Palomar is the earthquake insurer
for Californian homes
casualty, property, crop, fronting too
where it writes cover
Palomar prices each Californian home by its soil and distance to a fault, and writes other insurance across all 50 states.
Earthquake is now under a third
Growth has moved from earthquake to crop, casualty and other newer lines.
Premiums in, claims out, profit on the gap
An insurer earns when premiums exceed claims and costs, and on investing the money in between.
It sits inside other insurers' sales
insurers offer its earthquake cover
one agency, a fifth of sales
private share of earthquake policies, 2020 to 2025
A homeowner who bought the cover with a policy rarely shops it separately.
A state pool and larger specialists
Listed rivals: KNSL · CB · AFG
In crop, every approved provider sells a policy priced by the government, so no one wins on price.
Fast premium growth, steady profit
Lower overhead per premium dollar was offset by heavier losses in crop and casualty.
The earthquake market is not converting
Take-up has fallen from 13.77% in 2020, so the market is shrinking.
The founder still runs it
Under them it beat its own forecasts for years.
Fewer Californians buy earthquake cover
Palomar was built on earthquake cover, but fewer homeowners buy it each year. So growth now comes from lines where claims eat more of each premium.
Casualty claims arrive years later
- Sell casualty coverPremium arrives now.
- Set aside a guessFor future claims.
- Claims arrive laterYears later.
- Guess too lowProfit is cut later.
Casualty claims costing less than reserved would prove us wrong.
Returns hit 26.6% in a quiet quarter
Strong quarter
Disasters cost very little this quarter, which flatters the return.
A proven compounder, or a changed one?
A proven compounder with fifteen straight beats
Earthquake stalled; growth moved to weaker lines
The state regulator's own data shows earthquake take-up falling since 2020.
The price sits between our value and our best case
below $97.16
above $146
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We value Palomar on what it earns on its net worth over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
As a bet on crop insurance, it is fragile
Multiples of the company's value when the bet was last struck, 6 Sep 2026.
The price already pays for crop working, and about three-fifths is kept if it never earns.
Reserves nobody has tested
Casualty estimates.
Crop and casualty.
A third of sales.
Not reported.
Losses in crop and casualty are already heavier, and claims are expected to keep rising for two years.
February tests claims and reserves
Fourth-quarter 2026 results, 25 February. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares fall to within a fifth of our estimate, we move to Neutral.
The earthquake insurer whose earthquake business stalled
below $97.16
above $146
UnattractiveMedium conviction
Palomar sells earthquake cover to Californian homeowners. But earthquake has stopped growing, growth moved to thinner lines, casualty reserves are untested estimates, and the price sits about a third above our value.