← All thesesUPSTNeutralLow convictionTuesday 17 November 2026עברית

Upstart Holdings

This is the archived full research. Read the story

The company whose software decides who gets a personal loan, and at what rate, for more than 100 banks and credit unions.

Our viewNeutral Low conviction
The scores
The profile · 1-4
Growth3/4 →

Revenue fell 39% in 2023, then grew 24%, 64% and 34% in Q3 2026, fees up 41%; the guide is cut and October slowed.

Business quality3/4 →

A data and model lead the regulator confirmed and a 64% core contribution margin, but Pagaya sells the same product and funders decide volume.

Financial position2/4 →

$1.6B of low-rate convertibles with no near maturity, but loans and loan securities it holds tie its capital to credit; funding is others' choice.

Execution record2/4 ↓

Profit returned in 2025, but the 2026 guide was cut, the 2025-2028 targets look out of reach, and the CEO and CFO are new.

Per share capture2/4 →

Stock pay of 11% of revenue is more than twice net income, and buybacks only partly offset it.

Potential2/4 →

A $293B pool of personal loan balances growing fast and secured loans just profitable, but Upstart can lend only what its buyers fund.

Risk profile2/4 ↓

One partner is 41% of revenue, profit swings with defaults, and the bank still needs two approvals.

Valuation4/4 →

About 2.13 times book, 50% of an excess-return value near $38: cheap on the base case, which itself needs a record return on equity.

Evidence quality3/4 →

Filed figures carry revenue, profit, funding and concentration, but the model's edge and the macro index rest mostly on management's word.

The bet · 2-3 years
Priced for success1.1×

If it works 1.1× · if it fails you keep about 69%.

The Verdict

We rate Upstart Neutral, with low conviction. Its software approves more borrowers at lower rates than a credit score, a regulator found, and its fees grew 41% to a record. But it lends only what banks and investors choose to fund each month, one bank brings two fifths of its sales, and profit returned only last year after three years of losses. The price is about half our estimate of its value, so it looks cheap, but that estimate needs Upstart's best year ever, repeated while more borrowers fall behind. As a bet on car and home loans it is priced for success. Steady profit would change our view.

The long caseIf AI prices auto and home equity credit as well as it prices personal loans, Upstart's fee on each loan follows into much larger markets.

How we weighed it

The price against our value

In its favour

Price at 50% of our value

The price is about half our base value and close to our bear case, so much of the bad news is priced.

The business

Cuts both ways

Mixed

A model the regulator found approves more borrowers at lower rates, but funding and volume are decided by others.

Growth against what the price assumes

Cuts both ways

Fee revenue grows fast, but the outlook was cut and October slowed as defaults rose.

What could go wrong

Against it

One partner supplies two fifths of revenue, profit swings with defaults, and stock pay exceeds net income.

Against competitors

Cuts both ways

Pagaya sells the same model to lenders, and banks fund their own borrowers on deposits.

How its group is behaving

Against it

Consumer lenders trade on the credit cycle, and delinquencies on personal loans are rising across the industry.

The latest news and report

Cuts both ways

Record fees and a first profit on secured loans, against a cut guide and a new chief accounting officer to find.

Where this departs from the fair value

The base case needs the return on equity to climb to its best filed year and hold through a cycle that once brought years of losses. Funders and defaults decide that, both are moving against it, so the discount is owed for that risk.

The evidence under this - 7 claims
C30estimatemedium confidence
Valued on its equity plus the earnings above an 8% return, the equity growing on the analysts' revenue path and the return on it rising to 16.8%, its best filed year, Upstart is worth about $37.87 a share in the base case, $13.05 in the bear and $67.34 in the bull; $19.09 is about 50% of the base.
derivedlib/fair_value.py excess-return arithmetic on $887.4M of equity (C11) and 98.9M shares (C13), a starting return of 7.3% from trailing net income (C04), the analysts' growth path (C28) held to 30% in year three, and a normal return of 16.8%, 2021's net income over its year-end equity (C04, C42).
against this

The return Upstart earned turned to losses in 2022-2024 (C04); if funding pulls back again the bear case near $13 is the closer reading.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
C04facthigh confidence
Net income was $135.4M in 2021, then losses of $108.7M in 2022, $240.1M in 2023 and $128.6M in 2024, then a profit of $53.6M in 2025 and $65.1M over the four quarters to September 2026.
historical · FY2021-TTM Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C08management claimmedium confidence
Management's Upstart Macro Index, its estimate of how the economy affects defaults, averaged 1.50 in Q3 2026 against 1.41 in Q2, and its latest reading was 1.53. It says each 0.01 rise, or 10 basis points of funding cost, cuts daily originations by roughly 1% to 2%. October originations were about $1.25B, daily volume down 9% on September and up 26% on a year earlier.
against this

The index is Upstart's own and unpublished; TransUnion's count of personal loans 60 days late rose to 4.12% from 3.52% (C31), which points the same way from outside.

current state · 2026-10-31written 2026-11-17
C09facthigh confidence
One lending partner, Customer A, was 41% of Q3 2026 revenue and 35% of the first nine months; two others were 13% and 12% of the quarter. In 2025 the top three lending partners originated 83% of loans and supplied 61% of revenue.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C16facthigh confidence
The CFPB reported in 2019, from data Upstart supplied under its no-action letter, that Upstart's model approved 27% more applicants than a traditional model and gave approved loans 16% lower average APRs.
historical · 2017-2019written 2026-11-17
C10facthigh confidence
In 2025, 64% of originations were bought by institutional investors, 26% kept by lending partners and 10% held on Upstart's balance sheet. Management says over 95% of loans outstanding are now third-party funded, its own loans are 4.8% of the total, and the equity it uses fell to 9% of platform loans from 11.6%.
against this

More than half of funding runs through committed partnerships in which Upstart co-invests (S01), so its capital still rides on the loans it does not hold.

current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C18facthigh confidence
In Q3 2026 secured originations, auto loans and home equity lines, were $587M, up 194%, and earned about $34M of fee revenue; their combined contribution margin turned positive at 17%, from minus 35% in Q2 and minus 179% a year earlier. The two segments outside unsecured lending lost $13.0M of contribution in the first nine months of 2026, after earning $5.8M in Q3.
historical · Q3 2026 and 9M 2026written 2026-11-17
01

The company

Upstart, based in California and founded in 2012, built software that looks at more than a credit score: job, education, bank data and how people use the site. It approves more than 90% of loans with no person involved.

