Metallus
This is the archived full research. Read the story
An Ohio steel mill that makes special bars and tubes for gears, bearings and drilling, and the steel the US Army's artillery shells are made from.
The scores
Growth2/4 ↑
Trailing sales grew 16% and orders over 50%, but 2025 sales were below 2021's after a 20% fall in 2024; only defense grows steadily.
Business quality2/4 ↑
A protected defense niche at about 1.6 times the revenue per ton, inside bar and tube markets where larger mills compete on price.
Financial position3/4 →
No debt, $108.6M of cash and $395M of liquidity, against a $105M pension and retiree medical liability and thin cash flow.
Execution record2/4 →
Won the defense business and bought back a quarter of the shares, but missed the 2025 EBITDA target and the mill keeps under-running plan.
Per share capture3/4 →
Diluted shares fell from 55.0M to about 43M since 2021 with small pay in shares; the pension still has a claim on cash.
Potential2/4 ↑
HF-1 for the Army's shell goal is worth about $200M a year and the DLA up to $995M over five years, against $1.2B of sales.
Risk profile2/4 →
One steelmaking site, one customer at 10.6% of sales, a union workforce, a pension, and defense demand set by budgets.
Valuation1/4 ↓
About 9.5 times operating profit before depreciation, 171% of a three-stage value near $9.73 at an 8% return: priced for perfection, beyond the 20% margin.
Evidence quality3/4 →
Results, the Army's figures and the Inspector General's count are public; the DLA's volume and the defense sales target rest on management's word.
The Verdict
We rate Metallus unattractive. It is a mixed business: most of its steel goes into car and equipment parts, a market that rises and falls hard, but it is also the Army's one funded source of artillery-shell steel, and that part is growing. The price is stretched. At about 9 times last year's cash earnings, the shares already cost what earnings about 60% higher, near the last peak, would usually justify. That needs the mill to run better and defense orders to add to sales rather than replace them. Both are plausible; neither is shown yet.
The long caseThe Army is rebuilding shell stocks and has chosen Metallus as its one funded source of shell steel; the mill must run better to turn that into earnings.
How we weighed it
The price against our value
Against it
Price at 171% of our value
The price sits above our value and above the bull case.
The business
Cuts both ways
Mixed
A mixed business: cyclical car steel, plus a growing defense line.
Growth against what the price assumes
Cuts both ways
The defense order is new volume, but it ships later and the next quarter falls.
What could go wrong
Against it
The car cycle can turn, everything is made at one site and the Army may approve a second source.
Against competitors
Cuts both ways
No filed rival compares directly; against its own normal it is well dearer.
How its group is behaving
Cuts both ways
It sits in none of our ranked groups; car production and defense budgets move it.
The latest news and report
Cuts both ways
The last report backed the defense half while the fourth quarter falls back.
The evidence under this - 6 claims
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: the Defense Logistics Agency order is described as new, shipping from the second quarter of 2027
2025's cash flow carried $62.0M of pension contributions that management says end in 2026 (C10), so cash from operations understates the business.
Defense sales carry about 1.6 times the company's revenue per ton (C03) and are growing on government-funded assets, so a richer mix could earn a higher multiple than the old cycle's median.
Adjusted EBITDA excludes items the company chooses; the vendor's EBITDA for the same period is lower, about $68M, so the multiple on it is 11.4 rather than 9.2 (C22).
The rate was still up on Q1, and the Army-funded furnaces commissioned in August are meant to lift throughput (C13), so the shortfall may already be narrowing.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: melt utilisation 76% adjusted for curtailments; the cost explanation again includes power interruptions.
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: curtailments sized at about 10,000 tons
The company
Metallus makes special-bar-quality steel: clean, precisely mixed steel bars up to 16 inches across, and seamless tubes, for parts that must not crack, such as gears, bearings, axles and drill tools. It melts scrap in electric furnaces in Canton, Ohio, and shipped 631.7 thousand tons in 2025 to about 330 customers.
Its best-known product is HF-1, a steel that breaks into many fragments, forged by others into 155mm artillery shell bodies. Buyers could get ordinary bars from Steel Dynamics, Nucor or Gerdau; HF-1 they cannot.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
How it makes money
Metallus sells steel by the ton. Each price has two parts: a base price, and a surcharge that passes changes in scrap and alloy costs to the customer a few months later. About 70% of orders are on annual agreements, so prices reset once a year.
