Elk Creek holds niobium, a metal that strengthens steel, plus scandium and rare earths. The United States mines no niobium; it would be the only American niobium mine.
The company · 2 · What exactly does it sell?
The plan's biggest line is scandium, not rare earths
Each $1 of planned revenue, 40-year study
38%26%25%10%
ScandiumNiobium for steelRare earthsTitanium
These are the company's own study's forecasts over 40 years; nothing has been sold yet.
The company · 3 · How does it make money?
No sales yet: it lives on its cash
$403.4Mcash, no borrowings
-$11.6Mcash used last quarter
$37.44Bplanned lifetime revenue in its study
A mine earns nothing until it is built. NioCorp must find a loan and buyers before it can build, and selling new shares to raise money would shrink each holder's slice.
Is it a good business? · 4 · What gives it an edge?
The advantage is geology
About 93%
of the world's niobium from Brazil
About $10.0M
Department of War award, 2025
Lockheed Martin
a memorandum, not a contract
A richer rival cannot build another sizeable niobium deposit in America.
Is it a good business? · 5 · What is the catch?
Scandium supply already exists
Rio TintoQuebec plant expanding to nine tonnes
October 2025Australia licensed a scandium mine
About 85%of niobium held by one Brazilian producer
Listed rivals: RIO · SCY.V
Aircraft makers can use titanium or carbon fibre instead of scandium alloys.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
A $37.44B study, mostly scandium
Scandium38.3%of planned lifetime revenue
Niobium26.1%of planned lifetime revenue
Rare earths25.1%five products together
By the study's own numbers it is less a rare-earth company than a scandium one. There are no sales yet to record.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
The study's scandium is 9.4 times today's market
About $38Mthe whole world's scandium use, 2025
60 tonnesof scandium oxide used
$358Ma year in the study's scandium line
Both niobium buyers are bound; for scandium, the study's largest line, nothing is binding.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
A long-serving chief and a missed start date
Since 2013Mark Smith running NioCorp
2025promised start date, passed
About 7%owned by insiders, mostly options
The bonus pays on milestones the board judges, and raising money counted as one.
The story right now · 9 · Why does China's export ban matter?
China's export limits made American metals prized
April 2025China limited scandium and rare-earth exports
3 to 4xprices outside China against inside
NioCorptrades with rare-earth shares
China added scandium and rare earths to its export controls in April 2025. Investors bought American miners that might replace it, and NioCorp's shares move with them.
The story right now · 10 · What is a mine worth before it exists?
Its value rests on three things not yet done
Find buyers for each metalNiobium is sold.
Borrow to buildNo loan signed.
Prove the priceScandium's comes from one forecaster.
Then build and sellYears away.
Until those happen, the shares are worth little beyond the cash. Raising money with new shares would shrink each holder's slice.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
$403.4M of cash and nothing new signed
$403.4Mcash, no borrowings
-$11.6Mcash used in the quarter
15 yearsTraxys bound for half the niobium
$1,967 → $3,250the forecaster's scandium price per kilogram
Solid quarter
Cash is burning at the planned pace, and no scandium buyer or loan has appeared.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
Will anyone buy the scandium?
Many investors think
A rare-earth play riding China's export controls
We think
Scandium is 38.3% of the study, in a $38M market
The scandium price behind the study comes from one forecaster's revision. We are wrong if a scandium buyer signs a stated volume near the study's price.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
No single value here: it is priced as a bet
No upsidethe evidence defends inside three years
48%kept if it fails
Multiples of the company's value when the bet was last struck, 30 Sep 2026.
We put no single value on a share here, because the business does not yet earn a lasting profit. Instead we ask what the shares pay if the plan works, and what is left if it fails.
The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?
Scandium demand, the process and more shares
Scandium demand may not comeBiggest
The study needs 9.4 times today's market.
More shares to comeWatch
Funding the build could double the count.
A cost that keeps risingShowing now
Upfront cost up 62% since 2022.
Whether the forecast holdsUnknown
It rests on fuel cells for AI.
It applied for up to $800M from the US Export-Import Bank in 2023 and has no commitment.
The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?
A scandium buyer or a loan decides it
A scandium buyer near the study's priceGood sign
A binding loan to build Elk Creek by the end of 2028We turn positive
Scandium priced well below $3,250 a kilogramWe turn negative
FEB 20275
Quarterly report, 5 February. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view moves on these business events, not on a price line, since we put no single value on a share here.
The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?
