← All thesesFICOUnattractiveLow convictionWednesday 11 November 2026עברית

Fair Isaac

This is the archived full research. Read the story

The company behind the FICO score, the three-digit number most US lenders use to judge whether a borrower will pay them back.

Our viewUnattractive Low conviction
The scores
The profile · 1-4
Growth3/4 ↓

Revenue grew 26% in Q3 fiscal 2026, but almost all from doubling one price; software grew 2% and mortgage volumes low single digits.

Business quality3/4 ↓

The rule forcing lenders to buy FICO is gone, and a 99-cent rival its distributors own shares its grid; other lending still uses FICO.

Financial position2/4 ↓

Debt is about 3.9 times covenant earnings against a limit falling to 3.50 by 2028, when $2.4B also matures; a mortgage price cut breaches it.

Execution record3/4 →

Beat earnings estimates in 7 of 8 quarters and raised guidance twice, but borrowed to buy shares at about twice today's price.

Per share capture3/4 ↓

Diluted shares fell 7.6% in a year, far ahead of $188M of share pay, but $1.5B of it was borrowed at about $1,149 a share.

Potential2/4 ↓

The upside needs the agencies to accept FICO 10T, certify direct licensing and keep FICO's price, all decisions outside the company.

Risk profile2/4 ↓

About 70% of profit depends on one regulator's grid, still unpublished, and 63% of revenue flows through the rival score's owners.

Valuation2/4 ↓

About 17.3 times operating profit, 120% of a three-stage value near $610 at an 8% return: full, at the edge of the 20% margin.

Evidence quality3/4 →

Filings and the regulator back the core, but the mortgage split and prices are spoken on calls, and the grid deciding it is unpublished.

The Verdict

We rate FICO Unattractive, with low conviction. Its three-digit score is what most US lenders use to judge a borrower, and for decades the big mortgage buyers would accept only it, which let FICO raise its mortgage price sharply. Now the regulator lets lenders use a rival score sold for under a dollar, so the business is mixed. After a rise with no company news the price is about a fifth above our value, and nothing earns that premium while FICO no longer publishes its mortgage prices. Conviction is low because nobody knows how far those prices fall.

The long caseFICO rides no tide here: the mortgage regulator now lets lenders use a rival score, so the case needs most lenders to keep choosing FICO anyway.

How we weighed it

The price against our value

Against it

Price at 120% of our value

The price has risen to the edge of the line a fifth above our value, and the bear case sits far below it.

The business

Cuts both ways

Mixed

A strong franchise score whose pricing power the regulator has just weakened.

Growth against what the price assumes

Against it

The price assumes growth well above the analysts' path, while the value already needs mortgage prices that are not set and a rule not yet published.

What could go wrong

Against it

Lenders may send only the rival score, the bureaus that pay it own that rival, and its debt limit tightens.

Against competitors

Cuts both ways

No filed rival compares, since the bureaus are both customers and competitors.

How its group is behaving

Cuts both ways

Software names move together on fears about AI; its own fact is the regulator, not the group.

The latest news and report

Cuts both ways

The last report showed growth, but the mortgage quarter weakened and guidance was withheld.

Where this departs from the fair value

The price sits a hair inside the line a fifth above our value, but nothing on the other side earns even that premium: the mortgage price is unpublished, guidance was withheld, the rival is nearly free and the debt limit tightens.

What moved it from Neutral

The shares rose about four percent to the edge of the line a fifth above our value with no company news; asked whether anything earns that premium, none of the seven points leans in its favour, so the weaknesses decide.

The evidence under this - 10 claims
C05estimatemedium confidence
Mortgage origination scores were about $284.5M of Q3 FY2026 revenue, 42% of the company, and about $258M of segment operating income, equal to about 71% of consolidated operating income.
derived62% of Scores revenue of $458.9M is $284.5M, against total revenue of $674.2M. At the Scores segment margin of 90.8% that is $258M, 55% of $471.9M segment operating income and 71% of $362.6M consolidated operating income, before corporate costs are allocated.
against this
  • Mortgage scores may earn a different margin from the Scores average; the segment note gives one margin for all scores.
  • Comparing segment profit with consolidated profit overstates the share, since corporate costs and share pay of $109.3M sit outside the segments.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C06management claimmedium confidence
Management says FICO charged $4.95 per mortgage origination score in 2025, which the bureaus marked up to about $10; for 2026 it charges $10 per score into resellers, or $4.95 plus a fee on each funded loan.
against this

The $4.95 performance option depends on the direct licence program, which one GSE had still not certified at 2026-07-29, so the $10 price is what lenders actually pay.

current state · 2026-01-01written 2026-10-01
C08facthigh confidence
FHFA says Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required Classic FICO for decades; since 2026-09-09 every approved lender may use VantageScore 4.0 instead. Classic FICO stays approved with no retirement date, and FICO 10T is not yet accepted.
current state · 2026-09-09written 2026-10-01
C09factmedium confidence
On 2026-09-28 the FHFA director said Fannie and Freddie will price loans on one grid for Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0, removing the 20-point downward adjustment VantageScore carried; no effective date or grid was published.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C10facthigh confidence
TransUnion sells VantageScore 4.0 for $0.99 per standalone mortgage score through December 2028, free with a FICO purchase, and says over 1,100 mortgage lenders adopted it from January to September 2026.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C15inferencemedium confidence
On one grid with no adjustment, a lender can deliver an eligible Fannie or Freddie loan without buying a FICO score at all, so FICO's place in most of its mortgage revenue is now a choice rather than a rule.
derivedC08 (VantageScore open to all lenders, no FICO needed for eligible loans), C09 (one grid, no penalty), C10 (VantageScore at $0.99) and C11 (a top lender defaulting to it).
against this
  • Classic FICO is still required for manually underwritten GSE loans, and the FHFA FAQ keeps tri-merge reporting unchanged (C08).
  • Jumbo, portfolio and most FHA lending sit outside the GSE grid; FHA takes VantageScore only from 2027-01-01 (C10).
  • The grid is announced, not published (C09), and lenders choosing the better score must still pull both (C14).
current state · 2026-10-01written 2026-10-01
C29estimatehigh confidence
Enterprise value is about $20.7B: 21.55M diluted shares at $724.38 is $15.6B, plus $5.0B of net debt. That is 16.3 times fiscal 2026 operating income of $1,266M.
derivedC26 and the Q4 diluted share count (net income $175.0M over $8.12 a share), C28 price, C23 net debt and trailing operating income.
against this
  • Trailing income holds only two quarters at the $10 price, so 14.6 understates the run rate; it also holds two quarters a price cut would not reach.
  • The research pack's $14.2B market value uses a stale 24.0M share count; the filed 21.6M is used.
  1. 2026-11-04editedre-struck at $724.38 and fiscal 2026 operating income
current state · 2026-11-03written 2026-10-01
C47factmedium confidence
The credit agreement caps total leverage at 4.50 times EBITDA to 2026-12-30, 4.00 times through 2027-12-30 and 3.50 times after; its EBITDA adds back share pay, which puts FICO near 3.9 times today.
current state · 2026-06-30written 2026-10-01
C30factmedium confidence
The research pack puts the trailing multiple of enterprise value to earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation at 15.5, against a prior six-year median of 37.6, and the price-earnings ratio at 18.9 against 51.4.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
C60inferencemedium confidence
On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FICO is worth about $610 a share against $730.66 at the 10 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.53B grow 4%, 5% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 49.9% to 45.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.26B of debt net of $218M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 36.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $270, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.5% margin) about $826.
against this

The value leans on the analysts' path and margin, which this thesis has not tested name by name; at a 9% required return it is about $454, and the bear case of $270 is the downturn test.

