Metallus melts scrap in Canton, Ohio, into clean steel bars and tubes. Others forge them into gears, bearings, axles and 155mm artillery shells.
The company · 2 · What exactly does it sell?
Cars and equipment are most of it
Each $1 of sales, 2025
41%35%14%9%1%
CarsIndustrial equipmentAerospace and defenceEnergyOther
Defence is a sixth of sales; cars and equipment rise and fall hard.
The company · 3 · How does it make money?
Paid per ton, at cyclical prices
8.1%kept per $1 after making it
$250Mannual pace of defence sales
With one mill, fixed costs stay the same when orders fall, so profit swings hard.
Is it a good business? · 4 · What gives it an edge?
The Army's chosen source of shell steel
Since 1993
the Army has bought HF-1
$99.75M
Army money for two new furnaces
The protection is the government's choice and approval, not something a rival could never copy. In ordinary bars, little stops a customer switching.
Is it a good business? · 5 · What is the catch?
Bigger mills win ordinary bars on price
Steel Dynamicsrolls special bars too
Nucor, Gerdaucompete for ordinary orders
Listed rivals: STLD · NUE · GGB · TS · MT
No second approved shell-steel maker was found, but the Army wants more suppliers.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
Flat sales, much thinner profit
Sales, $B
1.3
1.3
1.4
1.1
1.2
1.3
Dec 2021Dec 2022Dec 2023Dec 2024Dec 2025last 12 mo
Sales$1.28B → $1.25Bsales, 2021 to the past year
Kept17% → 8.1%kept per $1 after making it
Profit13% → 1.9%operating profit per $1
The fixed costs of one mill cut hard when sales fall, as in 2024.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
Shell steel is small but growing
About $202Ma year at the Army's goal of 100,000 shells a month
36,000shells a month made today
About $73Ma year at today's rate
The new furnaces can make enough for about 120,000 shells a month.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
A new chief from 1 January 2027
1 January 2027Kristopher Westbrooks takes over
3.8%owned by directors and officers
14insider sales in the year, no purchases
The bonus paid out although cash earnings missed their target.
The story right now · 9 · Why does the Army want more shells?
The Army is tripling shell production
36,000shells a month today
100,000the Army's goal
29 Septembera new defence contract
Wars abroad emptied stockpiles, and the US Army is paying to make far more 155mm shells. Each needs special steel, and Metallus is its funded source.
The story right now · 10 · How much can defence add?
Defence is real but a sixth of sales
Army orders more shellsReal growth.
Metallus supplies the steelFunded furnaces.
Still a sixth of salesCars and equipment rule.
The cycle decidesProfit swings.
The contract ceiling is not a commitment, and the price already assumes earnings near the last peak.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
Cash earnings up, the Army order called new
$337.2Msales, up 10%
$34.5Mcash earnings, from $29.0M
Spring 2027the new Army order ships
31%share rise in six months
Mixed quarter
The fourth quarter falls back on the yearly shutdown.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
A munitions story, or a steel mill?
Many investors think
A munitions growth story with Army-funded furnaces
We think
The price assumes the mill runs better than it does
Against us: orders are up more than 50% and price rises take full effect in 2027.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
The price pays for earnings near the last peak
$9.73what we think a share is worth · the last close is of that
$9.73our value
Neutral
Unattractive above $11.68
$8.27gloomy: growth halves, less kept per $1
$9.73our estimate: experts' path, then slowing
$14.88sunny: growth beats the forecast by a quarter
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?
The cycle could turn
The cycle turnsBiggest
Car and equipment demand.
One siteShowing now
Power cuts hit output.
A second shell supplierWatch
The Army pays for one.
New or replaced demandUnknown
The split is unclear.
Defence budgets decide shell demand, and the pension is a standing cost.
The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?
February tests the mill and defence
Defence sales keep their paceGood sign
Profit per $1 recoversGood sign
Car and equipment orders fallBad sign
FEB 202718
Fourth-quarter 2026 results, 18 February. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares fall to within a fifth of our estimate, we move to Neutral.
The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?
Defence steel inside a cyclical mill, priced for recovery
$9.73our value
Neutral
Unattractive above $11.68
UnattractiveMedium conviction
Most of Metallus's steel goes into car and equipment parts, a market that rises and falls hard, but it is also the Army's one funded source of shell steel. The price already assumes earnings near the last peak.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
Metallus makes special-bar-quality steel: clean, precisely mixed steel bars up to 16 inches across, and seamless tubes, for parts that must not crack, such as gears, bearings, axles and drill tools. It melts scrap in electric furnaces in Canton, Ohio, and shipped 631.7 thousand tons in 2025 to about 330 customers.
Its best-known product is HF-1, a steel that breaks into many fragments, forged by others into 155mm artillery shell bodies. Buyers could get ordinary bars from Steel Dynamics, Nucor or Gerdau; HF-1 they cannot.
