← All thesesENSUnattractiveMedium convictionTuesday 17 November 2026עברית

EnerSys

This is the archived full research. Read the story

EnerSys makes the big batteries that keep data centres, phone networks, forklifts and military equipment running when the power fails or the plug is out.

Our viewUnattractive Medium conviction
The scores
The profile · 1-4
Growth2/4 →

Revenue grew about 2% a year over fiscal 2024-2026 with an acquisition inside it; forklift batteries, nearly half of sales, are shrinking.

Business quality2/4 ↓

A service network and installed base, but lead batteries are substitutable and lithium from Asian cells is taking forklifts; retention is the company's own figure.

Financial position3/4 →

Net leverage 0.8 times and $468M of free cash flow; $300M of notes fall due in December 2027 and refinance in a normal market.

Execution record3/4 →

Beat EPS eight quarters running and cut costs as promised, but missed revenue once on forklifts and shrank the lithium plant to a quarter.

Per share capture4/4 ↑

Diluted shares fell from 41.4M to 37.6M in two years on buybacks paid from cash; the dividend rose 10%.

Potential2/4 →

Data centre orders and defence rules point up, but orders are not sales, the lithium lines have no revenue, and the market size is management's.

Risk profile3/4 →

No customer above 10%, but a third or more of earnings depends on one law, the 45X credit, which phases out and could be changed.

Valuation2/4 →

About 15.7 times normal-year operating profit, 120% of a three-stage value near $116 at an 8% return: full, at the edge of the 20% margin.

Evidence quality3/4 →

Statements, segments and the credit's law are filed or official, but data centre orders, retention and the lithium products rest on management.

The bet · 2-3 years
Safe, little upside

No upside the evidence defends · if it fails you keep about 88%.

The Verdict

We rate EnerSys Unattractive. It is a steady battery maker earning about 11 cents of operating profit per sales dollar, but sales have grown only about 2% a year, so the business is mixed. The price looks cheap on reported earnings, yet about two-fifths of last year's adjusted earnings came from a US tax credit that shrinks from 2030 and that one law can change. Valued on what the businesses earn without it, the price sits above our value. Data-centre orders, defence demand and a forklift recovery could change that, but none is in the sales yet.

The long caseData centres and the military need reliable batteries made in America, and EnerSys already makes them.

How we weighed it

The price against our value

Against it

Price at 120% of our value

The price sits at the edge of our value's premium line on what the core earns, though the bear case is not far below.

The business

Cuts both ways

Mixed

A mixed business: a steady margin but slow growth.

Growth against what the price assumes

Against it

Sales grow slowly, edging forward on price rather than volume.

What could go wrong

Against it

Lithium is taking forklifts, the tax credit can change and data-centre orders are lumpy.

Against competitors

Cuts both ways

No filed rival compares directly; its own normal predates the credit.

How its group is behaving

Cuts both ways

Power names move together on AI power news; it ranks near the foot of its group.

The latest news and report

Cuts both ways

The second-quarter report grew earnings without the credit and orders rose, led by defence, but sales missed the guide and forklift orders still fell, the recovery pushed to the fourth quarter.

Where this departs from the fair value

The band reads Neutral by a hair after a falling week. That premium is too thin against the weaknesses: forklift batteries, nearly half of sales, are shrinking to lithium, the recovery slipped a quarter and there is no moat. A clearly lower price moves it.

The evidence under this - 7 claims
C04facthigh confidence
The Section 45X production credit, booked as a cut to cost of sales, was $158.6M in fiscal 2026 against $184.6M a year earlier. Excluding it, net earnings were $135.0M against $293.6M reported, adjusted net earnings $244.4M, and adjusted EPS $6.41 against $10.56.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C13facthigh confidence
Under Section 45X, US-made battery cells earn $35 per kilowatt-hour; the credit falls to 75% for goods sold in 2030, 50% in 2031 and 25% in 2032 and ends after that, and 2025 law added three foreign-entity restrictions.
current state · 2026-08-13written 2026-10-21
C15inferencemedium confidence
About two-fifths of last year's adjusted earnings and over half of GAAP net earnings came from a credit that steps down from 2030 and ends after 2032, so a large share of today's profit has an end date within seven years.
derivedAdjusted net earnings of $244.4M without the credit against $10.56 x 38.1M = $402M with it, so the credit was about 39%; GAAP $135.0M against $293.6M, so 54% (C04). Phase-down from CRS (C13) and management's own range (C14).
against this
  • Management plans to lift US output to half its batteries, which could raise the yearly credit through 2029 (C14).
  • Fiscal 2026 adjusted earnings without the credit still grew 15% (S02).
forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C16estimatemedium confidence
At $170.61 the company is valued at about $6.9B. Less about $0.56B for the credits still to come, the rest is about 15 times the segments' trailing $413M of adjusted operating profit, a 5% after-tax yield that needs about 3% growth a year for ever.
derived37.6M diluted shares x $170.61 = $6.42B, plus $1,039.0M of debt less $530.7M of cash = $6.93B (S11, S04). Credits at management's midpoints, $165M a year for fiscal 2027-2029 and $80M for 2030-2032, discounted at 10% = about $0.56B (C14). Segment adjusted operating earnings Q2 fiscal 2026 to Q1 fiscal 2027: NIS $167.7M, IMS $175.2M, PPS $69.7M = $412.6M (S03, S05). $6.37B / $412.6M = 15.4 times; at 21% tax the yield is 5.1%, which at an 8% required return implies about 3% growth.
against this
  • The panel's fiscal 2027 EPS of $13.34 puts the shares at 12.8 times earnings, which reads cheap because it includes the credit (S11).
  • Segment profit excludes about $10-20M a quarter of restructuring that has recurred every quarter of fiscal 2026 (S03, S04).
current state · 2026-10-20written 2026-10-21
C03facthigh confidence
Revenue was $3,581.9M in fiscal 2024, $3,617.6M in fiscal 2025 and $3,751.4M in fiscal 2026, about 2.3% a year, while Bren-Tronics was bought in July 2024 for $206.4M.
historical · FY 2024 - FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C05facthigh confidence
On the recast segments for fiscal 2026: NIS sales $1,651.3M, up 7.9%, adjusted operating earnings $150.2M (9.1%); IMS $1,741.6M, down 3.0%, $175.7M (10.1%); PPS $358.5M, up 22.9% with Bren-Tronics, $62.9M (17.5%). Corporate unallocated added $151.4M, mostly the 45X credit less lithium start-up costs.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C09management claimmedium confidence
Management says data centre orders rose by the mid-teens on the year in Q2 fiscal 2027 and the data centre backlog more than doubled, with network power backlog up 26%; it expects no material change to its data centre outlook from the US midterm elections, since its growth has come from existing sites.
against this

Orders slowed from more than 80% growth in Q1 to the mid-teens in Q2, and data centre revenue is still not disclosed in any filing (S06, S23, S22).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: data centre orders slowed to the mid-teens while the backlog doubled
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
01

The company

When the power fails, a data centre or a phone tower runs on batteries until the generator starts. EnerSys makes those batteries, mostly lead-acid, including a fast-charging type called TPPL. It also makes the batteries and chargers inside electric forklifts, truck batteries, and batteries for missiles, soldiers and military vehicles.

