 30 September
      Was

      The shares fell from $29.10 on 6 November 2025, after a third-quarter print 9.8% below the revenue estimate, to $19.49 on 20 November; rose 56.9% the…

Friday 23 October7

  • NVECNVEThesis changed
    ViewUnattractive→Neutral
    Valuation2→3

    NVE's shares fell 34% in a day after its weak quarter

    NVE's shares closed at $68.36 on 22 October, down 33.7% from $103.07 the day before, the first session after September's sales fell 47% to $5.8M. At that price the shares cost 18.5 times the last year's profit, near the 20.6 times they have usually cost over six years. Four law firms announced investigations, which are not company news.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Unattractive to Neutral. We called the shares full because they counted on June's sales returning; at the lower price they do not. The business has not changed, and December's sales still decide whether September was a pause.

    2 claims changed
    • C20EditedThe shares closed at $68.36 on 22 October 2026, the first session after the results, down 33.7% from $103.07 on 21 October and 41.3% from $116.53 on 6 October.re-struck at the 22 October close, the first session after the September results: the shares fell 33.7%
      Was

      The shares closed at $102.05 on 20 October 2026, the session before the results, down 12.4% from $116.53 on 6 October.

    • C22EditedAt $68.36 the shares are worth about $331M, about $287M net of cash and securities. That is 18.5 times trailing earnings against a six-year median of 20.6, and about 26 times the September quarter's earnings run for a year, so the price now pays for the old normal and little of the June step-up.re-struck at the 22 October close: 18.5 times trailing earnings, from 27.7 at $102.05, after the shares fell 33.7%
      Was

      At $102.05 the shares are worth about $494M, about $450M net of cash and securities. That is 27.7 times trailing earnings against a six-year median o…

  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsThesis changed
    ViewNeutral→Attractive

    Forgent's shares fell 21.5% the morning its finance chief quit

    Forgent closed at $24.92 on 22 October, down 21.5% on six times the usual trading. The shares opened 14% lower minutes after the company said its finance chief was leaving, seven months after listing and without severance. That afternoon it added that he left over no disagreement and said its quarter beat its forecast, and the shares recovered part of the fall.

    What it did to the thesisWe moved our view from Neutral to Attractive: the price now pays for the year already ordered. Confidence stays Medium because the finance chief's exit raises a question about the accounts; a restatement or a control weakness in the 12 November report would make it Unattractive.

    5 claims changed
    • C20EditedAt $20.57 the company value is about $6.66B, about 10.9 times the $612M midpoint of the raised FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 15.0 times the $1.37 adjusted EPS midpoint. Counting the $483.0M tax receivable liability as debt adds about three-quarters of a turn. Taking off stock pay at the September quarter's $13.9M a quarter, about $55.5M a year, it is about 12.0 times.re-struck at the 22 October close: 13.5 times FY27's guided EBITDA, from 21.3 at $40.35
      Was

      At $40.35 the company value is about $12.78B, about 21.3 times the $600M midpoint of FY27 adjusted EBITDA guidance and the shares about 30 times the…

    • C21EditedThe shares closed at $24.92 on 22 October 2026, 62.2% below the $66.00 high and 13.0% under the $28.64 low of 14 September. They rose about 41% after the Q4 results to $40.35 on 2 October, then fell 38.2% in three weeks, 21.5% of it on 22 October on 44.4M shares traded against 7.1M the day before, a day Vertiv fell 7.8% and Eaton 6.3%. The fall came at the open: the finance chief's departure was released at 7:00am (C31) and the shares opened 14.4% lower at $27.18, then drifted to $23.16 by 3:15pm. The statement that the quarter beat its forecast came at 3:15pm, after the amendment saying the departure was no disagreement, and the shares recovered to $24.92 at the close.The 15-minute bars put the fall at the open, minutes after the 7:00am release of the finance chief's departure; the claim said the day's filings did not explain it.
      Was

      The shares closed at $40.35 on 2 October 2026, 38.9% below the $66.00 high. From the 22 June close of $61.84 they fell 54% to $28.64 on 14 September,…

    • C24EditedAgainst the filed cohort of Vertiv, Eaton, Hubbell, nVent and Powell, the pack puts Forgent's trailing company value to EBITDA at 42.4 against a median of 28.7, the dearest of six; on the filed FY26 adjusted EBITDA of $322.9M the figure is about 40.counter-evidence re-struck at the 22 October close; the cohort figures are 2 October's and are re-measured at the next full review
    • C34EditedIf FY28 sales reach consensus at FY27's guided margin, today's company value is about 9.9 times FY28 profit before interest, tax and depreciation; at 16 times FY27's guide it would be about 11.8 times, a price that pays for FY27 and leaves FY28's growth close to free, and today's price is below that.re-struck at the 22 October close: 9.9 times FY28 at consensus, from 15.7
      Was

      If FY28 sales reach consensus at FY27's guided margin, today's company value is about 15.7 times FY28 profit before interest, tax and depreciation; a…

    • C21EditedThe shares closed at $24.92 on 22 October 2026, 62.2% below the $66.00 high and 13.0% under the $28.64 low of 14 September. They rose about 41% after the Q4 results to $40.35 on 2 October, then fell 38.2% in three weeks, 21.5% of it on 22 October on 44.4M shares traded against 7.1M the day before, a day Vertiv fell 7.8% and Eaton 6.3%. The fall came at the open: the finance chief's departure was released at 7:00am (C31) and the shares opened 14.4% lower at $27.18, then drifted to $23.16 by 3:15pm. The statement that the quarter beat its forecast came at 3:15pm, after the amendment saying the departure was no disagreement, and the shares recovered to $24.92 at the close.The 15-minute bars put the fall at the open, minutes after the 7:00am release of the finance chief's departure; the claim said the day's filings did not explain it.
      Was

      The shares closed at $24.92 on 22 October 2026, 62.2% below the $66.00 high and 13.0% under the $28.64 low of 14 September. They rose about 41% after…

  • FORMFormFactorUnchanged

    Teradyne agrees to invest $300 million in FormFactor and partner on chip testing

    A filing shows Teradyne, which makes chip-testing machines, will buy 2,234,887 new FormFactor shares for about $300 million, expected to close in the fourth quarter. The partnership release names no customers, revenue or products. FormFactor also announced its Texas plant opened; that release could not be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. The cash would about double what FormFactor held in June and adds about 2.8% to the share count, but it has not closed and the partnership has no stated revenue. The view stays Unattractive; the 4 November results are the test.

  • FICOFair IsaacUnchanged

    FICO will keep charging $10 per mortgage score for its preferred-program lenders

    FICO said it is holding its mortgage credit score fee at $10 for lenders enrolled in its preferred program, in answer to cheaper rivals. We could read only the headlines. How long the $10 lasts, who qualifies and whether lenders must promise volume are unknown.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We already assume about $10 for 2027, so a hold adds no new fact until we see the period and the terms. The 4 November results and fiscal 2027 guidance are the test of the fee and of volume.

  • EQTEQTRefreshed

    EQT reports on 27 October, raises its dividend 3%, adds a borrowing line

    EQT said its third-quarter results come after the close on 27 October, with the call on 28 October, a week later than we had pencilled in. It raised its quarterly dividend 3% to $0.17 a share and set up a $3.5 billion short-term borrowing programme, none of it used yet.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in the argument. Only the test date changed: the same questions on the Southgate pipeline, export deals and falling debt are now answered on 27 to 28 October. The dividend rise is small beside the debt paydown we are watching.

    3 claims changed
    • C05EditedMVP Southgate (Series B of the MVP Joint Venture) extends MVP Mainline into North Carolina; EQT is committed to an additional 0.55 Bcf/day of firm capacity on Southgate once placed into service. The FY2025 10-K estimated Southgate's total cost at $370-430 million and targeted an in-service date of mid-2028, pending remaining regulatory approvals. With the Q2 2026 print, EQT reported it had secured all key regulatory approvals for Southgate and elected to accelerate $85 million of capital contributions to complete construction by year-end 2026. The third-quarter 10-Q filed 28 October 2026 still gives 'mid-2028' as the in-service date and mentions no year-end 2026 acceleration (C35).EQT's own notice of 7 October puts the third-quarter results on 27 October; the 20 October refresh date came from a vendor estimate
    • C07EditedAs of December 31, 2025, EQT had entered three 20-year LNG offtake agreements for an aggregate 4.5 MTPA (3.0 MTPA expected to commence as early as 2030, 1.5 MTPA in 2031) plus a 20-year LNG tolling agreement for up to 2.0 MTPA expected to commence no earlier than 2030. Of the capacity that may commence in 2030, 1.0 MTPA of the offtake agreements and the entire 2.0 MTPA tolling commitment relate to projects that have not yet reached final investment decision. With the Q2 2026 print, EQT signed an additional 5-year LNG offtake SPA with an undisclosed 'large Asian integrated energy company' for 0.5 MTPA sourced from Gulf Coast facilities beginning 2028, expected to add approximately $45 million to 2028 free cash flow at recent strip pricing. No individual LNG counterparty is named in any of the four agreements.EQT's own notice of 7 October puts the third-quarter results on 27 October; the 20 October refresh date came from a vendor estimate
    • C11EditedQ2 2026 results beat guidance across every guided metric: sales volume of 634 Bcfe (above the high end of guidance); capital expenditures of $666 million (9% below the low end); realized-pricing differential of $(0.67) (favorable to guidance); total per-unit operating costs of $1.03/Mcfe (low end of guidance); net cash from operating activities of $1,048 million. EQT drilled the longest lateral in shale-development history (more than 29,000 feet) while staying 100% in zone, and set a new basin-wide 24-hour drilling record and a new company 48-hour record. EQT raised full-year 2026 total sales volume guidance to 2,375-2,450 Bcfe (from an original 2,275-2,375 Bcfe issued with the FY2025 results) and reduced full-year maintenance capex guidance by $25 million.EQT's own notice of 7 October puts the third-quarter results on 27 October; the 20 October refresh date came from a vendor estimate
  • APLDApplied DigitalThesis changed

    Applied Digital's two top executives bought shares near a one-year low

    Filings show the chief executive bought 55,803 shares at $18.04 and the president bought 300,000 at about $18.86 on 16 October, with their own money and no pre-set plan. Until then nobody inside had bought in over a year, while 20 sales were made.

    What it did to the thesisOur note that no insider bought is now out of date and was corrected. The buying is small next to the stock they own and says nothing about rent or debt, so the view stays Neutral and confidence stays Medium.

    1 claim changed
    • C36EditedInsiders made no open-market purchases from September 2025 to mid-October 2026 and sold on twenty occasions, nineteen of them (98.8% of the shares) outside a Rule 10b5-1 plan; on 16 October 2026 the chief executive bought 55,803 shares at $18.04 and the president 300,000 at about $18.86, both outside a plan, the first open-market purchases in the period.Form 4s of 16 October show two officers' first open-market purchases in the period; 'no purchases' was no longer true
      Was

      Insiders made no open-market purchases in the last year and twenty open-market sales; nineteen of the twenty, and 98.8% of the shares sold, were disc…

  • ACMRACM ResearchThesis changed

    ACM Research shares fall by a third; our valuation notes are re-measured

    ACM Research's shares closed at 49.12 on 22 October, 32.5% below where we last measured them, and its larger rivals Lam Research and Applied Materials were marked down too. No new filing explains it. ACM also said it will report third-quarter results on 5 November, not 4 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe business evidence did not move, but the price notes did. ACM now trades level with its own past instead of well above it, and still cheap against Lam and Applied. We keep Neutral: cash still lags profit.

    15 claims changed
    • C03-C50Edited · 12ACM's own notice of 19 October sets the third-quarter results for 5 November, not the 4 November a vendor estimated; the refresh date moves with it
    • C24EditedAt the 4 November 2026 close of $44.43 ACM trades at a TTM P/E of 25.98x and EV/EBITDA of 8.01x, against prior-six-fiscal-year medians of 20.99x and 10.83x: the P/E is about 24% above its own median and the EV/EBITDA 26% below it. TTM ROIC is 5.3% versus a prior median of 6.3%.re-struck at the 22 October close (49.12) from the 31 August close (72.82): P/E 32.25x to 22.47x and EV/EBITDA 14.83x to 9.92x, so ACM no longer trades above both of its own medians
      Was

      ACM trades at a TTM P/E of 32.25x and EV/EBITDA of 14.83x, both above their prior-three-fiscal-year medians of 20.99x and 10.83x; TTM ROIC is 4% vers…

    • C25EditedAgainst the two listed, filing-confirmed competitors (Lam Research, Applied Materials), ACM trades at a discount on every cohort multiple at the 4 November 2026 close - EV/EBIT 12.9x vs a 29.75x median, EV/Sales 1.9x vs 10.0x, P/E 26.0x vs 32.25x - while its TTM revenue growth (29.1%) is the second highest of the three, behind Lam's 33.4%, and its operating margin (14.5%) and ROIC (5.3%) are the lowest.re-struck at the 22 October close from 31 August: ACM's EV/EBIT 29.1x to 19.1x against a peer median of 42.1x to 30.65x; Lam's refreshed growth (33.4%) now exceeds ACM's 27.3%, so ACM is second fastest, not fastest
      Was

      Against the two listed, filing-confirmed competitors (Lam Research, Applied Materials), ACM trades at a discount on every cohort multiple - EV/EBIT 2…

    • C40EditedAt the 4 November 2026 close, ACM's 12.9x EV/EBIT, down from 29.1x on 31 August and 19.1x on 22 October and 43% of the two-peer median of 29.75x, prices continued growth with less to spare: the discount to Lam Research and Applied Materials is wider than it was. C24 (ACM's own valuation history), C25 (the two-peer filed-cohort discount) and C03 (FY2026 guidance of 38%-42% growth) read together against the EV/EBIT frame.re-struck at the 22 October close: 29.1x EV/EBIT to 19.1x, with the cohort median 42.1x to 30.65x; the reading moves from 'a narrowing discount' to a wider one, with the business evidence unchanged
      Was

      At today's price, ACM's 29.1x EV/EBIT prices in continued high-20s/low-30s percent revenue growth and a narrowing (not full closing) of its discount…

Thursday 22 October6

  • TET1 EnergyRefreshed

    T1 says it won a Commerce import waiver and pays a bill in shares

    T1 announced that the Commerce Department gave it a waiver tied to the new polysilicon tariffs. We could not read the release, so we do not know what it covers or for how long. Separately, T1 filed that it will pay $30 million of its patent price in 9,962,645 new shares, about $3.01 each.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We cannot judge the waiver without its terms, and it does not touch the funding or credit-sale tests due 13 November. The share payment was already in our funding stress case; it adds to the pile of new shares.

    1 claim changed
    • C58NewFor the $30.0M third tranche of the Evervolt patent price, due 15 October 2026, T1 chose to pay in 9,962,645 new shares, about $3.01 each; for the $25.0M second tranche of 30 September it chose 7,246,377 shares, about $3.45 each. Any issue that would take Evervolt above 4.99% of the shares is deferred, and all 9,962,645 October shares and 2,246,377 September shares are currently deferred; the $133.0M price, plus a $2.0M option premium, has now been paid partly in stock in each tranche so far reported.the 21 October 8-K showed the Evervolt payments being met in shares, which the ledger's funding assumption (A03) sizes
  • NBISNebius GroupRefreshed

    Nebius borrows $3.5 billion from Citi for one year to pay for its build-out

    Nebius signed a $3.5 billion loan with Citi, due 16 October 2027. It costs a floating rate plus 2.75 percentage points, rising to 3.5 over nine months, and is backed by nearly all of the company's assets. The money pays for data centers and chips. Nebius says it keeps its options open for longer-term financing.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the view moved. Our case needs the build funded without heavy new shares; this is debt, so that holds for now. But it is short, dearer than July's loan and has to be replaced within a year, so funding stays the thing to watch.

    1 claim changed
    • C54NewOn 17 October 2026 Nebius signed a $3.5B senior secured bridge facility with Citi, announced 22 October: it matures on 16 October 2027, pays Term SOFR plus 2.75%, stepping up 0.25 points every 90 days to 3.50%, is secured on substantially all assets including the shares of the US and Dutch borrowers, and carries a minimum-liquidity covenant. Management says it funds data centers and GPUs and leaves the timing of longer-term financing open.new financing disclosed in the 22 October 6-K, bearing on how the build is funded (A02)
  • MRKMerck & Co.Refreshed

    Merck and Moderna published full results for their personalised melanoma cancer shot

    Merck and Moderna gave the full results of a large trial of intismeran, a cancer shot made for each patient, added to Keytruda after melanoma surgery. After about two years, it cut the risk of the cancer returning or death by 42% against Keytruda alone. Survival data is not mature yet. They are talking to regulators and will present at the ESMO cancer congress.

    What it did to the thesisThe case holds. We already counted this trial as a win. The numbers make it firmer and the talks with regulators fit our filing-by-2027 check, but no filing exists, survival is unproven, and the price already pays for new medicines working. Neutral stays.

    1 claim changed
    • C19EditedOn 19 August 2026 Merck and Moderna said intismeran, a personalised mRNA cancer treatment, added to Keytruda cut melanoma recurrence at a planned interim look. On 22 October they gave the full results: after 24.6 months the risk of recurrence or death fell 42% (hazard ratio 0.58) and of distant spread or death 38% (0.62) against Keytruda alone, level for the first six months, with overall survival not yet mature and the companies engaging with regulators.22 October release gave the full INTerpath-001 figures and said the companies are engaging regulators; no filing yet.
      Was

      On 19 August 2026 Merck and Moderna said intismeran, a personalised mRNA cancer treatment, added to Keytruda cut melanoma recurrence at a planned int…

  • FPSForgent Power SolutionsRefreshed

    Forgent's finance chief steps down; it also says this quarter beats its forecast

    Forgent's chief financial officer, Ryan Fiedler, stepped down on 21 October; Amy Ard, who has run its finance team since January, replaces him, and a filing says it was no disagreement over accounting. Later that day Forgent said its September-quarter sales and adjusted earnings will beat the top of its forecast ($465M and $100M), with no exact figures. Results come 12 November.

    What it did to the thesisOur view held. A stated beat with no figures does not tell us the size or the margin, and the case rests on orders, prices and capacity. The 12 November report shows how big the beat is and whether the full-year forecast moves.

    3 claims changed
    • C31EditedGary Niederpruem has been chief executive since May 2025 after six years at Vertiv, where he helped lead its carve-out and listing. Ryan Fiedler, chief financial officer since July 2025 and a Caterpillar veteran, stepped down on 21 October 2026, about five weeks after the FY26 results he guided from, and leaves the payroll on 30 October; the company gave family time as the reason and a same-day amendment said it was not a disagreement over operations, accounting or reporting, and he gets no severance but keeps his unvested profits interests. Amy Ard, executive vice president of finance since January 2026 and earlier chief financial officer of Proterra, succeeds him. No executive or director holds shares directly; the executives hold profits interests in the Neos holding partnerships worth $39.8M, $22.5M and $20.2M at the June close of $55.86, mostly unvested.A same-day 8-K/A stated the departure was not a disagreement over operations, accounting or reporting; the claim carried only the unconfirmed family reason.
      Was

      Gary Niederpruem has been chief executive since May 2025 after six years at Vertiv, where he helped lead its carve-out and listing; Ryan Fiedler, chi…

    • C23EditedForgent guides FY27 revenue of $2.45B to $2.65B, up about 80% at the midpoint, adjusted EBITDA of $587M to $637M and adjusted EPS of $1.30 to $1.44, raised on 12 November from $2.4B to $2.6B, $575M to $625M and $1.26 to $1.40. Management says backlog fully covers the raised guide. The September 2026 quarter, guided at $445M to $465M of revenue and $90M to $100M of adjusted EBITDA, came in at $478.6M and $104.9M.The 22 October 8-K said the September quarter's revenue and adjusted EBITDA will beat the high end of the guide and moved the report date to 12 November; the claim described the guide alone.
      Was

      Forgent guides FY27 revenue of $2.4B to $2.6B, up about 76% at the midpoint, adjusted EBITDA of $575M to $625M (about 24%) and adjusted EPS of $1.26…

    • C31EditedGary Niederpruem has been chief executive since May 2025 after six years at Vertiv, where he helped lead its carve-out and listing. Ryan Fiedler, chief financial officer since July 2025 and a Caterpillar veteran, stepped down on 21 October 2026, about five weeks after the FY26 results he guided from, and leaves the payroll on 30 October; the company gave family time as the reason and a same-day amendment said it was not a disagreement over operations, accounting or reporting, and he gets no severance but keeps his unvested profits interests. Amy Ard, executive vice president of finance since January 2026 and earlier chief financial officer of Proterra, succeeds him. No executive or director holds shares directly; the executives hold profits interests in the Neos holding partnerships worth $39.8M, $22.5M and $20.2M at the June close of $55.86, mostly unvested.A same-day 8-K/A stated the departure was not a disagreement over operations, accounting or reporting; the claim carried only the unconfirmed family reason.
      Was

      Gary Niederpruem has been chief executive since May 2025 after six years at Vertiv, where he helped lead its carve-out and listing. Ryan Fiedler, chi…

  • AFRMAffirm HoldingsUnchanged

    Affirm becomes the only pay-over-time option at Sam's Club

    Affirm says it launched as the exclusive pay-over-time provider at Sam's Club, the warehouse chain. We could read only the headline, so how long the deal runs, how much it may bring in and whether it covers stores or online are unknown.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A large new merchant could widen Affirm's base beyond its biggest partner, but no volume or terms were readable. The 5 November results are the next test of whether returns per loan hold.

  • ADEAAdeiaUnchanged

    Adeia renews its patent licence with television maker TCL

    Adeia says it signed a multi-year renewal of its patent licence with TCL, a television maker. We could read only the headline. The length of the deal, which patents it covers and what TCL pays were not readable.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A renewal fits management's claim that most customers renew, but without the terms we cannot tell whether payments rose or fell. The 2 November results are the next test.

Wednesday 21 October4

  • SLNHSoluna HoldingsThesis changed

    Soluna agreed with Applied Digital to build a 50 MW AI data centre

    Soluna agreed to form a joint company with Applied Digital, which would own 51% and provide the money, to develop a 50 MW AI data centre on Soluna's Texas site. A company Applied owns signed a non-binding letter of intent to rent it. Closing depends on a local tax abatement and final contracts.

    What it did to the thesisA partner funding the build is the kind of deal our case wanted, but there is no signed lease, no money or rent stated, and the tenant is owned by the partner. The shares are down 46% to $0.577. The view stays Unattractive.

    5 claims changed
    • C64NewOn 21 October 2026 Soluna announced a definitive agreement with Applied Digital to form a jointly owned company, Applied expected to hold 51% and Soluna 49%, to develop a planned 50 MW AI data centre at Dorothy 3; Soluna contributes a portion of the site, land and power-related assets and Applied provides capital, and ChronoScale, which Applied majority-owns, signed a non-binding letter of intent to lease it; closing by the end of 2026 depends on a Briscoe County tax abatement, title policies, an operating agreement, definitive leases and power agreements. On 9 November 2026 the Briscoe County Commissioners Court approved the Chapter 312 tax abatement for Dorothy 3's first phase, one of those conditions.the 21 October release is the first partner-funded AI build the thesis asked about
    • C11EditedNo definitive AI lease is signed. At Kati 2 Soluna chose not to renew the first prospective tenant's exclusivity because, it said on the Q3 call, it did not expect that tenant to meet its credit requirements for a lease of that size; in November 2026 it signed a non-binding letter of intent with a new, unnamed tenant for 118 MW that it expects to meet them, with diligence running beside the lease talks. For Dorothy 3 ChronoScale, majority-owned by Applied Digital, signed a non-binding letter of intent on 21 October 2026, and lease talks are underway. Construction work began at both sites in October; the AI segment has earned nothing.21 October 2026: a second letter of intent, non-binding, for Dorothy 3; still no definitive lease.
      Was

      No AI lease is signed. For Kati 2 the company has a letter of intent, with exclusivity, with an unnamed tenant, and its 10-Q says it cannot assure a…

    • C29EditedApplied Digital, which Soluna's 10-K names as a rival, had signed leases for about 1,410 MW of AI load worth about $36.2B over 15-year terms at 31 May 2026, and builds a 150 MW design in 14 to 18 months. On 21 October 2026 Applied Digital also agreed to form a joint company with Soluna for a 50 MW Dorothy 3 data centre (C64), so it is now a partner as well as a named rival.21 October 2026: Applied Digital became Soluna's partner at Dorothy 3.
      Was

      Applied Digital, which Soluna's 10-K names as a rival, had signed leases for about 1,410 MW of AI load worth about $36.2B over 15-year terms at 31 Ma…

    • C50EditedAt $0.4571 on 256.2 million shares the common is worth about $117M, behind a preferred claim of $158.1M at June that grows about $2.8M a quarter and about $7.7M of loan principal, against $109.3M of September cash; the business lost $29.0M at the operating line in Q3, so the price pays for AI campuses no tenant has signed.re-struck at the 20 October 2026 close of $0.577 (FMP end-of-day) from $1.06 after a 45.6% fall: the common is worth about $142M rather than $262M, less than the preferred claim ahead of it; nothing else moved.
      Was

      At $1.06 on 246.7 million shares the common is worth about $262M, behind a $158.1M preferred claim and $37.9M of loan principal, against $113.4M of J…

    • C51EditedKati 2's first 100 MW at a rival's $11M to $13M a megawatt costs $1.1B to $1.3B; with 80% project debt the equity is $220M to $260M, about twice September's cash, and raised in common at $0.4571 it is 481 to 569 million new shares.re-struck at the 20 October 2026 close of $0.577 from $1.06 after a 45.6% fall: the equity is 381 to 451 million new shares rather than 208 to 245; the Dorothy 3 partner funding is a different build.
      Was

      Kati 2's first 100 MW at a rival's $11M to $13M a megawatt costs $1.1B to $1.3B; with 80% project debt the equity is $220M to $260M, more than June's…

  • MSFTMicrosoftUnchanged

    OpenAI will also sell its AI models through Google Cloud, not only Microsoft Azure

    CNBC reports that OpenAI will sell its models on Google's cloud, widening where business customers can buy them beyond Microsoft's Azure. Copies of the story say customers can pay through Google's marketplace. CNBC itself could not be read here, and no figures were given.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Microsoft agreed in April that OpenAI could sell through any cloud, so this is that deal in use. What matters is whether OpenAI shifts its Azure spending, which Microsoft would report on 28 October. View stays Neutral.

  • IRENIREN LimitedRefreshed

    IREN says it will build a 300 MW AI campus in Spain

    IREN announced a 300 megawatt campus in Spain aimed at European governments' own AI needs. We could not open the announcement itself. IREN's website shows the site, Badajoz, as planned for 2028 or later, with no customer, cost or start of power given.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The Spanish site was already counted in the roughly 5 gigawatts of power IREN holds. Without a customer or a cost, it adds no new evidence. The 5 November results remain the next test.

    What this review changed (2 edits)
    • research.unread records the item with every route tried
    • review_log row appended; as_of 2026-10-21
  • GOOGAlphabetUnchanged

    OpenAI says its AI models will be sold through Google Cloud

    Reuters and CNBC report that OpenAI will sell its top models on Google Cloud. Outlets that copied the story say business customers can buy them through Google's marketplace using money they already committed to Google Cloud, with the newest models due in weeks. No sales, prices or terms were given.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It gives Google Cloud another product to sell, but Google already says it cannot supply enough capacity, so extra demand may not lift growth soon. The 28 October report is the test. View stays Neutral.

Tuesday 20 October4

  • SMCISuper Micro ComputerRefreshed

    Super Micro says its September quarter beat its own forecast on sales and margin

    On 20 October Super Micro said that, before audit, its September quarter sales were $18.5 billion to $19.5 billion, against a forecast of $14.5 billion to $15.5 billion. It put its profit margin on sales at 12.0% to 12.5%, against a forecast of 10.4% to 10.8%. Full results come on 3 November.

    What it did to the thesisThe margin and sales parts of our case look better, but nothing moved the view. The case turns on whether growth is paid for from cash it earns, and the release says nothing on cash, stock on hand or funding. View stays Neutral.

    2 claims changed
    • C07EditedQ1 fiscal 2027 gross margin was guided to 10.4%-10.8%; on 20 October 2026 the company's unaudited preliminary estimate was 12.0%-12.5%, attributed to customer and product mix; the quarter reported 12.7% (C61).The company's 20 October preliminary update put Q1 gross margin at 12.0%-12.5% against the 10.4%-10.8% guide; claim now states both.
      Was

      Q1 fiscal 2027 gross margin is guided to 10.4%-10.8%.

