FICO is the maker of the credit score
judges most US borrowers
run it and pay per score
for lenders' decisions
FICO writes the formula; the three credit bureaus run it on each borrower's file and pay FICO per score. Scores are about two-thirds of revenue, software the rest.
Scores sold to lenders are most of it
Each score costs FICO almost nothing extra, so price rises flow almost straight to profit.
A fee each time a lender pulls a score
Lenders pay for a score at each application, through the bureaus that hold the files.
Lenders came back because they had to
required FICO on every loan they bought
mortgage revenue after price rises
lenders allowed to use a rival score
FICO's own annual report warned that a second approved score was a risk; that risk has arrived.
A rival owned by its own distributors
Listed rivals: TRU · EFX · EXPN.L · PEGA · NICE
The three bureaus that distribute FICO's score own the rival.
Price rises lifted profit to half of sales
The cause is price, not scale: score price rises reached revenue with almost no cost.
A billion-dollar market, or a tenth of it
The same score pulls are worth about a tenth as much if the rival's price sets the market.
A long-serving chief executive
FICO spent heavily buying back its own shares at high prices.
Mortgage buyers' rules set FICO's power
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac buy most US mortgages and once accepted only FICO's score. Their regulator now lets lenders use VantageScore instead.
A required product can charge more than an optional one
- Only FICO acceptedLenders must buy it.
- FICO raises prices$4.95 to $10.
- A rival is approvedAt 99 cents.
- Prices come under pressureFrom 2027.
Lenders wanting the better of two scores must buy both for a while, so volume holds, but $10 is hard to defend.
Record revenue, but no 2027 forecast
Mixed quarter
FICO gave no 2027 forecast and is moving to custom mortgage prices per lender, with deals not yet final; February brings the next hard evidence.
Will lenders keep paying $10?
The mortgage business is broken
Lenders keep buying, but $10 will not survive
We are wrong if 2027 mortgage score prices stay near $10.
The price sits about a fifth above our value
below $488
above $702
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
Lenders may stop buying FICO
A rival at 99 cents.
Tested on 31 December.
The bureaus sell both.
Not yet decided.
The regulator decides the rules, and FICO bought back shares at high prices.
February shows the mortgage price
First-quarter fiscal 2027 results, 3 February. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares fall to about 15% above our estimate, we move to Neutral.
The mortgage score lenders no longer have to buy
below $488
above $702
UnattractiveLow conviction
FICO's score judges most US borrowers, and mortgage buyers once accepted only it, so FICO raised prices sharply. Now lenders may use a rival sold for under a dollar, and the price sits about a fifth above our value.