In 2025 cars took 41% of sales, industrial equipment 35%, defense 14% and energy 9%. Defense earned $2,887 a ton, against $1,834 for the company as a whole.
The evidence under this - 4 claims
- Melt utilisation of 76% excludes a three-point curtailment; on the reported basis it was about 73%, below the 74% of June and the plan.
- Operating cash flow of $6.8M was largely absorbed by inventory, so the profit beat is not yet cash.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 results release read: the guide became a filed outcome (adjusted EBITDA $34.5M, melt 76% adjusted, defense run-rate reached).
Where the money comes from, stream by stream
| Stream | Share of sales (FY 2025) | How it earns it |
|---|---|---|
| Automotive | 41% | Bars and tubes for gears, bearings, axles and transmissions, sold mostly to parts makers under annual agreements. |
| Industrial | 35% | Bars and tubes for construction, mining and farm equipment, rail and bearings, about a fifth of it through distributors. |
| Aerospace and defense | 14% | HF-1 shell steel and other defense and aerospace bar, at about $2,887 of sales a ton. |
| Energy | 9% | Seamless tubes and bars for drilling tools and oil and gas equipment. |
| Other | 1% | Scrap and other sales. |
Who runs it
Michael Williams has been chief executive since 2021 and retires at the end of 2026. Kristopher Westbrooks, who joined in 2018 as finance chief and now runs operations, takes over on 1 January 2027.
Directors and officers own 3.8% of the company and sold shares this year rather than bought. Their bonus pays mostly on cash earnings and cash flow; it paid 102.5% for 2025 although cash earnings missed their target.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
Why it wins, and who could beat it
Why customers come back
In ordinary bars there is little to stop a customer switching to a bigger mill. Defense is different. The Army has bought HF-1 from Metallus continuously since 1993, paid $99.75M for two new furnaces in Canton, and the Defense Logistics Agency gave it a five-year contract without competition to keep a supplier ready in an emergency.
That protection is the government's choice and its approval, not something a rival could never copy. The Army needs the steel badly: it makes 36,000 shells a month against a goal of 100,000.
The evidence under this - 6 claims
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: the Defense Logistics Agency order is described as new, shipping from the second quarter of 2027
The ceiling is not a commitment (C14), and Metallus already sold HF-1 billets to shell makers as a subcontractor (S12), so some DLA steel may replace orders it would have had anyway.
The Army paid to bring a new metal parts maker into Mesquite, Texas when it needed more shells (C15), so it does fund second sources when supply falls short; the chief executive also says new entrants are coming into munitions (C29).
The threat
Steel Dynamics, Nucor and Gerdau already roll special bars up to 9 or 10 inches and win ordinary bar orders on price. None of their annual reports mentions shell steel, and no second approved maker was found. But the Army has paid to bring new suppliers into the shell chain before, so a second steel source is possible if it wants one.
The evidence under this - 2 claims
The Army paid to bring a new metal parts maker into Mesquite, Texas when it needed more shells (C15), so it does fund second sources when supply falls short; the chief executive also says new entrants are coming into munitions (C29).
The rivals: STLD, NUE, GGB, STLD, NUE, GGB, TS, MT, and 1 more that is private, in-house or listed abroad.
Who else does this, rival by rival
| Ticker | Rival | Where it competes | How far along | Priced against it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| STLD · NUE · GGB | Steel Dynamics, Nucor and Gerdau's US special bar millsPriced against it: Small part of it | Aerospace and defense steel | In research | Small part of it |
| Steel Dynamics, Nucor and Gerdau | Industrial, automotive and energy bar and tube | On sale | ||
| Private | Scot Forge and FrisaPriced against it: Private | Industrial, automotive and energy bar and tube | On sale | Private |
| TS · MT | Tenaris and ArcelorMittal Tubular ProductsPriced against it: Small part of it | Industrial, automotive and energy bar and tube | On sale | Small part of it |
How big it could get
How big this could get
Each 155mm shell takes about 56 kilograms of HF-1 before forging and machining. At today's 36,000 shells a month that is about 24 thousand tons a year, worth about $73M at what Metallus earns per defense ton.
At the Army's goal of 100,000 a month it is about 67 thousand tons, about $202M. Stockpile buying, allies' shells, rockets and bombs come on top. The new furnaces can make enough for about 120,000 shells a month.
The evidence under this - 4 claims
The 6,720 tons figure comes from trade reports of the Army agreement rather than the Army's own page, and some of that capacity serves rockets and bombs (C13).