    • C14EditedFiscal 2027 revenue was guided to $65.0B-$72.0B, and Q1 to $14.5B-$15.5B with GAAP diluted earnings of $0.89-$0.98 on 745 million diluted shares; on 20 October 2026 the company's preliminary estimate for Q1 revenue was $18.5B-$19.5B; Q1 reported $19.9B and the full-year guide was raised to $72.0B-$82.0B (C61, C63).The 20 October preliminary update put Q1 revenue at $18.5B-$19.5B against the $14.5B-$15.5B guide; claim now states both.
      Was

      Fiscal 2027 revenue is guided to $65.0B-$72.0B, and Q1 to $14.5B-$15.5B with GAAP diluted earnings of $0.89-$0.98 on 745 million diluted shares.

  • SLNHSoluna HoldingsThesis changed

    Soluna shareholders approved letting the company issue up to 1 billion shares

    At its 16 October annual meeting Soluna's shareholders voted to raise the most shares it may have from 375 million to 1 billion, and to let an equity line (a deal to sell new shares to an investor over time) sell 20% or more of the current shares. The change took effect that day. Dan Golding was elected a director.

    What it did to the thesisOur case already expected Soluna to keep funding itself by selling shares, so the view did not move. The vote removes the cap on how many it can sell; it does not mean it will. We now watch how many are sold in the September quarter.

    1 claim changed
    • C25EditedOn 16 October 2026 holders approved raising authorised common shares from 375 million to 1 billion (144.4 million votes for, 13.3 million against) and allowed the $250M equity line to issue 20% or more of the shares (89.7 million for, 5.4 million against); the amendment took effect that day.the 16 October vote happened: the forward ask became a filed result, approved
      Was

      The 16 October 2026 meeting asks holders to raise authorised common shares from 375 million to 1 billion, and to allow the $250M equity line to issue…

  • MQMarqetaUnchanged

    Block moves Square's business credit card onto Marqeta, with no numbers given

    Marqeta said Block's Square will run its business credit card, backed by the American Express network, on Marqeta, joining its debit and prepaid cards there. Marqeta also announced a stablecoin-backed card tie-up with Coinbase. Neither announcement gave volumes, revenue or terms, and only the opening of the Block release could be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Block is already Marqeta's largest customer, and Cash App's new cards are leaving. Square's credit card staying shows some Block volume remains, but without volume figures it cannot change our growth view. The 3 November results are the test.

  • CRMSalesforceUnchanged

    Salesforce agrees to buy marketing-software maker Braze for about $5.66 billion in cash

    Salesforce signed a deal to buy Braze, which sells software for messaging customers in real time, for about $5.66 billion in cash ($47.50 a share). It expects to close in its fiscal 2028, pending Braze shareholder and regulator approval. Salesforce says this year's outlook is unchanged and it has not yet given next year's.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Our case already names Salesforce's habit of buying growth with cash and borrowed money. This is another purchase of that kind, but it closes next year, so it changes no figure or test until then.

Monday 19 October12

  • TTMITTM TechnologiesUnchanged

    TTM agrees to buy an infrared optics business from MKS for $650 million

    TTM will pay about $650 million in cash for Ophir Optics, which MKS currently owns. It makes infrared cameras' lenses and laser optics for defence, security and industry. TTM expects to fund it from cash, future cash flow and its credit line, and to close in the second quarter of 2027. No sales or profit figures were given.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our case moved yet. It adds more debt to a company already borrowing for Epiq, and a third defence-related purchase, but closes only in 2027 and gives no figures. The leverage test and September-quarter print are still what decide.

    Checked against 4 claims - none changed
    • C24UnchangedTTM agreed in August to buy Epiq Solutions, a maker of software-defined radios, RF products and radiation-tolerant space computers for signals intelligence and electronic warfare, for about $1.1B in cash, about 17.4 times expected 2027 adjusted EBITDA after $9M of synergies; it closed on 30 September 2026.
    • C25UnchangedManagement expects Epiq to add to adjusted EBITDA margin at once but to non-GAAP EPS only during 2028, and estimated net leverage of 2.3 times at close, to be cut over the following 12 to 18 months.
    • C28UnchangedNet debt is about $2.0B after Epiq and STG, before ILFA, against $465.6M in June.
    • C20UnchangedManagement said A&D program backlog was $1.7B against $1.5B a year earlier, more than $7B of qualified proposals sat in its pipeline, it booked Golden Dome, munitions and APS-153 radar work, and A&D sales would grow low to mid teens in 2026.
  • MKSIMKSUnchanged

    MKS agrees to sell its infrared optics business to TTM for $650 million

    MKS will sell Ophir Optics, which makes lenses for infrared cameras and laser optics for defence, security and industry, to TTM for $650 million in cash. MKS keeps its laser measurement business and the Ophir brand. The sale should close in the second quarter of 2027. MKS gave no sales or profit figures for what it is selling.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The business sits in the smallest of MKS's three markets, outside chip equipment, which is what our case is about. The cash helps pay down debt in 2027, but no sales figure is given, so we cannot yet size the effect on guidance.

    Checked against 3 claims - none changed
    • C15UnchangedQ3 2026 guidance was revenue of $1,350M plus or minus $40M, gross margin 47.0%, non-GAAP operating expenses $280M, non-GAAP operating margin 26.3% and non-GAAP earnings of $3.58 a diluted share. Actual: revenue $1,413M, gross margin 47.7%, non-GAAP operating expenses $281M, margin 27.8% and earnings $4.18.
    • C17UnchangedAt 30 September 2026 MKS carried about $1.3B of secured term loan principal, $1,400M of convertible notes and EUR 1,000M of 4.25% senior notes, against $676M of cash and up to $1.0B of revolver capacity, subject to leverage tests. It prepaid $100M of the term loan in November 2026.
    • C18UnchangedManagement put leverage at 3.0 times trailing twelve-month adjusted earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation of $1.1B at the end of Q2 2026, 'down one full turn since Q2 of last year', after prepaying $1,274M of term loan in February 2026 and $100M in each of May and August 2026.
  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    Lilly's Omvoh worked in children with ulcerative colitis; a delivery-technology deal was announced

    Lilly said its Omvoh injection met the main goal of a one-year trial in children aged 6 to 17 with ulcerative colitis: 50% of those who responded early were in remission at week 52. Lilly plans to ask regulators for a wider label. Separately, Reuters reported a deal worth up to $1.1 billion with Metis TechBio; we could read only the headline.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Omvoh is part of immunology, about 6% of sales, so a children's label adds little to our case, which turns on volume against price and the 29 October results. The Metis terms are unknown.

  • LEUCentrus EnergyUnchanged

    Centrus buys Westerman, a maker of centrifuge parts, for about $116 million

    Centrus bought Westerman Holdings on 16 October for about $116 million: $95 million in cash and $21 million in new shares. Westerman builds casings and other parts for Centrus's uranium centrifuges and also sells equipment to oil and gas customers. Centrus says it will lower project costs. It gave no figures for Westerman's sales or profit, and none for the cost of its planned plant.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Owning a parts supplier may help the plant get built, but our case turns on the plant's cost and size, which Centrus has still not disclosed. The cash is small beside what it holds; the new shares make each existing holder's slice slightly smaller.

  • KLICKulicke and Soffa IndustriesThesis changed

    K&S changed the measures its executive bonuses are paid on

    On 13 October K&S's pay committee said that for fiscal 2027 bonuses will pay half on operating profit and half on gross margin, instead of net income and operating margin. Executives will also get 15% of their award from personal goals.

    What it did to the thesisA small update to our note on how the new chief executive is paid. Nothing in the plan pays for growth or cash, which is the point we already made. The case and the view are unchanged.

    1 claim changed
    • C55EditedThe new chief executive's annual bonus targets 110% of a $750,000 salary, paid between 0% and 200% on corporate results whose metrics the compensation committee sets, and he must hold shares worth three times salary within five years. On 13 October 2026 the committee changed the plan for fiscal 2027: the two measures became operating profit and gross margin, half each, and executive awards add a 15% personal-goal share (85% corporate).the 13 October 2026 8-K replaced the bonus measures (net income and operating margin) with operating profit and gross margin for fiscal 2027 and added a 15% individual-goal share for executives
      Was

      The new chief executive's annual bonus targets 110% of a $750,000 salary, paid between 0% and 200% on corporate results whose metrics the compensatio…

  • IESCIES HoldingsRefreshed

    IES's filing confirms it paid about $691 million for DBM

    IES's official filing on the DBM purchase shows a price of about $691 million: $545 million in cash and 430,974 IES shares. The cash came from IES's own money and a credit line enlarged to $700 million. A separate filing shows IES's largest owner, Tontine, still holds about 52% and has not traded in 60 days.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We had counted the deal at $685 million; the difference is only the shares' value on the day before closing. DBM still costs about 7.5 times its yearly profit. IES's shares are about 22% lower than when we wrote, which changes the price paid, not the business.

    3 claims changed
    • C02EditedTontine Associates owns about 52% of the shares and its founder Jeffrey Gendell is Executive Chairman.re-checked on the Tontine group's 13D/A of 6 October: about 51.7% after the DBM share issue, no group transactions in 60 days; the claim of about 52% stands
    • C17EditedIES agreed on 10 August 2026 to buy DBM Global for about $685M, $545M in cash and $140M in shares, and closed it on 5 October 2026 for about $691M, the shares being worth $146M at the 2 October close.closing 8-K read: total consideration about $691M because the share part was valued at the 2 October close; the cash $545M is unchanged and the signed $685M stands as the agreed figure
      Was

      IES agreed on 10 August 2026 to buy DBM Global for about $685M, $545M in cash and $140M in shares, and both companies announced on 5 October 2026 tha…

    • C20EditedIES is paying about 7.5 times DBM's trailing operating profit while its own shares cost 18 times theirs.closing 8-K read: $691M at the 2 October share price against $685M signed; 7.5 times unchanged
  • GEOThe GEO GroupUnchanged

    GEO has paid off all its 2029 secured notes

    GEO announced it finished repaying every one of its senior secured notes due 2029. In an October filing it had said it would repay $650 million of 8.625% notes on 15 October using money from selling its Adelanto facilities. We could read only the headline of the new announcement.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. This is the step our notes already expected, and it fits the first part of the November test, which asks whether the sale money went to debt. The interest saved will show in the 5 November results.

  • GDSGDS Holdings LimitedRefreshed

    DayOne, part-owned by GDS, filed its US listing paperwork in public

    DayOne Data Centers, which GDS partly owns, filed public listing documents on October 5. They show sales of $512 million in the first half of 2026, up from $152 million a year earlier, a half-year loss of $77 million, 666 megawatts being billed, and GDS owning 19.4%. The price and size of the offering are left blank.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in our view. The filing shows DayOne is growing fast and still losing money, as we already had it, and gives no listing price, which is what the value of GDS's stake waits for. GDS's own shares fell about 16%.

    3 claims changed
    • C53NewDayOne filed its Form F-1 publicly on 5 October 2026: revenue was $484.3M in 2025 and $512.0M in the first half of 2026, net loss $367.1M and $77.2M, Billings 666MW at 30 June 2026, and GDS holds 19.4%.DayOne's public F-1 of 5 October gives the stake's business its own filed revenue, loss and billed capacity for the first time
    • C22EditedDayOne had 1,250MW committed and 444MW billable at the end of 2025, lost money, and its revenue appears nowhere in GDS's filings.counter-evidence added from DayOne's public F-1 of 5 October; the claim about GDS's own filings stands
    • C24EditedReuters reported that DayOne plans to make its SEC filing public in mid-October and list in November, raising up to $5B at about $20B, after a $4.5B Series C closed in June.counter-evidence added: the public F-1 arrived 5 October, ahead of the reported mid-October; claim text is the report as made
  • EXEExpand EnergyThesis changed

    Expand names Danny Brown, formerly of Chord Energy, as its permanent chief executive

    Expand's board named Danny Brown chief executive on 19 October, to start about 26 October. He ran Chord Energy and spent two decades at Anadarko. The firing was in February, so the search took about eight and a half months, within the six to nine the chairman promised. Earlier this month it also named a chief accounting officer and lengthened its bank credit line by a year.

    What it did to the thesisThe leadership gap, the biggest open question in our case, is now closed on paper. The view stays Neutral, confidence Medium, because the rest of the case is untested: what Twin Eagle cost, net debt against our billion line, and cash earnings still not cheaper than rivals'.

    4 claims changed
    • C09EditedOn February 6, 2026, Expand's board terminated CEO Domenic (Nick) J. Dell'Osso, Jr. without cause, effective immediately; he also resigned from the board and serves as an external advisor for a transition period. Board Chairman Michael Wichterich was appointed Interim President and CEO the same day, and the 8-K discloses no reason for the termination. On October 19, 2026 the board appointed Daniel E. Brown, age 51, as President and CEO and a director, effective on the start of his employment, anticipated October 26. He was CEO of Chord Energy from July 2024 and of its predecessor Oasis Petroleum from April 2021, after 1998-2021 at Anadarko and Kerr-McGee (U.S. onshore, international and deepwater operations). Wichterich returns to Non-Executive Chairman. The search weighed internal and external candidates. Offer terms: $1,000,000 salary, a 125% target bonus, an annual long-term award with a target value of $8,750,000 (30% restricted units, 70% performance units), and a make-whole award of restricted units at $4,726,662 and performance units at $10,925,584 target value, which the 8-K says compensates for pay forfeited at his prior employer.The board named a permanent chief executive on 2026-10-19 (8-K Item 5.02 and release); the claim's 'no permanent successor named' ended.
      Was

      On February 6, 2026, Expand's board terminated CEO Domenic (Nick) J. Dell'Osso, Jr. without cause, effective immediately; he also resigned from the b…

    • C27EditedThe interim chairman said on the Q2 2026 call (2026-07-29) that the CEO search would take '6 to 9 months', that 'we're at the 6-month mark, and we will meet our goal', and that it was in 'the back third'. It did: the board named Daniel E. Brown on 2026-10-19, 255 days (about 8.4 months) after the 2026-02-06 termination, inside the window that ran to roughly 2026-11-06 (C09). Brown starts about 2026-10-26.Management's July timeline was tested by the appointment on 2026-10-19: a management claim became a fact with the 8-K behind it, and the window held.
      Was

      On the Q2 2026 earnings call held 2026-07-29, Interim President and CEO Michael Wichterich disclosed a timeline for the CEO search that no 8-K carrie…

    • C28EditedExpand's senior leadership turned over almost completely across 2026 in a sequence no single filing shows: the CEO was terminated 2026-02-06 (C09); Marcel Teunissen, age 52, was appointed EVP and CFO effective 2026-04-06, joining from Parkland Corporation where he was President, North America and previously CFO 2020-2024, after more than 20 years at Shell including VP Finance for Integrated Gas Ventures; director John D. Gass notified the company on 2026-04-06 that he would not stand for re-election and retired at the June annual meeting; and on 2026-06-23 Gregory M. Larson, VP-Accounting and Controller, resigned, with Teunissen assuming principal accounting officer duties 'on an interim basis' while the company searches for a permanent controller. On the Q2 call Wichterich added that a Chief Risk Officer and a CHRO had also joined and that the Houston business-development team had been rebuilt. On 2026-10-08 Sarah Grose, age 40, who joined in 2019 and was Director of Corporate Accounting from 2021, was appointed Vice President and Chief Accounting Officer and took over principal accounting officer duties, ending Teunissen's interim cover (8-K filed 2026-10-13).The controller's seat was filled on 2026-10-08 (8-K of 2026-10-13), so the finance chief no longer holds both roles; the claim and its counter-evidence said he did.
      Was

      Expand's senior leadership turned over almost completely across 2026 in a sequence no single filing shows: the CEO was terminated 2026-02-06 (C09); M…

    • C45EditedBelow the new chief executive and the finance chief (C09, C28), Joshua Viets has been EVP and chief operating officer since February 2022, after twenty years at ConocoPhillips; Chris Lacy general counsel since the October 2024 merger; and at the Twin Eagle closing on 2026-09-16 Dan Turco stopped running marketing and became EVP of Commercial Activities, focused on LNG and the marketing integration.The chief executive named on 2026-10-19 replaces the interim one in the sentence (C09); the other three officers are unchanged.
      Was

      Below the interim chief executive and the new CFO (C09, C28), Joshua Viets has been EVP and chief operating officer since February 2022, after twenty…

  • EOSEEos Energy EnterprisesUnchanged

    Eos says third-quarter sales were about $82 million and its losses narrowed

    Before its full report on 5 November, Eos said third-quarter sales were $82 to $83 million, up about a fifth. The loss on making and selling its batteries narrowed from 71 cents per sales dollar to about 54. Orders on hand fell to about $765 million from $807 million, and full-year sales are now expected in the lower half of its $300 to $350 million range.

    What it did to the thesisThe test we set cannot be scored yet: Eos did not say how much came from customers other than its related Frontier venture, or give the adjusted margin. Sales and margin moved the right way, backlog and the forecast the other way. Our view is unchanged.

    Checked against 5 claims - none changed
    • C04UnchangedQ3 2026 gross loss was $44.2M on $82.7M of revenue, a 53% negative margin; adjusted gross margin was negative 44%, against negative 62% in Q2, and adjusted EBITDA negative $63.8M against $71.4M. The nine months lost $137.4M at the gross line on $208.5M of revenue.
    • C03UnchangedQ3 2026 revenue was $82.7M, of which $68.4M was related-party product revenue from projects financed by a Cerberus affiliate and contributed to Frontier Power USA, about 83% of the quarter; product revenue from everyone else was $14.3M, against $12.7M in Q2 and about $56.7M in Q1.
    • C12UnchangedManagement reports backlog of $765M and 3.2 GWh at 30 September 2026, down 5% in the quarter as record shipments were only partly replaced by six new orders, including a $100M order that converted from an existing reservation, and a $24.9B pipeline.
    • C14UnchangedManagement now expects 2026 revenue in the lower half of its $300M to $350M range, saying the move of Line 1 into Thorn Hill from late October will temporarily lower capacity and delay some shipments; nine-month revenue is $208.5M, so the lower half needs $91.5M to $116.5M in the fourth quarter.
    • C05UnchangedCash, equivalents and restricted cash were $344.1M at 30 September 2026, of which $271.2M was unrestricted, against $624.6M at the end of 2025; the nine months used $261.6M in operations and $219.0M in investing, including the investment in Frontier Power USA, and raised $200.1M, including the $87.0M DOE advance.
  • BTDRBitdeer Technologies GroupUnchanged

    Bitdeer reports more bitcoin mined in September and a bigger AI cloud order book

    Bitdeer's last monthly update says it mined 1,355 bitcoin in September and ran 82.3 exahash per second of its own mining power, up from 79.9. Its AI cloud contracts now total about $2.9 billion, up from $0.9 billion. It will report quarterly from now on. It said nothing on its Norway site funding.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our concern is how the Norway site is funded and whether more shares are sold; this update says nothing on either. The bigger AI order book is real but small next to that funding need. November 9 results are the test.

  • AMZNAmazon.comUnchanged

    Amazon backs an Indiana nuclear plant and makes its AI chips easier to program

    X-energy and utility AEP signed a study agreement for 12 small nuclear reactors in Indiana (about 960 megawatts), with Amazon paying part of the development and first in line for the power; no amount or date. Amazon also said new free software, TorchNeuron, lets developers run their existing PyTorch code on its own Trainium AI chips with few changes.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The reactor study ties to the power limit on the build; no cost came with it. The software makes Amazon's chips easier to adopt, but is a beta and the claim is Amazon's own. Our test is the 29 October results.

Friday 16 October1

  • NBNioCorp DevelopmentsThesis changed

    NioCorp reported $405.1M cash and a quarterly profit that came from accounting gains

    NioCorp said it had $405.1M in cash at 30 September, down from $415.0M. It reported $3.7M of profit, but that came from $8.5M of non-cash gains as its share price fell. Operations used $6.1M and the mine entrance $5.9M. Its filing on the Traxys deal lets either side cancel if EXIM has not approved the loan by end-2027.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in the view. Spending matches plan and the profit is not real earnings. The new cancel date ties the niobium sales deal to the EXIM loan, which is still not approved. Scandium still has no bound buyer.

    1 claim changed
    • C26EditedOn 13 October 2026 NioCorp signed a binding definitive agreement with Traxys North America: Traxys will buy 50% of planned ferroniobium on a take-or-pay basis over the first 15 years of production, replacing the earlier Traxys ferroniobium and scandium arrangements, and has the exclusive right, but not the obligation, to buy the scandium, titanium and rare earth products and to market them worldwide for 15 years. The other 50% of ferroniobium stays with ThyssenKrupp under a ten-year offtake. Deliveries depend on project financing, construction, commercial production and final ancillary terms; a Traxys equity investment of up to $30M is under discussion and not agreed. Scandium, titanium and rare earths therefore still have no binding buyer. The 8-K adds that either party may terminate the agreement if the Export-Import Bank has not given final approval of senior debt, or financial close has not happened, by 31 December 2027 (six months more if approved but not closed), and Traxys may terminate if commercial production has not begun within 60 months. The 10-Q repeats the terms as a subsequent event and adds nothing binding for scandium, titanium or rare earths.The 8-K filed for the agreement states a termination right: either party may walk away if EXIM has not given final approval of senior debt by 31 December 2027, and Traxys if commercial production is not reached within 60 months.
      Was

      On 13 October 2026 NioCorp signed a binding definitive agreement with Traxys North America: Traxys will buy 50% of planned ferroniobium on a take-or-…

Thursday 15 October5

  • VSTVistraUnchanged

    Vistra pays off $1 billion of 8% preferred stock, as planned

    Vistra said it is redeeming all of its 8.0% Series A preferred stock, $1.0 billion in total, on 15 October. Preferred stock is a security that pays a fixed dividend ahead of ordinary shareholders. The company said no unpaid dividends were owed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. September's new notes were announced as a way to do this, so it matches the thesis. A second $1.0 billion of preferred stock comes up for the same choice on 15 December. The view stays Neutral.

  • TTMITTM TechnologiesUnchanged

    TTM plans $400 million more spending to make AI circuit boards

    TTM told the SEC on 12 October it plans to spend another $400 million expanding five factories, four in China and one in Malaysia, mostly for the advanced boards used in AI data centres. This is on top of the $1.2 billion already promised for 2025 to 2029. It gave no dates, sales goal or funding plan.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our case moved. It shows demand is strong enough for TTM to spend more, but it also adds to debt that is already rising for the Epiq purchase. Management said it will say more on the September-quarter call.

    Checked against 3 claims - none changed
    • C18UnchangedManagement raised 2026 capital spending from $240M to $260M in February to $300M to $320M in April and $345M to $365M in August, and has committed $1.2B to data center capacity over 2025 to 2029 and more than $400M to US defense plants through 2029.
    • C28UnchangedNet debt is about $2.0B after Epiq and STG, before ILFA, against $465.6M in June.
    • C11UnchangedManagement said its new N+M asymmetric boards, which carry signal and power layers at different thicknesses, would add about $600M of sales in the second half of 2026, a third in the September quarter and two thirds in December, with yields better than planned; data center and networking was to be 49% of September-quarter sales.
  • SMCISuper Micro ComputerRefreshed

    Super Micro names Mark Long as its new chief financial officer

    On 14 October the board made Mark Long chief financial officer, and David Weigand left that role. Long ran finance at Western Digital from 2016 to 2019. The filing gives no reason and no new figures.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in our case. We updated who runs finance. A new finance chief weeks before the 3 November results is worth watching, but the test stays gross margin and cash from operations. View stays Neutral.

    1 claim changed
    • C54EditedCharles Liang founded Super Micro in September 1993 and has been president, chief executive and chairman since; David Weigand was chief financial officer from February 2021 until 14 October 2026, when the board appointed Mark Long, a former Western Digital chief financial officer, to the role (the 8-K does not say whether Weigand remains chief compliance officer, a post he has held since May 2018); co-founder Yih-Shyan (Wally) Liaw, who resigned all positions in January 2018, rejoined the board in December 2023.8-K filed 2026-10-15: Mark Long became chief financial officer on 2026-10-14 and David Weigand ceased in that role; the officer fact was out of date, the argument is unchanged
      Was

      Charles Liang founded Super Micro in September 1993 and has been president, chief executive and chairman since; David Weigand has been chief financia…

  • GEVGE VernovaUnchanged

    Venture Global signs equipment deals with GE Vernova for up to 16 power units

    Venture Global, a US gas exporter, signed a framework with GE Vernova and Baker Hughes for up to 16 gas power units of 720 MW each. It paid to reserve factory space for eight of them, expects its first order by the end of 2026, and may buy the rest until 2027 to 2029.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It is another reservation, the kind our case needs to turn into firm orders, and it was signed after the September quarter ended. The deal is optional beyond the eight reserved, so it tests nothing until orders follow.

  • BKRBaker Hughes CompanyUnchanged

    Venture Global signs framework for up to 16 power plants

    Venture Global told the SEC it signed a framework deal on 9 October with GE Vernova and Baker Hughes for up to 16 power plant units, delivered through 2034. Almost none of it is binding yet. It expects to place the first order by the end of 2026, and neither side must buy or supply more until orders are signed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It shows a customer we already track may buy more power equipment, but it adds no order to Baker Hughes' backlog and its share of the work is not stated. Our case turns on the October results.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C23UnchangedVenture Global's own 10-K says it keeps 'a master supply relationship with Baker Hughes under a long-term master agreement' governing 'the supply of key liquefaction and power equipment', which 'secures equipment supply, pricing, and reserved manufacturing capacity' for existing and future projects and provides for long-term service arrangements; Venture Global lists 194 liquefaction trains across its projects, 152.0 mtpa expected.
    • C07UnchangedThe chief executive said Power Systems generated about $1B of revenue in 2025, booked $2.6B of orders in Q2 2026 including about 150 gas turbines, and approached $4B of orders in the first half against $3.2B for all of 2025; data centres were $2.2B of Q2 2026 Power Systems orders.

Wednesday 14 October6

  • SSentinelOneUnchanged

    SentinelOne is raising $1.25B by selling convertible notes that pay no interest

    SentinelOne said it would sell $1.25 billion of convertible notes due 2031 and then announced that they priced at 0% interest. Holders can swap them for shares later. The shares fell 6.4% on the day of the proposal. We could not read the terms, such as the conversion price.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. The raise adds debt to a company that had $813.2M of cash and no borrowing, and may add shares, but the terms are unread. The case rests on new subscriptions growing and stock pay falling, which show in the December results.

  • RKLBRocket LabThesis changed

    Rocket Lab pushes Neutron's first launch from this year to 2027

    Rocket Lab said its new large rocket, Neutron, will now make its first flight in 2027 instead of this year. Reuters reported the shares fell about 6% in after-hours trading. Rocket Lab had already warned that a launch this year was getting less likely. We could read only the first sentence of the announcement, so any new date is unknown.

    What it did to the thesisOne claim changed: the end-of-2026 target no longer holds. Our test line is a first flight by mid-2027, which is not yet broken, so the view stays unattractive, mainly on price. The 9 November results should name whether a firm date exists.

    1 claim changed
    • C02EditedOn 9 November 2026 Rocket Lab's Q3 release said Neutron's first launch is targeted for 'no earlier than 2027', after the 14 October move out of 2026; it named no pad-delivery date and no launch date, and the 10-Q's Q4 2026 pad-delivery target was not restated. On the call the chief executive said the replacement forward dome is laminated and cured, the Stage 1 tank's forward and aft assemblies remain to be built before hydrostatic tests and shipment to Launch Complex 3 for cryogenic qualification, and Stage 2 is at the pad heading into cryogenic proof tests; no date was given.On 14 October 2026 Rocket Lab moved Neutron's first launch to 2027, so the Q4 2026 pad-delivery and end-of-year launch target this claim recorded no longer holds.
      Was

      Neutron's Stage 1 tank production is currently aligned with a target delivery of the vehicle to the launch pad in Q4 2026, though the window for an e…

  • NFLXNetflixUnchanged

    Netflix cuts about 1,000 jobs, 6% of staff, before its results

    Netflix is cutting about 1,000 jobs, around 6% of its staff, mostly in product, technology, legal and human resources. It is the biggest cut since 2022 and comes six days before results on 20 October. Press reports say the two chief executives told staff the full-year forecast is still on track. The Journal article itself could not be opened.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case watches the full-year forecast and whether profit margin keeps widening. Fewer staff could help margin, but no savings figure was given and the forecast was only reported secondhand. The 20 October results are the real test.