Its rivals are other lead-acid makers, and increasingly lithium battery packs built from Asian cells. EnerSys has started selling its own lithium products, but most of its sales are still lead.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C01facthigh confidence
EnerSys makes industrial batteries, mostly lead-acid including its thin plate pure lead (TPPL) range, plus chargers, power systems and service, for telecom and data centre backup, forklifts, trucks and defence. It sells to more than 10,000 customers, none above 10% of sales. Since 28 May 2026 it reports three segments: Network & Infrastructure Solutions (NIS), Industrial Mobility Solutions (IMS) and Precision Power Solutions (PPS).
current state · 2026-05-28written 2026-10-21
C12facthigh confidence
The 10-K says lithium technologies have a growing share in the markets of its forklift and energy storage businesses, that forklift makers now integrate lithium packs from Asian cells themselves, and that it cannot assure its mostly lead-acid portfolio will stay competitive.
current state · 2026-05-20written 2026-10-21
C24management claimmedium confidence
Management says PPS has six US plants cleared for controlled defence work, is the largest primary reserve battery provider supporting every US missile defence platform, and serves an aerospace and defence market growing 9-11% a year.
against this

The 10-K names EaglePicher and Saft as main defence rivals, and no outside body measures the position claimed (S01).

current state · 2026-08-13written 2026-10-21
C26management claimlow confidence
Management says DataSafe Noir won its first customer order in Q2 fiscal 2027, with 6 cabinets in the order book against a pipeline of about 80 opportunities covering over 1,000 cabinets, that it will not be material this fiscal year, and that it is a fiscal 2028 revenue story.
against this

The Noir cells come from a supplier, not from EnerSys's own plant, and the first order's value is not disclosed; in August management spoke of about 100 systems on order with that supplier (S06, S23).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: the first Noir order and the size of its pipeline
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
C42facthigh confidence
The 10-K names East Penn, Stryten, Hoppecke and Chinese makers as lead-acid forklift rivals, East Penn, Stryten, Vertiv, GS Yuasa and others in network power, EaglePicher and Saft in defence, and Jule, Tritium and ABB in energy storage and charging.
current state · 2026-05-20written 2026-10-21

How it makes money

It sells batteries, replaces them when they wear out, and services them. Network and data centre power was 44% of fiscal 2026 sales, forklifts and trucks 46%, and defence 10%. Each kept about 9 to 18 cents of operating profit per sales dollar, defence the most.

On top of that, the US government pays a production credit for every battery made in America. It is booked as a lower cost and was $158.6M in fiscal 2026.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C05facthigh confidence
On the recast segments for fiscal 2026: NIS sales $1,651.3M, up 7.9%, adjusted operating earnings $150.2M (9.1%); IMS $1,741.6M, down 3.0%, $175.7M (10.1%); PPS $358.5M, up 22.9% with Bren-Tronics, $62.9M (17.5%). Corporate unallocated added $151.4M, mostly the 45X credit less lithium start-up costs.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C02facthigh confidence
Fiscal 2026 (year to 31 March 2026) revenue was $3,751.4M, up 3.7%; GAAP operating earnings $426.5M; net earnings $293.6M; adjusted operating earnings $540.2M and adjusted EPS $10.56.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C04facthigh confidence
The Section 45X production credit, booked as a cut to cost of sales, was $158.6M in fiscal 2026 against $184.6M a year earlier. Excluding it, net earnings were $135.0M against $293.6M reported, adjusted net earnings $244.4M, and adjusted EPS $6.41 against $10.56.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C33facthigh confidence
Fiscal 2026 operating cash flow was $547.6M and free cash flow $467.6M after $80.1M of capital spending; Q1 fiscal 2027 operating cash flow was $230.2M, including a $115M tax refund, and free cash flow $217.8M.
historical · FY 2026 - Q1 FY2027written 2026-10-21
Where the money comes from, stream by stream
StreamShare of sales (FY 2026)How it earns it
Network & Infrastructure Solutions44.0%Backup batteries, power systems and service for telecom, cable, utilities and data centres.
Industrial Mobility Solutions46.4%Forklift and truck batteries, chargers and service, lead and lithium.
Precision Power Solutions9.6%Batteries for missiles, soldiers, military vehicles, aircraft and space.

Who runs it

Shawn O'Connell, who joined in 2011 and ran the forklift business, became chief executive in May 2025; Andrea Funk has been finance chief since 2022. Directors and officers own about 1% of the shares.

Their bonus pays mostly on adjusted operating profit, which includes the tax credit, so part of their pay rests on a subsidy. Insider trading was small: the finance chief bought a few shares in May 2026.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C36facthigh confidence
Executive bonuses pay 60% on adjusted operating earnings, which include the 45X credit ($547.3M for fiscal 2026), 20% on operating capital and 20% on non-financial goals; fiscal 2026 paid 141.5% of target. Long-term awards are half options priced 10% above the market and half restricted stock.
current state · 2026-07-02written 2026-10-21
C37facthigh confidence
Directors and officers own 1.1% of the shares; BlackRock holds 13.9% and Vanguard about 6.6%.
current state · 2026-06-08written 2026-10-21
C38facthigh confidence
In the year to October 2026 the CFO bought 108 shares at $228.47 on 29 May 2026, and the IMS head sold 6,702 shares at $151.46 on 10 December 2025, not under a pre-arranged plan.
historical · November 2025 - October 2026written 2026-10-21
02

Why it wins, and who could beat it

Why customers come back

EnerSys has a large base of batteries already installed and about 750 service staff. A warehouse or a phone company that runs its batteries usually replaces like with like, and the company says over 90% of customers stay.

That hold is weakening where lithium arrives. An outside forecaster says lithium is passing lead in electric forklifts around 2026, though lithium's repair and service network is less mature. EnerSys's forklift sales fell 3% last year.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C31management claimlow confidence
Management claims the leading position in North American forklift batteries and in North American network power, a retention rate above 90%, and about 750 service staff.
against this

IMS sales fell 3.0% in fiscal 2026 and 3.2% in Q1 fiscal 2027 (C05, C07).

current state · 2026-06-11written 2026-10-21
C11estimatemedium confidence
Interact Analysis expects lithium-ion to pass lead-acid in share of electric forklift batteries around 2026, from about 32% in 2024 to over 70% by 2034, with the US reaching 50% only in 2032 and lithium's after-sales market not yet as mature as lead-acid's.
against this

The same forecast puts North America years behind China and Europe, which slows the shift in EnerSys's largest region (S13).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C05facthigh confidence
On the recast segments for fiscal 2026: NIS sales $1,651.3M, up 7.9%, adjusted operating earnings $150.2M (9.1%); IMS $1,741.6M, down 3.0%, $175.7M (10.1%); PPS $358.5M, up 22.9% with Bren-Tronics, $62.9M (17.5%). Corporate unallocated added $151.4M, mostly the 45X credit less lithium start-up costs.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C12facthigh confidence
The 10-K says lithium technologies have a growing share in the markets of its forklift and energy storage businesses, that forklift makers now integrate lithium packs from Asian cells themselves, and that it cannot assure its mostly lead-acid portfolio will stay competitive.
current state · 2026-05-20written 2026-10-21

The threat

Private lead-acid makers such as East Penn sell the same batteries to the same buyers. The bigger threat is lithium: forklift makers now fit their own lithium packs from Asian cells, and Vertiv sells lithium cabinets for data centre backup, the slot EnerSys's new DataSafe Noir lithium must win.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C42facthigh confidence
The 10-K names East Penn, Stryten, Hoppecke and Chinese makers as lead-acid forklift rivals, East Penn, Stryten, Vertiv, GS Yuasa and others in network power, EaglePicher and Saft in defence, and Jule, Tritium and ABB in energy storage and charging.
current state · 2026-05-20written 2026-10-21
C12facthigh confidence
The 10-K says lithium technologies have a growing share in the markets of its forklift and energy storage businesses, that forklift makers now integrate lithium packs from Asian cells themselves, and that it cannot assure its mostly lead-acid portfolio will stay competitive.
current state · 2026-05-20written 2026-10-21
C11estimatemedium confidence
Interact Analysis expects lithium-ion to pass lead-acid in share of electric forklift batteries around 2026, from about 32% in 2024 to over 70% by 2034, with the US reaching 50% only in 2032 and lithium's after-sales market not yet as mature as lead-acid's.
against this

The same forecast puts North America years behind China and Europe, which slows the shift in EnerSys's largest region (S13).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C26management claimlow confidence
Management says DataSafe Noir won its first customer order in Q2 fiscal 2027, with 6 cabinets in the order book against a pipeline of about 80 opportunities covering over 1,000 cabinets, that it will not be material this fiscal year, and that it is a fiscal 2028 revenue story.
against this

The Noir cells come from a supplier, not from EnerSys's own plant, and the first order's value is not disclosed; in August management spoke of about 100 systems on order with that supplier (S06, S23).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: the first Noir order and the size of its pipeline
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21

The rivals: HY, FLUX, VRT, VRT, TTE, APH, and 6 more that are private, in-house or listed abroad.