Allies' shell programmes, foreign sales, rockets and bombs, and DLA's stockpile buying all use the same steel and are not counted (C13, C14).
Who has signed
The Defense Logistics Agency can order up to $995M of HF-1 over five years, about 438 million pounds, but the ceiling is not a promise to buy. It has ordered about $125M so far, to be delivered within two years. The Army's $99.75M for the furnaces has been paid in full.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: the Defense Logistics Agency order is described as new, shipping from the second quarter of 2027
The ceiling is not a commitment (C14), and Metallus already sold HF-1 billets to shell makers as a subcontractor (S12), so some DLA steel may replace orders it would have had anyway.
Where the growth is coming from, business by business
Where the growth is coming from
| Business | Share of revenue | Growth: last quarter | Last half-year | Last year | Share in 3 years at its half-year rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Special Bar Quality Bars | 65% | +18.7% | +19.8% | +20.6% | 76% |
| Manufactured Components | 23% | -3.1% | -7.2% | +3.4% | 13% |
| Seamless Mechanical Tubing | 10% | +6.6% | +5.9% | +3.8% | 9% |
| Other Products | 2% | +42.2% | +24.7% | +12.9% | 2% |
| Whole company | 100% | +12.0% | +11.0% | +13.8% | 100% |
On the filed split through 2026-06-30, if each business keeps its last half-year's growth, the company grows about 12% next year and 14% in year 3, against 16.1% over the last twelve months. Special Bar Quality Bars grows fastest: it grows 20% against -2% for the rest, and would be 76% of revenue by then. A scenario, not a forecast: no business holds its rate.
How we read it: The blend: bars grow faster than tubes largely on defense and industrial bar, which the score already credits, and both come from one mill exposed to one cycle.
The results
The numbers
Sales grew 11% over the twelve months to Sep 2026, about the same pace as the 6.9% in the year to Dec 2025.
It keeps 1.9% of sales as profit, down from 5.1% in the year to Dec 2023.
It keeps 8¢ of each sales dollar after making what it sells, and spends 7¢ of it on selling and admin, its biggest running cost.
Shareholders' money earned 3.4% a year, down from 29% in the year to Dec 2021.
Operations used $9.20M of cash, 0.7% of sales, before capital spending, which the filer does not tag.
It holds $98.6M of cash against $0 of debt, $98.6M more cash than it owes.
The share count fell 22% in 4.8 years, and pay in shares costs 1.1% of sales.
All the numbers
Filed figures from the company's 10-K and 10-Q, read 2026-11-10. Fiscal years end in December.
| Dec 2021 | Dec 2022 | Dec 2023 | Dec 2024 | Dec 2025 | 12 mo to Sep 2026 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Size and growth | ||||||
| Sales | $1.28B | $1.33B | $1.36B | $1.08B | $1.16B | $1.25B |
| Sales growth | +54% | +3.7% | +2.4% | −20% | +6.9% | +11% |
| Profit | ||||||
| Gross margin | 17% | 9.5% | 14% | 9.0% | 8.2% | 8.1% |
| Net margin | 13% | 4.9% | 5.1% | 0.1% | −0.1% | 1.9% |
| What growth costs, per sales dollar | ||||||
| Research and development | 0.1% | 0.1% | - | - | - | - |
| Selling, general and admin | 6.0% | 5.5% | 6.2% | 8.1% | 8.1% | 7.3% |
| Pay in shares | 0.6% | 0.7% | 0.8% | 1.3% | 1.3% | 1.1% |
| Cash | ||||||
| Cash from operations | $197M | $134M | $125M | $40.3M | $16.0M | −$9.20M |
| Balance sheet | ||||||
| Cash and short-term investments | $260M | $257M | $281M | $241M | $157M | $98.6M |
| Debt | $44.9M | $20.4M | $13.2M | $5.40M | $0 | $0 |
| Net cash | $215M | $237M | $267M | $235M | $157M | $98.6M |
| Returns and shares | ||||||
| Shares (diluted) | 55.0M | 51.5M | 47.8M | 44.3M | 41.9M | 43.1M |
What growth costs
Growth has not made the business more profitable lately. In 2025 sales rose 6.9% but prices fell and cash earnings slipped. One big mill has high fixed costs, so the arithmetic works hardest in reverse: in 2024 a 20% fall in sales took 62% off earnings before depreciation.