  1. 2026-11-09editedgrowth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  2. 2026-11-10editedre-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
  3. 2026-11-11editedprice re-struck at the 10 November close of $730.66, about 120% of the unchanged base case
current state · 2026-11-10written 2026-11-09
01

The company

A lender deciding whether to trust a stranger with money wants one number that sums up their borrowing history. FICO writes the formula; the three credit bureaus, Experian, TransUnion and Equifax, run it on each person's file and sell the score to lenders, paying FICO a fee each time.

Scores are about two-thirds of revenue. The rest is software that helps banks decide whom to lend to and spot fraud.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C01facthigh confidence
FICO has two segments: Scores, the FICO credit score sold mostly through the three credit bureaus, was $458.9M of Q3 FY2026 revenue, 68%; Software, decision and fraud software for banks, was $215.3M.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C08facthigh confidence
FHFA says Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required Classic FICO for decades; since 2026-09-09 every approved lender may use VantageScore 4.0 instead. Classic FICO stays approved with no retirement date, and FICO 10T is not yet accepted.
current state · 2026-09-09written 2026-10-01
C13facthigh confidence
FICO's 10-K names the three bureaus and their joint venture VantageScore as its primary scoring competitors, and TransUnion's own 10-K says it competes with FICO and lists FICO's direct licence program as a risk.
  1. 2026-11-11editedre-read in the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November, which names the same competitors and adds VantageScore's increased regulatory acceptance in mortgages
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
C10facthigh confidence
TransUnion sells VantageScore 4.0 for $0.99 per standalone mortgage score through December 2028, free with a FICO purchase, and says over 1,100 mortgage lenders adopted it from January to September 2026.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01

How it makes money

FICO earns a fee every time a lender pulls a score. Mortgages pay most: a two-borrower mortgage pulls a score from each bureau for each borrower, six scores, and the fee is now $10 each. That made mortgage scores about 42% of revenue in Q3 fiscal 2026 and roughly 70% of profit, because a formula costs almost nothing to run again. The bureaus collect the fees and pass FICO its share: 63% of revenue arrives through them.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C01facthigh confidence
FICO has two segments: Scores, the FICO credit score sold mostly through the three credit bureaus, was $458.9M of Q3 FY2026 revenue, 68%; Software, decision and fraud software for banks, was $215.3M.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C04management claimmedium confidence
Management says mortgage origination scores were 62% of Scores revenue in Q3 FY2026 and up 97% on volumes up low single digits; 63% in Q2, up 127%; 42% in Q1.
against this
  • The 10-Q does not split B2B revenue by product, so the mortgage share is spoken on the call and never filed.
  • An analyst on the Q3 call said 127% growth in Q2 was hard to reach on a doubled price and market volume; the finance chief cited timing of bureau cut-offs.
historical · Q1 to Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C05estimatemedium confidence
Mortgage origination scores were about $284.5M of Q3 FY2026 revenue, 42% of the company, and about $258M of segment operating income, equal to about 71% of consolidated operating income.
derived62% of Scores revenue of $458.9M is $284.5M, against total revenue of $674.2M. At the Scores segment margin of 90.8% that is $258M, 55% of $471.9M segment operating income and 71% of $362.6M consolidated operating income, before corporate costs are allocated.
against this
  • Mortgage scores may earn a different margin from the Scores average; the segment note gives one margin for all scores.
  • Comparing segment profit with consolidated profit overstates the share, since corporate costs and share pay of $109.3M sit outside the segments.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C12facthigh confidence
Revenue from agreements with Experian, TransUnion and Equifax was 60% of FICO's fiscal 2026 revenue against 51% in fiscal 2025 and 45% in fiscal 2024, and 63% of Q3 FY2026 revenue; each was more than 10%.
  1. 2026-11-11editedre-sourced to the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November: the bureaus were 60% of the year's revenue, up from 51%
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
Where the money comes from, stream by stream
StreamShare of sales (Q3 FY2026)How it earns it
Business-to-business scores59.3%A royalty on each FICO score the credit bureaus sell to lenders; mortgage origination scores were about 71% of it.
Business-to-consumer scores8.7%Scores sold to consumers through myFICO and as royalties on scores the bureaus sell to consumers.
On-premises and SaaS software29.2%Decision, fraud and origination software for banks, licensed on premises or run as the FICO Platform service.
Professional services2.7%Implementation and consulting work alongside the software.

Who runs it

William Lansing has run FICO since 2012; Steven Weber, at the company since 2003, became finance chief in 2023. Insiders own about 3%, a little over half of it Lansing's. Their bonus and a third of their share awards ride on sales and earnings, which the mortgage price rises delivered; nothing rides on the debt they took on to buy back stock at about twice today's price.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C51facthigh confidence
William Lansing has been chief executive since January 2012; Steven Weber chief financial officer since May 2023, interim from January 2023, at FICO since 2003; Nikhil Behl president of Software since March 2025.
current state · 2025-09-30written 2026-10-04
C52facthigh confidence
At 2025-11-28 directors and executive officers as a group owned 719,282 shares, 3.02%; William Lansing 420,431, 1.77%, the largest insider; Vanguard reported 12.78% and BlackRock 8.60%.
against this

The share count has since fallen to 21.6M (C26), raising every percentage, while insiders sold 12,443 shares in the year with no purchases (C34).

current state · 2025-11-28written 2026-10-04
C53facthigh confidence
FICO's annual bonus pays half on adjusted revenue and half on adjusted EBITDA; long-term pay is equal thirds of one-year PSUs on the same two measures, MSUs on three-year return against the S&P 500, and RSUs. Fiscal 2025 paid 113.8% on the bonus and 150.2% on the PSUs; the first MSU period paid 0%.
against this

Revenue and EBITDA were met largely by the mortgage score price (C07), the lever the regulator has now opened to a rival; nothing pays on leverage, return on capital or per-share results, so the borrowed buyback (C24) costs the plan nothing.

historical · fiscal 2025written 2026-10-04
C24facthigh confidence
On 2026-06-05 FICO borrowed a $1.5B term loan and paid it to Wells Fargo for an accelerated buyback; nine-month repurchases reached $3,046M against $867M a year earlier.
historical · nine months to 2026-06-30written 2026-10-01
C25management claimhigh confidence
Management says it bought 1.705 million shares for $1.96B in Q3 FY2026 at an average $1,149, including the ASR; the shares closed at $592.47 on 2026-09-30.
against this

The 10-Q repurchase table shows $2.3B spent in the quarter, including $300M prepaid for shares not yet delivered, so the average will move at settlement; the 8-K's initial delivery implies about $1,137 to $1,422 a share.

historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
02

Why it wins, and who could beat it

Why customers come back

In mortgages, customers came back because they had to. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required a FICO score on every loan they bought, so lenders paid whatever FICO charged.

The proof is the price: FICO doubled its mortgage score from $4.95 to $10 for 2026, and mortgage revenue rose 97% while the number of scores grew only slightly. FICO's own annual report warned that a second approved score could do serious harm.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C08facthigh confidence
FHFA says Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required Classic FICO for decades; since 2026-09-09 every approved lender may use VantageScore 4.0 instead. Classic FICO stays approved with no retirement date, and FICO 10T is not yet accepted.
current state · 2026-09-09written 2026-10-01
C04management claimmedium confidence
Management says mortgage origination scores were 62% of Scores revenue in Q3 FY2026 and up 97% on volumes up low single digits; 63% in Q2, up 127%; 42% in Q1.
against this
  • The 10-Q does not split B2B revenue by product, so the mortgage share is spoken on the call and never filed.
  • An analyst on the Q3 call said 127% growth in Q2 was hard to reach on a doubled price and market volume; the finance chief cited timing of bureau cut-offs.
historical · Q1 to Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C06management claimmedium confidence
Management says FICO charged $4.95 per mortgage origination score in 2025, which the bureaus marked up to about $10; for 2026 it charges $10 per score into resellers, or $4.95 plus a fee on each funded loan.
against this

The $4.95 performance option depends on the direct licence program, which one GSE had still not certified at 2026-07-29, so the $10 price is what lenders actually pay.

current state · 2026-01-01written 2026-10-01
C07facthigh confidence
The 10-Q says Scores revenue rose $134.6M in Q3 FY2026 'primarily attributable to a higher mortgage origination scores unit price', lifting the Scores segment margin to 91% from 88%.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C38facthigh confidence
FICO's 10-K says other score models approved by Fannie and Freddie, or a choice of score, could have a material adverse effect, and that regulatory focus on closing costs may limit its mortgage price rises.
current state · 2025-11-07written 2026-10-01

The threat

The threat is VantageScore, a rival score owned by the same three bureaus that distribute FICO's. Since 9 September every lender may send it to Fannie and Freddie instead, and on 28 September the regulator said both scores would be priced on one grid, with no penalty for the rival.