More than 100 banks and credit unions use it to find borrowers. Beyond personal loans it now offers car loans, home equity loans and a credit line.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C01facthigh confidence
Upstart runs an online lending marketplace: a borrower applies on Upstart's site or a partner's, Upstart's AI models price and approve the loan, and one of more than 100 banks and credit unions, or an institutional investor, funds it. It offers personal loans, auto loans, home equity lines and a revolving Cash Line, and more than 90% of loans are approved with no human involved.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C15management claimmedium confidence
Upstart says its personal loan model used over 2,500 variables at the end of 2025, trained on nearly 104 million repayment events, and that in Q3 2026 it was 2.77 times as accurate as a traditional credit-score benchmark.
against this

No outside party has tested the 2.77 figure; the last regulator reading, the CFPB's, dates from 2019 (C16).

current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C16facthigh confidence
The CFPB reported in 2019, from data Upstart supplied under its no-action letter, that Upstart's model approved 27% more applicants than a traditional model and gave approved loans 16% lower average APRs.
historical · 2017-2019written 2026-11-17

How it makes money

Nearly nine tenths of sales are fees on personal loans, paid by the lender. About a tenth is the same fee on car and home equity loans. A small part is interest on loans Upstart keeps, less their losses. One lending partner alone brought 41% of sales in the third quarter.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C19facthigh confidence
Unsecured lending, personal loans, earned $330M of fee revenue in Q3 2026, up 30%, at a contribution margin of 64% against 62% a year earlier; its originations were $3.53B, up 33%.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C18facthigh confidence
In Q3 2026 secured originations, auto loans and home equity lines, were $587M, up 194%, and earned about $34M of fee revenue; their combined contribution margin turned positive at 17%, from minus 35% in Q2 and minus 179% a year earlier. The two segments outside unsecured lending lost $13.0M of contribution in the first nine months of 2026, after earning $5.8M in Q3.
historical · Q3 2026 and 9M 2026written 2026-11-17
C07facthigh confidence
Net interest income and fair value adjustments, the income from loans and securities Upstart holds, fell to $6.5M in Q3 2026 from $18.6M a year earlier; management said about half the sequential fall was write-downs as the macro index rose.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C09facthigh confidence
One lending partner, Customer A, was 41% of Q3 2026 revenue and 35% of the first nine months; two others were 13% and 12% of the quarter. In 2025 the top three lending partners originated 83% of loans and supplied 61% of revenue.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
Where the money comes from, stream by stream
StreamShare of sales (Q3 2026)How it earns it
Fees from unsecured loans89%Referral, platform and servicing fees on personal loans, small-dollar loans and Cash Line, paid by lenders and investors.
Fees from secured loans9%The same fees on auto loans and home equity lines.
Interest and fair value on loans held2%Interest on loans and securities Upstart holds, less the cost of funding them and changes in their value.

Who runs it

Paul Gu, a co-founder who built the software, became chief executive in May 2026; the other co-founder, Dave Girouard, stays on the board and owns 13.51%. Gu has bought shares with his own money three times this year. The finance chief is new, and the chief accounting officer leaves in November.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C22facthigh confidence
Co-founder Paul Gu became chief executive on 1 May 2026, succeeding co-founder Dave Girouard, who remains on the board; Andrea Blankmeyer has been finance chief since March 2026. The chief accounting officer resigned effective 30 November 2026.
current state · 2026-11-09written 2026-11-17
C23facthigh confidence
Girouard owned 13.51% and Gu 1.81% of the shares, and directors and officers 17.29%, at 31 March 2026; Vanguard held 7.33% and BlackRock 5.80%. The bonus pays on fee revenue with a net-income modifier, and performance shares vest in 2030 on four-year return against a fintech index.
current state · 2026-03-31written 2026-11-17
C24facthigh confidence
In the year to 16 November 2026 chief executive Paul Gu bought 50,000 shares on the open market at $20.57 on 11 November, after buys at $25.55 in September and $27.50 in May; Dave Girouard bought 169,940 at $29.37 in May. Finance executive Sanjay Datta sold 116,000 at $27.29 in September.
historical · 2025-11 to 2026-11written 2026-11-17
02

Why it wins, and who could beat it

Why customers come back

Every loan repaid or missed teaches the software, and Upstart has nearly 104 million repayments to learn from. In 2019 the US consumer finance regulator found its model approved 27% more people than a traditional one, at 16% lower rates.