The evidence under this - 2 claims
Management expects August's price rises to be fully felt in 2027 and the new furnaces to lower costs (C07, C09), which would widen the margin on the same tons.
2025's cash flow carried $62.0M of pension contributions that management says end in 2026 (C10), so cash from operations understates the business.
The last report (2 Nov)
Quarter ended September 2026, filed figures.
In the September 2026 quarter sales were $337.2M, up 10% from a year earlier, and adjusted EBITDA, a measure of cash earnings, rose to $34.5M from $29.0M, above the company's plan. It said defense sales reached an annual pace of $250M. The mill ran at 76% of capacity once power cuts are excluded.
The outlook is weaker: the fourth quarter has the yearly shutdown, which costs $10M to $15M, and 2026 adjusted EBITDA is forecast at $100M to $105M. On the call, managers called the new Army-logistics steel order extra volume, shipping from spring 2027, and said the fourth-quarter price dip is product mix.
What it did to the thesisThe call backs the defense half of our case: the big order is new volume, not a swap. But it ships from spring 2027, the fourth quarter still falls back and price talks are unfinished.
The quarter in detail
Sales growth from the previous quarter, filed figures. The company has restated its own history, so a quarter either side of the restatement may describe a different business; n/c marks one that does not compare.
Earnings per share $0.35 against $0.30 expected.
The evidence under this - 5 claims
- Melt utilisation of 76% excludes a three-point curtailment; on the reported basis it was about 73%, below the 74% of June and the plan.
- Operating cash flow of $6.8M was largely absorbed by inventory, so the profit beat is not yet cash.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 results release read: the guide became a filed outcome (adjusted EBITDA $34.5M, melt 76% adjusted, defense run-rate reached).
The chief executive also said defense timing is 'a little gray', set downstream by shell makers the company does not control (C29), and industrial shipments fell slightly in Q2.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: management says the $250M defense run-rate was reached; the dollar quarterly figure is not in the release.
The rate was still up on Q1, and the Army-funded furnaces commissioned in August are meant to lift throughput (C13), so the shortfall may already be narrowing.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: melt utilisation 76% adjusted for curtailments; the cost explanation again includes power interruptions.
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: curtailments sized at about 10,000 tons
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: cash and liquidity re-struck at 30 September; borrowings are not stated in the release and are owed from the 10-Q.
The 2026 range implies fourth-quarter adjusted EBITDA of roughly $12M to $17M after the $88.1M of the first three quarters, about half the third quarter, so the earnings the price pays for in 2027 depend on the shutdown cost not recurring.
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: fourth-quarter price dip is mix; annual contract talks a third done
What management did with the money
Since 2022 Metallus has bought back about a quarter of its shares, settled its convertible bonds and paid off its debt. In 2025 it put $62.0M into its pension fund. The Army and Ohio paid for the new defense furnaces, so the expansion cost shareholders little.
Insiders in 2026Q3: 1 purchases and 0 sales, from their Form 4 filings.
The evidence under this - 2 claims
The trailing diluted count rose from 41.7M to 43.1M over the six months to June, as the return to profit counted more awards and the buyback slowed.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: cash and liquidity re-struck at 30 September; borrowings are not stated in the release and are owed from the 10-Q.
The price, and where we disagree
In short. Priced for perfection. The price is about 171% of what we think the business is worth, at an 8% yearly return.
The shares rose 31% in six months, almost all of it because buyers now pay more for each dollar of sales, not because sales grew. The Defense Logistics Agency contract on 29 September added to the story.
This market has punished disappointments before: the shares fell by about a third after a soft outlook in 2024, and 16% in a day after a loss in February 2026. The next report, on 5 November 2026, shows whether the mill is catching up.
The evidence under this - 4 claims
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: the Defense Logistics Agency order is described as new, shipping from the second quarter of 2027
- Melt utilisation of 76% excludes a three-point curtailment; on the reported basis it was about 73%, below the 74% of June and the plan.
- Operating cash flow of $6.8M was largely absorbed by inventory, so the profit beat is not yet cash.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 results release read: the guide became a filed outcome (adjusted EBITDA $34.5M, melt 76% adjusted, defense run-rate reached).