Who else does this, rival by rival
TickerRivalWhere it competesHow far alongPriced against it
PrivateEast Penn ManufacturingPriced against it: PrivateIndustrial Mobility SolutionsOn salePrivate
PrivateStryten EnergyPriced against it: PrivateIndustrial Mobility SolutionsOn salePrivate
HYForklift makers' own lithium packs, such as Toyota Industries, KION and Hyster-YalePriced against it: Not checkedIndustrial Mobility SolutionsOn saleNot checked
FLUXFlux PowerPriced against it: Not checkedIndustrial Mobility SolutionsOn saleNot checked
VRTVertivPriced against it: One segment onlyNetwork & Infrastructure SolutionsOn saleOne segment only
VertivLithium growth betsOn sale
GS YuasaPriced against it: Listed abroadNetwork & Infrastructure SolutionsOn saleListed abroad
Chinese lithium cell makers such as CATLPriced against it: Listed abroadNetwork & Infrastructure SolutionsOn saleListed abroad
PrivateEaglePicher TechnologiesPriced against it: PrivatePrecision Power SolutionsOn salePrivate
TTESaft, part of TotalEnergiesPriced against it: Not checkedPrecision Power SolutionsOn saleNot checked
ABBPriced against it: Listed abroadLithium growth betsOn saleListed abroad
APHAmphenolPriced against it: One segment only-On saleOne segment only
03

How big it could get

How big this could get

Management puts the markets it serves at about $26B a year, so EnerSys's sales are about a seventh of it; nobody outside the company measures this. Two outside numbers show which way the parts move. The US Department of Energy expects data centres to use 6.7% to 12% of US electricity by 2028, up from 4.4% in 2023. In forklifts, lithium should pass 70% of batteries by 2034, a market lead-acid is losing.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C29management claimlow confidence
Management sizes the markets it serves at about $26B: NIS $15B, IMS $8.3B and PPS $3.1B, growing 4-6%, 2-4% and 9-11% a year.
against this

No outside body publishes the industrial battery market in these cuts, so the sizes cannot be checked (S07).

current state · 2026-06-11written 2026-10-21
C28estimatemedium confidence
The Department of Energy reports US data centres used about 4.4% of US electricity in 2023 and expects 6.7% to 12% by 2028.
against this

The range is wide: the high end is nearly twice the low end (S14).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C11estimatemedium confidence
Interact Analysis expects lithium-ion to pass lead-acid in share of electric forklift batteries around 2026, from about 32% in 2024 to over 70% by 2034, with the US reaching 50% only in 2032 and lithium's after-sales market not yet as mature as lead-acid's.
against this

The same forecast puts North America years behind China and Europe, which slows the shift in EnerSys's largest region (S13).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
Where the growth is coming from, business by business

Where the growth is coming from

BusinessShare of revenueGrowth: last quarterLast half-yearLast yearShare in 3 years at its half-year rate
Product89%-1.4%+1.1%+0.7%86%
Service11%+11.4%+13.0%+12.6%14%
Whole company100%-0.1%+2.2%+1.8%100%

On the filed split through 2026-10-04, if each business keeps its last half-year's growth, the company grows about 2% next year and 3% in year 3, against 3.7% over the last twelve months. A scenario, not a forecast: no business holds its rate.

04

The results

The numbers

Is it growing?Slow

Sales grew 1.8% over the twelve months to Oct 2026, about the same pace as the 3.7% in the year to Mar 2026.

Mar 2022: $3.36BMar 2023: $3.71BMar 2024: $3.58BMar 2025: $3.62BMar 2026: $3.75B12 mo to Oct 2026: $3.79B$3.36B$3.79B
Is it profitable?Healthy

Operating margin is 14%, up from 9.8% in the year to Mar 2024.

Mar 2022: 6.1%Mar 2023: 7.5%Mar 2024: 9.8%Mar 2025: 13%Mar 2026: 11%12 mo to Oct 2026: 14%6.1%14%
Does growth pay off?Flat

Running costs take 17¢ of each sales dollar, about where it was (16¢) in the year to Mar 2022.

Mar 2022: 16¢Mar 2023: 15¢Mar 2024: 18¢Mar 2025: 17¢Mar 2026: 18¢12 mo to Oct 2026: 17¢16¢17¢
Does it earn good returns?Decent

Each dollar put into the business earns 15% a year after tax, up from 6.4% in the year to Mar 2022.

Mar 2022: 6.4%Mar 2023: 8.5%Mar 2024: 12%Mar 2025: 15%Mar 2026: 12%12 mo to Oct 2026: 15%6.4%15%
Is it making cash?Strong

It turned 17% of sales into free cash, $650M over the last twelve months.

Mar 2022: −$140MMar 2023: $191MMar 2024: $371MMar 2025: $139MMar 2026: $468M12 mo to Oct 2026: $650M−$140M$650M
Is the balance sheet safe?Light debt

It owes $539M more than the cash it holds, about 0.8 years of the cash its operations bring in.

Mar 2022: −$896MMar 2023: −$726MMar 2024: −$499MMar 2025: −$769MMar 2026: −$670M12 mo to Oct 2026: −$539M−$896M−$539M
Are shares being diluted?Shrinking

The share count fell 14% in 4.5 years, and pay in shares costs 0.0% of sales.

Mar 2022: 42.8MMar 2023: 41.3MMar 2024: 41.4MMar 2025: 40.4MMar 2026: 38.1M12 mo to Oct 2026: 37.0M42.8M37.0M
All the numbers

Filed figures from the company's 10-K and 10-Q, read 2026-11-12. Fiscal years end in March.

Mar 2022Mar 2023Mar 2024Mar 2025Mar 202612 mo to Oct 2026
Size and growth
Sales$3.36B$3.71B$3.58B$3.62B$3.75B$3.79B
Sales growth+13%+10%−3.4%+1.0%+3.7%+1.8%
Profit
Gross margin22%23%27%30%29%31%
Operating margin6.1%7.5%9.8%13%11%14%
Net margin4.3%4.7%7.5%10%7.8%9.9%
What growth costs, per sales dollar
Pay in shares0.2%0.2%0.2%0.2%0.2%0.0%
Capital spending2.2%2.4%2.4%3.3%2.1%1.3%
Cash
Cash from operations−$65.6M$280M$457M$260M$548M$701M
Free cash flow−$140M$191M$371M$139M$468M$650M
Balance sheet
Cash and short-term investments$402M$347M$333M$343M$439M$276M
Debt$1.30B$1.07B$832M$1.11B$1.11B$815M
Net cash−$896M−$726M−$499M−$769M−$670M−$539M
Returns and shares
Return on capital6.4%8.5%12%15%12%15%
Shares (diluted)42.8M41.3M41.4M40.4M38.1M37.0M