  • IONQIonQUnchanged

    IonQ sells about $2 billion of new shares and warrants

    IonQ sold 50 million new shares at $40 each and gave the buyer warrants, which are rights to buy 100 million more shares at $69.46 within seven years. It raised about $1.99 billion after fees. It had 408.9 million shares before, and the shares fell about 6% to 9% that day.

    What it did to the thesisCash roughly doubles, so running out of money is much less likely. But each existing holder owns a smaller slice: 12% more shares at once, up to 37% more with the warrants, plus the Elisity deal. Our case rests on price and dilution, so the view stays.

  • CIFRCipher MiningUnchanged

    Cipher sold $850M of no-interest convertible notes and swaps old notes for shares

    Cipher priced its $850 million sale of convertible notes, which pay no interest and fall due in November 2032. They convert into shares at about $15.31. It will also hand over about 40.7 million shares to holders of $165.9 million of its 2030 notes. Part of the money buys protection against dilution; the rest goes to Barber Lake and new sites.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the thesis moved yet. More debt and about 40.7 million new shares test our assumption of no large new share issue, but those shares were already counted as possible dilution. The case still turns on Barber Lake rent and new leases, due with 2 November results.

  • BRK.BBerkshire HathawayUnchanged

    Berkshire put $330M more into Bending Spoons, bringing it to about 4%

    Berkshire announced a further $330M investment in Bending Spoons, the app company, after putting in $600M at its stock-market debut. Headlines put its holding near 4%. We could read only the headlines, not the release or the articles, so the terms are unconfirmed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. About $0.93B in total is small beside $359.2B of cash and bills and $340.8B of securities. It shows Abel buying a new stock, which we track, but it changes neither the cash pile nor our view of Berkshire.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C16UnchangedAt 30 September 2026 the insurance and other businesses held $352.3B of cash, cash equivalents and Treasury bills net of unsettled purchases, and $352.6B of equity and fixed maturity securities. Berkshire will not buy back stock if cash and Treasury bills would fall below $30B.
    • C17UnchangedThe five largest equity holdings at 30 June 2026, Alphabet, American Express, Apple, Bank of America and Coca-Cola, were 66% of the fair value of Berkshire's equity securities, against 65% at the end of 2025.

Tuesday 13 October7

  • NBNioCorp DevelopmentsThesis changed

    NioCorp signed a binding 15-year deal to sell half its niobium alloy to Traxys

    NioCorp signed a binding agreement with metals trader Traxys, which will buy half the mine's planned niobium alloy for 15 years, paying even if it does not take delivery. The other half is already contracted to ThyssenKrupp. Traxys also gets the exclusive right, but no duty, to buy and sell its other products.

    What it did to the thesisPart of our open question is answered: all the niobium alloy now has a buyer. But scandium, the biggest part of the mine's value, still has no buyer bound, and the loan to build is uncommitted. The view stays Neutral.

    1 claim changed
    • C26EditedOn 13 October 2026 NioCorp signed a binding definitive agreement with Traxys North America: Traxys will buy 50% of planned ferroniobium on a take-or-pay basis over the first 15 years of production, replacing the earlier Traxys ferroniobium and scandium arrangements, and has the exclusive right, but not the obligation, to buy the scandium, titanium and rare earth products and to market them worldwide for 15 years. The other 50% of ferroniobium stays with ThyssenKrupp under a ten-year offtake. Deliveries depend on project financing, construction, commercial production and final ancillary terms; a Traxys equity investment of up to $30M is under discussion and not agreed. Scandium, titanium and rare earths therefore still have no binding buyer. The 8-K adds that either party may terminate the agreement if the Export-Import Bank has not given final approval of senior debt, or financial close has not happened, by 31 December 2027 (six months more if approved but not closed), and Traxys may terminate if commercial production has not begun within 60 months. The 10-Q repeats the terms as a subsequent event and adds nothing binding for scandium, titanium or rare earths.The Traxys definitive agreement was signed on 13 October: binding take-or-pay for 50% of ferroniobium over 15 years, with exclusive but non-obligatory rights over every other product. It replaces the earlier arrangement, which the filed report called an unsigned draft.
      Was

      The only binding sales agreements are two ferroniobium offtakes, each for ten years: 25% of annual output up to 2,067 short tons a year to a US metal…

  • LPTHLightPath TechnologiesRefreshed

    LightPath won a further $6.3 million counter-drone optics order

    LightPath said a counter-drone and defence systems supplier placed another $6.3 million order for optical assemblies. That customer has now ordered more than $19 million since July, double its total for the year to June. No profit margin or term was given.

    What it did to the thesisLittle moved. It adds to orders we already track, but our case turns on profit margin and backlog at the November results, and an order this size gives neither. The view stays Unattractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C22EditedOn 13 October 2026 LightPath announced a further $6.3M follow-on optical assembly order from the same counter-UAS and defence systems supplier, saying total awards from that customer since 1 July exceed $19M, double its orders for fiscal 2026; this followed $13M of follow-on optical assembly orders announced on 22 July 2026. In fiscal 2025 it had announced $9.7M of cooled infrared camera orders for counter-unmanned-aerial applications with an existing defence customer for fiscal 2026 delivery, and a $2.2M engineering development model order from L3Harris for the Navy's SPEIR programme.A further $6.3M follow-on optical assembly order from the same counter-UAS supplier was announced on 13 October, taking its awards since 1 July above $19M.
      Was

      On 22 July 2026 LightPath announced $13M of follow-on optical assembly orders from a leading counter-UAS and defence systems supplier. In fiscal 2025…

  • JBLJabilUnchanged

    Jabil and Adani sign a non-binding deal to plan a joint India factory

    Jabil and India's Adani Enterprises signed a non-binding memorandum, a statement of intent, to build a 50:50 joint venture making AI and data-center equipment in India. It follows a June alliance announcement. No investment, sales figures or start date were given, and definitive agreements are still needed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case already treated the Adani plan as unproven and not before fiscal 2028. The memo adds a 50:50 structure but no money, volume or contract, so it is not yet evidence for AI growth. The view stays Neutral.

  • IONQIonQUnchanged

    IonQ agrees to buy security firm Elisity for up to $1.3 billion in shares

    IonQ says it will buy Elisity, a company that controls which devices and people can reach a company's network, paying only in new IonQ shares worth up to $1.3 billion, with up to $150 million tied to Elisity's performance. It should close in the fourth quarter. The shares fell about 9% that day.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our view moved yet. The deal adds roughly 6% to 10% more shares, which pushes our share-dilution warning closer without crossing it. Elisity's sales and profit were not disclosed, so we cannot judge the price paid.

  • DGXXDigi Power XUnchanged

    Digi Power X says a lender committed $200 million for its Alabama data center

    Digi Power X says a lender has issued a letter committing $200 million of debt for its 40 MW Alabama data center, to close within 90 days if paperwork and the lender's checks finish. It says no shares were sold under its share-sale programme in the third quarter, and cash is about $135 million.

    What it did to the thesisA step toward the funding route our case wants, debt not share sales. But the loan is not signed, its rate and length are not given, and the company still guarantees it until completion. The view stays Unattractive until results on 12 November.

  • CIFRCipher MiningUnchanged

    Cipher plans $850M of convertible notes and a swap of old notes for shares

    Cipher announced a proposed $850 million private sale of convertible notes that pay no interest and fall due in November 2032, with an option for $150 million more. At the same time it will swap some of its 2030 convertible notes for shares. Price and conversion terms are not yet set.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in the thesis moved yet. It adds debt and possibly shares to the funding and dilution claims, but the size and terms are unknown until pricing. The Barber Lake rent start and new leases, due with 2 November results, remain the test.

  • BULLWebullUnchanged

    Shareholders sued Webull over its China ties; Webull denies the report

    A shareholder class action was filed alleging Webull understated how much its engineering and data work depends on China, for investors who bought between April 2025 and October 2026. Webull also filed a statement saying US customer data and cash stay in the US and the report cites no misuse.

    What it did to the thesisThe suit rests on the committee report we already weighed and orders nothing. Our trigger is a US government action restricting Webull, and none exists. Trading and profit claims did not change, so Neutral holds.

Saturday 10 October2

  • GEOThe GEO GroupRefreshed

    GEO will repay its $650 million 2029 bonds with Adelanto sale money

    GEO filed the details of what it announced on 6 October: on 15 October it will repay all $650 million of its 2029 bonds for about $678 million, using the Adelanto sale money. Its bank credit line of $550 million now runs to 2031.

    What it did to the thesisMost of the $705 million Adelanto money goes to debt, as we assumed, so less is left for buybacks. Debt falls but the business is no bigger, so the price still pays for sales not yet agreed. View stays Neutral.

    2 claims changed
    • C24EditedAt 2026-09-30 GEO held $216.0M of cash against $1,530.6M of long-term debt at book value. On 2026-10-15 it redeemed all $650M of its 8.625% notes due 2029 with Adelanto proceeds, leaving $625M of 10.25% notes due 2031 and a $550M revolver extended to 2031-07-14; liquidity is about $600M.the 8-K of 2026-10-08 gives the size, price and date of the 2029 redemption and the new revolver maturity; the June-30 balances are otherwise unchanged until the Q3 10-Q
      Was

      At 2026-06-30 GEO held $55.0M of cash against about $1.54B of debt: $650M of 8.625% secured notes due 2029, $625M of 10.25% notes due 2031 and $248.9…

    • C56EditedGEO's board raised the share repurchase authorization on 2026-10-05 from $500M to $1.25B, effective through 2029-12-31; GEO says it will use the Adelanto net proceeds with cash flow to reduce debt, repurchase shares and for general purposes, and gives no split. The amended credit agreement of 2026-10-05 permits unlimited buybacks while pro forma total leverage is 2.25 times or less.the 8-K of 2026-10-08 shows the new credit agreement's buyback test; the proceeds' use still has no stated split beyond the 2029 redemption
      Was

      GEO's board raised the share repurchase authorization on 2026-10-05 from $500M to $1.25B, effective through 2029-12-31; GEO says it will use the Adel…

  • ASTSAST SpaceMobileThesis changed

    SpaceX agrees to buy phone airwaves; AST shares fall about 10%

    SpaceX said it will buy a nationwide block of low-frequency radio spectrum from Grain Management, to make Starlink phone service work indoors. It needs US regulator approval and no price was given. SpaceX says most phones already work on that band. AST shares fell 10.5% on the day.

    What it did to the thesisOur view stays Unattractive. We narrowed one claim: AST's edge of working on phones people already own is a shorter window, since SpaceX says this band needs no new phone. No carrier has switched to SpaceX, so no warning sign fired.

    1 claim changed
    • C45EditedThe edge AST still holds is broadband on phones people already own: SpaceX's own filing says today's phones lack the radio hardware for its new 2 GHz bands' 5G-like service, though its pending 800 MHz low-band purchase, which SpaceX says most phones already support, narrows that window.SpaceX's 2026-10-08 low-band purchase is aimed at phones people already own, so the hardware window is narrower than the claim said
      Was

      The edge AST still holds is broadband on phones people already own: SpaceX's own filing says today's phones lack the radio hardware for its new bands…

Friday 9 October5

  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    SpaceX agrees to buy more wireless airwaves; the price was not given

    SpaceX said it will buy a nationwide block of low-frequency radio spectrum from the investment firm Grain Management, to let Starlink Mobile work indoors. It needs US regulator approval and no price was disclosed. Phone carriers' shares fell on the news.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It shows SpaceX widening its spending on phone service, on top of the EchoStar spectrum we already track, but without a price we cannot say what it adds to the cash SpaceX owes. November results are the test.

  • ORCLOracleUnchanged

    OpenAI says its yearly revenue pace is $50 billion, not the $68 billion reported

    OpenAI told investors its revenue is running at about $50 billion a year, lower than the $68 billion figure reported in late September. A person familiar says the higher number counted partners' gross revenue. OpenAI also reported 77% annual growth. Oracle's shares fell about 5.6% that day, as did other AI names.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Most of Oracle's $664 billion of signed future revenue rests on OpenAI, so its ability to pay matters. A different way of counting revenue is not a missed payment or a cancelled contract. The December results are the test.

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    OpenAI says it earns about $50 billion a year, not the $68 billion reported

    OpenAI told investors its yearly sales pace was about $50 billion at the end of September, below a $68 billion figure that had circulated, which counted partners' sales. It also said growth ran at 77% in the quarter. Nvidia, Oracle and CoreWeave shares fell.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We lean on OpenAI only through the loans Nvidia has guaranteed for its data centres, and our case uses neither figure. It is a reminder that those customers must keep growing. Nvidia's November 17 results are the test.

  • BTDRBitdeer Technologies GroupUnchanged

    Bitdeer plans a $100 million share buyback and adds a 67MW Malaysian AI site

    Bitdeer told the SEC it may buy back up to $100 million of its own shares by October 2028. It also signed a 10-year agreement for a new 67MW AI data centre site in Malaysia, with no customer signed for it yet, and says the deals it is discussing are worth over $10 billion.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We worry about funding growth by selling new shares, and a buyback of this size does not change that while a $1 billion share-sale programme is open. The new site adds cost before any customer. November 9 results are the test.

  • AVGOBroadcomUnchanged

    OpenAI's revenue pace is $50 billion, not $68 billion; Broadcom shares fall

    OpenAI told investors its revenue runs at about $50 billion a year, below the $68 billion reported last month; the larger number counted partners' gross revenue. Broadcom's shares fell about 4.4%. Bloomberg also said Broadcom is in early talks to finance OpenAI's chips, which repeats yesterday's report.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We need OpenAI and Anthropic to pay for the chips Broadcom plans. A lower count of OpenAI's revenue does not cancel anything, and financing talks are not a deal. Broadcom's December results should show financing and who backs it.

Thursday 8 October11

  • WOLFWolfspeedRefreshed

    Wolfspeed gets a conditional offer of a $1.5 billion government loan

    The US defence department offered Wolfspeed up to $1.5 billion over 30 years, with the first $600 million repaying its costly 2030 notes. Nothing is signed. It needs Congress to fund it, most convertible notes to turn into shares, $750 million of new money from others, and warrants for up to 7.5% of the company.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. It could cut the interest bill but adds shares, and the case still turns on sales passing breakeven. The 4 November results are the test. View stays Unattractive.

    1 claim changed
    • C57NewOn October 7, 2026 Wolfspeed said it holds a conditional commitment letter from the U.S. Department of War for a senior secured delayed-draw loan of up to $1.5B in four tranches (the first $600M would repay the $635.9M of 2030 first-lien notes), 30 years, at the Treasury rate plus 1.25% to 1.75% with interest payable in kind for five years. It is not signed: it needs definitive agreements, Congressional appropriations, equitising most of the convertible notes, at least $750M of new equity-like money from others and warrants for up to 7.5% of the company. On the November 4 call the chief financial officer said the government's checks need about two more weeks, drawing tranches needs a limited equity raise and other balance-sheet steps, and closing is aimed before year end.the 8-K of 2026-10-07 disclosed a conditional government loan commitment bearing on the cash runway (C40), the first-lien notes (C27) and the conversion of the notes (C29)
  • UUnity SoftwareUnchanged

    Google and Unity announce a joint AI game-making tool, with no money terms

    On 7 October Unity said it is partnering with Google on a platform where people describe a game in words and get one back. Google's Playground is live now; Unity Spark, built on Unity's engine, follows later this year. The release gives no revenue, cost or contract terms.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It touches the engine half, which has been shrinking, but without numbers there is nothing to score. The test is whether engine sales stop falling in the November results. The view stays Unattractive.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C03UnchangedThe engine half has been shrinking for two years: Create Solutions fell from $859,174 thousand in 2023 to $621,409 thousand in 2025, down 27.7%.
    • C05UnchangedThe engine is inside the game after it ships, which is the one thing no advertising network can buy: management says Unity has access to the three billion people playing Unity games.
  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    SpaceX reportedly wants $40 billion of loans for Nvidia chips; FCC approved satellites

    News outlets say SpaceX is in talks to borrow about $40 billion, mostly investment-grade bonds plus bank loans with Apollo leading, to buy Nvidia chips. SpaceX has not confirmed it. Separately the US communications regulator approved 15,000 more Starlink satellites that connect directly to phones and allowed SpaceX to use its own radio spectrum.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The borrowing is unconfirmed, and if real it would weaken our assumption that spending is paid from the $100 billion raised. The approval lets Starlink offer more services but gives no sales figure. The results in November remain the test.

  • ORCLOracleUnchanged

    Reports say Oracle is talking to lenders about funding chips Oracle would then rent

    The Wall Street Journal reports that Oracle is in talks with Apollo and Goldman Sachs. Investors would fund a separate company that buys the chips for a large data centre, and Oracle would lease them over time. Oracle hopes to finish this year. The size is unclear and nothing is signed. The article is paywalled, so details come from summaries.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Rented chips would not show as Oracle's own cash spending, so the $70 billion spending limit we track could look met while commitments grow. It also points away from new share sales. We will read it against leases and debt, not cash spending alone.

  • ONDSOndas HoldingsUnchanged

    Ondas says it won over $165 million of new orders since mid-August

    Ondas says it won more than $165 million of orders from mid-August to October 1, which with about $105 million announced in August makes over $270 million since June 30. It named no customers apart from the $56 million European order already reported, and gave no sales figures.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. This is the company's own count of orders, not sales or cash, and our view rests on whether orders turn into the guided revenue. The November quarterly report is the test, so we keep our view.

  • MRVLMarvell TechnologyUnchanged

    Marvell raised its fiscal 2028 sales goal to about $20 billion

    At its 6 October investor day Marvell said it now expects about $20 billion of sales in the year to January 2028, up from $18 billion in August, and $70 billion to $90 billion in fiscal 2031. We only found news reports of this, not the company's slides.

    What it did to the thesisOur case assumed about $18 billion, so a key input moved up, but nothing changes until the company's own slides are read. No dated target for fiscal 2029, the year we asked about, was reported. The view stays Unattractive.

    Checked against 3 claims - none changed
    • C04UnchangedManagement guides Q3 FY27 revenue of $3.15B plus or minus 5%, more than 50% above a year earlier, and EPS of $1.10 excluding stock pay and amortization ($0.53 on the official accounts) on about 921M diluted shares. It expects about $12B of FY27 revenue and about $18B in FY28, up about 50%, raised from about $13B in December 2025, $15B in March and $16.5B in May, and an operating margin excluding stock pay and amortization of 38% to 40% from Q4 FY27.
    • C05UnchangedManagement says custom silicon revenue will more than double in FY28 and accelerate significantly in FY29, and that revenue from the programs covered by the Google warrant through FY28 is already inside its custom target; the larger effect comes in FY29 and later.
    • C14UnchangedAnalysts' average forecast is $6.76 of adjusted earnings a share, excluding stock pay and amortization, for the year to January 2028 on forecast sales of $18.17B (26 analysts), and $10.47 for the year to January 2029 on forecast sales of $26.25B (17 analysts). 60 rate the shares a buy, 12 a hold and 1 a sell; the share of positive ratings rose from 73.3% of 45 analysts in February to 87.0% of 46 on 1 October.
  • IONQIonQThesis changed

    IonQ says it has moved into DARPA's final quantum testing stage

    IonQ says it has moved into Stage C, the last stage, of a US defence research agency contest on quantum computers. The agreement is worth up to $300 million, runs through 2029, and money beyond the first payment depends on future government funding. The agency's own announcement and the list of other companies were not found.

    What it did to the thesisA step we had listed as good news happened, so we updated the notes. It does not change our view: the worry is the price and the many new shares issued, and neither moved. The amount is a ceiling, not cash received.

    2 claims changed
    • C53NewIonQ says it signed a Stage C agreement with DARPA's Quantum Benchmarking Initiative on 7 October 2026 with a potential value of up to $300 million, running through 2029, with funding beyond the initial obligation subject to appropriations; it says it is among the first companies selected, and that DARPA will test several generations of its Superion systems.IonQ's 7 October release: the Stage C step the invalidation list and bet milestones were waiting for
    • C20EditedDARPA picked 11 companies for Stage B of its Quantum Benchmarking Initiative in November 2025, including IonQ, Quantinuum, IBM, QuEra and Xanadu; it says no single dominant architecture exists and that the program is not meant to narrow the field to a few winners. IonQ says it has since entered Stage C, as one of the first companies selected (C53); DARPA has published no Stage C list.IonQ announced it advanced to Stage C; the claim now notes that, without DARPA's list of who else did
      Was

      DARPA picked 11 companies for Stage B of its Quantum Benchmarking Initiative in November 2025, including IonQ, Quantinuum, IBM, QuEra and Xanadu; it…

  • BULLWebullThesis changed

    A House committee says Webull's China ties are a national-security risk

    A US House committee published a report saying Webull's China links, including engineers in China and how data and customer cash are handled, are a national-security risk. The report orders nothing and carries no fine. Webull says it has significant inaccuracies. The shares fell about 19%. We could not open the report itself, only news accounts.

    What it did to the thesisThis is the risk we already listed, now written down by lawmakers. Our trigger is an actual US action that restricts Webull, and none exists, so it is closer but not hit. Trading and profit claims did not change, and Neutral holds.

    1 claim changed
    • C27EditedAbout 800 of Webull's 1,396 employees work in research and technology, much of it at a development centre in Changsha, China; 14 state attorneys general wrote in April 2024 and a House committee has asked about its China links. On 7 October 2026 the House Select Committee on China published a report calling Webull's China ties a national-security risk, naming its ownership structure, technical staff, cross-border data routing and, since October 2025, its handling of customer cash; the report carries no order or fine and Webull called it inaccurate.The House Select Committee on China report of 7 October 2026 turned a question some lawmakers had asked into a published finding; read second-hand because the report itself could not be fetched.
      Was

      About 800 of Webull's 1,396 employees work in research and technology, much of it at a development centre in Changsha, China; 14 state attorneys gene…

  • AVGOBroadcomUnchanged

    Reports say Broadcom is lining up over $50 billion of lender funding for OpenAI

    The Wall Street Journal reports that Broadcom is working to arrange more than $50 billion of financing so lenders can pay for the custom AI chips it builds with OpenAI. Apollo and Blackstone are among those approached. Talks are early, could change, and a deal is hoped for before year-end. The article is behind a paywall, so details come from summaries.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We want a second funding round led by outside lenders, and this is a step toward one, but nothing is signed. What matters is whether Broadcom guarantees any of it, which the reports do not say. The December results should show.

  • ANETArista NetworksUnchanged

    Arista announces Ethernet racks for linking up to 144 AI chips

    Arista announced complete liquid-cooled racks that link up to 144 AI processors over Ethernet, and up to 1,024 across racks, plus racks for the wider network between racks. It named partners such as AMD, Broadcom, Meta and Microsoft but no customer, order, price or delivery date. It will show them at a trade event on 12 to 15 October.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our notes say Arista's chief executive expects little role in the links inside Nvidia's own systems and that moving off Nvidia's technology will take time. This is a product launch to test that, not an order. Results on 3 November are the next check.

  • AEHRAehr Test SystemsUnchanged

    Aehr's biggest customer ordered more machines for a newer AI chip

    Aehr said its lead cloud-computing customer placed more orders for Aehr's Sonoma chip-testing machines, this time for a newer AI processor, its second chip program on those machines. We could only read the headline and a one-line teaser, so the order's size and delivery dates are unknown.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. This customer's repeat orders are already part of our case, and without a dollar figure the news cannot show whether the sales guide is safe. The price already assumes strong growth, so Unattractive holds until bookings are measured on 6 November.

Wednesday 7 October7

  • UBERUber TechnologiesUnchanged

    Uber will buy catering platform ezCater for $2.3 billion in cash

    Uber said on 6 October it will buy ezCater, which lets businesses order food from over 140,000 restaurants for meetings and events. The price is $2.3B in cash. ezCater handled over $2.5B of orders in the last twelve months, growing in the high teens, and is profitable.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The deal adds about 1% to Uber's order volume and uses cash while the Delivery Hero purchase is already under way. We watch the cash and debt claims, and the Delivery Hero timing, but the release gives no closing date or financing.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C29UnchangedThe deal is already consuming the buyback: Uber deployed about $4B in Q2 2026 on market purchases of Delivery Hero stock, and repurchases of its own shares fell to $518M in the quarter from $1,363M a year earlier. The chief financial officer said the policy is to deploy about 50% of free cash flow to buybacks and that rebuilding to that level is 'months, not quarters'.
    • C31UnchangedTotal debt rose to $12,723M at 30 June 2026 from $10,521M at 31 December 2025 while cash and short-term investments fell to $5,391M from $7,633M, and the acquisition financing is executed rather than indicative: a term loan credit agreement dated 6 August 2026 with Morgan Stanley Senior Funding as administrative agent and five joint lead arrangers was filed two days after the quarter's 10-Q.
  • NVTSNavitas SemiconductorRefreshed

    Navitas completes its Claros purchase, adding chips that power the processor directly

    Navitas finished buying Claros, a young company making power delivery that sits right under an AI chip. The filing confirms the closing but not new terms. Navitas says the deal doubles the market it can sell into. Claros revenue and losses are not disclosed.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The cash and new shares were already counted in our case, and the market-size claim is management's own. We still need signed 2027 demand and revenue. The November results are the test.

    1 claim changed
    • C13EditedNavitas closed its purchase of Claros, a 2024 start-up making power delivery that sits under the processor, on 2026-10-06. The terms announced in August were up to $232.8M: $216.0M at closing in cash and 6.91M shares, up to 1.29M more shares on milestones, plus about $28.9M of share awards to its staff. The closing 8-K does not restate the final cash and share amounts, and no Claros revenue or financial statements are disclosed.the deal closed on 2026-10-06 (8-K Item 8.01), so it is no longer pending; terms not restated at closing
      Was

      Navitas agreed to buy Claros, a 2024 start-up making power delivery that sits under the processor, for up to $232.8M: $216.0M at closing in cash and…

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    SpaceX reportedly wants to borrow $40 billion to buy Nvidia chips

    The Financial Times reported, and Reuters repeated, that SpaceX is raising $40 billion, about $10 billion of bank loans and $30 billion of bonds led by Apollo, to buy Nvidia chips, closing in 2027. Neither company has confirmed it, and no filing exists. Only press copies could be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It fits demand we already assume and shows a buyer paying with borrowed money, which our financing worry already covers. Unconfirmed, with no Nvidia contract or guarantee reported, it is not evidence for the numbers. November 17 results remain the test.

