Cricut's own annual report names every one of these attackers.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
Sales nearly halved; each sale kept more
Sales, $B
1.3
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.7
0.7
Dec 2021Dec 2022Dec 2023Dec 2024Dec 2025last 12 mo
Sales$1.31B → $708Mrevenue, 2021 to the past year
Per $135% → 59%kept per $1 after making it
Profit15% → 17%operating profit per $1
Selling and office costs rose as a share of a shrinking revenue.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
The market cannot be sized from outside
5.87 millionactive users, the floor
$55.77of app revenue per user
About 23%make things to sell
Nobody publishes how many US households craft with a cutting machine.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
A trust controls the votes
72.9%of the votes held by a trust
Since 2012Ashish Arora has run Cricut
60,000shares a day he sells under a pre-set plan
His 2025 bonus paid for beating profit even though machine sales missed.
The story right now · 9 · What drives Cricut's machine sales?
Machine sales rose and fell with crafting's boom
2021the sales peak, $1.31B
$709Msales in 2025, down every year since the peak
17%rise in machine and materials sales
Sales peaked in 2021 and fell for years after, as fewer new crafters bought machines. The latest quarter showed the first growth in five years.
The story right now · 10 · Why do investors disagree about Cricut?
A growing app over a shrinking machine business
Owners pay for the appGrowing slowly.
Machine units roseAt lower prices.
Rivals sell cheaperMachines and materials.
One quarter of growthNot yet a turn.
Bears see a shrinking gadget maker, buyers a cheap dividend payer. Both see one half of the company.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
Machine sales rose 17% and profit by half
$188.6Msales, up 11%
$33.9Moperating profit, up 50%
30.8 centskept per machine $1, from 23.1
49%share rise the next day
Solid quarter
App sales rose 4% to $85.9M as the subscription kept growing slowly.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
One good quarter, or a lasting turn?
Many investors think
A shrinking gadget maker, or a cheap dividend payer
We think
A growing subscription over a shrinking machine business
Against the turn: machines sold at lower prices, and every analyst left rates a sell.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
The price sits near our sunny future
$5.58what we think a share is worth · the last close is of that
$5.58our value
Attractive below $4.46
Neutral
Unattractive above $6.70
$4.79gloomy: growth halves and less kept per $1
$5.58our estimate: no growth
$6.78sunny: growth beats forecasts by a quarter
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
The price and our view · 14 · What if it all works?
As a bet on the turn, it is fragile
Priced for successthe kind of bet this is
0.8×if it works
53%kept if it fails
Multiples of the company's value when the bet was last struck, 4 Nov 2026.
If the turn holds the shares are worth about what they cost; if machine sales fall again, much less.
The price and our view · 15 · How could we be wrong?
Product sales falling again
Product sales fall againBiggest
One quarter is not a turn.
Cheaper rivalsShowing now
And store-brand materials.
TariffsWatch
Machines are made abroad.
How many cancelUnknown
Not disclosed.
A few big retailers carry most sales, and a trust controls the votes.
The price and our view · 16 · How will we know?
The holiday quarter tests the turn
Machine sales growing againGood sign
Paying owners risingGood sign
Machine sales falling backBad sign
MAR 20274
Fourth-quarter 2026 results, 4 March. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares fall to within a fifth of our estimate, we move to Neutral.
The price and our view · 17 · So, what do we think?
One good quarter, priced as a lasting turn
$5.58our value
Attractive below $4.46
Neutral
Unattractive above $6.70
UnattractiveHigh conviction
About 3.1 million owners pay for Cricut's design app, and machine sales finally rose. But one quarter is not a turn, cheaper rivals compete, and the shares rose by half on that report. Unattractive.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
Cricut makes small cutting machines for the home. You pick a design in its Design Space app, load vinyl, card, iron-on or fabric, and the machine cuts it with a fine blade. People use them for gifts, home decor, party supplies and things to sell.
It sells four families of machines, from the compact Joy to the Maker, plus blades, mats and materials, through Amazon, Michaels, Target, Walmart and others. In September 2026 it added the Maker 5, from $349, and StickerPix, a sticker printer and cutter from $299.
How it makes money
A dollar arrives in two ways. Products, the machines and materials, brought in $146.0M in the first half of 2026 and keeps about 23 cents of each dollar after making it, once one-offs are removed. Platform, mostly the Access subscription at $95.88 a year, brought in $169.8M and keeps about 89 cents.