What growth costs

Growth has not widened the margin. Profit per sales dollar sat near 10 to 11 cents while sales grew about 2% a year, and what improvement came was from closing plants and cutting about a tenth of the staff, not from selling more.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C05facthigh confidence
On the recast segments for fiscal 2026: NIS sales $1,651.3M, up 7.9%, adjusted operating earnings $150.2M (9.1%); IMS $1,741.6M, down 3.0%, $175.7M (10.1%); PPS $358.5M, up 22.9% with Bren-Tronics, $62.9M (17.5%). Corporate unallocated added $151.4M, mostly the 45X credit less lithium start-up costs.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21
C35facthigh confidence
Restructuring cost about $51M across fiscal 2026 and $10.7M in Q1 fiscal 2027. The Tijuana closure, announced in March 2026 partly to maximise near-term 45X benefits, costs about $37M, cuts 474 jobs and is expected to save about $20M a year from fiscal 2028; headcount fell 10.8% to 9,682.
historical · FY 2026 - Q1 FY2027written 2026-10-21
C04facthigh confidence
The Section 45X production credit, booked as a cut to cost of sales, was $158.6M in fiscal 2026 against $184.6M a year earlier. Excluding it, net earnings were $135.0M against $293.6M reported, adjusted net earnings $244.4M, and adjusted EPS $6.41 against $10.56.
historical · FY 2026written 2026-10-21

The last report (11 Nov)

Quarter ended October 2026, filed figures.

-0%
Sales growth
against the same quarter a year earlier
1.5%
Growth from the quarter before
against -5.3% the quarter before that
12¢
Operating profit
per dollar of sales

In the quarter to 4 October 2026 sales were $949.9M, flat on the year and just under the company's own guide. Defence sales grew 21.0% and network power 3.3%, while forklift and truck sales fell 7.8%. Without the US credit, adjusted earnings per share were $2.02, against $1.61.

On the call the next day, orders were up 21%, led by defence and truck batteries, and the data-centre backlog had doubled. But forklift orders still fell, and management now expects their recovery in the fourth quarter.

What it did to the thesisIt showed the core earning more on the same sales, with defence and data centres carrying the quarter and its orders, but forklifts shrank faster and their recovery slipped a quarter. The question the case turns on, whether forklift demand turns, is still open.

The quarter in detail

Sales growth from the previous quarter, filed figures.

Earnings per share $3.22 against $3.19 expected.

The evidence under this - 5 claims
C45facthigh confidence
Q2 fiscal 2027 (to 4 October 2026) sales were $949.9M, down 0.1% and under the $955-995M guide, which the company puts down to currency. Gross margin was 29.9%, or 25.2% without the $44.4M credit. EPS was $2.42 GAAP, $3.22 adjusted and $2.02 adjusted without the credit; adjusted figures now leave out all stock pay, with the prior year recast. $130M bought back 679K shares.
  1. 2026-11-13editedre-sourced to the Q2 fiscal 2027 10-Q and the release as filed on EDGAR, which confirm the wire text's figures
historical · Q2 FY2027written 2026-11-11
C46facthigh confidence
In Q2 fiscal 2027 NIS sales were $449.0M, up 3.3%, at an 11.2% adjusted margin; IMS $397.1M, down 7.8%, at 9.5%; PPS $103.8M, up 21.0%, at 21.9%. For the half, IMS sales fell 5.6% to $803.9M. Management says data centres grew double digits and expects material handling to start recovering in Q3.
against this

The recovery and the data centre growth are management's words; no order figure was given in the release (S20).

  1. 2026-11-13editedre-sourced to the Q2 fiscal 2027 10-Q, which confirms the release's figures
historical · Q2 FY2027written 2026-11-11
C08management claimmedium confidence
For Q3 fiscal 2027 management guided sales of $935-975M and adjusted EPS of $3.05-3.15 including the 45X credit, with fiscal 2027 capital spending of about $70M; the guide leaves out the Ultralife purchase and any tariff refunds.
against this
  • The Q2 guide of $955-995M was missed at $949.9M, on currency by the company's account (S20).
  • Management says IMS margins come under pressure in Q3 as transportation outgrows the richer material handling line (S20).
  1. 2026-11-11editedshelf life moved to the print: the quarter reports on 11 November (company date notice of 21 October, FMP calendar), not 4 November, so the guide is still the standing one
  2. 2026-11-11editedthe Q2 guide was tested by the 11 November report (sales $949.9M, under it on currency; adjusted EPS $3.22, inside it); the claim now carries the Q3 guide that replaced it
forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C10management claimmedium confidence
Management says Q2 fiscal 2027 orders rose 21% with a book-to-bill of 1.09 and backlog up 36%; transportation orders rose 60% while material handling orders fell by low single digits, and that the material handling recovery is taking longer than it expected, with more consistent signs in Q4 and a return to growth by the fiscal year-end.
against this
  • Q2 IMS sales fell 7.8%, faster than Q1's 3.2%, and management had said in August that material handling would improve later in the year; the recovery date has now moved to Q4 (S22, S23).
  • Most of the order growth came from defence, where orders rose 203% on program awards, and from transportation, which carries lower margins than material handling (S23).
  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: orders by segment and the later material handling recovery
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
C09management claimmedium confidence
Management says data centre orders rose by the mid-teens on the year in Q2 fiscal 2027 and the data centre backlog more than doubled, with network power backlog up 26%; it expects no material change to its data centre outlook from the US midterm elections, since its growth has come from existing sites.
against this

Orders slowed from more than 80% growth in Q1 to the mid-teens in Q2, and data centre revenue is still not disclosed in any filing (S06, S23, S22).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: data centre orders slowed to the mid-teens while the backlog doubled
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
What management did with the money

It buys back shares steadily, cutting the share count about 9% in two years, and raised the dividend 10%. It bought a soldier-battery maker in 2024, and in July 2026 shrank its planned lithium cell plant to a small defence-only factory.

Insiders in 2026Q3: 92 purchases and 17 sales, from their Form 4 filings.

The evidence under this - 3 claims
C34facthigh confidence
Diluted shares fell from 41.4M in fiscal 2024 to 38.1M in fiscal 2026 and 37.6M in Q1 fiscal 2027. It bought 219,000 shares for $50M in Q1 and 249,893 for $50M from 6 July to 7 August, with about $900M authorised, and raised the dividend 10% to $0.2875 a quarter.
historical · FY 2024 - Q1 FY2027written 2026-10-21
C25facthigh confidence
EnerSys bought Bren-Tronics, a maker of portable soldier batteries and chargers, in July 2024 for $206.4M; it sits in PPS.
historical · FY 2025written 2026-10-21
C21facthigh confidence
On 23 July 2026 EnerSys cut its planned US lithium cell plant to about 1 GWh a year for defence uses, from the 4-5 GWh first planned, its Department of Energy grant fell from $199M to $150M, and the Verkor partnership ended.
historical · July 2026written 2026-10-21
05

The price, and where we disagree

In short. Full. The price is about 120% of what we think the business is worth, at an 8% yearly return.

Share price
$151.33
close,
Price for each $1 of yearly profit
15.5
its 6-year normal 21.0
Company value for each $1 of cash profit
10.0
its 6-year normal 12.6

The shares are 30% below their May high after the lithium plant was cut and forklift demand stayed weak, so the price now asks less than it did.

The next test is the third-quarter report, expected in early February 2027, where management says forklift and truck sales should grow again. Further out, a ban on Defense Department purchases of batteries from six Chinese makers starts in October 2027, which could send more military orders to US plants like EnerSys's.

