Siebert runs ordinary brokerage accounts, but its larger business charges a fee to find shares that traders betting on a fall can borrow.
The company · 2 · What exactly does it sell?
Share lending is the biggest slice
Each $1 of revenue, first half of 2026
32%22%18%9%7%6%
Stock borrow / stock loanInterest, marketing and distribution feesPrincipal transactions and proprietary tradingCommissions and feesInvestment bankingOther income
Commissions, banking, advice and market making share the rest.
The company · 3 · How does it make money?
Fees on lending, interest on cash
$103Mrevenue in the past year
−5.5%operating profit per $1
64.8%of revenue goes on staff pay
Lending ties up the broker's capital, which fell as lending rose 49.7%.
Is it a good business? · 4 · What gives it an edge?
There is no lasting edge, and we say so
$2.7M
a quarter of commissions, heading to zero
Federal Reserve
sets the interest it earns
$17.5M → $5.6M
operating income, 2024 to 2025
Locate fees depend on how scarce a share is, which Siebert does not control.
Siebert charges $7.4M a quarter for a search others give their customers free.
Is it a good business? · 6 · What does its record show?
Revenue grew while the profit disappeared
Sales, $M
67.5
50.1
71.5
83.9
94.2
102.9
Dec 2021Dec 2022Dec 2023Dec 2024Dec 2025last 12 mo
Sales$67.5M → $103Mrevenue, 2021 to the past year
Profit9.8% → −5.5%operating profit per $1
Pay52.4% → 64.8%staff pay per $1 of revenue
New lines added cost before revenue, so growth cut profit per dollar.
Is it a good business? · 7 · How much room is there to grow?
A tiny slice of a large lending market
About $5.4BUS lending fees a year, by the SEC's arithmetic
$609.8Mof shares Siebert lends out
About 0.034%of American shares on loan
The market is large, but Siebert's share is a sliver and depends on scarce shares.
Is it a good business? · 8 · Who is in charge?
A family firm run by the Gebbias
2023John J. Gebbia took charge
42%of the shares held by the Gebbia family
September 2026a son joined the board
His sons run the broker-dealer, so the family decides most things.
The story right now · 9 · Why do traders borrow shares?
Traders borrow shares to bet on falls
About $5.4BUS lending fees a year
55.7%Siebert share rise in twenty sessions
A trader who expects a share to fall borrows it, sells it and buys it back later. Someone must find shares to borrow, and Siebert charges for that search. Scarcer shares fetch higher fees.
The story right now · 10 · Who gets the lending growth?
Staff pay rises faster than revenue
Lending revenue growsUp sharply.
Staff pay grows fasterTwo thirds of revenue.
A loss for ownersLast year.
Capital runs thinToward its floor.
Locate revenue growing while staff pay falls toward 52% of revenue would prove us wrong.
The story right now · 11 · What changed lately?
Revenue more than doubled into a loss
$31.2Msecond-quarter revenue
−$3.3Mfirst-half operating loss
$47.3Mbroker capital, down 23.3%
Unusual Whalesa partnership announced with no terms
Weak quarter
None of the announcements was filed with the SEC, which has had no current report from Siebert since November 2025.
The story right now · 12 · What is everyone arguing about?
Partnership news, or growth for staff?
Many investors think
No analyst covers it; partnership news lifted it
We think
Lending growth reaches employees, not owners
The announcements that moved the price state no terms and were never filed.
The price and our view · 13 · What is a share worth?
The price sits above the broker's own worth
No upsidethe evidence defends inside three years
82%kept if it fails
Multiples of the company's value when the bet was last struck, 8 Sep 2026.
We cannot value the media and crypto ventures, so we put no single value on a share. The broker alone is worth about four-fifths of today's price.
The price and our view · 14 · How could we be wrong?
Thin capital and pay outrunning revenue
Capital running thinBiggest
Fell toward its floor.
Pay outrunning revenueShowing now
Two thirds of revenue.
An undisclosed settlementWatch
Found in the filings.
The lending desk's profitUnknown
Not reported apart.
It also trades in a market nobody can see from outside.
The price and our view · 15 · How will we know?
November tests pay and capital
Staff pay falls toward 52%Good sign
Partnership terms filedGood sign
Capital falls againBad sign
NOV 2026-
Third-quarter 2026 results, November. Companies report every three months; each report is a test of the story.
Our view moves on these business events, not on a price line, since we put no single value on a share here.
The price and our view · 16 · So, what do we think?