How we value it
- Method
- Cash the business will produce, in three stages
- Required return
- 8%
- Long-run growth
- 4%
- Moat
- No moat
| Bear | Base | Bull | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales growth, years 1 to 3 | 5.3%, 5.9% | 10.7%, 11.9% | 13.4%, 14.9% |
| Normal operating margin | 3.2% | 4% | 4.4% |
| Return on new capital after year ten | 8% | 8% | 11% |
| Value a share | $8.27 | $9.73 | $14.88 |
- Price
- $16.65
- Priced on
- 6 Nov
- Price as a share of the base value
- 171%
- Yearly return the price offers on the base case
- 6.7%
- Risk check: valued at 10%, the rate for a cyclical or indebted business
- $6.48
Where each figure comes from
| Figure | Source | Where exactly |
|---|---|---|
| Sales, the last twelve months | Filed report | Quarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the four quarters to that date. |
| Operating margin today | Data vendor | FMP's income statement, since the filer tags no operating profit line. |
| Tax rate | Filed report | Quarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the four quarters to that date. |
| Sales per dollar of new capital | Filed report | Annual report (10-K) for the period to 31 Dec 2025, filed 20 Feb 2026: the year's sales over its operating capital. |
| Shares | Filed report | Quarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the diluted share count. |
| Cash and investments | Filed report | Quarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the balance sheet on that date. |
| Debt | Filed report | Quarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the balance sheet on that date. |
| Sales growth, years 1 to 3 | Analysts' forecasts | FMP's consensus for the years to 31 Dec 2026, 31 Dec 2027 and 31 Dec 2028: the average of 1 to 3 analysts' revenue estimates, 10.6%, 12%. FMP publishes how many analysts, not who they are. |
| Normal operating margin | Filed report | The median operating margin of its last five filed years, since it sells at a market price it does not set. |
| Return on new capital after year ten | Our method's rule | Set by our reading of the moat: the 8% rate with none, 12% with an average one, 15% with a strong one; the bear case earns the rate. |
| The bear and bull cases | Our method's rule | Our method's spread: the bear case takes half the growth and a fifth off the margin, the bull a quarter more growth and a tenth more margin. |
| Price | Market price | FMP's closing price on 6 Nov 2026. |
What each case rests on
Bear caseGrowth runs at half the analysts' path, 5% and 6%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 3.2%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.
Base caseRevenue grows 11% and 12% over three years, the analysts' path (C31), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin moves to 4.0%, the analysts' year-three figure after stock pay and on the filed basis (1.4% less).
Bull caseGrowth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, 13% and 15%, the margin reaches 4.4%, and new capital earns 11%.
What moves the base value
| Lower | Higher | |
|---|---|---|
| Growth in years 1 to 3, a quarter lower or higher | $10.33 | $9.08 |
| The normal margin, 15% lower or higher | $7.32 | $12.14 |
| Capital per dollar of growth, a quarter more or less | $6.74 | $11.52 |
| Return on new capital after year ten, at the rate or one step up | $9.73 | $12.99 |
| The rate, a point higher or lower | $6.89 | $14.59 |
| Long-run growth a point lower | $9.76 | - |
Value a share as growth and margin change
| Normal margin ↓ · growth → | 50% | 75% | 100% | 125% | 150% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.2% | $8.25 | $7.42 | $6.51 | $5.54 | $4.49 |
| 3.6% | $9.57 | $8.87 | $8.12 | $7.31 | $6.44 |
| 4% | $10.89 | $10.33 | $9.73 | $9.08 | $8.39 |
| 4.4% | $12.21 | $11.79 | $11.34 | $10.85 | $10.34 |
| 4.8% | $13.52 | $13.24 | $12.95 | $12.63 | $12.29 |
Growth is shown as a share of the base case's. Green: the price is at or under 80% of that value. Red: at or over 120%.
How we read the multiple
A buyer pays for a recovery that has not happened yet.
1. Over the last four quarters Metallus earned $85.0M of adjusted EBITDA. 2. The company is valued at about 9.2 times that. 3. Over six years buyers have usually paid about 6 times. 4. At 6 times, today's value needs about $135M, close to what it earned at the 2022 and 2023 peak.
Defense steel earns more per ton, which could deserve a higher price than the old cycle did, but it is still a sixth of sales.
Against its own history. Buyers pay well above the company's own normal for its cash earnings, at a time when those earnings are well below their last peak.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
Defense sales carry about 1.6 times the company's revenue per ton (C03) and are growing on government-funded assets, so a richer mix could earn a higher multiple than the old cycle's median.
Adjusted EBITDA excludes items the company chooses; the vendor's EBITDA for the same period is lower, about $68M, so the multiple on it is 11.4 rather than 9.2 (C22).