The evidence under this - 6 claims
C18facthigh confidence
The shares closed at $170.61 on 20 October 2026, 30% below the $243.34 close of 26 May and up 41% over 252 sessions, of which revenue per share added 8% and the multiple 30%.
historical · October 2025 - October 2026written 2026-10-21
C20facthigh confidence
The shares fell from $200.05 to $190.75 the session after the 23 July 2026 lithium plant cut, and rose from $186.72 to $197.38 the session after the Q1 call.
historical · July - August 2026written 2026-10-21
C21facthigh confidence
On 23 July 2026 EnerSys cut its planned US lithium cell plant to about 1 GWh a year for defence uses, from the 4-5 GWh first planned, its Department of Energy grant fell from $199M to $150M, and the Verkor partnership ended.
historical · July 2026written 2026-10-21
C08management claimmedium confidence
For Q3 fiscal 2027 management guided sales of $935-975M and adjusted EPS of $3.05-3.15 including the 45X credit, with fiscal 2027 capital spending of about $70M; the guide leaves out the Ultralife purchase and any tariff refunds.
against this
  • The Q2 guide of $955-995M was missed at $949.9M, on currency by the company's account (S20).
  • Management says IMS margins come under pressure in Q3 as transportation outgrows the richer material handling line (S20).
  1. 2026-11-11editedshelf life moved to the print: the quarter reports on 11 November (company date notice of 21 October, FMP calendar), not 4 November, so the guide is still the standing one
  2. 2026-11-11editedthe Q2 guide was tested by the 11 November report (sales $949.9M, under it on currency; adjusted EPS $3.22, inside it); the claim now carries the Q3 guide that replaced it
forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C46facthigh confidence
In Q2 fiscal 2027 NIS sales were $449.0M, up 3.3%, at an 11.2% adjusted margin; IMS $397.1M, down 7.8%, at 9.5%; PPS $103.8M, up 21.0%, at 21.9%. For the half, IMS sales fell 5.6% to $803.9M. Management says data centres grew double digits and expects material handling to start recovering in Q3.
against this

The recovery and the data centre growth are management's words; no order figure was given in the release (S20).

  1. 2026-11-13editedre-sourced to the Q2 fiscal 2027 10-Q, which confirms the release's figures
historical · Q2 FY2027written 2026-11-11
C23facthigh confidence
From 1 October 2027 the Defense Department may not buy batteries from CATL, BYD, Envision, EVE, Gotion or Hithium.
current state · 2026-10-21written 2026-10-21
The betSafe, little upside
If it works
no upside
none the evidence defends inside two to three years
If it fails
keep 88%
of today's market value: the rest of the company, less its debt
How we value it
Method
Cash the business will produce, in three stages
Required return
8%
Long-run growth
4%
Moat
No moat
BearBaseBull
Sales growth, years 1 to 32.1%, 2.3%4.1%, 4.6%5.1%, 5.7%
Normal operating margin7.6%9.5%10.5%
Return on new capital after year ten8%8%11%
Value a share$87.44$116$158
Price
$139
Priced on
16 Nov
Price as a share of the base value
120%
Starting growth the price pays for
17.8%
Yearly return the price offers on the base case
7.3%
Risk check: valued at 10%, the rate for a cyclical or indebted business
$87.96

Where each figure comes from

FigureSourceWhere exactly
Sales, the last twelve monthsFiled reportQuarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 5 Jul 2026, filed 12 Aug 2026; the four quarters to that date.
Operating margin todayFiled reportRead by hand from the filed statements; the period it was read from was not recorded.
Tax rateFiled reportQuarterly report (10-Q) for the period to 5 Jul 2026, filed 12 Aug 2026; the four quarters to that date.
Sales per dollar of new capitalFiled reportAnnual report (10-K) for the period to 31 Mar 2026, filed 20 May 2026: the year's sales over its operating capital.
SharesFiled reportRead by hand from the filed statements; the period it was read from was not recorded.
Cash and investmentsFiled reportRead by hand from the filed statements; the period it was read from was not recorded.
DebtFiled reportRead by hand from the filed statements; the period it was read from was not recorded.
Sales growth, years 1 to 3Analysts' forecastsFMP's consensus for the years to 31 Mar 2027, 31 Mar 2028 and 31 Mar 2029: the average of 1 to 4 analysts' revenue estimates, 4.1%, 6.1%. FMP publishes how many analysts, not who they are.
Normal operating marginFiled reportThe average operating margin of its last five filed years, since the business sits at a peak or a trough of its cycle.
Return on new capital after year tenOur method's ruleSet by our reading of the moat: the 8% rate with none, 12% with an average one, 15% with a strong one; the bear case earns the rate.
The bear and bull casesOur method's ruleOur method's spread: the bear case takes half the growth and a fifth off the margin, the bull a quarter more growth and a tenth more margin.
PriceMarket priceFMP's closing price on 16 Nov 2026.

What each case rests on

Bear caseGrowth runs at half the analysts' path, 2% and 2%, the margin settles a fifth lower at 7.6%, and new capital earns only the 8% rate: the downturn test.

Base caseRevenue grows 4% and 5% over three years, the analysts' path (C43), then fades toward 4%, closing 30% of the gap each year; the margin settles at its five-year average of 9.5%, not today's cycle peak. On 13 November the analysts' first-year average rose to about 5%, on a three-analyst panel, after a quarter that missed the sales guide and a Q3 guide that leaves out the Ultralife purchase; the base keeps the path the 10-Q confirms.

Bull caseGrowth runs a quarter above the analysts' path, 5% and 6%, the margin reaches 10.5%, and new capital earns 11%.

What moves the base value

LowerHigher
Growth in years 1 to 3, a quarter lower or higher$112$119
The normal margin, 15% lower or higher$97.94$134
Capital per dollar of growth, a quarter more or less$112$118
Return on new capital after year ten, at the rate or one step up$116$139
The rate, a point higher or lower$93.24$153
Long-run growth a point lower$113-

Value a share as growth and margin change

Normal margin ↓ · growth →50%75%100%125%150%
7.6%$87.41$89.68$92.01$94.41$96.89
8.6%$98.36$101$104$107$110
9.5%$109$112$116$119$123
10.5%$120$124$128$131$135
11.4%$131$135$139$144$148

Growth is shown as a share of the base case's. Green: the price is at or under 80% of that value. Red: at or over 120%.

How we read the multiple

Buyers pay about $6.9B for the company. Forecast earnings look cheap, but include a credit worth about $0.56B today that ends after 2032.

Taking that out, and asking for 5 cents of after-tax profit per dollar paid, a common rule of thumb for a slow-growing business, EnerSys must:

  1. Earn about $413M of operating profit a year, what its businesses earned last year.
  2. Grow that by about 3% a year, for ever.
  3. Beat its record: sales grew about 2% a year over the last two years.

Against its own history. Its own normal includes years when the credit did not exist, so the gap mostly measures how much of today's earnings the credit supplies.