A stock-lending desk inside an old discount broker
UnattractiveMedium conviction
Siebert's biggest business is now lending shares to traders betting on a fall. But staff pay takes about two thirds of revenue, the last year was a loss, and the price sits above the broker's own worth.
↑ ↓ to move · C for contents
What it does
More about the company
Who it is
Siebert sells two things through one broker that clears its own trades. The familiar one is an ordinary brokerage account. The larger one is securities finance: a short seller must first find shares to borrow, Siebert charges a fee to locate them, and it earns the gap between the rates on shares it borrows and lends.
In the June quarter that desk brought in $10.8M of $31.2M of revenue, with locate fees alone $7.4M. Interactive Brokers' customers run the same search free.
How it makes money
It has four streams: locate fees and the lending spread; commissions, now just $2.7M a quarter; interest on customers' cash and loans, set by the Federal Reserve and falling as rates fell; and a young investment banking arm, whose first-half revenue rose from $206,000 to $4.0M. None of it is under contract.
Growth and profit
What growth costs
Growth has been making Siebert less profitable. Its costs are mostly people and systems, and both have grown faster than sales as it added new lines, each of which spent money before it earned any. For now a bigger business means a thinner margin.
Its record
The numbers
Is it growing?Steady
Sales grew 13% over the twelve months to Sep 2026, about the same pace as the 12% in the year to Dec 2025.
Is it profitable?Losing
Operating margin is −5.5%, down from 25% in the year to Dec 2023.
How steady is it?Swingy
Yearly sales growth has ranged from −26% to +43% over the last 5 years, with sales falling in 1 of them.
How long can it keep going?Short
It used $15.7M of cash over the last twelve months, so the $9.07M it holds lasts about 0.6 years at that pace.
Is the balance sheet safe?Net cash
It holds $9.07M of cash against $4.94M of debt, $4.13M more cash than it owes.
Are shares being diluted?Diluting
The share count rose 32% in 4.8 years, and pay in shares costs 1.8% of sales.
Why it wins
The evidence
There is no moat, and the thesis says so. Commissions are being competed to zero, interest income is set by the Federal Reserve, and locate fees depend on how scarce a share is, which Siebert does not control. Its licence to clear its own trades is a barrier to starting, not to competing.
It shows in the profit: operating income fell from $17.5M in 2024 to $5.6M in 2025, and to a loss in the first half of 2026.
Who could beat it
The rivals in full
Interactive Brokers gives its customers free the locate search Siebert charges $7.4M a quarter for. Robinhood lends its customers' shares and has let them sell short since late 2025, taking both sides of the trade. And State Street, where lendable shares actually sit, runs the same business from the custody side; the SEC thinks a few such large programmes dominate.
The buyer stops paying anyone to find out whether a name can be borrowed: Interactive Brokers' own annual report says its customers search shortable availability from inside its platforms at no cost. That is the job Siebert charged $7,419,000 for in one quarter.
Both ends of the trade at once. Its fully-paid securities lending programme takes the retail lendable inventory a self-clearing broker rehypothecates, and its short-selling launch in the fourth quarter of 2025 takes the retail borrow demand - so the retail short seller who would have opened an account at a self-clearing broker no longer needs one.
State Street Corporation (agency lending and prime services)STT
The institutional borrower's reason to call a small broker at all. State Street borrows securities from lending clients or the market and lends them on to the subsequent borrower, its own client or a broker-dealer - the same trade, from the custody side where the supply actually sits.
Robinhood Markets, Inc. (crypto trading and Stock Tokens)HOOD
The reason a self-directed customer would open an account for digital assets at a small broker: a much larger app already sells crypto trading in every state and tokenised U.S. stocks abroad.
How big it could get
The market and who has signed
The market
The SEC's own arithmetic puts lending fees collected in the United States at about $5.4B a year, at an average fee of about 0.33% a year. Siebert's $609.8M of shares lent out is about 0.034% of the American shares on loan.
Who runs it
Leaders, pay and the cash
Who runs it
John J. Gebbia, a brokerage owner since the 1980s, has chaired and run Siebert since 2023; his sons run the broker-dealer, and one joined the board in September 2026. The family owns about two-fifths of the company and a Korean payments firm a fifth. Pay is salary plus a bonus the board sets by judgement, with nothing tied to profit or the share price: the chief executive's pay rose in the year profit fell by two-thirds.
What they did with the money
Little was returned and little raised: shares outstanding rose 2.4% in eighteen months, and none were sold under its $50M share-sale programme this year. The Gebbia family owns 42% and personally guarantees one of the company's bank credit lines.