So the machine is how an owner arrives, and the subscription is where the profit is made.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
Shrinking has cost Cricut leverage. As sales fell 46% from 2021 to 2025, sales and marketing rose from 10% of sales to 22%, and overheads from 4% to 10%. The operating margin held near 14% only because each sale kept more after making it, and in Q2 2026, without one-offs, it fell again.
Its record
The numbers
Is it growing?Shrinking
Sales fell 0.9% over the twelve months to Sep 2026, about the same pace as the −0.5% in the year to Dec 2025.
Is it profitable?Healthy
Operating margin is 17%, up from 9.1% in the year to Dec 2023.
Does growth pay off?Costly
Running costs take 42¢ of each sales dollar, up from 20¢ in the year to Dec 2021.
Does it earn good returns?Strong
Each dollar put into the business earns 23% a year after tax, down from 31% in the year to Dec 2021.
Is it making cash?Strong
The business brought in $183M of cash from operations, 26% of sales, before capital spending, which the filer does not tag.
How steady is it?Swingy
Yearly sales growth has ranged from −32% to +36% over the last 5 years, with sales falling in 4 of them.
Are shares being diluted?Stable
The share count fell 3.2% in 4.8 years, and pay in shares costs 3.6% of sales.
Why it wins
The evidence
Owners stay because their work lives in Cricut's app. Designs, uploads, fonts and machine settings sit in Design Space, which only runs Cricut machines, so leaving means buying a new machine and starting again. That shows in the numbers: from 2023 to 2025 paying subscribers rose from 2.77 million to 3.09 million while active users and sales fell.
The lock has a limit. In 2021 Cricut tried to charge owners for uploading more than 20 designs a month, and backed down within a week after users revolted.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
Cricut's own annual report names the attackers. Brother, Silhouette America, Loklik and others sell cheaper cutting machines. Store brands and marketplace sellers on Amazon sell vinyl and blanks that fit Cricut machines. And owners can buy single design files on Etsy or Creative Fabrica and upload them free, instead of paying for Access.
Each rival
Silhouette America (Cameo)private
Crafters buy a Cameo, a cheaper machine with free desktop software, instead of a Cricut and Access.
Brother (ScanNCut)BRTHY
Crafters, often sewers, buy a ScanNCut that scans a drawing and cuts it without a subscription.
Low-cost machines such as Loklik and xToolprivate
Cheaper imported cutters sold online take first-time buyers at a lower price.
Owners buy generic vinyl, mats and blades from third-party sellers instead of Cricut's.
Canva and Creative Fabricaprivate
Owners design in Canva or buy cut files from Creative Fabrica and upload them free, instead of paying for Access.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
There were 134.79 million US households in 2025. Nobody publishes how many of them craft with a cutting machine, so the market cannot be sized from outside; Cricut's own 5.87 million active users are the floor.
Each of those users brought in $55.77 of app revenue in 2025, so every million more users is worth about $56M a year. About 23% of users make things to sell.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
Ashish Arora has run Cricut since 2012. A trust controls 72.9% of the votes through ten-vote shares, and Arora holds 15.3%, so outside shareholders have no say.
His 2025 bonus paid for beating the profit target even though machine and materials sales missed theirs. Since August he has sold 60,000 shares a day under a plan set in advance; one director bought about 10,000 shares in May.
What they did with the money
Cricut hands its cash back. It pays a regular dividend twice a year, paid special dividends from 2023 to 2025, and in the first half of 2026 bought back 4.5 million shares for $19.7M. There was no special dividend in July 2026.
The last report
The latest report
Cricut's machine sales rose 17% and profit rose 50% in the September quarter
What it did to the thesis Strong quarter
It cleared both bars the thesis set: machine sales stopped falling and profit held above last year's. One quarter is not a turn, so the holiday quarter has to confirm it.
The report
Cricut's third quarter was the first to show the new machines working. Sales rose 11% to $188.6M. Machine and materials sales rose 17% to $102.7M, and operating profit rose 50% to $33.9M, with no one-offs named in the release.
The subscription kept growing slowly: 3.07 million paying owners, up 2%, and app sales up 4% to $85.9M. Machine and materials kept 30.8 cents of each sales dollar after making them, up from 23.1 cents a year earlier.
What's happening now
The background
The shares rose 49% the day after the Q3 print, the first quarter of product growth in five years. That turned a price that asked for the decline to stop into one that asks for the recovery to last.