That edge shows in what it keeps: on personal loans, 64 cents of each fee dollar is left after finding and serving borrowers.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C16facthigh confidence
The CFPB reported in 2019, from data Upstart supplied under its no-action letter, that Upstart's model approved 27% more applicants than a traditional model and gave approved loans 16% lower average APRs.
historical · 2017-2019written 2026-11-17
C15management claimmedium confidence
Upstart says its personal loan model used over 2,500 variables at the end of 2025, trained on nearly 104 million repayment events, and that in Q3 2026 it was 2.77 times as accurate as a traditional credit-score benchmark.
against this

No outside party has tested the 2.77 figure; the last regulator reading, the CFPB's, dates from 2019 (C16).

current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C19facthigh confidence
Unsecured lending, personal loans, earned $330M of fee revenue in Q3 2026, up 30%, at a contribution margin of 64% against 62% a year earlier; its originations were $3.53B, up 33%.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C20management claimmedium confidence
Management says the last 12 quarterly loan vintages have returned on average about 660 basis points more than US Treasuries.
against this

Fair value write-downs as the macro index rose (C07) say recent loans are performing worse than priced.

current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17

The threat

Pagaya sells banks a similar AI model. SoFi, a bank, lends to the same borrowers from its own deposits, and card issuers like Capital One hold the debt a personal loan would replace. A big bank could also build its own model.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C32facthigh confidence
Pagaya's 10-K describes a network connecting financial institutions and their customers with investors, using AI underwriting, which began in personal loans and has expanded into auto and point-of-sale loans.
current state · 2025-12-31written 2026-11-17
C33facthigh confidence
SoFi's 10-K reports its personal loan originations rose 56% in 2025, funded by its own bank's deposits.
historical · FY2025written 2026-11-17
C34facthigh confidence
Upstart's 10-K names no competitor; it lists classes: banks, non-bank and retail lenders, other fintech lending platforms, credit cards, which personal loans often replace, and technology companies selling lending software, and warns of new entrants with large machine-learning teams.
current state · 2025-12-31written 2026-11-17

The rivals: PGY, SOFI, COF, JPM, ALLY, FIGR, and 1 more that is private, in-house or listed abroad.

Who else does this, rival by rival
TickerRivalWhere it competesHow far alongPriced against it
PGYPagayaPriced against it: Not checkedUnsecured lending marketplaceOn saleNot checked
SOFISoFiPriced against it: Not checkedUnsecured lending marketplaceOn saleNot checked
COF · JPMCredit card issuers such as Capital One and JPMorgan ChasePriced against it: Not checkedUnsecured lending marketplaceOn saleNot checked
In-houseLenders' own credit-score modelsPriced against it: In-houseUnsecured lending marketplaceOn saleIn-house
ALLY · FIGRAlly and Figure in auto loans and home equity linesPriced against it: Not checkedSecured lending: auto loans and home equity linesOn saleNot checked
03

How big it could get

How big this could get

Americans owe about $293B on personal loans, up 9.0% in a year, and take out about 8.4 million new ones a quarter, a record, says TransUnion, a credit bureau. Upstart funded 574,089 loans in its latest quarter, so most of that market is still open to it.

The evidence under this - 2 claims
C31facthigh confidence
TransUnion reported that US unsecured personal loan originations rose 22.7% from a year earlier to a record 8.41 million in its latest quarter, balances rose 9.0% to $293.4B, and the share of borrowers 60 or more days late rose to 4.12% from 3.52%.
current state · 2026-11-05written 2026-11-17
C02facthigh confidence
In Q3 2026 originations were $4.1B across 574,089 loans, up 44%; revenue was $370.5M, up 34%, and fee revenue a record $364.0M, up 41%.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
04

The results

The numbers

Is it growing?Fast

Sales grew 39% over the twelve months to Sep 2026, slower than the 64% in the year to Dec 2025.

Dec 2021: $849MDec 2022: $842MDec 2023: $514MDec 2024: $637MDec 2025: $1.04B12 mo to Sep 2026: $1.34B$849M$1.34B
Is it profitable?Thin

Operating margin is 4.6%, up from −50% in the year to Dec 2023.

Dec 2021: 17%Dec 2022: −14%Dec 2023: −50%Dec 2024: −27%Dec 2025: 4.1%12 mo to Sep 2026: 4.6%17%4.6%
How steady is it?Swingy

Yearly sales growth has ranged from −39% to +264% over the last 5 years, with sales falling in 2 of them.

Dec 2021: +264%Dec 2022: −0.7%Dec 2023: −39%Dec 2024: +24%Dec 2025: +64%+264%+64%
Does it earn good returns?Low

Shareholders' money earned 8.0% a year, down from 24% in the year to Dec 2021.

Dec 2021: 24%Dec 2022: −15%Dec 2023: −37%Dec 2024: −20%Dec 2025: 7.5%12 mo to Sep 2026: 8.0%24%8.0%
How long can it keep going?Limited

It used $187M of cash over the last twelve months, so the $461M it holds lasts about 2.5 years at that pace.

Dec 2021: $160MDec 2022: −$667MDec 2023: −$113MDec 2024: $185MDec 2025: −$148M12 mo to Sep 2026: −$187M$160M−$187M
Is the balance sheet safe?Strained

It owes $1.57B more than the cash it holds, and its operations bring in no cash to repay it.

Dec 2023: −$672MDec 2024: −$614MDec 2025: −$1.18B12 mo to Sep 2026: −$1.57B−$672M−$1.57B
Are shares being diluted?Diluting

The share count rose 32% in 4.8 years, and pay in shares costs 11% of sales.

Dec 2021: 94.8MDec 2022: 82.8MDec 2023: 83.8MDec 2024: 89.5MDec 2025: 107M12 mo to Sep 2026: 125M94.8M125M
All the numbers

Filed figures from the company's 10-K and 10-Q, read 2026-11-17. Fiscal years end in December.