The evidence under this - 4 claims
C16estimatemedium confidence
At $170.61 the company is valued at about $6.9B. Less about $0.56B for the credits still to come, the rest is about 15 times the segments' trailing $413M of adjusted operating profit, a 5% after-tax yield that needs about 3% growth a year for ever.
derived37.6M diluted shares x $170.61 = $6.42B, plus $1,039.0M of debt less $530.7M of cash = $6.93B (S11, S04). Credits at management's midpoints, $165M a year for fiscal 2027-2029 and $80M for 2030-2032, discounted at 10% = about $0.56B (C14). Segment adjusted operating earnings Q2 fiscal 2026 to Q1 fiscal 2027: NIS $167.7M, IMS $175.2M, PPS $69.7M = $412.6M (S03, S05). $6.37B / $412.6M = 15.4 times; at 21% tax the yield is 5.1%, which at an 8% required return implies about 3% growth.
against this
  • The panel's fiscal 2027 EPS of $13.34 puts the shares at 12.8 times earnings, which reads cheap because it includes the credit (S11).
  • Segment profit excludes about $10-20M a quarter of restructuring that has recurred every quarter of fiscal 2026 (S03, S04).
current state · 2026-10-20written 2026-10-21
C17facthigh confidence
The panel expects fiscal 2027 EPS of $13.34 from 3 analysts and fiscal 2028 EPS of $14.58 from 4; ratings are 10 buy, 5 hold and 1 sell. At $170.61 that is 12.8 times fiscal 2027, against filed fiscal 2026 adjusted EPS of $10.56.
current state · 2026-10-21written 2026-10-21
C15inferencemedium confidence
About two-fifths of last year's adjusted earnings and over half of GAAP net earnings came from a credit that steps down from 2030 and ends after 2032, so a large share of today's profit has an end date within seven years.
derivedAdjusted net earnings of $244.4M without the credit against $10.56 x 38.1M = $402M with it, so the credit was about 39%; GAAP $135.0M against $293.6M, so 54% (C04). Phase-down from CRS (C13) and management's own range (C14).
against this
  • Management plans to lift US output to half its batteries, which could raise the yearly credit through 2029 (C14).
  • Fiscal 2026 adjusted earnings without the credit still grew 15% (S02).
forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C30management claimlow confidence
Management's fiscal 2030 framework: markets up 3-5% a year plus 1-3 points from new products, adjusted margin up 50-100 basis points a year without the credit, 80-100% cash conversion, and net leverage of 2-3 times over time.
against this

Revenue grew about 2.3% a year over fiscal 2024-2026, below the bottom of the framework (C03).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
Priced against its rivals

None of the listed rivals above sells the same thing to the same buyers as a large part of what it does. A price comparison needs at least two, so the price is judged against its own history instead.

Private or foreign rivals that cannot be priced: East Penn Manufacturing Co., Stryten Energy (formerly Exide Technologies' US business), C&D Technologies, Inc., Saft, GS Yuasa Corporation, Delta Electronics, Inc., Hoppecke, Fiamm, Midac, Sunlight, TAB, Banner, Atlas, Eternity, New Power and OmniOn Power, Clarios, EaglePicher Technologies, Jule, Tritium and ABB.

The bet: what it pays if it works

The bet is EnerSys's new lithium products: DataSafe Noir cabinets for data centres, Fortix storage for warehouses, and a small defence cell factory. Noir has orders but no sales yet, and the factory starts construction in fiscal 2028.

Nothing yet supports a revenue figure, so there is no upside we can count. If it fails, no current profit is lost, but years of its own cash go into the plant, and the price already sits above what we think the existing businesses are worth.

The steps it has to take

  • Done DataSafe Noir launched to data centre customers
  • Done Fortix storage approved under UL and NFPA 855
  • Slipped Cell plant built at its first planned size due 2030-09
  • Not started First Noir revenue recognised due 2028-03
  • Not started Cell plant construction starts due 2027-09
The detail behind the label
Rating
No real upside
the big win's payoff against the 2× and 5× lines
The evidence under this - 4 claims
C26management claimlow confidence
Management says DataSafe Noir won its first customer order in Q2 fiscal 2027, with 6 cabinets in the order book against a pipeline of about 80 opportunities covering over 1,000 cabinets, that it will not be material this fiscal year, and that it is a fiscal 2028 revenue story.
against this

The Noir cells come from a supplier, not from EnerSys's own plant, and the first order's value is not disclosed; in August management spoke of about 100 systems on order with that supplier (S06, S23).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: the first Noir order and the size of its pipeline
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
C22management claimlow confidence
Management puts the plant's cost near $650M, less the $150M grant, with about $500M from operating cash flow and $200M of state incentives; construction starts in the first half of fiscal 2028, full production about three years later, and it expects a mid-20s percent return.
against this

The plant is a quarter or less of the size first announced, and the start has moved into fiscal 2028 (S08).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C16estimatemedium confidence
At $170.61 the company is valued at about $6.9B. Less about $0.56B for the credits still to come, the rest is about 15 times the segments' trailing $413M of adjusted operating profit, a 5% after-tax yield that needs about 3% growth a year for ever.
derived37.6M diluted shares x $170.61 = $6.42B, plus $1,039.0M of debt less $530.7M of cash = $6.93B (S11, S04). Credits at management's midpoints, $165M a year for fiscal 2027-2029 and $80M for 2030-2032, discounted at 10% = about $0.56B (C14). Segment adjusted operating earnings Q2 fiscal 2026 to Q1 fiscal 2027: NIS $167.7M, IMS $175.2M, PPS $69.7M = $412.6M (S03, S05). $6.37B / $412.6M = 15.4 times; at 21% tax the yield is 5.1%, which at an 8% required return implies about 3% growth.
against this
  • The panel's fiscal 2027 EPS of $13.34 puts the shares at 12.8 times earnings, which reads cheap because it includes the credit (S11).
  • Segment profit excludes about $10-20M a quarter of restructuring that has recurred every quarter of fiscal 2026 (S03, S04).
current state · 2026-10-20written 2026-10-21
C21facthigh confidence
On 23 July 2026 EnerSys cut its planned US lithium cell plant to about 1 GWh a year for defence uses, from the 4-5 GWh first planned, its Department of Energy grant fell from $199M to $150M, and the Verkor partnership ended.
historical · July 2026written 2026-10-21

Where we disagree with the market

The market believes

A cheap industrial at about 13 times next year's earnings, with strong cash flow and data centres and defence to grow into.

We believe

About two-fifths of those earnings are a tax credit with an end date; without it the price is fair, not cheap.

The market prices the earnings the company reports, and those beat forecasts eight quarters running. We think the credit should be valued as what it is, a payment that shrinks from 2030, and the rest valued as a slow-growing battery business.

Against us: management plans to make more of its batteries in America, which could raise the credit until 2029, and data centre orders rose over 80%, which could lift growth above the record.

What analysts say, and the evidence
Analysts positive
60%
of 5, 1 Nov
Four months earlier
67%
of 6, 1 Jul
The evidence under this - 7 claims
C17facthigh confidence
The panel expects fiscal 2027 EPS of $13.34 from 3 analysts and fiscal 2028 EPS of $14.58 from 4; ratings are 10 buy, 5 hold and 1 sell. At $170.61 that is 12.8 times fiscal 2027, against filed fiscal 2026 adjusted EPS of $10.56.
current state · 2026-10-21written 2026-10-21
C40facthigh confidence
Adjusted EPS beat the panel's estimate in each of the last eight quarters; revenue fell short once, in Q3 fiscal 2026.
historical · Q2 FY2025 - Q1 FY2027written 2026-10-21
C15inferencemedium confidence
About two-fifths of last year's adjusted earnings and over half of GAAP net earnings came from a credit that steps down from 2030 and ends after 2032, so a large share of today's profit has an end date within seven years.
derivedAdjusted net earnings of $244.4M without the credit against $10.56 x 38.1M = $402M with it, so the credit was about 39%; GAAP $135.0M against $293.6M, so 54% (C04). Phase-down from CRS (C13) and management's own range (C14).
against this
  • Management plans to lift US output to half its batteries, which could raise the yearly credit through 2029 (C14).
  • Fiscal 2026 adjusted earnings without the credit still grew 15% (S02).
forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C13facthigh confidence
Under Section 45X, US-made battery cells earn $35 per kilowatt-hour; the credit falls to 75% for goods sold in 2030, 50% in 2031 and 25% in 2032 and ends after that, and 2025 law added three foreign-entity restrictions.
current state · 2026-08-13written 2026-10-21
C16estimatemedium confidence
At $170.61 the company is valued at about $6.9B. Less about $0.56B for the credits still to come, the rest is about 15 times the segments' trailing $413M of adjusted operating profit, a 5% after-tax yield that needs about 3% growth a year for ever.
derived37.6M diluted shares x $170.61 = $6.42B, plus $1,039.0M of debt less $530.7M of cash = $6.93B (S11, S04). Credits at management's midpoints, $165M a year for fiscal 2027-2029 and $80M for 2030-2032, discounted at 10% = about $0.56B (C14). Segment adjusted operating earnings Q2 fiscal 2026 to Q1 fiscal 2027: NIS $167.7M, IMS $175.2M, PPS $69.7M = $412.6M (S03, S05). $6.37B / $412.6M = 15.4 times; at 21% tax the yield is 5.1%, which at an 8% required return implies about 3% growth.
against this
  • The panel's fiscal 2027 EPS of $13.34 puts the shares at 12.8 times earnings, which reads cheap because it includes the credit (S11).
  • Segment profit excludes about $10-20M a quarter of restructuring that has recurred every quarter of fiscal 2026 (S03, S04).
current state · 2026-10-20written 2026-10-21
C19facthigh confidence
Q3 fiscal 2026 revenue of $919.1M fell short of the panel's $932M, which the release put down to Motive Power; the shares fell from $185.03 to $159.32 the next session.
historical · Q3 FY2026written 2026-10-21
C09management claimmedium confidence
Management says data centre orders rose by the mid-teens on the year in Q2 fiscal 2027 and the data centre backlog more than doubled, with network power backlog up 26%; it expects no material change to its data centre outlook from the US midterm elections, since its growth has come from existing sites.
against this