TransUnion sells it for 99 cents. Rocket, among the biggest lenders, says it will make it the default this quarter.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C08facthigh confidence
FHFA says Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required Classic FICO for decades; since 2026-09-09 every approved lender may use VantageScore 4.0 instead. Classic FICO stays approved with no retirement date, and FICO 10T is not yet accepted.
current state · 2026-09-09written 2026-10-01
C09factmedium confidence
On 2026-09-28 the FHFA director said Fannie and Freddie will price loans on one grid for Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0, removing the 20-point downward adjustment VantageScore carried; no effective date or grid was published.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C10facthigh confidence
TransUnion sells VantageScore 4.0 for $0.99 per standalone mortgage score through December 2028, free with a FICO purchase, and says over 1,100 mortgage lenders adopted it from January to September 2026.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C11factmedium confidence
Rocket Mortgage said it will make VantageScore 4.0 its default for eligible Fannie and Freddie loans in the fourth quarter after testing 1.4 million credit reports; borrowers who saved through it saved an average $1,600 at closing.
current state · 2026-09-28written 2026-10-01
C13facthigh confidence
FICO's 10-K names the three bureaus and their joint venture VantageScore as its primary scoring competitors, and TransUnion's own 10-K says it competes with FICO and lists FICO's direct licence program as a risk.
  1. 2026-11-11editedre-read in the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November, which names the same competitors and adds VantageScore's increased regulatory acceptance in mortgages
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01

The rivals: TRU, EFX, TRU, EFX, PEGA, NICE, and 1 more that is private, in-house or listed abroad.

Who else does this, rival by rival
TickerRivalWhere it competesHow far alongPriced against it
TRU · EFXVantageScore 4.0 (the joint venture of TransUnion, Equifax and Experian)Priced against it: One segment onlyMortgage scoresOn saleOne segment only
VantageScore 4.0, sold by the same three bureausOther scoresOn sale
Not listedFHFA's bi-merge credit reporting, approved in 2022Priced against it: Not listedMortgage scoresAnnouncedNot listed
PEGA · NICEPegasystems, NICE Actimize and SASPriced against it: One segment onlySoftwareOn saleOne segment only
03

How big it could get

How big this could get

US lenders took about 9.9 million mortgage applications in 2023, by the consumer finance regulator's count. FICO's revenue suggests roughly 11 scores are bought for each one, about 114 million a year.

At $10 a score that is about $1.1B a year, close to what FICO now earns from mortgages. At the rival's 99 cents the same pulls are worth about a tenth as much, which is the range this market now sits in.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C35facthigh confidence
The CFPB counted about 3.2 million single-family home purchase loans and 796,000 refinances made in 2023, with applications down about 4.3 million, 30.3%, from 2022, about 9.9 million left.
historical · 2023written 2026-10-01
C36estimatelow confidence
At about $10 a score, Q3 FY2026 mortgage revenue of about $284.5M is roughly 28 million scores a quarter, about 114 million a year, or about 11 scores for each of the roughly 10 million applications the CFPB counts.
derivedC05 revenue divided by the $10 per-score price in C06; applications from C35 (4.3M is 30.3% of 2022's 14.2M, leaving 9.9M in 2023).
against this

Applications in 2026 differ from 2023's, some scores are bought at lower negotiated prices, and pre-qualification pulls are not applications, so the per-application figure is an order of magnitude.

current state · 2026-06-30written 2026-10-01
C06management claimmedium confidence
Management says FICO charged $4.95 per mortgage origination score in 2025, which the bureaus marked up to about $10; for 2026 it charges $10 per score into resellers, or $4.95 plus a fee on each funded loan.
against this

The $4.95 performance option depends on the direct licence program, which one GSE had still not certified at 2026-07-29, so the $10 price is what lenders actually pay.

current state · 2026-01-01written 2026-10-01
C10facthigh confidence
TransUnion sells VantageScore 4.0 for $0.99 per standalone mortgage score through December 2028, free with a FICO purchase, and says over 1,100 mortgage lenders adopted it from January to September 2026.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C05estimatemedium confidence
Mortgage origination scores were about $284.5M of Q3 FY2026 revenue, 42% of the company, and about $258M of segment operating income, equal to about 71% of consolidated operating income.
derived62% of Scores revenue of $458.9M is $284.5M, against total revenue of $674.2M. At the Scores segment margin of 90.8% that is $258M, 55% of $471.9M segment operating income and 71% of $362.6M consolidated operating income, before corporate costs are allocated.
against this
  • Mortgage scores may earn a different margin from the Scores average; the segment note gives one margin for all scores.
  • Comparing segment profit with consolidated profit overstates the share, since corporate costs and share pay of $109.3M sit outside the segments.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
Where the growth is coming from, business by business

Where the growth is coming from

BusinessShare of revenueGrowth: last quarterLast half-yearLast year
Mortgage scores63%+32.8%+37.2%+41.4%
Software37%+19.1%+10.1%+7.3%
Whole company100%+27.4%+26.5%+27.3%

The filed split through 2026-09-30. These rates are not carried forward: the reading below says why.

How we read it: The blend. The 50% row is all Scores, mortgage 62% of it: a doubled mortgage score price on volumes up low single digits; software grew 2%. A price step the single grid threatens is no rate.

04

The results

The numbers

Is it growing?Fast

Sales grew 27% in the year to Sep 2026, faster than the 16% in the year before.

Sep 2022: $1.38BSep 2023: $1.51BSep 2024: $1.72BSep 2025: $1.99BSep 2026: $2.53B$1.38B$2.53B
Is it profitable?Strong

Operating margin is 50%, up from 42% in the year to Sep 2023.

Sep 2022: 39%Sep 2023: 42%Sep 2024: 43%Sep 2025: 46%Sep 2026: 50%39%50%
Does growth pay off?Pays off

Running costs take 36¢ of each sales dollar, down from 39¢ in the year to Sep 2022.

Sep 2022: 39¢Sep 2023: 37¢Sep 2024: 37¢Sep 2025: 36¢Sep 2026: 36¢39¢36¢
Does it earn good returns?Strong

Each dollar put into the business earns 71% a year after tax, up from 39% in the year to Sep 2022.

Sep 2022: 39%Sep 2023: 45%Sep 2024: 48%Sep 2025: 59%Sep 2026: 71%39%71%
Is it making cash?Strong

It turned 42% of sales into free cash, $1.07B over the year.

Sep 2022: $503MSep 2023: $465MSep 2024: $624MSep 2025: $770MSep 2026: $1.07B$503M$1.07B
Is the balance sheet safe?Strained

It owes $5.04B more than the cash it holds, about 4.7 years of the cash its operations bring in.

Sep 2022: −$1.72BSep 2023: −$1.72BSep 2024: −$2.06BSep 2025: −$2.92BSep 2026: −$5.04B−$1.72B−$5.04B
Are shares being diluted?Shrinking

The share count fell 13% in 4.0 years, and pay in shares costs 7.3% of sales.