The next test is the holiday quarter. Q4 results are due in early March 2027; another quarter of growth and a margin above 30 cents on the dollar would show the turn is real, and a fall would show the price ran ahead of it.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
A shrinking pandemic gadget maker past its peak, or, since August, a cheap, profitable dividend payer.
We believe
The subscription is real and growing, but the hardware half is still shrinking and the record quarter flattered the trend.
The argument
Analysts see only the decline, and the market cheered a record quarter. The filings show both are partly right: a subscription that keeps growing and earns most of the profit, under a hardware business that is shrinking and discounted.
Against us on the upside: machine units sold to shoppers rose by double digits in the first half, and new machines are out. Against us on the downside: those units sold at lower prices, and every analyst left rates the shares a sell.
What it's worth
How we value it
Valued on the analysts' revenue path for three years, each later year closing 30% of the gap to 4%, on official operating profit with stock pay a cost and tax paid in full; the thesis's own evidence is the check on that path.
What the price assumes
Sales growth in the first year, then slowing as ours does, at the same profit per sale.
The price assumed
25.3%
Our estimate
0%
Measured at the close of
6 Nov 2026
The three cases
Bear case$4.79
Growth runs at half the analysts' path, 0% and 1%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 9.1%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.
Our value$5.58
Revenue grows 0% and 1% over three years, the analysts' path (C45), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin settles at its five-year average of 11.4%, not today's cycle peak.
Bull case$6.78
Growth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, 1% and 2%, the margin reaches 12.6%, and new capital earns 11%.
The bet
Seen as a bet
The bet is that the new machines stop the fall in product sales while the subscription keeps growing, taking profit back above what it earned in 2025.
It now pays nothing: at what the bet assumes buyers pay for each dollar of profit, that recovery is worth less than today's price. If it fails and profit drifts down to what analysts expect, holders keep about half their money, because the cash and the subscription stay.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
Product sales keep falling
Machine and materials sales rose 17% in Q3 2026 after falling 22% in Q2; if the holiday quarter does not hold that, profit keeps shrinking under the price.
Cheaper rivals and store brands
Rival machines, store-brand materials and free design files compete for every part of the business except the app lock-in.
Tariffs
The machines are made in Asia; the refunds are one-offs, and the tariffs still in force raise what each machine costs.
A few big retailers
Seven retailers took 31% of 2025 sales, and one, JOANN, closed in 2025.
A trust controls the votes
A trust holds 72.9% of the votes, so outside shareholders cannot force a change of course.
The lock has limits
Owners revolted in 2021 when Cricut tried to charge for uploads, so it cannot squeeze subscribers hard.
What we still do not know
How many paying subscribers cancel each year, and how many new machine owners sign up; Cricut reports only the net number.
How many households craft with a cutting machine; nobody outside the company publishes it.
How much of Q2 2026's fall in product sales was lower prices rather than fewer machines sold.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
→ Neutral
The share price falls to about $6.70, back within 20% of what we think the business is worth.
→ Attractive
The share price falls to about $4.46, 80% of what we think the business is worth.
The next test
It supports the case if
Products revenue above Q4 2025's level and Products gross margin at or above 30%, with operating income at or above Q4 2025's $13.9M.
It pressures the case if
Products revenue below Q4 2025's level, or Products gross margin under 30%.
We would also be wrong if
App sales grow under 3% a year for two quarters running.
Machine and materials margins, one-offs removed, stay under 25% through 2027.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growth
1 of 4
Business quality
2 of 4
Financial position
4 of 4
Execution record
2 of 4
Per share capture
4 of 4
Potential
2 of 4
Risk profile
3 of 4
Valuation
1 of 4
Evidence quality
3 of 4
How we weighed it
ValueNegative
The price sits above our value and above the bull case, though the bear case is close.
BusinessMixed
A mixed business: a paying subscriber base, but falling product sales.
GrowthNegative
Sales barely grow on the analysts' path, even after the latest quarter.
RisksNegative
Product sales may slip again, cheaper rivals compete and tariffs hit the machines.
RivalsMixed
No filed rival compares directly; the price rose while sales per share fell.
The groupMixed
It sits in none of our ranked groups; hobby spending moves it.
Latest newsPositive
The last report cleared both bars the thesis set.
In plain words
Our estimate of value
We forecast how much cash the business can earn over the next ten years and beyond, then ask what that stream is worth today to an investor who wants an 8% yearly return. We do it three times: a gloomy future, an expected one and a sunny one. We call a share Attractive only when its price is at least 20% below the expected estimate, and Unattractive when it is 20% above.