Orders slowed from more than 80% growth in Q1 to the mid-teens in Q2, and data centre revenue is still not disclosed in any filing (S06, S23, S22).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: data centre orders slowed to the mid-teens while the backlog doubled
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
06

What could go wrong, and how we would know

The risks

  • Lithium takes forklifts Lithium is passing lead in electric forklifts, and forklift makers fit their own packs, so EnerSys's largest business could keep shrinking.
  • The credit can change A third or more of earnings rests on one law; Congress has already added limits once and could cut it sooner.
  • Orders are not sales Data centre orders are lumpy, deliver over up to three years, and are not given as a dollar figure in any filing.
  • The lithium plan keeps shrinking The cell plant was cut to a quarter or less of its first size, and its output arrives years from now.
  • Debt due in 2027 $300M of bonds fall due in December 2027; refinancing is routine in a normal market but costs more now.
The evidence under this - 7 claims
C11estimatemedium confidence
Interact Analysis expects lithium-ion to pass lead-acid in share of electric forklift batteries around 2026, from about 32% in 2024 to over 70% by 2034, with the US reaching 50% only in 2032 and lithium's after-sales market not yet as mature as lead-acid's.
against this

The same forecast puts North America years behind China and Europe, which slows the shift in EnerSys's largest region (S13).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C12facthigh confidence
The 10-K says lithium technologies have a growing share in the markets of its forklift and energy storage businesses, that forklift makers now integrate lithium packs from Asian cells themselves, and that it cannot assure its mostly lead-acid portfolio will stay competitive.
current state · 2026-05-20written 2026-10-21
C13facthigh confidence
Under Section 45X, US-made battery cells earn $35 per kilowatt-hour; the credit falls to 75% for goods sold in 2030, 50% in 2031 and 25% in 2032 and ends after that, and 2025 law added three foreign-entity restrictions.
current state · 2026-08-13written 2026-10-21
C14management claimmedium confidence
EnerSys says it generated $497M of 45X credits in fiscal 2023-2026, of which $231M has reached cash so far, and expects about $140-190M a year through 2029 and $40-120M a year in 2030-2032, with US output rising from 40% to 50% of its batteries.
against this
  • Less than half of the credits booked have reached cash, so the earnings run ahead of the money (S07).
  • The credit fell from $184.6M in fiscal 2025 to $158.6M in fiscal 2026 (S02).
forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C09management claimmedium confidence
Management says data centre orders rose by the mid-teens on the year in Q2 fiscal 2027 and the data centre backlog more than doubled, with network power backlog up 26%; it expects no material change to its data centre outlook from the US midterm elections, since its growth has come from existing sites.
against this

Orders slowed from more than 80% growth in Q1 to the mid-teens in Q2, and data centre revenue is still not disclosed in any filing (S06, S23, S22).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: data centre orders slowed to the mid-teens while the backlog doubled
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
C21facthigh confidence
On 23 July 2026 EnerSys cut its planned US lithium cell plant to about 1 GWh a year for defence uses, from the 4-5 GWh first planned, its Department of Energy grant fell from $199M to $150M, and the Verkor partnership ended.
historical · July 2026written 2026-10-21
C32facthigh confidence
At 4 October 2026 cash was $275.5M and debt $814.8M ($28.7M short-term and $786.2M long-term), after $294.6M of revolver repayments in the half; the July 10-Q listed $300M of 4.375% notes due 15 December 2027 and $300M of 6.625% notes due 2032; the company puts net leverage at 0.8 times.
  1. 2026-11-11editedre-sourced to the 4 October balance sheet in the Q2 release: cash and debt both fell as the revolver was repaid and $130M of shares bought back
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
What we still do not know
  • How much of network power sales comes from data centres, and at what margin.
  • How much of EnerSys's forklift sales are already lithium, and whether it is winning inside lithium.
  • How much of the credit booked so far is still waiting to arrive as cash.
The evidence under this - 3 claims
C09management claimmedium confidence
Management says data centre orders rose by the mid-teens on the year in Q2 fiscal 2027 and the data centre backlog more than doubled, with network power backlog up 26%; it expects no material change to its data centre outlook from the US midterm elections, since its growth has come from existing sites.
against this

Orders slowed from more than 80% growth in Q1 to the mid-teens in Q2, and data centre revenue is still not disclosed in any filing (S06, S23, S22).

  1. 2026-11-13editedthe Q2 fiscal 2027 call: data centre orders slowed to the mid-teens while the backlog doubled
current state · 2026-10-04written 2026-10-21
C11estimatemedium confidence
Interact Analysis expects lithium-ion to pass lead-acid in share of electric forklift batteries around 2026, from about 32% in 2024 to over 70% by 2034, with the US reaching 50% only in 2032 and lithium's after-sales market not yet as mature as lead-acid's.
against this

The same forecast puts North America years behind China and Europe, which slows the shift in EnerSys's largest region (S13).

forwardwritten 2026-10-21
C14management claimmedium confidence
EnerSys says it generated $497M of 45X credits in fiscal 2023-2026, of which $231M has reached cash so far, and expects about $140-190M a year through 2029 and $40-120M a year in 2030-2032, with US output rising from 40% to 50% of its batteries.
against this
  • Less than half of the credits booked have reached cash, so the earnings run ahead of the money (S07).
  • The credit fell from $184.6M in fiscal 2025 to $158.6M in fiscal 2026 (S02).
forwardwritten 2026-10-21

What would change our view

  1. Unattractive→NeutralThe price falls a tenth over fair value

    It needs:

    • ○The share price falls to about $127.30, a tenth above what we think the business is worth.about ≈$128.96 today, 15% below the last close
  2. Unattractive→AttractiveThe price falls 20% under fair value

    It needs:

    • ○The share price falls to about $92.58, 80% of what we think the business is worth.about ≈$97.16 today, 36% below the last close
  3. Unattractive→AttractiveThe core earns more without the credit

    It needs all of:

    • ○The businesses earn 12 cents or more of operating profit per sales dollar, without the credit, over four quarters.checked at the next results, due by 4 Feb
    • ○Forklift and truck sales grow on the year in two quarters running.watched as it happens
We would also be wrong if
  • Data centre sales grow less than mid single digits a year after orders rose over 80%.