Sep 2022: 26.3MSep 2023: 25.4MSep 2024: 25.1MSep 2025: 24.6MSep 2026: 23.0M26.3M23.0M
All the numbers

Filed figures from the company's 10-K and 10-Q, read 2026-11-10. Fiscal years end in September.

Sep 2022Sep 2023Sep 2024Sep 2025Sep 2026
Size and growth
Sales$1.38B$1.51B$1.72B$1.99B$2.53B
Sales growth+4.6%+9.9%+13%+16%+27%
Profit
Gross margin78%79%80%82%86%
Operating margin39%42%43%46%50%
Net margin27%28%30%33%33%
What growth costs, per sales dollar
Research and development11%11%10%9.5%8.3%
Selling, general and admin28%26%27%26%27%
Pay in shares8.4%8.2%8.7%7.9%7.3%
Capital spending0.4%0.3%0.5%0.4%0.1%
Cash
Cash from operations$509M$469M$633M$779M$1.07B
Free cash flow$503M$465M$624M$770M$1.07B
Balance sheet
Cash and short-term investments$133M$137M$151M$134M$218M
Debt$1.85B$1.86B$2.21B$3.06B$5.26B
Net cash−$1.72B−$1.72B−$2.06B−$2.92B−$5.04B
Returns and shares
Return on capital39%45%48%59%71%
Shares (diluted)26.3M25.4M25.1M24.6M23.0M

What growth costs

Growing has made FICO more profitable, but not because each sale got cheaper to win. Price rises on the mortgage score went almost straight to profit, while the software business, which has to sell to grow, became less profitable. If the score price has to fall, that margin goes back the same way it came.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C50facthigh confidence
Per sales dollar, cost of revenues fell from 20.6 cents in fiscal 2023 to 14.9 over the four quarters to June 2026, R&D from 10.6 to 8.7, selling, general and administrative from 26.5 to 24.3 and share pay from 8.2 to 7.3, while operating margin rose from 42.5% to 51.7%.
against this

Revenue rose 58% over the span while cost of revenues rose 15%, so the gain came from the Scores price (C07) rather than volume, and the Software segment margin fell over the same quarters (C20).

historical · fiscal 2023 to the four quarters to 2026-06-30written 2026-10-04
C07facthigh confidence
The 10-Q says Scores revenue rose $134.6M in Q3 FY2026 'primarily attributable to a higher mortgage origination scores unit price', lifting the Scores segment margin to 91% from 88%.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C20facthigh confidence
Software segment operating income was $55.0M on $215.3M of revenue in Q3 FY2026, against $67.9M a year earlier; for fiscal 2025 it was $247.7M, a 30% margin.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01

The last report (4 Nov)

Quarter ended September 2026, filed figures.

27%
Sales growth
against the same quarter a year earlier
-2.5%
Growth from the quarter before
against -2.5% the quarter before that
41¢
Operating profit
per dollar of sales

Fiscal 2026 ended with a record: fourth-quarter revenue up 27% to $657M, software up 19%, and earnings per share above forecast. Scores revenue rose 33%, again on the higher mortgage price, partly offset by fewer mortgage applications.

Then the warning. FICO gave no forecast for 2027 and said it is moving to custom mortgage pricing for each lender, with deals still being finalized. It also set aside $65M to settle antitrust lawsuits over its scores and $27M for job cuts.

What it did to the thesisIt showed the business still growing, and that the single mortgage price is ending without a replacement published. The weaker mortgage quarter implied by the sales split and the withheld forecast leave the real question open, which is why conviction stays Low.

The quarter in detail

Sales growth from the previous quarter, filed figures.

Earnings per share $11.10 against $10.69 expected.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C56facthigh confidence
In Q4 fiscal 2026 revenue was $657.0M, up 27%: Scores $413.8M (up 33%, business-to-business up 39% on a higher mortgage unit price partly offset by lower originations volume) and Software $243.2M (up 19%). Operating income was $266.6M and fiscal 2026 operating income $1,265.7M on revenue of $2,534.9M. GAAP EPS was $8.12 after a $65M accrual for a proposed settlement of the antitrust class actions on Scores, a $27M restructuring charge and a $48M gain on an investment sale; non-GAAP EPS was $11.10. FICO gave no fiscal 2027 guidance, saying it is transitioning to bespoke mortgage originations pricing with programs still being finalized.
historical · Q4 FY2026written 2026-11-04
C57inferencehigh confidence
Fourth-quarter mortgage origination revenue is not split out in the release; Scores revenue of $413.8M less business-to-consumer of about $59M less non-mortgage business-to-business of about $115M (Q3's level) leaves about $240M, against $284.5M in Q3 and the $256M line of the test.
historical · Q4 FY2026written 2026-11-04
C06management claimmedium confidence
Management says FICO charged $4.95 per mortgage origination score in 2025, which the bureaus marked up to about $10; for 2026 it charges $10 per score into resellers, or $4.95 plus a fee on each funded loan.
against this

The $4.95 performance option depends on the direct licence program, which one GSE had still not certified at 2026-07-29, so the $10 price is what lenders actually pay.

current state · 2026-01-01written 2026-10-01
C39facthigh confidence
On 2026-07-29 management raised fiscal 2026 guidance to revenue of $2.53B, GAAP net income of $850M and GAAP EPS of $36.86, from $2.45B, $825M and $35.60. Fiscal 2026 revenue was $2,534.9M and GAAP EPS $36.32 (net income $175.0M in Q4 after $92M of settlement and restructuring charges); no fiscal 2027 guidance was given.
  1. 2026-11-04editedtested against the print: fiscal 2026 revenue $2,534.9M
historical · FY2026written 2026-10-01
C14management claimlow confidence
FICO's chief executive said in July that lenders using VantageScore still pulled FICO too, so no volume was lost, and put VantageScore's ceiling in the 20s per cent because it wins only when it scores higher.
against this
  • The 20s ceiling assumed VantageScore priced on a separate grid with a 20-point penalty, which the single grid of 2026-09-28 removes (C09).
  • Rocket now defaults to VantageScore for eligible loans (C11), which is choosing it without first comparing scores.
  • He also said volume loss is 'not that easy' to monitor.
  • The Q4 release reports lower mortgage originations volume and no volume lost to VantageScore, but it ends the single mortgage price and gives no guide (C56).
  1. 2026-11-04editedre-dated after the Q4 release
current state · 2026-07-29written 2026-10-01
What management did with the money

In the quarter to June FICO spent $1.96B buying back its own shares at an average of $1,149, $1.5B of it borrowed for the purpose. The share count fell 7.6% in a year. The shares now trade at about half that price, and the loan is still owed.

Insiders in 2026Q3: 7 purchases and 8 sales, from their Form 4 filings.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C24facthigh confidence
On 2026-06-05 FICO borrowed a $1.5B term loan and paid it to Wells Fargo for an accelerated buyback; nine-month repurchases reached $3,046M against $867M a year earlier.
historical · nine months to 2026-06-30written 2026-10-01
C25management claimhigh confidence
Management says it bought 1.705 million shares for $1.96B in Q3 FY2026 at an average $1,149, including the ASR; the shares closed at $592.47 on 2026-09-30.
against this

The 10-Q repurchase table shows $2.3B spent in the quarter, including $300M prepaid for shares not yet delivered, so the average will move at settlement; the 8-K's initial delivery implies about $1,137 to $1,422 a share.

historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C26facthigh confidence
21,597,635 shares were outstanding on 2026-07-17; diluted weighted shares were 22.703M in Q3 FY2026 against 24.575M a year earlier, 7.6% fewer.
current state · 2026-07-17written 2026-10-01
05

The price, and where we disagree

In short. Full. The price is about 120% of what we think the business is worth, at an 8% yearly return.

Share price
$592.47
close,
Price for each $1 of yearly profit
18.9
its 6-year normal 51.4
Company value for each $1 of cash profit
15.5
its 6-year normal 37.6

The rules changed in three steps, and the shares fell each time: about 15% in July 2025, 16.7% on 4 September when it was opened to every lender, and 26.5% on 29 September when the single grid was announced. They then rose 22% into the November results.