An unbuilt mine whose biggest line is scandium
Priced for successthe kind of bet this is
NeutralMedium conviction
NioCorp has cash and a Nebraska mine that has never been built: no sales and no loan to build it. The price is little beyond its cash, and we think that discount is right. Neutral.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
NioCorp has no sales. Its only business is developing Elk Creek, a deposit in south-east Nebraska, and it needs more money to build it.
The deposit holds niobium, a metal that strengthens steel. The United States mines none, and Brazil produces about 93% of the world's; the government's geologists say Elk Creek would be the only American niobium mine. The plan also recovers scandium and rare earths. The rare earths now count toward the mine's proven reserves, but recovering them has been tested only in small trial plants.
How it makes money
Nothing yet. If built, the mine would sell eight products for 40 years. The study puts lifetime revenue at $37.44B: scandium 38.3%, niobium 26.1%, five rare-earth products 25.1% and titanium 10.5%. By its own numbers this is less a rare-earth company than a scandium one.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
With no sales yet, growth here means paying to get the mine ready: studies, drilling and a bigger head office, all of which rose sharply last year while interest on the cash offset part of it. The real cost is building the mine, which has not been paid for.
Why it wins
The evidence
The advantage is geology. Elk Creek is the only niobium deposit of consequence in a country that holds 210,000 tonnes of reserves and mines none, and a richer rival cannot build another.
Outsiders pick the deposit by name: the Department of War awarded about $10.0M to the project in August 2025, the government's geologists name the site, and Lockheed Martin signed a memorandum with a mine that does not yet exist.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
Scandium supply already exists. Rio Tinto's Quebec plant makes all of North America's from waste streams, and Canada is paying to expand it to nine tonnes a year. Australia licensed a scandium mine in October 2025, and aircraft makers can use titanium or carbon fibre instead. In niobium, the Brazilian producer holds about 85% of the world's supply and could push the price down.
Each rival
Rio Tinto's Sorel-Tracy scandium oxide plant, QuebecRIO
A North American buyer of scandium oxide takes it from Quebec titanium-dioxide waste streams instead of from a Nebraska mine - including the United States National Defense Stockpile, which USGS says planned to buy over 6,000 kilograms from Sorel-Tracy over five years.
The Nyngan scandium project, New South WalesSCY.V
A Western buyer signs primary scandium supply from outside China in Australia rather than in Nebraska.
Titanium and aluminium high-strength alloys, and carbon-fibre materialsnot listed
The aerospace buyer stops putting scandium in the alloy at all. USGS names these three as substitutes in high-performance scandium-alloy applications, and they are in production aircraft today.
Companhia Brasileira de Metalurgia e Mineracaoprivate
The steelmaker keeps buying ferroniobium from Brazil, which the company's own annual report says supplies about 85% of the world's niobium and which USGS puts at 93% of world production.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
The whole world used 60 tonnes of scandium oxide in 2025, at about $640 a kilogram: roughly $38M in all. Production was about 80 tonnes, with capacity for over 90.
The study's scandium line alone averages $358M a year, about 9.4 times that whole market. The largest Western producer, Rio Tinto, is expanding to nine tonnes a year.
Who has signed
Both niobium buyers are now bound: Traxys signed a 15-year agreement on 13 October for 50% of the mine's ferroniobium, the alloy it sells niobium as, and ThyssenKrupp covers the rest. For scandium, the study's largest line, nothing is binding: Traxys may buy it but need not, and Lockheed Martin's memorandum is not a contract.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
Chief executive Smith has run NioCorp since 2013, and the 2025 start date its 2022 study promised passed with only the mine's entrance begun. Insiders own about 7%, mostly options rather than shares. The bonus pays on milestones the board judges, and raising money counted as one; long-term pay is options, with nothing tied to how many new shares are sold.
What they did with the money
Share sales left about 2.5 times as many shares as a year earlier. Management also spent $8.4M buying FEA Materials, a maker of scandium-aluminium alloy, which gives its own scandium a buyer, and adopted a plan that makes a hostile takeover harder.
The last report
The latest report
NioCorp ended September with $403.4M of cash; nothing new was signed
What it did to the thesis Solid quarter
It changed nothing in the argument. Cash is burning at the planned pace and no scandium buyer or loan has appeared, so the small bet in the price still looks about right.
The report
There are still no sales. In the quarter to 30 September 2026 cash fell $11.6M to $403.4M, with no borrowings and no new shares sold: the count was 146.5M on 5 November, under 1% more.
The mine's entrance has now used about $12M of its $44.6M budget. The Export-Import Bank loan application is at the same stage, and the only agreement signed since quarter-end is the October one that binds a buyer for half the niobium.
