Vale digs iron ore in Brazil for the world's steel mills
Iron ore
the main ingredient of steel
About 13%
of the world's iron ore comes from Vale
Copper and nickel
a smaller second business
Steel is made from iron ore, and China's mills buy most of the world's. Vale's Brazilian ore is unusually rich in iron and cheap to dig, so it is one of the lowest-cost sellers.
The company · 2 · What exactly does it sell?
Iron ore is about four fifths of sales
Each $1 of sales, June quarter
66%15%12%12%
Iron oreCopperIron ore pelletsNickel and other metals
Richer ore needs less fuel in the furnace and leaves less waste, so mills pay a little more for it. China took 63% of Vale's ore in 2025.
The company · 3 · How does it make money?
It sells at the world price, so the price decides profit
$85.1a tonne received, 10% less than a year earlier
$60.4a tonne to dig and ship to China
39 centscash profit per sales dollar, held
Vale cannot set its price; it takes the market's. What it controls is its cost. Its profit is the gap between the two, so a lower ore price squeezes it fast.
Is it a good business? · 4 · What gives it an edge?
Few deposits are this large and this rich
About 65% iron
at its best mine, against 61-62% for standard ore
About $24 a tonne
to mine, level with Rio Tinto's
$6.2 → $4.4
extra earned per tonne for quality, in a quarter
The edge is real but narrowing: Vale sold a third less of its best ore and more middle-grade ore instead, so the extra it earns for quality fell.
Is it a good business? · 5 · What is the catch?
Far from China, with costs rising at home
10 daysfor Australian ore to reach China, against 40 from Brazil
+18%the cost of delivering a tonne to China in a year
About $6Bstill set aside for two dam collapses
Listed rivals: RIO · BHP · FMG.AX · FCX · SCCO
A stronger Brazilian currency and dearer fuel raised costs. Brazil's government also holds special shares that can block any sale of mines or railways.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
Output has been flat for years; prices do the moving
Output, 2025336.1 Mtof ore, about 13% of the world's
Sales+19%on prices, June quarter
Costs+20%on freight and currency, same quarter
Vale's sales rise and fall with the ore price, not with how much it digs. Costs rose as fast as sales, so profit per dollar held but did not widen.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
A huge market, but Vale earns from price, not growth
About $258Bof iron ore mined worldwide in 2025
336.1 Mtof iron ore produced in 2025, near its level for years
78.1 Mtfrom its oldest Northern mines in 2025, down from 91.3 Mt
With output barely moving, Vale's results depend far more on the price of ore than on selling more.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
Nobody controls it, and the board just had a fight
Since 2024Gustavo Pimenta as chief executive
8%owned by Previ, a pension fund and the largest holder
0.02%owned by directors and officers
In July the chairman resigned in a fight with Previ, and shareholders elected an independent chair. Pay rides on returns against rivals, the return on money invested and safety.
The story right now · 9 · Why are investors gloomy?
China's demand is slowing as a huge new mine opens
63%of Vale's ore went to China in 2025
60 Mt a yearwhat Simandou, a rich mine in Guinea, aims for by late 2028
42.3%of analysts positive, down from 57.7% in February
China builds less than it did, so it needs less steel. Meanwhile Simandou in Guinea is starting to ship rich ore that buyers expect to cap the price of high-grade ore.
The story right now · 10 · What drives a miner's profit?
A miner sells at the market price and controls only its costs
The world sets the ore priceVale got $85.1 a tonne.
Vale digs and ships itFor about $60.4 a tonne.
Profit is the gapAbout $25 a tonne, before other costs.
A $10 fall in priceTakes away about two fifths of that.