On 4 November FICO reported its year and declined to set a 2027 forecast or a single 2027 mortgage price, and its annual report did not split mortgage revenue out. The next hard evidence is the first-quarter results in February; the debt limit in its bank loan falls on 31 December.

The evidence under this - 6 claims
C28facthigh confidence
The shares closed at $724.38 on 2026-11-03, 69.6% below the 2024-11-26 close of $2,382.40 and 22.3% above the $592.47 of 2026-09-30; they fell 17.0% on 2026-07-30, 16.7% on 2026-09-04 and 26.5% on 2026-09-29.
  1. 2026-11-04editedre-struck at the 3 November close
current state · 2026-11-03written 2026-10-01
C41facthigh confidence
FHFA moved from an interim lender choice on 2025-07-08 to a limited VantageScore rollout on 2026-04-22 and to every lender on 2026-09-09; the shares fell about 15% over 2025-07-08 and 2025-07-09 and 16.7% on 2026-09-04.
historical · 2025-07 to 2026-09written 2026-10-01
C09factmedium confidence
On 2026-09-28 the FHFA director said Fannie and Freddie will price loans on one grid for Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0, removing the 20-point downward adjustment VantageScore carried; no effective date or grid was published.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C47factmedium confidence
The credit agreement caps total leverage at 4.50 times EBITDA to 2026-12-30, 4.00 times through 2027-12-30 and 3.50 times after; its EBITDA adds back share pay, which puts FICO near 3.9 times today.
current state · 2026-06-30written 2026-10-01
C39facthigh confidence
On 2026-07-29 management raised fiscal 2026 guidance to revenue of $2.53B, GAAP net income of $850M and GAAP EPS of $36.86, from $2.45B, $825M and $35.60. Fiscal 2026 revenue was $2,534.9M and GAAP EPS $36.32 (net income $175.0M in Q4 after $92M of settlement and restructuring charges); no fiscal 2027 guidance was given.
  1. 2026-11-04editedtested against the print: fiscal 2026 revenue $2,534.9M
historical · FY2026written 2026-10-01
C12facthigh confidence
Revenue from agreements with Experian, TransUnion and Equifax was 60% of FICO's fiscal 2026 revenue against 51% in fiscal 2025 and 45% in fiscal 2024, and 63% of Q3 FY2026 revenue; each was more than 10%.
  1. 2026-11-11editedre-sourced to the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November: the bureaus were 60% of the year's revenue, up from 51%
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
How we value it
Method
Cash the business will produce, in three stages
Required return
8%
Long-run growth
4%
Moat
An average moat
BearBaseBull
Sales growth, years 1 to 31.8%, 2.3%, 4.8%3.5%, 4.6%, 9.6%4.4%, 5.7%, 12%
Normal operating margin36%45%49.5%
Return on new capital after year ten8%12%15%
Value a share$270$610$826
Price
$731
Priced on
10 Nov
Price as a share of the base value
120%
Starting growth the price pays for
14%
Yearly return the price offers on the base case
7.5%
Risk check: valued at 10%, the rate for a cyclical or indebted business
$350

Where each figure comes from

FigureSourceWhere exactly
Sales, the last full yearFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026; the full year.
Operating margin todayFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026; the full year.
Tax rateFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026; the full year.
Sales per dollar of new capitalFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026: the year's sales over its operating capital, held to between 0.5 and 6.
SharesFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026; the diluted share count.
Cash and investmentsFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026; the balance sheet on that date.
DebtFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 6 Nov 2026; the balance sheet on that date.
Sales growth, years 1 to 3Analysts' forecastsFMP's consensus for the years to 30 Sep 2027, 30 Sep 2028 and 30 Sep 2029, as it stood when the value was struck on 10 Nov 2026: the average of 9 to 14 analysts' revenue estimates, 3.5%, 4.6%, 9.6%. FMP publishes how many analysts, not who they are.
Normal operating marginAnalysts' forecastsFMP's consensus operating margin for the year to 30 Sep 2029, as it stood when the value was struck on 10 Nov 2026, the average of 9 analysts' estimates, less stock pay: 45% in the base case. FMP publishes how many analysts, not who they are.
Return on new capital after year tenOur method's ruleSet by our reading of the moat: the 8% rate with none, 12% with an average one, 15% with a strong one; the bear case earns the rate.
The bear and bull casesOur method's ruleOur method's spread: the bear case takes half the growth and a fifth off the margin, the bull a quarter more growth and a tenth more margin.
PriceMarket priceFMP's closing price on 10 Nov 2026.

What each case rests on

Bear caseGrowth runs at half the analysts' path, 2%, 2% and 5%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 36.0%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.

Base caseRevenue grows 4%, 5% and 10% over three years, the analysts' path (C59), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin moves to 45.0%, the analysts' year-three figure after stock pay.

Bull caseGrowth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, 4%, 6% and 12%, the margin reaches 49.5%, and new capital earns 15%.

What moves the base value

LowerHigher
Growth in years 1 to 3, a quarter lower or higher$552$672
The normal margin, 15% lower or higher$496$724
Capital per dollar of growth, a quarter more or less$608$611
Return on new capital after year ten, at the rate or one step up$460$670
The rate, a point higher or lower$454$868
Long-run growth a point lower$535-

Value a share as growth and margin change

Normal margin ↓ · growth →50%75%100%125%150%
36%$369$412$459$508$560
40.5%$434$482$534$590$649
45%$499$552$610$672$737
49.5%$563$622$686$754$826
54%$628$692$762$835$914

Growth is shown as a share of the base case's. Green: the price is at or under 80% of that value. Red: at or over 120%.

How we read the multiple

A buyer of the whole company pays about 16.3 times last year's operating profit. For six years the market paid far more. What has to be true:

1. About $258M a quarter of profit came from mortgage scores at $10, the last split FICO published. 2. If half disappeared, the price would be about 22 times what is left. 3. If all disappeared, about 51 times. 4. So the price allows a deep cut, but not the loss of the business.

Against its own history. Far cheaper than its own normal, because the market no longer believes the mortgage price is safe; that gap is the regulator's decision, not a bargain.

The evidence under this - 6 claims
C29estimatehigh confidence
Enterprise value is about $20.7B: 21.55M diluted shares at $724.38 is $15.6B, plus $5.0B of net debt. That is 16.3 times fiscal 2026 operating income of $1,266M.
derivedC26 and the Q4 diluted share count (net income $175.0M over $8.12 a share), C28 price, C23 net debt and trailing operating income.
against this
  • Trailing income holds only two quarters at the $10 price, so 14.6 understates the run rate; it also holds two quarters a price cut would not reach.
  • The research pack's $14.2B market value uses a stale 24.0M share count; the filed 21.6M is used.
  1. 2026-11-04editedre-struck at $724.38 and fiscal 2026 operating income
current state · 2026-11-03written 2026-10-01
C30factmedium confidence
The research pack puts the trailing multiple of enterprise value to earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation at 15.5, against a prior six-year median of 37.6, and the price-earnings ratio at 18.9 against 51.4.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
C43estimatelow confidence
In Q3 FY2026 everything but the mortgage score produced about $104M of operating income after all corporate costs, about $417M a year.
derivedC03 operating income of $362.6M less the estimated $258M mortgage-score segment income in C05, which carries no corporate costs.
against this

Loading all corporate costs and share pay on the rest understates it; on segment figures the rest earned $213.6M before those costs.

historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C05estimatemedium confidence
Mortgage origination scores were about $284.5M of Q3 FY2026 revenue, 42% of the company, and about $258M of segment operating income, equal to about 71% of consolidated operating income.
derived62% of Scores revenue of $458.9M is $284.5M, against total revenue of $674.2M. At the Scores segment margin of 90.8% that is $258M, 55% of $471.9M segment operating income and 71% of $362.6M consolidated operating income, before corporate costs are allocated.
against this
  • Mortgage scores may earn a different margin from the Scores average; the segment note gives one margin for all scores.
  • Comparing segment profit with consolidated profit overstates the share, since corporate costs and share pay of $109.3M sit outside the segments.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
C23estimatehigh confidence
Net debt of $5,042M ($5,259M of debt less $218M of cash at 30 September) is 4.0 times fiscal 2026 operating income of $1,266M.
against this

If half the mortgage-score profit goes (about $517M a year at the Q3 rate), the same debt is about 7 times what is left.