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    UK regulator investigates Meta's safety checks on a new Instagram feature

    Ofcom, the UK communications regulator, is investigating whether Meta checked properly for illegal content and child access before launching Instagram Instants. Possible outcomes range from a warning to a fine of up to 10% of global revenue. Meta says it did a risk analysis and will cooperate. Separately, Meta joined a group of firms on a standard for dealing with AI bots; we read only that headline.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It adds to the legal scrutiny we already track on youth safety, but no finding or fine exists yet. The bot-standard news is a membership, with no revenue figure, so it does not answer our question about AI revenue.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C18UnchangedMeta's June 2026 quarter release warns that 'we continue to see scrutiny on youth-related issues in several markets and have a number of youth-related trials scheduled for this year in the U.S., which may ultimately result in a material loss'. The same quarter carried $2.4 billion of charges related to legal proceedings, which caused the company to raise the lower end of its full-year expense guidance. The quarter's 10-Q names two New Mexico Attorney General cases. In the youth-safety case a jury ordered a $375 million civil penalty on March 24, 2026 and the state sought $953 million in abatement; the Attorney General's own release list carries an August 7, 2026 headline reading 'Court Orders Meta to Pay $942 Million'. In the Cambridge Analytica data-privacy case the Attorney General 'has indicated that they intend to seek up to $62.85 billion in penalties', and on September 25, 2026 a jury found that Meta violated New Mexico's consumer protection law. At the October 1, 2026 penalty hearing the state asked the judge to apply the $5,000 statutory maximum per violation, which it puts at $219 billion, and then reduce the award to between $35 billion and $40 billion; Meta proposed a judgment of $345 million to $3.45 billion and signalled it would appeal. The judge said he would rule by late October. No penalty has been set in that case. On 21 October 2026 a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in the Cambridge Analytica case, on a jury finding of 43 million violations at $5,000 each; Meta says it will appeal (S30). Separately the August 2026 agreement with 52 attorneys general provides for payments of up to about $18.59 billion and produced a $9.89 billion charge in the September quarter (S28). The Q3 2026 10-Q adds that the order carries 15% post-judgment interest, that Meta has accrued an amount for the loss, and that it 'may be required to post a bond or other collateral during the course of the appeal, which could result in significant costs'; the court reserved ruling on injunctive relief.
    • C17UnchangedMeta reports 9 million small businesses using at least one of its generative AI ad creative tools, an Advantage+ end-to-end solution suite at 'over $75 billion in annual revenue run rate', and a 60% increase in the number of people interacting with its Meta AI assistant daily since it was rebuilt on the Muse Spark model. It cites a Brazilian rental car company, Movida, reporting a 44% increase in daily bookings through WhatsApp with 85% of conversations resolved by an AI agent without human assistance.
  • FICOFair IsaacUnchanged

    FICO says it will cut about 15% of its jobs

    FICO told the SEC it will remove about 15% of its positions, by simplifying layers, tools and using AI in product work. Staff were told from the week of 5 October and the plan should finish by mid-2027. It expects about $27.0M of one-off severance costs this quarter.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our view turns on the mortgage score price and volume, which this does not touch. Lower costs could lift profit margins later, but the company gave no savings figure, so we wait for the November results.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C50UnchangedPer sales dollar, cost of revenues fell from 20.6 cents in fiscal 2023 to 14.9 over the four quarters to June 2026, R&D from 10.6 to 8.7, selling, general and administrative from 26.5 to 24.3 and share pay from 8.2 to 7.3, while operating margin rose from 42.5% to 51.7%.
    • C20UnchangedSoftware segment operating income was $55.0M on $215.3M of revenue in Q3 FY2026, against $67.9M a year earlier; for fiscal 2025 it was $247.7M, a 30% margin.
  • CEGConstellation EnergyUnchanged

    Google signs a long-term deal for 890 MW of Constellation nuclear power

    Google and Constellation announced a long-term deal for 890 megawatts of new nuclear capacity on the grid that serves the mid-Atlantic and Midwest (PJM). Google is the third named buyer after Walmart and Amazon. The announcement could not be opened, so the length, price, start date and whether it is part of the 920 megawatts signed in August are not known.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Our case needs named, sized power deals to keep arriving, and this is the largest so far. Without terms we cannot say how much it adds beyond the August batch. The next results, due 9 November, should show whether it is new.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C07UnchangedThrough the Q3 2026 print (2026-11-09) Constellation says it has contracted about 8,500 MW of long-term agreements this year, about 4,560 MW of it with three customers in the quarter: a 20-year, 690 MW power purchase agreement with Amazon supporting Calvert Cliffs (September), a 20-year agreement with Google for about 890 MW of incremental nuclear capacity plus a 15-year, 2,700 MW financial load-following agreement (October), and a 20-year, 270 MW 'Peak+' agreement from 2028 with a customer it does not name. This follows the 920 MW batch of the Q2 print, of which only Walmart (176 MW) was named.
    • C09UnchangedOn the Q2 2026 earnings call, management described being engaged in a confidential bilateral contracting process with customers to add megawatts 'in combination with our existing capabilities,' referencing a 6 GW PJM reliability shortfall figure and '5 gigawatts' of newly eligible capacity highlighted on the prior call, while declining to disclose specific pricing or customer identity 'to protect customer sensitivity.'
  • APLDApplied DigitalUnchanged

    Applied Digital lines up power for a possible data centre site in Finland

    Applied Digital said it has secured access to up to 1 gigawatt of potential power in Finland, its first project outside the United States. It is marketing the site and talking to the largest cloud companies, but has no customer signed. More spending depends on demand and approvals. We could only read a news report of the announcement.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case rests on already-signed leases in the United States and on whether recurring rent takes over from construction revenue. A Finland site with no customer adds no rent and no cost yet; it is an option, and the results are the test.

Tuesday 6 October15

  • ZETAZeta Global HoldingsUnchanged

    Zeta agrees to buy AI engineering firm Senso

    Zeta Global says it agreed to buy Senso, which it describes as adding AI engineering and a way to connect to the leading AI models. We could read only the headline. The price, whether it is paid in cash or shares, and how big Senso is were not readable.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Zeta has paid for several smaller companies already. Until we see the price we cannot say whether it strains the cash Zeta holds or adds to the shares it issues.

  • VSTVistraUnchanged

    Energy Department says it will offer Vistra up to $4.2 billion for nuclear plants

    The US Energy Department said it will offer Vistra a conditional loan commitment of up to $4.2 billion to expand and modernize its nuclear plants in two states. That matches last weekend's reports. The interest rate, repayment terms and conditions have not been published, and Vistra has filed nothing.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. The thesis already counts nuclear upgrades for the Meta contracts, and cheap government debt could ease paying for them. Until the terms are known we cannot say whether it adds debt or lowers costs. Our view stays Attractive.

  • VRTVertiv HoldingsUnchanged

    Vertiv hires a new head of manufacturing from Stellantis

    Vertiv named Michael Resha, who ran stamping and injection operations at the carmaker Stellantis, to lead its factories, logistics and operational improvement. He replaces Anders Karlborg, who moves to a special projects role. The release gives no reason and no numbers.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case watches whether Vertiv delivers its second-half ramp, and it has had execution slips before. A new factory chief is worth noting but says nothing yet about output or margins. The October 28 results are the test.

  • TERTeradyneUnchanged

    Teradyne invests in Bright Machines, a maker of AI data-centre hardware

    Teradyne said on 5 October it made a strategic investment in Bright Machines, a company that builds AI and data-centre equipment in small automated factories. The two will look at using Teradyne's robots and test equipment there. No price, stake or order size was given in the text we could read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The deal touches Teradyne's robotics business, which earned a small loss last quarter, and our case rests on chip testing. Without an amount or an order there is nothing to measure it by, so it waits for the October results.

  • NVTSNavitas SemiconductorUnchanged

    Navitas and Microchip announce a joint 800-volt design for AI data centers

    Navitas and Microchip announced a shared reference design, a blueprint other makers can copy, for 800-volt power in AI data centers. Only the headline could be read. No order, volume or date is known.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A blueprint is a step toward sales, not a sale. Our case needs signed 2027 demand and revenue that has not yet arrived. The November results are the test.

  • NVDANVIDIAUnchanged

    Groq's former stockholders sue Nvidia, saying they were shortchanged in the $20 billion deal

    Stockholders of the chip startup Groq sued Nvidia, alleging they were shortchanged when Nvidia paid $20 billion to license Groq's technology and hire its people. Only the headline could be read. A video also recapped Nvidia's $235 billion buyback, announced September 28.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The Justice Department is already examining the same deal, and a private suit adds legal risk we cannot size without the complaint. The buyback is old news already in our numbers. The November 17 results are the test.

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    Norway limits camera glasses in public; Meta contests UK data demands

    Norway temporarily banned using camera glasses, including Meta's, in places such as parks, schools and beaches. Sale of the glasses is still allowed. Separately, Meta, TikTok and X are contesting the UK regulator's demands for data about their services. We read the Norway article in full and only the UK headline.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The glasses earned $431M last quarter against a $4.6B loss in that unit, and a use restriction in one country does not change that. The UK case adds to the legal scrutiny we already track; no penalty or figure is attached.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C12UnchangedReality Labs produced $431 million of revenue in the June 2026 quarter, up 16% year over year on AI glasses growth partially offset by lower Quest headset sales, against a segment operating loss of $4,619 million - an operating margin of negative 1,072%. The segment consumed 24.6% of what Family of Apps earned in the quarter.
    • C18UnchangedMeta's June 2026 quarter release warns that 'we continue to see scrutiny on youth-related issues in several markets and have a number of youth-related trials scheduled for this year in the U.S., which may ultimately result in a material loss'. The same quarter carried $2.4 billion of charges related to legal proceedings, which caused the company to raise the lower end of its full-year expense guidance. The quarter's 10-Q names two New Mexico Attorney General cases. In the youth-safety case a jury ordered a $375 million civil penalty on March 24, 2026 and the state sought $953 million in abatement; the Attorney General's own release list carries an August 7, 2026 headline reading 'Court Orders Meta to Pay $942 Million'. In the Cambridge Analytica data-privacy case the Attorney General 'has indicated that they intend to seek up to $62.85 billion in penalties', and on September 25, 2026 a jury found that Meta violated New Mexico's consumer protection law. At the October 1, 2026 penalty hearing the state asked the judge to apply the $5,000 statutory maximum per violation, which it puts at $219 billion, and then reduce the award to between $35 billion and $40 billion; Meta proposed a judgment of $345 million to $3.45 billion and signalled it would appeal. The judge said he would rule by late October. No penalty has been set in that case. On 21 October 2026 a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in the Cambridge Analytica case, on a jury finding of 43 million violations at $5,000 each; Meta says it will appeal (S30). Separately the August 2026 agreement with 52 attorneys general provides for payments of up to about $18.59 billion and produced a $9.89 billion charge in the September quarter (S28). The Q3 2026 10-Q adds that the order carries 15% post-judgment interest, that Meta has accrued an amount for the loss, and that it 'may be required to post a bond or other collateral during the course of the appeal, which could result in significant costs'; the court reserved ruling on injunctive relief.
  • INTCIntelUnchanged

    Musk says TSMC may join his chip venture; Intel shares fall

    Elon Musk said talks are under way for TSMC to join Terafab, his Texas chip venture whose named manufacturing process is Intel's. He called them 'just discussions'. Intel shares fell about 2.6% the next session. Only a headline and a second outlet's copy could be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case already assumes Intel has no named outside customer with committed volume, so a possible rival at Terafab removes hope rather than a fact. It leans the same way as our Unattractive view, and the October results are the real test.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C14UnchangedIntel committed in Q2 2026 to high-volume production of Intel 14A in 2028, describing external customer progress only as milestones for “potential significant customers”.
    • C58UnchangedOn the market case, Intel Foundry's external revenue reaches about $9.2B in 2029: 3% of a leading-edge merchant wafer market of about $175B, 10% of about $27.5B of TSMC-scale advanced packaging, and today's $1.17B base.
  • IESCIES HoldingsRefreshed

    IES says its purchase of steel business DBM Global is done

    IES Holdings and the seller, INNOVATE, each announced on 5 October that IES has finished buying DBM Global, a steel and modular builder. We could read only the headlines. The final price, any change to the terms and the exact closing date were not readable, and IES has not yet filed its closing report.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in our view. We already counted the purchase at about $685 million. What changed is wording: the deal is done, so the seller's right to walk away has lapsed. DBM's profit now counts inside IES, and the first results that show it come in 2027.

    5 claims changed
    • C17EditedIES agreed on 10 August 2026 to buy DBM Global for about $685M, $545M in cash and $140M in shares, and closed it on 5 October 2026 for about $691M, the shares being worth $146M at the 2 October close.2026-10-06 news review: IES and INNOVATE announced the sale completed; terms at closing not read, so the signed figure stands
      Was

      IES agreed on 10 August 2026 to buy DBM Global for about $685M, $545M in cash and $140M in shares.

    • C18EditedDBM Global earned $56.8M of operating profit in its last audited year, down from $65.5M, and $91.8M over the trailing twelve months.2026-10-06 news review: refresh trigger 'deal close' fired on the closing announcement; re-dated, claim text unchanged
    • C44EditedDBM's own management forecasts cash profit falling from $129M in 2026 to $120M in 2027, on rising revenue.2026-10-06 news review: refresh trigger 'deal close' fired on the closing announcement; re-dated, claim text unchanged
    • C46EditedThe seller receives 430,974 IES shares after the split and says it expects to sell them once a 60-day lock-up ends.2026-10-06 news review: refresh trigger 'deal close' fired on the closing announcement; re-dated, claim text unchanged
    • C56EditedThe DBM purchase agreement let either side walk away without a fee if it had not closed by 8 February 2027; the sale was announced as completed on 5 October 2026, so that right has lapsed.2026-10-06 news review: closing announced, so the walk-away right lapsed; refresh trigger 'deal close' fired
      Was

      Either side can walk away from the DBM purchase without a fee if it has not closed by 8 February 2027, or 8 August 2027 if regulators are still revie…

  • GEOThe GEO GroupThesis changed

    GEO sells three California detention centres to the government for $950 million

    GEO sold three Adelanto, California centres with 2,644 beds to the Department of Homeland Security for $950 million, about $359,300 a bed. It expects $705 million after tax and fees, will keep running them under its ICE contract, and raised its share buyback limit to $1.25 billion.

    What it did to the thesisThis is the sale our view was waiting on, at a better price a bed than CoreCivic got. It covers about 38% of what the share price counts on, and no further sale is agreed, so the view stays Neutral.

    9 claims changed
    • C55NewOn 2026-10-02 GEO sold its 1,280-bed Adelanto West, 660-bed Adelanto East and 704-bed Desert View facilities in California to DHS for $950M, about $359,300 a bed, expecting about $705M after tax and fees; it expects to keep operating all three under its ICE contract, whose full term runs to 2034-12-19.the first DHS sale the price was leaning on has closed
    • C56NewGEO's board raised the share repurchase authorization on 2026-10-05 from $500M to $1.25B, effective through 2029-12-31; GEO says it will use the Adelanto net proceeds with cash flow to reduce debt, repurchase shares and for general purposes, and gives no split. The amended credit agreement of 2026-10-05 permits unlimited buybacks while pro forma total leverage is 2.25 times or less.what the first sale's proceeds may do per share
    • C57NewPro forma for Adelanto's about $705M of net proceeds, enterprise value is about $4.83B at $31.94, 8.5 times the $570.5M 2026 guidance midpoint against about 7 times before; the remaining $0.83B gap to 7 times is about 3,100 beds at Adelanto's net price a bed, fewer than the 5,919 beds GEO classified as held for sale in October (C62).how much of what the price pays for the Adelanto sale delivers
    • C17EditedCoreCivic says the four sales averaged about $307,000 a bed; GEO sold its 2,388-bed Lawton prison to Oklahoma in 2025 for $312M, about $131,000 a bed. GEO's own Adelanto sale on 2026-10-02 was about $359,300 a bed (C55).GEO's own per-bed price, the DHS purchase the refresh trigger named, is now known
      Was

      CoreCivic says the four sales averaged about $307,000 a bed; GEO sold its 2,388-bed Lawton prison to Oklahoma in 2025 for $312M, about $131,000 a bed.

    • C20EditedGEO says it remains in an active process to sell several more company-owned facilities to ICE and keep operating them, subject to agreement on price; its 2026-10-05 8-K, its 2026-11-05 results release and its 10-Q filed 2026-11-06 all say there is no definitive agreement and no precise timeline for any further sale.the first sale closed on 2026-10-02 (C55); what remains in process is the further sales, with no agreement or date
      Was

      GEO says it is in an active process to sell several turnkey facilities to ICE and keep operating them, with ICE re-procuring four sites; no agreement…

    • C21EditedGEO filed its first 8-K reporting a sale to DHS on 2026-10-05, for the Adelanto complex (C55), after none through 2026-09-27; Clearfield County extended the Moshannon Valley agreement only to mid-March 2027, on a 2-1 vote.the 8-K that the claim said had not been filed was filed on 2026-10-05
      Was

      By 2026-09-27 GEO had filed no 8-K reporting a sale, and Clearfield County extended the Moshannon Valley agreement only to mid-March 2027, on a 2-1 v…

    • C29EditedThe shares closed at $13.26 on 2026-02-20, $32.34 on 2026-10-05, $27.53 on 2026-11-04 and $31.94 on 2026-11-10, up 16.0% from 4 November; the 52-week range at 2026-10-05 was $12.51 to $33.20.re-struck at the 2026-10-05 close after the Adelanto sale
      Was

      The shares closed at $13.26 on 2026-02-20 and $31.22 on 2026-09-25; the 52-week range is $12.51 to $33.15.

    • C30EditedAt $31.94 enterprise value is about $5.53B on the 30 September balance sheet (about 132M shares, $1.53B of debt, $216.0M of cash); that is 10.2 times trailing Adjusted EBITDA of $544.6M and 9.7 times the $570.5M 2026 guidance midpoint; the vendor's prior-year median EV/EBITDA is 7.0.re-struck at the 2026-10-05 close, $32.34, after the Adelanto sale
      Was

      At $31.22 enterprise value is about $5.60B; that is 10.8 times trailing Adjusted EBITDA of $519.4M and 10.1 times the $555M 2026 guidance midpoint; t…

    • C31EditedAt the old 7 times, $570.5M supports about $4.0B of enterprise value, about $20 a share on the 30 September balance sheet; the $1.54B gap to the price is what about 5,800 beds would net at Adelanto's price after tax, of which Adelanto's 2,644 beds net about $705M, about 46%.re-struck at the 2026-10-05 close and the first sale's proceeds set against the gap
      Was

      At the old 7 times, $555M supports about $3.9B of enterprise value, about $18 a share; the $1.7B gap is what about 7,600 beds would net at CoreCivic'…

  • BWXTBWX TechnologiesUnchanged

    BWXT's small reactor is chosen for a Canadian mobile nuclear plant

    BWXT says its BANR microreactor, a small reactor built in a factory and moved by rail, ship or truck, was chosen for a Canadian transportable nuclear plant project. We could read only the headline: who the customer is, how many reactors, and whether any money is committed were not readable.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Our case already counts the US Army's choice of BANR. A selection is not an order, so the claim that BWXT may win a new-build order by year-end is untested until the terms are read.

  • BRK.BBerkshire HathawayUnchanged

    Berkshire bought another $193M of Lennar shares, now about 12% of it

    A filing on 5 October shows Berkshire's insurance subsidiaries bought about $193M of homebuilder Lennar's shares on 1 and 2 October, at $77 to $82 each. They now hold 28.4M Class A shares. Barron's puts Berkshire's stake at 12%. Three earlier Berkshire filings on Lennar were made in September.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is about $0.19B against $340.8B of investments, so it changes neither the cash pile nor the biggest holdings in our case. It does show Abel putting cash to work in a stock, which we track, but one stake does not settle that.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C17UnchangedThe five largest equity holdings at 30 June 2026, Alphabet, American Express, Apple, Bank of America and Coca-Cola, were 66% of the fair value of Berkshire's equity securities, against 65% at the end of 2025.
    • C16UnchangedAt 30 September 2026 the insurance and other businesses held $352.3B of cash, cash equivalents and Treasury bills net of unsettled purchases, and $352.6B of equity and fixed maturity securities. Berkshire will not buy back stock if cash and Treasury bills would fall below $30B.
  • BKRBaker Hughes CompanyUnchanged

    Baker Hughes signs two Venezuela gas deals, no value given

    Baker Hughes announced on 5 October that it signed two Venezuela agreements: an alliance with the state oil company and two partners to build a gas business from wells to LNG exports, and a memorandum with New Stratus Energy on future oil and gas projects. As we read it, no dollar value, order or date was given.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Neither deal is an order, and the alliance needs separate project agreements first. Our case turns on equipment orders and margins in the October results, so this is a possible future customer, not evidence.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C22UnchangedOFSE revenue was $3.45B in Q2 2026, down 5% on Q2 2025, with Middle East/Asia down 13% as the regional conflict disrupted activity; OFSE's EBITDA margin was 17.5% against 18.7%, and management expects global upstream spending to 'decline modestly' in 2026 despite oil prices near $100.
    • C24UnchangedIn Q2 2026 Baker Hughes booked about $1.8B of LNG equipment across three projects - six liquefaction blocks (12 modules) for Venture Global's CP2, equipment for Cheniere's Sabine Pass Train 7, and four turbine-driven compressor trains for a Golar floating LNG vessel, its fourth Golar vessel - and $2.9B of LNG equipment in the first half, more than in all of 2025.
  • ADEAAdeiaUnchanged

    Adeia renews its patent licence with cable company Spectrum

    Adeia says it renewed the patent licence it holds with Spectrum, the cable and internet brand of Charter. We could read only the headline. The length of the deal, which patents it covers and what Spectrum pays were not readable.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Charter was already on our list of licensed customers, and a renewal fits management's claim that most customers renew. Without the terms we cannot tell whether the payments rose or fell.

  • AAOIApplied OptoelectronicsRefreshed

    Applied Optoelectronics finished selling new shares: 5.69M shares, $588M raised

    The company said on 5 October it finished its third programme of selling new shares on the open market. It sold 5,694,845 shares at an average $105.36 and kept $588.0M after fees. It plans to spend the money on equipment and machinery for production and research.

    What it did to the thesisThe case already counted dilution as a cost, so nothing moved. The share count is now about 90.3M against the 100M line in our criteria, and the money lowers the funding risk while each existing holder owns a smaller slice of the business.

    1 claim changed
    • C16EditedShares outstanding rose from 75,198,817 on 24 February 2026 to 84,569,237 on 3 August 2026, 12.5% in five months, after selling about 7.78M shares at the market between March and June. Diluted weighted shares were 81.6M in the second quarter against 56.8M a year earlier, the Q3 guide assumes 92.8M, and a third $600M at-the-market programme was signed on 21 August. On 5 October the company said it had completed that programme: 5,694,845 shares at an average $105.36, $588.0M net of commissions. The 10-Q cover shows 90,770,732 shares on 2 November, 9.2M short of the 100M in the third invalidation criterion, and the Q4 guide assumes about 96M diluted shares.5 October release: the third at-the-market programme is complete, 5.69M shares at $105.36, $588.0M net; adds the pro forma share count against the 100M criterion
      Was

      Shares outstanding rose from 75,198,817 on 24 February 2026 to 84,569,237 on 3 August 2026, 12.5% in five months, after selling about 7.78M shares at…

Sunday 4 October3

  • VSTVistraUnchanged

    US reportedly set to lend Vistra $4.2 billion for nuclear plants

    Reuters and Bloomberg, quoting unnamed sources, say the US Energy Department will lend Vistra about $4.2 billion to squeeze more output from three of its four nuclear plants. The Energy Secretary is expected to announce it on Monday. Neither Vistra nor the department has confirmed it, and no terms are public.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. The thesis already counts nuclear uprates for the Meta contracts, and cheap government debt could ease how they are paid for, but without terms or confirmation nothing in the ledger can be changed.

  • POWLPowell IndustriesRefreshed

    Powell's fiscal year ended 30 September; results are due 17 November

    Powell's financial year ended on 30 September. The results are not out until 17 November, so the last forecast management made about margins cannot yet be checked against a full year.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The case rests on backlog and margins, and the first full-year check is the November report, which is already our next test.

    1 claim changed
    • C25EditedIn the full-year fiscal 2025 results release of November 18, 2025 the chief financial officer issued the year's only forward statement on margin: 'we believe that on a total year basis, the margin profile recognized in fiscal 2025 is sustainable as we enter Fiscal 2026, as the pricing environment remains stable and we continue to efficiently execute and close out projects in our backlog'. Fiscal 2025 gross margin was 29.4% on revenue of $1,104.3 million, with operating income of $217.9 million and net income of $180.7 million. The same release disclosed the completed acquisition of Remsdaq Ltd., a UK manufacturer of SCADA remote terminal units for substation control and automation, and a capacity expansion at the Jacintoport manufacturing facility expected to complete in the second half of fiscal 2026.valid_through of 2026-09-30 passed with fiscal 2026 closed but not yet reported; the sentence is a closed statement about fiscal 2026, so it is tested against the full-year print and its shelf life rolled to the 2026-11-17 release
  • CHYMChime FinancialRefreshed

    Chime analyst ratings re-read: 16 buy, 1 hold, no sells

    The count of analysts rating Chime was re-read from the data vendor. It shows 16 saying buy, 1 saying hold and none saying sell, up from 13 buy and 1 hold in August.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The ratings were a side fact our case does not rest on; the view still waits for November's results to show the margin the company has promised.

    1 claim changed
    • C28EditedAnalyst consensus as of 2026-11-10 was 18 buy, 1 hold and 0 sell (FMP grade consensus) - a strongly bullish split, five more buys than the 13 buy and 1 hold recorded in August and two more than the 16 buy and 1 hold of October.valid_through of 2026-09-30 passed; re-struck on FMP's grade consensus of 2026-10-04 (16 buy, 1 hold, 0 sell) and shelf life rolled to the Q3 print

Saturday 3 October8

  • TSLATeslaRefreshed

    Tesla delivered 486,532 vehicles in the third quarter, up 1% on the last

    Tesla said it delivered 486,532 vehicles from July to September, 1.3% more than the spring quarter but 2.1% fewer than a year ago. It built 464,391, so it sold more than it made again, and it installed 13.7 gigawatt-hours of storage batteries. It will report profits on 21 October.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in our view. After a 25% jump last quarter, sales have stalled rather than kept climbing, but the release says nothing on profit margin or self-driving income, which is what our case turns on. The 21 October results are the test.

    1 claim changed
    • C48NewDeliveries in Q3 2026 were 486,532 vehicles, up 1.3% from 480,126 in Q2 and down 2.1% from 497,099 in Q3 2025, on production of 464,391, so Tesla again delivered more than it built (by 22,141). Storage deployments were 13.7 GWh. The slowing test turns on this series, and the quarter did not re-accelerate. Tesla will report Q3 results on 21 October 2026.Q3 2026 deliveries release of 2 October 2026 (Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K), read against the slowing test in the thesis
  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    Apple will flag AI apps' Mac data requests; a Dutch chain drops Meta glasses

    Reuters reports Apple will warn users when AI apps ask for Mac data, after complaints about Meta's new Muse app, which a journalist said read his private messages after he denied access. Meta's AI chief called its first explanation inaccurate. A Dutch glasses chain also stopped selling Meta's glasses over privacy. We read only headlines for both Reuters items.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Both items are privacy friction around new AI products, and no sales figure for Muse or the glasses exists to measure it. Our case rests on advertising growth and the spending bill, which the October results test.

  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    FDA approves Lilly's Jaypirca as a first treatment for a common leukemia

    The FDA approved Lilly's cancer pill Jaypirca for adults with chronic lymphocytic leukemia or small lymphocytic lymphoma who have not been treated before and lack a 17p deletion. In a trial of 282 patients it cut the risk of the disease progressing by 80% compared with chemotherapy plus rituximab. Until now it was used only after other treatments.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Jaypirca sold $192 million last quarter, part of the growth beyond the two big weight-loss medicines. A wider label could grow it, but no sales figure came with the approval and our tests are volume against price and the 29 October results.

  • GLWCorningUnchanged

    First Solar sues JA Solar and Corning's solar unit over patents

    First Solar, a rival solar panel maker, says it sued American Panel Solutions, a Corning subsidiary, and China's JA Solar for patent infringement. Only the article's first paragraph was readable, so the patents, damages and demands are unknown.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Corning's solar arm lost $7 million on $438 million of sales in Q2, and this does not change the optical-fibre case. It is a possible legal cost to watch, with no amount known.

  • FLOCFlowco HoldingsUnchanged

    Flowco buys a Canadian pump maker for about $113 million in cash

    Flowco closed its purchase of Lifting Solutions of Edmonton, which makes continuous rod and progressing cavity pumps for oil wells in Canada, the US and the Middle East. It paid about $113 million cash, borrowed on its revolving credit line, with up to C$10 million more depending on 2027 results. Management puts the price near 5 times expected 2027 earnings.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The purchase was paid in cash and borrowing, not new shares, which is what our share-count assumption needed. It adds new lift types and about 10% of sales outside the US. Its size will first show in the 11 November results.

  • AVGOBroadcomUnchanged

    Blackstone and banks reportedly gather $60 billion to finance Broadcom AI chips

    Bloomberg reported on 2 October that Blackstone and banks have gathered $60 billion for a Broadcom AI chip deal. In August, outlets said Broadcom was seeking more than $60 billion so investors can buy its chips and lease them to Anthropic. We read only the new headline, so the lenders, terms and Broadcom's share of the risk are unknown.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It looks like the financing we already track, and it does not say Broadcom has paid anything or been lent anything. It bears on our pending test of whether a second financing closes with an outside lead, which still needs the filing.

  • APLDApplied DigitalUnchanged

    Applied Digital says another 75 MW is live at its North Dakota campus

    Applied Digital said another 75 megawatts of capacity at its Polaris Forge 1 campus in North Dakota is ready for customers, bringing the fully leased campus to 250 megawatts working. We could only read a news report quoting the announcement, not the announcement itself.

    What it did to the thesisIt shows capacity being delivered on schedule, which our case needs, but it is one phase of a campus already leased. Nothing moved: the real test is next week's results, on whether recurring rent is overtaking construction pass-through revenue.