How it makes money
Metallus sells steel by the ton. Each price has two parts: a base price, and a surcharge that passes changes in scrap and alloy costs to the customer a few months later. About 70% of orders are on annual agreements, so prices reset once a year.
In 2025 cars took 41% of sales, industrial equipment 35%, defense 14% and energy 9%. Defense earned $2,887 a ton, against $1,834 for the company as a whole.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
Growth has not made the business more profitable lately. In 2025 sales rose 6.9% but prices fell and cash earnings slipped. One big mill has high fixed costs, so the arithmetic works hardest in reverse: in 2024 a 20% fall in sales took 62% off earnings before depreciation.
Its record
The numbers
Is it growing?Steady
Sales grew 11% over the twelve months to Sep 2026, about the same pace as the 6.9% in the year to Dec 2025.
Is it profitable?Thin
It keeps 1.9% of sales as profit, down from 5.1% in the year to Dec 2023.
What does it keep on each sale?Razor-thin
It keeps 8¢ of each sales dollar after making what it sells, and spends 7¢ of it on selling and admin, its biggest running cost.
Does it earn good returns?Low
Shareholders' money earned 3.4% a year, down from 29% in the year to Dec 2021.
Is it making cash?Burning
Operations used $9.20M of cash, 0.7% of sales, before capital spending, which the filer does not tag.
Is the balance sheet safe?Net cash
It holds $98.6M of cash against $0 of debt, $98.6M more cash than it owes.
Are shares being diluted?Shrinking
The share count fell 22% in 4.8 years, and pay in shares costs 1.1% of sales.
Why it wins
The evidence
In ordinary bars there is little to stop a customer switching to a bigger mill. Defense is different. The Army has bought HF-1 from Metallus continuously since 1993, paid $99.75M for two new furnaces in Canton, and the Defense Logistics Agency gave it a five-year contract without competition to keep a supplier ready in an emergency.
That protection is the government's choice and its approval, not something a rival could never copy. The Army needs the steel badly: it makes 36,000 shells a month against a goal of 100,000.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
Steel Dynamics, Nucor and Gerdau already roll special bars up to 9 or 10 inches and win ordinary bar orders on price. None of their annual reports mentions shell steel, and no second approved maker was found. But the Army has paid to bring new suppliers into the shell chain before, so a second steel source is possible if it wants one.
Each rival
Steel Dynamics, Nucor and Gerdau's US special bar millsSTLDNUEGGB
The Army or the DLA qualifies a second HF-1 source at one of the larger US mills that already roll special bars up to 9 or 10 inches, and splits the shell steel.
Steel Dynamics, Nucor and GerdauSTLDNUEGGB
Gear, bearing and axle makers buy special-bar-quality bars up to 9 or 10 inches from these larger mills instead of Metallus.
Scot Forge and Frisaprivate
Buyers of very large round bars from 10 to 16 inches buy forged bars from these private forgers or offshore mills instead.
Tenaris and ArcelorMittal Tubular ProductsTSMT
Buyers of seamless mechanical tubing buy from these tube makers, or from Vallourec and TMK offshore, instead of Metallus.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
Each 155mm shell takes about 56 kilograms of HF-1 before forging and machining. At today's 36,000 shells a month that is about 24 thousand tons a year, worth about $73M at what Metallus earns per defense ton.
At the Army's goal of 100,000 a month it is about 67 thousand tons, about $202M. Stockpile buying, allies' shells, rockets and bombs come on top. The new furnaces can make enough for about 120,000 shells a month.
Who has signed
The Defense Logistics Agency can order up to $995M of HF-1 over five years, about 438 million pounds, but the ceiling is not a promise to buy. It has ordered about $125M so far, to be delivered within two years. The Army's $99.75M for the furnaces has been paid in full.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
Michael Williams has been chief executive since 2021 and retires at the end of 2026. Kristopher Westbrooks, who joined in 2018 as finance chief and now runs operations, takes over on 1 January 2027.
Directors and officers own 3.8% of the company and sold shares this year rather than bought. Their bonus pays mostly on cash earnings and cash flow; it paid 102.5% for 2025 although cash earnings missed their target.
What they did with the money
Since 2022 Metallus has bought back about a quarter of its shares, settled its convertible bonds and paid off its debt. In 2025 it put $62.0M into its pension fund. The Army and Ohio paid for the new defense furnaces, so the expansion cost shareholders little.
The last report
The latest report
Metallus's cash earnings rose to $34.5M and its call called the defense order new
What it did to the thesis Mixed quarter
The call backs the defense half of our case: the big order is new volume, not a swap. But it ships from spring 2027, the fourth quarter still falls back and price talks are unfinished.
The report
In the September 2026 quarter sales were $337.2M, up 10% from a year earlier, and adjusted EBITDA, a measure of cash earnings, rose to $34.5M from $29.0M, above the company's plan. It said defense sales reached an annual pace of $250M. The mill ran at 76% of capacity once power cuts are excluded.