  1. 2026-11-04editedre-struck at 30 September
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
C60inferencemedium confidence
On a three-stage fair value at an 8% required return FICO is worth about $610 a share against $730.66 at the 10 November close, about 120% of it. Base case: trailing sales of $2.53B grow 4%, 5% and 10% over the next three years (the analysts' path, C59), then fade toward 4%, each year closing 30% of the gap, reaching it by year ten; the operating margin moves from 49.9% to 45.0% over five years, the analysts' year-three margin less stock pay of 7.3% of sales; each added dollar of sales needs 17 cents of capital; a 24.1% tax rate; then 4% growth for ever at a 12% return on new capital; less $5.26B of debt net of $218M of cash. Bear (half that growth, a 36.0% margin, new capital earning 8%) gives about $270, bull (a quarter more growth, a 49.5% margin) about $826.
against this

The value leans on the analysts' path and margin, which this thesis has not tested name by name; at a 9% required return it is about $454, and the bear case of $270 is the downturn test.

  1. 2026-11-09editedgrowth fades as each year closes 30% of its gap to 4% and the analysts' margin is put on the filed basis, the owner's call of 9 November
  2. 2026-11-10editedre-valued on the owner's rules of 10 November: the return on new capital glides to its terminal level over years six to ten
  3. 2026-11-11editedprice re-struck at the 10 November close of $730.66, about 120% of the unchanged base case
current state · 2026-11-10written 2026-11-09
Priced against its rivals

None of the listed rivals above sells the same thing to the same buyers as a large part of what it does. A price comparison needs at least two, so the price is judged against its own history instead.

Also checked and set aside: ACI Worldwide (a substitute, not the same product).

Where we disagree with the market

The market believes

The market thinks FICO's mortgage business is broken and has cut the shares by about 70%.

We believe

Lenders will keep buying FICO for a while, but the $10 price will not survive a 99-cent rival on the same grid.

The regulator still approves FICO with no end date, and lenders who want the better of two scores must buy both, so volume should hold for a while. The rival's 99-cent price is what limits FICO's price, and no filing shows that yet.

We are wrong if the 2027 programs keep the average mortgage price near $10 and mortgage revenue holds near the third quarter's. FICO's November release gave neither.

What analysts say, and the evidence
Analysts positive
61%
of 23, 1 Sep
Four months earlier
73%
of 22, 1 May
The evidence under this - 6 claims
C14management claimlow confidence
FICO's chief executive said in July that lenders using VantageScore still pulled FICO too, so no volume was lost, and put VantageScore's ceiling in the 20s per cent because it wins only when it scores higher.
against this
  • The 20s ceiling assumed VantageScore priced on a separate grid with a 20-point penalty, which the single grid of 2026-09-28 removes (C09).
  • Rocket now defaults to VantageScore for eligible loans (C11), which is choosing it without first comparing scores.
  • He also said volume loss is 'not that easy' to monitor.
  • The Q4 release reports lower mortgage originations volume and no volume lost to VantageScore, but it ends the single mortgage price and gives no guide (C56).
  1. 2026-11-04editedre-dated after the Q4 release
current state · 2026-07-29written 2026-10-01
C15inferencemedium confidence
On one grid with no adjustment, a lender can deliver an eligible Fannie or Freddie loan without buying a FICO score at all, so FICO's place in most of its mortgage revenue is now a choice rather than a rule.
derivedC08 (VantageScore open to all lenders, no FICO needed for eligible loans), C09 (one grid, no penalty), C10 (VantageScore at $0.99) and C11 (a top lender defaulting to it).
against this
  • Classic FICO is still required for manually underwritten GSE loans, and the FHFA FAQ keeps tri-merge reporting unchanged (C08).
  • Jumbo, portfolio and most FHA lending sit outside the GSE grid; FHA takes VantageScore only from 2027-01-01 (C10).
  • The grid is announced, not published (C09), and lenders choosing the better score must still pull both (C14).
current state · 2026-10-01written 2026-10-01
C08facthigh confidence
FHFA says Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac required Classic FICO for decades; since 2026-09-09 every approved lender may use VantageScore 4.0 instead. Classic FICO stays approved with no retirement date, and FICO 10T is not yet accepted.
current state · 2026-09-09written 2026-10-01
C10facthigh confidence
TransUnion sells VantageScore 4.0 for $0.99 per standalone mortgage score through December 2028, free with a FICO purchase, and says over 1,100 mortgage lenders adopted it from January to September 2026.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C06management claimmedium confidence
Management says FICO charged $4.95 per mortgage origination score in 2025, which the bureaus marked up to about $10; for 2026 it charges $10 per score into resellers, or $4.95 plus a fee on each funded loan.
against this

The $4.95 performance option depends on the direct licence program, which one GSE had still not certified at 2026-07-29, so the $10 price is what lenders actually pay.

current state · 2026-01-01written 2026-10-01
C39facthigh confidence
On 2026-07-29 management raised fiscal 2026 guidance to revenue of $2.53B, GAAP net income of $850M and GAAP EPS of $36.86, from $2.45B, $825M and $35.60. Fiscal 2026 revenue was $2,534.9M and GAAP EPS $36.32 (net income $175.0M in Q4 after $92M of settlement and restructuring charges); no fiscal 2027 guidance was given.
  1. 2026-11-04editedtested against the print: fiscal 2026 revenue $2,534.9M
historical · FY2026written 2026-10-01
06

What could go wrong, and how we would know

The risks

  • Lenders stop buying FICO On one grid, a lender can send a loan with only the 99-cent score. Rocket says it will default to it this quarter, and others may follow.
  • The debt limit tightens Its bank loan caps debt at 4.00 times yearly earnings from 31 December, 3.50 after 2027. Losing half the mortgage profit would put it near 6.
  • Distributors own the rival The three bureaus pay FICO 63% of its revenue and also own VantageScore, so FICO's sales channel competes against it.
  • The regulator decides No grid or start date has been published. The regulator could also retire the old FICO score before FICO's newer one is accepted.
  • Shares bought high FICO borrowed to buy shares at about twice today's price; that money is gone and the loan, $2.4B due in 2028 with other debt, remains.
The evidence under this - 7 claims
C15inferencemedium confidence
On one grid with no adjustment, a lender can deliver an eligible Fannie or Freddie loan without buying a FICO score at all, so FICO's place in most of its mortgage revenue is now a choice rather than a rule.
derivedC08 (VantageScore open to all lenders, no FICO needed for eligible loans), C09 (one grid, no penalty), C10 (VantageScore at $0.99) and C11 (a top lender defaulting to it).
against this
  • Classic FICO is still required for manually underwritten GSE loans, and the FHFA FAQ keeps tri-merge reporting unchanged (C08).
  • Jumbo, portfolio and most FHA lending sit outside the GSE grid; FHA takes VantageScore only from 2027-01-01 (C10).
  • The grid is announced, not published (C09), and lenders choosing the better score must still pull both (C14).
current state · 2026-10-01written 2026-10-01
C11factmedium confidence
Rocket Mortgage said it will make VantageScore 4.0 its default for eligible Fannie and Freddie loans in the fourth quarter after testing 1.4 million credit reports; borrowers who saved through it saved an average $1,600 at closing.
current state · 2026-09-28written 2026-10-01
C47factmedium confidence
The credit agreement caps total leverage at 4.50 times EBITDA to 2026-12-30, 4.00 times through 2027-12-30 and 3.50 times after; its EBITDA adds back share pay, which puts FICO near 3.9 times today.
current state · 2026-06-30written 2026-10-01
C48estimatemedium confidence
If half the mortgage-score profit went, covenant EBITDA would be about $910M and leverage about 6 times against a 4.00 limit, before any repayment.
derivedC47's about $1,427M less half of C05's about $258M a quarter, $517M a year; debt held at $5,610M.
against this