Dec 2021Dec 2022Dec 2023Dec 2024Dec 202512 mo to Sep 2026
Size and growth
Sales$849M$842M$514M$637M$1.04B$1.34B
Sales growth+264%−0.7%−39%+24%+64%+39%
Profit
Operating margin17%−14%−50%−27%4.1%4.6%
Net margin16%−13%−47%−20%5.1%4.9%
What growth costs, per sales dollar
Research and development16%28%55%40%25%25%
Sales and marketing39%41%25%26%29%31%
General and admin14%22%41%36%24%22%
Pay in shares8.6%15%34%21%13%11%
Capital spending1.0%1.0%0.3%0.1%0.0%0.4%
Cash
Cash from operations$168M−$658M−$112M$186M−$148M−$181M
Free cash flow$160M−$667M−$113M$185M−$148M−$187M
Balance sheet
Cash and short-term investments--$368M$788M$652M$461M
Debt$695M$986M$1.04B$1.40B$1.83B$2.03B
Net cash--−$672M−$614M−$1.18B−$1.57B
Returns and shares
Shares (diluted)94.8M82.8M83.8M89.5M107M125M

What growth costs

Growth is getting cheaper per dollar of sales: each employee now brings in nearly twice what one did in 2020, and Upstart turned a profit. But it pays staff about 11 cents of each sales dollar in shares, more than it earns.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C41facthigh confidence
Engineering and product development cost $92.7M in Q3 2026 against $64.0M a year earlier, and general and administrative $76.5M against $60.8M.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C05facthigh confidence
Q3 2026 GAAP operating income was $36.0M and net income $36.6M, $0.33 a diluted share; adjusted EBITDA was $89.3M, 24% of revenue, and contribution profit a record $218M, a 60% margin.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C14facthigh confidence
Stock pay was $175.0M in 2023, $133.4M in 2024, $132.0M in 2025 and $151.7M over the four quarters to September 2026, 11.3% of revenue.
historical · FY2023-TTM Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C36facthigh confidence
Headcount was 1,405 at the end of 2025, up 17.8%; revenue per employee was $742,959 against $421,329 in 2020.
historical · FY2020-FY2025written 2026-11-17

The last report (3 Nov)

Quarter ended September 2026, filed figures.

34%
Sales growth
against the same quarter a year earlier
1.6%
Growth from the quarter before
against 18.3% the quarter before that
10¢
Operating profit
per dollar of sales

In the third quarter of 2026 loans arranged rose 44% to $4.1B and fees rose 41% to a record $364M. Profit under accounting rules was $36.6M. Car and home equity loans made money for the first time.

But the interest earned on loans Upstart holds fell, because more borrowers are falling behind, and it cut its 2026 sales forecast to about $1.35B. October lending slowed.

What it did to the thesisIt showed the core lending business working, with record fees and a first profit on car and home loans, but rising late payments hit the loans it holds, which is the risk the case turns on.

The quarter in detail

Sales growth from the previous quarter, filed figures.

Earnings per share $0.33 against $0.20 expected; $0.33 as filed, with no adjustments.

The evidence under this - 6 claims
C02facthigh confidence
In Q3 2026 originations were $4.1B across 574,089 loans, up 44%; revenue was $370.5M, up 34%, and fee revenue a record $364.0M, up 41%.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C05facthigh confidence
Q3 2026 GAAP operating income was $36.0M and net income $36.6M, $0.33 a diluted share; adjusted EBITDA was $89.3M, 24% of revenue, and contribution profit a record $218M, a 60% margin.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C06management claimmedium confidence
Upstart cut its full-year 2026 outlook on 3 November: fee revenue of about $1.32B, total revenue of about $1.35B against about $1.4B before, and adjusted EBITDA of about $260M, 19%, against $294M.
against this

October originations of about $1.25B, with daily volume down 9% on September (C08), already point below the third quarter's pace.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
C07facthigh confidence
Net interest income and fair value adjustments, the income from loans and securities Upstart holds, fell to $6.5M in Q3 2026 from $18.6M a year earlier; management said about half the sequential fall was write-downs as the macro index rose.
historical · Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C18facthigh confidence
In Q3 2026 secured originations, auto loans and home equity lines, were $587M, up 194%, and earned about $34M of fee revenue; their combined contribution margin turned positive at 17%, from minus 35% in Q2 and minus 179% a year earlier. The two segments outside unsecured lending lost $13.0M of contribution in the first nine months of 2026, after earning $5.8M in Q3.
historical · Q3 2026 and 9M 2026written 2026-11-17
C37facthigh confidence
The shares fell 9.7% on 5 November 2025, 15.0% on 11 February 2026 and 7.9% on 6 May 2026, the sessions after three results; they rose 9.4% on 4 November 2026, the day after the Q3 2026 print, before falling to $19.09.
historical · 2025-11 to 2026-11written 2026-11-17
What management did with the money

Upstart bought back $100.1M of shares this year, paid off notes due in 2026, and borrowed cheaply through notes that turn into shares only far above today's price. It is putting about $404M into its own bank, which should let it fund loans with deposits.

Insiders in 2026Q3: 2 purchases and 11 sales, from their Form 4 filings.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C13facthigh confidence
98,906,930 shares were outstanding at 30 September 2026; Upstart bought back 3.2M shares for $100.1M in the first nine months of 2026, with $122.1M left on its plan. The diluted count of 125.4M in Q3 adds the shares the notes would convert into.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C12facthigh confidence
The convertible notes are 2% notes due 2029 converting at $45.66 a share, $500M of 1% notes due 2030 at $91.99, and $690M of 0% notes due 2032 at $82.50; the $66.5M of 2026 notes were repaid on 15 August 2026. Warehouse capacity is $650M, maturing 2027 to 2029, and a new $200M revolver was signed on 16 October 2026.
current state · 2026-10-20written 2026-11-17
C21management claimmedium confidence
Upstart Bank has the OCC's conditional approval; deposit insurance from the FDIC and the Federal Reserve's holding-company approval are pending. Management targets opening in early 2027 with about $404.1M of capital, funding the loans it holds with brokered deposits, and says that would leave over $1B of unrestricted cash.
against this

Two of three approvals are outstanding, and the cash figure is management's illustration on the Q3 balance sheet.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
05

The price, and where we disagree

In short. Cheap. The price is about 50% of what we think the business is worth, at an 8% yearly return.

