St. Joe owns much of Florida's Gulf coast and turns small pieces of it into homesites, hotels and shops.
The company · 2 · What exactly does it sell?
Hotels are now the biggest piece
Each $1 of sales, 2025
43%32%23%2%
Hotels and clubsHomesitesShops and officesOther
Homesites are sold once; hotels and rents recur.
The company · 3 · How does it make money?
It turns raw land into finished homesites
About $137,000per homesite, 2025
23,904homesites planned
2,013mapped into lots or being built
St. Joe does the permits, roads and utilities and sells finished homesites to builders and buyers.
Is it a good business? · 4 · What gives it an edge?
A state-approved plan lets it skip reviews
110,500 acres
in a state master plan that skips a regional review
170,000
homes its land may build
911 of 4,471
its homesites against new homes allowed locally, 2025
The land is the advantage, but it only pays as fast as homes are sold.
Is it a good business? · 5 · What is the catch?
Lot developers compete on scale and terms
Forestar14,240 lots sold nationally
Millroselets builders take lots on option
Panama Citywhere Forestar also sells
Listed rivals: FOR · MRP
Neither offers the club, golf and coast St. Joe sells beside the lot.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
Sales doubled; profit rose with land prices
Sales, $M
267.0
252.3
389.3
402.7
513.2
542.9
Dec 2021Dec 2022Dec 2023Dec 2024Dec 2025last 12 mo
Sales$267M → $543Mrevenue, 2021 to the past year
Profit24% → 32%operating profit per $1, since 2022
Prices+27%homesite price rise in 2025
The 2025 gain in profit came from higher homesite prices, not from selling more.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
A small, shrinking local market
4,471new homes allowed in its counties, 2025
16.5%fewer than the year before
About $612Ma year of lots if each needed one
St. Joe sold 911 homesites in 2025, 912 in 2024 and 1,063 in 2023: flat in a shrinking market.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
A long-serving team and one big outside owner
2015Jorge Gonzalez became chief executive
Under 1%owned by directors and officers
Bruce Berkowitzthe big outside owner
A large holder selling is a risk to the price.
The story right now · 9 · Why is this land valuable?
Coastal land near growing towns is scarce
170,000homes its land may build
−16.5%new homes allowed locally
3,500more homes filed for the venture
St. Joe owns coastal land nobody else can offer, with rights for 170,000 homes. But the number of new homes allowed in its counties has started to shrink.
The story right now · 10 · Why isn't all that land worth more?
Land pays only as fast as it sells
Huge land with rights170,000 homes.
About 911 sold a yearFlat for two years.
Current plan takes 26 yearsTo finish.
Money far in the futureIs worth less today.
The price is about double what the current plan would earn, paying for land with no plan yet.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
Fewer homesites, profit lifted by a land sale
80homesites sold, against 189
$61.5Moperating profit, up 16%
$50.4Mland sold to its own venture
67homes closed by the venture
Weak quarter
The quarter's profit leaned on selling land to its own venture, paid as homes sell, not on homesites.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
An operating company, or land?
Many investors think
An operating company, with the extra land free
We think
The land is irreplaceable but selling too slowly
We are wrong if homesite sales break above 1,200 a year as new communities open.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
The price sits above even our sunny case
$32.68what we think a share is worth · the last close is of that
$32.68our value
Attractive below $26.14
Neutral
Unattractive above $39.22
$13.91gloomy: growth halves, less kept per $1
$32.68our estimate: experts' path, then slowing
$49.96sunny: growth beats the forecast by a quarter
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?
Flat sales in a shrinking market
Flat salesBiggest
The market is shrinking.
Profit partly an estimateShowing now
Land sold to its venture.
A large holder sellsWatch
Could weigh on shares.
Second phase's paceUnknown
How fast homes sell.
Most profit is land sold once, so a slow selling year shows up quickly.
The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?
February tests homesite sales
Homesite sales above 1,200 a yearWe turn neutral
The venture's second phase closing homesGood sign
Homesite sales fall againBad sign
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares fall to within a fifth of our estimate, we move to Neutral.
The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?
Irreplaceable land, priced for acres without a plan
$32.68our value
Attractive below $26.14
Neutral
Unattractive above $39.22
UnattractiveHigh conviction
St. Joe owns much of Florida's Gulf coast and turns small pieces into homesites, hotels and shops. But most profit is land sold once, homesite sales have been flat for two years and the local market is shrinking.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
A homebuilder needs a finished lot: a legal parcel with roads, water, sewer and drainage already in. Getting raw land there takes permits, engineering and utilities, and a year or two in which the money earns nothing. St. Joe does that work and sells the finished homesite, at about $137,000 in 2025.