Free cash flow near $1B a year (C44) repays debt quickly, and the company said it would; a halving would take more than a year to arrive.

forward · FY2027written 2026-10-01
C12facthigh confidence
Revenue from agreements with Experian, TransUnion and Equifax was 60% of FICO's fiscal 2026 revenue against 51% in fiscal 2025 and 45% in fiscal 2024, and 63% of Q3 FY2026 revenue; each was more than 10%.
  1. 2026-11-11editedre-sourced to the fiscal 2026 10-K, filed 6 November: the bureaus were 60% of the year's revenue, up from 51%
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-10-01
C17management claimmedium confidence
In April FICO cut the price of FICO 10T under its direct licence program to $0.99 a score plus $65 per funded loan, and gives 10T free with Classic; the program still awaited one GSE's certification in July, with resellers for about 60% of volume signed.
against this

10T cannot be delivered to the GSEs at all yet (C08), so its price matches VantageScore only where the GSEs do not decide.

current state · 2026-07-29written 2026-10-01
C25management claimhigh confidence
Management says it bought 1.705 million shares for $1.96B in Q3 FY2026 at an average $1,149, including the ASR; the shares closed at $592.47 on 2026-09-30.
against this

The 10-Q repurchase table shows $2.3B spent in the quarter, including $300M prepaid for shares not yet delivered, so the average will move at settlement; the 8-K's initial delivery implies about $1,137 to $1,422 a share.

historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-01
What we still do not know
  • When the single grid starts, and whether it keeps any difference between the two scores.
  • What FICO will charge for a mortgage score in 2027; management said no decision had been made.
  • How many FICO scores the rival has already replaced; FICO itself says this is hard to see.
  • When Fannie and Freddie will accept FICO's newer score, 10T, which FICO says predicts defaults better.
The evidence under this - 4 claims
C09factmedium confidence
On 2026-09-28 the FHFA director said Fannie and Freddie will price loans on one grid for Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0, removing the 20-point downward adjustment VantageScore carried; no effective date or grid was published.
current state · 2026-09-29written 2026-10-01
C06management claimmedium confidence
Management says FICO charged $4.95 per mortgage origination score in 2025, which the bureaus marked up to about $10; for 2026 it charges $10 per score into resellers, or $4.95 plus a fee on each funded loan.
against this

The $4.95 performance option depends on the direct licence program, which one GSE had still not certified at 2026-07-29, so the $10 price is what lenders actually pay.

current state · 2026-01-01written 2026-10-01
C14management claimlow confidence
FICO's chief executive said in July that lenders using VantageScore still pulled FICO too, so no volume was lost, and put VantageScore's ceiling in the 20s per cent because it wins only when it scores higher.
against this
  • The 20s ceiling assumed VantageScore priced on a separate grid with a 20-point penalty, which the single grid of 2026-09-28 removes (C09).
  • Rocket now defaults to VantageScore for eligible loans (C11), which is choosing it without first comparing scores.
  • He also said volume loss is 'not that easy' to monitor.
  • The Q4 release reports lower mortgage originations volume and no volume lost to VantageScore, but it ends the single mortgage price and gives no guide (C56).
  1. 2026-11-04editedre-dated after the Q4 release
current state · 2026-07-29written 2026-10-01
C17management claimmedium confidence
In April FICO cut the price of FICO 10T under its direct licence program to $0.99 a score plus $65 per funded loan, and gives 10T free with Classic; the program still awaited one GSE's certification in July, with resellers for about 60% of volume signed.
against this

10T cannot be delivered to the GSEs at all yet (C08), so its price matches VantageScore only where the GSEs do not decide.

current state · 2026-07-29written 2026-10-01

What would change our view

  1. Unattractive→AttractiveThe price falls 20% under fair value

    It needs:

    • ○The share price falls to about $488, 80% of what we think the business is worth.about ≈$545.77 today, 8% below the last close
  2. Unattractive→NeutralThe price falls back to 115% of fair value

    It needs:

    • ○The share price falls back to about $702, 15% above what we think the business is worth.about ≈$708.24 today, -20% below the last close
  3. Unattractive→NeutralThe agencies settle in FICO's favour

    It needs all of:

    • ○Fannie and Freddie set a date to accept FICO 10T and approve FICO's direct pricing program.watched as it happens
    • ○FICO's forecast for fiscal 2027 keeps the mortgage score at $10.watched as it happens
We would also be wrong if
  • FICO cuts its 2027 mortgage price below the 2025 level of $4.95.
  • Debt rises above the 4.00-times limit in its bank loan.

What is coming

  • 24 November 2026 Fiscal 2026 10-K: The mortgage origination revenue split for the fourth quarter and the year, and any disclosed terms of the $65M antitrust settlement.
Every dated event ahead
  • 24 November 2026 Fiscal 2026 10-K: The mortgage origination revenue split for the fourth quarter and the year, and any disclosed terms of the $65M antitrust settlement.
  • December 2026 Rocket Mortgage makes VantageScore 4.0 its default for eligible agency loans: Whether the largest lender stops pulling FICO on those loans, or keeps buying both scores as FICO says lenders do.
  • 31 December 2026 Credit agreement leverage limit steps down to 4.00 times: Whether covenant EBITDA keeps leverage under the lower cap after the borrowed buyback, or forces debt repayment over further buybacks.
  • 3 February 2027 Q1 fiscal 2027 results: Whether the 2027 bespoke programs hold the mortgage price near $10 and whether FICO guides fiscal 2027.
Since we wrote this
Written
1 Oct
Price the thesis read
$592.47
30 Sep
  • 11 NovPrice moveMoved to Unattractive: the price reached 120% of our $610 valueA rise of about 4% with no company news took the shares to the edge of our margin of safety; with mortgage prices unpublished and the rival nearly free, nothing earns that premium. Conviction stays low.
  • 9 NovThesis reviewStill Neutral: priced at 109% of a value near $645Re-valued in three stages at an 8% return, the method now drawn on every thesis: the price sits inside the 20% margin of safety.
  • 5 NovEarningsOn the call, FICO says it will stop publishing mortgage pricesThe Preferred Program is described as steady-priced and popular, but all prices and terms go unpublished, so revenue and the guide must show the price. Neutral and Low hold.
  • 4 NovEarningsNo 2027 guidance as FICO moves to custom mortgage pricingRevenue beat but the single $10 price is ending and its replacement is unpublished, so the size of the fall is still unknown. Neutral and Low hold.
  • 23 OctNewsFICO keeps its $10 mortgage score fee for preferred-program lenders; terms unread. View heldFICO holds its $10 mortgage score fee for lenders in its preferred program.
  • 7 OctNewsFICO will cut about 15% of jobs, with a $27M charge this quarter. View heldWorkforce reduction of about 15% of positions (8-K Item 2.05).
  • 5 OctThesis reviewThe long case now sits under the verdictAfter the five-name pilot, the owner asked for the long case on every thesis.
  • 4 OctThesis reviewOwner's checklist: revenue streams, cost of growth, management, catalystsThe owner's checklist found the method silent on who runs the company, what growth costs, where the money comes from and what is dated ahead; this pass fills those four blocks from the proxy and filings.
  • 1 OctThesis writtenNeutral, low convictionWritten two days after the regulator put VantageScore on FICO's pricing grid and five weeks before FICO sets its 2027 mortgage price.

