Vistra runs power plants and sells electricity to homes
62% gas, 20% coal and 15% nuclear
homes and businesses buy their electricity from it
wholesale grids it sells power into
Vistra makes electricity and sells it two ways: wholesale into the grid, and directly to its own customers. Owning both cushions it when wholesale prices fall.
Selling power to its own customers is most of sales
Vistra locks in prices ahead with financial contracts, called hedges, so its income is steadier than the power price. Those contracts swing its reported profit up and down on paper.
Reported profit swings; the cash business is steadier
Office costs are steady at about 9 cents a sales dollar. Growth now comes from buying plants, so whether it pays depends on what those plants earn.
Its nuclear reactors cannot be copied
of nuclear, licensed into the 2030s and beyond
large reactors under construction in the US
Meta signed for, at a price above market
Only two reactors were finished in America in the past decade. A buyer wanting steady, carbon-free power came to Vistra's existing plants rather than wait for new ones.
Data centres are starting to make their own power
Every data centre that powers itself is demand that never reaches Vistra's grid. Batteries and a market redesign have also softened Texas prices.
The cash business grew more than 50% last quarter
Sales rose from $12.1B in 2021 to $20.6B. The higher 2027 range includes the Cogentrix plants Vistra bought, not only growth from what it already owned.
Texas demand is rising after decades of flat growth
About 410 GW of large users have asked to connect, far more than will ever be built. Vistra's chief is cautious about how much actually arrives.
Long-time insiders who bought plants and beat forecasts
On their watch Vistra bought more plants, signed long nuclear contracts with big tech buyers and beat its own forecasts.
AI data centres use huge amounts of electricity
After decades of flat demand, America needs more electricity for data centres. Plants that already exist, especially nuclear ones, have become valuable because new ones take years to build.
Hedges swing reported profit without changing the cash
- Vistra sells power aheadLocking in prices with hedges.
- Market prices moveThe hedges gain or lose value on paper.
- Reported profit jumps aroundA $559M paper gain in one period.
- The cash business is steadierThat is what we value.
The usual price-to-profit figure uses the distorted reported number, so Vistra looks dear. On what it actually earns, about 9.1 times last year's underlying profit, the AI story is not paid for.
The shares fell while the forecast went up
Solid quarter
Underlying profit rose over 50% and 2027 went up. A Texas audit has also paused reviews of large new users, for longer than management expected.
Is the AI power story already in the price?
An AI-power story the market has already paid up for
On what the business earns, the AI story is not paid for
The gap sits in a reconciliation table few people read. Against us: most AI demand is unsigned, Texas prices have softened and data centres can build their own plants.
The price sits about a quarter below our value
below $138
above $207
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
Demand may go around the grid
Data centres build their own turbines.
Batteries and a redesign lowered prices.
Borrowing rose while it keeps buying back shares.
No signed Texas deal of Meta's size yet.
Our estimate rests on contracts repricing the plants. If that demand never signs, the gloomy case is far below today's price.
February shows whether the 2027 range holds
Fourth-quarter results and the 2027 forecast. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares rise to within a fifth of our estimate, the cushion is gone and we move to Neutral.
Power plants nobody can build again soon, on a thin cushion
below $138
above $207
AttractiveMedium conviction
Vistra's plants, above all its reactors, are hard to replace, and its cash business is growing fast. Conviction is Medium because Texas prices are softening and much of the new demand is unsigned.