The last report
The latest report
Siebert's revenue more than doubled to $31.2M, but its first half made a loss
What it did to the thesis Weak quarter
It backed our negative view. Lending fees grew, but staff pay grew faster and turned a profit into a loss, while the broker's capital shrank as lending rose. Nothing in it shows growth reaching owners rather than employees.
The report
Revenue more than doubled in the second quarter of 2026, to $31.2M, but a year earlier carried about $6.8M of investment losses, so the jump overstates the improvement. Locate fees grew 22.9% across the first half.
Costs grew faster. Staff pay took 64.8% of first-half revenue, and the half turned the previous half's operating profit of $4.7M into a loss of $3.3M. Meanwhile the capital the broker must hold fell 23.3%, to $47.3M, as its lending rose 49.7%.
What's happening now
The background
Nothing makes it urgent. The shares rose 55.7% in twenty sessions to 8 September on partnership announcements, including one with Unusual Whales that names no fee, volume, term or launch date. None was filed with the SEC, which has had no current report from Siebert since November 2025. No analyst covers the company, and it holds no earnings call.
Where we disagree
Both sides in full
The market
No analyst covers it. The price rose on partnership news, as if the lending growth will turn back into profit.
We believe
The growth line is a fee short sellers pay, and every dollar of it is going to employees rather than to owners.
The argument
The announcements that moved the price state no terms and were never filed, and the pay ratio sits only in the quarterly filing, in no release.
We would be wrong if locate revenue keeps growing while staff pay falls back toward 2024's 52% of revenue and the broker's capital recovers.
What it's worth
How we value it
The bet
The bet is on Siebert's new lines: its media and sports business, its planned crypto arm and the new funds it announced. The broker and its lending desk are counted apart, at what they own.
We can find no upside to defend. The media business lost money and was written down, the crypto arm has not started and the funds do not exist yet. If none of it ever earns, shareholders keep the broker, most of today's price.
The bet
Seen as a bet
The bet is on Siebert's new lines: its media and sports business, its planned crypto arm and the new funds it announced. The broker and its lending desk are counted apart, at what they own.
We can find no upside to defend. The media business lost money and was written down, the crypto arm has not started and the funds do not exist yet. If none of it ever earns, shareholders keep the broker, most of today's price.
What could go wrong
Every risk
The risks
Capital running thin
The broker's net capital fell to $47.3M against a bank's required floor of $43M, and neither filing says why.
Pay outrunning revenue
Staff pay rose $14.5M in 2025 on revenue up $10.3M.
An undisclosed settlement
It paid about $1.48M to settle an arbitration after June and names neither the other party nor the subject.
A market nobody can see
The rule that would publish stock-loan rates has been pushed to 2028, so the desk stays hard to check.
What we still do not know
Why the broker's net capital fell by $14.4M in six months.
What the lending desk earns on its own. It is not a reported segment.
Whether any 2026 partnership carries a fee, a volume or a term.
What changes our view
Every route to a new view
Every route to a new view
Research reopens
Siebert reports the lending desk as its own segment, with revenue and margin, so the case can be checked from the filings. Two straight years of operating profit across a full interest-rate cycle, with staff pay below 55% of revenue.
The next test
It supports the case if
Compensation stays at or above 62% of revenue, or stock locate services revenue falls sequentially, or MSCO's net capital falls again from $47.3 million.
It pressures the case if
Compensation falls below 58% of revenue with operating income positive, MSCO's net capital recovers, and stock locate services revenue grows again.
We would also be wrong if
The broker's net capital recovers above $60M while it keeps lending more shares.
A 2026 partnership is filed with the SEC, stating volumes and a term.
Locate revenue grows for four quarters in a row.
The verdict
Scores and how we weighed it
The scores
Growth
2 of 4
Business quality
1 of 4
Financial position
2 of 4
Execution record
2 of 4
Per share capture
3 of 4
Potential
2 of 4
Risk profile
2 of 4
Valuation
2 of 4
Evidence quality
3 of 4
How we weighed it
ValueMixed
No fair value is drawn: it earns almost nothing on its capital, so the price is read against the business itself.
BusinessNegative
A weak business: staff pay eats most of the revenue.
GrowthMixed
Lending fees grow, but staff pay grows faster than revenue.
RisksNegative
Capital is running thin, pay outruns revenue and a settlement went undisclosed.
RivalsMixed
No filed rival compares directly; its lower price reflects lower returns.
The groupMixed
Fintech names move together on credit and rate news; it ranks last in its group.
Latest newsNegative
The last report backed our view: pay turned a profit into a loss.