The outlook is weaker: the fourth quarter has the yearly shutdown, which costs $10M to $15M, and 2026 adjusted EBITDA is forecast at $100M to $105M. On the call, managers called the new Army-logistics steel order extra volume, shipping from spring 2027, and said the fourth-quarter price dip is product mix.
What's happening now
The background
The shares rose 31% in six months, almost all of it because buyers now pay more for each dollar of sales, not because sales grew. The Defense Logistics Agency contract on 29 September added to the story.
This market has punished disappointments before: the shares fell by about a third after a soft outlook in 2024, and 16% in a day after a loss in February 2026. The next report, on 5 November 2026, shows whether the mill is catching up.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
A defense steel winner, with a sole-source contract and Army-funded furnaces that make this a munitions growth story.
We believe
Defense is real but a sixth of sales, and the price already assumes it lifts earnings 60% through a mill that is still under-running.
The argument
The contract's ceiling is not a commitment, and Metallus already sold this steel to shell makers before the agency bought directly, so some new orders may replace old ones. The mill is also still short of plan.
Against us: orders are up more than 50%, the industrial backlog has nearly doubled and price rises take full effect in 2027, so earnings may already be turning faster than last year's figures show.
What it's worth
How we value it
Valued on the analysts' revenue path for three years, each later year closing 30% of the gap to 4%, on official operating profit with stock pay a cost and tax paid in full; the thesis's own evidence is the check on that path.
The three cases
Bear case$8.27
Growth runs at half the analysts' path, 5% and 6%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 3.2%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.
Our value$9.73
Revenue grows 11% and 12% over three years, the analysts' path (C31), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin moves to 4.0%, the analysts' year-three figure after stock pay and on the filed basis (1.4% less).
Bull case$14.88
Growth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, 13% and 15%, the margin reaches 4.4%, and new capital earns 11%.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
The cycle turns
Most sales go to car and equipment makers; in 2024 a 20% fall in sales cut earnings before depreciation by 62%.
One site
All steel is made in Canton, so a furnace failure or a strike stops the whole company.
A second shell steel source
If the Army approves another mill for shell steel, the protected part of the business shrinks.
Budgets decide defense demand
Shell orders depend on government spending and on shell makers downstream, which management says it cannot see clearly.
The pension
Pension and retiree medical liabilities of $105.1M come ahead of shareholders, and contributions may resume after 2026.
The mill under-runs
Melting ran short of plan in the last quarter, mostly on the company's own execution and equipment reliability.
What we still do not know
How much of the agency's steel is new demand, and how much replaces steel Metallus would have sold to shell makers anyway.
Exactly how much steel each shell takes; no published bill of materials was found.
How large the US market for special steel bars is, and what share Metallus holds.
Who the customer is that bought 10.6% of 2025 sales.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
→ Neutral
The share price falls to about $11.68, back within 20% of what we think the business is worth.
→ Attractive
The share price falls to about $7.78, 80% of what we think the business is worth.
→ Attractive
Cash earnings pass $35M in each of two quarters in a row. Defense sales reach $62.5M a quarter, a pace of $250M a year.
The next test
It supports the case if
Adjusted EBITDA within or above the implied $12M to $17M, a first-quarter 2027 outlook that recovers to near the third quarter's $34.5M, melt utilisation above 75% without curtailments, and DLA volume described as additional to other defense orders.
It pressures the case if
Fourth-quarter adjusted EBITDA below $12M, a first-quarter outlook that stays below $30M, melt utilisation falling back to the low 70s, or defense sales below $50M.
We would also be wrong if
The agency orders nothing beyond the first $125M by the end of 2027.
Melting stays below 75% of capacity through June 2027.
The Army or the agency approves a second US source of shell steel.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growth
2 of 4
Business quality
2 of 4
Financial position
3 of 4
Execution record
2 of 4
Per share capture
3 of 4
Potential
2 of 4
Risk profile
2 of 4
Valuation
1 of 4
Evidence quality
3 of 4
How we weighed it
ValueNegative
The price sits above our value and above the bull case.
BusinessMixed
A mixed business: cyclical car steel, plus a growing defense line.
GrowthMixed
The defense order is new volume, but it ships later and the next quarter falls.
RisksNegative
The car cycle can turn, everything is made at one site and the Army may approve a second source.
RivalsMixed
No filed rival compares directly; against its own normal it is well dearer.
The groupMixed
It sits in none of our ranked groups; car production and defense budgets move it.
Latest newsMixed
The last report backed the defense half while the fourth quarter falls back.
In plain words
Our estimate of value
We forecast how much cash the business can earn over the next ten years and beyond, then ask what that stream is worth today to an investor who wants an 8% yearly return. We do it three times: a gloomy future, an expected one and a sunny one. We call a share Attractive only when its price is at least 20% below the expected estimate, and Unattractive when it is 20% above.