  • AMZNAmazon.comUnchanged

    Amazon pledges $1 billion to data-centre towns and argues against building freezes

    Amazon's cloud chief published a long post warning that freezes on new data centres would hurt the US for generations, saying over 100 are being considered locally. He announced more than $1 billion over five years for towns that host Amazon's data centres. Amazon withdrew a Maryland site in August.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Local resistance is one more sign that building capacity is getting harder, which we already track. The $1 billion is about 0.5% of the roughly $220 billion Amazon plans to spend this year. The 29 October results still decide the view.

Friday 2 October8

  • SPCXSpace Exploration TechnologiesUnchanged

    SpaceX launched Google's first AI chip to space

    A SpaceX rocket took off from California on 1 October carrying more than 100 small payloads. One was a Planet Labs satellite holding a Google AI chip, the first Google has sent to space, to test whether it works there. SpaceX only provided the ride; no price or contract was reported. Google calls its orbital-computing plan a long-term moonshot.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It is an outside customer on a launch business that mostly carries SpaceX's own satellites, and it adds no revenue figure. Our case rests on Starlink and the cloud contracts, so Google's orbit tests only matter if they later become a signed launch order.

  • OUSTOusterUnchanged

    A firefighting-drone maker picks Ouster's lidar sensor

    Ouster announced that Seneca, a California company building self-flying firefighting drones, will use Ouster's Rev8 lidar sensor for navigation in smoke and rough terrain. The announcement gave no number of sensors, no order value and no start date. It also repeats that the sensor meets American-made sourcing rules.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It names one more user of the Rev8 sensor, but without an order size it adds nothing to revenue or margin. The November results, which test gross margin and Rev8 volume, remain the next real check on the case.

  • METAMeta PlatformsRefreshed

    New Mexico asks a judge to make Meta pay $35 to $40 billion

    After winning a jury trial over how Facebook handled users' data, New Mexico asked a judge on 1 October to make Meta pay $35 billion to $40 billion. Meta argued for at most $3.45 billion and hinted it would appeal. The judge said he would decide by late October. Reuters's story could not be read, so local newspaper reports were used.

    What it did to the thesisThe legal-risk part of our case was updated with both figures. Nothing moved in the view: this is a request, not a ruling, and the state's ask is below the $62.85 billion we already carried. The view stays Attractive, conviction Medium. A ruling is due before the 28 October results.

    1 claim changed
    • C18EditedMeta's June 2026 quarter release warns that 'we continue to see scrutiny on youth-related issues in several markets and have a number of youth-related trials scheduled for this year in the U.S., which may ultimately result in a material loss'. The same quarter carried $2.4 billion of charges related to legal proceedings, which caused the company to raise the lower end of its full-year expense guidance. The quarter's 10-Q names two New Mexico Attorney General cases. In the youth-safety case a jury ordered a $375 million civil penalty on March 24, 2026 and the state sought $953 million in abatement; the Attorney General's own release list carries an August 7, 2026 headline reading 'Court Orders Meta to Pay $942 Million'. In the Cambridge Analytica data-privacy case the Attorney General 'has indicated that they intend to seek up to $62.85 billion in penalties', and on September 25, 2026 a jury found that Meta violated New Mexico's consumer protection law. At the October 1, 2026 penalty hearing the state asked the judge to apply the $5,000 statutory maximum per violation, which it puts at $219 billion, and then reduce the award to between $35 billion and $40 billion; Meta proposed a judgment of $345 million to $3.45 billion and signalled it would appeal. The judge said he would rule by late October. No penalty has been set in that case. On 21 October 2026 a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in the Cambridge Analytica case, on a jury finding of 43 million violations at $5,000 each; Meta says it will appeal (S30). Separately the August 2026 agreement with 52 attorneys general provides for payments of up to about $18.59 billion and produced a $9.89 billion charge in the September quarter (S28). The Q3 2026 10-Q adds that the order carries 15% post-judgment interest, that Meta has accrued an amount for the loss, and that it 'may be required to post a bond or other collateral during the course of the appeal, which could result in significant costs'; the court reserved ruling on injunctive relief.At the October 1 penalty hearing New Mexico asked for $35 billion to $40 billion, a step down from the $62.85 billion the 10-Q said it intended to seek and the $219 billion statutory maximum; Meta proposed $345 million to $3.45 billion. Both are requests, no penalty is set, and the ruling is expected by late October.
      Was

      Meta's June 2026 quarter release warns that 'we continue to see scrutiny on youth-related issues in several markets and have a number of youth-relate…

  • FSLRFirst SolarUnchanged

    First Solar sues JA Solar over a solar-cell patent

    First Solar sued JA Solar, a Chinese panel maker, and American Panel Solutions, a US panel seller, in a Delaware federal court. It says they use a method for making a type of silicon solar cell that First Solar owns a patent on. Only second-hand copies of the announcement could be read.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We said on 15 September that the company would pursue patent suits in court, and this is one. Our case rests on the import price floor and a US manufacturing tax credit, not on winning patent cases, so the view stays Attractive, conviction Medium.

  • AVGOBroadcomUnchanged

    Anthropic's IPO filing shows Broadcom could lend it up to $42 billion

    Reports of Anthropic's confidential IPO document say Broadcom could lend it up to $42 billion, about a third of its $125.2 billion five-year chip-computing commitment, with the loan possibly convertible into Anthropic shares. Anthropic says it does not expect the notes to be sold before its listing, and warns that Broadcom being both supplier and lender could create conflicts.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Broadcom's own September filing already described this $42 billion facility, and nothing has been lent or paid. The new part is Anthropic's side, and it is a reminder of how much 2027 growth rests on one customer's ability to pay.

  • AMZNAmazon.comRefreshed
    Risk / rewardFragile→Defensive

    Amazon reportedly seeks investors for an $8 billion AI-chip lease-back

    The Financial Times reports Amazon has asked investors about moving about $8 billion of Nvidia AI chips into a separate company. That company would borrow from outside investors and rent the chips back to Amazon, and Amazon would offer up to 10% of its ownership. Amazon has not confirmed it, and we could not read the FT itself.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Management said more financing was coming, and we had noted this kind of structure as a possibility. It is small against the roughly $220 billion Amazon plans to spend this year, and it would hide spending, not remove the bill. The 29 October results still decide the view.

    1 claim changed
    • C32EditedManagement said in the same quarter that it expects to keep going: 'We expect to undertake additional financing activities in 2026', and on the call answered a question about funding sources with 'You've seen us issue debt this year. We have a lot of options available to us... nothing to share today.'counter-evidence extended: the asset-backed structure the claim named as a possibility is now reported as being explored, about $8 billion of chips, unconfirmed
  • AMATApplied MaterialsUnchanged

    Applied Materials and Besi widen their chip-packaging partnership

    Applied Materials and Besi, a Dutch maker of machines that join chips together, widened a partnership begun in 2020. Besi will work inside Applied's new research centre in California on ways to stack and connect AI chips. The release gives no orders, revenue, price or timetable for any product.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It adds another partner to a research programme our file already counts at 11, and it shows Applied pushing into chip packaging, which management says is growing fast. No sale, customer or money figure came with it, so it does not test our view.

  • AFRMAffirm HoldingsRefreshed

    Affirm's shares fell about 9% and more analysts now rate it a buy

    Affirm's shares have fallen about 9% since we wrote the thesis, to $70.43, and more analysts now rate it a buy: 28, up from 24, with none saying sell. The company published nothing new, so we only brought our price and analyst figures up to date.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. On normal earnings a buyer now pays about 69 times profit instead of 76, still a price that assumes Affirm's first profitable year keeps growing for years. The November results are still the real test.

    3 claims changed
    • C06EditedAnnualizing trailing pretax income ($614.7 million: FY2026's $492.7 million plus the $122.0 million by which FQ1 2027 pretax income of $205.1 million exceeded FQ1 2026's $83.0 million) at a normalized effective tax rate of about 27.5% implies normalized net income of roughly $446 million and normalized diluted EPS of about $1.27 on 351.8 million shares - against $75.59 at the 2026-11-04 close, a normalized price-to-earnings multiple of roughly 60x, not the 12x trailing GAAP figure the vendor pack reports (inflated by the one-off tax benefit).price leg re-struck at the 2026-10-01 close of $70.43 (was $77.76) beside C29; the normalized EPS of about $1.02 is unchanged, so the multiple moves from about 76x to about 69x
      Was

      Annualizing FY2026 pretax income ($492.7 million, from C04) at a normalized effective tax rate of about 27.5% (the midpoint of management's guided mi…

    • C23EditedAnalyst consensus on 11 November 2026 was 29 buy, 10 hold and 0 sell on the vendor's snapshot, against 28, 10 and 0 on 2026-10-02 and 24, 10 and 1 on 2026-08-30. The vendor's dated series counts 36 analysts with 80.6% positive on 2026-11-01, unchanged from 2026-10-01 and up from 73.0% on 2026-09-01.valid_through of 2026-09-30 passed; re-sourced from the pack re-fetched 2026-10-02, which moved the split from 24/10/1 to 28/10/0
      Was

      Analyst consensus as of 2026-08-30 was 24 buy, 10 hold and 1 sell - a strong net Buy, and markedly more bullish than the split this repo's SOFI thesi…

    • C29EditedAFRM closed at $75.59 on 2026-11-04, implying a market capitalization of approximately $25.6 billion on 339.0 million shares, and a trailing GAAP price-to-earnings ratio far below the normalized multiple of C06 because that ratio rests on tax-benefit-inflated earnings.valid_through of 2026-09-30 passed; price, market capitalization and trailing P/E re-struck at the 2026-10-01 close of $70.43 (was $77.76 on 2026-08-28)
      Was

      AFRM last traded at $77.76, implying a market capitalization of approximately $26.0 billion and a trailing-twelve-month GAAP price-to-earnings ratio…

Thursday 1 October8

  • RKLBRocket LabThesis changed

    Iridium's shareholders approve Rocket Lab's takeover

    Shareholders of Iridium, the satellite company Rocket Lab is buying, voted to approve the deal: 85.9 million votes for, 0.3 million against. Separately, Rocket Lab announced its biggest commercial order for its small Electron rocket, 20 launches for Synspective, but the announcement could not be opened, so we know no price or dates.

    What it did to the thesisThe vote clears one of four hurdles for the Iridium deal; the US telecoms regulator's review, running to 9 November, is still open. The launch order's size is unknown, so it moves nothing yet. Our view stays unattractive on price.

    1 claim changed
    • C14EditedThe Iridium merger requires Iridium stockholder approval, HSR clearance, FCC consent to transfer Iridium's licenses and an effective Form S-4. The HSR period lapsed as of 2026-08-13 and the S-4 was declared effective on 2026-08-26. The FCC accepted the transfer applications for filing on 2026-09-15 (GN Docket No. 26-257) with comments and petitions due October 15, oppositions October 30 and replies November 9, 2026. Iridium's stockholders adopted the merger agreement at their 2026-09-24 special meeting, 85,862,105 votes for against 318,415 against and 67,862 abstained (Iridium Form 8-K, Item 5.07). Three stockholder lawsuits in New York state court allege proxy disclosure gaps and seek to enjoin the merger; Iridium calls them without merit and supplemented its proxy on 2026-09-18. Both companies say they expect to close in mid-2027; the outside date is June 28, 2027, extendable to September 28, 2027 and then December 28, 2027.Iridium's 8-K of 2026-09-24 reports the stockholder vote: the merger agreement was adopted with 85.9 million votes for and 0.3 million against, so the stockholder-approval condition is met.
      Was

      The Iridium merger requires Iridium stockholder approval, HSR clearance, FCC consent to transfer Iridium's licenses and an effective Form S-4. The HS…

  • OOMAOomaThesis changed

    Ooma's AirDial grows about 70% a year, and TELUS will resell it

    At its investor day on 29 September, Ooma said its copper-line replacement box, AirDial, is growing about 70% a year. A broker's report of the day puts its yearly subscription sales at about $20M, roughly 7% of Ooma's total. Canadian carrier TELUS will start reselling it in 2027 to a base of up to 300,000 lines, though it has not committed to any number.

    What it did to the thesisNothing in our view moved. AirDial's size, our biggest unknown, came in about where we estimated: real and fast-growing, but small. TELUS is a promising sales channel without a committed order. Ooma's own growth and the price still decide the view.

    4 claims changed
    • C07EditedManagement says AirDial service revenue grew 75% in Q2 fiscal 2027 and 80% in Q1, and about 70% from a year earlier at its 2026-09-29 Investor Day; Ooma files no AirDial revenue or line count.Investor Day review: its refresh trigger fired; management's 70% added from S25, and the filings still carry no AirDial figure
      Was

      Management says AirDial service revenue grew 75% in Q2 fiscal 2027 and 80% in Q1, but Ooma does not disclose AirDial revenue or lines.

    • C08EditedManagement's goal is 300,000 AirDial lines earning $100M a year, about $28 a line a month; it repeated the goal at its 2026-09-29 Investor Day as an intermediate one, still with no date.Investor Day review: its refresh trigger fired; the goal was repeated (S25), still undated
      Was

      Management's long-term goal is 300,000 AirDial lines earning $100M a year, about $28 a line a month; it gives no date.

    • C43EditedAirDial is still small: a broker's account of the 2026-09-29 Investor Day puts it at about $20M of recurring revenue a year, about 7% of the total, inside this thesis's own ceiling of about $7M a quarter.Investor Day review: its refresh trigger fired; a broker's relay of the Investor Day, about $20M a year (S26), sits inside the inferred ceiling
      Was

      AirDial is still small: its service revenue is probably no more than about $7M a quarter, under 10% of revenue.

    • C50EditedAt its 2026-09-29 Investor Day, management reported AirDial recurring revenue up 70% and, by a broker's account, about $20M a year, about 7% of the total; a TELUS resale partnership in Canada targeting up to 300,000 lines with go-live in the second half of the fiscal year; and over 8 million US business lines still to replace.Investor Day review: a second copy (S26) agrees on TELUS's 300,000 lines and the second-half go-live and adds about $20M of AirDial recurring revenue
      Was

      At its 2026-09-29 Investor Day, management reported AirDial recurring revenue up 70%, a TELUS resale partnership in Canada targeting up to 300,000 li…

  • NUNu HoldingsUnchanged

    Nu says it is not pursuing a deal for Britain's Monzo

    Nu told the SEC on 30 September that it is not pursuing a deal with Monzo, a British bank. A news report on 26 September had said talks were under way at about 10 billion pounds, and Nu's shares fell 10.0% the next trading day. Nu said its priorities and its rules for spending capital are unchanged.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The denial removes a possible large purchase that our case did not include. It leaves the US entry and the buyback in place, and the share price drop on the report was about a deal that is now denied.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C47UnchangedManagement says it will spend no more than 100 basis points of the efficiency ratio on the United States entry, and that United States credit models will take 12 to 30 months to build.
    • C40UnchangedNu held 40,659,600 Class A shares in treasury at 30 September 2026, bought for $500.4M under its repurchase programme, against none at 31 December 2025; the count did not change in the third quarter.
  • NEENextEra EnergyUnchanged

    NextEra picked to build 6.47 GW of Texas gas power with Korea

    The US Commerce Department and South Korea picked NextEra's power-development arm and Related Companies to build Project Star in Texas: 6.47 gigawatts of gas-fired power for a neighbouring 5-gigawatt data-center campus, costing $22 billion or more. Korea and the US would own it jointly. How much NextEra puts in, and when, was not stated.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It resembles the Japan-funded gas build already in our case, which NextEra has not yet turned into signed terms. The release gives no NextEra investment, return or start date, so it adds a project to watch and no figure to the argument.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C16UnchangedNextEra Energy announced it executed definitive agreements with the US Department of Commerce and the Government of Japan to fund the development and operation of up to 10 GW of natural gas-powered generation in Texas and Pennsylvania (including a roughly 4.3 GW project in Pennsylvania), releasing an initial funding tranche including an initial $3.3B investment for down payments on long-lead equipment and EPC contractor selection; the arrangement is tied to Japan's broader $550B US investment commitment, with initial completion targeted by the end of 2028 and full build-out by 2032. The 21 October 2026 results release says NextEra Energy Resources has now signed definitive agreements for three federal hub projects, two in Texas and one in Pennsylvania, totalling about 16.5 GW, with $5.7B of initial funding secured year to date, and expects to develop, build and operate them for fees without investing capital. On the call management said the early payments are modest in 2026 and 2027, building through 2032, and that operating fees from 2032 to 2052 should be roughly half the earnings per share NextEra would earn if it owned the plants.
    • C25UnchangedBehind-the-meter, off-grid data-center power is scaling nationally: nearly every hyperscaler is now pursuing behind-the-meter projects, and OpenAI and Anthropic alone have signed leases for more than 10 GW of behind-the-meter power.
  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    Lilly reports heart-safety and weight-loss trial results

    Lilly reported two studies. Its weight-loss pill Foundayo was no worse for the heart than insulin in 2,749 people with type 2 diabetes, with a 16% lower risk that was not statistically clear. A trial of tirzepatide with a second medicine, eloralintide, found 23.3% weight loss in 48 weeks.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Both studies add to what could replace today's biggest product later, but neither changes a dated filing, a sales figure or the October results test. The view stays Neutral.

  • HPEHewlett Packard Enterprise CompanyRefreshed

    HPE raises its networking outlook and wins a $1.2 billion AI order

    At an investor event, HPE said its networking business should grow 17% to 22% next year at a profit margin in the high 20s, up from earlier guidance. It raised its target for savings from the Juniper purchase to $800 million a year from $600 million, and said a cloud company, Vultr, ordered $1.2 billion of AI server racks.

    What it did to the thesisThese are promises, not results. Networking grew only 10% last quarter, so the new outlook is a big step up still to be shown. The order has no delivery dates. Nothing in our view moved; the December results are the test.

    3 claims changed
    • C40NewAt its 30 September 2026 Networking Investor Day HPE raised its fiscal 2027 Networking segment revenue growth outlook to high teens to low 20s percent, with segment operating margin in the mid-to-high 20s percent, and projected Networking revenue growing at a high-teens percent annual rate from fiscal 2026 to 2029.Networking Investor Day 8-K Exhibit 99.1 of 2026-09-30
    • C41NewHPE said on 30 September 2026 that it had secured a $1.2B order from the cloud provider Vultr for AMD Helios AI rack systems by HPE, its first order for that system.Networking Investor Day 8-K Exhibit 99.1 of 2026-09-30
    • C34EditedManagement reported Juniper cost savings on track for a $600M annual run rate by the end of fiscal 2028 and net leverage of 1.8 times, below its own 2 times target; on 30 September 2026 it raised the savings target to $800M a year by the end of fiscal 2028.Networking Investor Day release of 2026-09-30 raised the Juniper savings target from $600M to $800M a year
      Was

      Management reports Juniper cost savings on track for a $600M annual run rate by the end of fiscal 2028, and net leverage of 1.8 times, below its own…

  • CEGConstellation EnergyUnchanged

    Amazon signs a 20-year deal for Constellation nuclear power

    Constellation announced a 20-year deal to sell Amazon 190 megawatts of power from its Calvert Cliffs nuclear plant in Maryland. Amazon is the second named buyer after Walmart. The announcement itself could not be opened, so the price, the start date and whether this is part of the 920 megawatts signed in August are not known.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved yet. Our case rests on named, sized power deals continuing to arrive, and this is one, but without terms we cannot say how much it adds. The next quarterly results, due 9 November, should show whether it is new.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C07UnchangedThrough the Q3 2026 print (2026-11-09) Constellation says it has contracted about 8,500 MW of long-term agreements this year, about 4,560 MW of it with three customers in the quarter: a 20-year, 690 MW power purchase agreement with Amazon supporting Calvert Cliffs (September), a 20-year agreement with Google for about 890 MW of incremental nuclear capacity plus a 15-year, 2,700 MW financial load-following agreement (October), and a 20-year, 270 MW 'Peak+' agreement from 2028 with a customer it does not name. This follows the 920 MW batch of the Q2 print, of which only Walmart (176 MW) was named.
    • C09UnchangedOn the Q2 2026 earnings call, management described being engaged in a confidential bilateral contracting process with customers to add megawatts 'in combination with our existing capabilities,' referencing a 6 GW PJM reliability shortfall figure and '5 gigawatts' of newly eligible capacity highlighted on the prior call, while declining to disclose specific pricing or customer identity 'to protect customer sensitivity.'
  • ACMRACM ResearchRefreshed

    ACM's Chinese arm says its order backlog rose 88% in a year

    ACM Research's Chinese subsidiary said its order backlog, the value of tools ordered but not yet counted as sales, was 17.1 billion yuan (about $2.5 billion) on 29 September. That is 88.2% more than a year earlier. The company warns that the measure is its own and may not match other firms'.

    What it did to the thesisIt supports management's claim of fast order growth, but the figure does not say which products the orders are for. Our view rests on cleaning sales rebounding and two newer product lines winning orders, so nothing moved. The November results remain the test.

    2 claims changed
    • C43NewACM Research (Shanghai) reported total backlog of RMB 17.1 billion (about $2.5 billion) at 29 September 2026, up 88.2% from the backlog it disclosed a year earlier; the figure mixes tools shipped but not yet recognised as revenue with tools still to ship.ACM Shanghai's 30 September 2026 backlog disclosure, filed as 8-K Exhibit 99.1
    • C13EditedManagement said first-half 2026 order intake grew 105% year over year on a large backlog, and that shipments are expected to outgrow revenue in 2026 across every product category; Q3 shipments of $343.5M rose 30.6%, slower than the 36.6% rise in revenue. On the Q3 call the chief financial officer said Q4 shipments should be higher still, helped by the second Lingang building.The backlog disclosure this claim said was pending was published on 2026-09-30; the counter-evidence now points to it (C43) instead of saying it was awaited.

Wednesday 30 September3

  • TSLATeslaUnchanged

    Tesla signs $30 billion of bank credit lines

    Tesla signed three bank credit lines worth $30 billion in total, according to a filing on 29 September: a $20 billion three-year loan it can draw in stages, an $8 billion five-year line and a $2 billion one-year line. The filing does not say any of it has been borrowed. Tesla may use it for general corporate purposes.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The lines show Tesla expects to keep spending heavily, which fits our note that cash flow turned negative, but they report no sales or profit. Our case turns on the 28 October results. We still find the shares unattractive, with medium confidence.

  • TLNTalen EnergyRefreshed

    Talen names a new CEO and buys back $1.5 billion of shares

    Talen picked its President, Terry Nutt, to be chief executive from 1 January 2027; the current CEO retires. It also agreed to buy back $1.5 billion of its own shares at once, paid for by selling about $1.5 billion of future power-capacity income to Citi. The company says debt will fall to its target in late 2027.

    What it did to the thesisOur view held. Debt is a central worry, and this defers cash from later years to shareholders now, so the debt claim is noted, not changed. We still need a second signed customer and falling debt at a results report.

    2 claims changed
    • C16EditedTalen targets net leverage below 3.5x net debt-to-Adjusted EBITDA and reports no ratio in its release. From the filed figures: net debt of $9,234M (debt $9,569M less cash $335M) over trailing Adjusted EBITDA of $1,898M ($1,035M for 2025, less $653M for the first nine months of 2025, plus $1,516M for the first nine months of 2026) is about 4.9x at 30 September, against about 5.9x at 30 June, as the Cornerstone plants entered the trailing year. Counting the $1.5B capacity obligation taken on 1 October, which funded the accelerated repurchase, and the $220M of unrestricted cash left at 30 October, it is about 5.7x. Total liquidity was about $1.6B at 30 October. On 29 September management said it expects to reach 3.5x in the second half of 2027. On the 3 November call management said the capacity obligation is treated as short-term debt that amortises, so net leverage returns to the 3.5x target about a year out.8-K of 2026-09-29: capacity-revenue monetisation funds the repurchase; management restates the 3.5x target as second half of 2027.
      Was

      Talen targets net leverage below 3.5x net debt-to-Adjusted EBITDA; as of July 31, 2026, total available liquidity was approximately $1.9B ($525M unre…

    • C19EditedSince the start of 2024, Talen had repurchased approximately 15 million shares for about $2.3 billion through 30 June 2026, and a further 600,000 shares for about $204M in Q3 2026. On 1 October 2026 it received and retired about 3.8 million shares, 80% of the $1.5 billion accelerated repurchase, funded by the $1.3B net proceeds of the capacity monetization and cash on hand; final settlement is due by the first quarter of 2027. The program was upsized to $3.0 billion through 2028, leaving $1.5 billion beyond the accelerated repurchase, which Talen is not obliged to spend.8-K of 2026-09-29: program upsized to $3.0B with a $1.5B accelerated repurchase; the $1.7B remaining in the 10-Q is superseded.
      Was

      Since the start of 2024, Talen has repurchased approximately 15 million shares of common stock for a total of approximately $2.3 billion (including 5…

  • BTDRBitdeer Technologies GroupUnchanged

    Bitdeer says customers have committed to over 70% of its Malaysia AI site

    Bitdeer's AI cloud arm said customers have committed to more than 70% of the capacity at its 21.7-megawatt A201 site in Malaysia. Only the headline could be read. A filing the same day shows it has sold about $8.4 million of new shares since 10 August.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. A201 is small next to 1,752 megawatts, and the terms are unknown. Our case turns on whether the Tydal project is funded without new shares. The small share sales fit that view but do not settle it.

Tuesday 29 September6

  • SLNHSoluna HoldingsRefreshed

    Bitdeer adds 7 MW of mining machines at Soluna's Kati 1 site

    Soluna said Bitdeer, a bitcoin mining company, will place about 7 MW more of its own mining machines at the Kati 1 site, for about 35 MW in total, finishing in November 2026. Soluna supplies the site and power and shares the bitcoin mined. The copy filed with the SEC is stamped as a draft.

    What it did to the thesisSmall change to one fact: Bitdeer's share of Kati 1 grew. It is bitcoin mining, not AI, so it does not touch what holds our view down: no AI tenant has signed and the company still pays for growth by selling shares.

    1 claim changed
    • C10EditedBitdeer agreed in August 2026 to place about 28 MW of its own mining machines at Kati 1 and on 28 September 2026 added about 7 MW, for about 35 MW and 2.42 EH/s, to finish in November 2026; it shares the bitcoin they produce with Soluna, which supplies the site, power and operations.edited because the 28 September amendment raised Bitdeer's Kati 1 deployment from about 28 MW to about 35 MW on the same profit-share terms
      Was

      Bitdeer agreed in August 2026 to place about 28 MW of its own mining machines at Kati 1 and share the bitcoin they produce with Soluna, which supplie…

  • NTAPNetAppUnchanged

    NetApp plans to buy AI-storage firm PEAK:AIO

    NetApp said it plans to buy PEAK:AIO, a company selling storage software for AI. At its yearly conference it also announced a cloud storage service with Oracle, a wider deal with SAP, and a Supermicro collaboration. We could read only the headlines, so we know no prices, sizes or sales.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. This is NetApp pushing further into AI storage, where newer rivals are strong, but with no numbers it cannot show that its growth is its own rather than higher memory prices. The view stays Unattractive and confidence Medium.

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    Meta hires MongoDB's former chief to sell AI tools to businesses

    Meta hired CJ Desai, who ran the database company MongoDB, to lead a new push selling AI tools to businesses. MongoDB's shares fell about 16 to 18 percent on the news. Separately, Meta will rent AI computing capacity in Southeast Asia from Australia's Firmus. No revenue, price or spending amount was given for either.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. We are waiting to see whether Meta puts a revenue number on its business AI products and how much it spends on computing. The hire shows intent and the Firmus deal shows demand for computing, but neither is a result. The October 28 report remains the test.

  • GLWCorningUnchanged

    AT&T signs a multi-year fibre deal with Corning worth over $3 billion

    AT&T and Corning announced a multi-year agreement worth more than $3 billion. Corning will supply the fibre and cable AT&T needs to expand its network to more homes. The release gives no start date, length, volume or price, and Corning has not said how much of the value is new business.

    What it did to the thesisIt fits our case: Corning says its capacity growth is backed by signed long-term buyers, and AT&T is another named one after Verizon, Meta and Amazon. It says nothing about profit margin or the share-issuing worry, so the view stays Unattractive, Medium conviction.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C40UnchangedWeeks said long-term agreements 'will be the lion share of our optical business' because every significant capacity move is backed by one, and that the workflow of signing them continues whether or not customers want them announced.
    • C06UnchangedVerizon and Corning reached a multi-billion dollar agreement for over 80 million miles of high-density optical fibre and connectivity solutions from 2027 to 2032.
  • FTAIFTAI AviationUnchanged

    FTAI buys 27 Boeing 737s from WestJet

    FTAI bought 27 Boeing 737-700 passenger jets from Canadian airline WestJet. Seventeen stay leased to WestJet through FTAI's new investor-funded vehicle; the other ten are empty and will be broken up for their CFM56-7B engines, which FTAI repairs and sells. No price was given. The release was read through a summary, not directly.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. It fits the story that engines are scarce and FTAI is stocking up, but without a price we cannot say what it adds to profit. The real test is the 26 October results: the parts business's margin and its first new-turbine delivery.

