←VALEValeOur view: AttractiveFull analysisעברית
Updated 16 Nov 2026
The company · 1 · Who is this company?

Vale digs iron ore in Brazil for the world's steel mills

Iron ore

the main ingredient of steel

About 13%

of the world's iron ore comes from Vale

Copper and nickel

a smaller second business

Steel is made from iron ore, and China's mills buy most of the world's. Vale's Brazilian ore is unusually rich in iron and cheap to dig, so it is one of the lowest-cost sellers.

The company · 2 · What exactly does it sell?

Iron ore is about four fifths of sales

Each $1 of sales, June quarter
66%15%12%12%
Iron oreCopperIron ore pelletsNickel and other metals

Richer ore needs less fuel in the furnace and leaves less waste, so mills pay a little more for it. China took 63% of Vale's ore in 2025.

The company · 3 · How does it make money?

It sells at the world price, so the price decides profit

$85.1a tonne received, 10% less than a year earlier
$60.4a tonne to dig and ship to China
39 centscash profit per sales dollar, held

Vale cannot set its price; it takes the market's. What it controls is its cost. Its profit is the gap between the two, so a lower ore price squeezes it fast.

Is it a good business? · 4 · What gives it an edge?

Few deposits are this large and this rich

About 65% iron

at its best mine, against 61-62% for standard ore

About $24 a tonne

to mine, level with Rio Tinto's

$6.2 → $4.4

extra earned per tonne for quality, in a quarter

The edge is real but narrowing: Vale sold a third less of its best ore and more middle-grade ore instead, so the extra it earns for quality fell.

Is it a good business? · 5 · What is the catch?

Far from China, with costs rising at home

10 daysfor Australian ore to reach China, against 40 from Brazil
+18%the cost of delivering a tonne to China in a year
About $6Bstill set aside for two dam collapses

Listed rivals: RIO · BHP · FMG.AX · FCX · SCCO

A stronger Brazilian currency and dearer fuel raised costs. Brazil's government also holds special shares that can block any sale of mines or railways.

Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?

Output has been flat for years; prices do the moving

Output, 2025336.1 Mtof ore, about 13% of the world's
Sales+19%on prices, June quarter
Costs+20%on freight and currency, same quarter

Vale's sales rise and fall with the ore price, not with how much it digs. Costs rose as fast as sales, so profit per dollar held but did not widen.

Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?

A huge market, but Vale earns from price, not growth

About $258Bof iron ore mined worldwide in 2025
336.1 Mtof iron ore produced in 2025, near its level for years
78.1 Mtfrom its oldest Northern mines in 2025, down from 91.3 Mt

With output barely moving, Vale's results depend far more on the price of ore than on selling more.

Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?

Nobody controls it, and the board just had a fight

Since 2024Gustavo Pimenta as chief executive
8%owned by Previ, a pension fund and the largest holder
0.02%owned by directors and officers

In July the chairman resigned in a fight with Previ, and shareholders elected an independent chair. Pay rides on returns against rivals, the return on money invested and safety.

The story right now · 9 · Why are investors gloomy?

China's demand is slowing as a huge new mine opens

63%of Vale's ore went to China in 2025
60 Mt a yearwhat Simandou, a rich mine in Guinea, aims for by late 2028
42.3%of analysts positive, down from 57.7% in February

China builds less than it did, so it needs less steel. Meanwhile Simandou in Guinea is starting to ship rich ore that buyers expect to cap the price of high-grade ore.

The story right now · 10 · What drives a miner's profit?

A miner sells at the market price and controls only its costs

  1. The world sets the ore priceVale got $85.1 a tonne.
  2. Vale digs and ships itFor about $60.4 a tonne.
  3. Profit is the gapAbout $25 a tonne, before other costs.
  4. A $10 fall in priceTakes away about two fifths of that.

That is why miners' shares swing so much. We value Vale on a lower ore price than today's, and buyers already pay about 4 times a year's cash profit, as if ore keeps falling.

The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?

Ore sold for 10% less, and costs held

$85.1a tonne of ore, 10% below a year earlier
$60.4delivered cost a tonne, inside the forecast
$4.4extra a tonne for quality, held
$16.4Bdebt including dam costs, above the $15B hoped

Mixed quarter

The shares fell 29% in six months while sales per share rose 7%, after a raised cost forecast, a board fight and a stalled listing of its copper and nickel business.

The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?

Is Vale cheap, or cheap for a reason?

Many investors think

A cheap miner held back by China and an African rival

We think

A good business under pressure, priced below even our gloomy case

Vale's own costs rose and its quality premium fell, so cheapness alone is no reason to buy. But the price already assumes a lower ore price, which is why conviction is High.

The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?

The price sits below even our gloomy future

$21.61what we think a share is worth
$21.61our value
Attractive
below $17.29
Neutral
Unattractive
above $25.93
$15.87gloomy: sales fall faster and profit slips
$21.61our estimate: ore sales shrink slowly
$30.46sunny: profit per dollar holds near today's

Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.

We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.

The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?

China, a rival mine and the state's veto

China buys most of itBiggest

China took 63% of Vale's ore in 2025.

Costs are risingShowing now

Delivered costs rose 18% in a year.

The state has a vetoWatch

Special shares can block any sale of mines.

Rules on cavesUnknown

New limits on older mines are not final.

Two dam collapses still carry about $6B set aside, and Simandou aims at the same mills by late 2028.

The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?

February shows whether costs and debt ease

Delivered costs under $60 a tonneGood sign
Debt falls toward $15BGood sign
Vale gets less than $80 a tonne for its oreWe turn negative
FEB 202728

Fourth-quarter results and 2027 targets. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.

Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares rise to within a fifth of our estimate, the cushion is gone and we move to Neutral.

The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?

Rich, cheap ore, priced for a lower ore price

$21.61our value
Attractive
below $17.29
Neutral
Unattractive
above $25.93

AttractiveHigh conviction

Vale's ore is rich and cheap to dig, and the price sits below our gloomy case, which already assumes ore falls. That cushion is why conviction is High, despite rising costs and China's slowdown.

↑ ↓ to move · C for contents