What is coming

  • 4 February 2027 Q3 fiscal 2027 results: Whether forklift and truck sales grow on the year, as management now says, and whether sales land in the guide.
Every dated event ahead
  • 4 February 2027 Q3 fiscal 2027 results: Whether forklift and truck sales grow on the year, as management now says, and whether sales land in the guide.
  • 31 March 2027 First revenue from Gen 2 forklift lithium: Whether EnerSys can sell its own lithium into the market that is leaving lead.
  • 1 October 2027 Defense Department ban on six Chinese battery makers takes effect: Whether defence orders shift to US-made batteries such as PPS's.
  • 15 December 2027 $300M of 4.375% notes fall due: How the company refinances and whether leverage stays near one time.
Since we wrote this
Written
21 Oct
Price the thesis read
$151.33
10 Nov
  • 17 NovPrice moveHeld Unattractive: a hair inside the line is too thinThe shares fell to $138.68, about 120% of our value, a hair inside the line. With forklift sales shrinking and no moat, the view holds and turns Neutral near $127.30.
  • 13 NovEarningsCall read: orders up 21%, forklift recovery pushed backOrders rose 21%, led by defence and truck batteries, and the data-centre backlog doubled, but forklift orders still fell and management now expects their recovery in the fourth quarter. Our value did not move; the view stays Unattractive.
  • 11 NovPrice moveView held; the results date corrected to 11 NovemberThe price drew within about 9% of the line that would move the view to Neutral, but nothing about the business changed. The second-quarter report on 11 November is the test.
  • 11 NovEarningsView held: earnings without the credit rose, forklift sales fell 8%Sales came in just under the guide on currency and forklift sales fell faster, while data centres and defence lifted margins. Re-valued near $116, the price is still well above it.
  • 9 NovThesis reviewUnattractive: priced at 123% of a value near $119Re-valued in three stages at an 8% return, the method now drawn on every thesis: the price sits beyond the 20% margin of safety.
  • 27 OctNewsEnerSys will buy defence-battery maker Ultralife for about $320M cash, accretive in 18 months. View heldEnerSys agrees to buy Ultralife for about $320M in cash, to close in the first quarter of 2027.
  • 21 OctThesis writtenNeutral, medium convictionWritten two weeks before Q2 fiscal 2027 results, with the shares 30% below their May high.

Also checked 2 times with nothing new to act on.

Sources 24

Where this came from

Sources - 24

Every claim above cites one of these, or states the reasoning that derived it. The quote is frozen at the date it was read: a link can rot, and an agent fetch returns a reading of a page rather than the page. Backs counts the whole claim ledger, so it can name a claim this page does not surface.

  1. S01primarycompany filing2026-05-20
    the business, segments, competitors, customers, lithium risk factor, Bren-Tronics, Tijuana closure, headcount, debt
    backsC01C02C03C12C25C34C35C42
  2. S02primarycompany release2026-05-20
    full-year results, the 45X credit and earnings excluding it, cash flow
    backsC02C04C17C33
  3. S03primarycompany filing2026-05-28
    sales and adjusted operating earnings for NIS, IMS and PPS by quarter, and corporate unallocated
    backsC01C05
  4. S04primarycompany filing2026-08-12
    Q1 statements, debt, cash, share count, buybacks, tariff refund, restructuring
    backsC06C18C32C34C35
  5. S05primarycompany release2026-08-12
    Q1 results by segment, earnings excluding 45X and the tariff refund, Q2 guidance, buybacks, dividend
    backsC06C07C33C34C40
  6. S06primarytranscript2026-08-13
    EnerSys first-quarter fiscal 2027 earnings call transcript (FMP), held 2026-08-13
    data/cache/transcripts/ENS-2027Q1.json
    orders by market, data centre orders, DataSafe Noir and Fortix, the lithium plant, defence; four analysts' questions
    We expect our new lithium plant to have an initial annual production capacity of approximately 1 gigawatt hour
    backsC09C10C21C22C24C26C27
  7. S07primarycompany release2026-06-11
    45X credits expected by year, market sizes and growth by segment, the fiscal 2030 framework, positions claimed, leverage target
    Generated $497M of credits FY’23-FY’26, which resulted in $231M of cash flow benefits
    backsC14C24C27C29C30C31
  8. S08primarycompany filing2026-07-23
    the plant cut to about 1 GWh for defence, the DOE grant reduced, the Verkor partnership ended
    backsC20C21
  9. S09primarycompany filing2026-03-25
    charge, jobs, expected yearly savings and the 45X reason for the closure
    backsC35
  10. S10primarycompany filing2026-07-02
    bonus measures and payout, long-term awards, ownership table, leaders
    backsC36C37
  11. S11secondaryvendor data2026-10-21
    Research pack frozen beside this thesis, 2026-10-21
    content/ENS/research-pack.json
    price, returns and their split, consensus, estimates, earnings history, insider trades, short interest
    backsC17C18C19C20C38C39C40
  12. S12primarygovernment data2026-08-13
    the credit's rates for battery cells and modules, its phase-down and end, and the foreign-entity limits added in 2025
    Taxpayers may then receive 75% of normal credit amounts for goods sold in 2030, 50% for goods sold in 2031, and 25% for goods sold in 2032.
    backsC13
  13. S13secondaryindustry data2026-02-09
    lithium's share of electric forklift batteries now and to 2034, the US lag, the immature lithium after-sales market
    A pivotal industry inflection point is expected around 2026, when Li-ion technology is forecast to surpass lead-acid batteries in market share within the electric forklift segment.
    backsC11
  14. S14primarygovernment data2024-12-20
    US data centre electricity use in 2023 and the 2028 range
    data centers consumed about 4.4% of total U.S. electricity in 2023 and are expected to consume approximately 6.7 to 12% of total U.S. electricity by 2028
    backsC28
  15. S15primarygovernment data2023-12-22
    the ban on Defense Department purchases of batteries from six named Chinese makers from 1 October 2027
    procure a battery produced by an entity specified in subsection (b).
    backsC23
  16. S16primarycompany filing2026-08-04
    a forklift maker's order trend, the demand EnerSys's forklift batteries follow with a lag
    Bookings increased 17% from the first quarter and more than doubled from the prior year, marking the fourth consecutive quarter of growth
    backsC41
  17. S17primarycompany release2026-02-04
    the third-quarter revenue shortfall and its explanation
    backsC19C40
  18. S18primarycompany filing2026-11-09
    trailing revenue, operating profit, stock pay, tax, debt, cash and the diluted share count
    backsC44
  19. S19secondaryvendor data2026-11-09
    the analysts' average revenue and operating profit for the next three fiscal years, and the close
    backsC43C44
  20. S20primarycompany release2026-11-11
    Q2 statements, segment table, earnings without the credit, balance sheet at 4 October, buybacks, Q3 guidance
    The decrease compared to prior year quarter and net sales below the guidance range were the result of foreign currency translation.
    backsC08C32C44C45C46
  21. S21secondaryvendor data2026-11-11
    the 10 November close of $151.33 and the analysts' revenue path
    backsC44
  22. S22primarycompany filing2026-11-12
    net sales of $949.9M and segment sales of $449.0M, $397.1M and $103.8M for the quarter, confirming the release
    backsC45C46
  23. S23primarytranscript2026-11-12
    orders, book-to-bill and backlog by segment, material handling and transportation orders, data centre orders and backlog, the DataSafe Noir pipeline, the material handling recovery timing and the Ultralife terms; four analysts' questions on forklifts, network power, telecom and the backlog.
    Material handling orders, however, were down lower single digits year-over-year as the market continues to show mixed signals on timing of recovery in response to a volatile macro environment.
    backsC09C10C26
  24. S24primarycompany filing2026-11-12
    the results release as filed on EDGAR the morning after it was wired, the same text as S20
    backsC45
Rendered from content/ENS/thesis.json · thesis reviewed 2026-11-17. This page explains a company; it does not say what to pay, when to buy or how much.