Share price
$19.09
close,
Price for each $1 of net worth
2.1
its 6-year normal 5.3

The shares fell 48.8% in a year, to a 52-week low of $19.09, because buyers pay far less for each dollar of sales even as sales grew. They rose after the third-quarter report, then fell again.

The next check is the fourth-quarter report in February 2027, with a forecast for 2027. Upstart's own bank could open early in 2027 if two more regulators approve it.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C25facthigh confidence
The shares closed at $19.09 on 16 November 2026, down 48.8% in 252 sessions and 63.4% below the year's high of $52.10; the pack splits the fall into 21.3% more sales per share and 57.8% less paid per dollar of sales.
current state · 2026-11-16written 2026-11-17
C37facthigh confidence
The shares fell 9.7% on 5 November 2025, 15.0% on 11 February 2026 and 7.9% on 6 May 2026, the sessions after three results; they rose 9.4% on 4 November 2026, the day after the Q3 2026 print, before falling to $19.09.
historical · 2025-11 to 2026-11written 2026-11-17
C21management claimmedium confidence
Upstart Bank has the OCC's conditional approval; deposit insurance from the FDIC and the Federal Reserve's holding-company approval are pending. Management targets opening in early 2027 with about $404.1M of capital, funding the loans it holds with brokered deposits, and says that would leave over $1B of unrestricted cash.
against this

Two of three approvals are outstanding, and the cash figure is management's illustration on the Q3 balance sheet.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
C06management claimmedium confidence
Upstart cut its full-year 2026 outlook on 3 November: fee revenue of about $1.32B, total revenue of about $1.35B against about $1.4B before, and adjusted EBITDA of about $260M, 19%, against $294M.
against this

October originations of about $1.25B, with daily volume down 9% on September (C08), already point below the third quarter's pace.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
The betPriced for success
If it works
1.1×
from today's value, at the stated multiple
If it fails
keep 69%
of today's market value: the rest of the company, less its debt
How we value it
Method
The owners' book plus the returns it earns above the rate
Required return
8%
Long-run growth
4%
Moat
An average moat
BearBaseBull
Book growth, years 1 to 311.3%, 13.8%, 15%22.7%, 27.6%, 30%28.4%, 34.5%, 37.5%
Normal return on equity13.4%16.8%18.5%
Return on new capital after year ten8%12%15%
Value a share$13.05$37.87$67.34
Price
$19.09
Priced on
16 Nov
Price as a share of the base value
50%
Yearly return the price offers on the base case
10.4%
Risk check: valued at 10%, the rate for a cyclical or indebted business
$20.95

Where each figure comes from

FigureSourceWhere exactly
The owners' bookFiled reportQuarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the balance sheet on that date.
SharesFiled reportQuarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 30 Sep 2026, filed 3 Nov 2026; the diluted share count.
Book growth, years 1 to 3Analysts' forecastsFMP's consensus for the years to 31 Dec 2026, 31 Dec 2027 and 31 Dec 2028: the average of 11 analysts' revenue estimates; the owners' book grows on that path, held to 30% a year. FMP publishes how many analysts, not who they are.
Normal return on equityOur judgementOur reading of the evidence; each case below names it.
Return on new capital after year tenOur method's ruleSet by our reading of the moat: the 8% rate with none, 12% with an average one, 15% with a strong one; the bear case earns the rate.
The bear and bull casesOur method's ruleOur method's spread: the bear case takes half the growth and a fifth off the margin, the bull a quarter more growth and a tenth more margin.
PriceMarket priceFMP's closing price on 16 Nov 2026.

What each case rests on

Bear caseEquity grows at half the analysts' path, 11%, 14% and 15%, the return on it settles at 13.4%, a fifth under the base, and new equity earns only the 8% rate: the test if funding pulls back as in 2022.

Base caseEquity grows 23%, 28% and 30%, the analysts' revenue path (C28) held to 30% in year three, then fades toward 4%; the return on equity rises to 16.8%, its best filed year (C42), below the analysts' 2028 forecast near 20%.

Bull caseEquity grows a quarter faster, 28%, 35% and 38%, the return on equity reaches 18.5%, and new equity earns 15%, as if the bank lowers funding costs and secured loans add a second leg.

What moves the base value

LowerHigher
Growth in years 1 to 3, a quarter lower or higher$30.94$46.64
The normal return on equity, 15% lower or higher$34.74$41.00
Return on new capital after year ten, at the rate or one step up$19.75$51.46
The rate, a point higher or lower$27.65$55.13
Long-run growth a point lower$33.45-

Value a share as growth and margin change

Normal return on equity ↓ · growth →50%75%100%125%150%
13.4%$22.91$27.64$33.70$41.40$51.10
15.1%$24.21$29.29$35.79$44.02$54.37
16.8%$25.51$30.94$37.87$46.64$57.63
18.5%$26.81$32.59$39.95$49.25$60.90
20.1%$28.10$34.24$42.04$51.87$64.16

Growth is shown as a share of the base case's. Green: the price is at or under 80% of that value. Red: at or over 120%.