That is why miners' shares swing so much. We value Vale on a lower ore price than today's, and buyers already pay about 4 times a year's cash profit, as if ore keeps falling.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
Ore sold for 10% less, and costs held
$85.1a tonne of ore, 10% below a year earlier
$60.4delivered cost a tonne, inside the forecast
$4.4extra a tonne for quality, held
$16.4Bdebt including dam costs, above the $15B hoped
Mixed quarter
The shares fell 29% in six months while sales per share rose 7%, after a raised cost forecast, a board fight and a stalled listing of its copper and nickel business.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
Is Vale cheap, or cheap for a reason?
Many investors think
A cheap miner held back by China and an African rival
We think
A good business under pressure, priced below even our gloomy case
Vale's own costs rose and its quality premium fell, so cheapness alone is no reason to buy. But the price already assumes a lower ore price, which is why conviction is High.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
The price sits below even our gloomy future
$21.61what we think a share is worth · the last close is of that
$21.61our value
Attractive below $17.29
Neutral
Unattractive above $25.93
$15.87gloomy: sales fall faster and profit slips
$21.61our estimate: ore sales shrink slowly
$30.46sunny: profit per dollar holds near today's
Value per share in three futures. None is a prediction of the share price.
We estimate what a share is worth from the cash the business should earn over many years. Our rule: buy only when the price is at least a fifth below our estimate, as a cushion for being wrong.
The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?
China, a rival mine and the state's veto
China buys most of itBiggest
China took 63% of Vale's ore in 2025.
Costs are risingShowing now
Delivered costs rose 18% in a year.
The state has a vetoWatch
Special shares can block any sale of mines.
Rules on cavesUnknown
New limits on older mines are not final.
Two dam collapses still carry about $6B set aside, and Simandou aims at the same mills by late 2028.
The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?
February shows whether costs and debt ease
Delivered costs under $60 a tonneGood sign
Debt falls toward $15BGood sign
Vale gets less than $80 a tonne for its oreWe turn negative
FEB 202728
Fourth-quarter results and 2027 targets. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes on price alone: if the shares rise to within a fifth of our estimate, the cushion is gone and we move to Neutral.
The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?
Rich, cheap ore, priced for a lower ore price
$21.61our value
Attractive below $17.29
Neutral
Unattractive above $25.93
AttractiveHigh conviction
Vale's ore is rich and cheap to dig, and the price sits below our gloomy case, which already assumes ore falls. That cushion is why conviction is High, despite rising costs and China's slowdown.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
Vale sells the main ingredient of steel. A steel mill melts iron ore with coke in a blast furnace, and richer ore needs less coke and leaves less waste, so mills pay a little more for it and mix it with cheaper, poorer ore.
Vale's best ore, from Serra Sul in the Amazon state of Pará, holds about 65% iron, against 61-62% for the standard ore that sets the world price. It also sells pellets, small baked balls of ore, and mines copper and nickel through Vale Base Metals.
How it makes money
About four-fifths of sales are iron ore, sold at the world index price plus or minus adjustments for quality. Copper and nickel make most of the rest; copper alone earned $1.03B of cash profit in the June quarter, helped by record copper and gold prices.
Vale hands back a set share of its cash profit after the spending needed to keep mines running, at least 30% of it; in 2025 that came to $4.3B.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
Growth is not making Vale more profitable. In the June quarter sales rose 19% but costs rose 20%, so the share of each sales dollar kept as cash profit stayed at 39%. Delivering a tonne of ore to China cost 18% more than a year before.
Why it wins
The evidence
Few deposits are as large and as rich as Serra Sul: billions of tonnes at about 65% iron. That lets Vale sell ore that saves a mill fuel, at a mining cost of about $24 a tonne, level with Rio Tinto's in Australia.
The edge is real but narrowing. The extra Vale earns over the index fell from $6.2 to $4.4 a tonne in a quarter, as it sold a third less of its top-grade ore and more middle-grade ore instead.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
Simandou, a huge high-grade mine in Guinea built by Rio Tinto and Chinese partners, is shipping and aims for 60 Mt a year by late 2028, with rail and port room for 120 Mt. Its ore carries more alumina, which mills dislike, but buyers expect it to cap the price of high-grade ore. Australian ore also reaches China in about ten days, against forty from Brazil.