Also checked 5 times with nothing new to act on.

Sources 29

Where this came from

Sources - 29

Every claim above cites one of these, or states the reasoning that derived it. The quote is frozen at the date it was read: a link can rot, and an agent fetch returns a reading of a page rather than the page. Backs counts the whole claim ledger, so it can name a claim this page does not surface.

  1. S01primarycompany filing2025-11-07
    Item 1 business and competition, risk factors on the GSE requirement and closing costs, customer concentration, segment note, FY2025 statements
    backsC02C12C20C38C45C46C50C51C54
  2. S02primarycompany filing2026-07-29
    segment note and reconciliation, concentration, debt note and maturities, ASR note, share count, MD&A on unit price
    backsC01C03C07C12C20C22C24C26C27C30C47C49C50C54
  3. S03primarycompany release2026-07-29
    Q3 results, segment revenue, software ARR, cash flow, updated FY2026 guidance and its non-GAAP reconciliation
    backsC01C03C19C21C22C24C39C44C45
  4. S04primarytranscript2026-07-29
    FICO Q3 fiscal 2026 earnings call transcript
    the mortgage share of Scores, volumes, the buyback price, VantageScore share and gaming, the direct licence program; thirteen analysts' questions, a separate origin from the answers
    Mortgage origination revenues accounted for 71% of B2B revenues and 62% of total Scores revenues.
    backsC04C14C17C18C21C25
  5. S05primarytranscript2025-11-05
    FICO Q4 fiscal 2025 earnings call transcript
    the 2025 and 2026 mortgage score prices and the two pricing models of the direct licence program
    From a pricing perspective, the FICO score for mortgage originations was $4.95 per score in 2025. The bureaus marked this price up on average to $10 per score.
    backsC06C42
  6. S06primarytranscript2026-04-28
    FICO Q2 fiscal 2026 earnings call transcript
    the 10T price cut and the Q2 mortgage share
    we updated our FICO Score 10T performance model pricing in the FICO mortgage direct licensing program from $4.95 per score plus $33 funding fee to $0.99 per score plus $65 funding fee.
    backsC04C17
  7. S07primarytranscript2026-01-28
    FICO Q1 fiscal 2026 earnings call transcript
    the Q1 mortgage share, before the 2026 price took effect
    Mortgage originations revenues accounted for 51% of B2B revenue and 42% of total Scores revenue.
    backsC04
  8. S08primarycompany filing2026-06-08
    the $2.0B authorisation, the $1.5B term loan and the $1.5B ASR with about 1,055,100 shares initially delivered
    backsC24
  9. S09primaryregulator2026-09-09
    FHFA, Credit Scores policy page and FAQ Federal Housing Finance Agency
    the regulator's own timeline from the 2018 law to 2026-09-09, the status of Classic FICO and FICO 10T, the tri-merge rule
    On September 9, 2026, the Enterprises expanded the availability of VantageScore 4.0 to all approved lenders, removing the requirement for prior written approval. ... Classic FICO is expected to be retired at a future date, but no retirement date has been announced.
    backsC08C41
  10. S10secondarynews2026-09-29
    the single-grid announcement, the removed adjustment, Rocket's default, UWM's share and VantageScore's statement
    Under that framework, VantageScore 4.0 scores were subject to a 20-point downward adjustment to account for differences between the models. But the pricing grid shared by Pulte on Monday removes the 20-point adjustment.
    backsC09C11C16
  11. S11secondarynews2026-09-29
    that no grid or date was published, Fannie's MBS disclosure of score models from 2026-10-19, Rocket's default for direct-to-consumer loans
    Pulte did not provide an effective date or publish a replacement pricing matrix with the announcement.
    backsC09C11C55
  12. S12primarycompany release2026-09-29
    the rival's price and term, adoption by over 1,100 mortgage lenders, FHA acceptance from 2027-01-01
    Under the extended program, VantageScore 4.0 will continue to be available for $0.99 per mortgage origination score when ordered on a standalone basis. ... Between January and September 2026, VantageScore 4.0 adoption expanded to more than 1,100 mortgage lenders, including 9 of TransUnion's 15 largest mortgage lender customers.
    backsC10
  13. S13primarycompany filing2026-02-27
    TransUnion names FICO as a competitor and FICO's direct licence program as a risk; mortgage revenue growth from pricing
    backsC13
  14. S14primarygovernment data2024-12
    applications and originations counted from lenders' HMDA filings, and median loan costs
    with the number of applications decreasing by about 4.3 million or 30.3 percent and originations decreasing by 2.7 million or 32.2 percent from 2022. ... Lenders reported approximately 3.2 million closed-end site-built one-to-four family (single-family) home purchase originations in 2023, a 21.3 percent decrease from 4.1 million originations in 2022. ... The median total loan costs for home purchase loans in 2023 was $6,684
    backsC35C37
  15. S15secondaryvendor data2026-10-01
    Research pack, FICO, 2026-10-01
    closes and the price history, the multiple series, the price decomposition, the analyst split and target drift
    backsC25C28C30C31C32C41C42
  16. S16primaryregulator2026-09-15
    FINRA Consolidated Short Interest, FICO, settlement 2026-09-15 FINRA
    short interest and days to cover
    backsC33
  17. S17primarycompany filing2026-08-25
    Forms 4 filed by FICO insiders, 2025-10-01 to 2026-10-01, read by insider_fetch.py
    each open-market sale and its Rule 10b5-1 flag
    backsC34
  18. S18primarycompany filing2026-02-10
    what a named software rival sells, for the cohort review
    backsC46
  19. S19primarycompany filing2026-02-19
    what a named scoring rival sells, for the cohort review
    read, but no claim rests on it
  20. S20secondarynews2026-09-28
    the announcement and the absence of an effective date
    Pulte did not offer details on when the unified single-family pricing grid would go into effect in the social media post announcing it.
    backsC09
  21. S21primarycompany release2025-11-05
    Q4 fiscal 2025 results and the first fiscal 2026 guidance: revenue $2.35B, GAAP EPS $33.47
    backsC39
  22. S22primarycompany filing2026-06-08
    the term loan terms, the stepped total leverage covenant and the EBITDA definition
    backsC47
  23. S23primarycompany filing2026-01-27
    beneficial ownership as of November 28, 2025, the fiscal 2025 bonus and PSU goal tables and payouts, the equity mix and the MSU result certified December 3, 2025
    backsC52C53
  24. S24primarycompany release2026-11-04
    Q4 and FY2026 income statement, segment revenue, outlook, balance sheet, one-time items
    We are transitioning to bespoke mortgage originations pricing, tailored to the individual needs of our customers.
    backsC23C39C56C57
  25. S25secondaryvendor data2026-11-04
    close of $724.38 on 3 November 2026
    backsC28
  26. S26primarytranscript2026-11-04
    FICO Q4 fiscal 2026 earnings call transcript
    management's statement that prices and terms of the bespoke mortgage programs will no longer be disclosed; the Preferred Program's description as price-stable; FICO 10T status; guidance likely as pricing settles
    And so on a go-forward basis, our intention is to not share every detail. We're not going to share every pricing program. We're not going to share what the prices are.
    backsC58
  27. S27primarycompany filing2026-11-09
    trailing revenue, operating profit, stock pay, tax, debt, cash and the diluted share count
    backsC60
  28. S28secondaryvendor data2026-11-09
    the analysts' average revenue and operating profit for the next three fiscal years, and the close
    backsC59C60
  29. S29primarycompany filing2026-11-06
    customer concentration for fiscal 2026, the competition section naming VantageScore, Scores revenue by distribution method, and the MD&A on the mortgage unit price and volume; no split of mortgage origination revenue
    backsC12C13
Rendered from content/FICO/thesis.json · thesis reviewed 2026-11-11. This page explains a company; it does not say what to pay, when to buy or how much.