How we read the multiple

The shares are worth about $1.9B, about 2.1 times what Upstart owns minus what it owes, and about 29 times its profit over the last four quarters.

Analysts expect sales to grow about 29% a year to 2028. On that path, with profit climbing to Upstart's best year as a share of what it owns, we value the shares at about $38, $13 in our gloomy case and $67 in our sunny one.

Against its own history. Buyers now pay far less for each dollar of sales than a year ago, while sales per share grew.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C29inferencehigh confidence
At the 16 November 2026 close of $19.09 Upstart's 98.9M shares are worth about $1.89B, about 2.13 times its $887.4M of equity and about 29.0 times its trailing net income of $65.1M.
derivedClose of $19.09 (C25) times 98.9M shares outstanding (C13), against equity of $887.4M (C11) and trailing net income of $65.1M (C04).
against this

On the 125.4M diluted shares that count the notes as converted (C13) the market value is higher, but the notes convert far above the price (C12).

current state · 2026-11-16written 2026-11-17
C30estimatemedium confidence
Valued on its equity plus the earnings above an 8% return, the equity growing on the analysts' revenue path and the return on it rising to 16.8%, its best filed year, Upstart is worth about $37.87 a share in the base case, $13.05 in the bear and $67.34 in the bull; $19.09 is about 50% of the base.
derivedlib/fair_value.py excess-return arithmetic on $887.4M of equity (C11) and 98.9M shares (C13), a starting return of 7.3% from trailing net income (C04), the analysts' growth path (C28) held to 30% in year three, and a normal return of 16.8%, 2021's net income over its year-end equity (C04, C42).
against this

The return Upstart earned turned to losses in 2022-2024 (C04); if funding pulls back again the bear case near $13 is the closer reading.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
C28estimatemedium confidence
The analysts' average revenue is $1,357M for 2026, $1,753M for 2027 and $2,230M for 2028 (11 analysts), and their net income $44M, $153M and $278M.
against this

The 2027 figure needs revenue to grow 29% after a guide cut, with the macro index rising (C06, C08).

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
C04facthigh confidence
Net income was $135.4M in 2021, then losses of $108.7M in 2022, $240.1M in 2023 and $128.6M in 2024, then a profit of $53.6M in 2025 and $65.1M over the four quarters to September 2026.
historical · FY2021-TTM Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
Priced against its rivals

None of the listed rivals above sells the same thing to the same buyers as a large part of what it does. A price comparison needs at least two, so the price is judged against its own history instead.

The bet: what it pays if it works

The bet is on car loans and home equity loans. Loans arranged there nearly tripled in a year and just turned a profit, but they bring about $34M a quarter in fees.

If they grow to $400M a year, the shares would be worth only about a tenth more than today, because the price already counts on that growth. So this bet is priced for success.

Secured lending: auto loans and home equity lines revenue in two to three yearsDollars of secured loans originated a year neededAt the stated multiple
$200.00Mabout 3.4B at 100% kept0.9×
$400.00M (the big win)about 6.9B at 100% kept1.1×
$800.00Mabout 13.8B at 100% kept1.5×

To pay 2× (a Fair bet) it would need about $1.24B of Secured lending: auto loans and home equity lines revenue (about 21.3B dollars of secured loans originated a year); to pay 5× (a Cheap bet), about $4.07B of Secured lending: auto loans and home equity lines revenue (about 70.2B dollars of secured loans originated a year), at the same multiple.

Each row is Secured lending: auto loans and home equity lines alone, plus the rest of the company (Unsecured lending marketplace: personal loans, small-dollar loans and Cash Line) counted at about $1.30B.

The steps it has to take

  • Done Auto and home equity lending launched with partners
  • Done Secured contribution margin positive
  • In progress Secured loans funded by credit-union partners at scale due 2027-12
  • Not started Secured segments profitable for a full year due 2027-12
The detail behind the label
Rating
Expensive
the big win's payoff against the 2× and 5× lines
Cheap bet at about
$4.25
78% below the price (close, )
The option
1.4×
what Secured lending: auto loans and home equity lines is worth if it works, against what the price pays for it
The evidence under this - 3 claims
C18facthigh confidence
In Q3 2026 secured originations, auto loans and home equity lines, were $587M, up 194%, and earned about $34M of fee revenue; their combined contribution margin turned positive at 17%, from minus 35% in Q2 and minus 179% a year earlier. The two segments outside unsecured lending lost $13.0M of contribution in the first nine months of 2026, after earning $5.8M in Q3.
historical · Q3 2026 and 9M 2026written 2026-11-17
C29inferencehigh confidence
At the 16 November 2026 close of $19.09 Upstart's 98.9M shares are worth about $1.89B, about 2.13 times its $887.4M of equity and about 29.0 times its trailing net income of $65.1M.
derivedClose of $19.09 (C25) times 98.9M shares outstanding (C13), against equity of $887.4M (C11) and trailing net income of $65.1M (C04).
against this

On the 125.4M diluted shares that count the notes as converted (C13) the market value is higher, but the notes convert far above the price (C12).

current state · 2026-11-16written 2026-11-17
C04facthigh confidence
Net income was $135.4M in 2021, then losses of $108.7M in 2022, $240.1M in 2023 and $128.6M in 2024, then a profit of $53.6M in 2025 and $65.1M over the four quarters to September 2026.
historical · FY2021-TTM Q3 2026written 2026-11-17

Where we disagree with the market

The market believes

A lender that rises and falls with the economy, whose AI has not yet made steady money.

We believe

The AI is a real edge and the price is low, but steady profit depends on funders and late payments Upstart cannot control.

Analysts are split evenly, and nearly a third of the shares that trade are bet against it, while the chief executive buys. We agree the shares look cheap, but our value needs a record year that lasts.