It has 23,904 homesites planned, but only 2,013 are mapped into legal lots or being built; 18,391 exist only as a concept plan.
How it makes money
Selling homesites and land, plus its share of a homebuilding joint venture, made $147.4M of the $165.8M of pre-tax profit in the year to June. The hotels, club, shops and offices made the other $18.4M after their own costs.
So the business is mostly selling its land, once. The hotels and club brought in $215.4M of revenue in 2025, but after depreciation, overheads and interest the recurring side adds little.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
Growing costs St. Joe little in overhead, but growth does not make it much more profitable by itself. Hotel costs rise with hotel sales, and the recent jump in profit came mostly from charging more for each homesite rather than from getting bigger.
Its record
The numbers
Is it growing?Steady
Sales grew 11% over the twelve months to Sep 2026, slower than the 27% in the year to Dec 2025.
Is it profitable?Strong
Operating margin is 32%, up from 23% in the year to Dec 2023.
Does growth pay off?Flat
Running costs take 14¢ of each sales dollar, down from 18¢ in the year to Dec 2022.
Does it earn good returns?Decent
Each dollar put into the business earns 11% a year after tax, about where it was (9.2%) in the year to Dec 2021.
Is it making cash?Strong
It turned 34% of sales into free cash, $184M over the last twelve months.
Is the balance sheet safe?Light debt
It owes $244M more than the cash it holds, about 1.3 years of the cash its operations bring in.
Are shares being diluted?Stable
The share count fell 3.6% in 4.8 years, and pay in shares costs 0.2% of sales.
Why it wins
The evidence
Most of its land sits inside a long-term master plan approved under Florida law, which lets each new community skip a regional review every other developer must pass. Its land carries rights to build over 170,000 homes, and a rival would need thousands of neighbouring acres in counties where St. Joe is the main owner.
It shows: in 2025 St. Joe sold 911 homesites while its two counties authorised 4,471 new homes, roughly one in five.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
Forestar develops lots the same way at national scale, sold 14,240 in its 2025 fiscal year at an average $108,400, and lists Panama City among its markets. Millrose lets builders take homesites on option instead of buying them. Neither offers the club, golf and hotels already built around a St. Joe lot.
Each rival
Forestar Group (NYSE: FOR)FOR
The homebuilder stops buying a St. Joe finished lot and buys a Forestar-developed lot in the same metropolitan area - Forestar's own annual report lists Panama City, Pensacola and Tallahassee among its markets.
Millrose Properties (NYSE: MRP)MRP
The builder stops buying a finished lot outright and instead options homesites from a financing platform that funds the development and hands them over on a takedown schedule, so no lot purchase from a developer happens at all.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
The market is new homes in its two counties. They authorised 4,471 in 2025, down 16.5% and the lowest since 2019. At St. Joe's own price of about $137,000, that is about $612M a year of lots if every new home needed one.
St. Joe sold 911 homesites in 2025, 912 in 2024 and 1,063 in 2023: flat, in a local market that is shrinking.
Who has signed
Builders had 1,104 homesites under contract at June for about $109.2M, against 1,209 a year earlier, leaving aside two long-dated bulk deals. The joint venture with Minto is 64% built: 2,359 of about 3,700 homes occupied.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
Jorge Gonzalez has run St. Joe since 2015 and chairs the board; Marek Bakun has been finance chief since 2013. The directors and officers together own under 1%. The big owner is Bruce Berkowitz, an outside investor with about a third of the shares, who has been selling. Bonuses are set by the board's judgement, with no formula, and the stock awards vest with time, not with results.
What they did with the money
It has bought back 37.8% of its shares since 2015, leaving the fewest since 1997. Operating cash rose in the first half, but almost entirely because it spent less on land to sell.
The last report
The latest report
St. Joe sold 80 homesites against 189, while its venture grew by 3,500 homes
What it did to the thesis Weak quarter
The venture's extension is real and filed, but it adds years of runway and no profit yet, and one quarter's profit leaned on selling land to it. Homesite sales fell and the estimates went quiet, so the view stays Unattractive.
The report
The September quarter sold 80 homesites against 189 a year earlier, and the Latitude Margaritaville venture closed 67 homes against 82. Operating profit still rose 16% to $61.5M, because St. Joe sold more land to the venture for $50.4M, paid as its homes sell.