2025's cash flow carried $62.0M of pension contributions that management says end in 2026 (C10), so cash from operations understates the business.
Priced against its rivals
None of the listed rivals above sells the same thing to the same buyers as a large part of what it does. Steel Dynamics, Nucor, Gerdau and Tenaris do too, but as a small part of much bigger companies, so their price says little about this one. A price comparison needs at least two, so the price is judged against its own history instead.
Private or foreign rivals that cannot be priced: Scot Forge, Frisa, TMK Group.
Where we disagree with the market
A defense steel winner, with a sole-source contract and Army-funded furnaces that make this a munitions growth story.
Defense is real but a sixth of sales, and the price already assumes it lifts earnings 60% through a mill that is still under-running.
The contract's ceiling is not a commitment, and Metallus already sold this steel to shell makers before the agency bought directly, so some new orders may replace old ones. The mill is also still short of plan.
Against us: orders are up more than 50%, the industrial backlog has nearly doubled and price rises take full effect in 2027, so earnings may already be turning faster than last year's figures show.
What analysts say, and the evidence
The evidence under this - 5 claims
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: the Defense Logistics Agency order is described as new, shipping from the second quarter of 2027
The ceiling is not a commitment (C14), and Metallus already sold HF-1 billets to shell makers as a subcontractor (S12), so some DLA steel may replace orders it would have had anyway.
The rate was still up on Q1, and the Army-funded furnaces commissioned in August are meant to lift throughput (C13), so the shortfall may already be narrowing.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: melt utilisation 76% adjusted for curtailments; the cost explanation again includes power interruptions.
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: curtailments sized at about 10,000 tons
Defense sales carry about 1.6 times the company's revenue per ton (C03) and are growing on government-funded assets, so a richer mix could earn a higher multiple than the old cycle's median.
The chief executive also said defense timing is 'a little gray', set downstream by shell makers the company does not control (C29), and industrial shipments fell slightly in Q2.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: management says the $250M defense run-rate was reached; the dollar quarterly figure is not in the release.
What could go wrong, and how we would know
The risks
- The cycle turns Most sales go to car and equipment makers; in 2024 a 20% fall in sales cut earnings before depreciation by 62%.
- One site All steel is made in Canton, so a furnace failure or a strike stops the whole company.
- A second shell steel source If the Army approves another mill for shell steel, the protected part of the business shrinks.
- Budgets decide defense demand Shell orders depend on government spending and on shell makers downstream, which management says it cannot see clearly.
- The pension Pension and retiree medical liabilities of $105.1M come ahead of shareholders, and contributions may resume after 2026.
- The mill under-runs Melting ran short of plan in the last quarter, mostly on the company's own execution and equipment reliability.
The evidence under this - 6 claims
2025's cash flow carried $62.0M of pension contributions that management says end in 2026 (C10), so cash from operations understates the business.
The Army paid to bring a new metal parts maker into Mesquite, Texas when it needed more shells (C15), so it does fund second sources when supply falls short; the chief executive also says new entrants are coming into munitions (C29).
The Inspector General's report has the Army planning to multiply metal parts output fivefold by September 2026 (C15), which makes demand look more visible than 'a little gray'.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: cash and liquidity re-struck at 30 September; borrowings are not stated in the release and are owed from the 10-Q.
The rate was still up on Q1, and the Army-funded furnaces commissioned in August are meant to lift throughput (C13), so the shortfall may already be narrowing.
- 2026-11-02editedQ3 2026 release: melt utilisation 76% adjusted for curtailments; the cost explanation again includes power interruptions.
- 2026-11-03edited3 November call read: curtailments sized at about 10,000 tons
What we still do not know
- How much of the agency's steel is new demand, and how much replaces steel Metallus would have sold to shell makers anyway.
- Exactly how much steel each shell takes; no published bill of materials was found.
- How large the US market for special steel bars is, and what share Metallus holds.
- Who the customer is that bought 10.6% of 2025 sales.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
The ceiling is not a commitment (C14), and Metallus already sold HF-1 billets to shell makers as a subcontractor (S12), so some DLA steel may replace orders it would have had anyway.
The 6,720 tons figure comes from trade reports of the Army agreement rather than the Army's own page, and some of that capacity serves rockets and bombs (C13).