    Checked against 2 claims - none changed
    • C43UnchangedManagement says the CFM56 market is supply-constrained rather than demand-constrained, and that it is deliberately directing module output to third-party customers instead of replenishing its own leasing fleet.
    • C18UnchangedThe CFO says the first Strategic Capital vehicle holds approximately 300 aircraft, so about 600 engines, and that Strategic Capital should be about 20% of Aerospace Products revenue going forward.
  • ADEAAdeiaRefreshed

    Adeia names Dipti Vachani, from Arm, as chief executive

    Adeia named Dipti Vachani as its new chief executive, starting 12 October. She spent nearly 30 years in chips, most recently running a car-chip licensing unit at Arm. The outgoing chief executive, Paul Davis, who left for health reasons, stays on as a paid consultant until the end of December.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved in our view. The leadership question is now answered, but the case rests on royalties from two unsigned customers and a price that already assumes a recovery. The November results are the first real test, and she will not yet have run that quarter.

    1 claim changed
    • C37EditedChief executive Paul Davis announced on 4 May 2026 that he would step down for health reasons; on 24 September 2026 the board appointed Dipti Vachani, a former Arm automotive general manager with nearly 30 years in semiconductor IP, as his successor from 12 October 2026, and Davis stays as a consultant to 31 December 2026 for a fixed $183,000; on 22 July 2026 the board amended the severance agreements of the chief financial, revenue and legal officers.The successor search closed: 8-K of 28 September 2026 names Dipti Vachani chief executive from 12 October; the claim said the search was ongoing.
      Was

      Chief executive Paul Davis announced on 4 May 2026 that he will step down by Q4 2026 for health reasons and remain until a successor is appointed; on…

Sunday 27 September4

  • TSLATeslaUnchanged

    The EU vote on Tesla's Full Self-Driving slips past October

    The EU committee that could let Tesla sell its driver-supervised Full Self-Driving in every EU country will not vote on it at its 6 October meeting. Its published agenda gives the Dutch request 25 minutes of 'continuation of discussions'. The committee has no later meeting on the EU's register yet, and Reuters reports December as the earliest chance.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case waits on Tesla reporting what self-driving actually earns, and Tesla reports no such sales anywhere, so a delay in Europe changes nothing we can measure. We still find the shares unattractive, with medium confidence, and the next test is the 28 October results.

  • METAMeta PlatformsThesis changed
    Valuation4→3

    A New Mexico jury finds Meta misled residents about data privacy

    On September 25 a New Mexico jury found that Meta misled the state's residents about data privacy after the Cambridge Analytica scandal. No penalty is set; Meta's own filing says the state wants up to $62.85B. The same day, a researcher found a flaw in Meta's new Muse assistant that could expose personal data, and Meta added a warning; glasses owners can now keep camera requests out of AI training.

    What it did to the thesisOur view holds: Attractive, medium conviction. We had assumed legal costs stay near today's size; a penalty near $62.85B would break that, but none is set. Separately, the shares rose 34.5% since we measured them, so we re-measured: still the cheapest rival on profit, now fairly priced, not cheap.

    8 claims changed
    • C18EditedMeta's June 2026 quarter release warns that 'we continue to see scrutiny on youth-related issues in several markets and have a number of youth-related trials scheduled for this year in the U.S., which may ultimately result in a material loss'. The same quarter carried $2.4 billion of charges related to legal proceedings, which caused the company to raise the lower end of its full-year expense guidance. The quarter's 10-Q names two New Mexico Attorney General cases. In the youth-safety case a jury ordered a $375 million civil penalty on March 24, 2026 and the state sought $953 million in abatement; the Attorney General's own release list carries an August 7, 2026 headline reading 'Court Orders Meta to Pay $942 Million'. In the Cambridge Analytica data-privacy case the Attorney General 'has indicated that they intend to seek up to $62.85 billion in penalties', and on September 25, 2026 a jury found that Meta violated New Mexico's consumer protection law. At the October 1, 2026 penalty hearing the state asked the judge to apply the $5,000 statutory maximum per violation, which it puts at $219 billion, and then reduce the award to between $35 billion and $40 billion; Meta proposed a judgment of $345 million to $3.45 billion and signalled it would appeal. The judge said he would rule by late October. No penalty has been set in that case. On 21 October 2026 a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in the Cambridge Analytica case, on a jury finding of 43 million violations at $5,000 each; Meta says it will appeal (S30). Separately the August 2026 agreement with 52 attorneys general provides for payments of up to about $18.59 billion and produced a $9.89 billion charge in the September quarter (S28). The Q3 2026 10-Q adds that the order carries 15% post-judgment interest, that Meta has accrued an amount for the loss, and that it 'may be required to post a bond or other collateral during the course of the appeal, which could result in significant costs'; the court reserved ruling on injunctive relief.The New Mexico Cambridge Analytica case, where the 10-Q says the state intends to seek up to $62.85 billion, ended in a liability verdict on September 25, 2026; added with the earlier $375 million verdict and the $942 million court-order headline from the state's own release list.
      Was

      Meta's June 2026 quarter release warns that 'we continue to see scrutiny on youth-related issues in several markets and have a number of youth-relate…

    • C19EditedOver the research pack's 365-day window from September 29, 2025, Meta insiders filed 271 Form 4s with zero open-market purchases and 256 open-market sales. The Form 4s for the 34 open-market sales from September 3 to September 21, 2026 - 91,252 shares in all - mark every one as made under a Rule 10b5-1 plan adopted earlier; they include the chief product officer selling four blocks of 20,000 shares between September 9 and September 21 at $650.21 to $725.02. Before the rise, the chief financial officer sold on August 18, 2026 at $547.51 to $550.20 and the chief legal officer 1,559 shares at $558.00.Re-struck from the refreshed research pack at the 2026-09-25 close, over the pack's new 365-day insider window, and the September sales read from the Form 4s for the Rule 10b5-1 box.
      Was

      Insider activity in Meta comprised 15 Form 4 filings with zero open-market purchases and 15 open-market sales. The chief financial officer sold on Au…

    • C20EditedAt the September 25, 2026 close of $751.66 Meta trades at 23.1 times trailing enterprise value to operating profit against a comparable-peer median of 31.65 - Alphabet at 28.4 and Reddit at 34.9 - still the cheapest of the three members it can be struck on, and at 19.5 times EV/EBITDA against a median of 29.35, also the cheapest. On price to earnings it is 27.9 against a median of 32.8, second cheapest of four behind Alphabet at 16.9. Against its own six-year history it is now dearer on every measure: 27.9 times earnings against a prior median of 23.9, 18.8 times EBITDA against 16.7, and 8.39 times sales against 8.15. On cash it is 46.7 times free cash flow against a peer median of 20.65, second dearest of five behind Alphabet at 77.7, and its free cash flow yield of 2.14% is below its own six-year median of 3.89%. When the thesis was written, at the $559.02 close of August 24, 2026, the same price was 17.5 times operating profit, 20.8 times earnings and 34.8 times free cash flow, the dearest of the five.Re-struck at the 2026-09-25 close of $751.66 from the refreshed research pack, 34.5% above the $559.02 it was written at; Meta is no longer the dearest of the cohort on free cash flow.
      Was

      At a reference price of $559.02 Meta trades at 17.5 times trailing enterprise value to operating profit against a comparable-peer median of 32.25 - A…

    • C21EditedMeta's trailing operating margin of 38.1% is the highest of the comparable cohort against a median of 28.2% - Alphabet 33.1%, Reddit 28.2%, Snap negative 5.1%. On the other three operating measures it is second, and Reddit is what beats it: return on invested capital of 17.1% against Reddit's 23.6% and a median of 10.3%; gross margin of 81.7% against Reddit's 91.4% and a median of 70.2%; and trailing revenue growth of 27.7% against Reddit's 66.6% and a median of 18.35%. Reddit's trailing revenue is a small fraction of Meta's. Pinterest is withheld from the operating-margin and EV/EBIT comparisons because the vendor's operating margin of 5.96% differs from the filer's own XBRL figure of 4.92% by 1.03 percentage points, 21.0% of the filed base.Re-read from the refreshed research pack; the only figure that moved is the cohort median return on invested capital, 10.25% to 10.3%.
      Was

      Meta's trailing operating margin of 38.1% is the highest of the comparable cohort against a median of 28.2% - Alphabet 33.1%, Reddit 28.2%, Snap nega…

    • C23EditedAt the September 25, 2026 close Meta traded at $751.66, 3.61% below its 252-day high of $779.82 and 44.48% above its 252-day low of $520.26, at 89.2% of that range. It sits 22.1% above its 50-day moving average and 20.0% above its 200-day. Returns are positive 12.9% over 5 sessions, 31.6% over 20, 22.6% over 60 and 31.2% over 120, and negative 1.2% over 252. The 14-day relative strength index is 71.3 and the 20-day average daily high-to-low range is 3.47%, placing it in this repo's Stable bucket. Beta is 1.24. When the thesis was written, at the $559.02 close of August 24, 2026, the shares were 29.31% below their high and down 24.4% over 252 sessions.Re-struck at the 2026-09-25 close of $751.66 from the refreshed research pack; the shares went from 29.31% below their one-year high to 3.61% below it.
      Was

      As of the research pack date Meta traded at $559.02, 29.31% below its 252-day high of $790.80 and 7.45% above its 252-day low of $520.26, at 14.3% of…

    • C24EditedSell-side consensus on Meta is 2 strong buy, 50 buy, 11 hold and 2 sell - a Buy, and one of the most bullish distributions in this repo's coverage. Against that, the company has missed consensus earnings in two of the last four quarters, by 14.0% on July 29, 2026 and by 84.4% on October 29, 2025, and beaten it by 55.8% and 8.4% in the other two. For every print where the comparison is available the filed GAAP diluted figure equals the reported actual exactly, so earnings-per-share adjustments were 0.00.Re-read from the refreshed research pack: the rating split and the earnings record are unchanged; the counter-evidence no longer describes the shares as down 24% over a year.
    • C25EditedMeta's refreshed research pack raises two errors, both about the vendor's re-keyed segment history rather than the filed figures: the annual 2025 split does not sum to the income statement, and segment names used in older years - Advertising, Payments and Other Fees, Service, Other - are absent from the newest. Its vendor-versus-filings cross-check still reports a gap of exactly 0.0% on both annual revenue and annual operating income - filed $200,966 million against vendor $200,966 million, and filed $83,276 million against vendor $83,276 million - and the segment split read from the filing's own instance reconciles against the consolidated figure on the same tag.The refreshed research pack raises two errors it did not raise in August, both on the vendor's segment history; the filed-figure cross-check is still exact.
      Was

      Meta's research pack raises no errors and its vendor-versus-filings cross-check reports a gap of exactly 0.0% on both annual revenue and annual opera…

    • C28EditedShort interest in META was 30,990,107 shares at the September 15, 2026 settlement, up 7.58% from 28,807,174 a fortnight earlier - 1.41% of a float of 2,199,588,508 shares, at 1.57 days of average daily volume.Re-read at FINRA's September 15, 2026 settlement, the one after the August 31 figure the claim carried.
      Was

      Short interest in META was 28,807,174 shares at the August 31, 2026 settlement, up 2.71% from 28,048,106 a fortnight earlier - 1.31% of a float of 2,…

  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyUnchanged

    Lilly's Olumiant approved for teenagers with severe hair loss

    US regulators approved Lilly's Olumiant, a daily pill, for teenagers aged 12 and over with severe alopecia areata, a disease that makes hair fall out. In the trial, 42% of teenagers on the higher dose had at least 80% of their scalp covered with hair after 36 weeks, against 5% on a dummy pill. Lilly does not report Olumiant's sales on their own.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Olumiant sits in a group of immunology medicines that brought in $561 million last quarter, 2.4% of Lilly's $22,974 million, while one drug, tirzepatide, made 64.7%. A wider label for a small product cannot change that, so the view stays Neutral with Medium conviction.

    Checked against 1 claim - none changed
    • C01UnchangedOne molecule is the company. Mounjaro and Zepbound are both tirzepatide, and together they were $14,871 million of $22,974 million of Q2 2026 revenue - 64.7%.
  • FTAIFTAI AviationRefreshed

    Indonesia's GMF AeroAsia will reserve engine-repair capacity for FTAI

    GMF AeroAsia, Indonesia's largest aircraft-maintenance shop, agreed to keep repair capacity free for FTAI's CFM56 jet engines, and for the small extra power units planes carry, for five years. It already repairs engines for FTAI. No volume, price or value was given, and FTAI filed nothing with the US securities regulator. The shares fell 8.2% in the week with no stated cause.

    What it did to the thesisFigures updated; the view held at Neutral, Medium conviction. More repair capacity helps FTAI deliver the engine parts it has promised, but says nothing about what each one earns. The real test is the 26 October results: the parts business's profit margin and its first new-module delivery.

    5 claims changed
    • C59NewOn 23 September 2026 GMF AeroAsia, Indonesia's largest maintenance shop, agreed to guarantee FTAI engine and auxiliary-power-unit shop capacity for five years, starting with CFM56-5B and -7B engines, with no volume, price or value disclosed.the 23 September GMF release, read in the 27 September review
    • C60NewSafran's 28 July 2026 first-half release says civil engine spare-parts sales rose 27.9% in dollars, largely driven by CFM56, and raised its full-year spare-parts outlook to up mid-twenties from mid-teens.Safran's first-half release, reached through a second door in the 27 September review
    • C36EditedAt $175.06 on 25 September 2026 the enterprise value is about $21.1 billion: about 25 times the vendor's trailing operating profit - FTAI tags no operating-income subtotal, so that line is the vendor's - about 18 times trailing adjusted EBITDA, about 9 times the 2027 business-segment guidance, and about 38 times the four filed quarterly diluted earnings figures.re-struck at the 25 September 2026 close in the 27 September review; the shares fell 8.2% in the week with no filing and no stated cause
      Was

      At $190.74 on 18 September 2026 the enterprise value is about $22.7 billion: about 27 times the vendor's trailing operating profit - FTAI tags no ope…

    • C37EditedThe frozen pack's analyst panel shows 18 Buy, no Hold and no Sell, its monthly rating series ten analysts all positive for twelve readings to 1 September 2026, and a mean 2028 earnings estimate of $17.83 from six contributors; the shares sit 45.9% below their 252-day high and 5.94% of the float was short at the 15 September 2026 settlement.re-struck at the 25 September 2026 close in the 27 September review; the shares fell 8.2% in the week with no filing and no stated cause; the 2028 estimate eased from $18.34 and short interest fell 10.2% at the newer settlement
      Was

      The frozen pack's analyst panel shows 18 Buy, no Hold and no Sell, its monthly rating series ten analysts all positive for twelve readings to 1 Septe…

    • C47EditedOver the six months to 25 September 2026 the shares fell 27.0% while trailing revenue per diluted share rose 23.9%, so the multiple paid for each dollar of trailing sales fell 41.1%; over the same span the panel's average price target rose, the last month's single target sitting 8.5% above the year's average, on ten analysts all rated positive for twelve consecutive monthly readings.re-struck at the 25 September 2026 close in the 27 September review; the shares fell 8.2% in the week with no filing and no stated cause; the last month's target average now rests on one target rather than two
      Was

      Over the six months to 18 September 2026 the shares fell 20.6% while trailing revenue per diluted share rose 23.9%, so the multiple paid for each dol…

Friday 25 September4

  • TEMTempus AIThesis changed

    Tempus's Personalis purchase could need up to 31.5 million new shares

    The full filing for the Personalis purchase sets how many new shares Tempus issues: about 18.5 million at the 24 September share price, and up to 31.5 million if Tempus's price falls to $48.42, against the 26 million we had written. Paying up to half in cash instead would cost about $762 million, more than Tempus's $599.6 million of cash.

    What it did to the thesisWe corrected the deal claims and added the new shares; the view held, and we still find the shares unattractive. More shares mean each holder owns less of the company without changing what it earns, and the price still needs profit margins Tempus has never earned.

    3 claims changed
    • C53NewPaying in stock, Tempus would issue about 17.9 million new shares at its 25 September 2026 close of $85.01, and up to 31.5 million if its price averages $48.42 or less before closing: 9.9% to 17.3% of the 181.6 million shares it had in issue on 20 August 2026, before any Personalis options and share awards, which the S-4 leaves blank.Added at the 2026-09-25 review from the full read of the S-4: the thesis's 'up to roughly 26 million' shares understated the ceiling, which the filed share counts put at 31.5 million.
    • C32EditedTempus agreed on 20 July 2026 to buy the 87.8% of Personalis it does not already own for $16.25 a share, about $1.5B of enterprise value, in its own stock at a ratio that floats above a Tempus price of $48.42 and is fixed at 0.3356 at or below it, unless Tempus elects to pay up to half in cash.The S-4 read in full: the terms are restated from the filing rather than the release - the 12.2% Tempus already owns, the $48.42 floor below which the ratio stops rising, and the closing conditions and fees.
      Was

      Tempus agreed on 20 July 2026 to buy Personalis for $16.25 a share, about $1.5B of enterprise value, entirely in its own stock unless it elects up to…

    • C51EditedTempus management's own June 2026 projections for Personalis as a Tempus subsidiary show revenue rising from $79M in 2026 to $333M in 2030, adjusted EBITDA negative in every year to 2029 and zero in 2030, and unlevered free cash flow negative in every year to 2033 - $408M out in 2026 to 2029 alone - against Personalis's own 2030 revenue projection of $758M.The rest of the S-4 read: the note that it was unread is replaced, and the adviser's valuation of these same projections is added as counter-evidence.
  • SEDGSolarEdge TechnologiesRefreshed

    Court gives final approval to SolarEdge's $55 million settlement

    A New York federal court gave final approval to SolarEdge's $55 million settlement of an old shareholder lawsuit and closed the case. The money came from the company's insurers, who had already paid it in. The June quarterly report already said so: $55.0 million of the money set aside for legal claims is this case, matched by $55.0 million owed by insurers.

    What it did to the thesisFigures updated; the view held. The filing shows as fact, with corrected figures, what we had inferred. A lawsuit insurers paid does not touch why we find the shares unattractive: profit leans on a manufacturing credit the company has never sized, and its data-centre product has no named customer.

    1 claim changed
    • C36EditedAt June 30, 2026 SolarEdge's provision for legal claims was $68.7M against $13.2M at December 31, 2025, and $55.0M of it is the consolidated securities class action in the Southern District of New York, carried with a matching $55.0M insurance receivable. The insurers had already paid the $55M settlement into escrow, and the court granted final approval on August 26, 2026, so the case closed at the insurers' expense rather than the company's.Re-reading the Q2 2026 10-Q's commitments note found that it states the link the original pass inferred: $55.0M of the $68.7M accrual is the securities class action, with a related $55.0M insurance receivable, and the insurers had already paid the $55M into escrow. So the pairing of the $55.6M provision increase with the $59.2M receivable was the wrong one, and the claim is a fact rather than an inference. The court's Final Order and Judgment (ECF 177, 1:23-cv-09748, S.D.N.Y., dated and filed August 26, 2026) confirms final approval and dismissal with prejudice.
      Was

      At June 30, 2026 SolarEdge's provision for legal claims was $68.7M against $13.2M at December 31, 2025, alongside a new insurance recovery receivable…

  • OUSTOusterRefreshed

    Six Ouster officers sold shares to pay tax on vesting stock

    Six top officers, including the chief executive and the finance chief, sold 98,037 shares between them at about $33.96 each. Every filing says the shares were sold to pay tax on stock pay that had just become theirs. Over the past year, 95.0% of the shares company insiders sold went through selling plans set up months in advance.

    What it did to the thesisFigures updated; the argument did not move. Selling to pay tax says nothing about the business, so only our record of insider selling was redone. The share price has risen 15.7% since we wrote the case, so it now assumes sales growing 40.7% a year for five years, not 38.4%.

    5 claims changed
    • C51EditedShares outstanding are 54.8% above the 2024 weighted average and 21.2% above the Q2 2025 weighted average.Counter-evidence re-struck at the 24 September 2026 close; the July offering is still above today's price, so the point stands.
    • C55EditedNet of about $421M of cash and with no debt, buyers are paying about $2.34B for Ouster at the 11 November 2026 close - roughly 9.8 times annualised Q3 revenue and about 23.1 times annualised gross profit, with no refund in the quarter. Earning 12% a year for five years, on 20 times operating profit, needs about $1.16B of revenue in 2031 at a 17.7% operating margin: about 40% compound growth every year, at management's own 37.5% mid-point gross margin, with operating costs rising 6.5% a year throughout.Re-struck at the 24 September 2026 close of $41.37, 15.7% above the $35.75 the thesis was struck at; the drift check had fired at 14.2%. The filed share count, cash, July proceeds, revenue and gross profit are unchanged, so only the price moved: $2.12B becomes $2.53B and the growth the price needs rises from 38.4% to 40.7%.
      Was

      Net of about $454M of cash and with no debt, buyers are paying about $2.12B for Ouster - roughly 9.7 times annualised Q2 revenue and about 24.9 times…

    • C56EditedAt 30% compound growth - the floor of management's own framework - Ouster reaches about $814M of revenue and about $76M of operating profit in 2031, which at 20 times is about $1.51B: about two-thirds of what buyers are paying for the business today, before any discounting.Re-struck against the 24 September 2026 close. The 2031 figures do not depend on the price and stand; the counter-case does. At 42% gross margin the floor case is worth about $2.25B, which cleared the $2.12B of 25 August and falls short of today's $2.53B.
    • C57EditedOuster closed at $38.22 on 11 November 2026, 35.4% above the $28.22 of 2 November and 40.1% below its 252-day high of $63.79.Re-struck at the 24 September 2026 close. The original was misdated: the pack was fetched at 11:49 UTC on 25 August, before that session opened, so $35.75 was the close of 24 August; 25 August closed at $36.23.
      Was

      Ouster closed at $35.75 on 25 August 2026, 44.0% below its 252-day high of $63.79 and 118.0% above its low of $16.40. It has returned 20.3% over 252…

    • C61EditedFrom 25 August 2025 to 25 September 2026 Ouster insiders filed 73 open-market sales of 1,484,535 shares, about $50.4M, and three open-market purchases of 8,158 shares, all by one director at $20.95 to $25.35. 67 of the 73 sales and 95.0% of the shares sold carry the Rule 10b5-1 box. Of the six that do not, four are sales to cover tax on vesting restricted stock, among them the chief revenue officer's 8,896 shares on 14 September 2026, and two are one director's, 1.4% of the shares. The chief technology officer's plan dated 15 December 2025 accounts for 57.3% of the shares sold, and the chief financial officer's August sales ran under a plan dated 19 May 2026.Extended from the window to 19 August 2026 through 25 September 2026, as the 2026-09-24 review asked, to cover the six officer sales at $33.96 on 14 September. The full EDGAR sweep also showed the original count was short: the frozen pack's insider list began on 17 June 2026 although its window was a year, so it missed the six sales of 12 June (filed 16 June), the chief technology officer's spring plan sales and the director's purchases. The 14 September sale that read as discretionary is a sale to cover tax on vesting stock, per its own footnote.
      Was

      In the window to 19 August 2026 Ouster insiders filed eight open-market sales worth about $3.5M at prices between $44.65 and $47.09 and no purchases.…

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    Meta launches the Muse app, new AI glasses and a $1,299 pendant

    At its Connect conference Meta launched Muse, an AI assistant app; AI glasses with no camera; and Muse Charm, a $1,299 AI pendant. Amazon blocked Muse from its shopping pages, while Shopify, PayPal and Instacart agreed to let it work on theirs. Meta gave no sales, unit or usage figures for any of it.

    What it did to the thesisNothing changed. We already accept that Reality Labs, Meta's devices arm, keeps losing money and that its heavy spending may not pay off. These launches are that bet, with no sales figure attached. We test the core advertising business at the next quarterly report. Still Attractive, Medium conviction.

    Checked against 3 claims - none changed
    • C02UnchangedMeta's 2025 annual report states that it expects Reality Labs 'to continue to operate at a loss for the foreseeable future, and our ability to support our efforts to build the next computing platform is dependent on generating sufficient profits from other areas of our business'.
    • C12UnchangedReality Labs produced $431 million of revenue in the June 2026 quarter, up 16% year over year on AI glasses growth partially offset by lower Quest headset sales, against a segment operating loss of $4,619 million - an operating margin of negative 1,072%. The segment consumed 24.6% of what Family of Apps earned in the quarter.
    • C10UnchangedMeta has attached no disclosed revenue to the capital spending. The chief executive stated that 'we have quite a number of offers at a meaningful premium over what we paid for the compute' and that 'there's simply not enough compute to meet all demand', without quantifying any of it. The company describes new revenue lines - a model API on Muse Spark, business agents, the Meta One subscription, and selling compute directly - and reports no revenue figure for any of them. It also announced an infrastructure financing partnership with BlackRock, described by the chief financial officer as 'an example of the partnerships we can structure to complement our approach to building infrastructure capacity', with no terms disclosed in the release or the call. The 21 October 2026 release again states no revenue figure for the model API, business agents or compute, saying only that the investments are creating the technology to 'unlock significant new revenue opportunities' (S28).

Thursday 24 September18

  • VRTVertiv HoldingsUnchanged

    Vertiv buys Irish liquid-cooling services firm King Environmental

    Vertiv agreed to buy King Environmental Services, a firm near Dublin that flushes, tests and sets up the liquid-cooling systems in data centres. It takes a similar business Vertiv bought in December 2025 into Europe, and is the seventh deal in that run. The price was not disclosed; Vertiv says it is too small to matter to its results.

    What it did to the thesisNothing changed, because the deal is too small and too vague to test our case. Our view rests on the share price against profit and on growth Vertiv makes without buying it; a small bought-in business only adds to a count of deals our case already tracks.

    Checked against 1 claim - none changed
    • C24UnchangedVertiv has bought six businesses in nine months - PurgeRite for $1,138.3M in December 2025, then Thermal-Lube, ThermoKey, Strategic Thermal Labs and BMarko, and agreed in September 2026 to acquire UtilityInnovation Group for about $1.45B in cash plus up to $1.15B of earnout, stated at about 13 times its expected 2027 cash profit.
  • TSLATeslaThesis changed

    Tesla starts Cybercab rides as the US safety regulator opens an audit

    Tesla started paid rides in Austin with the Cybercab, a robotaxi with no steering wheel, pedals or mirrors; the US road-safety regulator called it a small number of cars. The same day the regulator opened an audit of how Tesla certified an estimated 1,000 Cybercabs as meeting every federal safety standard, and ordered sworn answers by 30 September.

    What it did to the thesisWe added the audit as a new claim and widened the risks it touches; the view held, and we still find the shares unattractive. The price pays for a self-driving software business that reports no sales. The launch brought no fleet count, and the audit adds a new question.

    3 claims changed
    • C47NewThe regulator opened a third front on 3 September 2026, the day Tesla began commercial Cybercab service in Austin. Audit Query AQ26002 examines how Tesla certified an estimated 1,000 Cybercabs - vehicles with no steering wheel, brake pedal, accelerator or mirrors - as meeting every federal motor vehicle safety standard. A Special Order dated 10 September demands sworn answers by 30 September, including how a car with no pedals meets the rule that 'the service brakes shall be activated by means of a foot control', and how it complies without an exemption.Added in the 2026-09-24 backlog review: NHTSA opened AQ26002 on 3 September 2026 and issued a Special Order on 10 September, both read from the regulator's own records.
    • C26EditedThe regulator has two open investigations into Full Self-Driving covering more than three million vehicles, and both were still open on 24 September 2026. EA26002, opened 18 March 2026, covers an estimated 3,203,754 vehicles equipped with FSD and was escalated from a Preliminary Evaluation to an Engineering Analysis - the stage before a recall demand.Scoped to the two investigations into Full Self-Driving, now that a third NHTSA inquiry (C47) audits the Cybercab's certification; re-dated after NHTSA's own records showed both still open on 24 September 2026.
      Was

      The regulator has two open investigations covering more than three million vehicles. EA26002, opened 18 March 2026, covers an estimated 3,203,754 veh…

    • C28EditedA second investigation, PE25012, opened 7 October 2025 over an estimated 2,882,566 vehicles, concerns 'Traffic safety law violations involving Tesla vehicles operating with FSD engaged, including proceeding through red traffic signals and driving against the proper direction of travel on public roadways' - 58 incidents, 14 crashes and 23 injuries.Re-dated: NHTSA's own records show PE25012 still open on 24 September 2026. Text unchanged.
  • TENBTenable HoldingsThesis changed

    Tenable borrows $800 million and buys back its own shares

    Tenable borrowed $800 million through notes due 2031 paying 0.25% interest, which pay out partly in shares if the stock rises above about $44.84. It used the money to repay its $358.1 million bank loan and to buy back 5.3 million of its own shares for $170.5 million. Its debt minus cash rises from about $60 million to about $316 million.