Each rival
Simandou (Rio Tinto, Chinalco consortium and WCS)RIO
New 65% ore from Guinea competes for the same high-grade slot in Chinese blends, up to 120 Mt a year through the shared corridor.
Rio Tinto and BHP in the PilbaraRIOBHP
Cheaper-to-ship 61-62% Australian blends a mill can use instead of Brazilian fines, about ten days' sail from China against forty.
FortescueFMG.AX
Lower-grade Australian ore sold at a discount to the index, the largest volume competitor after Rio and BHP.
Scrap-fed electric arc furnacesnot listed
Steel made from scrap needs no iron ore; China's growing scrap pool and emissions rules push mills that way.
Copper miners such as Freeport-McMoRan and Southern CopperFCXSCCO
Other concentrate for the smelters Vale sells Salobo and Sossego output to.
Other copper mine projects, such as Freeport-McMoRan's and Southern Copper's expansionsFCXSCCO
New concentrate from rival mines competes for the same smelter capacity and the same copper price Bacaba and Salobo's expansion are built on.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
The world mined about 2,600 Mt of iron ore in 2025, worth roughly $258B at the year's average price of about $99 a tonne. Vale produced 336.1 Mt, about 13% of it.
So Vale's results depend far more on the price of ore than on selling more: its volumes have barely changed for years, and its Northern mines produced less in each of the last two years.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
Gustavo Pimenta, finance chief from 2021, has run Vale since 2024; Marcelo Bacci runs finance. Nobody controls the company: the Banco do Brasil staff pension fund Previ owns 8%, BlackRock 7% and Mitsui 7%, while directors and officers together own a tiny 0.02%.
Most of the chief executive's pay is bonus and shares tied to returns against rivals, return on capital and safety. In July the chairman resigned in a fight with Previ, and shareholders elected an independent chair over the pension fund's preferred names.
What they did with the money
Vale pays out at least 30% of its cash profit after the spending that keeps mines running, and added $1B on top in 2025. It is buying back shares and has approved two copper projects at much lower cost than first planned. It wrote down its Canadian nickel business by about $3.5B in 2025.
The last report
The latest report
Vale's ore sold for 10% less, but costs stayed inside the forecast
What it did to the thesis Mixed quarter
Mixed against our test: costs stayed in the forecast and the premium held, but debt is above the hoped level and the ore price is lower.
The report
In the September 2026 quarter Vale's sales were $10.6B and its cash profit before dam charges $3.5B, down 20% on a year earlier and 14% on June, because iron ore sold for $85.1 a tonne, 10% less. The extra it earns for quality held at $4.4 a tonne.
Delivering a tonne of ore to China cost $60.4, inside the $58 to $62 forecast but 21% above a year earlier on the stronger real and dearer fuel. Debt including dam payments fell $264M to $16.4B, short of the $15B hoped for. Vale bought back no shares, and iron ore output is now expected at the low end of its range.
What's happening now
The background
Fewer analysts are positive than in February. Third-quarter results on 29 October left costs inside the forecast but debt above the hoped level; fourth-quarter results in February show whether that improves.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
A cheap, high-paying miner held back by China's slowdown and a rival African mine; most analysts say hold.
We believe
Fair at today's price: the ore business is good but under pressure, and nothing yet shows its costs or premium turning.
The argument
Most analysts say hold, and fewer are positive than in February. The market blames China and Simandou. The filings add something closer to home: Vale's own costs rose and the extra it earns for quality fell, so its cheapness is not by itself a reason to buy.
We would be wrong if costs fall back and the premium recovers, or if the price falls far enough to pay for much cheaper ore.
What it's worth
How we value it
Valued on the analysts' revenue path for three years, each later year closing 30% of the gap to 4%, on official operating profit with stock pay a cost and tax paid in full; the thesis's own evidence is the check on that path.