Where we could be wrong: if Upstart earns 12% a year on what it owns for four quarters while late payments stay high, the cheap price would be the real story.

What analysts say, and the evidence
Analysts positive
50%
of 16, 1 Nov
Four months earlier
53%
of 15, 1 Jul
The evidence under this - 5 claims
C26facthigh confidence
Analysts rate Upstart 10 buy, 10 hold and 2 sell; the series reads 50% positive of 16.
current state · 2026-11-16written 2026-11-17
C27facthigh confidence
Short interest was 26.5M shares, 31.3% of the float and 7.9 days of trading, at the 30 October 2026 settlement.
current state · 2026-10-30written 2026-11-17
C30estimatemedium confidence
Valued on its equity plus the earnings above an 8% return, the equity growing on the analysts' revenue path and the return on it rising to 16.8%, its best filed year, Upstart is worth about $37.87 a share in the base case, $13.05 in the bear and $67.34 in the bull; $19.09 is about 50% of the base.
derivedlib/fair_value.py excess-return arithmetic on $887.4M of equity (C11) and 98.9M shares (C13), a starting return of 7.3% from trailing net income (C04), the analysts' growth path (C28) held to 30% in year three, and a normal return of 16.8%, 2021's net income over its year-end equity (C04, C42).
against this

The return Upstart earned turned to losses in 2022-2024 (C04); if funding pulls back again the bear case near $13 is the closer reading.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
C04facthigh confidence
Net income was $135.4M in 2021, then losses of $108.7M in 2022, $240.1M in 2023 and $128.6M in 2024, then a profit of $53.6M in 2025 and $65.1M over the four quarters to September 2026.
historical · FY2021-TTM Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C24facthigh confidence
In the year to 16 November 2026 chief executive Paul Gu bought 50,000 shares on the open market at $20.57 on 11 November, after buys at $25.55 in September and $27.50 in May; Dave Girouard bought 169,940 at $29.37 in May. Finance executive Sanjay Datta sold 116,000 at $27.29 in September.
historical · 2025-11 to 2026-11written 2026-11-17
06

What could go wrong, and how we would know

The risks

  • One big partner. A single bank brought 41% of sales last quarter and could move its lending.
  • Others decide the money. Banks and investors choose each month how many loans to fund; in 2022 they pulled back and sales fell.
  • Late payments. As more borrowers fall behind, Upstart approves fewer loans and the loans it holds lose value.
  • Shares paid to staff. Upstart pays staff more in shares than it earns in profit.
  • The bank may wait. Two regulators still have to approve its bank.
The evidence under this - 5 claims
C09facthigh confidence
One lending partner, Customer A, was 41% of Q3 2026 revenue and 35% of the first nine months; two others were 13% and 12% of the quarter. In 2025 the top three lending partners originated 83% of loans and supplied 61% of revenue.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C10facthigh confidence
In 2025, 64% of originations were bought by institutional investors, 26% kept by lending partners and 10% held on Upstart's balance sheet. Management says over 95% of loans outstanding are now third-party funded, its own loans are 4.8% of the total, and the equity it uses fell to 9% of platform loans from 11.6%.
against this

More than half of funding runs through committed partnerships in which Upstart co-invests (S01), so its capital still rides on the loans it does not hold.

current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C08management claimmedium confidence
Management's Upstart Macro Index, its estimate of how the economy affects defaults, averaged 1.50 in Q3 2026 against 1.41 in Q2, and its latest reading was 1.53. It says each 0.01 rise, or 10 basis points of funding cost, cuts daily originations by roughly 1% to 2%. October originations were about $1.25B, daily volume down 9% on September and up 26% on a year earlier.
against this

The index is Upstart's own and unpublished; TransUnion's count of personal loans 60 days late rose to 4.12% from 3.52% (C31), which points the same way from outside.

current state · 2026-10-31written 2026-11-17
C14facthigh confidence
Stock pay was $175.0M in 2023, $133.4M in 2024, $132.0M in 2025 and $151.7M over the four quarters to September 2026, 11.3% of revenue.
historical · FY2023-TTM Q3 2026written 2026-11-17
C21management claimmedium confidence
Upstart Bank has the OCC's conditional approval; deposit insurance from the FDIC and the Federal Reserve's holding-company approval are pending. Management targets opening in early 2027 with about $404.1M of capital, funding the loans it holds with brokered deposits, and says that would leave over $1B of unrestricted cash.
against this

Two of three approvals are outstanding, and the cash figure is management's illustration on the Q3 balance sheet.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17
What we still do not know
  • How Upstart's loans perform against ordinary ones to the same borrowers as late payments rise; nobody outside has checked since 2019.
  • Who the biggest lending partner is, and how long it has agreed to stay.
  • When the last two regulators will rule on its bank.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
C15management claimmedium confidence
Upstart says its personal loan model used over 2,500 variables at the end of 2025, trained on nearly 104 million repayment events, and that in Q3 2026 it was 2.77 times as accurate as a traditional credit-score benchmark.
against this

No outside party has tested the 2.77 figure; the last regulator reading, the CFPB's, dates from 2019 (C16).

current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C09facthigh confidence
One lending partner, Customer A, was 41% of Q3 2026 revenue and 35% of the first nine months; two others were 13% and 12% of the quarter. In 2025 the top three lending partners originated 83% of loans and supplied 61% of revenue.
current state · 2026-09-30written 2026-11-17
C21management claimmedium confidence
Upstart Bank has the OCC's conditional approval; deposit insurance from the FDIC and the Federal Reserve's holding-company approval are pending. Management targets opening in early 2027 with about $404.1M of capital, funding the loans it holds with brokered deposits, and says that would leave over $1B of unrestricted cash.
against this

