If the mine stops for 60 days the buyer may take the whole Brazilian business at a fair value. Lynas already separates heavy rare earths in Malaysia.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
Sales are tiny and losses are large, until the mine runs
Sales$1.6M → $16.2Msales, 2025 to the last four quarters
Loss-$250.6Mlost before interest and tax, last four quarters
Cash$1,090.9Mcash, September 2026
Nearly all past sales are from Less Common Metals, bought in late 2025. The record that matters starts with the mine's first full quarter.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
The mine would be a small part of world supply
390,000 tonnesworld rare earth mine output, 2025
270,000 tonnesmined in China
6,400 tonnesPela Ema's Stage 2 target a year
A forecaster's figure in a rival's annual report puts the magnet rare earths at $7.8B in 2024. Nobody publishes the heavy rare earth market outside China.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
A new chief executive, from the mine it bought
Thras Moraitischief executive since October 2026, ran Serra Verde
9.1%of the shares held by officers and directors in April
$11.7Mpaid to the former chief executive for 2025
The executive chair bought 100,000 shares in January. Serra Verde's former owners hold about a third of the shares.
The story right now · 9 · Why does the source country matter?
China licenses heavy rare earths, and the US is shutting them out
April 2025China adds export licences on seven rare earths
2027Pentagon bars magnets mined or made in China
2,000 tonnesBrazil's output in 2025, up from 560
Buyers outside China now pay many times China's price for dysprosium and terbium, which is what makes a mine in Brazil valuable.
The story right now · 10 · What does the mine earn on each kilogram?
The buyer pays a floor, and shares any price above it
Mine and washClay is washed into a mixed carbonate.
Sell it allOne buyer takes Stage 1 for about 15 years.
Floor firstAbout $43 a kilogram at the floors.
Share the restAbout $97 at today's prices, after the buyer's 70%.
Today's high prices outside China roughly double what each kilogram earns, but the floors are all the buyer has to pay.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
The mine began shipping, but sales fell and targets slipped
$3.0MQ3 2026 sales, down from $5.8M
-$0.44adjusted loss a share, worse than analysts expected
325 tonnesof mine output promised for the fourth quarter
1 Octobera new chief executive took over
Mixed quarter
Round Top, the second Stillwater line and Less Common Metals' expansion each slipped one to three quarters this year.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
Will the new shares cost owners more than the mine adds?
Many investors think
The only US-listed heavy rare earth producer, with a government buyer, 78% below its high
We think
A real mine priced at record prices, before more than half again as many shares
Against us: the second stage on time with prices holding, or the equity raise met well above today's price.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
No single value here: the mine has only just begun to sell
2.2×if it works
16%kept if it fails
Multiples of the company's value when the bet was last struck, 16 Nov 2026.
The company lost $250.6M at the operating line over four quarters, so a value built on profits would rest on a guess. At the floors, the price is 13.2 times Stage 1's sales, before the new shares.
The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?
New shares, China's licences and the buyer's option
New sharesBiggest
About $1.55B required by end-2027.
LicencesShowing now
Prices hang on China.
Buyer's optionWatch
It may take the mine.
DelaysShowing now
Three targets slipped.
The Brazilian licence expires in December 2028 unless renewed, and the mine carries environmental notices from before the purchase.
The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?
Around 31 March shows the tonnes and the new shares
At least 325 tonnes sold in the fourth quarter, at prices above the floorsGood sign
A company value near 8 times Stage 1's sales at the floorsWe turn neutral
A large share issue near today's price, or fewer than 325 tonnesBad sign
MAR 202731
Fourth-quarter results and the equity deadline, 31 March 2027. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view also changes if Pela Ema sells at its 6,400-tonne rate with prices still above the floors.
The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?
A real mine, priced before the shares it still needs
Speculationthe kind of bet this is
UnattractiveMedium conviction
USA Rare Earth owns a scarce heavy rare earth mine with a government-backed buyer. But it loses far more than it sells, and the price pays for record prices before more than half again as many shares. Unattractive.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
USA Rare Earth, based in Oklahoma, is building a chain from mine to magnet outside China. Rare earths are metals whose magnets drive electric motors, wind turbines and guided weapons; the heavy ones, dysprosium and terbium, keep those magnets working when hot.