What would change our view
- Unattractive→NeutralThe price falls back within 20% of fair value
It needs:
- ○The share price falls to about $11.68, back within 20% of what we think the business is worth.about ≈$10.87 today, 48% below the last close
- Unattractive→AttractiveThe price falls 20% under fair value
It needs:
- ○The share price falls to about $7.78, 80% of what we think the business is worth.about ≈$6.31 today, 70% below the last close
- Unattractive→AttractiveEarnings catch up with the price
It needs all of:
- ○Cash earnings pass $35M in each of two quarters in a row.checked at the next results, due by 18 Feb
- ○Defense sales reach $62.5M a quarter, a pace of $250M a year.checked at the next results, due by 18 Feb
We would also be wrong if
- The agency orders nothing beyond the first $125M by the end of 2027.
- Melting stays below 75% of capacity through June 2027.
- The Army or the agency approves a second US source of shell steel.
What is coming
- 5 November 2026 Q3 2026 results: Whether adjusted EBITDA passes $29.0M, the melt rate rises above 74%, and what the DLA order adds to 2027.
Every dated event ahead
- 5 November 2026 Q3 2026 results: Whether adjusted EBITDA passes $29.0M, the melt rate rises above 74%, and what the DLA order adds to 2027.
- 1 January 2027 Kristopher Westbrooks becomes chief executive: Whether the new chief executive sets targets for the mill's reliability and the defense run rate.
- 28 February 2027 Q4 2026 results and annual contract talks: 2027 prices on the 70% of orders under annual agreements, and the clearer 2027 defense picture management promised.
Since we wrote this
- 9 NovThesis reviewUnattractive: priced at 183% of a value near $9.12Re-valued in three stages at an 8% return, the method now drawn on every thesis: the price sits beyond the 20% margin of safety.
- 3 NovEarningsCall called the defense order new; view heldManagement said the defense order is new volume shipping from spring 2027 and the fourth-quarter price dip is mix, but earnings still fall back next quarter.
- 2 NovEarningsEBITDA $34.5M beat the plan, defense run-rate reached; Q4 guided lowerThe quarter beat, but the fourth quarter falls to about half and the recovery the price pays for is deferred, so Neutral holds.
- 6 OctThesis writtenNeutral, medium convictionWritten a week after the DLA's $995M sole-source contract, with the shares up 31% in six months, mostly on a higher multiple.
Sources 30
Sources - 30
Every claim above cites one of these, or states the reasoning that derived it. The quote is frozen at the date it was read: a link can rot, and an agent fetch returns a reading of a page rather than the page. Backs counts the whole claim ledger, so it can name a claim this page does not surface.
- S01primarycompany filing2026-02-20products, plants and capacity, end markets by tons and sales, base sales per ton, customer concentration, the union contract, the named competitors, the Army agreement, the pension and the FY2025 statementsbacksC01C02C03C06C10C11C12C13C19
- S02primarycompany release2026-02-19Q4 2025 and Q3 2025 results, adjusted EBITDA and the full-year reconciliationbacksC02C05C24
- S03primarycompany release2026-08-03Q2 2026 results, end-market shipments and sales, free cash flow, liquidity, buybacks, the Q3 outlook and the price increasesbacksC04C05C08C10C11C23
- S04primarycompany filing2026-08-04the balance sheet, pension and postretirement liabilities, the refinanced credit line and the Army funding receivedbacksC04C10
- S05primarytranscript2026-08-04Metallus Q2 2026 earnings call transcript (FMP), held 4 August 2026the order book, the industrial backlog, the $250M defense run-rate target, the ring gear award, the melt shortfall and its causes, and the share of the order book on annual agreements
We also continue to benefit from healthy demand across our end markets with the order book up over 50% year-over-year, providing strong visibility heading into the second half of the year.
backsC08C09C11C29 - S06primarycompany filing2026-03-12major holders, director and officer ownership, the 2025 bonus targets and results, and the performance share planbacksC25C26
- S07primarycompany filing2026-08-31Michael Williams's retirement on 31 December 2026 and Kristopher Westbrooks's appointment from 1 January 2027backsC27
- S08primarycompany release2026-09-29the contract type, the five-year ordering period, the $995M ceiling, the $125M first order and the 24 months allowed per order
This ceiling represents the maximum amount the DLA may order over the contract term and is not a commitment to purchase that amount.