    What it did to the thesisWe corrected the claims about the balance sheet, which had described a loan now repaid; our Neutral view held. Our doubts are about paying staff in shares, keeping customers and growth, and the borrowing touches none of them. It keeps the buyback going, with $800 million due in 2031.

    6 claims changed
    • C47NewEach $1,000 note converts into 22.3005 shares, about $44.84 a share; Tenable repays the $800M face value in cash and settles only the excess in shares, and a $64.1M capped call absorbs that excess up to $64.06 a share.Written from the September 2026 convertible 8-K and its exhibits, read in the 2026-09-24 backlog review.
    • C48NewOn 30 September balances Tenable carries about $305M of net debt ($800M of notes against $495M of cash and short-term investments), 1.1 times its guided 2026 adjusted operating profit of $270M to $273M, while cash interest on borrowing falls from about $23M a year to $2M.Written from the September 2026 convertible 8-K against the Q2 2026 10-Q, in the 2026-09-24 backlog review.
    • C49NewThe notes and the capped call together add no net shares until the price passes $64.06, 77% above the 23 September close of $36.23; above it the net count rises toward the 17.84 million underlying, half of them at twice that level.Written from the September 2026 convertible 8-K terms, in the 2026-09-24 backlog review.
    • C09EditedTenable repurchased 11.4 million shares for about $230M in the first half of 2026 at an average of $20.23, with $108M left on the authorisation at 30 June, and on 10 September bought 5.3 million more for $170.5M at $32.03 with borrowed money.Added the $170.5M repurchase of 10 September 2026, funded from the convertible notes (8-K filed 2026-09-15).
      Was

      Tenable repurchased 11.4 million shares for about $230M in the first half of 2026 at an average of $20.23, and had $108M left on the authorisation at…

    • C22EditedOn 15 September 2026 Tenable repaid its $358.1M secured term loan and replaced it with $800M of unsecured 0.25% convertible notes due September 2031; at 30 September cash and short-term investments were $495.3M and nothing else was borrowed.The term loan was repaid and replaced by $800M of convertible notes on 2026-09-15; the balance sheet is no longer close to neutral.
      Was

      The balance sheet is close to neutral: a $353.0M term loan against $298.2M of cash and short-term investments, with a first lien net leverage ratio o…

    • C44EditedAn independent credit assessor moved the other way from the equity: S&P Global upgraded Tenable to BB from BB- in the fourth quarter of 2025.The secured term loan the rating was struck against was repaid on 2026-09-15; searched note updated.
  • TEMTempus AIThesis changed

    A filing shows Recursion cutting its yearly data fee to Tempus by two-thirds

    Tempus called its Recursion deal an extension, but Recursion's own filing shows this data customer's yearly fee falling from $42 million to $14 million, and Tempus paying Recursion $12 million for one of its models. A filing for the Personalis purchase shows Tempus's own plan for that business losing money until 2030. The chief executive said Medicare pricing on one test adds $80 million to $100 million from January.

    What it did to the thesisWe added three new claims; the view held, and we still find the shares unattractive. The price needs profit margins Tempus has never earned, and both filings sharpen that worry. The one hopeful figure is the chief executive's, found in no filing and not in the company's forecast.

    3 claims changed
    • C50NewOn 15 September 2026 Recursion and Tempus amended their 2023 data agreement: the term runs six years instead of five and Recursion can no longer terminate for convenience, but its yearly fee falls from $42M to $14M for each of the third, fourth and fifth years, it may access fewer records, and Tempus separately pays Recursion $12M for a two-year licence to its RNA model.Added at the 2026-09-24 review: the 15 September amendment, read in Recursion's own 8-K after Tempus's release announced it as an extension.
    • C51NewTempus management's own June 2026 projections for Personalis as a Tempus subsidiary show revenue rising from $79M in 2026 to $333M in 2030, adjusted EBITDA negative in every year to 2029 and zero in 2030, and unlevered free cash flow negative in every year to 2033 - $408M out in 2026 to 2029 alone - against Personalis's own 2030 revenue projection of $758M.Added at the 2026-09-24 review from the S-4 filed 2026-08-31, after the thesis, which no review had read.
    • C52NewThe chief executive said the tumour-only version of xT will be billed at the $4,500 Medicare price from 1 January, adding '$80 million to $100 million of revenue in margin benefit', and that approval and pricing of the liquid biopsy, expected in the second half of 2027, would move it from about $3,200 to the mid-to-high $7,000s, worth '$250 million to $300 million'.Added at the 2026-09-24 review from the 15 September conference transcript Tempus filed as a Form 425.
  • RKLBRocket LabThesis changed

    Rocket Lab sells $1.9 billion of shares to pay for Iridium

    To pay the cash part of its deal to buy Iridium, Rocket Lab sold about 29.3 million new shares for about $1.944 billion. Iridium's lenders agreed to keep its $1.775 billion of loans in place, so a $3.6 billion short-term loan was cancelled unused. The US telecoms regulator, the FCC, opened its review of the deal.

    What it did to the thesisClaims on the funding and share count were corrected; we still find the shares unattractive. The deal is less likely to fail for lack of money but no cheaper per existing share, and the company is now valued at about 52 times a year's sales, up from 44.

    8 claims changed
    • C12EditedCommon shares outstanding were 639,163,713 at September 30, 2026, up from 543,574,552 at December 31, 2025 (17.6% more), with 40,951,250 Series A preferred shares also outstanding; Q4 guidance assumes 681 million basic shares including the preferred. Iridium stock consideration is still to come at closing.The September 15, 2026 8-K reports about 29.3 million shares sold under the ATM; the count now carries them.
      Was

      Common shares outstanding rose from 543,574,552 (December 31, 2025) to 598,180,438 (June 30, 2026), and total shares outstanding (including preferred…

    • C14EditedThe Iridium merger requires Iridium stockholder approval, HSR clearance, FCC consent to transfer Iridium's licenses and an effective Form S-4. The HSR period lapsed as of 2026-08-13 and the S-4 was declared effective on 2026-08-26. The FCC accepted the transfer applications for filing on 2026-09-15 (GN Docket No. 26-257) with comments and petitions due October 15, oppositions October 30 and replies November 9, 2026. Iridium's stockholders adopted the merger agreement at their 2026-09-24 special meeting, 85,862,105 votes for against 318,415 against and 67,862 abstained (Iridium Form 8-K, Item 5.07). Three stockholder lawsuits in New York state court allege proxy disclosure gaps and seek to enjoin the merger; Iridium calls them without merit and supplemented its proxy on 2026-09-18. Both companies say they expect to close in mid-2027; the outside date is June 28, 2027, extendable to September 28, 2027 and then December 28, 2027.Re-checked at the 2026-09-24 review: the S-4 is effective, the FCC opened a pleading cycle ending November 9, three disclosure lawsuits were filed and Iridium supplemented its proxy; the vote result is not yet filed.
      Was

      The Iridium merger requires Iridium shareholder approval (vote scheduled 2026-09-24), HSR clearance (lapsed as of 2026-08-13), FCC consent to transfe…

    • C15EditedSpaceX filed with the FCC urging scrutiny of Iridium's conduct toward rival satellite operators (a spectrum-interference dispute in the 19.4-19.6 GHz and 29.1-29.3 GHz bands) as part of the license-transfer review, while stating it does not oppose the Rocket Lab-Iridium merger itself.Its refresh trigger (the 2026-09-24 vote) arrived with no new SpaceX filing found; the FCC's own pleading cycle is now the next point at which SpaceX or anyone else has to put an objection on the record.
    • C23EditedRocket Lab's CEO stated on the Q2 2026 call that spacecraft-component customers ordering at scale (e.g., 1,000 reaction wheels) have 'almost zero' chance of being served except by a supplier with Rocket Lab's scale, and that its Albuquerque solar business has become the largest space-grade solar manufacturer in the world.Re-checked at the 2026-09-24 review: no independent source on component scale or solar share appeared (the September 8 solar-cell release is the company again), so the claim stands as management's and waits for the next call.
    • C25EditedIn the Form 4 filings the vendor carries from 2025-11-15 to 2026-09-24, officers made 213 open-market sales and zero open-market purchases. Of the 22 open-market sales filed between 2026-08-20 and 2026-09-24 (260,592 shares, including the COO's and CFO's August 24-27 sales at $66.25-$71.17 and the CFO's 140,157 shares sold on September 2 at $62.26-$62.97), 19 covering 259,923 shares - 99.7% - were made under Rule 10b5-1 plans adopted in advance; the only discretionary sales were 669 shares by the chief accounting officer on August 24.Its refresh trigger fired at this review. Re-sourced from the current Form 4 roster (the vendor now carries filings from 2025-11-15, so 213 is not comparable with the 252 counted over a longer window), and the Rule 10b5-1 flag was read: 99.7% of the August-September shares were sold under pre-adopted plans.
      Was

      Over the trailing 365 days, officer Form 4 filings showed 252 open-market sales and zero open-market purchases; the COO and CFO both sold shares betw…

    • C28EditedAt the 2026-11-06 close of $53.07, Rocket Lab's enterprise value is approximately 33 times trailing-twelve-month revenue.Re-struck at the 2026-09-23 close: the price is 12.4% above the thesis-day close, the ATM added about 29.3 million shares and $1.944 billion of cash, and the share count is now the filed one rather than the vendor's, which ran about 21 million shares short.
      Was

      At the 2026-09-01 close, Rocket Lab's enterprise value is approximately 44 times trailing-twelve-month revenue.

    • C31EditedRocket Lab's own funded debt is minimal (about $13.1 million of convertible notes plus $1.7 million of other borrowings at June 30, 2026). On September 15, 2026 it terminated, undrawn, the $3.6 billion senior secured bridge commitment signed to fund the Iridium cash payments: Iridium's lenders consented to the merger, so Iridium's $1.775 billion of term loans (as of June 30, 2026) stay outstanding after closing, guaranteed (unsecured) by Rocket Lab USA, Inc., at a margin that rises at closing to SOFR plus 2.50-3.00% (or base rate plus 1.50-2.00%) depending on Rocket Lab's credit ratings, with a 1% fee on prepayment after the first anniversary. The company says those loans, the ATM proceeds (C32) and other cash are enough to pay the cash consideration, repay Iridium's other debt and pay fees at closing.The September 15, 2026 8-K terminated the bridge and replaced the undetermined refinancing with Iridium's own term loans kept in place under a Rocket Lab guarantee; the claim now says what the financing is rather than what it might be.
      Was

      Total funded debt today is minimal (about $13.1 million of convertible notes plus $1.7 million of other borrowings), but Rocket Lab has obtained fina…

    • C32EditedRocket Lab's replacement ATM program of up to $1,944,369,826, set up on August 13, 2026 to fund the Iridium cash payments, was used in full by September 15, 2026: about 29.3 million shares were sold for about $1.944 billion of gross proceeds, before commissions and expenses. If the Iridium deal does not close, the company says the proceeds go to future growth, possible acquisitions and general corporate purposes.The September 15, 2026 8-K reports the ATM completed: about 29.3 million shares for about $1.944 billion gross.
      Was

      On August 13, 2026, Rocket Lab replaced its equity distribution program with an ATM offering of up to $1,944,369,826 (the unsold amount under the pri…

  • QQnity ElectronicsUnchanged

    North Carolina's pollution claims settle within what Qnity set aside

    DuPont, Chemours and Corteva settled North Carolina's claims over PFAS chemicals and other pollution from the Fayetteville Works plant. Qnity pays 44% of DuPont's after-tax cost in old cases like this, and its share stays at the $43 million it had already set aside in the second quarter, so there is no new charge.

    What it did to the thesisNothing changed, because the case settled at the amount already set aside, inside the $253 million of old liabilities our case already counts. It closes one case of several; Qnity's open-ended 44% share of the rest, the real risk, is untouched.

  • NFLXNetflixThesis changed

    Netflix's share of US TV viewing fell for a second month

    Nielsen, which measures TV viewing, found Netflix had 7.8% of American TV time in July, against 8.8% a year earlier. June was also below a year earlier, so that is two falls in a row. YouTube hit a record 14.2%. Separately, the shares fell 12.9% from when we wrote our view, so they now cost about $24 for each dollar of profit the company forecasts for 2026.

    What it did to the thesisWe updated price figures and one line: Netflix's TV share is now below a year earlier, not just off its peak. A third straight fall would trip one of our tests for being wrong. Still Neutral, Medium conviction: two falls is not three, and cheaper is not yet cheap.

    7 claims changed
    • C08EditedTrailing diluted earnings per share of $3.18 include about $0.53 from the termination fee after tax, so at $71.36 the price is about $27 for each $1 of profit excluding the fee against about $22 including it.Re-struck at the 2026-09-23 close of $71.36: the thesis's 12% drift trigger fired.
      Was

      Trailing diluted earnings per share of $3.18 include about $0.53 from the termination fee after tax, so at $81.89 the price is about $31 for each $1…

    • C13EditedNielsen measured YouTube at a record 14.2% of United States television watch-time in July 2026, the largest share of any distributor and 5.0 points ahead of the second, against Netflix at 7.8%, level with FOX behind NBCUniversal-Versant and Disney.Re-sourced: its refresh trigger fired when Nielsen published the July 2026 Gauge on 10 September; YouTube rose to a record 14.2% and Netflix fell to 7.8%.
      Was

      Nielsen measured YouTube at 13.8% of United States television watch-time in May 2026, the largest share of any distributor for a third consecutive mo…

    • C15EditedNetflix's measured share of United States television time is now below its year-earlier level in two consecutive months: Nielsen put it at 7.9% in June 2026 against 8.3% in June 2025 and 7.8% in July 2026 against 8.8% in July 2025, after 8.0% in May 2026 against 7.5% a year earlier.Re-derived on the June and July 2026 Gauge charts and Nielsen's own 2025 releases: Netflix's share is now below its year-earlier level in two consecutive months, which the claim did not say before.
      Was

      Netflix's measured share of United States television time has not advanced since its December 2025 peak: Nielsen put it at 8.0% in May 2026 and repor…

    • C27EditedAt $71.36 the equity is about $304B and enterprise value about $309B, so Netflix's own 2026 guide of about $16.1B of operating profit and about $12.6B of net profit puts the price at about $24 for each $1 of net profit and about $19 of enterprise value for each $1 of operating profit.Re-struck at the 2026-09-23 close of $71.36: the thesis's 12% drift trigger fired. The consensus figures in the counter-evidence are re-read from the new pack.
      Was

      At $81.89 the equity is about $349B and enterprise value about $354B, so Netflix's own 2026 guide of about $16.1B of operating profit and about $12.6…

    • C35EditedNielsen measured streaming at 49.0% of total United States television watch-time in July 2026, against broadcast at 19.5% and cable at 18.7%, after 48.6% in May and 48.5% in June 2026.Re-sourced: its refresh trigger fired with the July 2026 Gauge; streaming rose to 49.0%.
      Was

      Nielsen measured streaming at 48.6% of total United States television watch-time in May 2026, up 1.0 percentage point on the month, against broadcast…

    • C43EditedThe shares closed at $71.36 on 23 September 2026, down 41.9% over 252 sessions and 42.8% below the 252-day high of $124.86, with a trailing price of about 22.2 times earnings against a six-year median of 41.7.Re-read from the research pack of 2026-09-24 (close of 2026-09-23): the refresh trigger 'the next research pack' fired.
      Was

      The shares closed at $81.89 on 25 August 2026, down 32.0% over 252 sessions and 35.4% below the 252-day high of $126.71, with a trailing price of abo…

    • C44EditedThe analyst panel the research pack aggregates stands at 63 buy, 30 hold and 7 sell, with no strong sells, and its consensus label is Buy.Re-read from the research pack of 2026-09-24: one more sell rating than on 25 August.
      Was

      The analyst panel the research pack aggregates stands at 63 buy, 30 hold and 6 sell, with no strong sells, and its consensus label is Buy.

  • NEENextEra EnergyRefreshed

    NextEra and Dominion shareholders approve their merger

    Shareholders of NextEra and Dominion both approved their merger by wide margins, with 99.47% of NextEra's votes in favour. To win over Virginia officials, the pair enlarged their offer, stretching a $10-a-month household bill credit from two years to four. Virginia's consumer lawyers want the state's 180-day review restarted. Separately, the US government agreed a loan of up to $1.9 billion to restart the Duane Arnold nuclear plant.

    What it did to the thesisFacts were updated; nothing was re-judged. The vote is done and only regulators remain. Even a restarted Virginia review ends about March 2027, before the planned late-2027 completion. The view stays Neutral with Medium conviction, held there by shares valued above similar regulated utilities, which none of this touches.

    3 claims changed
    • C07EditedThe combined company proposed $2.25B in total bill credits for Dominion Energy's customers in Virginia (~79%, stated as $1.78B over two years), South Carolina (~17%) and North Carolina (~3%), paid over 24 months post-close; on September 14, 2026 the companies proposed extending Virginia's $10-a-month residential credit from two years to four by increasing the aggregate shareholder-funded Virginia credit (new total not disclosed) and asking the Virginia SCC to redirect data centers' share to residential customers, and added a $100M increase to the EnergyShare bill-assistance program through 2038, a $100M workforce fund, an up-to-$1B-a-year, five-year Virginia supplier spending program and a shareholder-funded co-headquarters tower in Richmond.2026-09-14 8-K (Ex-99.1, Ex-99.2) and Dominion's Ex-99.2 of the same day: the Virginia residential credit was extended from two to four years with an undisclosed larger aggregate, and new shareholder-funded commitments were added.
      Was

      The combined company proposes $2.25B in total bill credits for Dominion Energy's customers in Virginia (~79%), South Carolina (~17%) and North Caroli…

    • C08EditedClosing requires HSR Act clearance and regulatory clearances from FERC, the NRC, the Virginia SCC, the North Carolina Utilities Commission and the South Carolina PSC, each without a 'Burdensome Condition' as defined in the Merger Agreement; the companies filed for state and federal merger approvals on July 15, 2026 (Virginia's filing triggering a 180-day statutory review in SCC case PUR-2026-00112, with an evidentiary hearing set to begin November 17, 2026), and both shareholder approvals were obtained on September 3, 2026: NEE's share-issuance proposal passed with 99.47% of votes cast and Dominion's merger proposal with 671.3M votes for against 8.6M against. Virginia's consumer counsel in the Attorney General's office has asked the SCC to treat the September 14 benefits package as an amended application and restart the 180-day clock, which the SCC had not ruled on as of September 24, 2026; management continues to expect the transaction to close in the second half of 2027. The 21 October 2026 release says procedural schedules are set with hearings in Virginia in November and South Carolina in December and final orders expected in January 2027, the North Carolina Utilities Commission's expert witness hearings begin in February 2027, the federal reviews are underway, and the companies still expect to close in the second half of 2027. Testimony filed in Virginia on 2026-10-19 shows the governor's consultant and the SCC's own staff both saying the merger should not be approved as filed; staff suggested limits on Dominion's dividends and an independent board, and on the 21 October call chief executive John Ketchum said he stands behind the filing, will file rebuttal in about two weeks, and sees room for compromise on specific issues. On 3 November the companies' rebuttal accepted 101 of the 117 conditions Staff and Consumer Counsel proposed and 13 more with modifications, and declined the governor's six-year residential rate freeze; the evidentiary hearing began on 17 November, and NextEra told employees a ruling is expected by 11 January 2027 under the 180-day clock, so the clock was not restarted.Both shareholder votes passed on 2026-09-03 (NEE and Dominion Item 5.07 8-Ks); added the Virginia SCC docket schedule and the consumer counsel's request to restart the review clock.
      Was

      Closing requires both companies' shareholder approvals, HSR Act clearance, and regulatory clearances from FERC, the NRC, the Virginia SCC, the North…

    • C18EditedNEER remains on track to bring the previously shut 615-megawatt Duane Arnold nuclear plant in Iowa back online no later than Q1 2029; the Iowa Utilities Commission approved a generating certificate for the plant, NEER closed on acquiring the final 30% minority interest held by two cooperative partners, making it the plant's sole owner, and on September 8, 2026 NextEra and the US Department of Energy reached conditional commitment and financial close on a loan of up to $1.9B to support the restart.2026-09-08 NextEra release: the DOE loan of up to $1.9B for the restart reached financial close; restart target unchanged.
      Was

      NEER remains on track to bring the previously shut Duane Arnold nuclear plant in Iowa back online no later than Q1 2029; the Iowa Utilities Commissio…

  • HLIOHelios TechnologiesUnchanged

    Helios buys Radio Sound's assets and an Indian Motorcycle contract

    Helios bought some assets of Radio Sound, which makes audio electronics for vehicles, mainly its technology and designs. With it came a contract lasting several years to supply electronics to Indian Motorcycle. Helios says the deal is too small to matter to its results and gave no price, contract value, volume or length. It filed no formal notice with the US securities regulator.

    What it did to the thesisNothing changed. Our view turns on a data centre order arriving with a size attached, second-half profit reaching the company's forecast, and how much of its 2030 target relies on deals not found. A tiny purchase and an unsized contract answer none of those. Still Neutral, Medium conviction.

    Checked against 1 claim - none changed
    • C14UnchangedAt its March 2026 investor day Helios targeted 2030 sales of $1.6B including acquisitions - roughly double the $792M of 2025 sales excluding the divested business - with an adjusted cash-profit margin above 25%, an adjusted operating margin of 20% and a return on invested capital in the low to mid teens.
  • GLWCorningThesis changed

    Corning sets up a $2 billion programme to sell new shares

    Corning signed a deal letting it sell up to $2.0 billion of new shares on the stock market whenever it chooses, through Goldman Sachs. At the 23 September price that is about 12.9 million shares, about 1.5% of the company, and none has been sold yet. It was signed on 11 September, the day we wrote our view, and the shares fell 13.7% the next day.

    What it did to the thesisWe corrected our record: it said Corning needed no new shares and had signed nothing like this, both wrong the day we wrote them. New shares leave each share owning less, a worry we already held; this is too small to move a grade. Still Unattractive, Medium conviction.

    1 claim changed
    • C44NewOn 11 September 2026 Corning signed an agreement to sell up to $2.0 billion of new common stock at the market through Goldman Sachs, for general corporate purposes, with no minimum amount; against the 861,388,331 shares outstanding at 24 July 2026, $2.0 billion at the 25 September 2026 close of $156.74 would be about 12.8 million shares, or 1.5%.Added at the 2026-09-24 review: the 11 September 2026 8-K and prospectus supplement were filed on the day the thesis was struck and were not read by it.
  • FSLRFirst SolarRefreshed

    First Solar drops its trade-body patent case and keeps suing in court

    First Solar is dropping its complaint asking a US trade body to block imports of one type of solar panel made by ten rivals, which it says uses its patents. It will keep suing them in federal court instead, and tied the change to a separate US tariff action on polysilicon. The trade body could not have ruled before September 2027. Only the announcement's first paragraph could be read.

    What it did to the thesisThe argument held and one fact was updated. We never counted on an import ban. Our case rests on the price floor on rivals' imported cells and a US tax credit for making panels at home, so the view stays Attractive with Medium conviction.

    1 claim changed
    • C26EditedFirst Solar asked the trade commission in February 2026 to bar imports of competing panels made by ten named rivals, and on 15 September 2026 said it would withdraw that complaint without prejudice and pursue its district-court patent suits instead.The company said on 15 September 2026 that it will withdraw its Section 337 complaint without prejudice and move to terminate the investigation, keeping its district-court TOPCon suits. The claim described a petition still being pursued; it now records both the petition and the withdrawal. The Federal Register shows no termination yet, so the next 10-Q is where it is confirmed.
      Was

      First Solar is asking the trade commission to bar imports of competing panels made by ten named rivals.

  • EXEExpand EnergyThesis changed

    Expand closes its Twin Eagle purchase and sells $500 million of bonds

    Expand completed its purchase of Twin Eagle on 16 September, 54 days after signing and within the quarter it had promised. The next day it borrowed $500 million through bonds paying 5.65% a year, due 2031. The borrowing alone leaves debt minus cash unchanged, since the cash raised sits beside the new debt; the purchase lifts it to roughly $4.4 billion.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Neutral, confidence Medium. We rewrote the deal claims as history and re-checked our debt warning line: debt minus cash is closer to $5 billion but about $574 million below it. The other thing we wait for, a permanent chief executive, is still missing.

    4 claims changed
    • C40NewOn 2026-09-17 Expand issued $500M of 5.650% Senior Notes due 2031 at 99.889% of face, senior unsecured and guaranteed by no subsidiary, for net proceeds of about $496.4M before expenses, to be used for 'general corporate purposes'. The prospectus supplement's as-adjusted capitalization at 2026-06-30, reflecting the notes alone, shows cash of $1,157M against $663M actual and total debt, net, of $4,179M against $3,685M, taking senior-note principal from $3,738M to $4,238M. It also discloses that Twin Eagle's own senior secured credit facility - $95M drawn, $282M of letters of credit and $623M available at 2026-06-30, maturing May 2027 - stays in place after closing as an obligation of the Twin Eagle subsidiaries, unguaranteed by Expand, until Expand terminates it; the new notes are structurally subordinated to it.Written on the 2026-09-24 backlog review from the notes 8-Ks and the 424B2 prospectus supplement, filed after the 2026-09-13 thesis.
    • C41NewIllustratively, adding the $1.25B base purchase price and the $95M drawn on Twin Eagle's facility at 2026-06-30 to the as-adjusted June position - senior-note principal of $4,238M less cash of $1,157M, about $3,081M on the company's own net-debt definition - puts net debt near $4,426M, about $574M below the $5B line this thesis treats as invalidating, where the unadjusted June figure stood about $1,925M below it. The illustration carries no third-quarter cash flow, dividends or buybacks and no closing adjustments to the price.Written on the 2026-09-24 backlog review so the net-debt criterion is read against the post-closing position rather than June's.
    • C15EditedThe Twin Eagle acquisition closed on 16 September 2026, 54 days after the 24 July merger agreement and inside the third quarter management had guided. The agreement had required HSR Act clearance, approval under Canada's Competition Act and FERC approval under Section 203(a) of the Federal Power Act, with seller approval given in advance by irrevocable written consent; the prospectus supplement dated 15 September said all conditions other than those satisfied at closing had been met. The closing 8-K states only that the acquisition was completed: it does not give the price paid after working-capital, cash, debt and expense adjustments, or how much was drawn on the revolving credit facility.Twin Eagle closed on 2026-09-16 (8-K Items 5.02/8.01); the claim was a forward statement of closing conditions and a Q3 expectation, and is now the historical fact that the expectation was met.
      Was

      The Twin Eagle Merger Agreement requires HSR Act clearance, approval under Canada's Competition Act and FERC approval under Section 203(a) of the Fed…

    • C36EditedThe executed Twin Eagle merger agreement, dated 2026-07-24, protected Expand more than the announcement disclosed - an outside date of January 24, 2027 that 'shall automatically be extended by six (6) months' where only the regulatory conditions remained outstanding, and a seller remedy on Expand's breach limited to 'payment of the Deposit, which payment shall constitute liquidated damages (and not a penalty)', capping exposure at the $62.5M deposit absent fraud. None of it was called on: the deal closed on 2026-09-16, more than four months before the original outside date, so the extension and the deposit cap lapsed unused.The deal closed on 2026-09-16 (S25), so the outside-date extension and the deposit cap this claim described as live protections lapsed unused; restated as history.
      Was

      The executed Twin Eagle merger agreement, dated 2026-07-24, is more protective of Expand than the announcement disclosed. The Outside Date is January…

  • EQTEQTUnchanged

    EQT wins its first named LNG buyer: Lithuania's Ignitis

    EQT won a Lithuanian tender to sell ten shiploads of liquefied natural gas to Ignitis, the country's state-controlled energy group, one a year from 2027 to 2036, priced on both US and European gas prices. It is the first named buyer on any EQT gas-export deal, but one shipload is about 0.14% of this year's expected sales volume. Lithuanian security and EQT approvals are still pending.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our case rests on larger conditional gas sales deals becoming firm, on two projects, Southgate and Boost, staying on schedule, and on debt coming down. One shipload a year changes none of those, and EQT has not yet filed anything on the deal.