Its Pela Ema mine in Brazil washes rare earths out of clay. Less Common Metals in England turns rare earth oxide into metal and alloy, and a plant in Stillwater, Oklahoma, makes magnets.
How it makes money
In the third quarter of 2026, $2.8M of its $3.0M of sales came from Less Common Metals and $0.2M from magnets. The work cost $22.9M to deliver, a loss before any overheads.
From the fourth quarter the mine adds sales: all its first-stage output goes to one buyer at agreed floor prices, plus most of any market price above them.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
Growth has not yet paid. In the third quarter the work cost $22.9M to deliver $3.0M of sales, and over the last four quarters the business lost $250.6M at the operating line on $16.2M of sales. Whether scale pays waits on the mine's first full quarters.
Its record
The numbers
Is it profitable?Losing
Operating margin is −16×.
Does growth pay off?Unclear
Running costs take 1419¢ of each sales dollar, down from 3633¢ in the year to Dec 2025.
Does it earn good returns?Poor
Shareholders' money lost 4.9% a year, up from −125% in the year to Dec 2025.
How long can it keep going?Limited
It used $463M of cash over the last twelve months, so the $1.09B it holds lasts about 2.4 years at that pace.
Is the balance sheet safe?Net cash
It holds $1.09B of cash against $668M of debt, $423M more cash than it owes.
Why it wins
The evidence
Heavy rare earths are mined at scale almost only in China and Burma, and since April 2025 China requires a licence to export them. From 2027 the Pentagon may not buy magnets whose supply chain runs through China, from the mine onward.
Pela Ema is one of few such mines outside China, and a buyer backed by the government takes its first stage for about 15 years at floors of $575 a kilogram for dysprosium and $2,050 for terbium.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
MP Materials, the US rival, sells under its own government price floor and is building a second magnet plant. Lynas separates dysprosium and terbium in Malaysia. Private magnet makers Noveon and VACUUMSCHMELZE run US plants, and Energy Fuels is buying a metal maker. If China eased its licences, cheaper Chinese supply would compete at every step.
Lynas, the Australian producer separating dysprosium and terbium in Malaysianot listed
Heavy rare earth oxide from outside China.
Noveon Magnetics and VACUUMSCHMELZE, private magnet makers with US plantsprivate
Stillwater's magnets for US buyers.
Energy Fuels with KSM MetalsUUUU
Separated oxide from Utah and rare earth metal making that Less Common Metals sells.
Chinese producers, if export licences loosennot listed
Every step, at lower prices.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
The world mined about 390,000 tonnes of rare earths in 2025, 270,000 of it in China; Brazil mined about 2,000. A forecaster's figure in a rival's annual report puts the magnet rare earths at $7.8B in 2024. Nobody publishes the heavy rare earth market outside China, so its size cannot be counted; at the second stage's 6,400 tonnes, Pela Ema would sell about $621M a year at today's prices.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
Thras Moraitis, who ran Serra Verde, became chief executive on 1 October 2026; Rob Steele is finance chief and Michael Blitzer, whose acquisition company took the business public, is executive chair. Officers and directors owned 9.1% in April, and Serra Verde's former owners now hold about a third of the shares.
What they did with the money
The company raised $1.50B by selling new shares in January 2026, then paid $300.0M of cash and 126.8M shares for Serra Verde. It agreed to buy 13.6% of Carester, a French separation plant. Operations used $228.2M of cash over nine months and building spent $182.9M more.
The last report
The latest report
Sales fell and losses grew as the newly bought mine began to ship
What it did to the thesis Mixed quarter
It moved the case from plans to a running mine, but sales fell, losses grew and targets slipped, so the view rests even more on the mine's ramp and on how the new shares are issued.
The report
In the third quarter of 2026, sales fell to $3.0M from $5.8M the quarter before, as shortages of Chinese inputs held back Less Common Metals. The operating loss was $141.4M, swollen by deal costs; a gain on warrants turned it into a small net profit, and the adjusted loss was $0.44 a share.
The mine was bought in September and began selling in November, with at least 325 tonnes guided for the quarter. Several targets set in March slipped by one to three quarters.
What's happening now
The background
The next test is the fourth-quarter report, around 31 March 2027: whether the mine sold at least 325 tonnes, and how the company met or changed the equity raise its government agreements require by that date.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
The only US-listed heavy rare earth producer, with a government buyer, 78% below its high.