That sale carries the venture's plan from about 3,700 homes to about 7,200 and booked a $31.4M gain at present value, $10.9M of it net after the venture's share. The estimated house-price top-ups that lifted the first half added only about $1.3M, the same as a year ago.
What's happening now
The background
The 3,500-home plan is now filed: in September St. Joe sold the venture the land for $50.4M, paid as each home sells, and the planned community is about 7,200 homes. What is still missing is the pace: the venture closed 67 homes in the quarter.
The next check is the full-year report in late February: whether 2026 homesite sales end above 911, and whether the second phase has started to close homes.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
Reported growth proves St. Joe is an operating company now, and the land beyond the plan comes free.
We believe
The land is irreplaceable, but it is not being sold fast enough: 911 homesites a year is 26 years of the current plan.
The argument
The company tells the market's story itself: it says it is not just a land bank, and leads its presentation with a 237% rise in homesites under contract.
Nobody publishes the split between land sales and recurring profit, and that is where we differ. We are wrong if homesite sales break above 1,200 a year as the new communities open, and recurring profit keeps roughly doubling.
What it's worth
How we value it
Valued on the analysts' revenue path for three years, each later year closing 30% of the gap to 4%, on official operating profit with stock pay a cost and tax paid in full; the thesis's own evidence is the check on that path.
What the price assumes
Sales growth in the first year, then slowing as ours does, at the same profit per sale.
The price assumed
26.5%
Our estimate
-25%
Measured at the close of
6 Nov 2026
The three cases
Bear case$13.91
Growth runs at half the analysts' path, -38% and 6%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 25.6%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.
Our value$32.68
Revenue grows -25% and 11% over three years, the analysts' path (C49), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin moves to 32.0%, the analysts' year-three figure after stock pay.
Bull case$49.96
Growth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, -12% and 14%, the margin reaches 35.2%, and new capital earns 15%.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
Flat sales, shrinking market
Homesite sales have held near 911 for two years while new-home permits in its two counties fell 16.5% in 2025.
Profit that is partly an estimate
$14.6M of future house-price sharing was booked in the first half and $5.3M collected.
Its best earner is 64% built
The joint venture has made over a fifth of pre-tax profit every year since 2023, and its home sales halved in the first half of 2026.
A large holder selling
The 36.2% shareholder sold 27 times in a year, into the company's own buyback.
What we still do not know
How fast the second phase's 3,500 homes sell, and whether the venture's profit per home matches the first phase's.
Whether the two new communities opening in early 2027 lift homesite sales above the 911 a year they have held.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
→ Neutral
The share price falls to about $39.22, back within 20% of what we think the business is worth.
→ Attractive
The share price falls to about $26.14, 80% of what we think the business is worth.
→ Attractive
The hotels, club, shops and offices earn more than $60M a year before tax, so more of the value is a business. Homesite sales top 1,200 a year for two years running, with revenue per homesite still rising more than 20% a year.
Research reopens
New-home permits in its two counties return above 5,300 a year. A new joint venture, or a real extension of the existing one, earns what Latitude Margaritaville does on a similarly small investment.
The next test
It supports the case if
Full-year homesite volume at or below 911 and venture home sales below 130 in the fourth quarter, with residual revenue recognised back at its historical pace of about $1M a quarter.
It pressures the case if
Full-year homesite volume well above 911, venture home sales above 130 in the quarter, or the second phase starting to close homes and earn at least what the first phase did.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growth
3 of 4
Business quality
3 of 4
Financial position
3 of 4
Execution record
3 of 4
Per share capture
4 of 4
Potential
2 of 4
Risk profile
2 of 4
Valuation
1 of 4
Evidence quality
3 of 4
How we weighed it
ValueNegative
The price sits above our value and above the bull case.
BusinessMixed
A solid landowner, but much of its profit is land sold once.
GrowthNegative
Homesite sales are flat while new-home permits shrink.
RisksNegative
Sales are flat, part of profit is an estimate and its best earner is mostly built out.
RivalsMixed
No filed rival compares directly; its profit is not the recurring kind.
The groupMixed
It sits in none of our ranked groups; Florida housing moves it.
Latest newsNegative
The last report leaned on a land sale and homesite sales fell.
In plain words
Our estimate of value
We forecast how much cash the business can earn over the next ten years and beyond, then ask what that stream is worth today to an investor who wants an 8% yearly return. We do it three times: a gloomy future, an expected one and a sunny one. We call a share Attractive only when its price is at least 20% below the expected estimate, and Unattractive when it is 20% above.