  • CHYMChime FinancialThesis changed
    Valuation2→3

    Chime agrees to buy Stride Bank, one of its partner banks, for $590 million

    Chime agreed to buy Stride Bank for $590 million in cash. Stride is one of the two partner banks Chime relies on because it has no banking licence of its own. Regulators must approve, and closing is expected in the first half of 2027. Chime also raised this year's profit forecast, on its own adjusted measure, a fourth time, to $481 million to $489 million.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Neutral, confidence Medium. The company, counting debt and cash, now costs about 18.5 times this year's forecast profit, down from 25, so we rate the price fair, not full. But becoming Attractive needs two reported quarters with profit above 17% of sales; none has topped 15%.

    7 claims changed
    • C33NewOn September 8, 2026 Chime agreed to acquire Central Service Corporation, parent of Stride Bank, N.A. - one of its two bank partners, for more than seven years - for $590 million in cash, about 1.5 times Stride's tangible book value, funded from balance-sheet cash with no new capital. Closing is expected in the first half of 2027 and requires approval from the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Federal Reserve Board; on closing Chime becomes a bank holding company and Stride becomes Chime Bank, N.A. On the 4 November call management said combined assets of Chime, Stride and the holding company would have been about $6.5 billion at September 30, of which about $1.6 billion is commercial loans outside the core, and that Chime intends to stay below the $10 billion bank-size line for the foreseeable future.the 2026-09-08 Stride announcement, read in the 2026-09-24 review
    • C34NewManagement expects the Stride acquisition to be accretive to earnings per share immediately on closing and to produce more than $100 million of net synergies, from eliminated sponsor-bank fees, expanded lending and a significantly lower cost of funds.the 2026-09-08 Stride announcement, read in the 2026-09-24 review
    • C35NewRegulation II exempts debit-card issuers that, together with their affiliates, hold less than $10 billion of assets from its caps on interchange fees; Chime's 10-K says interchange has historically been a substantial majority of its revenue and that it depends in part on its bank partners keeping that exemption. Announcing the Stride deal, Chime said it 'will manage its balance sheet and keep its assets below $10 billion for the foreseeable future.'the 2026-09-08 Stride announcement, read in the 2026-09-24 review
    • C07EditedOn November 4, 2026 Chime raised guidance again, to FY2026 revenue of $2.792-$2.802 billion (about 28% growth) and Adjusted EBITDA of $519-$524 million (about a 19% margin), and to Q4 revenue of $757-$767 million and Adjusted EBITDA of $161-$166 million (a 21%-22% margin). The guide it replaced, issued September 8, was $2.76-$2.77 billion and $481-$489 million.Superseded on 2026-09-08: guidance raised for the fourth time in the Stride announcement (S12).
      Was

      Chime raised FY2026 guidance to revenue of $2.725-$2.745 billion (25%-26% growth) and Adjusted EBITDA of $465-$475 million (about 17% margin, roughly…

    • C27EditedCHYM's short interest was 21,348,953 shares, 9.5% of float, at the FINRA settlement of 2026-08-31, up 12.7% from the prior settlement, with 3.06 days to cover.Refreshed at the next FINRA settlement, as its refresh_by required.
      Was

      CHYM's short interest was 18,952,244 shares, 8.4% of float, at the FINRA settlement of 2026-08-14, down 17.8% from the prior settlement, with 1.56 da…

    • C29EditedAt the November 3, 2026 close of $28.20 and 378,585,111 shares outstanding on August 3, 2026, CHYM's market capitalisation was about $10.68 billion and, against $1,183.0 million of cash and marketable securities at September 30, 2026 (cash $636.7 million, marketable securities $546.3 million, restricted cash excluded), its enterprise value about $9.50 billion - roughly 18.2 times the raised FY2026 Adjusted EBITDA guidance midpoint of $521.5 million (C07), against 18.5 times at the September 23 close of $26.46 and about 25 times when this thesis was written at $33.20. The Stride purchase (C33) is to be paid from that cash, so after closing the same share price carries an enterprise value about $590 million higher.Re-struck at the 2026-09-23 close on filed cash and shares and the raised guidance midpoint; the price had fallen 20% since the thesis while the guide rose 3%.
      Was

      CHYM last traded at $33.20, implying a market capitalization of approximately $12.65 billion and, against the $1.05 billion of cash and marketable se…

    • C31EditedFY2026 Adjusted EBITDA guidance moved up in four steps across the company's first year public: $380-400 million (14%-15% margin) issued February 25, 2026 alongside management's statement that 2026 was expected to be Chime's first full year of GAAP net income profitability; $416-431 million (16% margin) issued May 6, 2026; $465-475 million issued at Q2 2026; and $481-489 million (17%-18% margin) issued September 8, 2026 with the Stride announcement (C07) - a roughly 24% increase at the midpoint from the original guide, in under seven months.Fourth step added: the 2026-09-08 raise (S12).
      Was

      FY2026 Adjusted EBITDA guidance moved up in three steps across the company's first year public: $380-400 million (14%-15% margin) issued February 25,…

  • CEGConstellation EnergyUnchanged

    Constellation buys a Rhode Island gas plant from Shell for $715 million

    Constellation agreed to buy a gas-fired power plant in Johnston, Rhode Island, from a Shell company for $715 million. That is about 2.9% of Constellation's roughly $24.7 billion of debt. The announcement could be read only in part, so how the purchase will be paid for is not known. It names no data-centre customer or power contract.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. The deal is too small to change Constellation's debt in any way that matters. Our view rests on signed data-centre power deals, the Crane plant restarting in 2027, and the regional grid not loading new costs onto existing plants. The next quarterly filing will show the funding.

    Checked against 1 claim - none changed
    • C13UnchangedBalance sheet, 2026-09-30 versus 2026-06-30 and 2025-12-31: total debt (short-term borrowings $3,989M, current long-term debt $359M, long-term debt $19,039M) $23,387M versus approximately $24,700M and approximately $8,992M; cash and restricted cash $1,009M; total assets $99,185M versus $98,253M and $57,249M; goodwill $11,499M; assets held for sale $5,661M versus $126M at year-end. Average diluted shares were 354M in Q3 2026 against 360M in Q2, after about $3.0B of buybacks this year. Management targets 2.00x to 2.25x debt to EBITDA and shows ratings of BBB+ and Baa1.
  • BEBloom EnergyThesis changed

    Gas for Bloom's biggest named data-centre site slips to 2027

    Oracle says its Project Jupiter data centre in New Mexico will run on Bloom fuel cells, but the gas pipeline feeding it slipped from August 2026 to February 2027, and Oracle sent the developer a notice letting it delay payments. A July filing we had missed shows Bloom denies its scandium, a rare metal, depends on China, but names no source. Four executives sold shares; none bought.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Unattractive, confidence Medium. We corrected our record, which wrongly said Bloom never answered the scandium charge; a denial naming no supplier leaves the question open. The shares rose 34.9% without new results, so the company, counting debt, costs $25.20 per $1 of yearly sales, up from $19.35.

    9 claims changed
    • C27NewOn July 9, 2026, the day after the short report, Bloom filed an 8-K under Item 7.01 stating that it 'categorically rejects' the report's claims about its financial results and accounting and, on scandium oxide: 'We have sufficient supply of scandium oxide to meet our current fuel cell demand and backlog, and our supply is not dependent on China. We are also not dependent on China to scale scandium oxide to meet future demand growth,' with 'clear visibility into our supply chain to support production of 25GW of fuel cells per year.' Asked about scandium on the July 28, 2026 Q2 call, the chief executive repeated that Bloom is 'not dependent on China' and added: 'That's all we are going to say about it. Everything else is proprietary to the company.' The Q3 2026 Form 10-Q repeats a shortened form of the denial ('we believe we have sufficient supply of the relevant raw materials to meet our current fuel cell demand and backlog') without the China statement, and no analyst asked about scandium on the October 22 call.Written at the 2026-09-24 review: the July 9, 2026 8-K and the Q2 call answer, neither of which the original pass read.
    • C28NewOracle, the tenant of Project Jupiter, a data-center campus in Doña Ana County, New Mexico, told the New Mexico Environment Department on July 2, 2026 that the project 'will now use Bloom Energy fuel cells to power the AI data center campus', running on natural gas, under an updated air permit application then pending. Coverage of a filing by Energy Transfer's Transwestern unit with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission reports that the in-service date of the 'Green Chile' gas pipeline to the site moved from August 15, 2026 to February 1, 2027, after New Mexico's land commissioner twice refused its route across state trust land; Bloomberg reported in September 2026 that Oracle sent a force majeure notice to the project's developer, Stack Infrastructure. No Bloom filing names Project Jupiter, and no primary document read states the capacity Bloom is to supply there.Written at the 2026-09-24 review: Bloom's largest publicly named deployment, and the delay reported against it since the thesis.
    • C09EditedThe word 'scandium' does not appear anywhere in Bloom's FY2025 10-K, a document of approximately 649,000 characters, nor in its Q2 2026 results release. Scandium oxide is a standard stabiliser for solid-oxide fuel cell electrolytes and is the material at the centre of the July 2026 short report and the subsequent securities class action. The Q3 2026 Form 10-Q (filed October 22, 2026) does not contain the word either; its risk factor says Bloom 'rejected the report's conclusions regarding our supply chain' and that it believes it has 'sufficient supply of the relevant raw materials to meet our current fuel cell demand and backlog', without the China statement or any supplier. Neither the October 22 release nor the call, where no analyst asked, mentions scandium or China.Counter-evidence corrected in the open: it said Bloom had never confirmed its cells use scandium, but the July 9, 2026 8-K (S14), which the original pass did not open, discusses Bloom's scandium oxide supply directly. The claim text itself remains true.
    • C12EditedA securities class action, Nevins v. Bloom Energy Corporation, No. 26-cv-07944 in the Northern District of California, has been filed against Bloom Energy and certain executives in respect of a class period running February 27, 2025 through July 8, 2026, alleging that the company made false or misleading statements by failing to disclose that it obtained scandium through intermediaries who sourced the metal from China and thereby understated its reliance on Chinese scandium. The court-set deadline to apply for lead plaintiff is September 28, 2026. Neither the Q2 2026 Form 10-Q filed July 28, 2026 nor the Q2 2026 results release mentions the litigation, Hunterbrook, China or scandium. The Q3 2026 Form 10-Q discloses the suit, says its allegations 'mirror' the Hunterbrook report, calls it without merit and records that on October 15, 2026 the court appointed Nicole Caraoué as lead plaintiff and Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd as lead counsel; the complaint is still preliminary and the lead-plaintiff deadline has passed.Caption and court added from the lead-plaintiff notices (S19); counter-evidence corrected, because the company has answered the allegation by denial in a July 9, 2026 8-K and on the Q2 call (C27), which the original pass recorded as unanswered.
      Was

      A securities class action has been filed against Bloom Energy in respect of a class period running February 27, 2025 through July 8, 2026, alleging t…

    • C14EditedShares of common stock outstanding rose from 231,969,446 at March 31, 2025 to 233,661,168 at June 30, 2025 to 280,045,459 at December 31, 2025. Against the August 24, 2026 research pack's reference price of $204.02 and market capitalisation of $59.33 billion, implied shares outstanding are approximately 291 million, roughly 25% above the March 2025 count. Bloom also has convertible notes outstanding, with a premium on convertible debt recorded in additional paid-in capital. The Q3 2026 equity statement shows 295,537,217 shares outstanding at September 30, 2026, including 7,796,169 shares issued on conversion of the Green Notes and 2,154,231 on a cashless exercise of the warrant issued as consideration for Oracle's partnership.Wording made explicit that the reference price is the August 24, 2026 pack's, since the pack beside the thesis was refreshed at the 2026-09-24 review.
      Was

      Shares of common stock outstanding rose from 231,969,446 at March 31, 2025 to 233,661,168 at June 30, 2025 to 280,045,459 at December 31, 2025. Again…

    • C15EditedAt the October 28, 2026 close of $228.08, with the 294.5 million shares the research pack carried at the September 25 close and the filer's trailing revenue of $3,829.9 million for the four quarters to September 30, 2026, Bloom's price-to-sales is about 17.5 and its enterprise value to sales about 17.5, against prior-fiscal-years medians of 3.67 and 4.29. At the September 25 close the same two multiples were 27.31 and 27.36 on the June-quarter revenue of $3,113.2 million; the fall is the 21.0% drop in the price plus a quarter of revenue. The earnings, book and cash-flow multiples were not recomputed. The negative prior medians on the earnings ratios reflect that Bloom was loss-making across most of the comparison window.Re-struck on the research pack refreshed at the 2026-09-24 review (S21): the price rose 34.9% between the two reviews with no quarter reported in between, so every price multiple moved and the own-history medians did not.
      Was

      On the research pack's market tier, Bloom's trailing-twelve-month multiples are: price-to-earnings 244.10 against a prior-fiscal-years median of -20.…

    • C17EditedOver the research pack's 365-day window the vendor's Form 4 roster records 55 open-market sales and zero open-market purchases. Since this thesis was written on August 24, 2026 there have been four more sales, all on September 16, 2026 at $268.42 to $270.07: the Chief Commercial Officer (3,601 shares), the Chief Operations Officer (2,870), the Chief Legal Officer (2,870) and the Chief Accounting Officer (2,295). The chairman and chief executive reported a gift of 300,000 shares on August 31, 2026, and no insider bought. Earlier sellers include director Jeffrey R. Immelt (30,000 shares at $238.91 on 2026-08-17) and director John T. Chambers (15,000 shares at $250.00 on 2026-08-13). On October 1, 2026 the Chief Commercial Officer sold a further 8,437 shares at $277.17 under a Rule 10b5-1 plan; the 45-day Form 4 read to October 22 shows five open-market sales, four under a plan (88.6% of the shares), and no purchase.Refreshed at the 2026-09-24 review: four more open-market sales and no purchases since the thesis, and the Rule 10b5-1 box now read on each Form 4 (S20) rather than left unknown.
      Was

      Insider activity in the research window comprised 15 Form 4 filings with 12 open-market sales and zero open-market purchases. Sellers include directo…

    • C18EditedAs of the October 28, 2026 close Bloom traded at $228.08, 21.0% below the $288.70 close of September 25, 11.8% above the $204.02 close on which this thesis was first struck, and 35.1% below its 252-day high of $351.28 (the high is from the September 25 pack).Refreshed at the 2026-09-24 review on the refreshed research pack (S21); the 20-day range fell out of the 'Very volatile' bucket.
      Was

      As of the research pack date Bloom traded at $204.02, 41.92% below its 252-day high of $351.28 and 51.98% up its 52-week range from a low of $44.64;…

    • C19EditedSell-side consensus is 17 buy, 12 hold and 3 sell - a Buy, but with the largest proportion of hold and sell ratings of any name in this repo's current energy coverage. Bloom has beaten consensus earnings per share in 7 of the last 8 quarters, most recently by 100.0% ($0.78 against $0.39) on 2026-07-28 and by 255.1% ($0.44 against $0.12) on 2026-04-28.Re-checked at the 2026-09-24 review against the refreshed pack (S21): the rating split and the surprise history are unchanged.
  • ARMKAramarkUnchanged

    Aramark's Nexus unit will run a Texas data-centre workers' camp

    An unnamed workforce housing company picked Aramark's Nexus unit to run dining, cleaning, fitness and leisure for up to 4,000 trade workers at a new AI data-centre site in Texas. No sales figure, contract length or start date was given. It may be a Texas site of the same size that Aramark already counted at about $160 million a year.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. Our view turns on Nexus growing past the three sites Aramark has sized at $400 million to $500 million of yearly sales, with each new site signed, sized and dated. This one is signed but not sized or dated, so it cannot count yet.

    Checked against 3 claims - none changed
    • C23UnchangedIn November 2026 Aramark described two hyperscaler Nexus sites operating or mobilising, and a workforce-housing site and a colocation engagement expected to progress in the second half of fiscal 2027.
    • C21UnchangedAramark's chief executive said Nexus is planned at about $500M of revenue realised in fiscal 2027 from operations already under contract, driven by the two hyperscaler sites.
    • C32UnchangedAramark's first two Nexus sites are in Texas and the colocation engagement covers locations including Wyoming and Texas.
  • AMZNAmazon.comUnchanged

    Amazon sells pound bonds, and the FTC sues over ad-auction pricing

    Amazon borrowed £4.25 billion through its first bonds in British pounds, paying 5.2% to 6.65% a year. The Federal Trade Commission, a US regulator, and 22 states sued, saying Amazon secretly raised prices in its ad auctions since 2019, so advertisers paid their full bid about 80% of the time in 2024. Qualcomm said it will work with Amazon on custom AI chips; no terms were given.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. More borrowing was expected, and the lawsuit names no amount and hits advertising, not the cloud business, AWS, where most profit is made. Our view rests on cloud growth, signed cloud contracts and whether spare cash stops falling, which only the 29 October results will show.

    Checked against 4 claims - none changed
    • C32UnchangedManagement said in the same quarter that it expects to keep going: 'We expect to undertake additional financing activities in 2026', and on the call answered a question about funding sources with 'You've seen us issue debt this year. We have a lot of options available to us... nothing to share today.'
    • C30UnchangedThe funding has moved to the credit markets. Proceeds from short-term and long-term debt were $82.4 billion in the first half of 2026 against $4.7 billion in the first half of 2025, and long-term debt on the balance sheet rose from $65,648 million to $128,894 million over the six months.
    • C36UnchangedAdvertising is the quiet third engine: $19,809 million of revenue in Q2 2026, up 26% year over year, growing faster than the stores it sits inside and disclosed only in the supplemental table rather than as a segment.
    • C04UnchangedAmazon designs and operates its own processors. Graviton is the general-purpose CPU and Trainium the AI accelerator, and management states Graviton delivers up to 30% to 40% better price-performance than comparable instances and is used by 98% of the top 1,000 EC2 customers.

Monday 21 September6

  • METAMeta PlatformsUnchanged

    Meta's new AI app Muse tops the US App Store

    Muse, Meta's new standalone AI assistant app, reached number one on the US App Store within days of launch. Meta has given no figures for how many people use it, what it charges or what it earns. Separately, a German court ruled Meta liable for fake adverts on Instagram and Facebook; no damages figure was reported.

    What it did to the thesisNothing changed. Our case turns on whether Meta's $130 to $145 billion of heavy investment pays off, and Meta still reports no sales from it; a chart ranking is not sales. The German ruling has no amount, so it cannot be weighed. Still Attractive, Medium conviction.

  • LLYEli Lilly and CompanyThesis changed

    Lilly's breast cancer drug Inluriyo wins a second US approval

    US regulators fully approved Inluriyo, a Lilly breast cancer drug, for use with another Lilly drug, Verzenio, in advanced cancer carrying a particular gene change. It is Inluriyo's second approval in under a year. In the trial, the pair held the disease back for a typical 11.1 months, against 5.5 months for Inluriyo alone. Inluriyo sold $75 million last quarter, 0.3% of Lilly's $22,974 million.

    What it did to the thesisWe updated one line. We had said the fast growth of small new products like Inluriyo might not last; a second approval is a reason this one may. But one drug, tirzepatide, is still 64.7% of sales, so the view stays Neutral with Medium conviction.

    1 claim changed
    • C36EditedGrowth is broadening beyond the two big products: key products in immunology, oncology and neuroscience grew 121% in Q2 2026, with Ebglyss at $201 million, Kisunla $167 million, Jaypirca $192 million and Inluriyo $75 million.The second counter-evidence line said Inluriyo's growth was arithmetic rather than evidence of durability. A second FDA approval within a year, granted on a trial that doubled progression-free survival, is durability evidence, so the line now holds only for Kisunla.
  • JOEThe St. Joe CompanyThesis changed

    St. Joe plans 3,500 more homes at Latitude Margaritaville Watersound

    St. Joe announced plans for 3,500 more homes at Latitude Margaritaville Watersound, a community it builds with a partner. Its filings put that community at about 3,700 homes, with 2,359 lived in at 30 June 2026. A week earlier it announced a new weddings and events business. Neither announcement could be read beyond its title, so nothing is known about timing or cost.

    What it did to the thesisNo fact moved: a headline cannot replace a filed number. But one of our tests for changing our mind counted only a new venture, so it could never fire if this one simply grows; we rewrote it to count either. Still Unattractive, Medium conviction.

    What this review changed (2 edits)
    • Invalidation criterion 4 edited: it asked for a new joint venture replacing Latitude Margaritaville's profit on comparable capital, which cannot fire if the same venture is extended instead. It now reads 'a new or materially extended joint venture', so the criterion tests the economic question rather than one route to it.
    • review_log: a row for this review, with the grades held, the criterion defect named, and the reason no claim moved.
  • CPAYCorpayThesis changed

    Corpay and its chief executive will repay $100 million over hidden fees

    The Federal Trade Commission, a US regulator, accepted a deal under which Corpay and its chief executive, Ronald Clarke, pay $100 million back to business customers harmed by hidden fuel-card fees. The regulator's release, the only one we could read, adds that an appeals court upheld the 2023 ruling against the company on all counts, and that Clarke agreed not to fight a court order against him personally.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Neutral, confidence Medium. We updated the record because the settlement is no longer preliminary, and the chief executive being a named party is a fact about how the company is run. The money was already counted as a cost; the fees involved are about 3% of sales.

    2 claims changed
    • C43NewThe chief executive is a named party to the FTC matter, not only the company. Ronald Clarke is jointly liable for the $100M, a federal appeals court affirmed the judgment against him in 2026 on all but one count while vacating the injunction as to him, and he has agreed not to oppose its reimposition.The file held the settlement as a corporate matter and never that the chief executive is a named party affirmed against on appeal.
    • C21EditedThe FTC matter is settled in substance and not yet final. Corpay charged $100M in Q2 2026 for the settlement, the Commission voted 1-0-1 on 17 September 2026 to accept the consent agreement with the chairman recused, and the agreement now goes to the Federal Register for 30 days of public comment before the Commission decides whether to make the order final. The $100M is payable jointly by the company and its chief executive and is to provide redress to harmed business customers rather than as a penalty. The liability was decided before the settlement: a federal court entered summary judgment for the FTC on all counts in 2023, and in 2026 an appeals court upheld it on all counts and affirmed the permanent injunction against the company. Corpay remains subject to that injunction, which bars billing without express informed consent, hiding material information about a charge behind a hyperlink, and deceptive claims about its fuel cards.The claim described a preliminary settlement subject to Commission approval and the Commission has approved it. The regulator's own release also carries the 2026 appellate affirmance, the redress purpose and the remaining procedure, none of which the claim held.
      Was

      Corpay recorded a $100M charge in Q2 2026 for a preliminary settlement with the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection, subject to commission approval,…

  • APPAppLovinThesis changed

    A second shareholder lawsuit says AppLovin overstated its AI progress

    A second group of shareholders has sued AppLovin on behalf of anyone who bought its shares from 12 February to 5 August 2026. They claim the company overstated how steadily its AI models were improving and hid delays to a tool that makes video ads with AI. Nothing has been decided; a lawsuit is one side's account. An earlier, separate suit is about the accounting.

    What it did to the thesisThe view stays Attractive and confidence Medium. We rewrote the record to name two lawsuits, because this one challenges the weakest part of our case: that the second-quarter slowdown came from the timing of AppLovin's model releases, not weak demand. The 4 November results test that; a complaint does not.

    4 claims changed
    • C52NewA second securities class action was filed in September 2026, on different allegations from the first. It covers purchases between 12 February 2026 and 5 August 2026, sets a lead plaintiff deadline of 16 November 2026, and alleges that the generative video creative feature for AppLovin Ads faced significant development delays making release on the stated timeline unlikely, that the constancy of the AI model improvement was overstated, and that the 'virtuous cycle' and 'compounding' value the models were said to deliver was therefore overstated. These are allegations in a complaint, not findings, and nothing has been decided.A second class action was filed on allegations about the model-release cadence, which the ledger had no claim for.
    • C22EditedManagement attributes the sequential slowdown to timing in its own research output: the pace of meaningful model improvement was lighter than normal and the next step-up landed just after quarter end. On the Q3 call the chief executive said a new generation of larger models is in partial rollout and performing well, without committing to a full-rollout date.The counter-evidence held one outside account of the quarter. A second class action now alleges the opposite of what management said about the model cadence, which belongs beside it.
    • C42EditedTwo securities class actions are live and they allege different things. The first, the Brownback action, alleges materially false statements about the advertising solutions and the financial growth; its motion to dismiss was fully briefed in February 2026 and remained undecided at 5 August 2026. The second was filed in September 2026 on the model-improvement and generative creative statements, and is the subject of C52.The claim counted one class action. A second was filed in September 2026 on different allegations, so a claim naming one had become false.
      Was

      A securities class action alleging materially false statements about the advertising solutions and financial growth is live; the motion to dismiss wa…

    • C46EditedThe consumer platform's own gaps are stated by management: creative is the biggest hurdle, a high-quality long-form video advertisement cannot yet be generated out of the box, and mid-market rather than the long tail is where it works.A new complaint alleges the creative delay this claim records as a conceded hurdle was understated, which is the counter-account the field was missing.
  • AFRMAffirm HoldingsUnchanged

    Affirm now approves loans with a new AI model, with no numbers given

    Affirm says it now decides who gets a loan with a new kind of AI model. It gave no numbers - not how many people it approves, nor how many loans go bad - and the announcement itself could not be read beyond its headline. The first filing that must describe it is due on 5 November.

    What it did to the thesisNothing moved. How Affirm decides who to lend to is the heart of our case, but without results there is nothing to judge the new model by. The November results, which report how many loans go bad, are the first real test.

Sunday 20 September1

  • IESCIES HoldingsThesis changed

    The steel business IES is buying earned less than we had assumed

    The company selling DBM Global, a steel business IES is buying, published DBM's audited accounts. DBM earned $91.8 million of operating profit, profit from the business before interest and tax, over the year to 4 July 2026, not the $111 million we got by doubling one strong half-year. Its managers expect profit to fall in 2027. In an auction with 37 interested parties, IES raised its bid to $650 million.

    What it did to the thesisWe corrected our most flattering number: IES pays about 7.5 times DBM's yearly profit, not 6. That is still far cheaper than IES's own shares at 26 times, so the deal still adds to profit per share, and the view stays Unattractive with Medium conviction.

    10 claims changed
    • C18EditedDBM Global earned $56.8M of operating profit in its last audited year, down from $65.5M, and $91.8M over the trailing twelve months.corrected against DBM Global's audited accounts in INNOVATE's 3 September information statement: twelve-month operating profit is $91.8M, not the $111M annualised from a seasonally strong half
    • C19EditedCovenants on the seller's 10.5% secured notes compelled the sale of DBM: missing a dated bid milestone triggered it.the information statement's auction record shows the sale was compelled but not cheap: 37 parties under confidentiality and IES raised its own offer from $558M to $650M
    • C20EditedIES is paying about 7.5 times DBM's trailing operating profit while its own shares cost 18 times theirs.restated on the audited trailing figure: IES pays about 7.5 times DBM's operating profit, not about 6
    • C44NewDBM's own management forecasts cash profit falling from $129M in 2026 to $120M in 2027, on rising revenue.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series
    • C45NewThe sale ran as an auction: 37 parties signed confidentiality agreements and IES lifted its offer from $558M to $650M.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series
    • C46NewThe seller receives 430,974 IES shares after the split and says it expects to sell them once a 60-day lock-up ends.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series
    • C47NewHomebuilders passed their own buyer incentives back to IES as price cuts, which IES says reduced its revenue and margins.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series
    • C48NewThe largest US homebuilder subcontracts its trades and counts subcontractor availability among the factors deciding where it builds.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series
    • C49NewThe shares have fallen a fifth or more nine times in five years and regained every completed fall.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series
    • C50NewOf the 80.1% the shares gained in a year, revenue per share supplied 22.8% and the rest was re-rating.added in the 2026-09-20 news review, from INNOVATE's definitive information statement and the price series