The three cases
Bear case$15.87
Growth runs at half the analysts' path, -3%, -3% and -3%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 20.4%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.
Our value$21.61
Revenue grows -2%, -2% and -2% over three years, the analysts' path (C51), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin moves to 25.5%, the analysts' year-three figure after stock pay.
Bull case$30.46
Growth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, -1%, -1% and -1%, the margin reaches 28.0%, and new capital earns 11%.
The bet
Seen as a bet
The bet is on Vale's new copper mines: Bacaba starting in 2027 and a larger Salobo plant in 2028. Even if both deliver in full, the whole company would be worth only a little more than today, because iron ore is so much bigger.
If no new copper comes, the iron ore and today's copper and nickel, at the price Vale usually trades on, less what it owes, still cover today's market value.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
China buys most of it
China took 63% of Vale's ore in 2025, and its steel output fell 4.4% that year and 3.7% in August 2026.
A rival mine arrives
Simandou aims for 60 Mt a year of high-grade ore by late 2028, aimed at the same mills.
The dams still cost
Two dam collapses, at Mariana in 2015 and Brumadinho in 2019, still carry about $6B of provisions.
The state has a veto
Brazil's government holds golden shares that can block any sale of the iron ore mines, railways or ports.
Rules on caves
A decree protecting caves limits mining in the older Northern mines, and its new terms are not final.
Costs are rising
A stronger Brazilian real and dearer ship fuel pushed delivered costs up 18% in a year.
What we still do not know
How much Simandou's ore will cut the price mills pay for Vale's best ore.
What the new caves decree will let Vale mine in its older Northern mines.
Whether Brasília would ever let Vale list or sell part of its copper and nickel business.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
→ Neutral
The share price rises to about $17.29, 80% of what we think the business is worth, so it is no longer cheap enough.
→ Unattractive
The share price rises to about $25.93, 20% above what we think the business is worth.
→ Unattractive
The price Vale gets for its ore falls below $80 a tonne at a quarterly print. The extra Vale earns for quality turns into a discount.
The next test
It supports the case if
All-in cost under $60 a tonne, the all-in premium at or above $4.4, and expanded net debt at or under $15.5B.
It pressures the case if
All-in cost above $62, the premium below $3, the realised fines price under $80, or expanded net debt above $17.5B.
We would also be wrong if
Debt including the dam payments rises above $20B, the top of Vale's own range.
Another dam fails, or the government moves to undo the 2026 board elections.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growth
2 of 4
Business quality
3 of 4
Financial position
3 of 4
Execution record
3 of 4
Per share capture
3 of 4
Potential
2 of 4
Risk profile
2 of 4
Valuation
4 of 4
Evidence quality
3 of 4
How we weighed it
ValuePositive
The price is about half our value and under the bear case, already assuming a lower ore price.
BusinessMixed
Rich, cheap-to-dig ore, but sold at the market's price, mostly to China, with the quality premium shrinking.
GrowthMixed
Sales are expected to drift lower, which the value already assumes; the new copper adds little to the whole.
RisksNegative
China's steel output is falling, a large rival mine aims at the same mills, the dams still carry costs and the state can block sales of key assets.
RivalsMixed
It is cheaper than both rivals, which mine other metals closer to China; it has traded at a discount for years.
The groupMixed
It sits in none of our ranked groups; what moves it is the ore price and Brazilian politics.
Latest newsMixed
The last report kept costs in the forecast and the premium held, but debt sits above the hoped level and the ore price is lower.
In plain words
Our estimate of value
We forecast how much cash the business can earn over the next ten years and beyond, then ask what that stream is worth today to an investor who wants an 8% yearly return. We do it three times: a gloomy future, an expected one and a sunny one. We call a share Attractive only when its price is at least 20% below the expected estimate, and Unattractive when it is 20% above.