Two of three approvals are outstanding, and the cash figure is management's illustration on the Q3 balance sheet.

forwardwritten 2026-11-17

What would change our view

  1. Neutral→AttractiveProfit proves the return

    It needs:

    • ○Upstart earns 12% a year on what it owns for four quarters while late payments stay high.checked at the next results, due by 9 Feb
  2. Neutral→UnattractiveThe price runs 20% above fair value

    It needs:

    • ○The share price rises to about $45.44, 20% above what we think the business is worth.about $45.35 today, 138% above the last close
  3. Neutral→UnattractiveFunding pulls back

    It needs any of:

    • ○Loans arranged fall from a year earlier for two quarters running.checked at the next results, due by 9 Feb
    • ○A lending partner bringing a tenth or more of sales ends or shrinks its lending.watched as it happens
We would also be wrong if
  • Profit kept on personal loans falls below 55 cents of each fee dollar for two quarters.
  • Its bank opens and funds the loans it holds with deposits.

What is coming

  • 9 February 2027 Q4 2026 results and the 2027 outlook: Whether originations grow again after October's dip and what return on equity the 2027 guide implies with the macro index where it is.
Every dated event ahead
  • 9 February 2027 Q4 2026 results and the 2027 outlook: Whether originations grow again after October's dip and what return on equity the 2027 guide implies with the macro index where it is.
  • 31 March 2027 Upstart Bank opens: Whether deposits fund the held loans, cutting funding costs and freeing over $1B of cash, as management says.
  • 30 April 2027 2027 proxy statement: Whether pay keeps riding on fee revenue, and the founders' holdings.
Since we wrote this
Written
17 Nov
Price the thesis read
$19.09
16 Nov
  • 17 NovThesis writtenNeutral, low convictionThe price is about half our value, but that value needs a record return on equity through a credit cycle that funders and defaults decide.

Sources 15

Where this came from

Sources - 15

Every claim above cites one of these, or states the reasoning that derived it. The quote is frozen at the date it was read: a link can rot, and an agent fetch returns a reading of a page rather than the page. Backs counts the whole claim ledger, so it can name a claim this page does not surface.

  1. S01primarycompany filing2026-02-10
    Item 1 products, the model's variables and repayment events, the internal approval study, the funding mix, the top three lending partners, the competition classes, loan terms and APR caps, headcount, statements
    backsC01C03C04C09C10C14C15C17C34C36C39
  2. S02primarycompany filing2026-11-03
    customer concentration, the balance sheet, the convertible notes and warehouse lines, the share count, the buyback, the segment note and the contribution of the other segments
    backsC02C03C04C09C11C12C13C14C18
  3. S03primarycompany filing2026-11-03
    originations, revenue, fee revenue by product, contribution profit and margin, GAAP and adjusted profit, and the cut full-year 2026 outlook
    backsC01C02C05C06C07C18C19C38C41
  4. S04primarytranscript2026-11-03
    Q3 2026 earnings call transcript (FMP)
    data/cache/transcripts/UPST-2026Q3.json
    the Upstart Macro Index and its effect on originations, secured originations, the take rate, funding and equity use, vintage returns, Upstart Bank's funding plan, October originations and the chief executive's answer on profits
    Our model is now 2.77x as accurate, and 87.27% of the inaccuracy gap is still ahead of us.
    backsC06C07C08C10C15C18C20C21C40
  5. S05primarycompany filing2026-02-10
    2025 originations and revenue, the 2025-2028 targets and the chief executive transition
    backsC22C35
  6. S06primarycompany filing2026-04-16
    executive officers, beneficial ownership, bonus and performance-share metrics
    backsC22C23
  7. S07primarycompany filing2026-11-09
    the chief accounting officer's resignation, effective 30 November 2026
    backsC22
  8. S08primarycompany filing2026-10-20
    a new $200M revolving credit agreement signed on 16 October 2026
    backsC12
  9. S09primaryregulator2019-08-06
    the regulator's reading of Upstart's model against a traditional one, from data Upstart supplied under its no-action letter
    the tested model approves 27% more applicants than the traditional model, and yields 16% lower average APRs for approved loans
    backsC16
  10. S10primaryindustry data2026-11-05
    US unsecured personal loan originations, balances and serious delinquency
    originations climbing 22.7% YoY to a record 8.41 million loans and outstanding balances rising 9.0% to $293.4 billion
    backsC31
  11. S11primarycompany filing2026-03-02
    a rival's description of the same product: AI underwriting connecting lenders with investors, in personal, auto and point-of-sale loans
    a network connecting financial institutions and their customers with investors
    backsC32
  12. S12primarycompany filing2026-02-17
    a deposit-funded lender's personal loan growth in 2025
    During the year ended December 31, 2025, total personal loan origination volume increased by 56% relative to 2024
    backsC33
  13. S13secondaryvendor data2026-11-17
    UPST research pack (FMP market tier, FINRA short interest, headcount), frozen 2026-11-17
    content/UPST/research-pack.json
    the 16 November close of $19.09, daily bars, returns and their split, analyst ratings and their history, earnings history, insider filings, short interest, headcount
    backsC24C25C26C27C36C37C38
  14. S14secondaryvendor data2026-11-17
    the analysts' average revenue and net income for 2026 to 2029, with the count of analysts
    backsC28
  15. S15primarycompany filing2026-11-17
    every open-market purchase and sale, and its Rule 10b5-1 flag
    backsC24
Rendered from content/UPST/thesis.json · thesis reviewed 2026-11-17. This page explains a company; it does not say what to pay, when to buy or how much.