backsC14 - S09primarycompany release2026-08-26the commissioning of the bloom reheat furnace and roller furnace at Gambrinus
For more than 30 years, Metallus has supplied specialty steel for essential Army artillery and mortar shell applications
backsC13 - S10primarygovernment data2026-09-02the Army's account of the capacity, Metallus's continuous HF-1 production since 1993, and the other munitions the steel serves
At full operational capacity, the plant will be able to produce enough HF-1 Steel to manufacture over 120,000 155mm metal parts monthly.
backsC13C16 - S11primaryregulator2026-07-09DoD Office of Inspector General, Evaluation of the Army's 155-mm artillery production (DOWIG-2026-095) DoD Office of Inspector Generalthe 36,000 a month production rate, the 100,000 goal, metal parts as the limiting factor, the three metal parts plants and Mesquite's failure, and the 3.6 million round drawdown
According to CPE A&E officials, as of March 2026, the production rate is 36,000 rounds per month, or 432,000 rounds per year.
backsC15 - S12secondarynews2026-09-26the sole-source basis of the award from the Defense Department's contract announcement, Metallus's role as a billet subcontractor, and the 1,500 to 6,720 tons a month expansion
The agency awarded it without competition under a federal rule that allows sole-source deals to keep a producer available for industrial mobilization or a national emergency.
backsC14 - S13secondarynews2026-09-27GovCon Feed: DLA hands Ohio steelmaker Metallus a $995M sole-source deal for 155mm shell steel GovCon Feedthe statutory basis, the end date of 24 September 2031, no options, the funding years, and the capacity in tons a month
In February 2024, the Army signed an agreement worth up to $99 million, funded through Ukraine supplemental appropriations, that raised the plant's HF-1 output from 1,500 tons a month to 6,720 tons a month.
backsC13C14C16 - S14secondarynews2026-10-05the volume ceiling, the 6.75-inch forged bar form and DLA Strategic Materials as the buyer
The five-year ceiling is about 438 million pounds of steel.
backsC14 - S15primaryother2026-10-06what an HF-1 shell weighs once finished and filled
The M795 is a 155mm high fragmentation steel (HF1) body projectile filled with 23.8 pounds (10.8kg) of TNT or IMX-101 and weighing approximately 103 pounds (47 kg).
backsC16 - S16primarycompany filing2026-02-27its Engineered Bar Products Division and the special-bar-quality bars it rollsbacksC19
- S17primarycompany filing2026-02-25its four bar mills focused on special-bar-quality steel and the markets they servebacksC19
- S18primarycompany filing2026-03-13its special steel business for the automotive industry, including North AmericabacksC19
- S19primarycompany filing2026-03-31that its seamless tubes are sold mainly to the oil and gas industrybacksC19
- S20secondaryvendor data2026-10-05Research pack (FMP market data, FINRA, SEC filed figures), frozen as research-pack.jsonprice, range and the price move split, the multiples against their own six-year medians, analyst estimates and the rating series, short interest, insider trades and the earnings reactionsbacksC21C23C24C25
- S21primarycompany filing2026-10-06five years of filed revenue, net income, pretax income, depreciation, cash flow, buybacks and diluted share countsbacksC05C06C11
- S22primarycompany release2024-08-08the Q3 2024 outlook of lower shipments and lower defense volumesbacksC24
- S23primarycompany release2024-11-07the Q3 2024 fall in sales and shipmentsbacksC24
- S24primarycompany release2026-08-04the aerospace and defense quality certification of the Canton bar and tube plants, valid to June 2029
today announced it has achieved AS9100D certification, a globally recognized quality management standard for the aerospace and defense industries.
read, but no claim rests on it - S25primarycompany filing2026-10-05the chief executive's sales and the Rule 10b5-1 plan boxbacksC25
- S26primarycompany filing2026-07-01the $300M asset-based credit line and its June 2031 maturitybacksC10
- S27primarycompany filing2026-11-02third-quarter sales, adjusted EBITDA, shipments, melt utilisation, cash and liquidity, and the fourth-quarter and full-year outlookbacksC07C08C09C10C30
- S28primarytranscript2026-11-03Metallus Q3 2026 earnings call transcript (FMP), held 2026-11-03the new Defense Logistics Agency order's timing, annual contract talks, the fourth-quarter price mix and the third-quarter power cuts
we are optimistic there will be future orders, but there's no guarantees for that
backsC09C14C30 - S29primarycompany filing2026-11-09trailing revenue, operating profit, stock pay, tax, debt, cash and the diluted share countbacksC32
- S30secondaryvendor data2026-11-09the analysts' average revenue and operating profit for the next three fiscal years, and the closebacksC31C32