We believe
A real mine priced at record prices, before the new shares its build still needs.
The argument
The market sees the only US-listed heavy rare earth producer, with a government buyer, after a 78% fall, and analysts expect sales of about $611M next year. We see a price that pays for the first stage at today's record prices, before more than half again as many shares.
The evidence against us: the second stage on time with prices outside China holding, or the equity raise met well above today's price, would show the price was cheap.
What it's worth
How we value it
No fair value: USA Rare Earth lost $250.6M at the operating line over the last four quarters on $16.2M of revenue, and the mine that would earn a profit began selling only in November; the bet prices it instead.
The bet
This bet is on the mine-to-magnet build. If the second stage ran at full rate with today's prices outside China, and buyers paid a generous multiple of sales, the company would be worth a little over twice today's value; after the new shares the build needs, each share gains much less.
If prices fall to the floors and the second stage stalls, the first stage alone earns too little to cover the losses, and new shares keep coming.
The bet
Seen as a bet
This bet is on the mine-to-magnet build. If the second stage ran at full rate with today's prices outside China, and buyers paid a generous multiple of sales, the company would be worth a little over twice today's value; after the new shares the build needs, each share gains much less.
If prices fall to the floors and the second stage stalls, the first stage alone earns too little to cover the losses, and new shares keep coming.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
New shares
About $1.55B of equity is required by the end of 2027.
China's licences
Easier export licences would pull prices toward the floors.
The buyer's option
If the mine stops for 60 days, the buyer may take it at a fair value.
Licences in Brazil
The mine's licence expires in December 2028 and it carries environmental notices.
Slipping targets
Three targets slipped one to three quarters in 2026.
What we still do not know
What heavy rare earths actually sell for outside China, element by element.
How much of the second stage's output falls under the floor-priced offtake.
What Round Top would cost to build and produce, which no study has shown.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
→ Neutral
The whole company's value falls to 8 times the first stage's sales at the floors.
→ Neutral
Pela Ema sells at a 6,400-tonne yearly rate in a quarter of 2027 or 2028. Prices in that quarter stay above the floors, so the buyer pays more than the guaranteed price.
The next test
It supports the case if
At least 325 tonnes at a basket above the floors, Stage 1 on track for 4,000 tonnes by mid-2027, and the milestone met without heavy dilution or deferred.
It pressures the case if
Volumes below guidance, a basket falling toward the floors, or a large share issue near today's price.
We would also be wrong if
The equity raise due by 31 March 2027 is waived, deferred or met well above today's price.
Stage 1 runs at 4,000 tonnes a year by mid-2027.
China tightens its licences further and prices outside China rise again.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growth
3 of 4
Business quality
2 of 4
Financial position
2 of 4
Execution record
2 of 4
Per share capture
1 of 4
Potential
3 of 4
Risk profile
1 of 4
Valuation
2 of 4
Evidence quality
2 of 4
How we weighed it
ValueNegative
No fair value is drawn, since the mine has only just begun to ship. At the guaranteed floors the price is a high multiple of the first stage's sales, before the new shares.
BusinessMixed
A scarce deposit and a floor-priced buyer, but no margin earned yet, a royalty taken first and the buyer sharing most of any upside.
GrowthPositive
The mine's ramp would lift sales many times over, and analysts expect hundreds of millions of dollars next year.
RisksNegative
Prices set by China's licensing, a Brazilian licence to renew, environmental notices, a buyer's option on the mine and equity milestones that force new shares.
RivalsMixed
MP holds its own government floor and Lynas already separates heavy elements, but heavy rare earths outside China remain scarce.
The groupMixed
Government support for supply outside China is strong, but the listed group was priced on export-control headlines and fell hard this autumn.
Latest newsNegative
The last report missed on losses, revenue fell from the quarter before, targets slipped and the chief executive changed.
In plain words
Floor price
The least the buyer will pay per kilogram, whatever the market does. Above it, the mine keeps part of the higher price.
In plain words
Heavy rare earths
The rarer members of the rare earth family, chiefly dysprosium and terbium. A little of them keeps a magnet strong when it runs hot, as in an electric motor.
In plain words
Offtake
A contract in which a buyer agrees in advance to take a mine's output, here all of it, for years, and to pay even if it does not collect it.