What's happening now
The background
The annual report arrived on 25 September with the signed engineering report behind the study. It matches the August release, and it names OnG Commodities as the outside forecaster behind the scandium price. That forecaster raised its price for NioCorp from about $1,967 a kilogram to $3,250 in ten months.
On 13 October Traxys signed a binding 15-year agreement for half the ferroniobium. The next test is whether anything else becomes binding: a scandium buyer, or a loan to build the mine.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
A rare-earth play riding China's export controls, with government money behind it.
We believe
The discount is right and the label is wrong. Scandium is 38.3% of the study; its whole world market is about $38M.
The argument
The shares move closely with the rare-earth stocks, and both analysts who cover them rate them a buy. But the scandium price that carries the study comes from one forecaster's revision this year, and the government's own geologists measure the scandium market at $640 a kilogram.
We would be wrong if a scandium buyer signs a stated volume near the study's price, or world use grows well beyond 60 tonnes.
What it's worth
How we value it
No fair value: the analysts' forecasts show no lasting operating profit after stock pay, so a value built on earnings would rest on a guess; the bet prices it instead.
The bet
This is not a bet that can pay inside two to three years. The mine cannot be built until the debt is raised, and building it takes about three years after that, so no sales arrive within the window we judge.
If it fails, shareholders keep a company with plenty of cash and no debt, though the cash shrinks each year and building the mine would need many new shares.
The bet
Seen as a bet
This is not a bet that can pay inside two to three years. The mine cannot be built until the debt is raised, and building it takes about three years after that, so no sales arrive within the window we judge.
If it fails, shareholders keep a company with plenty of cash and no debt, though the cash shrinks each year and building the mine would need many new shares.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
Scandium demand may not come
The study's largest line needs about 9.4 times today's whole market, and the company lists the durability of AI-driven demand among its own risks.
An unproven rare-earth process
Rare earths are a quarter of the study's revenue and now count as reserves, but commercial recovery has not been proved.
More shares to come
Funding 35% of the $1.85B cost with shares at today's price would issue about 230M, more than doubling the count.
No loan yet
It applied for up to $800M from the Export-Import Bank in 2023 and has no commitment for any of the debt.
A cost that keeps rising
The upfront cost rose 62% between the 2022 study and the 2026 one.
What we still do not know
Whether the scandium forecast holds. It rests on fuel cells for AI data centres, and the forecaster says a downturn there would cut it sharply.
Where the mine's costs sit against Brazil's producer, which publishes nothing to compare them with.
Whether Lockheed Martin's memorandum, or any other scandium buyer, becomes a binding contract now that Traxys holds only a right to buy.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
→ Attractive
A binding loan to build Elk Creek is signed by the end of 2028. Scandium buyers sign volume near the study's price, and world use grows well beyond the 60 tonnes of 2025.
→ Unattractive
A fuller study, or the forecaster's next update, prices scandium well below $3,250 a kilogram. Full-scale processing fails to match the pilot plant's rare-earth recoveries.
The next test
It supports the case if
A scandium buyer commits to a stated volume at a price near $3,250 a kilogram, EXIM's review reaches a board decision, or construction debt is committed.
It pressures the case if
Scandium is still without a binding buyer and EXIM is at the same stage, or the company sells shares before any debt is committed.
We would also be wrong if
No binding loan for construction is signed by the end of 2028.
Scandium buyers sign only at prices far below the study's.
World scandium use stays near 60 tonnes through 2028.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growthnot scored
Business quality
2 of 4
Financial position
2 of 4
Execution record
2 of 4
Per share capture
1 of 4
Potential
2 of 4
Risk profile
2 of 4
Valuation
3 of 4
Evidence quality
3 of 4
How we weighed it
ValueMixed
No fair value is drawn: the forecasts show no lasting profit after stock pay, so the bet prices it. The price is now close to the cash, which is being spent.
BusinessNegative
A weak business: no sales, no loan, and a mine never built.
GrowthMixed
Growth cannot be measured until the mine is funded and built.
RisksNegative
The study needs scandium demand far beyond today's market, the rare-earth process is unproven, new shares may fund most of it and no loan is signed.
RivalsMixed
No filed rival compares directly, so the price is judged on its own.
The groupMixed
It sits in none of our ranked groups; critical-mineral policy moves it.
Latest newsMixed
The last report changed nothing: cash burns at plan, and no buyer or loan appeared.
In plain words
Selling new shares
A company can raise money by creating new shares and selling them. The company gets cash, but the same business is now divided into more slices, so each existing share owns a little less of it. This is called dilution.